WP 51

MIDANPIRG/21 & RASG-MID/11-WP/51
12/02/2024
International Civil Aviation Organization
MIDANPIRG/21 & RASG-MID/11 Meetings
(Abu Dhabi, UAE, 4 – 8 March 2024)
Agenda Item 5.4: Air Navigation Deficiencies
MID AIR NAVIGATION DEFICIENCIES STATUS
(Presented by the Secretariat)
SUMMARY
This paper presents the outcome of the MIDANPIRG subsidiary bodies with
regard to the review and update of air navigation deficiencies.
Action by the meeting is at paragraph 3.

Reference
- MIDANPIRG/20 and RASG-MID/10 Meetings Report (Muscat, Oman, 14

– 17 May 2023)
- ATM SG/9 (Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt, 14 – 16 November 2023)
- AIM SG/10 Report (Cairo, Egypt, 28-29 February 2024)
- ASPIG/5 Report (Doha, Qatar, 13-15 June 2023)
- CNS SG/12 Report (Amman, Jordan, 02 – 04 May 2023)
- MET SG/11 Report (Cairo, Egypt, 14-16 November 2023)
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 The meeting may wish to note that MIDANPIRG/20 meeting (Muscat, Oman, 14 – 17
May 2023), reviewed and endorsed the list of deficiencies in the AIM, AOP, ATM, CNS, SAR and
MET fields as reported by the relevant subsidiary bodies. The meeting noted that the total number of
air navigation deficiencies recorded, was 116 deficiencies compared to 105 deficiencies approved by
MIDANPIRG/19 (Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, 14-17 February 2022).
1.2 The air navigation deficiencies are reflected in the MID Air Navigation Deficiency
Database (MANDD) at: http://www.icao.int/mid.
1.3 The MIDANPIRG/20 meeting noted with concern that the majority of deficiencies
listed in the MANDD have no specific Corrective Action Plan (CAP). The meeting urged States to
implement the provisions of MIDANPIRG Conclusion 15/35 related to the elimination of Air
Navigation Deficiencies, in particular, the submission of a specific Corrective Action Plan (CAP) for
each deficiency.
-2-
2. DISCUSSION
2.1 The meeting may wish to note that:
a) In the AOP field: the total number of AOP deficiencies is nine (9) priority “A”.
Seven (7) deficiencies related to aerodrome certification; one (1) related to runway
physical characteristics; and one (1) related to apron lighting. The lack of
implementation of aerodromes’ certification represents 78% of these deficiencies.
b) In the AIM field: the total number of AIM deficiencies is forty-eight (48); forty-
two (42) priority “A” and six (6) priority “B”. Twenty-two (22) deficiencies related
to eTOD (based on the agreement to include new deficiencies related to the non-
provision of TOD for Area 2a/TOFP and OLS); five (5) related to QMS; five (5)
related to AIXM; six (6) related to WAC; three (3) related to pre-flight information
services; two (2) related to AIP and aeronautical charts; three (3) related to AIRAC
adherence; and two (2) related to WGS-84.
Based on AIM SG/10, deficiency reported against Iraq related to related to AIP and
aeronautical charts is proposed for deletion; therefore, the total number of
deficiencies in the AIM field would be forty-seven (47).
c) In the ATM field: the total number of deficiencies is seventeen (17); twelve (12)
priority “A” and seven (7) priority “B”. Eight (8) related to the uncompleted
signature of contingency agreements; seven (7) related to the non-implementation
of planned regional ATS Routes, and two (2) related to unsatisfactory reporting of
large Height deviation (LHD) and Traffic Data Sample (TDS) to the MIDRMA.
d) In the CNS field: the total number of CNS deficiencies is sixteen (16); fourteen
(14) priority “A” and two (2) priority “B”. Two (2) deficiencies are related to ATS
Direct speech circuits, twelve (12) related to lack of OLDI/AIDC connection, one
(1) related to Inter-Regional Communication link with ICAO EUR/NAT Region
and one (1) for HF service.
Deficiency reported against Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon,
Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and UAE for not implementing the Priority 1
AIDC/OLDI connection are proposed for deletion; therefore, the total number of
deficiencies in the CNS field would be four (4).
e) In the MET field: the total number of MET deficiencies is fifteen (15) priority “A”
deficiencies. five (5) related to QMS, eight (8) related to METAR, TAF, SIGMET
and WAFS and two (2) related to SADIS.
Based on MET SG/11, deficiency reported against Jordan related to SADIS service
is proposed for deletion; therefore, the total number of deficiencies in the MET
field would be fourteen (14).
f) In the SAR field: the total number of deficiencies is nine (9) priority “A”. Five (5)
related to the lack of implementation of SAR provisions; and four (4) related to
non-compliance with the carriage of Emergency Locator Transmitter (ELT)
requirements.
2.2 The updated lists of deficiencies in the AIM, AOP, ATM, CNS, SAR and MET fields
are at Appendices A, B, C, D, E and F, respectively.
2.3 The analysis of the MID States’ air navigation deficiencies is shown in the tables and
-3-
graphs presented at Appendices G and H. In particular, it is to be highlighted that:
− The total number of air navigation deficiencies recorded would be 100 deficiencies compared
to 116 deficiencies approved by MIDANPIRG/20.
− The total number of deficiencies varies between 0 and 20 deficiencies per State as shown in
Appendix H.
− The distribution of air navigation deficiencies by field is shown in Appendix G as follows:

AIM 47%, AOP 9%, ATM 17%, CNS 4%, MET 14% and SAR 9%.
− The distribution of air navigation deficiencies by priority is shown in Appendix G as follows:

0% “U”, 85% “A”, and 15% “B”.
3. ACTION BY THE MEETING
3.1 The meeting is invited to:
a) review, update and approve the air navigation deficiencies at Appendices A, B, C,

D, E and F;
b) review the analyses in Appendices G and H; and
c) urge States to:
i. implement the provisions of the MIDANPIRG/15 Conclusion 15/35 and

provide updates on the status of their deficiencies using MANDD;
ii. submit CAP for each deficiency; and
iii. submit official Letter with the associated evidence(s) when requesting to
eliminate an air navigation deficiency.
------------------
APPENDIX A
APPENDIX A
Deficiencies in the AIM field
EGYPT
Item
Identification Deficiencies Corrective Action
No
Priority
Facilities/ Date first Remarks/ Rationale for Executing Date of
Requirement Description Facilities/ Services for
Services reported non-elimination body completion
action
Phase 1: Determine the required

specification for Obstacles area 1 and 4
(1/1/2018 to 1/3/2018); Phase 2: provide
the required specification to Consultancy
office to determine the implementing entity
(1/3/2018 to 1/3/2019); Phase 3: Determine
the implementing entity and begin to
ANNEX 15 : produce new software for eTOD (1/03/2019
Lack of provision of
5.3.3.4.3 May to 1/12/2019); Phase 4: finish the new
1 - required obstacle data - O Egypt Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.4.5 2014 software and begin to produce eTOD area 4
sets
5.3.3.4.10 (from existing raw data from Cairo
International Airport Company) (1/1/2020 to
1/6/2020); Phase 5 (in parallel with phase
4): begin to produce eTOD area 1 after get
raw data (1/1/2020 to 31/12/2020) Terrain
data sets are provided for Areas 1 and 4.
Terrain data sets for area 2a, TOFP and OLS
are not provided.
(1)
Rationale for non-elimination: “F”= Financial “H”= Human Resources “S”= State (Military/political) “O”= Other unknown causes
APPENDIX A
A-2
Phase 1: Determine the required

specification for Obstacles area 1 and 4
(1/1/2018 to 1/3/2018); Phase 2: provide
the required specification to Consultancy
office to determine the implementing entity
(1/3/2018 to 1/3/2019); Phase 3: Determine
the implementing entity and begin to
ANNEX 15: Para. produce new software for eTOD (1/03/2019
Lack of provision of Jan 2021
5.3.3.3.2 to 1/12/2019); Phase 4: finish the new
2 - required terrain data May - O Egypt Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 software and begin to produce eTOD area 4
sets 2014
5.3.3.3.8 (from existing raw data from Cairo
International Airport Company) (1/1/2020 to
1/6/2020); Phase 5 (in parallel with phase
4): begin to produce eTOD area 1 after get
raw data (1/1/2020 to 31/12/2020) Terrain
data sets are provided for Areas 1 and 4.
Terrain data sets for area 2a, TOFP and OLS
are not provided.
IRAN
Item
No
Priority
action
Based on the Corrective action plan it's

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of AIXM-based Dec divided into two millstones, First; Setup up
1 - - O Iran July 2024 A
2.3.10 and 3.5.3 AIS Database 2007 new software till DEC 2022, and Second
Update the database by End of July 2024.
(1)
Rationale for non-elimination: “F” = Financial “H” = Human Resources “S” = State (Military/political) “O” = Other unknown causes
APPENDIX A
A-3
ANNEX 15 :
Lack of provision of Obstacle data sets are available for Areas 1,
5.3.3.4.3
2 - required obstacle data Jan 2021 - O 4 and 2a. Obstacle data sets for TOFP and Iran July 2024 A
5.3.3.4.5
sets OLS are not provided.
5.3.3.4.10
ANNEX 15 :
Lack of provision of Terrain data sets are available for Areas 1, 4
5.3.3.3.2
3 - required terrain data Jan 2021 - O and 2a. Terrain data sets for TOFP and OLS Iran July 2024 A
5.3.3.3.3
sets are not provided.
5.3.3.3.8
IRAQ
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
ANNEX 4: Para. World Aeronautical May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 - - FHS Iraq Dec 2023 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO 1:1 000 1995 provided by the State
000
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-4
Implementation of
ANNEX 15: Para. geoid undulation Dec Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
2 - - FHO Iraq Dec 2024 A
1.2.1.1 referenced to the 1997 provided by the State
WGS-84 ellipsoid
Lack of
ANNEX 15: Para. QMS Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
3 Implementation of Jan 2003 - FHO Iraq Dec 2023 A
3.6 Implementation provided by the State
QMS
Non-production of
ANNEX 4: Para. Instrument Approach An official letter regarding the status of Mosul
4 - Jan 2003 - FHO Iraq Dec 2021 A
11.2 Chart-ICAO for Mousl Airport was not submitted to ICAO MID office
Intl. Airport
Non provision of pre-

ANNEX 15: Para. flight information Mar Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
5 - - FHO Iraq Dec 2023 A
5.5 service at 2004 provided by the State
international airports
ANNEX 15:
Para.5.3.3.4.3 May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
6 - required obstacle data - O Iraq Dec 2024 A
5.3.3.4.5 2014 provided by the State
sets
5.3.3.4.10
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-5
ANNEX 15: Para.

5.3.3.3.2 May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
7 - required terrain data - O Iraq Dec 2024 A
sets
5.3.3.3.8
JORDAN
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
ANNEX 4: Para. World Aeronautical Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 - Feb 2008 - FH Jordan Dec 2024 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO1:1 000 provided by the State
000
ANNEX 15: Para.

2 - required obstacle data - FH Jordan Dec 2024 A
sets
5.3.3.4.10
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-6
ANNEX 15: Para.

3 - required terrain data - FH Jordan Dec 2024 A
sets
5.3.3.3.8
LEBANON
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
ANNEX 4: Para. World Aeronautical May Corrective Action Plan was provided in
1 - - H Lebanon Dec 2023 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO1:1 000 1995 August 2016.
000
Lack of (USOAP-
ANNEX 15: Para. QMS Corrective Action Plan was provided in
2 Implementation of Jan 2003 CMA H Lebanon Dec 2023 A
3.6 Implementation August 2016.
QMS finding)
ANNEX 15: Lack of provision of

May Corrective Action Plan was provided in
3 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Lebanon Dec 2023 A
2014 August 2016.
5.3.3.4.5 sets
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-7
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

May Corrective Action Plan was provided in
4 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O Lebanon Dec 2023 A
2014 August 2016.
5.3.3.3.3 sets
LIBYA
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
1 - - O Libya Dec 2023 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO 1:1 000 2014 provided by the State
000

May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
2 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Libya Dec 2023 A
2014 provided by the State
5.3.3.4.5 sets

3 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O Libya Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 sets
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of AIXM-based May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
4 - - O Libya Dec 2023 A
2.3.10 and 3.5.3 AIS Database 2014 provided by the State
Lack of (USOAP-
ANNEX 15: Para. QMS May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
5 Implementation of CMA O Libya Dec 2023 A
3.6 Implementation 2014 provided by the State
QMS finding)
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-8
OMAN
Item
No
Priority
action
A contract is going to be signed with a
company specializing in this area for AIP
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of AIXM-based Data Migration. AIM equipment installation
1 - Jul 2005 - O Oman Oct 2023 A
2.3.10 and 3.5.3 AIS Database will be completed by end of February 2017.
The target is to have 70% of the data by
June 2018
Area 1 obstacles are published in AIP Oman
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of ENR 5.4 “Air Navigation (En-Route)
May
2 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Obstacles”. Data originators for obstacles will Oman Dec 2023 A
2014
5.3.3.4.5 sets be consulted for Area 1 obstacle
completeness and update.
An agreement with National survey authority
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of is going to be established to assist for
May
3 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O progressive implementation of terrain Oman Dec 2023 A
2014
5.3.3.3.3 sets datasets for area1. The target is to have the
required data by Dec 2019.
SAUDI ARABIA
Item
No
Priority
action
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-9
Obstacle data sets are provided for Areas 1

ANNEX 15 : and 4. Obstacle data sets for area 2a, TOFP
5.3.3.4.3 Dec and OLS are provided in: OERK, OEDF, Saudi
1 - required obstacle data - O Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.4.5 2021 OEMA, and OEJN. Updates of OEJN terrain Arabia
sets
5.3.3.4.10 digital data sets are expected to be available
and published by: Q1-2021
Terrain data sets are available for Areas 1

ANNEX 15 : and 4. Terrain data sets for area 2a, TOFP
para. 5.3.3.3.2 Dec and OLS are provided in: OERK, OEDF, Saudi
2 - required terrain data - O Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 2021 OEMA, and OEJN. Updates of OEJN terrain Arabia
sets
5.3.3.3.8 digital data sets are expected to be available
and published by: Q1-2021
SUDAN
Item
No
Priority
action
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-10

1 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Sudan Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.4.5 sets

2 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O Sudan Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 sets
SYRIA
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
1 - - FHS Syria Dec 2023 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO1:1 000 1995 provided by the State
000
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-11
Lack of a system for

ANNEX 15: Para May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
2 - AIRAC adherence - FH Syria Dec 2023 A
6.2 1995 provided by the State
monitoring
Implementation of
ANNEX 15: Para. geoid undulation Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
3 - Jan 2003 - FH Syria Dec 2023 A
1.2.1.1 referenced to the provided by the State
WGS-84 ellipsoid.
Lack of (USOAP-
4 Implementation of Jan 2003 CMA FH Syria Dec 2023 A
QMS finding)
Lack of consistency in
AIP information and
ANNEX 15 Para. Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
5 - lack of regular and Jul 2005 - H Syria Dec 2023 A
5.2 and 6.3.1 provided by the State
effective updating of
the AIP.
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of AIXM-based Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
6 - Jul 2005 - FH Syria Dec 2023 A
2.3.10 and 3.5.3 AIS Database provided by the State
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-12

ANNEX 15: Para. flight information Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
7 - Jul 2005 - FH Syria Dec 2021 A
5.5 service at provided by the State

8 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Syria Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.4.5 sets

9 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O Syria Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 sets
YEMEN
Item
No
Priority
action
Non-production of
1 - - F Yemen Dec 2023 B
16.2 Chart – ICAO1:1 000 1995 provided by the State
000
(1)
APPENDIX A
A-13
Lack of a system for

ANNEX 15: Para May Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
2 - AIRAC adherence - HO Yemen Dec 2023 A
monitoring
Non-production of
ANNEX 4: Para. Instrument Approach Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
3 - Jan 2003 - O Yemen Dec 2025 A
11.2 Chart-ICAO for TAIZ provided by the State
Intl. Airport
Lack of
4 Implementation of Jan 2003 - F Yemen Dec 2023 A
QMS

ANNEX 15: Para. flight information Mar Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
5 - - FH Yemen Dec 2023 A
5.5 service at 2004 provided by the State
ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of AIXM-based Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
6 - Jul 2005 - F Yemen Dec 2023 A
2.3.10 and 3.5.3 AIS Database provided by the State
ANNEX 15 : Para Lack of provision of

7 5.3.3.3.2 - required terrain data - O Yemen Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.3.3 sets
ANNEX 15 : Lack of provision of

8 Para. 5.3.3.4.3 - required obstacle data - O Yemen Dec 2023 A
5.3.3.4.5 sets
--------------------
(1)
APPENDIX B
APPENDIX B
Deficiencies in the AOP field
IRAN
Item
No
Priority
Date first Remarks/ Rationale for non- Facilities/ Executing Date of
Requirement Facilities/ Services Description for
reported elimination Services body completion
action
Certification Status for: - Corrective
-MASHHAD/Shahid Hashemi Nejad Intl Implementation of
TEHRAN/ IKIA Intl (OIIE) Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 (OIMM), SHIRAZ/Shiraz Intl (OISS ), Certification of
Nov - BANDAR Abbas /Bandar F not been
1 VOL I: Para. TABRIZ/Tabriz Intl (OITT), TEHRAN/Imam Aerodromes used for Iran Dec 2021 A
2006 Abbas Intl (OIKB) are H formally
1.4 Khomaini Intl (OIIE), BANDAR international
waiting final action for provided by
ABBAS/Bandar Abbas Intl (OIKB) operations
certification very soon the State
IRAQ
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective
Implementation of
Al Najaf/Al Najaf Intl (ORNI), Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 Certification of F
BASRAH/Basrah Intl (ORMM), MOUSL/Mousl Nov not been
1 VOL I: Para. Aerodromes used for - H Iraq Dec 2021 A
Intl (ORBM), SULYMANIYAH/Sulaymaniyah 2006 formally
1.4 international O
Intl (ORSU ) provided by
operations
the State
LEBANON
(1)
APPENDIX B
B-2
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective
Implementation of
Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 Certification of
Nov F not been
1 VOL I: Para. BEIRUT/ Rafic Hariri Intl (OLBA) Aerodromes used for - Lebanon Dec 2021 A
2006 H formally
1.4 international
provided by
operations
the State
LIBYA
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective
Implementation of
Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 Certification of F
BENGHAZI/Benina (HLLB), SEBHA/Sebha May not been
1 VOL I: Para. Aerodromes used for - H Libya Dec 2021 A
(HLLS), TRIPOLI/Tripoli Intl (HLLT) 2015 formally
1.4 international S
provided by
operations
the State
SUDAN
(1)
APPENDIX B
B-3
Item
No
Priority
action
Implementation of
ANNEX 14 Certification of Certification of
May F
1 VOL I: Para. - Nyala/Nyala Airports Aerodromes used for NYALA/Nyala (HSNN) Will - Sudan Dec 2021 A
2015 H
1.4 international be in January 2018
operations
SYRIA
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective
Action Plan has
MID eANP
Apron lighting F not been
1 VOL II Table Damascus int'l Airport Sep 2003 - Syria Dec 2021 A
inadequate H formally
AOP II-1
provided by
the State
Runway surface rough Corrective

MID eANP
and damaged. Runway F Action Plan has
2 VOL II Table Damascus int'l Airport Sep 2003 - Syria Dec 2021 A
markings H not been
AOP II-1
unsatisfactory formally
(1)
APPENDIX B
B-4
provided by
the State
Corrective
Implementation of
Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 ALEPPO/Aleppo Intl (OSAP), DAMASCUS/ Certification of
Nov F not been
3 VOL I: Para. Damascus Intl (OSDI), LATTAKIA /Bassel Aerodromes used for - Syria Dec 2021 A
2006 H formally
1.4 AL-Assad Intl (OSLK) international
provided by
operations
the State
YEMEN
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective
Implementation of
ADEN/Aden Intl (OYAA), HODEIDAH/ Action Plan has
ANNEX 14 Certification of
Hodeidah Intl (OYHD), MUKALLA/Riyan Intl Nov F not been
1 VOL I: Para. Aerodromes used for - Yemen Dec 2021 A
(OYRN), SANA'A/Sana'a Intl (OYSN), TAIZ/ 2006 H formally
1.4 international
Taiz Intl (OYTZ) provided by
operations
the State
--------------------
(1)
APPENDIX C
APPENDIX C
Deficiencies in the ATM Field
IRAN
Item
No
Facilities/ Date first Remarks/ Rationale Executing Date of Priority
Requirement Description Facilities/ Services
Services reported for non-elimination body completion for action
MID ANP TABLE
KUMUN-PAPAR Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID ATS routes A418/UP574 not S
1 - Dec 2006 segment not not been formally provided Iran- UAE Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS implemented O
implemented. by the State
ROUTE NETWORK
Deficiencies in the ATM field
IRAQ
Item
No
MID ANP Table
Segment ALSAN- Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID Iraq- Iran-
1 - ATS route G667 not implemented Sep 2006 ABD not S not been formally provided Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS Kuwait
implemented by the State
ROUTE NETWORK
Development of contingency plan for
implementation in the event of
disruption or potential disruption of
ATS and related supporting services. Contingency Corrective Action Plan has
Annex 11 Para.
2 - The Plan should also address natural Nov 2006 Agreement to be S not been formally provided Iraq Dec 2021 A
2.31
disasters and public health signed with Syria by the State
emergencies. Contingency agreements
should be signed with all adjacent
ACCs.
(1)
APPENDIX C
C-2
MID ANP Table

Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID RAF-BSR segment Iraq- Saudi
3 - ATS route G795 not implemented May 2008 S not been formally provided Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS not implemented Arabia
by the State
ROUTE NETWORK
MID ANP Table

LOTAN-LOVEK Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID
4 - ATS route A424 not implemented May 2008 segment not O not been formally provided Iraq Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS
ROUTE NETWORK
JORDAN
Item
No

not been formally provided
by the State. State comment:
ATS and related supporting services. Contingency
Annex 11 Para. due to political impact in the
1 - The Plan should also address natural Nov 2006 agreements not H Jordan Dec 2021 A
2.31 region Jordan is not able to
disasters and public health signed with Syria.
complete the signature of
contingency agreements with
all adjacent States
ACCs.
(1)
APPENDIX C
C-3
LEBANON
Item
No
Annex 11 Para.
1 - The Plan should also address natural Nov 2006 agreements not S not been formally provided Lebanon Dec 2021 A
2.31
disasters and public health signed with Syria by the State
ACCs.
Lebanon to Corrective Action Plan has
Annex 11 Para Reporting unsatisfactory LHDs to
2 - Dec 2023 coordinate with H not been formally provided Lebanon A
3.3.5.1 MIDRMA
MIDRMA. by the State
LIBYA
Item
No
Annex 11 Para Not reporting the required data to the H
1 - Dec 2013 - not been formally provided Libya Dec 2021 A
3.3.5.1 MIDRMA in a timely manner. O
by the State
implementation in the event of Agreement Corrective Action Plan has
Annex 11 Para. S
2 - disruption or potential disruption of Dec 2014 signed only with not been formally provided Libya Dec 2021 A
2.31 O
ATS and related supporting services. Egypt by the State
The Plan should also address natural
(1)
APPENDIX C
C-4
disasters and public health

ACCs
QATAR
Item
No
Annex 11 Para. Qatar-
1 - The Plan should also address natural Nov 2006 agreements not S not been formally provided Dec 2021 A
2.31 Bahrain
disasters and public health signed with UAE. by the State
ACCs.
SAUDI ARABIA
Item
No
implementation in the event of Contingency
Annex 11 Para. disruption or potential disruption of Agreements not Saudi
1 - Nov 2006 S not been formally provided Dec 2021 A
2.31 ATS and related supporting services. signed with Iraq, Arabia
by the State
The Plan should also address natural Qatar and Sudan.
disasters and public health
(1)
APPENDIX C
C-5

ACCs.
SUDAN
Item
No
Remarks/ Priority
Facilities/ Date first Executing Date of
Requirement Description Rationale for non- Facilities/ Services for
Services reported body completion
elimination action
Contingency
ATS and related supporting services. H Corrective Action Plan has
Annex 11 Para. Agreement
1 - The Plan should also address natural Dec 2014 S not been formally provided Sudan Dec 2021 A
2.31 signed only with
disasters and public health O by the State
Egypt
ACCs.
SYRIA
Item
No
MID ANP Table
Segment DAKWE Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID
1 - ATS route G202 not implemented Dec 1997 - Damascus not S not been formally provided Syria Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS
ROUTE NETWORK
(1)
APPENDIX C
C-6
MID ANP Table

Segments ELEXI- Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID
2 - ATS route UL602 not implemented Dec 2003 DRZ-GAZ not S not been formally provided Syria Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS
ROUTE NETWORK
ATS and related supporting services. Corrective Action Plan has
Annex 11 Para. No signed H
3 - The Plan should also address natural Nov 2006 not been formally provided Syria Dec 2021 A
2.31 agreement yet O
disasters and public health by the State
ACCs.
UAE
Item
No
MID ANP Table
KUMUN-PAPAR Corrective Action Plan has
ATM II-MID-1 MID ATS routes A418/UP574 not
1 - Dec 2006 segment not S not been formally provided Iran- UAE Dec 2021 B
REGION ATS implemented
ROUTE NETWORK
------------------
(1)
APPENDIX D
APPENDIX D
Deficiencies in the CNS field
KUWAIT
Item
No
Priority
action
The Inter-regional Communication

MID eANP VOl Inter-regional Link between Kuwait COM Centre
1 II, Table CNS Communication link with and one of the entry/exit points of Mar 2019 - O - Kuwait Dec 2021 B
II-2 ICAO EUR/NAT Region the ICAO EUR/NAT Region is not
implemented
LEBANON
Item
No
Priority
action
MID eANP VOL ATS Direct Speech Circuit Lebanon

ATS Direct Speech circuit
1 II, Table CNS between Ankara and Beirut is not Mar 2019 - O - and Dec 2021 B
Ankara - Beirut
II-3 implemented Turkey
(1)
APPENDIX D
D-2
LIBYA
Item
No
Priority
action
MID eANP Vol

HF Service in Tripoli is
1 II, Table CNS HF Service Mar 2019 - O - Libya Dec 2021 A
unserviceable
II-4
YEMEN
Item
No
Priority
action
ATS Direct speech Circuits
Corrective Action
MID eANP VOL Sana'a-Asmara, Sana'a- ATS Direct speech circuits are not
Plan has not been Yemen
1 II Table CNS Djibouti, Sana'a- implemented between Sana'a- Oct 1998 - O Dec 2021 A
formally provided and India
II-3 Mogadishu and Sana'a- Mumbai a
by the State
Mumbai
--------------------
(1)
APPENDIX E
APPENDIX E
Deficiencies in the MET field
IRAQ
Item
No
Priority
Date first Remarks/ Rationale Executing Date of
Requirement Facilities/ Services Description Facilities/ Services for
reported for non-elimination body completion
action
Lack of
Annex 3: Para Sep Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 QMS Implementation Implementation of - O Iraq Dec 2022 A
QMS
Annex 3; Para
WAFS forecasts Payment not made on
9.1.4, 9.3.1, Coordinate with the SADIS Manager
required for briefing time and SADIS
2 9.4.1 and Jan 2021 SADIS Provider F (sadis.manager@metoffice.gov.uk) on Iraq Dec 2022 A
and flight service ceased per
Appendix 2, payment to resume SADIS service
documentation contract
2.1.1
JORDAN
Item
No
Priority
action
Annex 3; Para
WAFS forecasts Payment not made on
required for briefing time and SADIS
1 9.4.1 and Jan 2022 SADIS Provider F (sadis.manager@metoffice.gov.uk) on Jordan Dec 2022 A
and flight service ceased per
documentation contract
2.1.1
LEBANON
(1)
APPENDIX E
E-2
Item
No
Priority
action
Lack of
Annex 3: Para Sep (USOAP - CMA Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 QMS Implementation Implementation of O Lebanon Dec 2022 A
2.2 2014 finding) provided by the State
QMS
Annex 3: Para.
WAFS forecasts Payment not made on (METP WG-MOG:
required for briefing time and SADIS May Status of
2 9.4.1 and O (sadis.manager@metoffice.gov.uk) on Lebanon Dec 2022 A
and flight service ceased by 2016 implementation of
documentation contract SADIS FTP)
2.1.1
LIBYA
Item
No
Priority
action
Lack of
1 QMS Implementation Implementation of O Libya Dec 2022 A
QMS
Annex 3, Para SADIS FTP not
WAFS forecasts (METP WG-MOG:
9.1.4, 9.3.1, available due to ICAO MID RO, SADIS Provider and Libya to
required for briefing Status of
2 9.4.1 and necessary hardware Jan 2019 O coordinate on obtaining the necessary Libya Dec 2022 A
and flight implementation of
Appendix 2, and software not hardware and software to retrieve SADIS
documentation SADIS FTP)
2.1.1 available
ICAO RO and Libya will investigate a method
MID eANP VOL HLLB and HLLT HLLB and HLLT METAR ROC Jeddah
Nov to disseminate OPMET data internationally as
3 II, MET Table METAR and 24-hour and 24-hour TAF; monthly OPMET S Libya Dec 2022 A
2021 a contingency arrangement when AFS is not
II-2 TAF; HLLS METAR HLLS METAR not monitoring
available
(1)
APPENDIX E
E-3
available
internationally
SUDAN
Item
No
Priority
action
HSSK and HSPN
HSSK and HSPN
MID eANP VOL METAR and 30-hour ROC Jeddah
METAR and 30-hour Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 II, MET Table TAF; HSOB and HSNN Oct 2021 monthly OPMET S Sudan Dec 2022 A
TAF; HSOB and provided by the State
II-2 METAR not available monitoring
HSNN METAR
internationally
SYRIA
Item
No
Priority
action
MID eANP VOL OSAP METAR and 24-
OSAP METAR and Nov Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
1 II, MET Table hour TAF not available - O Syria Dec 2022 A
24-hour TAF 2013 provided by the State
II-2 internationally
Lack of
2 QMS Implementation Implementation of O Syria Dec 2022 A
QMS
Corrective Action Plan has not been formally
Annex 3; Para SIGMET Non-issuance of Nov (USOAP – CMA
3 O provided by the State Consider bi-lateral Syria Dec 2022 A
7.1 implementation SIGMET information 2017 finding)
arrangement
(1)
APPENDIX E
E-4
YEMEN
Item
No
Priority
action
A contract is being signed with an external
Lack of
Annex 3: Para Sep F quality consultant to assist in establishment &
1 QMS Implementation Implementation of - Yemen Dec 2022 A
2.2 2014 H implementation of QMS in the provision of
QMS
MET service by the end of year 2022.
All OPMET (SIGMET) information is issued
internally but not transmitted internationally
Annex 3; Para SIGMET Non-issuance of Nov
2 - S due to war, considering a reconnection with Yemen Dec 2022 A
7.1 implementation SIGMET information 2017
another MET regional centre other than
Jeddah.
OYAA METAR and 30-
OYAA METAR and
hour TAF; OYHD, All OPMET information is issued internally but
MID eANP VOL 30-hour TAF; OYHD,
OYRN, OYSN, OYTZ Dec annual OPMET O not transmitted internationally due to war,
3 II, MET Table OYRN, OYSN, OYTZ Yemen Dec 2022 A
METAR and 24-hour 2019 monitoring S considering a reconnection with another MET
II-2 METAR and 24-hour
TAF not available regional centre other than Jeddah.
TAF
internationally
-------------------
(1)
APPENDIX F
APPENDIX F
Deficiencies in the SAR field
IRAQ
Item
No
Priority
Facilities/ Date first Remarks/ Rationale for non- Executing Date of
Services reported elimination body completion
action
Corrective Action
Lack of provision of Plan has not been
1 Annex 12 Para. 2.1 - Apr 2012 - O Iraq Dec 2021 A
required SAR services formally provided by
the State
KUWAIT
Item
No
Priority
action
Annex 6 Part I chap. 6 and Non-compliance with Corrective Action

Part II chap. 2 Annex 10, carriage of Emergency Plan has not been
1 ELT Apr 2012 - O Kuwait Dec 2021 A
Vol III, Chap. 5 Annex 12 Locator Transmitter (ELT) formally provided by
para. 2.6.4 requirements the State
LEBANON
Item
No
(1)
APPENDIX F
F-2
Priority
action
Corrective Action
1 Annex 12 Para. 2.1 - Apr 2012 - O Lebanon Dec 2021 A
the State
LIBYA
Item
No
Priority
action

1 - Dec 2014 - HSO Libya Dec 2021 A
Corrective Action
2 Annex 12 Para. 2.1 - Dec 2014 - HSO Libya Dec 2021 A
the State
SYRIA
Item
No
(1)
APPENDIX F
F-3
Priority
action
Corrective Action
1 Annex 12 Para. 2.1 - Apr 2012 - O Syria Dec 2021 A
the State
2 - Apr 2012 - O Syria Dec 2021 A
YEMEN
Item
No
Priority
action
Corrective Action
1 Annex 12 Para. 2.1 - Apr 2012 - O Yemen Dec 2021 A
the State
2 - Apr 2012 - O Yemen Dec 2021 A
-------------------------------
(1)
APPENDIX G
AIR NAVIGATION DEFICIENCIES IN THE THE MID REGION
AIM Total AOP Total ATM Total SAR Total CNS Total MET Total
Priority Rational AIM Priority Rational AOP Priority Rational ATM Priority Rational SAR Priority Rational CNS Priority Rational MET
STATE
U A B F H S O U A B F H S O U A B F H S O U A B F H S O U A B F H S O U A B F H S O
Bahrain 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Egypt 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0
Iran 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Iraq 5 1 4 4 1 5 6 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 4 1 1 1 0 0 2 1 1 2
Jordan 2 1 3 3 3 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Kuwait 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 0
Lebanon 3 1 2 2 4 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 2 2 2
Libya 4 1 5 5 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 3 1 2 3
Oman 3 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0
Qatar 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Saudi
Arabia 2 2 2 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0
Sudan 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 1 1
Syria 8 1 6 7 1 2 9 3 3 3 3 1 2 1 2 1 3 2 2 2 0 0 3 3 3
UAE 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 0
Yemen 7 1 4 2 4 8 1 1 1 1 0 2 2 2 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 3
Total 0 41 6 17 18 2 30 47 0 9 0 9 9 1 1 9 0 10 7 0 5 12 9 17 0 9 0 0 2 2 9 9 0 2 2 0 0 0 4 4 0 14 0 2 1 3 8 14
TOTAL DEFICIENCIES:100
Distribution of Air Navigation deficiencies by field in % Distribution of Air navigation deficiencies by priority in % Reported Deficiencies by field (MIDANPIRG/21 & MIDANPIRG/20)
MET 48
Current (100) MIDANPIRG/20 (116)
14.0% 47
CNS
4.0%
15%
SAR
9.0% AIM
47.0%
19
17
16
15
14
85%
9 9 9 9
ATM
17.0% 4
AOP
9.0% AIM AOP ATM SAR CNS MET
U A B
AIM AOP ATM SAR CNS MET
MIDANPIRG/21 RASG-MID/11-WP/51
APPENDIX H APPENDIX H
Number of Air Navigation Deficiencies by State and by Field

22
3
17
2
3 3
2
12 3
1 1
1
2 2
4 2
1
7 1 9
2 7
2
8
1 1
6 2
1 5 1
4
2 3 1
2
3 1 3 3
2 2
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
0
Bahrain Egypt Iran Iraq Jordan Kuwait Lebanon Libya Oman Qatar Saudi Arabia Sudan Syria UAE Yemen
-3
AOP AIM ATM SAR CNS MET
Deficiencies to be approved by MIDANPIRG/21
Saudi
Bahrain Egypt Iran Iraq Jordan Kuwait Lebanon Libya Oman Qatar Sudan Syria UAE Yemen Total
Arabia
AOP 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 3 0 1 9
AIM 0 2 3 6 3 0 4 5 3 0 2 2 9 0 8 47
ATM 0 0 1 4 1 0 2 2 0 1 1 1 3 1 0 17
SAR 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0 2 9
CNS 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 4
MET 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 3 0 0 0 1 3 0 3 14
TOTAL 0 2 5 14 4 2 11 14 3 1 3 5 20 1 15 100
MIDANPIG/21-WP/51
APPENDIX H H-2
Deficiencies approved by MIDANPIRG/20
Saudi
Arabia
AOP 0 0 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 3 0 1 9
AIM 0 2 3 7 3 0 4 5 3 0 2 2 9 0 8 48
ATM 0 1 1 4 1 1 2 2 0 1 1 1 3 1 0 19
SAR 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 2 0 2 9
CNS 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 16
MET 0 0 0 2 1 0 2 3 0 0 0 1 3 0 3 15
TOTAL 1 4 6 16 6 4 12 14 4 2 4 6 20 2 15 116
Saudi
Arabia
MIDANPIRG/20
deficiencies 1 4 6 16 6 4 12 14 4 2 4 6 20 2 15 116
MIDANPIRG/21
deficiencies 0 2 5 14 4 2 11 14 3 1 3 5 20 1 15 100
25
Number of Air Navigation deficiencies by State
(MIDANPIRG/20 & MIDANPIRG/21) 20 20
20
16
15 15
15 14 14 14
12
11
10
6 6 6
5 5
5 4 4 4 4 4
3 3
2 2 2 2
1 1 1
0
0
Bahrain Egypt Iran Iraq Jordan Kuwait Lebanon Libya Oman Qatar Saudi Arabia Sudan Syria UAE Yemen
MIDANPIRG/20 deficiencies MIDANPIRG/21 deficiencies

WP 51

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

WP 51

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

WP 51

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

MIDANPIRG/21 & RASG-MID/11-WP/51

International Civil Aviation Organization

MIDANPIRG/21 & RASG-MID/11 Meetings

(Abu Dhabi, UAE, 4 – 8 March 2024)

Agenda Item 5.4: Air Navigation Deficiencies

MID AIR NAVIGATION DEFICIENCIES STATUS

(Presented by the Secretariat)

Action by the meeting is at paragraph 3.

- MIDANPIRG/20 and RASG-MID/10 Meetings Report (Muscat, Oman, 14

2.1 The meeting may wish to note that:

graphs presented at Appendices G and H. In particular, it is to be highlighted that:

− The distribution of air navigation deficiencies by field is shown in Appendix G as follows:

− The distribution of air navigation deficiencies by priority is shown in Appendix G as follows:

3. ACTION BY THE MEETING

3.1 The meeting is invited to:

a) review, update and approve the air navigation deficiencies at Appendices A, B, C,

b) review the analyses in Appendices G and H; and

c) urge States to:

i. implement the provisions of the MIDANPIRG/15 Conclusion 15/35 and

ii. submit CAP for each deficiency; and

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Phase 1: Determine the required

Phase 1: Determine the required

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Based on the Corrective action plan it's

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Non provision of pre-

ANNEX 15: Para.

Deficiencies in the AIM field

ANNEX 15: Para.

ANNEX 15: Para.

Deficiencies in the AIM field

ANNEX 15: Lack of provision of

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

Deficiencies in the AIM field

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Obstacle data sets are provided for Areas 1

Terrain data sets are available for Areas 1

Deficiencies in the AIM field

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Lack of a system for

Non provision of pre-

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

ANNEX 15: Para. Lack of provision of

Deficiencies in the AIM field

Lack of a system for

Non provision of pre-

ANNEX 15 : Para Lack of provision of

ANNEX 15 : Lack of provision of

Deficiencies in the AOP field

Deficiencies in the AOP field

Deficiencies in the AOP field

Deficiencies in the AOP field

Deficiencies in the AOP field

Deficiencies in the AOP field