Social Pharmacy Assignment 2
Social Pharmacy Assignment 2
Social Pharmacy Assignment 2
Abstract
Background: Little attention has been given to characterizing the roles of pharmacists in disasters even though the importance of
pharmacists’ involvement is widely acknowledged. Objective: We amid to review a broad range of pharmacists roles in disasters and
their response by numerous reports in the literature. Method: A quantitative content analysis technique was used to gather data
consisting of words and phrases from literature regarding pharmacists’ roles and their response in disasters. Results: A total of 106
reports were reviewed and screened based on titles and abstracts. Of these, only 20 studies were determined to meet the eligibility
criteria for discussion. A total of 7 natural disasters (pandemics, tornadoes, fires, earthquakes, floods, hurricanes and storms) were
found in the literature. Roles were classified using the Setlak classification scheme, which includes descriptors such as pharmaceutical
supply, patient management, policy coordination, and response integration. Pharmaceutical supply was remains the pharmacists’
preferred role. Conclusion: It is evident from the literature that pharmacists are uniquely positioned during disasters to provide
healthcare continuity and medication.
Europe and the U.S to expand the legal roles of pharmacists to research findings that met the above keywords. The reviewers
fight an ongoing COVID19 disaster. Pharmacists in Australia are agreed to exclude articles that did not meet the
receiving prescriptions through mails/faxed/email, and phone aforementioned eligibility criteria, whereas those that met the
messages for home delivery services. Pharmacists promoted eligibility criteria based on reviewers’ assessments were
social distancing by organizing pharmacies in such a way as to included for full paper review. Full articles were reviewed
make it difficult for the virus to spread. They designed independently by each reviewer against the inclusion and
temporary barriers to limit the number of patients in the exclusion criteria. In case of disagreement between the three
pharmacy at any given time and to increase the distance reviewers, a fourth reviewer (SMR) who was an expert in
between patients. They played an important role in educating pharmacy practice and practice based research was asked to
people and patient on how to behave in the pharmacy and, how review the disagreement between the authors. However, there
patients can protect themselves from infection. Pharmacists were no disagreements between the reviewers during the
worked with other members of the healthcare team and refer review process.
patients’ chronic disease-related issues to them. They also
provided additional information to patients having associated Data items extraction and studies quality assessment
chronic diseases and educate them to perform self-monitoring We extracted and recorded data on a Microsoft Excel data
[8-10]
. extraction sheet. We reviewed the following information in the
full-text records: authors and year of publication, the country
The purpose of this article was to review a broad range of where the study was conducted, study design, nature of
pharmacists’ functions in disasters and their response by disasters, and pharmacist role and response to the disaster
numerous reports in the literature. management. Study qualities were evaluated using the Critical
Appraisal Skills Program (CASP) checklist [12]. (See table 4)
Methods
Search strategy Data analysis
The units of analysis and observation were journal articles. Data Natural disasters and pharmacists’ roles were examined using
for this review were identified by a structured review of the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test, and a follow-up multiple
‘PubMed’ ‘Medline’, ‘Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied comparison procedure (Dunn’s test) was run using an online
Health Literature (CINAHL), ‘International Pharmaceutical macro compatible with the statistics software [13]. Statistical
Abstracts (IPA), ‘Sociological Sources’ including sociINDEX and analysis was performed using SAS and descriptive statistics,
Social Work Abstracts. The following keywords were used: including counts and percentages, were run using Microsoft
‘Pharmacist’ ‘Pharmacist roles’ ‘Natural Disasters’ ‘Pharmacist Excel. Descriptive statistics such as pie chart and bar chart were
and Natural Disasters’ ‘Pharmacist and Disaster Management’. used for cumulative percentages of disasters referenced in the
All papers reviewed were written in the English language. The literature and cumulative percentage of pharmacist roles in
included papers were quantitative studies that analyzed disaster management. Goodness-of-fit analysis was used to
pharmacists’ roles and classified using the Setlak classification calculate the differences between pharmacists’ roles and
scheme[11] across the areas related to pharmaceutical supply, functions in disaster management.
patient management, response integration and policy
coordination during disasters. The last search was performed in Results
July 2020 which was based on COVID19. All studies were The electronic search based on the screening of titles yielded a
screened based on titles and abstracts to exclude irrelevant total of 106 reports from ‘PubMed’ ‘Medline’, ‘CINAHL’, ‘IPA’,
articles and the remaining full-text reports were further ‘Sociological Sources’ including sociINDEX and Social Work
examined to determine whether they met the inclusion criteria. Abstracts. A total of 106 articles were identified as relating to
pharmacists’ roles during natural disasters; after removing
Eligibility criteria for inclusion duplicate and non-English articles, 96 articles were screened for
Studies conducted to examine or report the role of pharmacists eligibility. In total, 80 articles were related to the topic, but only
in natural disasters were included and considered eligible for 20 fit the inclusion criteria. In the first screening process, 35
this review. The studied population was community articles were excluded because they were not related to
pharmacists, hospital pharmacists, and regulatory pharmacists, pharmacist role, natural disasters, and pharmacist response to
those involved in the field of disaster and health, or any disaster management. In the next step, 25 articles including
combination of the above. Only English studies were included non-peer-reviewed articles (n=13), review articles (n=2),
in the review. Studies that did not directly address pharmacists’ reports, editorial and commentaries (n=3), and inaccessible
roles in disasters response and management were excluded. online articles (n=7) were also excluded. All the included articles
Commentary articles were excluded because these depend on had clear aims and objectives, and describing data sources. The
the author or authors’ point of view. Partially available reported study selection process is illustrated in Figure 1.
studies (e.g., abstracts, forms, or articles that were inaccessible
online) were also excluded. The three authors (MAR, SA and
MN) independently reviewed the titles and abstracts of the
13. Elliott, A.C. and L.S. Hynan, A SAS® macro 22. Massoomi, F., Pharmacists in the Omaha
implementation of a multiple comparison post hoc Metropolitan Medical Response System. American
test for a Kruskal–Wallis analysis. Computer methods journal of health-system pharmacy, 2005. 62(12): p.
and programs in biomedicine, 2011. 102(1): p. 75-80. 1290-1298.
14. Ford, H., C.E. Dallas, and C. Harris, Examining roles 23. Merges, V., Hurricane Iniki--providing hospital
pharmacists assume in disasters: a content analytic pharmacy services. Hospital pharmacy, 1993. 28(5): p.
approach. Disaster Med Public Health Prep, 2013. 393-4, 400.
7(6): p. 563-72. 24. Montello, M.J. and T. Ames, Therapeutic selection
15. Terriff, C.M. and S. Newton, Pharmacist role in during an emergency response. American journal of
emergency preparedness. Journal of the American health-system pharmacy, 1999. 56(3): p. 236-240.
Pharmacists Association, 2008. 48(6): p. 702-708. 25. Austin, Z., J.C. Martin, and P.A. Gregory, Pharmacy
16. Thompson, C.A., HHS redesigns role of pharmacy practice in times of civil crisis: The experience of SARS
personnel in disaster preparedness. 2010, Oxford and “the blackout” in Ontario, Canada. Research in
University Press. Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 2007. 3(3): p.
17. Young, D., Pharmacists play vital roles in Katrina 320-335.
response: more disaster-response participation urged. 26. Nolin, K., et al., Chempack program: Role of the
2005, Oxford University Press. health-system pharmacist. American journal of
18. Romano, S., et al., Time-trend analysis of medicine health-system pharmacy, 2006. 63(22): p. 2188-2190.
sales and shortages during COVID-19 outbreak: Data 27. Grabenstein, J.D., Public and patient concerns in
from community pharmacies. Research in Social and catastrophic circumstances. American journal of
Administrative Pharmacy, 2021. 17(1): p. 1876-1881. health-system pharmacy, 2002. 59(10): p. 923-925.
19. Badreldin, H.A. and B. Atallah, Global drug shortages 28. Miller, C., Hurricane Iniki--providing Prescription
due to COVID-19: impact on patient care and Service in a Clinic. Hospital pharmacy, 1993. 28(5): p.
mitigation strategies. Research in Social and 401-403.
Administrative Pharmacy, 2021. 17(1): p. 1946-1949. 29. Haffer, A.S., et al., 2001 anthrax crisis in Washington,
20. Pinto, G.S., et al., FIP's response to the COVID-19 DC: Clinic for persons exposed to contaminated mail.
pandemic: Global pharmacy rises to the challenge. American journal of health-system pharmacy, 2002.
Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 59(12): p. 1189-1192.
2021. 17(1): p. 1929-1933. 30. Chin, T.W., et al., Severe acute respiratory syndrome
21. Levy, D.B., et al., Pharmacist participation in the (SARS): the pharmacist's role. Pharmacotherapy: The
management of incidents involving hazardous Journal of Human Pharmacology and Drug Therapy,
materials. American journal of hospital pharmacy, 2004. 24(6): p. 705-712.
1987. 44(3): p. 549-556.
Records screened: n = 65
excluded: n = 35
not about pharmacist role in disasters
Eligibility
Selected articles: n = 20
9%
8%
36%
Pandemics
Hurricanes, Tornados, Storms
Fires
Earthquacks
47%
3. Was the research design appropriate to address the aims of the research? 20 0
5. Has the relationship between researcher and participants been adequately considered? 09 11