Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 47 views

    Cricket Pitchesin Trinidad

    Uploaded by

    CIVIL ENGINEERING

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd

    Cricket Pitchesin Trinidad

    Uploaded by

    CIVIL ENGINEERING
    47 views14 pages

    Original Title

    CricketPitchesinTrinidad[1]

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf
    47 views14 pages

    Cricket Pitchesin Trinidad

    Uploaded by

    CIVIL ENGINEERING

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf
    You are on page 1of 14
    West Indian Journal of Engineering Vol. 28, No. 2, January 2006) Technical Paper (Ekwue, Lall & Stone) 27 - 40 Engineering Properties of Major Soils Used in Cricket Pitches in Trinidad E.1. Ekwue,‘ D.Z. Lal & RJ. Stone* The physical and engineering properties of major soits used in cricket pitches in Trinidad were measured in the laboratory. The study was undertaken to identify suitable soils for use in cricket pitches, as well as to provide advice on how to manage the pitches where these and similar soils are used. The properties assessed were soil texture, Atterberg limits, swelling characteristics, density-water relations, penetration resistance, shear strength and compressibility. Values obtained for the parameters were consistent with those expected for soils with high clay content \(46%-80%). The soils exhibited liquid limits that were both high and quite variable, ranging from 58%-91%. Maximum bulk densities of the soils subjected to 5, 15 and 25 Proctor comipaction blows ranged from 1.26-1.55 Mg nt’. Peak penetration resistance of the soils obtained after the threé Proctor compaction efforts varied from 2.21-6.44 MPa. Shear strengths of most of the soils exceeded 130 KPa, particularly at high compaction levels. The compression index obtained from a standard confined compressibility test upon compaction varied from 0.60- 0.77. Generally, the soil properties that affect the performance and preparation of cricket pitches are consistent with the high clay content of the test soils. Results indicaie that some 6f the soils are ideally suited for use in cricket pitches. However, further measurement or monitoring of these measured properties in actual or simulated cricket pitches are recommended. Keywords: Soils, cricket, strength, stress Sr 1. Introduction Itis well knowa that good cricket can only be played con good pitches. In the late 1970s, red sand was used in the construction of most cricket pitches in Trinidad. The sand was wet and rolled to allow compaction and then matting was placed on the surface of the pitch. ‘These were called sand wickets, unlike the turf wickets, which have clay on the surface. With the growing popularity of the sport locally, regionally and intemationally, turf wickets are now becoming very popular and these require proper management to promote their performance. Ground managers and curators have usually chosen ‘cane land’ soil for cricket pitches in Trinidad. Princes Town Clay is the mast common soil type used today. Sevilla Clay was very popular in the 1980s, Princes Town Clay is mainly found in Princes Town, Ste. Madeline, Indian Walk and areas in the vicinity of the Cipero Road. This soil has been described by Brown and Bally [1] as a calcareous vertisol, a dark grey-black soil which is high in humic content. The soil is alkaline, has impeded drainage and is high in carbonates [2), as well as being extremely plastic [3]. The Sevilla Clay is more sparsely distributed in Trinidad. It is found in Felicity, Chaguanas, Couva, California, Gasparillo, Bonne Aventure, Cipero Road and Ste. Madeline, The soil has been described as a relatively neutral vertisol, developed from calcareous shales and marls of (Central and Southem Trinidad [1]. These two soils exist. Senior Lectre, Department of Mechanical & Manufacturing Eoginceing, The University of the West Indies (UWD, St Augusize, The Republic of Trinidad & Tobago, WL Emait: ckwue@enguwitt * Service Baginer, Process Management Limited, Pot Litas, The Republic of Trinidad & Tobago, Wal ° Senior Lecture, Faculty of Science & Agriculture, UWL, St Augustine, The Repabic of Trinidad & Tobago, WL Pertnettdscassion willbe published in Jal, 2006 West indian Joeraal of Engineering if received by May, 2006, 7 ‘West Indian Journal of Engineering Vol. 28, No. 2, (January 2006) Technical Paper (Ekwue, Lall & Stone) 27 - 40 in the sugarcane belt in Trinidad. A third soil, Integrade Clay, which is a mixture of the two, was identified by Gumbs et al. {3]. Not many properties of this latter soil have been identified, except for the work done by the authors. The soil is moderately high in clay and silt and is highly plastic [3]. These authors have recommended this soil and itis indeed now being used in the prestigious Queen's Park Oval in Port of Spain, Another soil commonly used in cricket pitches in ‘Trinidad is Frederick Clay. This soil is slightly acidic, contains moderate amounts of nutrients and displays considerable swelling and shrinkage in response to wetting and drying [4] ‘The performance of cricket pitches in Trinidad and in the Caribbean region generally can best be described as erratic and unreliable. This unpredictable behaviour of the pitches was emphasised during the two Test matches played in Trinidad as part of the 1998 Test Series of England vs. West Indies, Upon conclusion of the series, the West Indies Cricket Board was asked to submit a report on the state of its pitches by the International Cricket Council. A similar incident ‘occurred at the Queen's Park Oval in January 2002, where during a match organised to select the National team, the match was called off because of the unpredictable bounce which posed severe threats to batsmen, Ground curators always prepare cricket pitches by feel. Surveys conducted as a part of this study revealed that throughout Trinidad, curators depend on their senses to determine when a pitch has suifieient water and has been rolled enough to achieve a good result, which includes a durable pitch that allows for good bounce and pace of the ball. Scientific measurements of moisture conteat, compaction, infiltration rates and other parameters are not used in the preparation of cricket pitches. Presently, the game demands a fair, precise, durable and sometimes predictable pitch in order to achieve a successful match for both batsmen and bowlers. The need for the detailed ‘study of soil properties used in cricket pitches is very important in order to help in advising curators in their preparation and maintenance of pitches. From literature, only Gumbs ef al. [3] and Ahmad [2] have carried out work on the soils used in cricket pitches in ‘Trinidad. Ho ver, these works are a bit limited since they only emphasised the physical and chemical propertics, leaving out the soil engineering properties, c.g. strength enetrability, compactibility and ‘compressibility. These engineering properties greatly influence the performance of cricket pitches [5]. The work by these latter authors in South Africa provides useful guidelines on the preparation of cricket pitches and particularly on how soil engincering properties affect the performance of cricket pitches ‘They reported that an ideal cricket pitch should have 50-60% clay, less than 10% coarse sand, less than 5% calcium carbonate and sodium levels, a linear shrinkage of 0.08-0, 15 and less than 5% organic matter content. ‘This paper reports the results of the study of the physical and engineering properties of soils commonly used in cricket pitches in Trinidad and uses the paper by ‘Tainton et al. [5] and others to make inferences on the suitability of these soils for use in cricket pitches, as well as offer advice on the management of Trinidad’s cricket pitches. These inferences are appropriate in Trinidad’s conditions since in the West Indies, cricket is mostly played during the dry season which corresponds to the summer period in South Africa. 2. Materials and Methods Six samples of soils (Table 1) were collected from Hed S.uaenD ose zr zee ove ret 08 ost os ‘e10 ouepers (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (96) (4) (%) eure edureg toms xepu wun wr awn wu wus wu Ayonseid pinbr ONseld sBeyunys —(Z00'0>)- (z00'0-s0'0) (G0'0-z) £10 us pues smog yond IPD ays fo Soptsadoug MmuOS %y TTAVL [aj works Auousre, ios yasn o Bupseco® UOREOYBER.D. g {a1 4a peynuep| ABo.e0u A810 Pex PexIW exw owredsep ‘yeH Auouuey ‘Reo ope Banu ‘suepnusoiyg squenby ‘aquooURLON ayy Pury euED eujepewy “21 BuIs ‘eIQ uMoL S60Ulid ‘suepnusoiud onuenby PeXIW a UMO] SEOUL! “HH JEBED ‘Aeig ovedyey ‘svepnwoiyo oquenby equoquounuon, see ‘uO. Seoul ‘pietd eUED c1veH| ueNE, ‘fej9 eNnos, pox exw exw SOd ‘SPunoiE FeAO wea $:UeERD Nos pio 2Hed Suse) ‘syonbedox, oe", eXIW 60r seuenBeyo ‘Aja 'uones ANIC ‘Rei yopepels MOMBOYIOSEID NOS ABojorouy Ae10, JOqUINN 11S ‘uoqEac] eiduieg ‘ouren exdureg, M108 Vong OD 248 fo UoqsDOYSSOTD pry Bunydos +1 TEV, ‘West Indian Journal of Engineering Vol. 28, No. 2, (January 2006) Technical Paper (Ekwue, Lall & Stone) 27 - 40 FIGURE 1: Map of Trinidad showing the Sampling Positions. (I- Felicity, Chaguanas: 2- Queen's Park, Port of Spain; 3,4- Princes Town; 5- St. Madeline and 6- Gasparillo) spring-type, Proctor penetrometer [12] with a probe diameter of 6.4 mm. Four penetration resistance readings were taken on the surface and averaged to ‘obtain the mean penetration resistance. Shear strength ‘measurements were also made for soils compacted with the 5 Proctor blows using a shear vane whose vane size was 19 mm, One shear strength reading was taken at the top 5-cm depth of each sample. Shear strength readings for the 15 and 25 blows could not be taken for five of the soils because the soil strength at these compaction levels exceeded the limit (130 kPa) of the shear vane. Two replicate soils were used for each test. For each soil and compaction effort, the mean values of bulk density, penetration resistance and shear strength were plotted against corresponding water contents to obtain maximum bulk density, peak penetration resistance and peak shear strength and the corresponding water contents. Liquid limits and shrinkage limits were also determined using the ‘methods described by Lambe [8]. The plasticity index (Table 2) is the difference between the liquid limit and the plastic limit, The swell test of the soils immersed in distilled water was done using the method described by Bowles [13] 30 ‘The compressibility of each soil was determined with a standard compression machine using the procedure earlier described [9, 14]. The soils were all tested at their Proctor optimur water contents for maximum compaction to ensure that they were at similar compaction states before testing. The soils were loosely packed intoa cylinder 15.2 em in diameter and 11.6 em high and weighed to determine the initial dry bulk density. This loose condition simulates the freshly placed layer of the soil in cricket pitches. The soils were then placed in a compression machine which applied confined uniaxial static compression at the rate of 2 inm min. Because the soils were confined during testing, there was no lateral strain and the axial strain was exactly equal to the volumetric strain US}. Values of applied stress were monitored forevery 2.5 mm compression until a stress of 1000 kPa was reached. Values of bulk density, volumetric strain and void ratio at any applied stress were computed using the formulae derived by Stone & Ekwue [14, 16]. In addition, the compression index, C, [15] based on void ratio, and popular in Civil Engineering literature was computed using the following equation derived by Stone & Ekwue [14] “West Indian Journal of Engincering Vol. 28, No. 2, (Ianuary 2006) Technical Paper (Ekwue, Lall & Stone) 27 - 40 __Plea-%) p,log(o2/o%) ol) where p, is the particle density of the soil assumed as 2.65 Mg m; p, is the initial bulk density of the soil before compaction; ¢,,€, are strains at two compressive stresses 0, and 0;, respectively. 3. Results 3.1 Soil Physical Properties Al the soils had high clay content with the Frederick Clay with 80% content having the greatest amount (Table 2). The high clay contents are consistent with previous results [9] which showed high clay contents for many soils in Trinidad, The high clay soils are likely tobe related to the pedology of the soils and the climate in Trinidad, With the high clay content in the Frederick, Clay, it is likely to have the ability to withstand a long game duration without considerable surface deterioration, Interviews done at the Calcutta Cricket Ground in Couva and the Invaders Ground in Felicity, the two major cricket grounds which presently usc this type of clay, revealed that players were happy with the consistent pace and bounce which the pitch delivered

    You might also like