Social and Cultural World Unit Booklets 1-3
Social and Cultural World Unit Booklets 1-3
Social and Cultural World Unit Booklets 1-3
1
THE FIVE KEY CONCEPTS
Persons
Every person is a unique individual who develops in a social and environmental setting in which
he or she is influenced by, and interacts with, other persons and groups. Communication, the
sharing of values and beliefs, and cooperation are major interactions. The identity achieved by
each individual is the result of interactions at the micro, meso and macro levels of society.
Examples include: Socialisation. Self and Identity, Human Rights and Obligations, Individual
growth and development, Communication, Personality, Life Style, Rights of passage, Alienation.
Society
Society is made up of people, groups, networks, institutions, organisations and systems. These
aspects of society may include local, national, regional and international patterns of relationships
and organisation. People belong to informal and formal groups, and within and between these
groups there are patterns of interactions that contribute to unique cultures. Examples include:
Groups and institutions, Class and Status, Authority/Influence and Power, Conflict and Co-
operation, Kinship, Social Networks, Peer Groups, Class, Race & Ethnicity, Community, Roles.
Discrimination, Socialisation.
Culture
Culture refers to the shared knowledge, attitudes and behaviours that give each society its
coherence, identity and distinctive way of life. Culture is demonstrated by the beliefs, customs,
values, norms, rules, laws, governance, arts, technologies and artefacts that people generate
and use as they interpret meaning from their world and solve present and future problems.
Culture is dynamic and undergoes change, and is therefore not static. Examples include:
Language, Myths/Rituals and Beliefs, Knowledge, Technology, Cultural Diversity,
Customs/Norms/Values, Art and Artifacts, Prejudice and Stereotypes, Science and Civilisation.
Environment
Every society is located in a particular physical setting and interacts with its environment.
The attitudes and values that people have in regard to their environment greatly affect
interactions between persons, society, culture and the environment. Unique culture is
generated from the interactions with the immediate environment. Different locations and
their environments – including urban, rural, coastal, inland and isolated – present societies
and their cultures with both opportunities and constraints. Examples include: Location,
surroundings, Landforms/Vegetation/Climate, Landuse, Interdependence, Ecosystems.
Time
Every person, society, culture and environment is located in a period of time and is changing
with time. Time can be examined as past, present and future. Our perceptions of time are
drawn from past events and these influence our ideas about the present. These perceptions
need not, however, determine possible ideas of a future. The concept of time is best studied
in context – last century, this century, and pre- and post-events – or as a particular decade.
Time is studied in relation to continuity and change. Examples include: Past and Future, Present,
Continuity, Change and Conflict. Cultural Heritage, Social Mobility, Innovation, Adaptability,
Science, Technology, Tradition.
2
ACTIVITY
Instructions: Complete the activity below based on the information provided and your own knowledge and experience.
Society
3
CONCEPT DEFINITION EXAMPLES FROM BOOKLET OWN EXAMPLE
Culture
Environment
Time
4
The additional and related course concepts are:
power
authority
gender
identity
technologies
globalisation
The additional course concepts help us to understand and analyse the interactions between the
fundamental course concepts. These additional course concepts are important when analysing
and understanding the interactions of society at the micro, meso and macro levels.
Power
Power is the ability or capacity to influence or persuade others to a point of view or action to which
they may not always agree. Exercising power is important in initiating or preventing change.
Authority
Authority is linked to power and the right to make decisions and to determine, adjudicate or
settle issues and disputes in society. Authority is best understood as the legitimate use of power.
The use of authority is important in the process of decision-making and in initiating change and
maintaining continuity.
Gender
Gender refers to the socially constructed differences between females and males. Social life –
including family life, roles, work, behaviour and other activities – is organised around the
dimensions of this difference. Gender also refers to the cultural ideals, identities and stereotypes
of masculinity and femininity and the sexual division of labour in institutions and organisations.
Gender reflects the value a society places on these social constructs, which are particular and
unique to a society.
Identity
Identity refers to the sense of self and can be viewed from a personal, social and cultural level.
Identity is formed over a period of time and is the result of interactions at the micro, meso and
macro levels of society. An identity has dimensions or layers that create a sense of inclusion in
a group or culture. Contributing factors to one’s identity may be gender, sexuality, family, class,
ethnicity, beliefs, social status, group membership and national pride.
Technologies
The term ‘technologies’ refers to all the tools that we use to assist our interactions in society.
Technologies can lead to innovation and can initiate change to micro, meso and macro operations
in society. The value placed on technologies at any level of society influences the rate of change
to society and culture. Technologies are constantly changing and adapting and their impact varies
over time. Communication-based technologies facilitate the interaction between the micro, meso
and macro levels of society.
Globalisation
Globalisation is the process of integration and sharing of goods, capital, labour, services,
knowledge, leisure, sport, ideas and culture between countries. Globalisation is evidenced in
the emergence of global patterns of consumption and consumerism; the growth of transnational
corporations; global sport; the spread of world tourism; and the growth of global military and
economic systems. Globalisation is assisted by technologies and media integration, resulting
in an increasing consciousness of the world as a single place.
5
Watch: How to understand power:
https://ed.ted.com/lessons/how-to-understand-power-eric-liu
Interactions exist between micro and meso, micro and macro,and meso and macro levels.
Interactions should be viewed as two-way.
6
ACTIVITY
Instructions: Complete the activity below based on the information provided and your own knowledge and experience.
Authority
Gender
7
CONCEPT DEFINITION EXAMPLES
Identity
Technologies
Gender
8
Answer:
1. Who holds power in your family? _________________________________________________
2. How is that power used ? _______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
3. Who has authority in your family? ________________________________________________
4. How is that authority used?
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
5. Who holds power in your everyday experience of school? _____________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
6. How is that power used? _______________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
7. Who has authority in your school? ________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
8. How is that authority applied? ____________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
9.List 3 male gender stereotypes and 3 female gender stereotypes
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
10. Will these stereotypes change over time? If so, how and why? _________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
11. Research: Provide an example of 2 types of technology that was essential in each of the
following periods of history and explain why each was so important in those times:
9
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
10
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
13. Imagine you live in the future and are digging the ruins of the city of Sydney. Identify 3
artefacts you might uncover that would be evidence of Sydney having been a globalised city.
Explain.
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
11
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
12
TO PEEL AND ALARM
ALARM – A Learning and Responding Matrix
https://www.virtuallibrary.info/alarm.html
Why ALARM?
ALARM was developed by ESL Teacher Max Woods. It aimed to assist students to improve
their writing skills by making each body paragraph specific. This, however, was not the
motivation behind its development.
ALARM seeks to help students learn how to learn by making the learning process EXPLICIT.
It is important to understand how to learn if we are to take on board more than just
the content to be learned. Understanding how to learn, rather than just the content, is the key to
becoming lifelong learners.
Another purpose of ALARM is to promote deep understanding, rather than superficial
knowledge which is learned by rote. This is achieved partly by requiring us to employ higher
order thinking skills, such as analysis and evaluation, but primarily by asking provocative
questions, which promote inquiry and reflection. ALARM fundamentally challenges the role of
the teacher - demanding that the teacher primarily be the lead enquirer, rather than providing
students with the answers immediately.
How does ALARM work?
ALARM:
provides a step by step guide to the process of learning and then responding to a
question
makes explicit the ordering of concepts from simple to complex
allows students to tap into higher order concepts throughout the teaching process
aids students to identify gaps in their knowledge
allows students to communicate with a common terminology across the curriculum
provides templates which can be adapted to suit content area, complexity of information,
level of depth required
‘Egypt is the gift of the Nile.’ (a quote from the historian Herodotus). Assess this statement.
The River Nile is incredibly important to Egypt. The river runs the entire length of Egypt with fertile land on
either side. Egypt is located in a desert environment and it is this river which allows it to flourish. The
important historian Herodotus stated that is was a ‘gift’ to the Egyptians. It is this water that provided
transport, water for drinking and crops for the Egyptians. Therefore without the Nile River, Egypt would have
been a desert area which did not allow for habitation, for food sources and the development of society.
13
Costello, C. (2015). ALARM- A learning and responding matrix. Virtual Library. Retrieved from
https://www.virtuallibrary.info/alarm.html
14
Secondary research
Watch the following clips & read the newspaper article.
Answer the questions below for each clip & the newspaper article.
Clip 1:
Where the hell is Matt? 2012
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pwe-pA6TaZk
Clip 2:
The women behind the Napoleon Perdis beauty empire
https://au.tv.yahoo.com/the-morning-show/video/watch/29174447/the-women-behind-the-
napoleon-perdis-beauty-empire/#page1
Clip 3:
Changing the world, One word at a time! The Queen Latifah Show.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YshUDa10JYY
Clip 4:
Newspaper article 1:
15
About 73,000 Australians identified as Jedis in the 2001 census
Founded in 1997 by Ivo Benda, an information systems engineer with the Czech Skoda
car company, two years after cowherd Miloslav Drskova “changed his world” by
introducing him to communications with extraterrestrials on the planet Pleiades.
Influenced by Czech “spiritual scientist” and ufologist Eduard Meier, Benda believes
extraterrestrial civilisations have spaceships orbiting Earth to watch and help the good,
who will be transported into another dimension. Claiming 12,000 followers, in 2001
Benda contacted Czech president Vaclav Havel and Slovak president Rudolf Schuster to
request a meeting between extraterrestrial civilisations and heads of state.
16
Church of All Worlds
A revival of ancient polytheistic European and Middle Eastern worship began in Britain
before World War II, but blossomed with devotion to nature and psychology from the
late 1950s. The Church of All Worlds, founded in 1962 by Oberon Zell-Ravenheart and
his wife Morning Glory Zell-Ravenheart, is one of America’s oldest neo-pagan deities.
Partly based on Robert Heinlein’s 1961 science fiction novel, Stranger In A Strange
Land, followers recognise Gaea as the Earth Mother Goddess and the Father God, as
well as Faerie realms from Greek pantheons.
The faith adopted by Kastom people on Vanuatu’s Tanna island in the 1950s was
reinforced when Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip visited in 1974. Yaohnanens
believed Philip was an ancient divine being, the son of a mountain spirit who travelled
to a distant land where he married a powerful lady, only to eventually return. Philip was
sometimes considered a brother to John Frum of another Tanna cargo cult. Philip then
sent a portrait to villagers, who responded with a traditional pig-killing club, or nal-nal.
In compliance with their request, Philip sent a photograph of himself posing with the
club.
Maradonian Church
Maradonians count the years since football legend Maradona’s birth in 1960. Devotees
Hernan Amez, Alejandro Veron and Hector Campomar opened their church in 2001 in
Rosario, 300km from Buenos Aires, using Maradona’s jersey number 10, or diez in
Spanish, and dios, Spanish for God, as a symbol. With 200,000 followers, they
celebrate the nativity on Maradona’s birthdate, October 30, and use an Anno Diego
calendar, dating from 1960. Easter is celebrated on June 22 to honour Maradona
leading Argentina to victory against England in the 1986 FIFA World Cup.
ANSWER:
1. List the concepts related to the clips/newspaper article.
17
2. Explain how the concepts are related to the clips/newspaper article.
3. Describe how the clip assists with your understanding of the course using the ALARM
structure.
Identify / Define
Describe
18
ACTIVITY
Using the ALARM structure, explain the significance of TWO CLIPS (CLIP 1, CLIP 2, CLIP 3) to
Society and Culture.
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
19
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
20
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
Multiculturalism...
Definition
Multiculturalism is a term which recognises and celebrates the cultural diversity of Australia’s
population.
Cultural and linguistic diversity has always been a feature of Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander societies. In the past 200 years this diversity has been augmented with the
settlement of over six million migrants. The 2001 Census determined that 43%
of Australians were either born overseas or had at least one parent born overseas. This
diversity has had a marked influence on all aspects of our society.
Multiculturalism is the third phase in the evolution of Australia’s public policies on cultural
diversity and migration. In place since 1973, this policy respects and values the right of
all Australians to express and share their individual cultural heritage within a cohesive and
harmonious society, and within an overriding commitment to the basic structures and values
of Australian democracy.
Government strategies, policies and programs have been implemented to promote social
harmony among different cultural groups, optimise the benefits of cultural diversity for
all Australians and make our administrative and economic infrastructure responsive to
the rights, needs and responsibilities of different cultural groups. These have focussed on
access and equity to public services, equal opportunity in employment, creation of the
Special Broadcasting Service (SBS) and productive diversity. Productive diversity promotes
21
utilising Australia’s language and cultural diversity for the economic and social benefits of
all Australians.
Coexistence of people from diverse cultures is feasible when there is common agreement
about basic principles such as respect for the rights and property of others, a commitment to
democratic ideals and the rule of law. Many people recognise the reality of Australia as a
multicultural society, are proud of the harmonious co-existence of diverse cultures and value
the benefits arising from this.
22
23
24
Indonesia: A Hybrid Society
Read the following information and answer the
questions in your exercise book.
Indonesia has a population of approximately 210
million people, from 300 different ethnic groups who
speak more than 400 distinct languages and dialects.
The Javanese are the largest ethnic group,
comprising 41% of the population, and more than
85% of the population are Muslim, 10% Christian and
3% Hindu or Buddhist.
This diversity makes Indonesia a hybrid society.
Rather than having a single or homogenous identity it
is comprised of a range of social and cultural
influences and components. As you know from
Australia, a family from a Chinese or Indian background will have a very different customs and
values compared to a family from an English or Greek background, although there will be some
central Australian values and behaviours that will be common to all.
Since gaining independence in 1945 the Indonesian government has followed a philosophy known
as the Pancasila – meaning “five principles” in the Sanskrit language. This philosophy is designed
to unite the various ethnic groups and maintain national stability.
A plural society
Bali is renowned for its identity as a Hindu-Buddhist island in the Indonesian archipelago, the
world’s most populous Muslim nation. Yet Bali in fact has a substantial Muslim minority. Muslims
residing in rural areas are usually descendants of long-standing populations, with origins in Java,
Madura, South Sulawesi (Bugis), Lombok (Sasak), or elsewhere in the Indonesian-Malaysian
region. These Muslims — who have long histories in Bali — are known as Bali Slam, or Bali
Muslims, and have assimilated to Balinese identity. They are culturally Balinese. A few live in
predominantly Muslim villages, but most live in mixed Hindu-Muslim communities.
As the last published census of 2000 revealed, meanwhile, the number of Muslims in Bali has
grown quite dramatically in a short time. In that year, 9.7 per cent of the island’s population was
Muslim, up from six per cent less than a decade earlier.
With a population of 3,890,757 in the 2010 census and 4,225,000 as of January 2014, the island is
home to most of Indonesia’s Hindu Minority. According to the 2010 Census 83.5% of Bali’s
population adhered to Balinese Hinduism, followed by 13.4% Muslim, Christianity at 2.5% and
Buddhism 0.5%.
Most of the new arrivals are migrants from neighbouring islands who come in search of jobs. The
increase may be associated in part with the growing tourism industry and its labour needs, but
their numbers also escalated during the Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s, when Bali fared
better than most areas of Indonesia. Bali is attractive, moreover, because it is considered one of
the safest parts of Indonesia by Indonesians too. The new arrivals have settled mainly in the urban
areas of southern Bali, where they serve as a cheap labour force. Accordingly, the percentage of
Muslims in these areas, an estimated 17 per cent, is higher than average.
1. Define ‘Multicultural’.
2. What is a hybrid society? How is it different from a homogenous society?
3. Explain how Australia adheres to being a multicultural society AND a hybrid society.
4. Explain how Indonesia adheres to being a multicultural society AND a hybrid society.
25
MICRO, MESO AND MACRO LEVELS IN SOCIETY
See also Page 4 above
MESO LEVEL
MACRO LEVEL
26
DOCUMENTARY: MICHAEL PALIN’S SAHARA
PROGRAM 3: THE WODAABE PEOPLE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goZJSkIFes8
2. According to the French woman, what are the interactions like between the men and
women?
3. Describe what the men are doing. Why are they doing it?
27
Once upon a time in Punchbowl.
1. LIST and EXPLAIN how this documentary relates to 5 key concepts
2. Outline the struggles faced by the Lebanese community and the impact that this had for
their community and for the rest of Australia.
3. Using the ALARM structure, explain how this documentary relates to the following
concepts:
a. Multiculturalism
b. Social expectations
c. Micro and Meso levels of society.
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
28
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
29
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________
30
31
32
33
34
QUESTIONS
1. Explain the concept ‘society is a social construct’.
2. Define ‘social expectation’.
3. Outline the social expectation of women and explain how they have
changed since World War 2.
4. Define ‘social norms’ and provide 5 examples.
5. Explain how the concepts below relate to social expectations:
Macro Level
Micro Level
Meso Level
6. Explain how Social Expectations can be linked to communication
technology.
35
GROUPS AND INSTITUTIONS OF SOCIETY
(HOW THEY SHAPE AND ARE SHAPED BY INDIVIDUALS)
In order to understand the social structure that makes up our social and cultural
world, it is important to understand the roles of family, school, peers, work,
government, media and the legal system. Read the following information and
complete the table below.
GROUP/ Outline the role, influence and significance of each
INSTITUTION group/institution
FAMILY
SCHOOL
PEERS
WORK
GOVERNMENT
MEDIA
LEGAL
SYSTEM
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
THE AMISH
Make notes based on the following information
History of the
Amish
Religion
Ordnung
Family
Gender Roles
(two sections)
44
Roles and
Status
Adolescence
and
Rumschpringes
Conflict, co-
operation and
decision
making
Communication
Power,
Authority and
influence
45
46
47
48
49
50
FILM STUDY: WITNESS
1. What are your first impressions of the Amish when the film opens?
2. Do you think that the scenario that finds the young boy, Samuel,
witnessing a murder is realistic? Make sure you explain your
answer.
3. What examples can you find of the networks that bind the Amish
together?
51
4. What aspects of the Amish culture are portrayed in the film?
5. Compare your own culture with the Amish – what do you share
and what is different? Provide THREE similarities and THREE
differences.
52
FILM STUDY: WITNESS
Make notes from the film about the way the following groups and institutions of society are
shaped by individuals
Family
School
Peers
Work
Government
Media
Legal System
53
Social and cultural research methods
During the study of both the Preliminary and the HSC courses, students are required to develop
knowledge and understanding of a variety of the methods used to conduct research. Students will
also need to develop skills in:
planning research tasks, including developing appropriate research methods
applying research methods ethically
compiling and organising collected information
analysing, synthesising and interpreting the findings
writing up and editing their conclusions in ways appropriate to different audiences.
The term ‘method’ refers to the specific tools of the investigation, or the ways that data can be
collected and analysed – for example, a questionnaire.
Two main approaches for research are quantitative and qualitative.
Quantitative methods enable the collection of very specific data from a sample of the
relevant population. The findings may then be extrapolated for the whole population under study.
With a quantitative method, information is collected by counting, and is able to be collated into
percentages and then represented by tables and graphs.
While the ease of collating data gathered through quantitative methods has its advantages for
the researcher, it must be remembered that quantitative methods:
do not allow the researcher to interact closely or personally with those being questioned;
the process is impersonal and as objective as possible
rely heavily on the researcher’s ability to develop a non-biased set of research questions
or items in order to record data within the selected sample.
Qualitative methods rely on the researcher’s interpretive skills to understand the often complex
and detailed data gathered.
Qualitative research is useful:
for studies at the individual or small group level
for finding out, in depth, how and what people are thinking and feeling.
Analysis of qualitative data can be more challenging than analysis of the numbers collected
through a quantitative method.
Analysis of qualitative data requires sorting responses to open-ended questions and interviews
into broad themes or categories before the researcher is able to draw meaning or conclusions
from the data.
Research methods such as questionnaire and interview can produce both quantitative and
qualitative information, depending on how the questions are structured.
Closed questions that require only a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer, or questions that allow only a limited
choice of responses, produce easily quantified and tabulated data.
Open-ended questions, on the other hand, produce descriptive responses that are qualitative in
nature and therefore require categorising and analysing before any understanding can be gained.
54
It is important to remember that research methods exist on a continuum from quantitative
to qualitative – that is, from methods that easily measure and quantify data to those that
collect detailed and less measurable and, therefore, less quantifiable data. Many methods
contain aspects of both – that is, they include quantitative and qualitative elements.
Main features Large and randomly selected Usually a small sample and not
sample of respondents who randomly selected
represent the particular
Interactive process
population of interest
Participants’ characteristics may
Structured data collection be known to the researcher
instrument, with closed-ended
or rating-scale questions Narrative report with conceptual
description of behaviour, values,
Quantities and trends identified; attitudes and beliefs
comparisons can be made
Contains direct quotations from
Researcher is not necessarily research participants
known to the participants
Invaluable for the exploration of
Participant characteristics can subjective experiences
be hidden from the research
Relies heavily on the researcher’s
Lack of direct contact with interpretive skills to understand the
the sample assists detachment complexities of findings
of the researcher; however,
care still needs to be taken in Direct quotations from documents
construction of the instrument and from participants can be utilised
to ensure that the researcher
is aware of potential bias that
may be built into the questions
Quantifies the findings in
numerical data, tables, graphs
and diagrams
55
Research methods
Quantitative methods of research Qualitative methods of research
56
Quantitative methods of research Qualitative methods of research
of individuals who share a common social
experience and/or location. Case study is
considered a methodology when it combines
two or more research methods, such as
‘observation, interview and documentary
evidence’, to gather the data.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES
SURVEY
Features:
Combines observation, interview and/or a written list of questions
Uses representative samples of specific populations
Can be done in large numbers
Advantages
Large sample = less bias
Easy to calculate
Able to ensure anonymity = more honest answers
Quick to answer
Provides lots of information
Disadvantages
No assurance of honesty
No way of knowing if the questions were understood
Standardised form restrict people
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Features:
Examines the data generated from questionnaires or secondary research
Enables you to make generalisations and describe trends
May involve graphs or charts
Advantages
Complements qualitative research
May be beneficial
Disadvantages
The strength of the analysis is linked to the quality of the questionnaire
Collating information could be difficult
CONTENT ANALYSIS
Features
Systematic process for examining the subject matter of a source of information to obtain
justifiable and reliable information
Method of summarizing any form of content by counting various aspects of the content
Interprets hidden meanings and trends in common media types
Sources if information include textbooks, novels, TV, internet sites etc
Advantages
Provides quantitative data to supplement research
Can be used on a wide range of media
Disadvantages
Difficult to design
57
QUESTIONNAIRE
Features
A collection of questions related of questions related to a specific topic that you distribute to
a sample of respondents
Can include open and closed ended questions
Ensure you:
o Relate questions to hypothesis
o Do not use unclear questions
o Avoid emotions in questions
o Ensure confidentiality
Advantages
Investigates a wide range of areas
Can assess values beliefs, opinions and attitudes
Minimal cost
Can be answered quickly
Allows for a variety of questions
Quick analysis
Disadvantages
People may not answer open ended questions
Little flexibility
May lead to misinterpretations of questions
People may not return questionnaire
FOCUS GROUPS
Features
Involves bringing a group of 3-8 people together to discuss an issue
Planning and implementation similar to an in-depth interview
Advantages
Complements quantitative results of a questionnaire
Helps gauge people’s thoughts etc on an issue
Can be taped and used for reports
May provide a broad range of options
Disadvantages
May be difficult to manage
Must have a definite framework to stay on task
Will produce findings which can’t be measured so best to use with quantitative results
INTERVIEW
Features
Speaking to another person to find out information
It requires prior knowledge of the topic
A list of questions you know you’ll ask
Your technique in gaining information is important
It requires a recording device (eg I Phone)
Advantages
Good as a supplement to questionnaires
Additional info is easily asked for
The pressure is on the interviewer
People talk more than they write
Can be taped and used for reports
Allows the interviewer to press for more details
58
Disadvantages
Lack of anonymity
Will not give a broad range of opinions
Difficult to re-administer
Cannot be quantified or easily collated
Only as good as the subject chosen
PERSONAL REFLECTION
Features
Dependent on your experiences, memories and values
Requires you to respect the people and issues you are going to be reflecting on
Advantages
As it is about your it requires you to be honest and open about your life and feelings about a
specific thing
It is often used by the person researching and writing to explain how they felt during the
process and their reaction to the topic
Disadvantages
Should be used in conjunction with other information
Impossible to quantify
Some topics could cause friction within the family
59
Task
Examine the characteristics of the following methodologies and identify their advantages and disadvantages. Some topics may require research
on a laptop.
METHODOLOGY CHARACTERISTICS ADVANTAGES/DISADVANTAGES
Survey: uses different
instruments such as
observation, interview
or questionnaire
Participant
Observation:
Researcher immerses
in the action that is
being researched. Data
is collected by the
observer, quantitatively
and qualitatively,
although researcher
needs to be aware of
bias
60
Content analysis:
Study and
interpretation of written
and visual information
Action Research: an
informal qualitative,
interpretive, reflective
and experimental
methodology
Interview: A set of
questions closed and/or
open- ended questions
for quantitative and
qualitative results
61
Questionnaire: An
impersonal instrument
suitable for a large
group of people. Set of
closed ended and open
ended questions
Observation:
Watching and recording
behaviors within a
defined area.
Ethnographic study:
Direct observation and
reflection of data from
immersion within a
group by the
researcher.
Observation, interview
used
Statistical Analysis:
Examination of data to
interpret meaning,
make generalisations
and extrapolate trends.
62
TASK
HSC Examiners are keen to find out how well you know the research methodologies
and whether you can distinguish between them. Complete the following as part of
your revision.
TERM DEFINITION LIST EXAMPLES
QUALITATIVE
METHODOLOGIES
QUANTITATIVE
METHODOLOGIES
Distinguish between
qualitative and
quantitative
methodologies
PRIMARY RESEARCH
SECONDARY
RESEARCH
63
TASK
Can you tell the difference between these methodologies?
Observation and
participant observation
64
Social and cultural literacy
Society and Culture is designed to facilitate the development of a student’s social and cultural literacy.
Achieving social and cultural literacy is a developmental process that requires the student to synthesise
personal experience and public knowledge at the micro, meso and macro levels of society.
Social and cultural literacy refers to the idea that people should possess a body of knowledge,
understanding and skills that allows them to share, communicate effectively, and respect themselves and
others. The process of gaining social and cultural literacy is reflected in the diagram below.
Personal experience refers to the knowledge gained from reflecting on individual experiences.
Public knowledge refers to general knowledge and the knowledge available to everyone.
The term also refers to all the knowledge found in the public domain that is the work or research
of other people.
Micro-level interactions are personal and occur between individuals and their family, peers and
individuals in the community.
Meso-level interactions occur between the micro and the macro levels of society. Meso-level
structures are groups in the community, village, school, workplace, local interest club, branch,
organisation and state. The meso level is also known as the middle level.
Macro-level interactions are impersonal and relate to large institutions, the media, law and
government and are evident at a national and international level.
Interactions exist between micro and meso, micro and macro, and meso and macro levels.
Interactions should be viewed as two-way.
65
Social and cultural literacy
66
Social and cultural research
Students will:
outline the principles and practices of ethical research that underpin all social and cultural research
examine the process of research using the steps briefly outlined below as a guide.
2. Develop a focus question or hypothesis
3. Gather background information
4. Design the research
5. Develop the research methods to be used
6. Apply the research methods ethically
7. Compile and organise the collected information so that it is manageable
8. Analyse, synthesise and interpret the findings
9. Write up the conclusions in an appropriate format, considering the audience for the final product
10. Check the final product for editing or typing mistakes and ensure that all bibliographical information is
included and correct
67
Ethical research
Social and cultural researchers are expected to conduct research in an ethical manner.
Following the principles of ethical research is important because:
this promotes trust that the information collected will be used responsibly and will be treated
with respect and confidentiality
if the respondents feel comfortable with the ethical research process, they are much more
likely to offer replies to questions and therefore genuine knowledge can be gained by
the researcher.
In practice, ethical research means that:
any prospective research participants must be fully informed about the procedures and any
possible risks involved in the research, and must give their consent to participate
participants are not put in awkward situations or asked to talk about sensitive topics that may
make them feel uncomfortable
the ethical researcher is open and honest with participants about the topic and scope of the
project and the nature of the participation or information expected from them
the protection of participants’ rights to confidentiality and privacy is ensured
the researcher anticipates any negative effects on the research participants (including
the researcher), such as personal danger, police intervention, social embarrassment or
harassment – the researcher needs to prevent these
the researcher is mindful of the special needs of any vulnerable groups, such as children
there is nothing covert associated with the research.
Once data (information) is collected, the researcher begins the process of analysis, synthesis and
deduction. At this point, the ethical researcher needs to be aware of any assumptions or biases
that may underlie the research. It is critical that the researcher analyses the data without looking
for evidence to support any preconceived ideas about what she or he may find.
Ethical research practices apply to both primary and secondary research – for example, in
secondary research, the collection and use of information from books, magazines, the internet,
communication technologies and so on. The protection of intellectual property in the writing-up
process through the acknowledgement of all information used is critical, not only out of respect
for the original author of the information but also to protect the researcher from breach of copyright
law. With the availability of film clips, information, images and other content from the many
sources accessible to researchers, discernment and care need to be taken in order to avoid
material that might be inappropriate or potentially offensive for the audience of the final product.
Plagiarising other people’s work is unethical, a breach of copyright law, a misuse of intellectual
property, and an untruthful representation of other people’s work as the researcher’s own.
Researchers must never plagiarise!
68
TASK
As part of your study routine, research and complete the following.
Define public
knowledge
Define personal
experience
Distinguish
between public
knowledge and
personal
experience
Define micro world
Define macro
world
Explain social and
cultural literacy
Explain the
characteristics of a
socially and
culturally literate
person
69
Explain why it is
important to be a
socially and
culturally literate
person.
List the
advantages in
undertaking the
steps in social and
cultural research
Research and
write a definition of
‘Ethical Research’.
When conducting
research, what does
the researcher need
to be aware of in
terms of ‘Ethical
research’?
70
71