Unit 6 Psychoanalysis : Structure
Unit 6 Psychoanalysis : Structure
Unit 6 Psychoanalysis : Structure
Structure
6.0 Introduction
6.1 Influences on Psychoanalysis
6.1.1 Theories of the Unconscious Mind
6.1.2 Ideas of Psychopathology
6.1.3 The Use of Hypnosis
6.1.4 Charles Darwin
6.1.5 Attitude towards Sexuality in late 19th century Vienna
6.1.6 The Concept of Catharsis
6.1.7 Ideas about Dreams
6.2 Development of Psychoanalysis
6.2.1 Adopting Catharsis and Rejecting Hypnosis
6.2.2 Free Association
6.2.3 First Book on Psychoanalysis and Separation from Breuer
6.2.4 Self-Analysis and the Interpretations of Dreams
6.2.5 Recognition and Dissention
6.3 Psychoanalysis as a Method of Treatment
6.3.1 Free Association
6.3.1.1 Resistance
6.3.1.2 Repression
6.3.1.3 Transference
6.3.2 Dream Analysis
6.4 Freud’s Method of Research
6.5 Psychoanalysis as a System of Personality
6.5.1 Instincts
6.5.2 Conscious and Unconscious Aspects of Personality
6.5.3 Anxiety
6.5.4 Defence Mechanisms
6.5.5 Psychosexual Stages
6.6 Criticisms
6.6.1 Method of Data Collection
6.6.2 Published Case History
6.6.3 Freud’s Data
6.6.4 Assumptions about Human Nature
6.0 Introduction
Psychoanalysis formally began in the year 1895, and thus, overlaps the
other school of thoughts of psychology. Initially, the representatives of the
settings of psychology and psychoanalysis had little contact with each other.
Despite their fundamental disagreements, the school of thoughts shared an
academic heritage and owed much of their inspiration and form to Wundt.
The science of psychology developed in an academic and laboratory setting,
whereas psychoanalysis developed in a clinical setting.
In its early years, psychology was concerned with investigating the
elements and processes of consciousness. Sensation, perception, memory,
and thinking were its chief topics of interest. Psychoanalysis, on the other
hand, was mainly concerned with the unconscious. Its interests were in the
areas of motivation, emotion, conflict, neurotic symptoms, dreams, and
character traits. These differing areas of interest kept both psychology and
psychoanalysis apart for quite some time.
Box 6.0: Sigmund Freud
Sigmund Freud, the founder of psychoanalysis, which led to the first
comprehensive theory of personality. Psychoanalysis is about the role of
the unconscious mind in behaviour and psychological disorders.
Freud was born on May 6, 1856, in Jewish family. He spent most of his
life in Vienna, where he completed all his education and training, and
eventually developed psychoanalysis. Due to the gradual popularity of
psychoanalysis, Freud developed a worldwide following. After the rise of Figure 6.1: Sigmund Freud
Naziism, Freud had to flee from Vienna. He died on September 23, 1939, (1856-1939)
in London. Source: www.livescience.com
97
105
108
6.6 Criticisms
Even though being highly influential and popular, Sigmund Freud faced a
number of criticisms:
6.6.1 Method of Data Collection
Freud’s methods of data collection have been the target of much criticism.
He drew his insights and conclusion from the responses his patients while
they were undergoing analysis. Compared with the experimental method
of systematically collecting objective data under controlled conditions
of observation, Freud’s method has been considered to have a number of
shortcomings:
1) The conditions under which Freud collected his data are unsystematic
and uncontrolled. He did not make a verbatim transcript of each
patient’s words but worked from notes he made several hours after
seeing the patient. Some of the original data (patient’s actual words)
would surely have been lost in the time that had elapsed because
of the vagaries of memory and the well-documented possibility of
distortion and omission. Thus, the data consisted only of what Freud
remembered.
2) It is possible that while recalling his patients’ words, Freud reinterpreted
them. He may have been guided by his desire to find material that
supported his ideas. In other words, he may have remembered and
recorded only what he wanted to hear. Freud’s notes could have been
accurate, but it is not possible to know this because the original data
have not survived.
6.6.2 Published Case Histories
There are discrepancies between Freud’s notes on his therapy sessions
and the case histories he eventually published. One researcher compared
111
112
6.8 Summary
Now that we have come to the end of this unit, let us recapitulate all the
major points that we have learnt.
●● In its early years, psychology was concerned with investigating the
elements and processes of consciousness. Sensation, perception,
memory, and thinking were its chief topics of interest. Psychoanalysis,
on the other hand, was mainly concerned with the unconscious. Its
interests were in the areas of motivation, emotion, conflict, neurotic
symptoms, dreams, and character traits. These differing areas of
interest kept both psychology and psychoanalysis apart for quite
some time.
●● Freud was influenced by the early theories of unconscious given
by different philosophers such as Leibniz, Herbart, and Fechner.
Psychoanalysis formally began in the year 1895. The science of
psychology developed in an academic and laboratory setting, whereas
psychoanalysis developed in a clinical setting.
●● Charcot extensively used hypnosis to study the patients of hysteria.
Freud was highly influenced by his use of hypnosis in the treatment
of disorders. He began to use hypnosis as a method of treatment of
disorders.
●● Pierre Janet posited mental phenomena – especially memory
impairments, fixed ideas, and unconscious forces – as causal factors,
and he chose hypnosis as the method of treatment. Janet’s work
anticipated many of Freud’s ideas.
●● Darwin discussed several ideas that Freud later made central issues
in his psychoanalysis, including – unconscious mental processes,
conflicts, the significance of dreams, the hidden symbolism of certain
behavioural symptoms, and the importance of sexual arousal.
114
116
117
118
119