Applied Mathematics and Mechanics
Applied Mathematics and Mechanics
Applied Mathematics and Mechanics
1 Introduction
Many efforts have been devoted in recent years to study propagation of elastic waves in
phononic crystals (PCs)[1–2] . The PC is an artificial crystal in which materials and structures
∗ Received Mar. 23, 2016 / Revised Aug. 7, 2016
Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos.11272126,
51435006, and 51121002) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities
(Nos. HUST:2016JCTD114 and HUST:2015TS121)
† Corresponding author, E-mail: huhp@hust.edu.cn
412 Shan JIANG, Longxiang DAI, Hao CHEN, Hongping HU, Wei JIANG, and Xuedong CHEN
are periodically arranged. The elastic waves are modulated by the periodic materials and struc-
tures of the PC, and thus elastic waves within some frequency ranges named band gaps are
forbidden or attenuated to spread. The main interest for proposing new PCs is to explore
their potential applications in engineering, such as resonators[3], frequency filters[4] , vibration
isolator[5], transducers[6] . Meanwhile, micro-vibration on the order of nanometers poses chal-
lenges for the improving precision of ultra-precision machine tools and metrology equipment[7] .
Owing to the band gap, PCs are expected to be used for the micro-vibration isolation.
However, to be a vibration isolator of the ultra-precision mechanical system, a PC still
needs to be improved on the following properties: (i) miniaturization; (ii) low-frequency band
gap; (iii) broad band gap; (iv) frequency range of band gap can be tuned; (v) strong vibration
attenuation in band gap for a PC with a few unit cells[8–9] .
Based on the generation mechanisms, band gaps are divided into Bragg band gap and locally
resonant band gap[10] . Many studies have shown that the spatial modulation must be of the
same order as the wavelength in the Bragg band gaps. This would require a big size PC to
isolate low-frequency vibration. In other words, a normal size PC only can bring Bragg band
gaps with high frequencies, which are far beyond the mechanical vibration frequency. However,
for a PC with the same size, locally resonant band gaps can appear in a frequency range of two
orders lower than the Bragg band gaps[10–12] . Although with the merit of low-frequency, locally
resonant band gaps are too narrow to make the PCs as low-frequency sound and vibration
shelters in engineering. Recently, smart materials and structures have been applied in PCs
to control the propagation of vibration[13–14] . By replacing a commonly heavy mass-spring
oscillator, a piezoelectric patch and a resonant shunting circuit act as an inductor-capacitor
oscillator to compose a locally resonant unit. Hence, periodic piezoelectric structures shunted
by electrical resonant circuits can also produce locally resonant band gaps.
Besides the light weight, the piezoelectric PCs have another significant advantage that the
band gaps can be easily tuned by the circuits without necessity to reconfigure the structure. To
obtain low-frequency band gaps, researchers have proposed different piezoelectric PCs. Wang
et al.[15] experimentally investigated low-frequency locally resonant band gaps induced by ar-
rays of resonant shunts with Antoniou’s circuit. Thorp et al.[16] applied a periodic array of
resistor-inductor-shunted piezos-mounted on fluid-loaded shells to create band gaps. Chen et
al.[17] studied propagation and attenuation of elastic wave in plates with periodic arrays of
shunted piezo-patches. Shu et al.[18] presented a circular plate PC placing periodically with
piezoelectric rings along the radial direction. Among these proposed PCs, piezoelectric bi-
morph beam and the bending mode are the most commonly used structure and operational
mode respectively[19–21] .
Furthermore, compared with a long straight beam, a folding structure owns a low natural
frequency but with a smaller size. Hence the folding structure is always employed by the
low-frequency actuator or isolator[22–23] . But to the best of our knowledge, little research has
been done on the PCs with folding structures. We propose a new piezoelectric PC with a
folding structure in which bimorphs are joined by masses periodically. The folding structure
extends the propagation path of the elastic wave, which generates low frequency band gaps
while the structure size remains quite small. Coupled extensional and flexural motion of the
folding structure is studied. The band structure and vibration transmission are calculated
by transfer matrix method. Vibration transmission is further examined by the finite element
method (FEM) to confirm the existence of band gaps predicted by the transfer matrix method.
We aim to reduce the center frequency of the band gap, broaden the band gap and enhance the
vibration attenuation.
The paper is organized as follows: the mathematical model of the new PC is established in
Section 2. A theoretical analysis on the structure is conducted, and analytic solution is obtained
in Section 3. The numerical results are presented in Section 4. Finally, some conclusions are
drawn in Section 5.
Folding beam-type piezoelectric phononic crystal with low-frequency and broad band gap 413
Consider flexural motion of the bimorph in the x3 direction and the extensional motion in
the x1 direction. From the Euler beam theory on laminated beam in coupled vibration between
extension and flexure, the axial strain S1 (x1 , t) is expressed as
where u3 (x1 , t) and u1 (x1 , t) represent flexural and extensional displacements of the bimorph
respectively.
The constitutive relations of the bimorph are
T1 = s−1 −1
11 (−x3 u3,11 + u1,1 ) − s11 d31 E3 ,
−1
D = s11 d31 (−x3 u3,11 + u1,1 ) + ε̄33 E3 in c < |x3 | < c + h, (2)
3
T1 = ES1 = E (−x3 u3,11 + u1,1 ) in |x3 | < c,
414 Shan JIANG, Longxiang DAI, Hao CHEN, Hongping HU, Wei JIANG, and Xuedong CHEN
where s11 is axial elastic compliance constant in fixed 2 electric field, d31 piezoelectric strain
2
constant, ε33 dielectric constant, ε̄33 = ε33 1 − k31 , k31 = d231 (ε33 s11 ), E Young’s modulus
of the host beam of the bimorph. D3 is electric displacement, T1 axial stress. The electric fields
E3 in piezoelectric patches are[24]
V d h
E3 = − + 31 u3,11 x3 −
+ c , c 6 x3 6 h + c,
h s11 ε̄33 2 (3)
V d31 h
E3 =
+ u3,11 x3 + + c , − h + c 6 x3 6 −c.
h s11 ε̄33 2
The bending moment, shear force, and axial force are given by
R
M = A x3 T1 dA = −D11 u3,11 + D12 V,
Q13 =R M,1 = −D11 u3,111 , (4)
N = A T1 dA = D21 u1,1 ,
3 .
where D11 = DE + Dp1 + Dp2 with DE = 2bc3 E 3, Dp1 = 2s−1 − c3 3, and
11 b c + h
Dp2 = −s−1 2 3 2 2 −1
11 k̄31 bh 6, k̄31 = d31 ε̄33 s11 , D12 = 2s11 d31 G h with G=(h + 2c) hb/2, and D21 =
2b(cE +hs−111 ). V is the voltage of top and bottom electrodes of the bimorph, and two electrodes
in the middle are grounded.
From (2) and (3), the electrical displacement of two piezoelectric patches of the bimorph
can be obtained
V h
D3 = − ε̄33 + s−1
d
11 31 1,1u − s −1
d u
11 31 3,11 + c , c 6 x3 6 h + c,
h 2 (5)
D3 = V ε̄33 + s−1 d31 u1,1 + s−1 d31 u3,11 h + c , − h + c 6 x3 6 −c.
11 11
h 2
The charges on the top and bottom electrodes of the bimorph can be written as
Rl h
T −1
Q e = −b 0 D 3 dx 1 = b s 11 d 31 + c u 3,1 l, t − u 3,1 0, t
2
V
−1
−s11 d31 u1 l, t − u1 0, t + ε̄33 l ,
h (6)
Rl h
B −1
Q = b D dx = b s d + c u l, t − u 0, t
3 1 11 31 3,1 3,1
e 0 2
−1
V
+s11 d31 u1 l, t − u1 0, t + ε̄33 l .
h
The current can be calculated as
I = − Q̇T e + Q̇e .
B
(7)
where superscripts (n) represent nth periodic unit. The mass is made of the same material as
the host beam, and hence m0 = ρa1 a2 b. Jc = m0 a21 + a22 12 is centroidal moment of inertia
of the mass. The relationship between displacements of the centroid of the left mass and the
bimorph I is
a
2
(n)I (n)I
uC1
1 = u1 (0, t) + − c u3,1 (0, t) ,
2 (13)
uC1 = u(n)I (0, t) − a1 u(n)I (0, t) .
3 3
2 3,1
Similarly, the rigid body motion of the right mass is governed by
(n)I (n)II (n)II
u1 (l, t) = u1 (l, t) + (a2 − 2c) u3,1 (l, t) ,
(n)I (n)II
u3 (l, t) = u3 (l, t) ,
(n)I (n)II
u3,1 (n)I(l, t) = u3,1 (l, t) ,
− N (l, t) + N (n)II (l, t) = m0 üC21 , (14)
− Q (n)I (n)II C2
13 (l, t) + Q13 (l, t) = m0 ü3 ,
a1 (n)I
(n)II
(n)I (n)II
M (l, t) + M (l, t) + Q13 (l, t) + Q13 (l, t)
a 2
2 (n)II
− c N (n)II (l, t) − N (n)I (l, t) = Jc ü3,1 (l, t) ,
+
2
where
a
uC2 (n)II 2 (n)II
1 = u1 (l, t) + − c u3,1 (l, t) ,
2 a1 (15)
uC2 (n)II (n)II
3 = u3 (l, t) + u3,1 (l, t) .
2
Additionally, for a PC in engineering with a finite periodicity number, the boundary conditions
are considered to calculate vibration transmission. On one end of the proposed PC, a harmonic
displacement excitation with amplitude A is considered at the x3 direction. As a response end,
the other end is free. Therefore, boundary conditions on two ends of the proposed PC with
periodicity number J are
(
(1)I
N (1)I (0, t) = 0, M (1)I (0, t) = 0, u3 (0, t) = Aeiωt ,
(J)II (16)
N (J)II (0, t) = 0, M (J)II (0, t) = 0, Q13 (0, t) = 0.
Substitution of (4) and (19) into (14) yields the matrix form of the continuity conditions
between the undetermined constants of two bimorphs in an arbitrary nth unit
(n) (n)
K1 φ1 = K2 φ2 , (20)
(n) (n)
where K1 and K2 are coefficients matrices of φ1 and φ2 respectively.
h iT
(n) (n) (n) (n) (n) (n) (n)
φj = Aj1 Aj2 Aj3 Aj4 Aj5 Aj6 , (21)
where H1 and H2 are also coefficients matrices. From (20) and (22) transmission relationship
between undetermined constants of bimorphs II in two neighboring units becomes
(n) (n−1)
φ2 = T φ2 , (23)
where transfer matrix T = K2−1 K1 H1−1 H2 . From the Bloch theorem, we have
(n) (n−1)
φ2 = eika φ2 , (24)
where k is wave vector, and a = 2l is the lattice constant of the PC. From (23) and (24),
nontrivial solutions may exist if the determinant satisfies
where I is an identity matrix. Thus, the band structure of the proposed PC is obtained. For a
given ω, (25) determines 6 roots of k. These 6 roots correspond to 6 mode functions with respect
to x1 : 2 extensional modes with trigonometric functions, 2 flexural modes with trigonometric
functions, and 2 flexural modes with exponential functions. The real part of k is the wave
number, which can be used to describe phenomena of wave propagation. When k is a pure
real number but not 0 or π/(2a), a flexural wave can propagate without attenuation. On the
other hand, a complex k means the frequency of the wave lies in a band gap. The attenuation
constant µ is defined by the product of the imaginary part of k and lattice constant a, which
indicates the attenuation of the amplitude when the elastic wave propagates from one period
to the next.
In order to illustrate the vibration attenuation characteristic of the proposed PC,we choose
epoxy as the material of the host beams and the masses, and PZT-5H as the material of
piezoelectric patches of the bimorph. The material parameters of the epoxy are: density ρ =
1 185 kg/m3 , Young’s modulus E= 4.35 GPa. PZT-5H has the following material parameters:
ρ′ =7 500 kg/m3 , s11 =1.65×10−11 m2 /N, d31 =–2.74×10−10 C/N, and ε33 =3.01×10−8 F/m.
The geometrical parameters of the unit cell are: l =60 mm, b = 10 mm, h=0.2 mm, c=1.5 mm,
a1 =10 mm, a2 =10 mm. The inductance and resistance of shunting circuits are L =0.06 H and
R =1 Ω. These parameters are fixed unless otherwise stated.
Firstly, the shunting circuits are shorted to consider the effect of the coupling vibration
between extension and flexure on band structure. The band structure of the folding beam-type
418 Shan JIANG, Longxiang DAI, Hao CHEN, Hongping HU, Wei JIANG, and Xuedong CHEN
PC is illustrated in Fig. 4 as frequency versus wave numbers Re(k) and attenuation constants
µ. As we know, a nontrivial attenuation constant µ means the corresponding frequency locates
in a band gap. It is observed from Fig. 4 (b) that frequency ranges below 4 000 Hz all are band
gaps. In addition, these band gaps belong to evanescent wave since the wave number is also not
equal to 0 or π/(2a). In this case, flexural wave and extensional wave spread along the folding
beam-type structure as transverse wave and longitudinal wave respectively. However, we still
cannot tell which kind of wave a certain dispersion curve belongs to.
Fig. 4 Frequency versus (a) wave number Re(k) and (b) attenuation constant µ of folding beam-type
PC
Fig. 5 (a) Attenuation constants µ and (b) transmission factors versus frequency of folding beam-type
PC
In order to validate the theoretical model, the transmission characteristic of the folding
beam-type PC is also calculated by the FEM. The FEM is carried using the ANSYS software.
SOLID45 is chosen as three-dimensional element for the host beams and masses. SOLID5 is
chosen for piezoelectric patches with keyopt(1) =3 so that SOLID5 has a voltage degree of
freedom. The resistors and inductors in the shunting circuits are defined by element CIRCU94
with keyopt(1) =0 and 1, respectively. Harmonic response analysis is conducted. Convergent
solutions are obtained by refining the mesh. The comparison on the transmission factor curves
between theoretical result and FEM result is presented in Fig. 6. We can find that the theoretical
results are in agreement with those of FEM.
As the next step, we investigate the influence of parameters of resonant shunting circuits
on the locally resonant band gaps (abbreviated by LR BGs in Fig. 7). First, the effects of
shunting inductances on transmission factor are shown in Fig. 7. The frequency of the locally
resonant band gap decreases with increasing of the inductance. It indicates that a required
locally resonant band gap can be achieved conveniently by just tuning the inductances without
necessity to reconfigure the structure. Second, we study the effect of the resistance on band
gaps by fixing the inductance L = 0.06 H. Figure 8 illustrates the transmission factor versus
frequency for different resistances. The transmission factor amplitude of the frequency within
the locally resonant band gap is reduced dramatically by decreasing the resistance. But for
both locally resonant and Bragg band gaps, the frequencies almost have no change with the
resistance. It is also worth mentioning that the transmission factors are all less than zero for
the frequency from 1 384 Hz to 2 204 Hz when the resistance increases to 100 Ω. Thus, the
frequencies above 369 Hz all become band gap since the first two Bragg band gaps are joined
by the locally resonant band gap.
Finally, we investigate the effect of geometrical parameters on vibration transmission. Trans-
mission factors versus frequency with different bimorph lengths l are illustrated in Fig. 9. It
420 Shan JIANG, Longxiang DAI, Hao CHEN, Hongping HU, Wei JIANG, and Xuedong CHEN
can be seen that frequencies of locally resonant band gap and the Bragg band gap both de-
crease with increase of bimorph length l. Moreover, when the length l increases, the Bragg
band gap becomes narrower, and the attenuation is slightly enhanced. The minimum value of
transmission factor reaches –134 dB. But it has little effect on the width of locally resonant
band gap.
5 Conclusions
References
[1] Wei, C. Q., Yan, Z. Z., Zheng, H., and Zhang, C. Z. RBF collocation method and stability analysis
for phononic crystals. Applied Mathematics and Mechanics (English Edition), 37(5), 627–638
(2016) DOI 10.1007/s10483-016-2076-8
[2] Shi, Z. J., Wang, Y. S., and Zhang, C. Z. Band structure calculations of in-plane waves in two-
dimensional phononic crystals based on generalized multipole technique. Applied Mathematics and
Mechanics (English Edition), 36(5), 557–580 (2015) DOI 10.1007/s10483-015-1938-7
[3] Liu, T. W., Tsai, Y. C., Lin, Y. C., Ono, T., Tanaka, S., and Wu, T. T. Design and fabrication
of a phononic-crystal-based Love wave resonator in GHz range. AIP Advances, 4, 124201 (2014)
[4] Lee, I. K., Kim, Y. J., Oh, J. H., and Kim, Y. Y. One-dimensional broadband phononic crystal
filter with unit cells made of two non-uniform impedance-mirrored elements. AIP Advances, 3,
022105 (2013)
[5] Dai, L. X., Jiang, S., Lian, Z. Y., Hu, H. P., and Chen, X. D. Locally resonant band gaps achieved
by equal frequency shunting circuits of piezoelectric rings in a periodic circular plate. Journal of
Sound and Vibration, 337, 150–160 (2015)
[6] Yantchev, V. A transversely coupled phononic surface acoustic wave transducer. Applied Physics
Letters, 104, 103503–103503-3 (2014)
[7] Chen, X. D., Chen, H., Luo, X., Ye, Y. X., Hu, Y. T., and Xu, J. Q. Air vortices and nano-vibration
of aerostatic bearings. Tribology Letters, 42, 179–183 (2011)
[8] Yan, T., Pu, H., Chen, X., Li, Q., and Xu, C. Integrated hybrid vibration isolator with feed-
forward compensation for fast high-precision positioning X/Y tables. Measurement Science and
Technology, 21, 065901 (2010)
[9] Aggogeri, F., Al-Bender, F., Brunner, B., Elsaid, M., Mazzola, M., Merlo, A., Ricciardi, D., de la
O Rodriguez, M., and Salvi, E. Design of piezo-based AVC system for machine tool applications.
Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 36, 53–65 (2013)
[10] Liu, Z., Zhang, X., Mao, Y., Zhu, Y., Yang, Z., Chan, C., and Sheng, P. Locally resonant sonic
materials. Science, 289, 1734–1736 (2000)
422 Shan JIANG, Longxiang DAI, Hao CHEN, Hongping HU, Wei JIANG, and Xuedong CHEN
[11] Goffaux, C., Sánchez-Dehesa, J., Yeyati, A. L., Lambin, P., Khelif, A., Vasseur, J., and Djafari-
Rouhani, B. Evidence of Fano-like interference phenomena in locally resonant materials. Physical
Review Letters, 88, 225502 (2002)
[12] Goffaux, C., and Sánchez-Dehesa, J. Two-dimensional phononic crystals studied using a varia-
tional method: application to lattices of locally resonant materials. Physical Review B, 67, 144301
(2003)
[13] Spadoni, A., Ruzzene, M., and Cunefare, K. Vibration and wave propagation control of plates
with periodic arrays of shunted piezoelectric patches. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and
Structures, 20, 979–990 (2009)
[14] Casadei, F., Ruzzene, M., Dozio, L., and Cunefare, K. Broadband vibration control through peri-
odic arrays of resonant shunts: experimental investigation on plates. Smart Materials & Structures,
19, 015002 (2010)
[15] Wang, G., Chen, S. B., and Wen, J. H. Low-frequency locally resonant band gaps induced by
arrays of resonant shunts with Antoniou’s circuit: experimental investigation on beams. Smart
Materials & Structures, 20, 015026 (2011)
[16] Thorp, O., Ruzzene, M., and Baz, A. Attenuation of wave propagation in fluid-loaded shells with
periodic shunted piezoelectric rings. Smart Materials & Structures, 14, 594–604 (2005)
[17] Chen, S. B., Wang, G., Wen, J. H., and Wen, X. S. Wave propagation and attenuation in plates
with periodic arrays of shunted piezo-patches. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 332, 1520–1532
(2013)
[18] Shu, H., Zhao, L., Shi, X., Liu, W., Shi, D., and Kong, F. Torsional wave propagation in a circular
plate of piezoelectric radial phononic crystals. Journal of Applied Physics, 118, 184904 (2015)
[19] Airoldi, L. and Ruzzene, M. Wave propagation control in beams through periodic multi-branch
shunts. Journal of Intelligent Material Systems and Structures, 22, 1567–1579 (2011)
[20] Jiang, S., Lian, Z. Y., Dai, L. X., Hu, H. P., and Xue, H. Band gap frequencies of piezoelectric
phononic crystals tuned by aixal force. 2014 Symposium on Piezoelectricity, Acoustic Waves, and
Device Applications, Beijing (2014)
[21] Wang, G., Wang, J. W., Chen, S. B., and Wen, J. H. Vibration attenuations induced by periodic
arrays of piezoelectric patches connected by enhanced resonant shunting circuits. Smart Materials
& Structures, 20, 125019 (2011)
[22] Kamesh, D., Pandiyan, R., and Ghosal, A. Passive vibration isolation of reaction wheel dis-
turbances using a low frequency flexible space platform. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 331,
1310–1330 (2012)
[23] Kawakubo, T., Nagano, T., Nishigaki, M., and Abe, K. RF-MEMS tunable capacitor with 3 V
operation using folded beam piezoelectric bimorph actuator. Journal of Microelectromechanical
Systems, 15, 1759–1765 (2006)
[24] Wang, Y. J., Lian, Z. Y., Wang, J., and Hu, H. P. Analysis of a piezoelectric power harvester
with adjustable frequency by precise electric field method. IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics
Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control, 60, 2154–2161 (2013)