Intro PS NTMP-merged
Intro PS NTMP-merged
Intro PS NTMP-merged
Machining Processes
presented by
Partha Saha
Department of Mechanical Engineering
Need of Nontraditional
Manufacturing Processes
40 mm
50 mm
Manufacturing of a square blind hole of 40 x 40 mm
(need good finish and sharp corners)
Case 2: Circular blind hole
with high accuracy
Φ 10 mm
60 mm
Need Manufacturing of a circular blind hole with accuracy
of (±) 100 micron, taper less than 0.5 degree
Case 3: Drilling of circular hole of very
small diameter & high aspect ratio
Φ 0.2 mm
5 mm
Aspect ratio = (hole dia./ depth)= (1:25)
Competition in manufacturing
industry today demands
New products
Better performance
More features
Low cost
Energy efficiency
Reduction of
residual stresses
Low HAZ
Emergence of new exotic
materials
Super alloys, ceramics and
composites
• Too hard / brittle / difficult to
machine with traditional
process
• Improved mechanical, thermal, Product from quartz
& chemical properties
• Materials too flexible / slender
to handle
Solar cell
Case-4: Industrial marking and
drilling with highest accuracy
Branding goggles
Ink-jet nozzle drilling
20 micron hole with
high tolerance Microreactor channels in teflon
by
Dr. P Saha
Department of Mechanical Engineering
IIT Kharagpur
Scheme of Presentation
[Ref: Electric Spark Method for the Machining of Metals, B. R. Lazarenko, N. I. Lazarenko, H. Brutcher
Technical Translations, 1950]
Dielectric fluid
Spark is initiated
Dielectric is decomposed
Ionization of Dielectric:
If the voltage is high Inertia of adjacent dielectric
enough and the gap creates high pressure
between the electrode
and the workpiece is
sufficiently small, the Stoppage of pulse results in an
intense electric field will implosive a blast
cause the dielectric fluid
to ionize at the point
where the electric field Removes molten debris of
is strongest. Ionization
means that the fluid's
anode and cathode Crater
atoms or molecules lose
or gain electrons, Leaves a crater behind
forming ions.
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 6
Material Removal Mechanism in EDM Voltage
Increase:
Initially, the
voltage between
the tool
electrode and
the workpiece is
ramped up.
This is
represented by
a rising curve on
the voltage
graph. The
voltage
increases until it
reaches a level
sufficient to
overcome the
dielectric
strength of the
fluid between
the electrodes.
Three-dimensional die-
sinking: Die-sinking
Machining through holes
EDM involves using a
pre-shaped electrode
that is gradually brought
close to the workpiece
submerged in a
dielectric fluid. The
electrode does not
physically touch the
workpiece; instead, it is
brought close enough
for sparks to jump the
gap between the
electrode and the
workpiece.
Three dimensional die-sinking
Cutting with a blade Cutting with a rotating disc Cutting with a ribbon: Similar
to the blade method, but
with a ribbon-like electrode
that is often wider than a
blade and can have different
shapes. It moves across the
workpiece to erode material
in a path determined by the
shape of the ribbon's edge.
Working Tank:
The tank that
contains the
dielectric fluid
Dielectric
Reservoir: This
is a storage tank
for the dielectric
fluid
Dielectric system
Good thermal & oxidation stability less potential fire hazard of the fluid.
Low cost
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 19
Commonly used Dielectric Fluids in EDM
Transformer oil
Paraffin oil
Lubricating oil
Kerosene oil
Deionized water good ionizing and
deionizing capability/ high MRR, high
TWR, corrosive, good coolant used in
WEDM
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 20
Flash points for common liquids
• Gasoline 4.5º C
• Ethanol 12.5º C
• Kerosene 49º C
• Diesel 62º C
• Vegetable Oil 327º C
The flash point for commonly used EDM
dielectric oils ranges from 71º C to 124º C.
The flash point of a dielectric fluid, which is used in EDM (Electrical Discharge Machining), refers to the lowest
temperature at which the fluid can vaporize to form an ignitable mixture in air. This is an important safety
characteristic because it indicates the potential fire hazard of the fluid.
Dielectric System
electrical insulator until the
voltage between the electrode
and the workpiece is high
enough to break down its
insulating properties, at which
point it allows for spark
discharge. The fluid also helps
to cool the process and flush
away the eroded material from
the workpiece.
Flushing Techniques
Normal flushing
Reverse flushing
Jet flushing
Immersion flushing
Intermittent opening up the gap by lifting tool
Decreased Electrode Life: As debris accumulates, the electrode may be subjected to more intense and erratic discharges
than intended. These irregular discharges can lead to increased wear or damage to the electrode, reducing its life.
Increased Production Time: When debris is not properly flushed away, it can cause unstable machining conditions. This
instability may require the machining process to be stopped frequently for cleaning, or it may slow down the process to
avoid damage, both of which can lead to increased production time.
Normal Flushing
Copper electrode
Bass electrode
Copper-tungsten electrode
Silver-tungsten electrode
Tungsten electrode
Graphite electrode
Copper impregnated graphite
Eletroformed electrode
•Downwards
•Orbital
•Vectorial
•Angular
Downwards: This refers to the straightforward vertical
motion of the electrode towards the workpiece. It's the
basic movement required to erode the material directly
beneath the electrode.
Orbital: An orbital motion involves moving the electrode in
a circular or orbital path. This can help to enlarge a hole
beyond what would be possible with a simple downward
movement and can assist in the even distribution of wear
on the electrode and more uniform removal of material.
Vectorial: This might involve moving the electrode in a
linear path at any angle, not just vertically. The vectorial
movement can be used to create channels or complex
shapes within the workpiece.
09-Feb-23
Angular: Angular movement means the electrode is tilted at
an angle rather than being aligned perfectly vertically. This
P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 31
allows for the machining of angled features within the
workpiece.
Expanding: This might refer to a movement where the electrode moves outward
in a spiral pattern to gradually increase the size of a hole or cavity.
Conical: This involves machining a conical shape, which would require the
•Expanding
electrode to move in a way that expands the cavity in both depth and diameter
simultaneously.
EDM Operations
Goto: This term is often used in programming to move the electrode directly to a
specific coordinate or position without machining along the way.
Helical: Helical movement implies that the electrode follows a helix or spiral path,
which could be used for creating threaded features or complex 3D contours.
Spin: This indicates that the electrode is rotated around its own axis while
•Conical
machining, which can help in creating a more uniform surface finish and assist in
the flushing of debris.
Rotation along C axis: This refers to the rotation of the electrode or workpiece
around the vertical axis (commonly referred to as the C-axis in CNC terminology),
enabling the machining of features at different orientations without having to re-
•Goto
fixture or move the workpiece.
•Helical
•Spin
•Rotation
along C axis
Signal to Servo System - Reverse Direction: The EDM machine constantly monitors the condition of the gap. If a short circuit is
detected (the gap being bridged by debris), the servo system receives a signal to reverse the direction of the electrode. This
retraction helps clear the gap by pulling the electrode away from the workpiece, allowing the dielectric fluid to flush out the
conductive particles.
Reciprocates Towards Workpiece Until Dielectric Flushes Gap: The electrode will then move back towards the workpiece to
continue the machining process once the gap is clear. This reciprocating action ensures that the machining process can continue
with the correct gap maintained.
Inefficient Flushing - Very Long Cycle Time: If the flushing system is not effective at removing the debris, the cycle time for
machining will increase. This is because the electrode will need to retract more frequently to clear the gap, slowing down the
overall process. Efficient flushing is thus critical for maintaining an optimal cycle time.
Servo Operation Based on Machining and Reference Voltage
Open Circuit Voltage: This is the voltage across the electrode and workpiece when no
current is flowing. No sparks are generated at this voltage because the dielectric fluid
between the electrode and the workpiece is not ionized.
Range of Voltage Where Sparking Occurs After Ionization: This indicates the voltage
range within which the dielectric fluid ionizes and sparks occur. The actual voltage at
Range of voltage where
which sparking begins is lower than the open-circuit voltage due to the gap between the
electrode and the workpiece. sparking occurs after ionization
Servo-Control Reference Voltage: This is a preset voltage level within the servo system
50
that acts as a threshold. When the voltage across the gap reaches this level, it signifies
that the gap is at the correct distance for optimal sparking. If the voltage drops below
this reference, it means the electrode is too close to the workpiece, and the servo
system will retract the electrode slightly to re-establish the correct gap.
Servo System Operational Voltage Range: This is the voltage range the servo system
allows during operation, determined by the sensitivity settings of the servo system. It's
the window of voltage in which the system will operate to maintain the gap.
c) Arcs and
operating condition for the EDM process.
Arcs: An arc occurs when there is a continuous
discharge of electricity across the gap, which is not
desired in standard EDM processes. Arcing can
lead to excessive tool wear and poor surface finish
d) Short circuits
on the workpiece because it can create a more
sustained and hotter discharge than a spark, which
can melt rather than vaporize the material.
Short Circuits: This happens when the electrode
comes into direct contact with the workpiece,
allowing current to flow without any resistance.
Short circuits are undesirable as they can cause
damage to the workpiece and the electrode, and
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 38
they interrupt the controlled erosion process.
voltage drops after spark in effective
Signal
Current
Signal
Electronic Pulse
Generator
Hybrid Pulse
Generator
(Electronic +
Relaxation)
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 43
Relaxation
Generator
Charging Discharging
portion portion
Electro-discharge machining
characteristics of various
electrode-material combinations
When the workpiece is negative (cathode), it will tend to have a higher material removal rate, and the tool wear will be lower. This is often referred
to as reverse polarity.
Conversely, when the workpiece is positive (anode), it will tend to result in a better surface finish, but higher tool wear. This is often referred to as
straight polarity.
The choice between negative or positive polarity for the workpiece in EDM is made based on the specific requirements of the job, such as the
need for precision, surface quality, and tool life. The type of material being machined can also influence the choice of polarity.
Yes, in the context of EDM and electrical circuits in general, a negative polarity indicates a surplus of electrons, which means that
the negatively charged electrode (or workpiece, in the case of EDM with negative workpiece polarity) will tend to lose electrons.
Surface Integrity in EDM
Surface topography nad subsurface metallurgy
Recast Layer
Base Metal
Recast Layer
Molten metal not flushed away,
resolidified on workpiece
hardened due to fast cooling,
hardness (6o HRC),
thin : 2.5 – 50 micron
may contain micro-cracks
should be removed
09-Feb-23 P Saha, Mech Engg, IIT Kharagpur 58
EDM Applications
Material : Steel
Dimensions : 200 x 150 mm
Electrode : One graphite
electrode for
rouging and
finishing
Machining time : 30 hours
Material : Steel
Preliminary Machining : Boring a
50 mm diameter hole
Electrode: Two graphite
electrodes. One for
rouging and one for
finishing
Surface finish : 1.3 micron Ra
Machining time : 50 hours
Material :
Die in carbide 63 mm, Punch in
carbide 20 mm
Geometric tolerance : 2 mm
Surface finish : 1.1 micron Ra
Relief angle :
Die 4 minutes, Punch 1 minute
Machining time :
Die:15 hours, Punch: 3.5 hours
Material : Steel
Precision : 0.01mm
Electrode : Copper
Surface Finish: 0.4 mm Ra
Machining time: 9 hours