Business Taxation Mock Exam FH Aachen

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

[Hier eingeben] Prof. Dr.

Meike Utzerath
FH Aachen University of Applied Sciences

Mock Exam Reading Week


Sample Solution

Business Taxation
Part: Personal income tax (total of 31 points)

Question 1 (3 points)

- The basic principle of individual taxation is abandoned. 1


- The joint assessment is advantageous if the incomes of the spouses/life part-
ners are of different amounts. The wider the gap the better the joint assess- 2
ment.

Question 2 (10 points)

• Income from capital assets [§ 2 I no. 5 i. c. w.] § 20 II no. 1 EStG (+) be- 1
cause of disposal of the shares
• § 20 VIII, no indication that income is attributable to any of the main types of 2
income
• Determination of the profit on disposal:
Income surplus over the income-related expenses,
2
[§ 2 II no. 2 EStG i. c. w.] §§ 8, 9 EStG
• § 20 IV 1 EStG:
EUR 25,000 [sales price] 1
- EUR 15,000 [acquisition costs] 1
- EUR 0 * 1
= EUR 10,000 [profit on disposal] 1

* [Expenses that are directly materially related. For capital gains within the
meaning of § 20 IV EStG, there is an exception to the deduction prohibition

Page 1 of 3
Page 2 of 3

pursuant to § 20 IX EStG. The savers’ lump sum allowance is not deductible.]

• No exemption according to § 3 EStG apparent 1

Question 3 (18 points)

III) Material Tax Liability and Determination of Income

Janitor
- [§ 2 I 1 no. 2 i. c. w.] § 15 I 1 no. 1 EStG 1
- § 15 II 1 EStG income from janitor activities
o Self-employment (+) acc. to the facts Fred has got 2 employees 1
o Sustainability (+) acc. to the facts since 15 years 1
o Intention of realizing profits (+) acc. to the facts EUR 35,000 profit in 01 1
o Participation in general economic activities (+), providing janitorial ser- 1
vices to customers
o No income from self-employment? 1
§ 2 I 1 no. 3 i. c. w. § 18 I EStG (-), janitorial activities are not covered
by § 18 EStG
o Not merely asset administration [cf. § 14 AO as well] (+), craftsmen ser- 1
vices ≠ asset administration

Conclusion: Fred generated income from business operations. 1

No indications of tax exemption 1

[income determination: acc. facts profit = 35,000]

Private Apartment
Income from rental and royalties [§ 2 I 1 no. 6 i. c. w.] § 21 I 1 no. 1 EStG, renting
of parts of buildings (+) apartments 1
- § 21 III EStG: Assignment to another type of income? 1
- [§ 2 I 1 no. 2 i. c. w.] § 15 I no. 1 EStG? (-), 2
[reasoning either]
because mere asset management
[or]
no indication in the facts that the apartment is part of Fred's business assets.
- [No indication for income within the meaning of other types of income in the
facts.]

No indication for tax exemption 1

Conclusion: the married couple generates income from rental and royalties. 1
Page 3 of 3

Surplus determination of income over income-related expenses


Income [acc. to § 2 II no. 2] i. c. w. §§ 8, 9 EStG 1
Income within the meaning of § 8 I EStG= rent 1
[Acc. to the facts, there are no income-related expenses within the meaning of § 9 I
EStG.]

Janitor EUR 35,000


Private Apartment EUR 6,000
= Sum of Income EUR 41,000 1

You might also like