Hedge Funds
Hedge Funds
Hedge Funds
A Collection Of Articles
Table Of Contents
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge
Funds 5
Which Is A Better Investment Hedge Funds Vs Equity
Market 26
Drowning In Expenses Hedge Fund Startups 42
Illusory Chase For The Best Hedge Fund 55
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English 64
Are Hedge Funds Risky 75
16 Questions To Test
What You Know About
Hedge Funds
Written By
Ask anyone on the streets if they know what “hedge funds” are, and you will
most likely be greeted with a blank look. And if not, thanks to bad press, a range
of answers with often negative connotations. For example:
I will leave these for now, each of which can be a lengthy topic by itself. For
now, let’s answer some basic questions.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
There are 2 persons who can claim credit to the founding of hedge funds. The
more well-known is an Australian named Alfred Winslow Jones, and the other,
an American called Karl G. Karsten. Interestingly, both of them were not nance
professionals to start with.
Karl G. Karsten
Karl G. Karsten was a statistician and economist. In the course of his research
work, he developed certain “barometers” to forecast business conditions. These
included measures on volume of trade, interest rates, wholesale price level,
building activity etc. In the 1930s, he applied these “barometers” to the stock
market by starting a private fund using his and his colleagues’ money. He set
the foundation then, perhaps for the rst statistical arbitrage fund, where he
bought a group of stocks that are predicted to do best and shorted another that
are predicted to do worst. According to records, his fund did very well. In less
than 6 months, it was up 78%, and it displayed desirable characteristics such as
the ability to make large gains while keeping losses low. It also exhibit a return
pro le that is independent of the market it trades. However, his sole objective is
to test out his theory. There was no intention on his part to ever evolve this into
a commercial for-pro t fund.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
You cannot rely on the literal meaning of “hedge” as well. Modern day hedge
funds, even though they are still called “hedge funds”, have evolved to do all
sorts of different things other than what Karl G. Karsten or Alfred Winslow
Jones started. The concept of a hedge may not be as strong, or even just
outright not applicable to some of these funds. Even the boundaries between
hedge and mutual funds are blurring. For example, long-short strategies use to
be associated only with hedge funds. Today, you can also nd special long-short
mutual funds such as the 130-30. On the regulation side, hedge funds, meeting
certain criteria, can also be offered to retail instead of only accredited investors.
So do not be too obsessed with nding a perfect de nition.
The fund is a separate entity set up to hold money and make investments
according to the fund’s offering documents. The investment management
company (IMC) is a licensed entity that is appointed to manage the fund’s
investments. It does the research, makes the investment calls, size up the
positions, execute trades, monitor risks, does the marketing and handles
investor relations etc. In majority of the cases, this company is also the one that
sponsors and sets up the fund. The IMC, together with other service providers
engaged by the fund, carry out most of the work. Other than a board of
directors, the fund has no employees. Such an arrangement is not unique to
hedge funds. You will nd similarities within the more well-known mutual fund
industry.
The portfolio manager is the person in the IMC that manages investments for
the fund. This person can be an employee, but more often than not, he/she is
also a stakeholder in the IMC and has a personal investment in the hedge fund
itself.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
Sounds like common sense? Yes, that is the gist of it. But in an institutional
setting like hedge funds, you are not just going to be dealing with your family or
close friends who have absolute trust in you. You will need to have proper legal
structures and safeguards in place. For that purpose, most funds engage
external service providers such as fund administrators to perform this function.
This gives assurance that the IMC cannot freely manipulate the numbers.
There are bene ts to such a set up. A pooled arrangement provide investors,
even smaller ones, with economies of scale such as lower trade commissions,
lower borrowing costs, better broker services, ability to diversify more widely
across different assets, regions or strategies etc. It is also easier for the
portfolio managers operationally, since they just have to focus on managing a
single pool of money without concerns on con icts of interests.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
Let me use back the previous example. So instead of pooling all the money into
an account under your name, you ask each one to open their own personal
broker account and fund it. After that, both parties will agree on terms like
performance targets, risks and compensation etc. Then your family and friends
will authorize you to trade on their broker accounts. Basically, that is it.
Onshore funds are domiciled in the local jurisdiction and offshore funds are
funds domiciled in other foreign jurisdictions. As it turns out, tax implications
are the impetus behind the use of an offshore fund which is typically
incorporated in a tax haven such as Cayman Islands. And do not be mistaken,
this is not some shady tax evasion plan. It is entirely legitimate and sensible.
These offshore fund caters to foreign investors and other tax-exempt entities so
that they will not be subject to any inadvertent tax from the local jurisdiction of
the onshore fund. For example, if you are a non-US investor and you invest in a
US onshore fund, you might nd yourself subject to certain US taxes such as
income tax if the fund engage in speci c activities, and estate tax upon death.
The solution to this is to park your money with the offshore fund instead. To
cater to global investors, many US funds adopt a master-feeder structure, with
an onshore US feeder fund for US investors, an offshore feeder fund for foreign
or tax exempt investors, and an offshore master fund. The 2 feeder funds will
invest everything into the offshore master fund. All investment activities are
carried out in the master fund.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
For institutions, licensed and regulated entities such as banks, fund of funds,
sovereign wealth funds, pensions or listed companies are all eligible as
investors. You can look up a compiled list of what it takes to be accredited in
different countries on Wikipedia.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
There are a whole multitude of different hedge fund strategies today ranging
from equity long-shorts, activists, sector specialist, distressed investing, event
driven, convertible arbitrage, merger arbitrage, global macro, multi-strategy,
volatility to fund of funds and more. A few can technically be classi ed under
the umbrella of a broader strategy. But do not be too xated on these strategies
as I will not be touching on them here. It is good enough to have a avour of
how diverse the hedge fund strategy landscape looks.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
You might be thinking who would want to run such a fund. Would anyone even
invest in them? The answer is yes. Because when the big crash comes along
and trounce most people out there, these guys jump through the roof and have
their last laugh. So they ll an important gap in the portfolio of large institutional
investors who allocate capital to these funds to get the protection they need
during bad times.
Hence, we should not take the de nition of absolute return as a one size ts all.
All strategies have will their own strengths and weaknesses. What is more
important is for the investor to do his/her own due diligence to understand and
nd out what each fund is made out to do before plunging in.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
The liquidity terms among hedge funds can vary a great deal. It is really up to
the fund’s sponsor, usually the IMC, to de ne the terms in the offering
documents. To a large extent, it depends on the strategy of the fund. A short
term trading fund with holding period of days to weeks may provide monthly
liquidity or better, meaning you can subscribe or redeem every month. An
equity long-short fund that invests over a long term horizon may provide
quarterly or semi-annual liquidity, and quite often, also impose a lock-in period of
a year or more. Lock-in is a stipulated period where the investor is unable to
redeem (hard lock-in) or can redeem but with a penalty (soft lock-in). On the
other end of the spectrum, funds that deal with private equity or hard to liquidate
assets can lock your money in for as long as 5-10 years.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
The fund also incur expenses which are deducted off directly from the fund.
These are not included in the fees. For example, the initial set up costs of the
fund is usually borne by the initial investors. The fund also pays a host of other
things such as fees to the fund administrator, fund auditor, fund legal counsel,
fund custodian, regulators, distributors as well as trading related costs such as
market data, broker commissions, etc. While these expenses can be material
for a starting hedge fund with little assets, it becomes a lot more manageable if
the fund size grows huge and it is spread out over more assets.
Overall, hedge fund fees and expenses are higher than mutual funds whose
expense ratio which can be as low as 0.25% (passive index funds) or more than
2% (active managed funds) and it covers pretty much everything. This glaring
difference pressured many hedge funds into lowering their fees especially with
increasing competition and lackluster performance in recent years.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
_____________________________________________
That’s all for now. Hope this gives you a better idea of what hedge funds are,
how and why they operate as they do, and some of their distinctive features.
16 Questions To Test What You Know About Hedge Funds
Which Is A Better
Investment
Hedge Funds
Vs
Equity Market
Written By
People like to compare. I guess it is just human nature. But many times, the
basis for comparison may not make a lot of sense. If you are a fund manager,
you might encounter people that frequently compare your fund against the
stock markets regardless of what the fund strategy is. For example, I will not be
surprised if an investment manager who runs a dedicated short bias fund
receive questions like “Why did your fund not make any money? This is one of
the best bull market in history!”; or a long-only manager getting quizzed on why
he failed to deliver a positive return during a huge market crash. On the positive
side, more often than not, this stems from a lack of understanding of the
product’s strategy rather than being unreasonable.
But have hedge funds really lost its shine? Let’s look further.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
1. Hedge fund indices suffer from numerous biases such as selection and
survivorship bias. It is not mandatory for a hedge fund to report
performance to any index providers. Thus, managers can opt to start
reporting only when they have good performance. This is a form of
selection bias. Fortunately, HFRI does not back ll the data of the new
manager into its index. It only starts including it henceforth, meaning only
future performance of the manager is taken into account.
Funds that have shuttered mostly due to performance reasons may also
stop reporting to the index provider way before the fund even close,
omitting a period of bad performance which would otherwise drag the
index down. This leaves only surviving funds, which tend to be the good
performers, thereby putting an upward bias on the index performance.
This is called survivorship bias. However, aside from poor performance,
there are also funds that did very well, but cease reporting because they are
no longer taking in money. So while the former produces an upward bias,
the latter creates a downward bias which reduces this effect.
To mitigate some of these biases, I included the HFRI fund of funds index.
All managers managed by the fund of funds will be accounted for in the
returns submitted to the index provider regardless of whether their
performance is good or bad. Individual managers would not have the
choice to opt out of reporting in this scenario. They are left out only when
they are no longer invested by the fund of funds. But of course, one can
argue that there are active selection by the fund of funds to pick good
managers and drop bad ones as well. The representation may also be less
comprehensive as fund of funds have a tendency to go for more
established managers. To top it off, they charged an additional layer of
fees complicating matters.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
2. HFRI indices are equal weighted. The index is rebalanced annually and
equal weight is applied to all funds. That inherently suggest an active
mechanism where winners are sold and losers are bought to maintain the
weights. One can also contest that the results can be skewed upwards as
emerging managers, which receive the same weightage as established
managers, tend to deliver higher returns in the long term.
3. HFRI indices have no equivalent investable products. There are investable
products such as ETFs and index funds that are replicated after MSCI WL.
HFRI indices, however, have no such investable equivalents. Its underlying
funds are investable though. But it will take an enormous resource to
allocate capital to 1500 hedge funds. It is, at this moment, an index used
mostly for benchmarking and tracking broad hedge fund performance.
4. HFRI FWI and HFRI FOF are not pure equity indices. HFRI FWI and FOF
cuts across many asset classes, geographical regions, strategies and time
frames. MSCI WL, on the contrary, is a pure equity index. That is why I
included HFRI EHI, the equity hedged (long-short) index for hedge funds, in
our comparison.
5. Volatility is used as the risk measure here. Despite its prevalent use and
being adopted in modern portfolio theory by Harry Markowitz, volatility as a
proxy for risk has been controversial. Because, it does not measure how
much you can lose (in a more permanent sense), based on exposure to
some speci c factors. Technically, it is nothing more than just an indication
of how much the value of a security or fund can move from an expected
average, both upwards and downwards over time.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
Advocators see it as the shortfall risk you may experience should you need to
liquidate at an inopportune time. Others will contest that an investor with a long-
term horizon would render this reasoning less compelling. And the list goes on.
But I am not here to debate this. Yes, everyone has a point. Volatility is not
perfect. It is indeed not a good proxy for many types of risks e.g. tail risks,
counterparty risks, fraud risks, liquidity risks etc. But at present we have no
means to adequately quantify some of these risks, much less to unify them into
a single sensible statistic. And if we are talking about large diversi ed portfolios,
as is the case in this exercise, then some of these risks may be dramatically
reduced. And to show a slightly better picture, I have also included other metrics
like maximum drawdown into this exercise.
I have taken data as far back as 1990. This is the earliest for HFRI indices. But it
should su ce as we have 3 bear and 3 bull phases to examine over this period
of approximately 29 years. I de ne any bear market here to be a drop of more
than 20% on the MSCI WL. Let’s have a look at the returns and the maximum
drawdowns generated by the indices over each bull and bear period. For the
chart, I have presented it in log scale, else we would not be able to see the
different curves clearly in the earlier years.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
1. Annualized returns – In terms of annualized returns, HFRI FWI and EHI still
holds the upper hand against MSCI WL if we take results since 1990 and
2000. HFRI FOF, however, underperformed here. If you noticed, the FOF
seems trail both MSCI WL and its 2 other brethren. I did not dive deep
enough to explore this phenomenon. Manager selection skills can play a
part, though I would think a larger portion of this underperformance may be
attributed to an additional layer of fees. MSCI WL, on the other hand,
clearly held the lead in the period since 2009.
2. Total Returns – For the periods since 1990, HFRI FWI and EHI deliver more
than twice and almost 4 times the total returns of MSCI WL respectively.
Let’s rebased the indices to start at $1 from Jan 1990. If you had held a
dollar worth of HFRI EHI, it would be worth more than $21 today, and a
dollar of HFRI FWI would be $14. HFRI FOF and MSCI WL looks more
comparable, at about $6 each today.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
6. Other metrics – Let’s take a look at some other metrics computed for the
period since 1990. HFRI indices all experienced signi cantly less
drawdowns than MSCI WL. Their average monthly upside is also more than
the downside, with their best and worst month giving comparable returns.
Overall, this is a desirable outcome. MSCI WL, on the other hand, has a less
favorable performance here.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
Even though hedge funds may appear to have deteriorated after 2008, I would
say this is not out of expectations. Hedge funds tend to underperform the stock
market during bull phases. And this has been an exceptionally long bull market.
If the current bull market continues raging on without signs of abating, I would
expect hedge funds as a group to lag even further behind, and any buffers that
hedge funds have accumulated since 1990 could possibly be eroded away.
To many, it seems like a no-brainer to make money. All one has to do is to buy a
low-cost index fund or ETF and hold it. Why bother investing in hedge funds and
pay costly fees to someone who can’t even beat the market? But all parties will
come to an end, and we should not forget that hedge funds have delivered
signi cant outperformance during all the previous downturns. I believe hedge
funds still has a place as an attractive alternative investment.
Until then, let’s see if the buffer runs out before the bear comes.
Which Is A Better Investment - Hedge Funds Vs Equity Market
Drowning In Expenses
Hedge Fund Startups
Written By
Many years back, I was searching for information on how to set up and run a
hedge fund. Can I start one myself? That was my thought then. However, I was
sorely lacking in information. In particular, I want to know how much it is going
to cost. It was not an easy task. I managed to gather bits and pieces from the
internet and friends in the industry. But like solving a giant puzzle, there are
always missing pieces. Pieces which you know you are missing, and pieces
which you don’t know you are missing. And costs are one of those.
I guess I could have talked to a fund lawyer. But it was not a rm thought then. I
was not some pedigreed portfolio manager looking to go start his own fund.
Neither am I rich to begin with, nor do I have wealthy sponsors lining to back me
up. I don’t want to go to a fund lawyer sounding stupid, looking less than half-
committed, and end up wasting both side’s time. Anyway, to cut the long story
short, I did not end up starting a hedge fund. Instead, I joined a start-up hedge
fund several years later. Only then did all the pieces fall into place. Not
surprisingly, I have way underestimated what is needed.
For those who are contemplating starting and running one with the investment
management company based in Singapore, there are a few things you might
want know.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
In this post, I will focus on the more typical fund structure approach. There are 2
entities involved. First, you need to incorporate an Investment Management
Company (IMC). After that, you need to create a Hedge Fund (HF). The HF holds
the pooled assets of all its investors and engages the IMC to manage these
assets. It sounds kind of roundabout, but this elaborate arrangement is
necessary. It segregates the investors’ assets and isolate them from business
risks associated with the IMC. For more generic information about hedge funds,
you can read up an earlier article I wrote 16 Questions To Test What You Know
About Hedge Funds.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
Besides your CEO & CIO, ideally, you should also have a corporate secretary,
nance o cer, a compliance o cer, an IT personnel, and a marketing person.
But there is no rule to say you can’t hire someone who is both IT savvy and
good at nance, or the CEO/CIO can’t double up as the marketing director. It is
fairly common for people in startups to wear many hats. Compliance, however,
is a full time dedicated function. And due to con ict of interests, you can’t have
the CEO/CIO wearing this hat. You are, however, allowed to outsource this
function to an external service provider.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
What if you can’t pay? Then the only alternative is to nd trusted partners who
share the same passion with you. And they must have su ciently deep pockets
to see themselves through the next couple of years. Else this venture is almost
guaranteed to fail. It is, however, by no means easy to nd that many partners.
So let’s just assume you are the CIO, and the CEO/Marketing is your business
partner. Both of you hire another 2 people to ll the roles of a nance/IT and
compliance o cer. It is highly unlikely you want to hire senior professionals
from large institutions unless you can pay really generously. Let’s go for 2 junior
hires and budget about $12000 a month.
Contrary to what many people may think, the hedge fund actually does not have
any direct hires other than a board of directors for oversight. But that does not
mean its expenses are low. Because it engages the service of many third party
providers. And these services do not come cheap. Typically, these expenses are
deducted from the fund. But when the fund is small, as is usually the case for
unknown start ups, there are implications. An annual expense of say $100,000
on a fund with an AUM of $1 million means you got to make 10% rst before
your fund will show any pro t. That is a killing blow to any track record you want
to build. It is also unfair for early investors to bear such a big burden. In such
instances, it makes more sense for the IMC to bear these expenses on behalf of
the fund before it grows to a reasonable size.
Cayman islands o shore fund associated and other regulatory fees: $20,000 per
year
Let’s say you incorporate an offshore fund in Cayman Islands – one of the tax
havens. There are probably lower cost options like British Virgin Islands (BVI),
but I am only familiar with Cayman Islands, so I will go with that. Cayman
Islands is also the choice of domicile for most offshore funds, accounting for
more than half of all offshore structures.
There are of course fees to pay to set up and maintain a fund in Cayman
Islands. Very brie y, you will need to pay on a yearly basis – mutual fund
registration fee, Cayman government fee, Cayman registered o ce fee, annual
returns ling fee, CIMA director fee for each director on board the fund etc. And
just last year in 2018, the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) introduce
a new rule requiring all regulated funds to appoint an Anti-Money Laundering
Compliance O cer (MLRO) and a deputy MLRO. If you do not have suitable
candidates, you can outsource this function to the fund administrators for a fee.
Cayman-based nancial institution are also to subject to FATCA reporting
obligations for tax purposes. It is beyond me to explain. But su ce to know you
need to pay to get others to do the reporting for you.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
As a ballpark gure, all these stuffs might set you back easily by $20,000 or
more per year.
This is where the fund administrator steps in. They track all the positions and
trades of the fund and reconcile them against the broker statements at the end
of each month to arrive at the o cial NAV. This leaves no room for tricks.
Besides this, they also process investor subscriptions and redemptions, perform
Anti Money Laundering (AML) checks, and prepare the fund’s annual nancial
statement for audit purposes etc.
Fund administration is one of the largest expense. They charge a monthly fee,
usually a couple of basis points based on the size of your fund subject to a
minimum. Again, prices vary according to the complexity of your fund and
administrators. But as a rough estimate, put aside $3,000-$4,000 per month.
Concluding Remarks
Note what I mentioned is not exhaustive. For example, I have not included
expenses on things like web domain, website development, emails, secured
cloud servers, backup power supplies, laptops, name cards, design and printing
of marketing materials, professional indemnity insurance etc. The set up
also cannot be used to solicit US monies. That will require a master feeder fund
structure comprising a US onshore feeder, a Cayman offshore feeder and a
Cayman Master Fund. 3 sets of nancial accounts. More work for auditors.
Complicated tax reporting. And on top of that, you need a US fund lawyer to
draft another PPM for the US investors. Basically, expect to pay a lot more.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
There are other paths one can take though. One way is to start with an
incubator fund instead of a full edged hedge fund. Another is to look at joining
a hedge fund platform who have the expertise and economies of scale to
negotiate better deals with the service providers. I did not explore those paths so
I will not comment much here. In any case, anyone serious about it should do
their own homework and consult the relevant professionals. However, I do hope
this post let you have a glimpse into how hedge funds work and some of the
challenges that start up hedge funds faced.
Drowning in Expenses : Hedge Fund Start Ups
Illusory Chase
For The Best Hedge Fund
Written By
We constantly strive to look for the best in everything. The best partner, best
employee, best deal, best career, best education, best investment, and the list
goes endlessly on. And the world has as many categories of “BEST” awards as
you can think of. Similarly, when someone goes out hunting for a hedge fund to
invest, he wants to know which is the best. Somehow, our DNA is hardwired to
seek out the optimal solution to whatever we need. The focus is sharp and
simple. The behavior is also entirely rational. However, like many things in life,
the answers are never as clear.
3. Dearth of information
Hedge funds are well known for its secrecy. They are not your publicly listed
companies. Getting to know its existence can already be a challenge, and
extracting information out of it can be no less grueling. Hedge funds do not
follow a standard marketing or reporting template. Their pitch deck or monthly
reports can range from a comprehensive one covering all aspects to a black
box containing nothing other than some fancy stories or a set of elementary
information.
Illusory Chase For The Best Hedge Fund
During my earlier career in the role as fund of hedge funds analyst, I have
personally come across monthly reports that print nothing other than the month
to date (MTD) and year to date (YTD) gures. Of course, you can always ask for
the info, but getting it is another story. I have talked to funds who ercely guards
everything beyond what they put on the pitch deck as some “If I tell you, I have
to kill you” type of secrets. And there are funds that have grown so big and
complicated that unless you are talking to the partners, the rest does not know
the whole picture.
He is not alone. Many hedge fund strategies are hammered after 2008 for
lagging behind the markets. Why? We can only surmise e.g. change in market
dynamics from excessive central bank meddling; and/or thinning alpha as a
result of intensi ed competition. But not all are suffering. Long-only managers
running equities or risk parity type strategies ourished during this period from a
ood of easy money.
As a matter of fact, the industry is already doing it. But unlike mutual funds,
which has a very clear and narrow mandate, hedge funds have no such
constraints. Hedge funds are typically grouped into strategy silos, say equity
long/short, global macro, event driven, relative value, xed income/credit,
volatility etc. And within each silo, you can further break it down into many other
sub-strategies.
Illusory Chase For The Best Hedge Fund
However, there are potentially so many variations that the full spectrum cannot
be fully represented. Even funds within each sub-strategy are likely to be doing
things differently from the rest. You can have a long/short equity fund that
decide to create a side pocket for illiquid opportunities; or a credit fund
specialized in extending privately negotiated loans; or a volatility fund biased on
the long side while majority are net short. Hence, unless you know the speci cs,
the right Apple is hard to come by, or there may simply be no other comparable
Apple.
In short, even when armed with such resources and expertise, the bulk of the the
professionals can’t quite hack it. What makes you think you have an edge
against them?
Illusory Chase For The Best Hedge Fund
The same principles applies for picking hedge funds. You have to know clearly
what you want in the rst place. Search and lter out a pool of candidates. Do
your investment due diligence: understand the managers, their strategies, risk
management methodologies etc. Then do your best to pick those you think ts
your purpose, and accept the risks that come with your choice. Manage your
portfolio and just leave the decision of who is the BEST at any point in time in
hands of fate.
Illusory Chase For The Best Hedge Fund
Written By
An investment into any hedge funds require an understanding not just on its
strategy and associated risks. Aside from that, an investor should also
familiarize themselves with basic terms often found on a hedge fund’s Private
Placement Memorandum (PPM) or fact sheet. These are terms stating the fees,
expenses and any special terms with regards to an investment in the fund.
While the PPM do explain what these terms meant, they are written by lawyers.
Well, su ce to say, it is in English but yet not quite your English or my English.
In this post, I want to run through these terms. But do take note that there are
many different variations within the hedge fund industry today. Nevertheless, by
and large, they don’t deviate much from these.
If you are interested in knowing more about hedge funds in general, you can
look up one of my earlier post about hedge funds.
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English
1. Fund Expenses
For those who think operating a hedge fund should not be any more costlier
than trading his or her personal account at home, it is time to wake up. I shared
this in my prior post on Hedge Fund Startup Expenses. Fund expenses cover
items such as commissions, regulatory fees, withholding taxes, interests on
borrowed funds, stock loan fees for shorting, fund administration fees, fund
audit fees and legal fees etc. In fact, management and performance fees are
also fund expenses from an accounting perspective. But they are separately
calculated after netting off all other expenses for the fund which you will see
later. Hence, when I refer to “expense” in this article, it includes everything a
Hedge Fund pays other than management and performance fee.
HWM is a very important metric for both the Investment Manager and Investors
because it is used to determine the performance fee. Both follow a common
frequency where the HWM is reset at the end of each performance period. So if
the performance fee is calculated and paid at the end of each year, your HWM
will be reset at the end of each year. But should the performance fee follows a
quarterly schedule instead, the HWM will be reset on a quarterly basis.
3. Hurdle Rate
Not all hedge funds have hurdle rates. Hurdle rate, when applicable, means the
Investment Manager is only entitled to a performance fee on pro ts they made
for the fund over and above the hurdle. Anything below the hurdle are not eligible
for performance fee. As a quick example, lets say an investor puts $10,000,000
into a Fund that has a hurdle rate of 5% and charges 20% performance fee. At
the end of the year, the fund makes 20% or $2,000,000 before performance fee
for the investor. Without the hurdle, the Investment Manager will get a 20% cut
of the $2,000,000 pro t which works out to be $400,000. However, with a 5%
hurdle, the Investment Manager cannot charge the 20% fee on the rst 5% or
$500,000 of the pro ts. Instead, the 20% performance fee is applied only on the
next $1,500,000 pro t to give $300,000.
Example
There are a few things to note here. First, we use the GAV as at the end of the
month, not the start or some time weighted average. Second, GAV as mentioned
earlier, is net of expenses (other than management and performance fee).
Finally, we use the actual number of days in the month over the number of
actual days in the year as a proportion to to compute the management fee for
that speci c month. Exact terms can vary among funds, so always refer back to
the PPM.
5. Performance Fee
This is one of the more distinct features that differentiates hedge funds from
mutual funds. Aside from management fee, a hedge fund also pays its
Investment Manager a performance fee if targets are met. That can differ from
fund to fund, but in most cases, it just means making a pro t over the high
water mark for the investor. When that happens, the Investment Manager
receives a share on the pro ts made, typically 20%, although that is also on the
decline. This fee is adjusted every month but cast in concrete and deducted only
at the end of the applicable period. It is termed the performance period and is
usually a calendar year. But it can be longer or shorter depending on the fund’s
strategy.
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English
Example
Performance Fee (PF) 20%x MAX [0, GAV Less MF – (HWM x $96,433
#Shares)]
In this example, the Fund has starts the year with a HWM value (HWM x
#Shares) of $10,000,000. It makes $500,000 net of expenses for the rst month
in January giving us a GAV of $10,500,000. After deducting the applicable
management fee of $17,836, the fund is left with $10,482,164 which is $482,164
above the HWM value. This translates to a performance fee of $96,433 at the
end of January. This amount is held back but not actually deducted. It is subject
to further adjustments till the end of the performance period (end of the year).
To see how this works, let’s say the Fund subsequently loses $400,000 including
expenses in February.
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English
Gross Asset Value (GAV) Subtract $400,000 from November’s GAV Less MF $10,082,164
Performance Fee (PF) 20%x MAX [0, GAV Less MF – (HWM x # Shares)] $13,339
6. Liquidity
You probably seen or heard about the term “liquidity”. Investment professionals
and the media like to carry it on their mouth wherever they go. But not to worry,
it is not something awfully complex. In short, it means how easy one can get in
and out of an investment. And in our context, that explicitly refers to the
subscription and redemption terms of a hedge fund, or more speci cally, an
open-end hedge fund. Majority of the hedge funds are open-end funds that
issue shares to buyers and redeem shares from sellers. So as far as an investor
is concerned, the hedge fund is their only counterparty. In contrast, a closed end
hedge fund is listed and traded on an exchange just like a stock.
Subscription
Subscription is about how frequent you can invest in the fund, that is, if the fund
is not already closed to further subscriptions. Typically, subscription tends to be
more “friendly” than redemption if we discount the Know Your Customer (KYC)
and Anti Money Laundering (AML) checks for onboarding new clients . You can
usually subscribe at least as frequently as you can redeem, if not more. The
more common terms I seen are monthly or quarterly subscription frequencies.
And unlike mutual funds, you cannot just subscribe today and expect the
transaction to be done the following day. You have to submit an subscription
application form and wire the money over before a subscription deadline for the
transaction to be completed at the start of the following month or quarter.
Redemption
Buying things is always easy. All you need to do is pay up and you can walk
away with the product. Now, try asking for a refund and see if it is that
straightforward. The best you can get, and rarely so, is at most as easy you
bought the item. But these added di culties may not be without rationale.
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English
Investment Managers prefer “sticky” money and for good reasons. As the name
implies, these are money that sticks around. This is ideal as managers can then
concentrate on managing the investments rather than spend time dealing with
redemptions from investors who ee from the rst sight of “blood”.
Redemption frequencies in hedge funds are usually lower than subscription and
tied with more onerous conditions. On top of that, ample advance notice have to
be given through a redemption notice, and failing that, you may have to wait for
the next window. Redemption terms are typically justi ed through the underlying
strategies. For example, an equity long short with long term view horizon will
have a lower redemption frequency or even lock ups (we will see later) than a
fund trading liquid futures.
Lock Ups
Hedge funds pursuing less liquid or long term strategies often impose a lock up
period. This can be a hard or soft lock up. In a hard lock up, investors cannot
redeem during the lock up period. And for a soft lock up, investors can redeem
but either in limited amounts and / or with a penalty. A lock up period of 1 year is
fairly common among equity long short funds. On the higher end, lock ups can
go as far as 5 years or more for funds that deal in private equity.
Gate
This is a special provision that a hedge fund, which has it in its PPM, can
exercise should the need arise. Its intent is to act as a brake when redemption
exceeds a certain level at any point in time. For large hedge funds in particular,
this provide for orderly exits with minimal impact to the market in the event of
massive redemptions.
Hedge Fund Terms Explained In English
Written By
Patrick Ling
Are Hedge Funds Risky?
It is a common perception that hedge funds are risky or at least riskier than
traditional mutual funds. This is understandable as there have been many
examples of hedge funds blowup. The most famous example is perhaps LTCM.
On the other hand, we seldom hear about mutual funds blowup. However,
hedge funds should be less risky than mutual funds if they truly live up to the
word hedge. The reason is because hedge funds practice what is called risk
control. Alfred Winslow Jones started the rst modern hedge fund with risk
control in mind. He wanted to insulate himself from the vagaries of broad
economic conditions so he came up with the long/short equities approach. That
way, even in a terrible bear market, his long/short portfolio should still be able to
generate returns if his longs perform better than his shorts. On the other hand, a
long-only mutual fund would be suffering huge losses.
Putting aside the fact that it cost more to short, you have exchanged absolute
market risk for relative market risk. This is the risk that the company that you
shorted may outperform drastically for whatever reason while the company that
you bought under-performs. An extreme case is that the company you are long
decided to take over the company you shorted at a huge premium. This would
lead to the share price of the acquiring company dropping while the target
company’s share price rises to the takeover price. This is a double whammy
since both legs of the long/short pair is losing at the same time.
This style of hedging market cycle risk is now becoming commoditized. Even
some big robo-advisor in the US is offering it to retail clients. However, some
hedge funds have taken things to the extreme by employing high leverage on
risk parity to generate exceptional returns. In this instance, they have exchanged
market cycle risk for correlation risk. This is the risk that all asset classes goes
down together at the same time. The diversi cation bene t disappears and the
portfolio suffers a deep draw-down. It might even lead to ruin on an over-
leveraged portfolio.
Are Hedge Funds Risky?
Portfolio insurance became seen as the magic bullet that will ensure a portfolio
will never experience a loss beyond a comfortable limit. Many people including
institutions began to load up on stocks because of having portfolio insurance in
place. However, they either forgot or they ignored gap risk as well as over-
crowding risk. Gap risk is the risk of a sudden discontinuous drop in price
resulting in the inability to hedge in time. Over-crowding risk is the risk that too
many people are employing the same technique and trying to hedge at the
same time.
Let’s face it. A hedge fund is also a business that is ghting for investor dollars.
A responsible fund manager can do the right thing based on realistic
expectations of risk and return but if investors have unrealistic expectations,
their money would ow to those managers who dare to promise those
unrealistic returns regardless of the risk involved. In the end, the responsible
fund manager would not be able to survive simply on pure economics. It is sad
but true. In all instances of those spectacular hedge fund blew ups, the
managers walked away rich while the investors suffered losses.
The Upshot
Unfortunately, this is the way things are and it would be unrealistic to expect
investor behavior to change anytime soon. At the individual level though, before
you say categorically that hedge funds are risky, ask yourself whether you have
realistic expectations in the rst place. Do you accept the need for risk control
which acts as a natural limiter on returns or do you only look at returns without
regards to risk?
Are Hedge Funds Risky?
For hedge fund managers, the point about risk control is to be conservative. If
you are a discretionary player, multiply the worst draw-down you have ever
experienced in the past by 1.5 times and assume that is the worst draw-down
you have yet to encounter. For a systematic player, do the same for either live or
back-test period whichever contains the worst draw-down. If you cannot survive
such a draw-down, then you are using too much leverage. And by surviving, I do
not only mean avoiding a blowup. A draw-down of 20% can often mean the end
for a hedge fund.
Of course, the best risk control is having the humility to know that you can
always be wrong.
Are Hedge Funds Risky?
Patrick Ling
Patrick is the cp-founder and Partner of AllQuant which is set up to empower
retail investors to invest professionally. Prior to starting AllQuant, Patrick is a
portfolio manager of a systematic hedge fund. He has spent more than a
decade in the asset management and banking industry working through various
roles since 2005. These include managing private client portfolios, covering
hedge fund clients for equity derivatives products and strategy, product control
on derivative and structured products, and fund management.
Disclaimer
3. Any downloadable les and images is provided at the user’s own risk.
Any downloadable le, including but not limited to Microsoft Excel les, Word
documents, pdfs, jpegs, pngs, is provided at the user’s own risk. The authors will
not be liable for any losses, injuries, or damages resulting from a corrupted or
damaged le, or any errors or misinformation in the content of the le.