Michigan Crayfish Guide
Michigan Crayfish Guide
Michigan Crayfish Guide
to
MICHIGAN
CRAYFISH
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Background and introduction 3
Key terms 6
Anatomy diagram 7
Identification Key 8
Big water crayfish (Cambarus robustus) 10
Digger crayfish (Creaserinus fodiens) 12
Calico crayfish (Faxonius immunis) 14
Northern clearwater crayfish (Faxonius propinquus) 16
Rusty crayfish (Faxonius rusticus) INVASIVE 18
Virile crayfish (Faxonius virilis) 20
Devil crayfish (Lacunicambarus diogenes) 22
Paintedhand mudbug (Lacunicambarus polychromatus) 24
White river crayfish (Procambarus acutus) 26
Red swamp crayfish (Procambarus clarkii) INVASIVE 28
Potential invasive species 30
Regulations and reporting 31
CREDITS
Kelley Smith, Michigan State University
Edition 2, 2021
2
BACKGROUND
Crayfish are members of the order Decapoda, or 10-footed crustaceans,
which also includes shrimp, crabs and lobsters. There are approximately 700
species of crayfish worldwide. Of the 10 crayfish species known in Michigan,
eight of them are native and two are invasive. All of Michigan’s crayfish are
part of the family Cambaridae that are broken up into three distinct groups
based on their preferred habitat: primary burrowers, secondary burrowers
and tertiary burrowers. Additionally, North American Cambarid crayfishes
are unique in that all males seasonally alternate between reproductive (Form
I) and non-reproductive (Form II) states. The reproductive Form I male has
unique changes to body shape which can be used to make positive species
identifications. Despite relatively low crayfish species richness in Michigan,
each of the state’s eight native species lives in, and contributes to, wetlands
and aquatic ecosystems in important and unique ways.
Primary burrowers
Three of Michigan’s crayfish, the paintedhand mudbug (Lacunicambarus
polychromatus), devil crayfish (Lacunicambarus diogenes) and digger crayfish
(Creaserinus fodiens), are considered primary burrowers. These species
spend most of their lives underground in fields, ditches, prairies and wet
meadows. The best time to see these crayfish is in the spring during early
morning rain showers as they make their trek to nearby water sources to
explore or release their young. The rest of the year, they build and occupy a
deep and complex subterranean tunnel system that goes at least as deep as
the ground water table. Sometimes you can spot these crayfish on rainy or
humid nights hunting or walking on land. Burrows sometimes include small
mounds of protracting soil, referred to as “chimney” which can help spot
their presence.
1. Glon, M., R. Thoma. 2017. An Observation of the Use of Devil Crayfish (Cambarus cf. diogenes)
Burrows as Brooding Habitat by Eastern Cicada Killer Wasps (Sphecius speciosus). Freshwater
Crayfish. 23. 55-57.
Secondary burrowers
Secondary burrowers can occupy diverse habitats. They are capable of
burrowing to escape drought, cold temperatures and predation, but their
burrows tend to be much smaller and less complex, and their burrows
may or may not have chimneys like in primary burrowers. Most secondary
burrowers have a direct connection to permanent bodies of water such as
streams, wetlands or ponds. Secondary burrowers are likely to be found in
the water during the spring, summer and fall.
Tertiary burrowers
Permanent bodies of water like streams, lakes and ponds are home to
Michigan’s last group of crayfish, the tertiary burrowers. These crayfish
spend their entire life under surface water. The four species include the big
water crayfish (Cambarus robustus), northern clearwater crayfish (F.
propinquus), northern crayfish (F. virilis), and the non-native rusty crayfish
(F. rusticus). These crayfish rarely, if ever, leave permanent water and only
burrow during extreme circumstances or to excavate depressions under
rocks and debris in the water for shelter. As both predators and prey, they
are important keystone species to Michigan’s aquatic ecosystems. They
help to shape the vegetative and invertebrate communities in streams and
lakes while simultaneously acting as a popular food item for many predatory
fish.4,5
4
Invasive crayfish species in Michigan
Michigan defines invasive species as those that are not native and whose
introduction causes harm, or is likely to cause harm, to the environment,
economy or human health. Some invasive species are legally designated by
the state as “prohibited” or “restricted.” If a species is prohibited or
restricted, it is unlawful to possesses, introduce, import, sell or offer that
species for sale as a live organism, except under certain circumstances.6
Rusty crayfish (Faxonius rusticus) are native to the Ohio River basin and
have been introduced throughout the Great Lakes region. They have spread
across many of Michigan’s inland and Great Lakes waters in the last 100
years, their spread most likely facilitated by habitat alterations and angler
bait bucket transfers. Once established, they outcompete native crayfish,
alter habitat, and consume fish eggs.
Red swamp crayfish (Procambarus clarkii) are native to the western Gulf
Coast states and the southern Mississippi River drainage. Due to their
popularity in the live food trade, biological supply industry, and pet trade,
they have been introduced in many U.S. states and around the world.1,2 The
first observations of established red swamp crayfish in Michigan occurred in
2017. Like rusty crayfish, red swamp crayfish can outcompete native species
and negatively affect the ecosystem. Their burrowing tendencies can cause
shoreline erosion and have negative effects on water quality.
Range maps
Maps in this guide show known ranges in green, based on the most current
surveys and public reports. The most recent comprehensive state-wide
stream and river survey was conducted by Smith et al. in 2018 and
specimens identified in later field seasons. Species in Michigan have seen
changes in their abundance and statewide range due to a variety of factors
including natural and human-caused dispersal, habitat loss, pollution, and
competition with invasive species.7
4, Twardochleb, L. A., J. D. Olden, and E. R. Larson. 2013. A global meta-analysis of the ecological
impacts of nonnative crayfish. Freshwater Science 32(4):1367–1382.
5. Loureiro, T. G., P. M. S. G. Anastácio, C. Souty-Grosset, P. B. Araujo, and M. P. Almerão. 2015. Red
swamp crayfish: biology, ecology and invasion - an overview. Nauplius 23(1):1–19.
6. Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act (NREPA), Michigan Public Act 451. 1994.
Part 413: Transgenic and Nonnative Organisms, section 324.41302.
7. Smith, K. R., B. M. Roth, M. L. Jones, D. B. Hayes, S. J. Herbst, N. Popoff. 2018. Changes in the
distribution of Michigan crayfishes and the influence of invasive rusty crayfish (Faxonius
rusticus) on native crayfish substrate associations. Biological Invasions 21; 637–656.
5
Key Terms
Areola: Hourglass-shaped area on the dorsal surface of the carapace.
Two arching portions of the carapace meet, or nearly meet.
Outline of the gill arch.
Carapace: Hardened exterior of the crayfish’s thoracic region, composed
of two fused segments. It covers the head, gills, and internal
organs of the crayfish.
Chelae: First walking legs of crayfish. They are often enlarged and com-
monly referred to as the claws.
Copulatory hook: Small thorn-like extension near the base of the third and/or
fourth walking legs. Found only in mature, Form I males. Used
for holding female in place during sexual reproduction. Loca-
tions on which legs is distinguishing in many species.
Dactyl: Movable part of the chelae.
Dorsal: Top side or “back” of the crayfish.
Gonopod: First pleopod of male crayfish, often used as an identifying
feature, as they are significantly different in both shape and
size from the remaining pleopods. Used for transferring sperm
to the annulus ventralis. Form I gonopods, breeding phase, are
used as an identifying feature and are larger and more robust.
Form II gonopods are the non-reproductive form and are often
smaller and less robust.
Gonopore: Opening on female crayfish through which eggs are released.
Located between the fourth and fifth walking legs. Also known
as annulus ventralis in some guides.
Lateral view: View from the side when crayfish is held horizontally level and
perpendicular to the observer’s line of sight.
Marginal spines: Spines located at the margins of the rostrum.
Median carina: Raised ridge located in the center of the rostrum. If the
medina carina is not easily visible, it can be felt by using one’s
fingernail to scratch along the rostrum.
Mesial: Towards the mid-line of the body.
Pleopod: Appendages in ventral side of tail, also called swimmerets.
Female crayfish have longer pleopods for holding eggs.
Rostrum: “Nose” of the crayfish. The extended triangular or shovel-
shaped dorsal extension located above and between the eyes.
Suborbital angle: Triangular point formed directly below the eye of the crayfish,
as seen from the side view. The presence or absence of this
point is an identifying feature in Michigan crayfish.
Tubercle: Hard, rounded bumps located on carapace and/or chelae of
crayfish. The presence or absence and arrangement of the
tubercles can be helpful in identifying individuals.
Ventral: Underside or “belly” of the crayfish.
6
Basic crayfish anatomy
DORSAL VIEW
Chela Suborbital Carapace
angle
Dactyl
Tubercle
VENTRAL VIEW
Male Female
Form 1 Gonopore
gonopod
Pleopods
7
Crayfish of Michigan identification key
1. Areola:
A. Closed ... go to 2. B. Open ... go to 5.
2. Rostrum:
A. Without marginal B. Small marginal spines;
spines; carapace carapace covered in
without tubercles; tubercles; gonopods
gonopods with with more than two
two terminal terminal elements ...
elements ... red swamp crayfish
go to 3. (P. clarkii).
3. Sub-orbital angle:
A. Present ... B. Absent ...
go to 4. digger crayfish
(C. fodiens).
4. Rostrum:
A. Steeply deflected B. Straight and slightly
downward in lateral downward lateral view ...
view ... devil crayfish (L. diogenes).
paintedhand mudbug
(L. polychromatus).
5. Rostrum:
A. Rostrum terminates B. Rostrum terminates
without marginal spines with marginal spines ...
... big water crayfish go to 6.
(C. robustus).
8
6. Median carina:
A. Median carina on B. No median carina on
dorsal surface of rostrum ... go to 7.
rostrum ... northern
clearwater crayfish
(F. propinquus).
7. Carapace:
A. Carapace covered in tubercles; B. Carapace lacking numerous
gonopods having more than two tubercles; gonopods with two terminal
terminal elements ... white river elements ... go to 8.
crayfish (P. acutus).
8. Chelae:
A. Deep incision at base of dactyl ... B. No deep incision at base of dactyl ...
calico crayfish (F. immunis). go to 9.
9. Rostrum:
A. Rostrum margins concave; B. Rostrum margins straight or slightly
tubercles on mesial margins of dactyl convex; tubercles on margins of dactyl
and chelae small ... rusty crayfish and chelae robust ... virile crayfish
(F. rusticus). (F. virilis).
9
Big water crayfish
Cambarus robustus
Open areola
No marginal spines
10
Big water crayfish
Cambarus robustus
A robust tertiary burrower that prefers fast, oxygen-rich, stone-laden streams and
is often found occupying depressions beneath large stones. Abundant populations
inhabit the eastern Lower Peninsula streams, and found occasionally in the western
Lower Peninsula. The big water crayfish has a smooth body with two rows of
tubercles on the inside edge of its large claws. It rarely exhibits flashy colors;
instead these crayfish are monotones of drab green, brown, tan, or gray. Big water
crayfish appear to share streams with rusty crayfish, which are known to displace
other crayfish species.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Open, moderately wide.
Rostrum: Terminates without marginal spines in a strong point.
Chela: Large and robust.
Tubercles: Mesial margin of palm has two rows of rounded Known range of
tubercles. C. robustus, 2020
Gonopods: Two short, sharply angled and sickle-shaped terminal
elements on form 1 gonopods.
Habitat: Open water (tertiary burrowers); often found under large rocks in
flowing, well-oxygenated water.
Chela
Form 1
Areola Gonopods
Rostrum
Tubercles
11
Digger crayfish
Creaserinus fodiens
No suborbital angle;
downward deflected
rostrum with no
marginal spines
Closed areola
Notch in dactyl;
large tubercles at
base of dactyl;
sometimes hairs
in chelae
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Closed.
Chela: Large and wide with flattened fingers. Often dactyl Known range of
has prominent notch and hairs. C. fodiens, 2020
Rostrum margins
converges in small
spines
Areola narrowly
open
Deep incision at
base of movable
dactyl
14
Calico crayfish
Faxonius immunis
A small to medium, thin-shelled crayfish, often called the “paper-shell
crayfish.” This secondary burrower has a scattered range across the Lower
Peninsula and is occasionally observed in the western Upper Peninsula. It can be
quite abundant where observed, occupying sluggish, soft-bottomed streams, ditch
lines, vernal pools and flooded meadows. It is often found in vegetated portions of
water bodies, or in simple burrows near permanent and temporary bodies of
water. It is highly dynamic in its use of simple burrows or open water, often
returning to burrows when conditions are not favorable or during water draw-
down. Calico crayfish have a wide range of color patterns, from black and brown to
mottled displays of green, gray and brown and sometimes blue, green, or purple
chelae. Chelae in larger individuals usually display a prominent notch in the dactyl.
Because of its availability and its soft body, the calico crayfish it is popular among
anglers as a form of live bait.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Narrowly open.
Chela: Large; deep incision at base of the movable dactyl. Known range of
F. immunis, 2020
Tubercles: Large, forward-angling tubercles along mesial
margin of palm region and dactyl.
Median carina
between marginal
spines on rostrum Broad, open
areola
16
Northern clearwater crayfish
Faxonius propinquus
One of the more common native tertiary burrowers in Michigan, they are found in
both the Upper and Lower peninsulas, in both fast-moving and stagnant waters.
These crayfish are not tolerant of water drawdown and are poor excavators of even
temporary burrows to escape drying out. Northern clearwater crayfish are most
abundant in bodies of water that offer large areas of cobble and boulders, but can
utilize vegetation, detritus and wood as alternate habitat when rusty crayfish are
present. Northern clearwater crayfish have been observed hybridizing with other
members of their genus, in particular rusty crayfish, which leads to concern over local
extirpation through hybridization with invasive rusty crayfish. The northern
clearwater crayfish’s is very similar in appearance to the rusty crayfish, with the most
notable differences being the lack of the rust- colored saddle, and the presence of a
median carina, a prominent notch in the middle of the rostrum.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Open, wide.
Chela: Large; tips of fingers red or orange with black bands. Known range of
F. propinquus, 2020
Tubercles: Two rows of rounded tubercles along mesial margin of the palm region.
Open areola
No median carina
between marginal
spines on rostrum;
margins slightly
concave
18
Rusty crayfish
Faxonius rusticus INVASIVE
Rusty crayfish are one of the most widespread invasive crayfish in the United States
and are one of the most abundant crayfish in the Great Lakes and Midwest. Rusty
crayfish are generalist tertiary burrowers, occupying fast-flowing streams, large
lakes, small ponds and offshore reefs in the Great Lakes. They prefer hard, rocky
substrates and will readily push native northern clearwater and virile crayfish out
of these habitats, forcing them to use less ideal vegetative habitat, if it’s available.
Rusty crayfish have been shown to alter macrophyte, fish, and invertebrate
communities, where they abound. In Michigan, rusty crayfish can reach large sizes,
with chelae significantly larger than similarly sized native crayfish.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Open; moderately wide.
Narrowly open
areola
No median carina
between parallel
marginal spines on
rostrum
Large forward-
facing tubercles
along mesial side
of palm and inside
of chelae dactyl
20
Virile Crayfish (northern crayfish)
Faxonius virilis
Common large tertiary burrower widely distributed across the Upper and Lower
peninsulas. They are highly adaptable and often found in small streams, large rivers,
inland lakes and the Great Lakes. Preferring hard, rocky substrates, this species can
also shift its habitat to vegetative areas and detritus if necessary to avoid aggressive
interactions with northern clearwater crayfish and red swamp crayfish. Virile crayfish
have been observed occupying crude, shallow burrows in muddy river bottoms or
river banks during dry periods. Virile crayfish can grow quite large, with significantly
meatier tails than both northern clearwater and rusty crayfish. However, its chelae
are often reduced in comparison to its body size relative to those species.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Open, narrowly.
Rostrum: Slightly convex or straight margins that terminate in
strong marginal spines; median carina absent.
21
Devil crayfish
Lacunicambarus diogenes
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Closed.
Rostrum: Terminates without marginal spines in a straight,
slightly downward angle. Has sub-orbital angle.
Areola
Form 1
gonopods
Tubercles
Rostrum
23
Paintedhand mudbug
Lacunicambarus polychromatus
Closed areola
Small
scattered
tubercles
on palm of
chelae
Downward
deflected
rostrum with no
marginal spines
24
Paintedhand mudbug
Lacunicambarus polychromatus
Large, long-lived primary burrower found throughout much of the southern Lower
Peninsula. This species is rarely observed in permanent water and spends most of
its life in deep, complex subterranean burrows. It is occasionally viewed at night
with its chelae outside its burrow, waiting on passing prey. It can be found in a
variety of habitats, from farm fields to ditches, and floodplains to wet meadows,
and its chimneys are a common sight in some suburban areas. The paintedhand
mudbug is easily identified by its strong, large claws with numerous tubercles on
the mesial side, a downwardly deflected rostrum, and closed areola. This is the
most colorful crayfish species in Michigan. Its carapace is most often olive, tan, and
brown with an occasional accent of purple, green, or blue. Painted hand mudbugs
have bright red and orange margins on the rostrum, claws, and tail segments, with
claws that are often tones of green, blue, and olive.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Closed.
Rostrum: Terminates without marginal spines in a steep
downward angle. Has suborbital angle.
Chela: Large and robust.
Tubercles: Dorsal surface of palm covered with many small, Known range of
round tubercles. L. polychromatus,
2020
Gonopods: Two short, sharply angled and sickle-
shaped terminal elements on form 1 gonopods.
25
White river crayfish
Procambarus acutus
Open, narrow
areola; carapace
covered in small
tubercles
Strongly pointed
rostrum
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Open, narrowly.
Rostrum: Terminates in a strong point with weak marginal spines.
Chela: Long and thin; dorsal surface covered in black tubercles.
Tubercles: Carapace covered in small black tubercles.
Gonopods: Multiple thin, curved terminal elements on form Known range of
1 gonopods. P. acutus, 2020
Chela
Areola
Form 1
gonopods
Tubercles
Rostrum
27
Red swamp crayfish INVASIVE
Procambarus clarkii
Invasion details: The first observations and active response efforts in Michigan
occurred in 2017. As of 2021, red swamp crayfish had been found in over 30 Michigan
bodies of water in seven unique locations, with most of the observations occurring in
the southeast Lower Peninsula.
Robust chelae
covered in red
tubercles
28
Red swamp crayfish
Procambarus clarkii INVASIVE
Recently discovered in Michigan waters, the red swamp crayfish is one of the most
widespread invasive crayfish on the planet. Native to the southern U.S., it has
invaded several other U.S. states as well as, Africa, Asia, Europe and South America.
In other parts of the world, red swamp crayfish have extirpated native crayfish and
invertebrates, affected amphibian populations, damaged and eroded levees, altered
vegetation communities and directly affected water quality through intensive
burrowing and foraging. As secondary burrowers, they exhibit a dynamic ability to
persist in a wide variety of ecological systems and disturbed areas. When surface
conditions become less hospitable, they quickly construct crude burrows that, due
to high population densities, can erode banks and upset wetland systems. It is
common for multiple females and a male to occupy a single burrow, each with their
own chamber, with the males occupying the deepest recess. Red swamp crayfish
look very similar to white river crayfish. They can be distinguished by noting their
closed areola, and red tubercles covering the carapace and chelae.
IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS
Areola: Closed.
Rostrum: Terminates in a strong point with weak marginal spines.
Chela: Long and thin; dorsal surface covered in red tubercles.
Tubercles: Carapace covered in small, red tubercles.
Gonopods: Multiple stout, robust, curved terminal
elements on form 1 gonopod. Areola
Habitat: Secondary burrowers. A generalist
but prefers sluggish to stagnant waters.
Burrows are often simple and shallow
where documented in Michigan. Burrows
often inhabited by multiple females
and single male.
Chela
Color notes: Body colors in Form 1
wild individuals range from Gonopods
crimson to olive, brown and
black. Individuals in the pet Rostrum
trade have been reported
being bright blue, white,
candy cane-colored and an
assortment of other unique
patterns.
Tubercles
29
Other prohibited species
Marbled crayfish
Marbled crayfish, also known as marmokreb (Procambarus virginalis), is an invasive
species threat that has the potential to harm Michigan’s natural resources and
economy. For this reason, it has been listed as a prohibited species in Michigan,
making it unlawful to possess, introduce, import, sell or offer the sale in the state.8
The marbled crayfish is a unique species believed to have been the result of aquarium
breeding. They can self-replicate and have aggressive behavioral traits, allowing for
rapid colonization when introduced into natural habitats. Introduction of a single
individual can result in the establishment and spread of a population. Marbled
crayfish can quickly dominate lakes, ponds, rivers and wetlands. Introduced
populations of marbled crayfish in Madagascar and several European countries have
spread rapidly. They feed heavily on plants, snails, and amphibians, aggressively
competing with native species for food and habitat. In addition, they dig burrows,
which causes instability of riparian soils, increasing the potential for shoreline
erosion. Marbled crayfish are readily available in the aquarium trade, so there is a
high risk of introduction and spread
through the release of live unwanted
pets. Although they have not been
documented in Michigan, their
popularity in the aquarium trade
makes them a high risk for future
introductions. Marbled crayfish were
added to Michigan’s prohibited
species list and invasive species watch
list in May 2020.
Chucholl C. / CC BY-SA
Common yabby
Common yabby (Cherax destructor) is native to eastern Australia and has been
introduced into Western Australia and several countries in Europe, Asia and Africa.
Their spread is likely due to their availability in the live food and aquarium trades.
When introduced, yabby have the potential to displace native crayfish species, alter
habitat, consume large amounts of native aquatic species and spread disease. Yabby
can tolerate a wide range of environmental conditions,
which allows them to establish and spread in new places.
No wild populations have been
documented in the United States; however, their
popularity in the aquarium trade raises concern over
potential introductions. To prevent future introductions,
yabby are prohibited in Michigan and most other states
and provinces in the Great Lakes region.
8: Michigan Invasive Species Order Amendment No. 1 of 2020. Approved May 14, 2020.
30
Invasive species regulations & reporting
Red swamp crayfish, yabby crayfish and marbled crayfish are listed as prohibited
species in Michigan, meaning they cannot be possessed, sold, imported, introduced
or transported live. Rusty crayfish, which are restricted in the state, may be harvested
for personal consumption (see below); however they are illegal to commercially
take, possess or sell. Invasive crayfish may not be used for bait, whether alive or dead,
on any private or public waters.
Any observations of red swamp, yabby or marbled crayfish should be reported to the
Michigan DNR Fisheries Division at DNR-Fisheries@Michigan.gov.
More information about watch list species and reporting can be found at the
Michigan invasive species website, Michigan.gov/Invasives.
Harvest regulations
• Native crayfish can be harvested in all waters open to fishing with the
possession of a recreational fishing license.
• Rusty crayfish may only be harvested and posessed live for personal
consumption.
• Fishing methods can include traps, nets, spears, hook and line, or hand
harvesting.
• Native crayfish may be taken and used for bait except on the Michigan-
Wisconsin boundary waters.