IE CH 3 Assignment
IE CH 3 Assignment
IE CH 3 Assignment
Extra Questions
Ques 1. Those public sector undertakings which are making profits should be
privatised. Do you agree? Why?
Ans. No, the profit making public sector enterprises should not be privatised for
the following reasons:
a. These PSUs are revenue generators for the government.
b. The assets of the profit making industries, if undervalued, might lead to a
substantial loss to the government.
c. Some of the PSUs like water, railways etc. enhance the welfare of the
nation and serve the general public at a nominal cost. Thus, strategic
industries should be retained by the government to avoid emergence of
monopolies.
d. Privatisation may cause exploitation of workers in these units and may
have socially undesirable effects such as concentration of economic
power thereby leading to reduced welfare.
Ques 3. Do you think outsourcing is good for India? Why are developed
countries opposing it?
Ans: Outsourcing is beneficial to India. Outsourcing appears to be beneficial to
India, as evidenced by the following points.
1. Employment: For a growing country like India, job creation is a critical goal,
and outsourcing has shown to be a godsend in this regard. It results in the
creation of new, higher-paying jobs.
2. Technical know-how transfer: Outsourcing allows for the transfer of
complex and advanced technology ideas and technical know-how from
developed to developing countries.
3. International credibility: Outsourcing to India improves India's
international credibility. This raises the amount of money coming into India.
4. Encourages other sectors: Outsourcing benefits not just the service industry,
but also other associated sectors such as the industrial and agricultural sectors,
due to different backward and forward connections.
5. Assists in the growth and formation of human capital: Outsourcing aids in
the development and formation of human capital by training and imparting
advanced skills to employees, hence enhancing their future scope and
appropriateness for high-ranking positions.
6. Eradication of poverty: Outsourcing enhances the level of living and the
eradication of poverty in developing countries by producing more and better-
paying jobs. It also aids in the reduction of poverty.
7. Increased infrastructure investment: Outsourcing to India necessitates the
development of higher-quality infrastructure. This leads to the economy's
modernisation and the government's increased investment in developing high-
quality infrastructure and human resources.
However, while outsourcing to India is beneficial, developed countries oppose it
since outsourcing causes a movement of income and investments from rich
countries to developing countries. MNCs also contribute more to the host
country's development than they do to their own. Outsourcing also reduces the
number of jobs created in wealthy countries because the same jobs can be done
for less money in developing countries. Furthermore, this results in job
insecurity in rich countries, as jobs might be outsourced to poor countries at any
time.