Adam Horticulture Farm PLC
Adam Horticulture Farm PLC
Adam Horticulture Farm PLC
FEASIBILITY STUDY
FOR
VEGETABLE EXPORT,
Prepared By:
June, 2011
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
2. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
2.1 Applicant
2.2 Brief Summary of the Company
3. PROJECT TECHNICAL STUDY
3.1 General
3.1.1 Objectives of the Project
3.1.2 Project Area
3.1.2.1 Geographic Location
3.1.2.2 Land Ownership
3.1.2.3 Topography
3.1.2.4 Climate
3.1.2.5 Physical Conditions
3.1.2.6 Water Resource and Quality
3.1.2.7 Electricity
3.1.2.8 Soil
3.1.2.9 Transport and Communication
3.1.2.10 Service Provider Organizations and Institutions
3.2 Project Particulars
3.2.1 Technical Study
3.2.1.1 Irrigation Scheme
3.2.1.2 Crop Selection
3.2.1.3 Production System
3.2.1.4 Production Cycle
3.2.1.5 Harvesting and Post-harvest Handling
3.2.1.6 Disease and Pest
3.2.1.7 In-farm Roads and Path ways
3.2.1.8 Drainage System
3.2.1.9 Ecological, Human and Social Aspects
4. MARKET STUDY
4.1 Overview of Global Vegetable Trade
4.2 EU Fresh Vegetable Market
4.2.1 Market Trends
4.2.1.1 Production
4.2.1.2 Imports
4.2.1.3 Exports
4.2.1.4 Consumption
4.2.2 Supply Chain
4.2.2.1 Overview
4.2.2.2 Retail
4.2.2.3 Importers
4.2.2.4 Wholesale and Food Service
4.2.3 Market Requirements and Standards
4.2.3.1 Tariff Barriers
4.2.3.2 Non Tariff Barriers
4.2.3.3 Logistics and Traceability
4.2.4 High Value Vegetable Markets
4.2.4.1 Green Beans
4.2.4.2 Peas
4.2.5 Structure of Key EU Markets
4.2.5.1 The United Kingdom
4.2.5.2 The Netherlands
4.3 Prospects
4.4 Production and Technical Strategy
4.5 Packaging
4.6 Labeling and Branding
4.7 Conclusion
5. PROJECT DESIGN
5.1 Buildings and Civil works
5.2 Irrigation System
5.3 Plant and Machinery
5.4 Agricultural Machinery and Equipments
5.5 Vehicles
5.6 Office Furniture and Equipments
5.7 Utilities
5.7.1 Electricity and Power Supply
5.7.2 Fuel, Oil ,and Lubricants
5.7.3 Communication Facilities
6. ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT
6.1 Organizational Structure
6.2 Man Power Requirement and Costs
7. OPERATION PLAN
7.1 Production Plan
7.2 Marketing Plan
7.3 Implementation Plan
8. FINANCIAL STUDY
8.1 Investment Costs
8.1.1 Fixed Investment Costs
8.1.2 Pre-Production Costs
8.1.3 Total Investment Costs
8.2 Operating Costs
8.2.1 Direct Operating Costs
8.2.2 Indirect Operating Costs
8.3 Financing Plan
8.4 Loan Repayment Scheme
8.5 Financial Statements and Indicators
8.5.1 Projected Balance Sheet
8.5.2 Projected Income Statement
8.5.3 Projected Cash Flow
8.6 Financial Indicators and Sensitivity Analysis
9. BENEFITS AND JUSTIFICATION
10. RECOMMENDATIONS
List of Figures
List of Tables
List of Annexes
- Financial annexes
- Soil test analysis
- Water test analysis
- Sales agreement
- Land lease agreement
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Adam Horticulture Plc is a joint venture established by one U.K based company
(Tenadam Produce Ltd) and three Ethiopian nationals. It is engaged in producing
export oriented vegetables (particularly green fresh peas, beans and pepper on 20 ha
of open field land in Guraghe Zone, Cheha woreda, Amora meda kebele.
The project will use a drip system for irrigating the crops. The main vegetable crops
which are selected for export include peas (sugar snap peas and snow peas), beans
(fine and extra-fine beans), and pepper. The total area of land that will be covered for
each vegetable will be 6 ha for peas, 8 ha for beans and 6 ha for pepper annually
during the project life.
The main market destinations for Adam Horticulture Plc’s export will be the European
market, particularly U.K, Holland, and Belgium.
The Production of and international trade in fresh vegetables has grown by 37 per cent
in volume terms over the last decade. The volume of trade has grown more than for
any other agricultural commodity group. The annual volumes of vegetables entering
international trade is approximately 27.1 million tonnes – equal to just over 5 per cent
of production – while the value is approximately US$18.67 billion. International trade in
fresh vegetables during the last decade has increased from $11.5 billion to $18.7
billion, with the fastest growth being in the category of chillies and green peppers.
Developing countries dominate vegetable production and account for approximately a
third of global vegetable trade. However, this trade is very concentrated with
approximately two thirds of developing country exports accounted for by eight countries
only one of which is African, namely South Africa. There are no least developed
countries among leading vegetable exporters although within Africa, Egypt, Kenya and
Morocco are important exporters.
EU fresh vegetable consumption in 2010 was approximately 41.1 million tonnes.
Despite the trend towards healthier diets consumption has been relatively stable over
the past decade. Per capita vegetable consumption is often well below recommended
levels and there are wide variations between countries in consumption levels. The EU
is the world’s biggest importer and the second largest exporter of vegetables. Although
EU (and UK) consumption of vegetables has remained relatively stable over recent
years but there has been a growth of vegetables imports from developing countries
making them an increasingly important source of supply.
The majority of fresh vegetable imports in Western Europe are made via specialist fruit
and vegetable importers direct to major retail multiples. This means, in effect, that the
traditional wholesale market system of produce distribution has been bypassed as
supermarkets look to shorten supply chains and increase direct contact with growers
and exporters—although importers are used to actually handle the physical act of
importing and distribution. This is particularly the case in the U.K., where supermarkets
capture around 85 percent of the overall food retail market. In Continental Europe the
picture is more fragmented, as there is a larger role for traditional markets in the supply
of fresh vegetables at both wholesale and retail. This is due in part to consumer
preferences but also to the higher degree of liberalization, commercialization, and
investment in the grocery retail industry in the U.K.
There are some market requirements and standards in force in the E.U vegetable
market. The main issues are related with tariff and non tariff barriers (GlobalGap,
HACCP), and traceability. Recent concerns over consumer safety have underscored
the importance of tracking produce imported into the EU. Retailers must be able to
trace goods back to their producer in case of product recalls or liability cases.
The European Union is the major market for fine and bobby beans produced in Africa.
Europe’s imports of fresh beans from non-EU sources have grown significantly over
the past eight years, largely a result of increased production of high value fine, extra-
fine, and bobby beans in such countries as Kenya, Zimbabwe, Ethiopia, and Morocco.
France and Holland are the largest European importers of fresh beans, although UK
imports are not far behind and are expanding at a much faster pace. The market
average price for beans is Euro 3.0 per Kg. The market price for loose produce varies
from Euro 2-3.5 per Kg.
In order to benefit from the vegetable export market prospects, Adam Horticulture Plc
will put in place a management system that will ensure the supply of high quality
standards for its export vegetables to gain from the existing good demand for Ethiopian
produce. The company will adopt proper production, packaging and labeling practices
to ensure its products are marketable.
The total cost of the project is estimated at ETB 5,400,000 and out of this the total fixed
investment cost is ETB 3,666,000. The project will be financed from the bank in two
ways. As an expansion of a new project the company will get ETB 3,150,000 and an
additional loan of ETB 900,000 will be financed on the basis of the existing assets
value of the farm.
The project will be profitable starting from first year. The projected income statement
indicates that the Net profit after tax will be ETB 4.5 million in the first year and ETB 9.3
million in ten years. The net present value (NPV) of the project is found to be ETB
6.5 million at 10 % discount rate and with an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 28 %
The project is financially and commercially viable according to the financial analysis
computations carried out. It will also have technical and social benefits to the
surrounding area of the project site.
2. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
2.1 Applicant
2. Address
2.1 Project: Southern Nations and Nationalities Peoples Regional State,
Wolkite Zone, Ezea Woreda, Amora Meda Kebele.
2.2 Addis Abeba Office : A.A, Nifassilk Lafto Subcity, Kebele 03,
H.No.1020, Tel. +251-11-3710604
2.3 Contact Person: Charles Sherlock
3. Type of Project: Irrigated Vegetable Export Production
4. Legal Form of Business: Private Limited Company
5. Status of the Project: Existing
6. Registering Agency: Ministry of Trade and Industry
6.1 Registration No. –EIA PC01/2130/07
6.2 Registration Date : June 7, 2011
7. Licensing Agency : Ethiopian Investment Commission
8. Investment Certificate No.: EIA-IP/20127/2010
9. Tax Payer Identification Number (TIN): 0004328503
10. Value Added Tax (VAT) Registration No. 853200002
11. Size of present Land Holding : 20 Hectares
12. Right of Occupancy: On lease basis
13. Lease Period: 25 years
14. Capital: ETB 2,000,000
It is proposed that in July 2011 further ETB 2,000,000 of equity should be brought in by
the major shareholders and a loan of ETB 4,050,000 will be sought from the
Development Bank of Ethiopia.
3. PROJECT TECHNICAL STUDY
3.1 General
Adam Horticulture Plc is a foreign and local joint venture company established by one
U.K based company (Tenadam Produce Ltd) and three Ethiopian nationals. It
envisages producing export oriented vegetables (particularly fresh green peas
(sugarsnaps peas and snow peas) and extra-fine beans alternating with pepper and
rotational crops) on 20 ha of open field land to the European markets.
The demand for these types of vegetables has grown in European markets during the
last five years. Only a few commercial farms have started producing and exporting the
vegetables in small quantities, but now the area of cultivation is increasing from time to
time.
Since 209, Adam Horticulture Plc has been supplying sugarsnaps peas and snow peas
as an outgrower to Margin par farm and has been growing fine beans, tomato, pepper,
and other vegetables for local market.
3.1.2.3 Topography
The average elevation of the farm land is about 1,948 meters above
sea level. With a slope of 2-4%, the land has good drainage and is
suited for irrigated farming and production of various types of warm
season as well as cool season vegetables.
3.1.2.4 Climate
The area has a good climate throughout the year and gets a mean
annual rainfall of 880 mm. The mean annual temperature is 20.03oC
with monthly maximum and minimum temperatures of 30.4oC and
8.03oC, respectively. The annual wind speed is 2.5m/s, while
sunshine hours vary from a daily mean of 9.54 hrs in November to
5.17 hrs in July. The monthly variation in relative humidity ranges
from 39.7% in February to 71.4% in September. In general, the
climatic factors are quite suitable for the production of the intended
crops using irrigation system.
3.1.2.6 Electricity
The farm is connected to the national electric power grid with power
transmission lines.
3.1.2.7 Soil
Composite samples from the area were taken and analyzed at the
National Soil Testing Center for major soil fertility indicators.
According to the soil analysis the texture of the soil is clay which is
favorable to grow most vegetables. The pH ranges from 5.0 to 5.7 in
the optimum range of most crops.
3.1.2.8 Transport and Communication
The road to the farm from Addis Ababa Airport is all tarmac, except for
the last 16 km from Wolkite town to the farm which is good all weather
road. The area is covered by mobile phone telecommunication
network that is established and reliable. The farm will utilize the
mobile phone E-mail connectivity for its business and e-mail
communication.
Thus, the benefits obtained from using drip irrigation system out-
weigh the high initial investment cost normally incurred. Furthermore,
the stiff competition from producers in the technologically advanced
countries of the world and their standardization of quality of produce
obligates that it is produced under modern and result tested farm
conditions
Pea and beans are now being exported to Africa, Europe and the
Middle East and the demand is very high throughout the year. Price
increases from time to time and has reached CIF 3.5 Euro per
kilogram now. Thus peas are a reliable vegetable in terms of
marketability. They can be exported in bulk or in punnets to add value
to the vegetable and can be exported mixed with baby corn and
pepper as an assorted item. Pepper is consumed in the above
mentioned countries as a spice or food ingredient and can be
consumed with any kind of food thus being a vegetable not to miss at
every meal. It can be exported fresh green or fresh red which will
increase its value.
Ridges or beds should be 1.5m apart center to center (1m bed and
50cm path). Each bed will have 2 rows of plants, 20-30 cm apart.
Irrigation
A good irrigation program is essential for a productive crop. In
addition to water’s role in photosynthesis, plants rely on water to
absorb nutrients dissolved in soil water. Over irrigation is just as
detrimental as under irrigation. Too little, results in plants wilting as
water cannot be extracted from the soil and too much, the roots
become waterlogged and die due to a lack of oxygen in the soil as
well as increased pressure from soil pathogens. Healthy roots with
a good balance of air and water in the soil are essential for high
yields.
Trellising
The trellising of the crop is the single most important cultural
operation. The advantages of trellising are:
• Ventilation of the crop to lower relative humidity in the
canopy (reduces disease incidence)
• Assists in spray penetration
• Keeps peas off the ground
• Aids harvest by keeping peas visible
• Improved crop drying in wet weather
Poles for trellising should be placed along the beds prior to
planting and should ideally be 2 to 3 meters apart. The absolute
maximum distance poles can be placed is 5m and this is only
when growing the semi leafless, determinate varieties
Nutrition
It is essential to have soil tests done every six months and to
fertilize the fields accordingly. The main limiting nutrient in peas is
usually phosphorus, but other macronutrients such as nitrogen and
potassium are also required to reach yield potentials. A productive
crop will require between 80-100 kilograms of nitrogen per
hectare. Phosphate requirements vary between 40-120 kilograms
per hectare depending on status of soil. It is advisable to apply 40
to 50 kg/ha of phosphorus as a pre-plant broadcast or if equipment
is available, this can be banded along the row for efficient uptake.
Potassium levels are similar; 40 kilograms per hectare on
potassium rich soils and up to 120 kilograms per hectare on
deficient soils. Micro nutrient requirements will depend on the
results of the soil analysis
Diseases and Pests
Major threats from disease include powdery mildew and from
pests include cutworms and thrips. These can be controlled using
biological and chemical means
Diseases can be controlled using preventative and curative
fungicides. Usually the preventative fungicides are cheaper than
the curative ones. However, effective control is not always
possible with curative applications as they have very little effect
once the fungi start producing spores. The pest can be controlled
by spraying chemicals which have less toxicity to the ecology.
Harvesting
Harvesting of snow and snap peas is the most critical and costly
part of growing the crop. The consumers require the pods to be of
maximum size but with virtually no seed development. The pods
must be completely flat in case of snow peas - at this stage they
contain no cross fibers and the whole pod can be eaten.The crop
will be ready for harvest from 60-90 days after planting, depending
on the variety and the climatic condition. Before harvest the
following activities are checked to make sure that:
• Baskets are ready for harvesters
• Crates are clean and available for transportation to cold
store
• Accurate scales are set up to record reaping weight
• In-field shelter is available
• Transport to take product to cold storage
Packaging
After the produce comes to the pack house it should be placed in a
cold room (2-4oC) for 2 to 4 hours to take out the field heat. After
field heat has been removed, the pods are taken to the packing
hall to be ‘topped and tailed’ with scissors. Care should be taken to
avoid excessive cutting of the ends of the pods – this can lead to
rapid dehydration and disease development. Excessive handling
should also be avoided.
3.2.1.3.2 Fine and Extra- fine Beans
Harvesting
Approximately 50-60 days after planting, the beans will be ready
for harvesting. Harvest frequency has to be adjusted to the type of
bean exported with extra fine beans being picked daily (sometimes
twice a day), fine beans every two days and bobby beans every
three to four days. Failure to remove the beans at the right time
will result in the plant aborting the next flush of flowers and cause
an overall reduction in yield. These harvesting intervals may need
to be adjusted depending on prevailing temperatures which will
affect the time of flowering to bean maturity
Packaging
After the produce comes to the pack house it should be placed in a
cold room and held at 4-5oC for up to 4 hours to remove the field
heat. After this has been done, the beans are taken to the packing
hall and may be graded where those that are bent, insect
damaged and over mature are removed. They are then packed
loose into boxes or into perforated bags or ‘topped and tailed’
depending on supermarket orders. Excessive handling should be
avoided. Different varieties are not to be mixed in the same
packaging.
3.2.1.3.3 Pepper
Nursery
Transplanting
Fertilization
Irrigation
The frequency of irrigation depends on soil type, environmental
conditions and crop growth stage. Although hot peppers are
moderately deep rooted, they are quite sensitive to moisture
stress. Stress during blooming can cause flower abortion and
substantial reduction in fruit set, while stress during early fruit
growth can induce blossom end rot. Soil moisture stress can also
minimize foliage cover, increasing sun burning of fruit. Drip
irrigation is the preferred form of irrigation with either one or two
drip lines per bed.
The main pests and diseases found in hot peppers in Ethiopia are:
• Whitefly
• Aphids
• Leaf miner
• Powdery mildew
• Viruses
Diseases are controlled in a different way from insects, since their
initial infection is more difficult to detect. Sampling for diseases is
similar to that for pests, except that preventive applications of
contact fungicides such as copper or sulphur are made before we
observe the disease symptoms. Once detected, application of
systemic fungicides is begun and over and above the contact
fungicides which are continued. Application of contact fungicides
ranges from 7-10 days interval, while for systemic products the
interval is from 10-14 days. In any one season never use systemic
products of the same group for more than two times.
Harvesting
Hot peppers may be harvested green or red depending on
supermarket orders. This normally occurs between 10 to 14 weeks
after transplanting depending on the color harvested and the
prevailing temperatures. All chilies are harvested by hand
although it is easier to pick the bigger ones than the smaller Thai
chili types. One person is capable of harvesting over 100kg per
day of Serenade chilies’ but only 10-12 kg/day of the smaller
Demon, a Thai chili. Pickers should be encouraged to harvest the
fruit with stalks attached as this is super market requirement and
reduces bacterial soft rot
Packaging
Peas 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
Beans 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
Pepper 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
TOTAL(Ha) 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20
Bed making
Daily Drip Irrigation Initial fertilization
Harvesting
Fertigation& IrrigationPlant protection
Transplanting
For peas and beans direct planting is practiced. The seeds to be used
in the farm will be F1 hybrid seeds designed for the export quality,
disease resistance, and high yield with extended shelf life. Seed
varieties will be selected by companies which will buy the product of
the farm, to ensure best quality to end users or consumers
The companies that will supply the seeds will be Enza Zaden, Bejo
Zaden, Seminis, Kenya Highland Seeds and Pop Vriend which are all
known for their good reputation in vegetable seed production.
Crop Weeks
Peas 8-9
Beans 8-9
Pepper 12
Table 6: Gross yield
The Production and international trade in fresh vegetables has grown by 37 per
cent in volume terms over the last decade. The volume of trade has grown more
than for any other agricultural commodity group. The annual volumes of vegetables
entering international trade is approximately 27.1 million tonnes – equal to just over
5 per cent of production – while the value is approximately US$18.67 billion.
International trade in fresh vegetables during the last decade has increased from
$11.5 billion to $18.7 billion, with the fastest growth being in the category of chillies
and green peppers. Developing countries dominate vegetable production and
account for approximately a third of global vegetable trade. However, this trade is
very concentrated with approximately two thirds of developing country exports
accounted for by eight countries only one of which is African, namely South Africa.
There are no least developed countries among leading vegetable exporters
although within Africa, Egypt, Kenya and Morocco are important exporters.
Factors cited for the growth in developing countries vegetable supplies include:
Low labor and input costs;
Improved storage techniques;
Improved input use e.g. irrigation, seeds, fertilizer and pesticides;
Better production techniques;
Improved logistics and transport including refrigerated bulk sea freight services
and,
Increased demand from developed countries.
A range of growers and production systems are involved in vegetable exports. This
can range from smallholders to very large-scale farmers employing modern crop
management systems. Larger producers are often involved in most aspects of pre-
and post-harvest operations while smallholders adopt a range of practices
including selling their produce to local operators or traders; exporting their produce
jointly with other smallholders or undertaking outgrowing or contract farming for
larger operations.
The countries that are successful in exporting vegetables have more developed
infrastructures and mostly rely on large-scale commercial farming and an
integrated supply chain. In contrast smallholders have been less able to meet
quality standards, price, volume and delivery schedules of the developed country
buyers.
Real prices for horticultural commodities have declined over the past decade but
much less than other commodities.
.
4.2 EU Fresh Vegetables Market
4.2.1.1 Production
4.2.1.2 Imports
4.2.1.3 Exports
Exports of fresh vegetables from EU countries are similar in value to
imports, both accounting for around US$10.9 billion; both figures have
increased in recent years. This reflects the fact that the majority of
fresh vegetables grown within the EU are also traded within the EU.
Only around 14 percent of such produce is exported to outside the
EU.
4.2.1.4 Consumption
4.2.2.1 Overview
4.2.2.3 Importers
European fruit and vegetable importers are responsible for the import
formalities, such as customs and excise clearance, and often are
responsible for redistributing fresh produce, either in their own country
or by re-exporting to other countries within the EU. This is particularly
common in a number of key centers around the EU. Key importers
often look to add value to products by undertaking tasks such as
ripening, portioning, repackaging, and re-palletizing produce before
they are redistributed. Much of this work is being pushed back up the
supply chain as exporters are becoming more involved in preparing
and packing vegetables ready for supermarket shelves.
In most cases, importers have long-standing relationships with key
suppliers and work with them directly or through agents to advise on
aspects of quality control, such as produce size, levels of maturity,
and packaging. Agents are often used as intermediaries to establish
contacts between exporters and importers, frequently working for
wholesalers by maintaining contact with a number of foreign suppliers
and taking commission on the final sales.
4.2.2.4 Wholesale and Food Service
The EU has a complex import tariff regime that has traditionally aimed
to protect the domestic EU production of fruits and vegetables during
the European growing season. Tariffs are generally higher for
vegetables, as the majority can be grown within the EU. The highest
tariffs are generally applied to exports from developed countries such
as New Zealand, Australia, Canada, the United States, and Japan.
Most developing country suppliers have been able to negotiate at
least some degree of preferential access to the EU market. This
allows them to export to the EU at rates of either very low or even
zero duty (as opposed to regular 7 percent tariff) for a whole range of
agricultural and food products, including off-season fruits and
vegetables.
As a signatory to the EU–African, Caribbean, and Pacific (ACP) Free
Trade Agreement, Ethiopia enjoys duty-free access to the EU market,
as do all of the other key suppliers from East and Southern Africa,
such as Tanzania, Zimbabwe, Uganda, Zambia, Uganda, and Kenya.
In this respect, Ethiopia is at neither a disadvantage nor an advantage
versus its competitors in other developing countries.
Interestingly, Kenya will lose its status as a Least Developed Country
when the current Lomé Agreement comes to an end. This will force
Kenya to negotiate a separate economic partnership agreement with
the EU, likely less favorable than that for its neighbors and reducing
its competitiveness. This may prompt new investments to shift from
Kenya to neighboring countries. Leading horticultural exporters in
Kenya have already been hinting at this possibility, especially for the
flower industry.
It is critical that imported produce reach the market in the EU via the
fastest, most economical transport method to allow the produce to
arrive in the destination country in the best possible condition. The
main points of entry into the EU market for air-freighted produce are at
London, Heathrow, Amsterdam Schiphol in the Netherlands, and
Frankfurt International in Germany. Paris, France, also features as a
“gateway to Europe,” but to a lesser extent. All these airports have
state-off the-art produce handling facilities and are well serviced by
the leading international airlines connecting East Africa and the EU
market. Logistics and direct air freight links are likely to be one of the
bigger challenges for building up the industry for Ethiopian vegetable
exports. Air freight is the key cost element in vegetables from East
Africa, making up around 50 percent of the EU CIF (cost, insurance,
freight) price.
Sea freight is technically an option for vegetables from East Africa. It
is significantly cheaper (maybe 50 percent). For some countries, the
quality of produce can be better preserved using sea freight than air
freight, because the cold chain can be more consistently maintained.
Air freight from East Africa usually implies several hours on the (hot)
tarmac before the produce is loaded on the plane. However, the
goods would take about 21–28 days to reach Europe—a long time
compared with the 7–9 day boat trip from Egypt. Hence, sea
transportation of fresh vegetables from East Africa remains a little-
explored option.
Recent concerns over consumer safety have underscored the
importance of tracking produce imported into the EU. Retailers must
be able to trace goods back to their producer in case of product
recalls or liability cases. Traceability systems that can identify
products’ origin and their path along the supply chain help to reassure
consumers, importers, retailers, and governments alike. With
increasing pressure from the transparency requirement , growers and
exporters interested in the EU market need to make sure they are
taking issues of labeling and traceability seriously and that they are
communicating information clearly and regularly to key market
contacts.
Since full market data for chillies in the EU is not available, only a market
analysis for beans and peas are described below.
The European Union is the major market for fine and bobby beans
produced in Africa. Europe’s imports of fresh beans from non-EU
sources have grown significantly over the past eight years, largely a
result of increased production of high value fine, extra-fine, and bobby
beans in such countries as Kenya, Zimbabwe, Ethiopia, and Morocco.
France and Holland are the largest European importers of fresh
beans, although UK imports are not far behind and are expanding at a
much faster pace. German imports from non-EU sources are relatively
low, but significant imports from the Netherlands also make it an
attractive market. The French bean market is still growing. EU imports
increased by 15 % from more than 166,000 tons to more than
191,000 tons between 2007 and 2009. Moroccan bean exports to
Europe increased by 22 % and Kenyan exports by 23 %, while
exports from Egypt increased by only 3 %. The largest increase in
2007-2009 was scored by Burkina Faso, whose exports increased by
more than 80% from 514 tons to a little more than 925 tons. Exports
to Europe from all the other major sources decreased, with the most
marked case being Mali, which ceased all exports in 2007. Ethiopian
exports decreased by more than 30%.
EU SUPPLY CALENDAR
MARKET PRICE
FRANCE
This is the bean market par excellence, even if Bobby beans are also
sold. The prices of beans from sources other than Kenya were fairly
high in the order of EUR 3.00 per Kg. Kenya batches remained the
benchmark for the quality of Very fine filet beans.
Table 9: France beans import price
French Beans - France Import Price (euro/Kg)
Minimum Maximum
Very fine type
Burkina Faso 1.75 3.1
Kenya 3.55 4.15
Morocco 1.35 2.5
Senegal 1.25 2.75
Bobby type
Morocco 1 2.15
Senegal 1.25 2.1
Source: FruitTrop
BELGIUM
Even if a small niche (supermarkets) does exist for filet beans, most
trade is in Bobby bean. Three sources share the market: Senegal,
Morocco, and Egypt. Generally the same price ranges for all sources.
NETHERLANDS
Source: FruitTrop
ITALY
4.2.4.2 Peas
Sugar snap and Snow peas (mangetout) are widely eaten in Europe,
but snow peas are at a later stage of development. Snow peas began
as a specialty item, but are now increasingly becoming main-stream
due to their year-round availability, and are particularly popular with
restaurants. Sugar snap peas are slightly more developed in the
market than snow peas, and many people recognize them as different
from mangetout. As snow peas and sugar snaps can both be eaten
whole, and are good whether raw or cooked, these versatile
vegetables suit the demand for convenience by modern European
consumers.
Table 13: EU imports of Snap and Snow peas from 2006 to 2010 in MT, Source EUROSTAT
The crop is a tempered crop and does not need high temperature.
The climate allows growing it in Europe, there is a spring production in
Spain and a summer production in South of France. Nevertheless the
European production is low, mainly due to the importance of the labor
costs. The volume of production is furthermore low and main of the
consumption is imported from Africa.
The market price for loose produce varies from Euro 2-3.5 per Kg
Adam Horticulture Plc is a new entrant into the export market. Being a new
entrant, the company will take time to build a brand name and attract good prices.
The company’s selection of vegetable types and the use of optimal production and
management practices will ensure the vegetables produced are of high quality. It
is important that the company strives to sustain the production of high quality
vegetables and provides professional services to the clients to speed up its
attainment of brand recognition and attainment of good prices. The future of the
Ethiopia's share of the international vegetable market is bright. Ethiopia is known
as quality suppliers of vegetables and continues to grow in importance. Adam
Horticulture Plc has to put in place a management system that will ensure
aggressive marketing and high quality standards for its export vegetables to
benefit from the existing good demand of Ethiopian produces.
The proposed vegetable types have been selected on the basis of:
Climatic conditions,
Buyer preference,
Potential production per unit area,
Most of the vegetables are relatively has stable market and therefore attracting
favorable prices and
These considerations will be maintained in future selection of vegetable types for
expansion and replacement of existing types. All vegetables produced are
expected to be, of appropriate quality standards, fresh, free of parasites,
mechanical damage, residues and defects of development. These factors form the
basic requirements of the target market. The technical production team will
comprise of technically competent personnel to ensure these are attained. Regular
consultation with a technical consultant will be maintained to ensure up to date
technologies are adopted at the farm.
4.5 Packaging
Each box will bear the company’s logo to be developed, bearing the brand name
“Adam Horticulture Plc and "Produce of Ethiopia".
4.7 Conclusion
It is the opinion of the Consultant that a market for Adam Horticulture Plc
vegetables exists. The company will strive to be knowledgeable on the
requirements of this market and will put in place systems that enable it meet the
market demands. The export vegetable market is already well developed and new
entrants have had comfortable access. The strategic plan is to develop a reliable
production cycle, produce high quality vegetables, and continuously undertake
effective market and prices trends analysis. The industry has grown tremendously
within east, central and South African region over the last decade promising Adam
Horticulture Plc a similar opportunity to succeed. The consultant therefore
recommends that the project is viable from a marketing perspective.
5. PROJECT DESIGN
5.4 Vehicles
The main vehicle required for the project is a cold truck with a capacity of 3.5 tons
that can transport the produce from the farm to airport. The cost of the cold truck is
ETB 650,000.
The conventional form of vegetable exporting farm organization will be adopted for the
farm which reflects, the different functions required by the various activities. The form
of organization permits the efficient use of resources, both human and machinery
resources aimed at optimizing the expected return from the farm. It also increases the
rate of development of professional and technical skills by constant contact and
interaction of staff in each department, unit and section which will contribute to
improvement of farm productivity.
The farm organization structure is developed in line with the various activities of the
farm during its design life. The development and operation of Adam Horticulture Plc
focuses on exportable vegetables and some cereals as well as pulses as crop rotation.
The planning and operation of the farm will be coordinated by the farm manager but
run independently by Agronomists and supervisors. Hence, it requires dynamic
management team starting at the implementation phase that will keep abreast the
current production technology. The administration structure includes the farm manager
and other department heads/supervisors. When the farm operates at its full capacity, it
will provide job opportunity for more than 45 permanent workers and about 9000 per
year daily laborers for operational activities. This will be one of the major contributions
to the socio economics of the area. The farm manager will also be assisted by
professional consultants, general and deputy managers and commercial head.
Furthermore, professional and experienced individuals will be employed for the
accounts, administrative and technical departments of the company. Similarly, all the
required skilled, semi-skilled and casual laborers will also be employed. Availability of
such workers is not going to pose any problem since there is an abundant work force in
Wolkite and around the project site.
6.1 Organizational Structure
The type of vegetable lines and extent of the farm operation is considered as the
major criteria to formulate the farm organization. Accordingly, the farm will be
organized into four departments; Production, Finance and Administration,
Commercial, and Logistics. Each department will have its own team headed by a
manager. The farm will be managed by a farm manager at the project site.
The head office will provide the overall planning and management. The main line
departments of the company that execute the main functions of the farm, the
general manager, deputy manager, commercial, logistics and finance department,
will be located in the head office, Addis Ababa.
General Manager
Packhouse
Manager
Production Head
Agronomist
Protection Head
Agronomist
Irrigatio Head
Supervisors, &
General Services
6.2 Manpower Requirement and Costs
The permanent staff required to develop and operate the farm has been prepared
on the farm organizational plan. The number of the required staff depends on
activities to operate the whole farm efficiently to render it profitable. The staff
requirement and cost is presented in Table14.
The main export production season of the farm in a year calendar will start in October
and ends in June
7.1 Production Plan
The production plan for each type of vegetables is described below
PEAS
The planting program for peas is 2 ha per month and continues for three months. It
will start in October ends in March and the total area covered by peas will be 6 ha
BEANS
The planting program for beans is also 2 ha per month and extends for four
months. The time of planting beans starts in October till December and the total
area covered per year will be 8 ha.
PEPPER
Pepper will be planted for three months starting in February till April at 2 ha per
month. The total area covered by pepper per year will be 6 ha.
The area and yield of each vegetables is summarized in the following table
The annual revenue that can be obtained from the marketable yield of each
vegetable type is presented below in table.
The exact time to finalize loan process application with the Development Bank of
Ethiopia is not known. But the promoters of this project will expect to start production
during this year (2011). Accordingly the following activities are planned for
implementation of the project.
8. FINANCIAL STUDY
8.1 Investment Costs
The financial analysis is made on the assumption that all planned investments are
made at the same time and during the initial year.
The fixed investment costs are Buildings and Construction, irrigation system,
plant and machinery, agricultural machinery and equipments, vehicle, and
office furniture and equipments. Most of the investments will be made during
the first year. The total fixed investment cost is estimated to be about ETB
3,666,000. The summary of the required fixed investment costs is presented
in table 17 below.
Vehicles 650,000
TOTAL 3,666,000
Contingency (0%) 0
Out of the total project cost 25 % will be contributed from the company owner’s
equity, which is ETB 1,350,000 and 75 % will be financed from the Bank in medium
term loan, ETB 4,050,000.
The total proposed loan shall be repaid in 5 years and 10 semi-annual installments
which includes one and half year of grace period.
An interest rate of 7.5% per annum will be charged on the outstanding loan
balance and a service charge of 0.75% per annum shall be charged on the
outstanding loan balance and will be paid together with the interest. The annual
principal loan repayment including interest payable is shown in the following table.
Table 21: Loan Repayment Scheme
Repayment Date Serv.Charge (0.75%) Interest (7.5%) Principal Repayment Outstanding Balance
Year-0 4,050,000
Year-1 7,594 75,938 4,050,000
Year-1 15,188 151,875 4,050,000
Sub-Total 22,781 227,813
Year-2 15,188 151,875 4,050,000
Year-2 15,188 151,875 405,000 3,645,000
Sub-Total 30,375 303,750 405,000
Year-3 13,669 136,688 405,000 3,240,000
Year-3 12,150 121,500 405,000 2,835,000
Sub-Total 25,819 258,188 810,000
Year-4 10,631 106,313 405,000 2,430,000
Year-4 9,113 91,125 405,000 2,025,000
Sub-Total 19,744 197,438 810,000
Year-5 7,594 75,938 405,000 1,620,000
Year-5 6,075 60,750 405,000 1,215,000
Sub-Total 13,669 136,688 810,000
Year-6 4,556 45,563 405,000 810,000
Year-6 3,038 30,375 405,000 405,000
Sub-Total 7,594 75,938 810,000
Year-7 1,519 15188 405,000 0
Business results include the projected balance sheet, income statement, and the
cash flow. Each of the business results are described in the following sections
The balance sheet projected for ten years shows that the total assets of the
project will increase from ETB 6.1 million to ETB 19.3 million. The detailed
balance sheet is shown below in table.
Table 22: Projected Balance Sheet
Y E A R S
DESCRIPTION
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS
Cash 1,021,833 1,421,793 2,859,151 4,340,936 5,943,345 7,674,611 9,543,571 11,625,520 13,922,493 16,376,885 18,588,891
Inventory 0 1,310,174 5,220,978 4,630,641 3,918,212 3,414,646 2,841,663 1,987,223 1,277,197 609,175 0
Total Current Assets 1,021,833 2,731,967 8,080,129 8,971,577 9,861,557 11,089,257 12,385,234 13,612,743 15,199,690 16,986,060 18,588,891
FIXED ASSETS
Land Development 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Building and Constr. 1,100,000
Irrigation Material 1,200,000
Plant & Machinery 550,000
Agri Machinery & Equit 125,000
Vehicles 650,000
Office Furniture & Equit 41,000
Total Fixed Assets 3,666,000 3,666,000 3,369,400 3,072,800 2,776,200 2,479,600 2,183,000 1,886,400 1,589,800 1,293,200 996,600
Accum Depreciation 0 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600
Book Value of Fix Assets 3,666,000 3,369,400 3,072,800 2,776,200 2,479,600 2,183,000 1,886,400 1,589,800 1,293,200 996,600 700,000
TOTAL ASSETS 4,687,833 6,101,367 11,152,929 11,747,777 12,341,157 13,272,257 14,271,634 15,202,543 16,492,890 17,982,660 19,288,891
LIABILITIES & Capital
CURRENT LIABILITIES
1. Accounts Payable 1,021,833 250,594 334,125 284,006 217,181 150,356 83,531 16,706 0 0 0
Total Current Liability 250,594 334,125 284,006 217,181 150,356 83,531 16,706 0 0 0
LONG TERM LIABILITIES
1. Fixed Investment Loan 0 405,000 810,000 810,000 810,000 810,000 405,000 0 0 0
Total Long Term Liabilities 0 405,000 810,000 810,000 810,000 810,000 405,000 0 0 0
EQUITY
1. Owners Equity 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000
2. Profit of Previous Period 0 0 4,500,773 4,563,031 4,740,740 5,223,236 5,738,664 6,289,438 7,141,398 8,001,493 8,631,168
3. Current Profit 0 4,500,773 4,563,031 4,740,740 5,223,236 5,738,664 6,289,438 7,141,398 8,001,493 8,631,168 9,307,723
Total Equity 1,350,000 5,850,773 10,413,804 10,653,770 11,313,976 12,311,901 13,378,103 14,780,836 16,492,891 17,982,660 19,288,891
TOTAL LIABILITIES & EQUITY 6,101,367 11,152,929 11,747,777 12,341,157 13,272,257 14,271,634 15,202,543 16,492,891 17,982,660 19,288,891
The projected income statement indicates that the Net profit after tax will be
ETB 4.5 million in the first year and ETB 9.3 million in the tenth year.
Table 23: Projected Income Statement
Description Project Years
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Gross Revenue 10,536,960 11,274,547 12,063,766 12,908,229 13,811,805 14,778,631 15,813,136 16,920,055 18,104,459 19,371,771
Less Operating Costs
- Direct Production Cost 1,633,500 1,715,175 1,800,934 1,890,980 1,985,529 2,084,806 2,189,046 2,298,499 2,413,423 2,534,095
- Indirect Production Cost 1,432,000 1,503,600 1,578,780 1,657,719 1,740,605 1,827,635 1,919,017 2,014,968 2,115,716 2,221,502
Revenue Before Int. and Depr. 7,471,460 8,055,772 8,684,052 9,359,530 10,085,671 10,866,190 11,705,073 12,606,589 13,575,319 14,616,175
Less: Depreciation and Amort. 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600 296,600
:Financial Costs 250,594 739,125 1,094,006 1,027,181 960,356 893,531 421,706 0 0 0
Revenue Before Tax 6,924,266 7,020,047 7,293,446 8,035,748 8,828,714 9,676,059 10,986,766 12,309,989 13,278,719 14,319,575
Less: Profit Tax 2,423,493 2,457,017 2,552,706 2,812,512 3,090,050 3,386,621 3,845,368 4,308,496 4,647,552 5,011,851
Net Profit 4,500,773 4,563,031 4,740,740 5,223,236 5,738,664 6,289,438 7,141,398 8,001,493 8,631,168 9,307,723
Retained Earning 1,125,193 1,140,758 1,185,185 1,305,809 1,434,666 1,572,360 1,785,350 2,000,373 2,157,792 2,326,931
The cash flow analysis shows surplus for all of the years and the volume is
affected by different cash flow components mainly of operating costs. As
financial costs and loan repayment diminish, the volume of surplus
concomitantly grows. At the end of the project period, the cumulative cash
balance reaches ETB 19.0 million.
Table 24: Projected Cash Flow
Description Project Years
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Cash Inflows
Owner's Equity 1,350,000
Bank Loan 4,050,000
Sales 0 10,536,960 11,274,547 12,063,766 12,908,229 13,811,805 14,778,631 15,813,136 16,920,055 18,104,459 19,371,771
Total Cash Inflow 5,400,000 10,536,960 11,274,547 12,063,766 12,908,229 13,811,805 14,778,631 15,813,136 16,920,055 18,104,459 19,371,771
Cash Outflows
Investment on Fixed Assets 3,666,000
Pre-Production & Interest 712,167
Direct Operating Cost 0 1,633,500 1,715,175 1,800,934 1,890,980 1,985,529 2,084,806 2,189,046 2,298,499 2,413,423 2,534,095
Indirect Operating Cost 0 1,432,000 1,503,600 1,578,780 1,657,719 1,740,605 1,827,635 1,919,017 2,014,968 2,115,716 2,221,502
Tax 0 2,423,493 2,457,017 2,552,706 2,812,512 3,090,050 3,386,621 3,845,368 4,308,496 4,647,552 5,011,851
Loan Repayment 0 250,594 739,125 1,094,006 1,027,181 960,356 893,531 421,706 0 0 0
Dividend 0 3,375,580 3,422,273 3,555,555 3,917,427 4,303,998 4,717,079 5,356,049 6,001,120 6,473,376 6,980,793
Total Cash Outflow 4,378,167 9,115,167 9,837,190 10,581,981 11,305,820 12,080,539 12,909,672 13,731,186 14,623,082 15,650,067 16,748,240
Ending Cash Balance 1,021,833 1,421,793 1,437,358 1,481,785 1,602,409 1,731,266 1,868,960 2,081,950 2,296,973 2,454,392 2,623,531
Cumulative Cash 1,021,833 1,421,793 2,859,151 4,340,936 5,943,345 7,674,611 9,543,571 11,625,520 13,922,493 16,376,885 19,000,416
The net present worth of benefits and the internal rate of return (IRR) of the
project have been measured by discounting the cash flow of the project at 10
%, which is nearly equal to the prevailing bank interest rate. The net
present value (NPV) of the project is found to be ETB 6.5 million at the
given cut of rate.
The internal rate of return (IRR) of the project with respect to committed
resources has been also computed to be 28%, which is higher than the
prevailing cost of capital (discount rate) and reveals viability of the
project.
A sensitivity analysis has been conducted to test the strength and
viability of the project with respect to major changes in the discounted
benefits. The IRR and NPV of the project at 10 % increase are 31 % and
ETB 7.7 million, and at 10 % decrease the result is 25 % and ETB 5.4
million respectively.
9. BENEFITS AND JUSTIFICATIONS
In addition to the project’s financial benefits, the following will also be gained from the
implementation of the project.
It is believed that the project is financially and commercially viable according to the
financial analysis computations carried out. Moreover, it is also technically feasible
and socially beneficial.
Based on the overall viability of the project, Adam Horticulture Plc proposes a loan of
ETB 4,050,000 from Development Bank of Ethiopia.
10. RECOMMENDATIONS
The implementation of the crop production plan will have to be consistent with
commercial orders from the buyers as this will affect the future relationships with them
and it is also a basic foundation for the company.
ANNEXES
FINANCIAL ANNEX
ASSUMPTIONS
COST (ETB)
DIRECT OPERATING COST Peas/ 6 Ha Beans/ 8 Ha Pepper/ 6 Ha TOTAL/Year
Labor Operation 36000 36000 22500 94500
Land Prep 27000 36000 27000 90000
Seed 30000 16000 33600 79600
Cultural practice Material 204000 0 144000 348000
Fertilizer 24000 32000 27000 83000
Chemical 24000 28000 24000 76000
Packaging 240000 320000 302400 862400
Air Freight 0 0 0 0
TOTAL DIRECT OPERATING COST/YEAR 1633500
Project Years
Description 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1. Land Preparation 90,000 94500 99225 104186.25 109395.563 114865.341 120608.608 126639.038 132970.99 139619.539
2. Labour Operations 94,500 99225 104186.25 109395.563 114865.341 120608.608 126639.038 132970.99 139619.539 146600.516
3. Input Materials 1,449,000 1521450 1597522.5 1677398.63 1761268.56 1849331.98 1941798.58 2038888.51 2140832.94 2247874.58
4. Freight Costs 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SUB TOTAL 1,633,500 1,715,175 1,800,934 1,890,980 1,985,529 2,084,806 2,189,046 2,298,499 2,413,423 2,534,095
Indirect Operating Costs
Investment Costs
Financing Plan
Total Cash Inflow 5,400,000 10,536,960 11,274,547 12,063,766 12,908,229 13,811,805 14,778,631 15,813,136 16,920,055 18,104,459 19,371,771
Cash Outflows
Investment on Fixed Assets 3,666,000
Pre-Production & Interest 712,167
Direct Operating Cost 0 1,633,500 1,715,175 1,800,934 1,890,980 1,985,529 2,084,806 2,189,046 2,298,499 2,413,423 2,534,095
Indirect Operating Cost 0 1,432,000 1,503,600 1,578,780 1,657,719 1,740,605 1,827,635 1,919,017 2,014,968 2,115,716 2,221,502
Tax 0 2,423,493 2,457,017 2,552,706 2,812,512 3,090,050 3,386,621 3,845,368 4,308,496 4,647,552 5,011,851
Loan Repayment 0 250,594 739,125 1,094,006 1,027,181 960,356 893,531 421,706 0 0 0
Dividend 0 3,375,580 3,422,273 3,555,555 3,917,427 4,303,998 4,717,079 5,356,049 6,001,120 6,473,376 6,980,793
Total Cash Outflow 4,378,167 9,115,167 9,837,190 10,581,981 11,305,820 12,080,539 12,909,672 13,731,186 14,623,082 15,650,067 16,748,240
Ending Cash Balance 1,021,833 1,421,793 1,437,358 1,481,785 1,602,409 1,731,266 1,868,960 2,081,950 2,296,973 2,454,392 2,623,531
Cumulative Cash 1,021,833 1,421,793 2,859,151 4,340,936 5,943,345 7,674,611 9,543,571 11,625,520 13,922,493 16,376,885 19,000,416
Projected Income Statement