Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 9 views

    EAP3 RC Failure Summary Table

    Uploaded by

    Philip Chan
    Summary of critical reinforced concrete structures design failures mode. Essential for engineers to avoid these mistakes to produce safe, sound, robust and rigid structures.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    EAP3 RC Failure Summary Table

    Uploaded by

    Philip Chan
    9 views1 page
    Summary of critical reinforced concrete structures design failures mode. Essential for engineers to avoid these mistakes to produce safe, sound, robust and rigid structures.

    Original Title

    231106 EAP3 RC Failure Summary Table

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Summary of critical reinforced concrete structures design failures mode. Essential for engineers to avoid these mistakes to produce safe, sound, robust and rigid structures.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    9 views1 page

    EAP3 RC Failure Summary Table

    Uploaded by

    Philip Chan
    Summary of critical reinforced concrete structures design failures mode. Essential for engineers to avoid these mistakes to produce safe, sound, robust and rigid structures.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    You are on page 1of 1

    Beam Main Bar Failure Reason As required(mm2) As provided(mm2) As provided in As-Build Drawings(mm2) Utilization Factor

    CRB7 *lack of RB16 beam loading 2538 (4T32) 3217 (4T20) 1257 0.788933789
    RB15 *lack of Parapet Wall loading 3051 (3T40) 3770 (3T25) 1473 2.071283096
    GB6 *provide inadequate reinforcements in the previous design 1950 (7T20) 2199 (7T16) 1407 1.385927505
    GB7a *lack of Mass Concrete Fill and Parapet Wall loading 869 (3T20) 942 (3T16) 603 1.441127695

    Shear Link Make-up


    CRB7 T10-300 to T16-300
    GB5 T10-250 4 legs to T10-250 8 legs
    GB6 T10-300 4 legs to T10-300 6 legs
    GB15 T10-300 to T10-225

    Slab Failure Reason As/d required(mm2) As/d provided(mm2) As provided in As-Build Drawings(mm2) Utilization Factor
    GS26 *define the wrong span length in the SADS design 1.571 (T16-150) 2.681 (T12-150) 1.508 1.041777188
    GS39 *miss the Qk from Loading Key Plan Type D 0.785 (T16-300) 1.34 (T12-300) 0.754 1.041114058
    GS55 *miss the Qk from Loading Key Plan Type D 1.571 (T16-150) 2.681 (T12-150) 1.508 1.041777188
    RS23 *design by less loading area for Trapizium Area 2.262 (T16-150) 2.681 (T12-150) 1.508 1.5

    Column Main Bar Failure Reason Size Amendment Design Moment/Capacity (Based on MN Curve) Over-design Ratio
    C1 *due to bending moment failure, axial resistance OK 450*450 to 500*500 556 KN.m/500 KN.m(450*450) 11%
    C2 *due to bending moment failure, axial resistance OK 450*450 to 550*550 871 KN.m/500 KN.m(450*450) 74%
    C3 *due to bending moment failure, axial resistance OK 450*450 to 550*550 783 KN.m/500 KN.m(450*450) 57%
    Design DL&LL(Factored) (KN) DL&LL(Factored) Reduction (KN)
    C1 1201 110
    C2 639 247
    C3 642 210

    Wall Main Bar Failure Reason Thick Amendment Design Moment/Capacity (Based on MN Curve) Over-design Ratio
    W9b *due to bending moment failure in minor axis, axial resistance OK 250 THK to 300 THK 5404 KN.m/1540 KN.m(250 THK) 251%
    CW1c *due to bending moment failure in minor axis, axial resistance OK 250 THK 1298 KN.m/745 KN.m(250THK) 74%
    Design DL&LL(Factored) (KN) DL&LL(Factored) Reduction (KN)
    Shear Link Make-up W9b 1663 626
    CW1a T10-125 to T10-120 CW1c 1145 489
    CW2d T10-125 to T10-120
    CW3a T10-125 to T10-120
    CW4d T10-125 to T10-120
    CW5a T10-125 to T10-120
    CW6d T10-125 to T10-120
    CW7a T10-125 to T10-120
    CW8d T10-125 to T10-120
    W9b T10-200 to T10-120
    W10 T12-150 to T12-100
    W11 T12-150 to T12-100
    W12 T12-150 to T12-100

    You might also like