Civil Engg Project Management CE404
Civil Engg Project Management CE404
Civil Engg Project Management CE404
Human Technical
Time Finance
Resource Resource
CONSTRUCTION PROJECT
Is the organised process of constructing, renovating etc. of
building or infrastructure
Project Include huge
amount of resource:
1. Funds
2. Manpower
3. Equipment
4. Materials
5. Time
UNIQUE FEATURES OF CONSTRUCTION
PROJECTS
1. One time activity- it must be performed correctly the first
time every time.
2. Complexity –multidisciplinary tasks to be done
3. High cost and time for execution.
4. High risk of failure
5. Difficulty in defining quality standards.
6. Uniqueness of people relationship.
7. Lack of experience of client
8. Untrained workforce
CONSTRUCTION PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Knowledge of
Predetermined course of
action to achieve project
objective
2. PLANNING - Effective allocation of resources
▪Involves formulation of alternatives and choosing the
most suitable
▪Define scope of work
▪Work breakdown structure (WBS) for activities
▪Work schedule and project network
▪Estimate resource and expenditure requirements
3. DESIGN
More specific details and information gathered
1. Preliminary design
2. Detailed design
3. DESIGN…
Preliminary design – continuation of feasibility study
▪Studies of various design alternative, their economic
comparative studies and architectural aspect
▪Detailed field investigation
▪Soil testing
▪Geological & hydrological data collection
▪Market survey
3. DESIGN…
Detailed design
▪Various components are analysed and designed
Mode of execution
PROJECT FINANCIAL VIABILITY
The project viability assessment section should include:
❖The assumptions on cost and revenues
❖Projected income and cash flow statements –
❖Return or revenue income if any
CONSTRUCTION PLANNING
AND SCHEDULING
❖ Scope recognition
❖ Task definition & responsibility identification
❖ Effective utilization of resources (labour, material &
equipment)
❖ Tracking and controlling project time and cost
Project
Planning
Project
Scheduling
Project
Controlling
CONSTRUCTION PLANNING
Planning: Process of formulating in advance, plan of
action for coordinating various activities and resources
CONSTRUCTION PLANNING - OBJECTIVES
❖To predetermine how project objectives will be achieved
❖To determine inter dependencies of activities
❖Procurement of resources in advance
❖Proper choice of equipment / technology
❖Proper design of various elements of the project
❖To ensure constant flow of funds till completion of
projects
❖To employ trained and experienced staff
CONSTRUCTION PLANNING
1. Time plan 2. Resources 3. Finance 4. Project
plan plan control plan
• Design and • Labour • Budget • Progress of
drawing • Materials • Cash flow planned
preparation • Equipment estimates work –
• Work updating
quantities and
revising
plans
CONSTRUCTION PLANNING STEPS
1. Define project objective
Aim:
Limitations
▪Relationships between all activities cannot be effectively represented
MODULE 2
NETWORK CRASHING
NETWORK CRASHING
Process of reducing project duration by providing more
resources
❖Activities must be so scheduled to be completed with minimum cost and time
❖Projectduration can be reduced to certain extend by assigning more
resources to activities
❖However, doing this increases project cost
❖This process which reduce project time by reducing duration of one or more
activities is termed crashing
❖Decision is based on analysis of trade - off between time and cost
NETWORK CRASHING
AIM
To achieve the maximum decrease in completion
time for minimum additional cost
PROJECT COST
Total project cost = Direct Cost + Indirect Cost
Direct cost
• Expenditures which are directly associated with project activities
• Including labour cost, material cost, salaries etc.
Indirect cost
• Are not directly associated with specific project activities but are
assessed for whole project
• Including administrative cost, rent, office space, loss of profit,
overheads, insurance cost etc.
COST – TIME TRADE OFF
The analysis of inter-relationship between time and
cost of a project, in order to minimise its cost and
duration is termed cost-time trade off
COST – TIME TRADE OFF
PROJECT COST
Total project cost:
• Increaseif project crashed beyond
certain extend
• Increase if project prolonged
indefinitely
• Is
at minimum for optimum project
duration
Normal time (tn):
Standard time which is usually allowed for an activity
Crash time (tc): :
Minimum possible time in which an activity can be completed by
providing extra resources
Time beyond which an activity cannot be shortened by any amount of
increase in resources
Normal cost (Cn):
Direct cost required to complete the activity in normal time duration
Crash cost (Cc):
Direct cost required to complete activity within crash time
COST SLOPE:
The extra cost incurred for
expediting an activity to reduce
the project duration by unit time
𝐶𝑐 − 𝐶𝑛 ∆𝐶
Cost slope = =
𝑡𝑛 − 𝑡𝑐 ∆𝑡
STEPS IN PROJECT CRASHING
1. Prepare network diagram and using CPM calculations find the
critical path
2. Compute cost-slope for each activity
3. Reduce duration of critical activity with least cost-slope ( which is not
shortened to its crash duration)
4. Increase in cost can be determined by cost slope multiplied by time
units
5. Reduce duration of critical activity with least cost-slope until crash
duration is reached or critical path changes
STEPS IN PROJECT CRASHING
6. When multiple critical paths arise, activities to be shortened can be
determined by comparing cost slope of activities on critical path
and combining them
7. Continue the process until no further shortening is possible as the
crash point is reached
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Estimating activity times using network diagrams are on the assumption
that resources are liberally available
In practice construction projects face constraints such as:
Resource shortage
Delay in procurement
Reduced availability of funds
...
This constraints affects the performance and completion of activities
and may delay the project
RESOURCE ALLOCATION
Process of assigning and scheduling available resources
in the most effective and economical way
Current budget
Very short term budget
Prepared to account currently prevailing circumstances
Fixed budget
Budget which is designed to remain unchanged irrespective of the level of
activity attained
Helpful only when the actual activity will be equal to budgeted activity
Is most suited for fixed expenses, which have no relation to the volume of
output
It shows what product will be sold, in what quantities, and at what prices
Production budget
Production budget is prepared on the basis of the sales budget
The production budget lists the number of units that must be produced to
satisfy sales needs
Shows the number of each grade workmen needed to complete the activity
• Depreciation
Owning • Interest on investments
cost • Taxes
• Fuel cost
Operating • Maintenance / repair cost
cost • Operator's cost
• Replacement cost
MATERIALS STANDARD PRICE
Defined as the estimated all-in price of the unit quantity of an
item, delivered at the project site
All-in price include: Source Price, Wastage Costs, Transportation Costs and
Taxes
MATERIALS STANDARD PRICE
Purchase price can be estimated from
Response to quotation invitations
Standard price catalogues
Past experience
During any project execution several issues may arise among project participants
Results in disputes between employer, engineer and contractor on various factors such as defect in
construction, payments, time lag etc.
CAUSES OF DISPUTES
Dispute arises when the contracting parties disagrees with a particular
claim as per the contract document
There may be insufficiency in contract preparation such as:
All the required information are thoroughly incorporated in tenders
Inaccuracies in contract data
Discrepancies in site data, drawings & quantities
Incompleteness, inaccuracy & inconsistency are only part of the causes
for construction disputes
CAUSES OF DISPUTES
Incorrect Ground Data
Ground data include details such as soil properties, ground water level, temperature,
etc.
Contractor estimations are based on ground data provided with tender document
Variations during execution time may result in disputes
Use of Faulty/Ambiguous provisions/Language in contracts
Language of contract must be clear and not open to different interpretations
Clear documentation must be given for procedures in case of any contingencies
Deviations
The contract should be so designed that there must not be significant extra items &
deviations
CAUSES OF DISPUTES
Unreasonable attitude
Project participants must preserve mutual trust
Need to keep professional approach even at stages of disagreements
Contractor being of poor means
The contractor must have sufficient resources to carry out the project
If not may resort to suspension or termination of projects/contracts
Unfair distribution of risks
When contractors are unfairly forced to take the risks, will cover that by
hiking rates, which results in increase in project cost
DISPUTE AVOIDANCE
Means to avoid disputes:
Fair allocation of contract risks
There can be a
Sole arbitrators - agreed by both parties
Joint arbitrators – when each party appoints their own arbitrator
These individuals together chose a third colleague arbitrator to complete
the bench of arbitrators
ARBITRATION AWARD
Arbitration award is the award granted by the arbitrator in their decision
It is the final and binding decision made which resolves, wholly or in part, the dispute submitted
to the jurisdiction
This award can be money one party has to pay to the other party
It can also be a non-financial award
Arbitration Award - Types
Interim Award: This is a temporary award until the tribunal has given its final decision
Partial Award: Some elements of the claim have been determined but other issues remain and need to
be resolved before the final award is made. Parties can continue arbitrating the remaining issues
Performance Award: A party can be ordered to perform specific works as award other than monetary
award
Final Award: This is usually in writing and signed by all the arbitrators. It must also be dated for
calculating interest on payments. Once the final award is made this ends proceedings.
Additional Award: Usually once the final award it made, the tribunal has no further authority. the
parties can request an additional award be made on an undecided issue still in dispute
ARBITRATION - ADVANTAGES
Faster than court litigation
The cases can be handled quickly than the court proceedings and hence
is more cost-effective
More flexible
The scope of arbitration procedures can be decided by the parties
themselves & can be deviated from the complex court proceedings
Privacy & confidentiality
Arbitration is a private method of dispute settling. Arbitral proceedings
& arbitral awards are more confidential. General public are not allowed
and the documents are also not to be made public
Need not follow official language of judicial proceedings
ARBITRATION - ADVANTAGES
• Choice of arbitrator
• Ideal for technical disputes
• Disputing parties can themselves decide the arbitrator. Since the
arbitrator will be a person with domain knowledge than be a
lawyer can give better resolutions
• Economic
• Arbitration processes are more cost effective than court actions
ARBITRATION - DISADVANTAGES
Limited authority of arbitrators
Process may subject to pressures from the stronger/wealthier side
The fees for arbitrator may increase the legal cost. This may not be cost-effective for smaller
disputes/projects
Arbitration agreements may be sometimes present in ancillary agreements in contracts
This causes parties to waive their right to access courts and to have a judge/jury to decide the case
In case of multiple arbitrators, setting hearing dates as per everyone’s schedule may lead to
delays
ETHICS
Ethics are moral principles that govern a person’s behaviour or
conducting of an activity
Extortion: When one party threatens other of adverse consequences unless other party meets
certain demands
Not adhering to the permits from government authorities regarding construction mandates
Ethical Issues In Civil Engineering
• Overbilling by increasing unit price for activities to raise cash flow
• Hiding incompetency
• Not providing labours with safety equipment or insurance as per law
• Government firms bidding against private firms while being a part of
tendering process and unfairly penalize private firms
• Granting tenders to lowest quoted parties without considering
experience & capacity
Ethical Issues In Civil Engineering
Tendering
• Client give more vital information to preferred tenderers - Bias in tendering
• Bias in tendering evaluation for major tenders
• Clients preselecting contractors and then doing tender for a statutory requirement only
• Contractors overstating their capacity and qualification & experience
Consultant Fees and Project Costs
• Developers not properly pay the consultants
• Main consultants cutting costs of another consultant’s fee
• Main contractors deducting subcontractors fee without proper justification
Code of Ethics
A code of ethics is a guide of principles designed to help
professionals conduct works with honesty and with integrity
An ethical code may include business ethics, a code of professional practice, and an employee
code of conduct
If violated will lead to ethical problems
Provides a framework for ethical judgement
Defines roles and responsibilities of professionals
Code of Ethics - ASCE
As per ASCE engineers shall adhere to certain ethical values such as:
Data:
▪Data is the raw input
▪Data represents unanalysed facts, and events
▪Data is processed to retrieve information
DATA MANAGEMENT
2 types of data in project management
1. Basic document data
Covers the project initial database & project baseline plans
Include: approved design & drawings, contract documents,
purchase orders etc.
From these data information effective & efficient functioning of
project can be analysed
DATA MANAGEMENT
2 types of data in project management
2. Performance data
Represents actual outcome of a planned activity on a given date
Derived through performance evaluation reports, observations,
appropriate measurements
Performance data is analysed by monitoring centre to check
deviations from basic data & standards and make appropriate
decisions
COMPONENTS OF PMIS
▪Operators:
▪Include data preparation personnel, system analysts, programmers,
computer operators, etc.
▪Procedures:
▪Include basic steps to analyse data and carry out project activity
▪Formal operating procedures in the form of manual or instruction
booklet
CONTENTS
➢Safety in construction
➢Causes of accidents
SAFETY OF STRUCTURE
To ensure minimum cost of construction
To ensure good quality of construction and better rate of work
progress
IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY MEASURES
ECONOMIC REASONS
Many additional expenses will incur from accidents in site
Direct cost from accidents: Indirect cost from accidents:
▪Medical expenses ▪Slow down of operations
▪Workman’s compensation ▪Decrease on productivity
▪Increase in insurance premium ▪Administrative works
▪Replacement of associated
equipment/material damaged ▪Loss of clients’ confidence
▪Court fees ▪Overtime necessitated by slow
down in work
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
The causes of accidents in a construction site may be grouped
according to their nature:
▪Planning & Organisation
▪Execution
▪Equipment
▪Management & conduct of work
▪Worker’s behaviour
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
PLANNING & ORGANISATION
▪Defects in technical planning
▪Fixing unsuitable time limits for works
▪Assigning works to incompetent contractors
▪Insufficient or defective supervision of works
▪Lack of cooperation with different departments
EXECUTION OF WORK
▪Defects in construction
▪Use of unsuitable materials
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
MANAGEMENT & CONDUCT OF WORK
Inadequate preparation for work
Lack of knowledge and skill for recruited employers
Inadequate examination of equipment
Inadequate instructions from supervisors
Inadequate supervision
EQUIPMENT
Lack of equipment
Unsuitable equipment
Defects in equipment
Lack of safety devices or safety measures
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
WORKER’S BEHAVIOUR
▪Irresponsible acts
▪Improper attitude towards work
▪Emotional instability
▪Improper use of safety devices
▪Unauthorised acts
▪carelessness
SAFETY MEASURES AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF
CONSTRUCTION
SAFETY MEASURES
Proper safety measures need to be carried out at different
construction stages including:
▪Pre-construction stage
▪Construction stage
▪Commissioning and handing over stage
SAFETY MEASURES – PRE CONSTRUCTION STAGE
Plan the effective safety measure for the nature of project
Decide on the construction methods which suits the health &
safety of workers
Allocate proper budget for safety considerations
Ascertain proper time frame for project
Proper safety requirements must be given in contract
documents
Contracting agencies may be asked to submit a health &
safety plan which effectively propose their methodology to
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Design & construction methods shall be considerate towards
the health and safety of people during construction
▪Adequate time must be allowed to carry out activities in
accordance with health & safety requirements
▪Review whether the construction methods comply with safety
measures and identify the possibilities of safety hazards in
activities and risk levels
▪If risk levels are unacceptable, take additional control
measures including method revisions if required
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Establish facilities such as training facilities, medical check up,
first aid, etc.
Ensure that the establishments at site such as site offices,
workmen camps, toilets, canteens, etc. meet required safety
standards
Construction agency shall properly coordinate the safety
measures
Project manager of construction agency shall ensure that all the
sub-contractors meet proper safety standards
Safety measures - Commissioning stage
Effectiveness of health and safety measures and
management system shall be reviewed for future planning
➢Causes of accidents
SAFETY OF STRUCTURE
To ensure minimum cost of construction
To ensure good quality of construction and better rate of work
progress
IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY MEASURES
ECONOMIC REASONS
Many additional expenses will incur from accidents in site
Direct cost from accidents: Indirect cost from accidents:
▪Medical expenses ▪Slow down of operations
▪Workman’s compensation ▪Decrease on productivity
▪Increase in insurance premium ▪Administrative works
▪Replacement of associated
equipment/material damaged ▪Loss of clients’ confidence
▪Court fees ▪Overtime necessitated by slow
down in work
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
The causes of accidents in a construction site may be grouped
according to their nature:
▪Planning & Organisation
▪Execution
▪Equipment
▪Management & conduct of work
▪Worker’s behaviour
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
PLANNING & ORGANISATION
▪Defects in technical planning
▪Fixing unsuitable time limits for works
▪Assigning works to incompetent contractors
▪Insufficient or defective supervision of works
▪Lack of cooperation with different departments
EXECUTION OF WORK
▪Defects in construction
▪Use of unsuitable materials
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
MANAGEMENT & CONDUCT OF WORK
Inadequate preparation for work
Lack of knowledge and skill for recruited employers
Inadequate examination of equipment
Inadequate instructions from supervisors
Inadequate supervision
EQUIPMENT
Lack of equipment
Unsuitable equipment
Defects in equipment
Lack of safety devices or safety measures
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
WORKER’S BEHAVIOUR
▪Irresponsible acts
▪Improper attitude towards work
▪Emotional instability
▪Improper use of safety devices
▪Unauthorised acts
▪carelessness
SAFETY MEASURES AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF
CONSTRUCTION
SAFETY MEASURES
Proper safety measures need to be carried out at different
construction stages including:
▪Pre-construction stage
▪Construction stage
▪Commissioning and handing over stage
SAFETY MEASURES – PRE CONSTRUCTION STAGE
Plan the effective safety measure for the nature of project
Decide on the construction methods which suits the health &
safety of workers
Allocate proper budget for safety considerations
Ascertain proper time frame for project
Proper safety requirements must be given in contract
documents
Contracting agencies may be asked to submit a health &
safety plan which effectively propose their methodology to
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Design & construction methods shall be considerate towards
the health and safety of people during construction
▪Adequate time must be allowed to carry out activities in
accordance with health & safety requirements
▪Review whether the construction methods comply with safety
measures and identify the possibilities of safety hazards in
activities and risk levels
▪If risk levels are unacceptable, take additional control
measures including method revisions if required
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Establish facilities such as training facilities, medical check up,
first aid, etc.
Ensure that the establishments at site such as site offices,
workmen camps, toilets, canteens, etc. meet required safety
standards
Construction agency shall properly coordinate the safety
measures
Project manager of construction agency shall ensure that all the
sub-contractors meet proper safety standards
Safety measures - Commissioning stage
Effectiveness of health and safety measures and
management system shall be reviewed for future planning
➢Causes of accidents
SAFETY OF STRUCTURE
To ensure minimum cost of construction
To ensure good quality of construction and better rate of work
progress
IMPORTANCE OF SAFETY MEASURES
ECONOMIC REASONS
Many additional expenses will incur from accidents in site
Direct cost from accidents: Indirect cost from accidents:
▪Medical expenses ▪Slow down of operations
▪Workman’s compensation ▪Decrease on productivity
▪Increase in insurance premium ▪Administrative works
▪Replacement of associated
equipment/material damaged ▪Loss of clients’ confidence
▪Court fees ▪Overtime necessitated by slow
down in work
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
The causes of accidents in a construction site may be grouped
according to their nature:
▪Planning & Organisation
▪Execution
▪Equipment
▪Management & conduct of work
▪Worker’s behaviour
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
PLANNING & ORGANISATION
▪Defects in technical planning
▪Fixing unsuitable time limits for works
▪Assigning works to incompetent contractors
▪Insufficient or defective supervision of works
▪Lack of cooperation with different departments
EXECUTION OF WORK
▪Defects in construction
▪Use of unsuitable materials
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
MANAGEMENT & CONDUCT OF WORK
Inadequate preparation for work
Lack of knowledge and skill for recruited employers
Inadequate examination of equipment
Inadequate instructions from supervisors
Inadequate supervision
EQUIPMENT
Lack of equipment
Unsuitable equipment
Defects in equipment
Lack of safety devices or safety measures
CAUSES OF ACCIDENTS
WORKER’S BEHAVIOUR
▪Irresponsible acts
▪Improper attitude towards work
▪Emotional instability
▪Improper use of safety devices
▪Unauthorised acts
▪carelessness
SAFETY MEASURES AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF
CONSTRUCTION
SAFETY MEASURES
Proper safety measures need to be carried out at different
construction stages including:
▪Pre-construction stage
▪Construction stage
▪Commissioning and handing over stage
SAFETY MEASURES – PRE CONSTRUCTION STAGE
Plan the effective safety measure for the nature of project
Decide on the construction methods which suits the health &
safety of workers
Allocate proper budget for safety considerations
Ascertain proper time frame for project
Proper safety requirements must be given in contract
documents
Contracting agencies may be asked to submit a health &
safety plan which effectively propose their methodology to
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Design & construction methods shall be considerate towards
the health and safety of people during construction
▪Adequate time must be allowed to carry out activities in
accordance with health & safety requirements
▪Review whether the construction methods comply with safety
measures and identify the possibilities of safety hazards in
activities and risk levels
▪If risk levels are unacceptable, take additional control
measures including method revisions if required
SAFETY MEASURES – CONSTRUCTION
STAGE
▪Establish facilities such as training facilities, medical check up,
first aid, etc.
Ensure that the establishments at site such as site offices,
workmen camps, toilets, canteens, etc. meet required safety
standards
Construction agency shall properly coordinate the safety
measures
Project manager of construction agency shall ensure that all the
sub-contractors meet proper safety standards
Safety measures - Commissioning stage
Effectiveness of health and safety measures and
management system shall be reviewed for future planning