6.4 Identifying Positive Ions Teacher
6.4 Identifying Positive Ions Teacher
6.4 Identifying Positive Ions Teacher
4
Teacher practical
Aims
In this activity, students carry out two types of tests which can be used to identify
which positive ion is present in a solution: the flame test and the sodium
hydroxide test.
Learning outcomes
After completing this activity, students should be able to:
describe and safely carry out a flame test and testing for metal ions using
sodium hydroxide
write a word equation and symbol equation for the reaction between
sodium hydroxide and a specified metal salt solution
identify a metal ion from the colour of a flame or the colour of the
hydroxide precipitate
write balanced symbol equations, including state symbols, for the
production of insoluble metal hydroxide
explain why a flame test cannot be used to identify a mixture of metal
solutions
evaluate flame tests as a method for identifying positive metal ions
explain the limitations of these tests
write balanced ionic equations, including state symbols for the production
of an insoluble metal hydroxide .
Teacher notes
Flame tests work best in a darkened room so that the colour can be seen more
easily. The lilac colour of potassium is particularly hard to see, and is often
masked by the yellow colour of the sodium ion (which is often present in
potassium compounds).
As an alternative to using nichrome wire (which has to be cleaned using
concentrated hydrochloric acid), pre-soaked wooden splints can be used (see
alternative method). This is much safer and works well, though students need to
be careful not to let the whole splint burn.
Details can be found in the RSC resource: wooden splint flame tests
This practical works well in a circus arrangement with the five solutions arranged
in stations around the lab.
The colours can be linked to the colour of fireworks: there are a number of videos
and other teaching resources on this theme: RSC FireworksResources
Before students carry out the sodium hydroxide test, it should be stressed that we
are looking for the colour of the precipitate and whether it dissolves in excess
sodium hydroxide (students will need reminding what we mean by a precipitate).
The questions require students to know the formulae of the reactants and
products: help may be needed for this.
A good way of helping students understand the reactions is to demonstrate the
sodium hydroxide test with a variety of different salts with the same metal ion, for
example copper sulfate, copper chloride and copper nitrate: in each case the
same blue precipitate is seen, thus showing that the observed reaction is due to
the positive ion present.
It is important to stress that students will need to learn the colours of the flames and
the hydroxide precipitates, and which metal hydroxide dissolves in excess sodium
hydroxide (see the Task – students will need materials to make revision cards).
Higher-tier students should be encouraged to write ionic equations for the
reactions they have observed (see question 2 (b)).
A short video on ionic equations Ionic Equations is a useful resource for this.
Results
Flame Test
Answers
1 a It is difficult to distinguish between lithium chloride and calcium chloride,
because the flame colours are very similar: both are red. (2 marks)
b It is not possible to identify the metal ions present in a solution containing
a mixture of sodium chloride and potassium chloride, because the orange
colour due to sodium masks the pale lilac colour of potassium. (2
marks)
2 a i magnesium sulfate sodium hydroxide magnesium hydroxide
sodium sulfate
MgSO4 (aq) 2NaOH (aq) Mg(OH)2 (s) Na2SO4 (aq)
ii iron(II) sulfate sodium hydroxide Iron(II) hydroxide sodium sulfate
FeSO4 (aq) 2NaOH (aq) Fe(OH)2 (s) Na2SO4 (aq)
iii iron(III) chloride sodium hydroxide Iron(III) hydroxide sodium chloride
FeCl3 (aq) 3NaOH (aq) Fe(OH)3 (s) 3NaCl (aq)
iv copper(II) chloride sodium hydroxide copper(II) hydroxide sodium chloride
CuCl2 (aq) 2NaOH (aq) Cu(OH)2 (s) 2NaCl (aq) (8 marks)
b Ionic Equations
Mg2+ (aq) 2OH– (aq) Mg(OH)2 (s)
Fe2+ (aq) 2OH– (aq) Fe(OH)2 (s)
Fe3+ (aq) 3OH– (aq) Fe(OH)3 (s)
Cu2+ (aq) 2OH– (aq) Cu(OH)2 (s).(8 marks)
3 a Add sodium hydroxide to each solution in turn until in excess. All should
give a white precipitate, but only one of the precipitates dissolves in
excess NaOH. This tells you which solution is aluminium chloride.
Carry out a flame test on the remaining two solutions. The one which gives
an orange-red flame is calcium chloride. The one which gives no colour
must be magnesium chloride.(3 marks)
b calcium chloride sodium hydroxide calcium hydroxide sodium chloride
CaCl2 (aq) 2NaOH (aq) Ca(OH)2 (s) 2NaCl (aq). (2 marks)
Safety
2 mol/dm3 sodium hydroxide: CORROSIVE- CLEAPSS Hazcard 91A
Iron (III) chloride: HARMFUL- CLEAPSS Hazcard 55C
1mol/dm3 iron(II) sulfate solution: HARMFUL- CLEAPSS Hazcard 55B
1 mol/dm3 copper (II) sulfate solution: HARMFUL- CLEAPSS Hazcard
27C
solid lithium chloride: HARMFUL-CLEAPSS Hazcard 47B
solid calcium chloride: IRRITANT- CLEAPSS Hazcard 19A
solid copper (II) chloride: HARMFUL- CLEAPSS Hazcard 27A
Concentrated hydrochloric acid: CORROSIVE- CLEAPSS Hazcard 47A
Eye protection
Equipment
Flame Test Sodium Hydroxide Test
3
1 mol/dm lithium chloride solution 0.1 mol/dm3 magnesium sulfate solution
1 mol/dm3 sodium chloride solution 0.1 mol/dm3 calcium chloride solution- irritant
1 mol/dm3 potassium chloride solution 0.1 mol/dm3 aluminium sulfate solution
1 mol/dm3 calcium chloride solution- irritant 0.1 mol/dm3 iron (III) chloride solution- irritant
1 mol/dm3 copper (II) chloride solution 0.1 mol/dm3 copper (II) sulfate solution- harmful
nichrome wire mounted in a handle 0.1 mol/dm3 iron(II) sulfate solution- harmful
concentrated hydrochloric acid- corrosive 0.4 mol/dm3 sodium hydroxide- corrosive
Bunsen burner test tubes and rack
test tubes and rack droppers