HE Hydrogen Report 2021 FINAL
HE Hydrogen Report 2021 FINAL
HE Hydrogen Report 2021 FINAL
Editorial /12
Insights from the President of Hydrogen Europe, Jon André
Løkke, about the high hopes surrounding hydrogen
In a Nutshell /14
Discover the colors of hydrogen, debunk the myths around hydrogen,
and learn the facts and key moments in modern history for hydrogen
Features /30
Policy Developments
Market Developments
Beyond Europe: Middle East & North Africa
VIEWS /69
Snapshots into the lives of people and projects implementing the
energy transition and the integration of hydrogen in the Netherlands
Acknowledgements /120
About Hydrogen Europe /121
Chapter | 5
Air Liquide
of gases produced with renewable electricity develop large-capacity hydrogen stations which
for their efforts to reduce their carbon footprint. will be used to power long-distance trucks. Air
Liquide’s ambition is also to contribute to build
Moreover, the Group increased to 100% its total
and Hydrogen:
the sustainable aviation ecosystem alongside the
stake in H2V Normandy in October 2021. Renamed
leading players in the sector. Our Group started
Air Liquide Normand’Hy, this company aims to
at the end of the 2000s to promote hydrogen
build a large-scale electrolyzer of at least 200
applied to aviation, notably through studies
MW for the production of renewable hydrogen in
Transitioning to Clean Energies is a Reality France to supply industry and mobility markets.
and demonstrators in flight or on land. In June,
Air Liquide, Airbus and Groupe ADP signed a
This strategic investment will support the devel-
Memorandum of Understanding to prepare for
opment of a low-carbon hydrogen ecosystem in
the arrival of hydrogen in airports by 2035 as
Air Liquide commitments address the urgency of climate change the Normandy industrial basin.
part of the development of hydrogen-powered
and energy transition, targeting carbon neutrality by 2050. Using its extensive experience in hydrogen plants, commercial aircraft. Alongside Airbus and Vinci
Air Liquide has developed a process unique in Airports, the Group also announced a partnership
the world, the CryocapTM H2 technology, which to promote the use of hydrogen at airports and
was commissioned in 2015 in Air Liquide’s build the European airport network to accom-
As a pioneer, Air Liquide is convinced that hy- of the Air Liquide Group’s strategy. The new 20 largest hydrogen production unit in France, in modate future hydrogen aircrafts.
drogen is a cornerstone of the energy transition. MW proton-exchange membrane (PEM) electro- Port-Jérôme-sur-Seine. This technology makes
A global transition towards a low-carbon so-
In the past 50 years, the Group has developed lyser, equipped with Cummins technology, is the it possible to recover and isolate the CO2 emit-
ciety is underway. As a pioneer in hydrogen
unique expertise enabling it to master the entire largest operating unit of its kind. Supplied with ted during hydrogen production involving low
technologies, Air Liquide is fully committed to
supply chain, from production and storage to renewable energy, this unit is now producing up temperatures to separate gases.
achieving this goal.
distribution, contributing to the widespread use to 8.2 tonnes per day of low-carbon hydrogen
In July 2021, the Group announced working with
of hydrogen as a clean energy carrier for a wide and will help meet the growing demand in North
other major players in the Normandy industrial
range of applications such as industrial usages America.
basin to implement a CO2 capture and storage
and clean mobility.
In order to meet rapidly renewable hydrogen chain, from their industrial activities to
growing demand, and to lower costs, it is key final storage in the North Sea.
Air Liquide is committed to reaching several
to accelerate the production of sustainably
ambitious goals, investing approximately Air Liquide is therefore fully involved
generated hydrogen through large-scale PEM
€8 billion in the low-carbon hydrogen full in the development of low carbon and
electrolysers. In this context, Air Liquide and
value chain by 2035, and a total of 3 GW renewable hydrogen, serving both
Siemens Energy have joined forces to create
electrolysis capacity by 2030. the decarbonization of industry and
a European ecosystem for electrolysis and
mobility. As well as the roll-out of
hydrogen technologies. The first worldscale
Air Liquide’s long-term commitment to hydrogen stations for light vehicles in Europe,
PEM electrolyzer Air Liquide is planning to build
energy and its ambition to be a major player in the Japan, South Korea and the United
in the framework of this partnership will be lo-
supply of renewable and low-carbon hydrogen is States, Air Liquide is also focused
cated in Oberhausen, Germany. This renewable
at the heart of its strategic investments. Indeed, on the truck segment. Large-scale
hydrogen production plant, with a total capacity
Air Liquide inaugurated the world’s largest low- projects are becoming a reality: in
to reach 30MW, will support sectors such as
carbon hydrogen membrane-based production Rotterdam in the Netherlands and Fos-
Steel, Chemicals, Refining and Mobility in North
unit in Canada earlier this year, illustrating that sur-Mer in France for example, where
Rhine-Westphalia by accelerating the availability
the fight against climate change is at the heart the Group is part of key initiatives to
Your global partner for
Contributors
new energies & feedstocks
Bastien Bonnet-Cantalloube | Officer, Industry Policy
Major Push for Fighting We already see the change happening: the world’s
first passenger train powered by a hydrogen fuel
cell is already running on German railways. The
For hydrogen to become a commercial success,
European and global decision-makers need to
develop regulatory and policy incentives for clean
The long-awaited 2021 United Nations Climate be achieved, with what means and which methodol-
Change Conference – COP26 – is expected to ogy should be applied.
become a watershed moment in global efforts
to fight climate change. After the Paris COP21 High hopes are on hydrogen.
Conference reached a breakthrough agreement to
limit the global warming to 1.5 degrees, all eyes are Hydrogen is the most abundant element in the
on Glasgow now to make sure the world stays on universe. It can be produced from various sources,
track and keeps 1.5 degrees within reach. including renewables such as solar and wind, and
used as a net-zero energy carrier or fuel. Hydrogen
With world leaders, climate negotiators, scientists, is key and will be a solution to many of the world’s
industry, and society representatives coming together to climate neutrality objectives: it unleashes the
discuss how to get the climate changes under control, potential of renewables, ensures energy system
COP26 will be a litmus test for global policy makers to efficiency, and enables a carbon-neutral transport
prove they can put words and ambitions into action. system, both on land and sea.
COP26 must go beyond a mere goal of setting By using hydrogen technologies, we can contribute
standards for emissions reductions: It must give a to the decarbonization of economies, notably within
clear indication on how a climate-neutral future will industry and transport, thus making renewables 01
1520 1875
First recorded
observation of hydrogen The hydrogen-filled LZ 127 Graf Zeppelin
by Paracelsus through Hans Gaffron discovered
made a 33,234 km circumnavigation of the
dissolution of metals that algae can switch
world. The voyage took a total of 21 days,
(iron, zinc, and tin) in between producing oxygen
sulfuric acid. 5 hours, and 31 minutes.
and hydrogen.
Humphry Davy
discovers the
concept of the
Fuel Cell.
1966
1909 General Motors presents
1919 Electrovan, the world's
first fuel cell automobile
2020
2002 2016
8 July
Creation of the European Clean Hydrogen Alliance
6 May
FCH 2 Joint Undertaking (JU) www.ec.europa.eu/growth/industry/policy/european-clean-hydrogen-alliance_en
extended by the European
Commission to 2020 with
€1.33 billion
2008 2020
2014
Fuel Cells and Hydrogen (FCH) launched World Hydrogen Alliance MENA
www.fch.europa.eu www.dii-desertenergy.org/mena-hydrogen-alliance/
Myth 2
Hydrogen gas is dangerous to store and use
Myth 5
Hydrogen is too explosive!
Arguably one of the most common concerns raised when discuss-
ing the use of hydrogen is that, as a flammable gas, it can be easily You may think of the hydrogen bomb or atomic weapons of mass de-
ignited and as such far too hazardous to be stored either in refuelling struction when you hear hydrogen, but the process for making such
stations or within a pressure tank. Yet, hydrogen is no more danger- bombs is the opposite to electrolysis for example which is about split-
ous than other flammable fuels or the batteries used in electric cars. ting the water molecule. Even the Hinderburg accident in 1937, often
In fact, vehicles with pressure gas storage tanks are nothing new. With remembered for the fact that the zeppelin floated due to hydrogen, is
millions of on-the-road miles driven over the last few years, an exist- unrelated to the gas itself. The most accepted explanation indicates
ing global multi-billion industry transporting and making hydrogen for that it was the flammable components on the paint that covered the
many decades, the automotive industry seems to be more than suf- zeppelin - not hydrogen, which dissipated in seconds - that caused
ficiently convinced that hydrogen can be stored safely, with Toyota for the fire in the aircraft structure.
example having received approval from Japan’s Ministry of Economy,
Trade and Industry (METI) to self-inspect and manufacture hydrogen
tanks for FCEVs. Sources: HIRINGA, EDP
H He
N
The world’s O
P
Q
Hydrogen 7 things you may largest hydrogen Helium
1.008 Pnictogens Chalcogens Halogens 4.0026
electrolysis plant
N
G
not know about hydrogen:
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 K
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 L
is currently being M
Li Be B C Nfirst O F Ne
N
O
G
K
appeared in 1800
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 K
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 L
Na Mg Al P S a Cl Ar
N
O
G
One of the
K
P
E
G
K
P
E
T
37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 K
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 L
18
(if you
18
believe in189the 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 M
Rb Sr Y Zr Nb Mo Tc Ru Rh Pd Ag Cd In Sn Sb Te I Xe
8 8 10 12 13 13 15 16 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 N
1 2 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 O
Big Bang). P
Rubidium Strontium Yttrium Zirconium Niobium Molybdenum Technetium Ruthenium Rhodium Palladium Silver The nameIndium
Cadmium hydrogen
Tin Hydrogen
Antimony Tellurium Iodine is Xenon
Q
85.468 87.62 88.906 91.224 92.906 95.95 (98) 101.07 102.91 106.42 107.87 comes 114.82
112.41 from 118.71
the Greek 121.76 127.60 the126.90
most 131.29
G
K
P
E
T
55 56 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 “hydro”
words 81 (meaning
82 83 84abundant
85 86
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 K
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 L
18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 M
Cs Ba Hf Ta W Re Os Ir Pt Au Hg Tl
water) and Pb
“genes” Bi Po At
element Rn
18 18 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 N
8 8 10 11 12 13 14 15 17 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 O
1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 P
Q
Caesium Barium Hafnium Tantalum Tungsten Rhenium Osmium Iridium Platinum Gold Mercury Thallium
(meaning Lead
creator). Bismuth Polonium Astatine Radon
in the
132.91 137.33 178.49 It’s
180.95 183.84 186.21
the most 190.23 192.22 195.08 196.97 200.59 204.38 207.2 208.98 (209) universe.
(210) (222)
G
K
P
E
T
It was named by French
87 88 104 abundant 105 106
substance 107 108 109 110 111 112 Antoine 113 114 18328 115 18328 116 18328 117 18328 118 18328
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 K
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 L
18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 chemist
18 18 18Lavoisier
18 M
Fr Ra Rf Db Sg Bh Hs Mt Ds Rg Cn Nh Fl Mc Lv Ts Og
32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 N
18
8
1
18
8
2
32
10
2
(75%) in the universe
32
11
2
32
12
2
32
13
2
32
14
2
32
15
2
32
1
32 32
because182when it burns
17 18
1
32
18
3
it
32
18
4
32
18
5
32
18
6
32
18
7
32
18
8
O
P
Q
Francium Radium Rutherfordium and
Dubnium Seaborgium Bohrium Hassium Meitnerium Darmstadtium Roentgenium “creates
the richest Copernicium water”.
Nihonium Flerovium Moscovium Livermorium Tennessine Oganesson
(223) (226) (267) (268) (269) (270) (277) (278) (281) (282) (285) (286) (289) (290) (293) (294) (294)
energy source for
K
P
E
T
stars.
(The sun is made up of
mostly hydrogen).
57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18
La Ce Pr Nd Pm Sm Eu Gd Tb Dy Ho Er Tm Yb Lu
18 19 21 22 23 24 25 25 27 28 29 30 31 32 32
9 9 8 8 8 8 8 9 8 8 8 8 8 8 9
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Lanthanum Cerium Praseodymium Neodymium Promethium Samarium Europium Gadolinium Terbium Dysprosium Holmium Erbium Thulium Ytterbium Lutetium
138.91 140.12 140.91 144.24 (145) 150.36 151.96 157.25 158.93 162.50 164.93 167.26 168.93 173.05 174.97
L
L
89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18
Ac Th Pa U Np Pu Am Cm Bk Cf Es Fm Md No Lr
32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32 32
18 18 20 21 22 24 25 25 27 28 29 30 31 32 32
9 10 9 9 9 8 8 9 8 8 8 8 8 8 8
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3
Actinium Thorium Protactinium Uranium Neptunium Plutonium Americium Curium Berkelium Californium Einsteinium Fermium Mendelevium Nobelium Lawrencium
Image adapted from: Dayah, Michael.
Periodic Table - Ptable. Ptable, 1
Oct. 1997, ptable.com. Accessed 8
Nov. 2021 (227) 232.04 231.04 238.03 (237) (244) (243) (247) (247) (251) (252) (257) (258) (259) (266)
A
A
22 | Hydrogen: ENABLING A ZERO EMISSION SOCIETY 7 Facts You Need To Know | 23
How Green Hydrogen Electrolyzers consist of several interconnected
electrolysis cells, also called stacks.
WIND
SOLAR
Between
the two partial
reactions, charge
equalisation
takes place
in the form
Electrolysis
of ion conduction
The electricity must come via an electrolyte
100% from renewables (which is an
electrically
conductive
substance).
Hydrogen Storage
Hydrogen Oxygen
Distribution
In addition, a membrane is needed to spatially separate
the two reactions and prevent the product gases from mixing.
Fuelling station
H2 Turquoise
(such as bricks) and utilized. This is called
carbon capture, storage and utilisation
(CCSU).
Black / Brown
H2 in the presence of a catalyst, where a
chemical reaction creates hydrogen and
H2
catalytic splitting of that can occur in the production of “blue”
generated from renewable energy sources,
H2
water using nuclear hydrogen (depending on upstream methane
it can also refer to hydrogen produced via
power thermal as an emissions and the production technology
different methods using other renewable
energy source. used), the term itself can be considered too
sources such as biogas, biomethane, bio-waste
and other renewable sources, these methods
Pink broad. Instead, when referring to hydrogen
produced from natural gas, it is more
are less common than water electrolysis but Pink hydrogen is generated through electrolysis
accurate to refer to it using the actual GHG
also result in either very low or zero emissions. of water by using electricity from a nuclear
footprint associated to its production.
power plant.
29%
Other industry
CO2 EMISSIONS
HYDROGEN
3.7 Gt
27%
14% Cement GLOBAL ANNUAL
STEEL PRODUCTION STEELMAKING
1,869 Mt
Chemicals &
Petrochemicals
70%
of total steel production is
suitable for hydrogen route
requires
approx.
TRADITIONAL ROUTE HYDROGEN-BASED
1,308 Mt 1t 55H kg
of production capacity steel 2
to convert
Iron ore
CORSIA scheme
Non-binding policies and strategies
Energy Taxation Directive (ETD)
Alternative Fuels Infrastructure Regulation (AFIR - formerly AFID)
In the EU legislative process, non-binding policy
CO2 Emission Standards Regulation for cars and vans
HYDROGEN EUROPE
CLEAN
HYDROGEN
documents, strategies, communications, white pa-
FuelEU Maritime
MONITOR 2020
the components of the energy systems, to store acquis since the completion of the EU single market.
energy for long-term periods, and to decarbonise The package touches upon almost all aspects of
hard-to-abate sectors (especially trucks, industry, the EU economy, especially in the area of energy,
maritime, and aviation). industry and mobility. For the purposes of this re-
port, we will limit ourselves to a short presentation
The European Commission published numerous of the legislative proposals within the Fit-for-55
supporting strategies in 2020 that include the package with the highest potential impact on the
Offshore Renewable Strategy which considers hydrogen market and highlight provisions which
offshore hydrogen production and hydrogen pipe- are most relevant.
lines as the most promising means of delivering
offshore energy to consumption centres onshore; The Renewable Energy Directive (RED) sets rules
the Sustainable and Smart Mobility Strategy for the development of renewable energy across
is also very relevant, as it provides the EU’s first all sectors of the EU’s economy. The revised pro-
clear targets for hydrogen refuelling stations: 500 posal raises the renewable energy target from 32
in 2025 and 1,000 in 2030, up from 144 in 2021. to 40% in total energy consumption, but also sets
minimum binding targets for the use of renewable
While the foundations for the legislative environ- fuels of non-biological origin (RFNBOs) by 2030,
ment affecting hydrogen were already in place, which means some 50% of hydrogen consumption
the developments which took place following in industry and at least 2.6% of the total energy
the adoption of the Hydrogen Strategy have the consumption in the transport sector (including
potential to be truly transformational for the clean renewable hydrogen consumed in refineries).
hydrogen sector. Figure 15, below presents just
a few of such developments which are likely to Specific provisions are also proposed to mainstream
have a major impact. renewable energy in heating and cooling, such
as 1.1% annual increase in heating and cooling 01
02 03
Market Developments
develop a European hydrogen economy and achieve
its commercial competitiveness. Hydrogen will shift
from local to regional and national applications as
large-scale storage, hydrogen ‘backbones’, and
hydrogen valleys will be realised with support from
WRITERS: the appropriate measures to stimulate supply and
ALEXANDRU FLORISTEAN & GRZEGORZ PAWELEC demand. Throughout this period and for many
applications, hydrogen will also require regulatory
support, including for example through tariffs,
auctions/tenders, quotas, investment support,
tax relief, and supported by Guarantees of Origin
(GO). Most hydrogen production and applications
will have achieved commercial competitiveness at
the end of the ramp-up phase.
02 03
8
6
during the combustion of e-fuels, but provided with the supply of renewable electricity to power
5
0
4
9
5
the conditions expressed above are met, the CO2 the EAF, will help decarbonize the entire steel
6
9
1,
Similarly, the ammonia production process is a big emissions should correspond to the amounts of production process. The steel industry is, in fact,
12
9
7
hydrogen consumer that can benefit from the adop- carbon dioxide taken out of the atmosphere and the sector that is currently planning the biggest
9
5
3
6
5
tion of clean hydrogen. Although it is usually used used in the production process as a feedstock. consumption of clean hydrogen by 2030, accord-
as a feedstock for fertilizer production, ammonia ing to the Clean Hydrogen Monitor.
has also been seen as a potential energy carrier Clean hydrogen can also be used to help decar-
and/or fuel, already considered a suitable e-fuel bonize the steel industry, a highly energy-intensive Ammonia
for maritime applications. The same reasoning can process that is responsible for 4% of the total
be applied to the production of methanol, used GHG emissions in Europe. The steel production Methanol
both in chemical processes and, as of recently, process can take different routes. In Europe, 60% E-fuels 04 B
last furnace smelting liquid steel in steel
as an e-fuel. of the production involves a blast furnace (BF) and mills. Source: ABCDstock / Shutterstock
95,5%
Thermal
3,9%
By-product electrolysis
0,5%
Reforming (carbon capture)
0,1%
Power-to-hydrogen
04
Germany
Netherlands
Poland
Spain
Italy
France
United Kingdom
Belgium
Norway
Lithuania
Hungary
Bulgaria
Finland
Romania
Slovakia
Sweden
Greece
Austria
Portugal
Croatia
Czechia
Switzerland
Denmark
Slovenia
Ireland
hydrogen production points in EU, EFTA, and Countries with the largest hydrogen production
the UK with production capacity of 10.5 Mt of capacity are Germany, Netherlands, Poland, and
Captive
hydrogen per year as of 2019. The “thermal” Spain. These four countries account for 50% of the
By-Product
production methods (reforming, partial oxidation, total EU, EFTA, and the UK hydrogen production
Merchant
by-product production from refining operations, capacity. Figure 1(4) below provides an overview
and by-product production from ethylene and of total hydrogen production capacity by country
styrene) constitute 95.5% of the total hydrogen and by production type.
118,522 500
120.000
98,165
100.000 400
80.000 76,815
Capacity (MW)
# of projects
300
60.000 55,627
200
40.000 31,986
27,521
100
20.000
6,773
202 474 2,167
0 0
2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
07
Hydrogen
A Small Molecule
over long distances, to a large extent using existing
natural gas infrastructure.
in MENA
natural gas with CCS, will help meet hydrogen
demand in the short to medium term. More than
half of all hydrogen initiatives are in Europe and
predictions for hydrogen’s share in the EU’s final
energy demand by 2050 range from 24% to 50%.
FRANK WOUTERS An estimated 50% of that will be imported.
CHAIRMAN MENA HYDROGEN ALLIANCE
Green hydrogen made from renewable electricity
and water is currently still more expensive than
01
conventional hydrogen but is expected to become
cost-competitive within a decade. The 2020s are
described as the “hydrogen’s decade” by the
likes of HSBC and Wood Mackenzie, building on
Climate change is finally receiving the attention it (IPCC), released in August 2021, was a wake-up However, in recent years, clean energy solutions
the IEA’s landmark 2019 report “The Future of
deserves. According to IPSOS, two thirds of the call: the window of opportunity to avoid climate have been developed that are now quickly be-
Hydrogen” calling for international action to tap
global population is concerned about the con- chaos is closing fast. coming the bedrock of positive climate action.
into hydrogen’s vast potential.
sequences of global warming and expects more
action from public and private leadership. The The energy sector – one of the largest sectors The energy sector is integral to development
With all its promise, hydrogen still faces many
Sixth Assessment Report of the United Nations of the global economy – has traditionally been and our modern way of life. Low carbon energy
barriers before it can become a globally accepted
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change a major source of greenhouse gas emissions. technologies include renewable energies, storage
ASU
Figure 1. The Helios Project Figure 2. Technology providers of the Helios project
In the north of the Netherlands, Eemshaven is strategically located for the construction and
maintenance of offshore wind farms. The Buss terminal at Eemshaven leads to a great deal
of chain employment and to the growth of hydrogen.
Green Planet in northern Netherlands is a multi-
fuel station where fuels for all passenger and cargo
transportation are available. It is one of the largest
hydrogen filling stations in Europe, supported by
regional, national and European funds.
Decarbonizing the gas network simply means replacing natural gas, representing 99% of the
volumes we transport today, with renewable or low-carbon gas. This is the challenge of our work
for the years to come: transporting hydrogen and biomethane and designing the new European
gas system.
The key areas we work on are to assess the capability of our network to receive hydrogen and pure
hydrogen. This is what we are doing with our MosaHYc project aiming at leveraging the existing
natural gas network already connecting France, Germany and the border of Luxembourg to transport
pure hydrogen. In 2021, we organized a nation-wide consultation to listen to the expectations and
needs of all stakeholders in the French low-carbon and renewable hydrogen market to conceive
and plan the hydrogen transmission network of tomorrow. We are also working with European
authorities to design the regulation of the future hydrogen market, highlighting the logistics issues,
because if we don’t get logistics right, we will hinder the development of the hydrogen economy.
Thierry Trouvé
CEO of GRTgaz In the energy transition, R&D is essential, and that is why in 2017 we set up a research department
named RICE to enable us to focus on these energy transition issues: in particular on gas quality, on
hydrogen and on smart gas grids. This is a key element and today GRTgaz is one of the network
operators with the highest rate of research and development in its category, and we intend to
maintain this effort because it is absolutely vital.
Hydrogen & the Energy Transition Dealing with hydrogen shows our desire and our ability to provide innovative solutions and work with all
the players across the hydrogen value chain. Our commitment is to enable an energy transition towards
The 3rd Gas Revolution: Back to the Future a carbon-neutral world that is safe, in the sense of energy security, and affordable, in the sense we will
all be able to pay for it – a transition to an ideal world that we can’t afford is not a real transition.
In line with the 2015 Paris Agreement, the gases consumed in France and Europe will be renewable
or carbon-neutral, and hydrogen has a special role to play. Renewable gases and the energy Watch Video: Le monde de l’hydrogène avec GRTgaz : présentation des atouts par Thierry Trouvé
transition together form the third gas revolution that more than a transition, it’s a real transformation.
The first gas revolution was town gas in Europe from coal. Natural gas was the second gas
revolution, which took place in the middle of the 20th century with gas becoming a raw material
from oil. The third gas revolution is the renewable gases revolution: hydrogen and biomethane.
In a way, we are going back to the future because local town gas in the 20th century consisted of
methane and large quantities of hydrogen. So, the return to hydrogen and to green gases made
in Europe is a recent adaptation of the gas industry to new challenges – now the fight against
climate change.
There is now a broad consensus in Europe that hydrogen will first be developed on a local basis in
what are called “clusters” or “valleys” – with production and consumption being relatively close. As
more players produce and consume hydrogen, it will be necessary to manage situations in which
production and consumption sites are potentially more distant; and it will also be necessary to
manage the need for access to hydrogen storage, since one of the major interests of hydrogen
is precisely the storage of large quantities of energy. These clusters and valleys will become
increasingly connected: going from a ‘leopard-spots’ network to integrate progressively until they
form the hydrogen backbone of Europe.
Research & Innovation Center for Energy, RICE. Source: Azmoun Hamid / GRTgaz.
Case Studies
FRONIUS / SOLHUB ALSTOM
CUMMINS NEL HYDROGEN
GREEN CITY FERRIES BOSCH
TÜV-SÜD REPSOL
EH GROUP VIESSMAN / SMARTQUART PROJECT
LINDE UNIPER
CASE STUDY: SOLHUB
Fronius offers a sustainable solution for green What role will green hydrogen play in the
hydrogen from renewable energy with its European energy mix of the future? What
Solhub. What are the benefits for customers? hurdles are there to overcome?
Biotech Park,
Lower Austria
TR - The Fronius Solhub is our system solution for MD - As shown in many scenarios, hydrogen
Application:
700bar refuelling infrstructure
generating, storing, distributing and converting green will play a vital role in Europe’s climate neutral
Emergency power supply by hydrogen from solar, wind and water energy back economy as a crucial energy vector and could
fuel cell
1.5 MWp PV plant for PV into electricity. It uses electrolysis to convert ecologi- supply a substantial part of the European energy
optimised operation cally generated on-site electricity (and renewable mix by 2050.
Dimensioning: electricity via the public grid) into green hydrogen,
Daily output of 96 kg green
hydrogen
which can be stored over the long term. This opens The production of green hydrogen via electrolysis
up various possibilities: On the one hand, the solar enables synergies from sector coupling to be ex-
power yield of the summer can be brought into the ploited, reducing technology costs and increasing
winter, and thanks to reconversion, green electricity the flexibility of the power system. Low various
is available all year round. On the other hand, the renewable energy (VRE) costs and technological
03 S
olhubs are already in realization, such
What is green hydrogen and what can be for producing green hydrogen is water electrolysis as the first green hydrogen customer plant
realized with hydrogen in general? powered by renewable electricity. in Lower Austria. Source: Visualisation:
Janusch - the visual collective | SAN Group
Mathieu DELPIERRE - Currently, there is no Thomas RÜHRLINGER - Together with the 01
uniform definition (yet). There have been political fuel cell, hydrogen has the potential to revolu-
debates about the definitions of the different types tionize the entire energy supply. Whether as a
of hydrogen. At present, hydrogen production fuel in transportation or as an energy supplier
methods are divided via color-coded scheme. for electricity and heat generation: Hydrogen
Green hydrogen therefore stands for renewable enables the use of renewable energy sources
hydrogen. The most established technology options in all these areas.
02 03
Stockholm,
Sweden
Approximately 2.1 billion people use ferries every must be implemented across the EU. The technol- 01 B
eluga24 – the world’s first hydrogen high-speed hydrogen ferry taking on longer routes within
year, putting the industry on a par with commercial ogy to do is here. The time to act is now. catamaran ferry. Source: GCF the area, with support from the European Union
airlines in terms of annual users worldwide. To many funded project, TECOW. With many other cities
cities and their citizens, travelling the waterways Green ferry technology already showing interest in the technology it won’t
lies at the heart of everyday life. While some cities extremely well-suited for usage on waterways in be long before hydrogen ferries are taking mobil-
have mandated the switch to ‘fossil-free’ biodiesel, As a systems integrator, Green City Ferries (GCF) and around cities by enabling attractive timetables ity into cleaner waters across the EU and beyond.
these vessels are still omitting harmful particles offers a holistic solution for cities. We bring together and comfortable commutes. Except for the vessels itself and the infrastructure
that cause numerous health issues to citizens. state-of-the-art zero-emission (ZE) fast passenger GCF also offers financing for authorities for an ef-
Despite a widespread push to reduce emissions, ferries and shoreside and hydrogen infrastructure. The biggest challenge with these vessels is their ficient transition.
ferries have long been neglected in the drive to The company has unveiled the Beluga24 – the weight compared to a conventional diesel ferries.
create cleaner, greener public transport in cities. world’s first hydrogen high-speed catamaran ferry. To mitigate this, the Beluga24 uses a hydrofoil GCF stands ready to contribute to the 1.5°C
system and lightweight carbon fiber hulls. The target by introducing its zero-emission ferry on a
The European Commission has set out its vision to The Beluga24 comes with two emission-free op- lifting force created by the hydrofoil when the global scale.
establish 100 climate-neutral smart cities by 2030, tions – electric for short journeys and hydrogen for vessel is operating at cruise speed effectively
but this cannot be achieved without investing in long – and has been designed as a multi-purpose reduces the displacement of the vessel, lifts the www.greencityferries.com
new emission-free waterborne transport solutions. solution for public transportation with space for 150 hull partly out of the water, and thereby reduces
With air pollution continuing to kill 400,000 people passengers and 28 bikes. The high-speed ferries the resistance, alleviating the impact of the ad-
annually in the EU, zero-emission ferry systems have low-wake signatures, a long range, and are ditional weight of the electrical propulsion system.
Transport
few years. Finally, we believe the opportunity for
fuel-cell systems to replace diesel trains remains
hyper-efficiency
under-appreciated for new locomotives and retrofits.
With nearly half of train lines in Europe unelectrified,
the prohibitive cost of adding cantilevered lines
The rapid scale-up of fuel-cell technology in par-
at over 1 million EUR/km makes the TCO of FC
allel to the battery means that we are entering a
Why Fuel Cells are no longer the its production capacity with significant investments locomotives a compelling story.
new era that is characterized less by competition
Wallflowers by the likes of major automotive suppliers (such as
and more by the wisdom of complementarity,
Bosch), existing players (such as Ballard, Toyota
and Hyundai), and nimble start-ups (such as EH
Next Challenges circularity, and hyper-efficiency. For decades now,
As the electrification of transportation continues to
the opportunity of the fuel cell must not be under-
accelerate with battery solutions leading the way, Group Engineering of Switzerland). The objective
The next significant areas where FCs with high- estimated if we wish to come closer to the SDG
are the right technological and strategic decisions is simple: prepare to scale-up production and
power densities will yield a significant advantage and other climate targets set for 2030 and beyond.
being made? It is now increasingly recognized that reduce cost. We believe that a fully integrated
over battery technologies will play out in the mari- As the old adage goes: a mistake repeated more
fuel-cell (FC) systems are best applied to commer- assembly process is the best path to radically
time and aerospace sectors, both of which offer than once is a decision. The energy sector and
cial vehicles where range, payload and extensive reduce costs. In parallel, fuel-cell systems remain
tremendous long-term opportunities, although with investors have made the error before in thinking
usage are key. They offer range and refueling times complex, with often expensive balance of plant
some near-term challenges to be overcome. To of the fuel cell as the unattractive wallflower; FCs
that compete or often exceed that of fossil fuel components. Pathways to simplifying these are
meet the growing potential in these applications, still remain unequivocally the most sustainable,
vehicles. With the rapid industrialization of the key also being rapidly developed, leading to higher
EH Group has developed a high-power density ecological and carbon-zero technological energy
building blocks of the hydrogen ecosystem, are efficiencies and lower costs.
250kW FC solution that sets new market standards. options of our age.
we fast approaching a tipping point where hybrid
Across all mobility sectors, a new generation of
solutions combining FCs with battery technology
become the true norm, and with far wider coverage
Low Hanging Fruit skilled jobs is being created to accelerate these
deployment opportunities.
of transport applications?
While for many years much of the attention on fuel- 01 E
H TRACE Fuel Cell System. Source: EH Group
cell mobility was focused on cars as an alternative 02 E
H-81 Fuel Cell Stack. Source: EH Group
Tackling Cost & Complexity to battery solutions, the real battle was being waged
elsewhere – on the floors of large e-commerce fulfill-
Aside from hydrogen infrastructure, cost remains ment centers. The forklift model, perfected by the
arguably the most significant obstacle to the more likes of Plug Power, has demonstrated that where
widespread adoption of FC technology in mobility. intensive commercial vehicle use is required, with
To meet this challenge, the industry is ramping up low downtimes, fuel cells are already economically
01 02
With its extensive hydrogen portfolio and large installed base, Linde is
a driving force in the transition to a hydrogen economy. Yet success will
also depend on striking new partnerships.
Societies are focusing on decarbonization, and in the early 20th century. Today, we cover every
that has moved the topic of hydrogen front and aspect of the hydrogen value chain: production
center. What does this mean for Linde? using steam methane reforming (SMR), more re-
cently including CO2 capture, and expanding use
This is an important opportunity for us to contrib- of electrolysis; storage in cryogenic tanks and in
ute to the development of a hydrogen economy. the world’s first commercial high-purity hydrogen
Our experience with hydrogen stretches back cavern; distribution via pipeline, trailers and tankers;
over 100 years, initially with Carl von Linde co- and, finally, hydrogen applications across many
developing a method for producing hydrogen different sectors – including mobility, industry and
01
World’s First Hydrogen We are convinced that hydrogen and batteries will
first pre-serial hydrogen regional train was ready
for passenger service.
Passenger Train
bring about change in rail transport – towards a
The Coradia iLint has been certified for regular use
cleaner and ultimately emission-free energy sys-
in Germany and Austria. This followed extensive
tem. For hydrogen rail, a key driver is the rapid
testing carried out in Lower Saxony, Germany
is Already a Reality
development of a hydrogen economy in transport
supported by a strong public and private alliance.
Hydrogen also has an important role to play in
decarbonising other industries beyond transport,
that’s why Alstom is a member of Hydrogen Europe
Alstom is convinced that decarbonising mobility is an essential part of
and the Hydrogen Council.
fighting global climate change and that hydrogen trains are a key technology
to enable zero emission mobility. The fuel cell is the core of a hydrogen train: it is
where hydrogen is combined with oxygen from the
atmosphere to generate electricity, with the only
Alstom is the world’s largest international rail Transportation accounts for around a quarter of exhaust being steam and water. The electricity
technology player, we have made furthering the global CO2 emissions. Unlike other sectors, these produced is used to directly power the train or
development of smart, green technologies like green emissions have continued to grow, even as efforts stored in a high-performance battery. This battery
traction a key focus of our 2025 strategy. The aim to fight climate change have increased. Rail is is also used to capture energy when the train is 01
is to provide zero-emission alternatives on non- already by far the greenest way to provide mobility braking, increasing its fuel efficiency. By acquiring
electrified rail tracks. The potential is substantial: for people and freight on land. Bringing hydrogen Helion Hydrogen Power, Alstom now has access
in Europe as the world’s largest rail region, almost and battery as viable alternatives to using diesel to in-house fuel cell competence, providing us
half of all tracks are not electrified and currently power on non-electrified lines will unlock further with the unique ability to develop and integrate the
rely on diesel-powered trains. reductions in the environmental impact of rail trans- entire on-board hydrogen technology for trains.
port. On longer routes, hydrogen is the technology
01 C
oradia iLint in Sweden in August, 2021.
Source: Alstom / Tommy Hvitfeldt
02 A
hydrogen powered train takes about the same
amount of time to refuel as a diesel one. The train
will then run up to 1,000 kilometers after one filling
Source: Alstom / Christoph Busse
02
with Clean Energy ered in 80+ countries since 1927. For readers
new to the hydrogen topic, to put it simply, an
electrolyser is a system the uses electricity to
innovations already absorbed. Although some
technological innovation may still contribute, the
cost reductions available for alkaline electrolysis
01
02
(SOFC) Systems
duction of electricity is extremely climate-friendly. MS: Yes, several. For example, we have put a
stationary fuel cell into operation at the main bus
What does that mean specifically? station in Bamberg. The system is two meters high
and generates some ten kilowatts of electricity,
MS: By level of efficiency, we mean an electrical which is enough to power more than 20 four-person
DR. WILFRIED KÖLSCHEID (LEFT) & MARCUS SPICKERMANN (RIGHT) efficiency of more than 60%. If we are also using households in the part of the city surrounding
PROJECT LEADERS FOR THE SOLID OXIDE FUEL CELL AT ROBERT BOSCH GMBH the waste heat, then the levels of efficiency can the bus station. We want to use it to show how a
be 85% or more. This makes the solid oxide fuel decentralized, climate-friendly energy supply of
cells far superior than other energy converters. the future can look.
A coal-fired power station, for example, has an
efficiency level of 40%. What other areas of application are there?
And what about the emissions? MS: A wide range. Our appliances can be used
in the urban context to supply buildings, provide
WK: The operation of fuel cells is nearly emission- electricity to data centers, and to supply energy
free; it produces hardly any nitrogen oxides or in industrial and commercial segments.
particulates. When run purely on hydrogen, the
emission level falls almost to zero. In addition, What is Bosch’s position in the market for
fuel cells fed with natural gas provide a significant stationary fuel cell systems?
“Fuel cell systems play an essential role CO2 emission benefit compared to electricity from
coal power plants and they pave the way to zero MS: With our devices, we occupy the 10-kilowatt
in the energy mix of the future.”
carbon emission when green hydrogen is used. performance class of the energy market. That is a
new segment that we plan to help set up. But we
What roles do stationary fuel cell systems can also see that many manufacturers of fuel cell
Stationary solid oxide fuel cell systems (SOFC) are When you think about the stationary fuel cell play in the energy mix of the future? systems, even those in higher performance classes,
a key component in the energy mix of the future. systems, do you get fired up? are trying to access the new market. Our aim is
The small, decentralized power stations generate WK: Without doubt, they play a relevant role, for to become a leading provider in this segment.
electricity and heat from natural gas, hydrogen, or a WK: The subject electrifies us all, because we example in markets such as Germany, where a
blend of both. A promising market, in which Bosch are able to offer an efficient, cleaner, decentral- huge natural gas network is in place. In the future,
places great hopes. The two people in charge of ized energy supply. We consider stationary fuel this can be converted towards green hydrogen
the project, Dr. Wilfried Kölscheid (WK), Senior cells to be an essential component of the energy transport. With the networked SOFC, electricity
Vice President Engineering & Manufacturing, and transition, and a promising market to boot. Bosch and heat can be generated efficiently in exactly the
Marcus Spickermann (MS), Senior Vice President believes that the whole market for decentralized places where they are needed. In doing so, we are
Sales & Market development, talk about fuel cell energy production using stationary fuel cells will
systems for power generation and their advantages. reach a volume of around 20 billion euros by 2030.
01 C
entral bus station in Bamberg: A system there
generates around 10 kW of electricity - enough
to meet the annual requirements of more than
20 four-person households in an urban quarter.
Source: Robert Bosch GmbH.
01
Decarbonize Buildings
connected households can automatically use
the (bio)methane-hydrogen mix. In fact, today’s
heating installations can already run on 100%
biomethane. For hydrogen blends: the existing,
installed, heating equipment can already process
hydrogen admixtures up to 10% right away, and
Kaisersesch, a small town located in the state of Rhineland-Palatinate in
new appliances can process up to 20%. For re-
the quaint south-west of Germany, will soon be a frontrunner in heating gions and localities that decide to switch to 100%
innovation: by 2023, the SmartQuart project will set up a complete hydrogen hydrogen, heating systems can be upgraded at
infrastructure – from renewable electricity generation to hydrogen-powered marginal costs – just like in the SmartQuart pilot
transport and Viessmann hydrogen heating. in Kaisersesch.
How can hydrogen help us to decarbonise yearly replacement rates for heat generators are
01 T
he SmartQuart project value chain in Kaisersesch: 01
heating and generate benefits for people, the stalling at below 4%. 1 Production: Wind turbine, photovoltaic systems,
environment and the economy? Heating and electrolyzer | 2 Storage: Hydrogen-based microgrids
cooling make up 75% of the carbon footprint of Hydrogen opens additional options – in tandem | 3 Consuming: Excess energy LOHC hydrogen
every citizen in Germany, and buildings account with large-scale electrification via heat pumps – storage plant, H2-user industrial building, heat
use, hydrogen mobility, H2-cogeneration plant | 4
for 36% of total EU CO2 emissions. The majority to accelerate heating decarbonisation where 71% of
Control: Intelligent neighborhood control | 5 Source:
of space heaters installed in European homes are installed space heaters in the EU are gas-based. The “Reallabor SmartQuart”.
old and inefficient (64% to be exact). And yet, gas infrastructure is tailor-made for high seasonal
02 H
ydrogen-ready boilers are an affordable future-
proof retrofit solution: initially they process methane
or methane-hydrogen blends. If the gas supplier
switches to pure hydrogen, they can be adapted with
minor changes on-site. Source: Viessmann
02
but what turns words into Only if this foundation takes hold, then the in-
a large-scale market ramp-up? dustries that can use and consume green and
low-carbon hydrogen will schedule and execute
Uniper spends millions each year to develop pro-
jects up to financial decision with a team of more
their conversion activities, then the signal will be than 50 people. With our cross-functional team of
sent to grow the hydrogen market. These signals experts and hydrogen specialists, we are among
of demand for green and low-carbon hydrogen the pioneers in the field of green and low-carbon
DR. AXEL WIETFELD
will then trigger the development of hydrogen hydrogen and will use this expertise to actively
UNIPER SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT HYDROGEN
production, transport and storage infrastructure shape the international hydrogen market. Our
in parallel with the upscaling of renewables. project portfolio aims at more than 1 GW Hydrogen
Production Capacity by 2030 and a significant
Protecting our climate and achieving a decarbon- even break even with fossil-based hydrogen in
With green and low-carbon hydrogen as one impor- market share in trading and global sourcing for
ized energy future requires the efforts of business, the late 2020s already. This cost decrease is es-
tant pillar to reach the ambitious and increasingly imports. We are also in a constructive dialogue
policy and the public. We have already embarked sential to make green and low-carbon hydrogen a
urgent climate targets of the EU Green Deal, it is with our customers to overcome one of the major
on the path and set ourselves ambitious targets: key factor of success especially in hard to abate
time to act now. remaining obstacles – demand uncertainty.
Uniper has committed to a net zero carbon target industries such as steel, aviation and shipping that
for European generation by 2035. In addition, we face strong global competition. However, such
will have largely phased-out coal-based power a cost decrease will only materialize if sufficient
generation in Europe by 2029. For the sustainable green and low-carbon hydrogen demand triggers:
development of a climate-friendly economy, we have
made hydrogen the focus of our business activities. • the ramp-up of renewables in high-yield sites
around the globe
We see hydrogen as a key element of the energy
transition. But how can green and low-carbon • the upscaling of green and low-carbon hydrogen
hydrogen really become the driver of the decar- production capacity
bonized energy future?
• the establishment of green and low-carbon
Various studies state significant cost decreases in storage and transport infrastructure on- and
green and low-carbon hydrogen production and offshore
01 D
r. Axel Wietfeld
Uniper Senior,
Vice President
Hydrogen.
Source: UNIPER
02
Thank you!
Disclaimer
This special report on Hydrogen, Enabling A Zero-Emission Society is produced by Hydrogen
Europe and curated by REVOLVE. All opinions expressed in the content provided are those of the
authors and their respective companies and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of REVOLVE
or Hydrogen Europe. Any errata that may be present in the core content of this report are the
responsibility of the producers and curators and in no way can be attributed to the Members of
Hydrogen Europe. If you spot are errors, please contact: secretariat@hydrogeneurope.eu and
info@revolve.media.
www.hydrogeneurope.eu
✔ ISO 14001
Colophon
✔ 100% GREEN POWER
This report is printed on 100% recycled and chlorine-free paper by ARTOOS Group that is con-
scientious of its environment footprint caused by printing and therefore offsets its emissions with
carbon credits in a sustainability project. ARTOOS calculates the emissions causes by the amount
of paper used and printed, and then the partner purchases the certificate from ARTOOS. For this @H2Europe
report, ARTOOS will contribute to the Clean Drinking Water “Spouts” Project in Uganda. More
@h2europe
PRINTED CLIMATE NEUTRALLY
CERT. NR: 53520-2111-1003
details on ARTOOS sustainability here: www.artoosgroup.eu/mvo/
#HydrogenEurope