J Urology 2011 08 062
J Urology 2011 08 062
Empirical Treatment of
Low-level Leukocytospermia With
Doxycycline in Male Infertility Patients
Alaa Hamada, Ashok Agarwal, Reecha Sharma, Dan B. French, Ahmed Ragheb, and
Edmund S. Sabanegh, Jr.
OBJECTIVE To design a retrospective study in which infertile men with a seminal leukocyte count of 0.2-1 ⫻ 106
white blood cells [WBC]/mL were given doxycycline to examine the potential benefits of the
treatment on the improvement of semen parameters and natural pregnancy outcomes. It has been
reported that even low-level leukocytospermia (0.2-1.0 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL) could be harmful to
male reproductive function and achievement of pregnancy.
METHODS The records of 223 patients were reviewed and 61 patients were identified with a leukocyte count
of 0.2-1.0 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL. Of the 61 patients, 27 presented before 2006 and were not routinely
treated for this level of leukocytospermia. These patients were our historic control population.
Since 2006, 34 patients met these criteria and received empirical antibiotic therapy (treatment
group).
RESULTS The treatment of low-level leukocytospermia with doxycycline did not show statistically signif-
icant differences in the semen parameters among the treated patients. Although the therapy did
not alter the semen parameters, low-level leukocytospermia resolved in 56% of the treatment
group, well above the spontaneous resolution rate of 25% observed in historic controls. The
natural pregnancy rate among the treatment group (15 of 32 [47%]) was significantly greater than
that among the controls (5 of 25 [20%]). The odds ratio for pregnancy outcome was 3.7 (95%
confidence interval 1.1-11.7; P ⫽ .04).
CONCLUSION Low-level leukocytospermia might have deleterious effects on male fertility, and antibiotic
therapy for such a condition might improve the natural pregnancy rate among infertile
couples. UROLOGY 78: 1320 –1325, 2011. © 2011 Elsevier Inc.
T
he pathologic role and origin of leukocytospermia mal digital rectal examination findings, or there are 2
in male factor infertility and the indications for disordered ejaculate signs, such as leukocytospermia or
treatment remain controversial. Leukocytes are bacteriospermia.2 Infertility due to MAGI is attributed to
present in the semen of both fertile and infertile men, direct microbial damage to the sperm or indirect injury to
even in the absence of florid genital infections. In addi- the sperm through increased activated seminal leukocyte
tion, leukocytospermia might be a presenting feature of release of cytokines and reactive oxygen species (ROS).
prostatitis, seminal vesiculitis, or epididymitis. However, However, the correlation between leukocytospermia
it has been described in 10%-20% of infertile men pre- and bacteriospermia is controversial, particularly in
senting for fertility evaluation without clinical signs of asymptomatic men.3-5 Specific bacterial pathogens and
accessory glands infection, a phenomenon sometimes viral etiology have been identified in only 40%-54.9%
termed “silent accessory gland infection.”1 and 11% of leukocytospermic men, respectively.3,5 To
Male accessory gland infection (MAGI) is defined by complicate the picture, Lackner et al3 identified patho-
the World Health Organization (WHO) when there are genic bacteria in the absence of leukocytospermia in
2 clinical features suggestive of MAGI, such as a history 48.2% of infertile men. Furthermore, the presence of
of urinary tract infection, epididymitis, or sexually trans- bacteriospermia might represent contamination or nor-
mitted disease, and/or abnormal physical signs, such as mal urethral colonization, rather than a real infection,6
thickened or tender epididymis or vas deferens or abnor- and the value of semen culture to identify the pathogenic
bacteria is, therefore, limited. Leukocytospermia in the
From the Center for Reproductive Medicine and Glickman Urological and Kidney absence of infection can be attributed to other causes,
Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio such as smoking, marijuana use, heavy alcohol use, and
Reprint requests: Edmund Sabanegh, Jr., M.D., Department of Urology, Cleveland
Clinic, Q100, 9500 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44195. E-mail: sabanee@ccf.org clomiphene therapy. The effect of leukocytospermia on
Submitted: June 1, 2011, accepted (with revisions): August 30, 2011 the semen parameters and pregnancy outcomes is still
1320 © 2011 Elsevier Inc. 0090-4295/11/$36.00
All Rights Reserved doi:10.1016/j.urology.2011.08.062
under debate. Although some studies have demonstrated achievement of pregnancy. We designed a retrospective
a beneficial effect of leukocytospermia on sperm func- study in which infertile men with a leukocyte count of
tion,7 considerable evidence from other studies has 0.2-1 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL were given empirical doxycycline
shown detrimental effects on the semen parameters and therapy to examine the potential benefits of therapy on
sperm function tests, such as the hamster egg fertilization the semen parameters and natural pregnancy outcomes.
test.8-10 Alternatively, no significant relationship be-
tween leukocytospermia and poor semen quality or preg-
MATERIAL AND METHODS
nancy outcomes has been found in other studies.6
The WHO has arbitrarily defined leukocytospermia as Subjects
⬎1 million white blood cells (WBC)/mL of semen,11 and Since September 2006, it has been our practice to treat men
most of the previously mentioned studies have used this presenting for fertility assessment who have a level of seminal
level as the pathologic threshold. This threshold level is leukocytes ⱖ0.2 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL with empirical antibiotic
therapy. The standard therapy is a 3-week course of doxycycline
considered a presumptive indicator of MAGI. However,
100 mg orally taken twice daily. Semen analysis and seminal
seminal leukocyte levels of 0.2-1.0 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL have leukocyte levels are reassessed 3 months after therapy completion.
been associated with significantly greater bacterial counts We conducted a retrospective review of the records of male
than lower leukocyte levels.4 Evidence is growing that patients presenting to our Center for Male Fertility for fertility
low-level leukocytospermia (LLLC) is also detrimental to assessment during the period from September 2006 to February
sperm quality and fertility. Thomas et al9 have demon- 2008 to identify those with seminal leukocyte levels of 0.2-1.0 ⫻
strated that the percentage of normal sperm morphology 106 WBC/mL. The Cleveland Clinic institutional review board
varies inversely with the concentration of seminal leu- approved the present study. A control group was obtained by
kocytes, with a significant difference present using a reviewing the records of consecutive patients with seminal leuko-
cyte levels of 0.2-1.0 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL for a period immediately
threshold value of 0.5 million WBC/mL. Seminal leuko-
preceding the practice of routine treatment of LLLC. The men
cyte levels as low as 0.1 ⫻ 106 WBC/mL have been with the clinical symptoms or signs of MAGI, varicocele, and
associated with elevated ROS levels and increased sperm hormonal disturbances were excluded from the study. Patients
DNA damage.12,13 were also screened with standard urinalysis and excluded if
Because of these findings, recent reports have sug- noted to have pyuria or other evidence of urinary tract infec-
gested that LLLC less than the WHO’s empirical value tion. In each couple, the female partner was fully evaluated, and
might induce sperm damage and support lowering the cutoff female factor infertility was excluded.
value for the diagnosis of leukocytospermia to 0.2 ⫻ 106
leukocyte/mL.3,4,14 This value was considered the cutoff for Semen Analysis
leukocytospermia in our study. Computer-assisted semen analysis was performed in the androl-
The optimal therapy for leukocytospermia remains ogy laboratory using a Hamilton-Thorne-Integrated Visual Op-
controversial. Several investigators have empirically used tical System, version 10, semen analyzer (Hamilton Thorne
antibiotic therapy in infertile men with traditional leu- Biosciences, Beverly, MA). A 5-L aliquot was loaded onto a
counting chamber for each semen parameter analyzed and 4-10
kocytospermia with variable success. Some studies found
fields were examined by computed-assisted semen analysis and
no improvement in the semen parameters after antibiotic manually. The semen parameters are reported according to
therapy.15,16 Others have shown a reduction in the sem- 1999 WHO criteria,11 with an additional assessment of mor-
inal leukocyte level and ROS levels after antibiotic ther- phology using the strict criteria of Kruger et al22 and were
apy17 and an increased rate of conception.18 Antibiotic recorded for each patient before and after treatment.
therapy for leukocytospermia has been shown to improve
the pregnancy rates, even among infertile men with other- Seminal Leukocyte Quantification
wise normal semen parameters.19 Furthermore, Berger et To distinguish the WBCs from immature sperm, the seminal
al20 has demonstrated that doxycycline improves the sperm leukocyte levels were assessed with immunoperoxidase staining
fertilizing potential in the hamster egg penetration assay. (Endtz test).23 Peroxidase-positive leukocytes stain brown and
Doxycycline is a commonly prescribed medication for were counted using a Makler’s counting chamber (Sefi Medical,
the treatment of MAGI owing to its excellent penetra- Haifa, Israel) under bright-field microscopy.
tion into prostatic fluid and semen. Although doxycy-
cline inhibits protein synthesis, it appears to be relatively Outcomes Analysis
nontoxic to spermatogenesis. In addition to its wide The pregnancy outcomes were obtained by chart review. If this
antimicrobial spectrum, doxycycline has a direct effect information was not available in the chart, a telephone inter-
on leukocytes. It inhibits leukocyte chemotaxis and view was conducted. Pregnancies resulting from in vitro fertil-
ization and intrauterine insemination were counted as treat-
phagocytosis,21 interferes with the activation of peroxi-
ment failures. Only natural pregnancies occurring within 6
dase system in seminal leukocytes, and hinders the gen- months of treatment were attributed to treatment success. Res-
eration and release of ROS from leukocytes, the most olution of leukocytospermia was defined as a follow-up Endtz
significant source of ROS in semen.8 test measuring ⬍0.2 million WBC/mL.
We have assumed that even LLLC, such as 0.2 ⫻ 106 Statistical analysis was performed using S-plus, version 7.0,
WBC/mL can be detrimental to sperm function and the software (Insightful, Seattle, WA). The paired t test was used to
sults are in consistent with other studies that used em- ethoprim/sulfamethoxasole to be effective therapy for
pirical antibiotic therapy in infertile men with traditional traditional leukocytospermia, noting no change in semen
leukocytospermia. Comhaire et al,26 in 1986, treated parameters after treatment. Erel et al15 similarly con-
leukocytospermic patients with doxycycline and observed cluded that antibiotics (doxycycline and/or ceftriaxone)
no differences in the semen parameters. Also, Yanush- did not treat leukocytospermia and noted no change in
polsky et al16 found neither doxycycline nor trim- semen parameters after treatment. Finally, Krisp et al27