Download
Download
Download
Enfermagem
2019;27:e3140
DOI: 10.1590/1518-8345.2777-3140
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
Original Article
Chaves AFL, Ximenes LB, Rodrigues DP, Vasconcelos CTM, Monteiro JCS, Oriá MOB. Telephone intervention
in the promotion of self-efficacy, duration and exclusivity of breastfeeding: randomized controlled
trial. Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem. 2019;27:e3140. [Access ___ __ ____]; Available in: ___________________ .
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1518-8345.2777-3140. month day year URL
2 Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem 2019;27:e3140.
successfully, which involves knowledge and skill. Trial (CRT) conducted in the period from May to
This factor has been shown to have a positive effect November, 2015, in a District Hospital in the city of
on the duration and exclusivity of BF, promoting in Fortaleza, Ceará. The inclusion criteria were being
the woman the feeling that she is able to modify in the immediate puerperium, single full-term
her behaviors aiming at better health conditions for gestation with newborns hospitalized in rooming-
both her and her child(3). in (RI), being practicing BF and having at least
Several technologies have been used to one telephone number for contact. We excluded
improve maternal self-efficacy in breastfeeding women whose children presented deficiencies that
and the prevalence of BF and EBF (workshops, prevented breastfeeding, presented some type of
educational booklets, album, telephone). Among contraindication for breastfeeding and impaired
these, telephone use has been increasingly used, hearing. The criteria for discontinuation were
being seen as a useful tool capable of promoting BF, maternal or newborn death during the course
proving to be effective when the interventions are of the study, interruption of the BF before the
performed in the long term during the puerperium intervention was completed, and failure to answer
and by health experts with mastery and experience telephone calls after three attempts at different
in breastfeeding(4). days and times.
A US study of 298 women that used a For the sample calculation, we used a
telephone contact intervention developed by formula for comparative group studies, adopting
prenatal breastfeeding consultants up to six months the following values: Z5% = 1.96, z20% = 0.84,
after delivery found that women in the intervention p1 = proportion of the outcome in the control of
group (IG) had longer duration of BF and were 30%, p2 = proportion of the outcome in the 55%
more likely to continue the EBF . A randomized
(5) experiment, n = sample size, confidence coefficient
experimental study involving 461 Nigerian women, = 95%, test power = 80%. Thus, by replacing the
in which counseling on BF was implemented through values, 57 puerperal women would be required
meetings with songs and dramatizations, telephone for each group. However, a safety percentage of
follow-up and text messages, found that women 15% was added based on the losses of a study that
from the IG were more likely to practice EBF with addressed self-efficacy in breastfeeding using the
one month (Odds Ratio: 1.6, p = 0.10), 3 months telephone(7) for possible telephone losses, making
(OR: 1.8, p <0.05) and 6 months (OR: 2.4, p up a total of 66 puerperal women per group, totaling
<0.01)(6). 132 postpartum women. Participants were allocated
Several aspects have already been addressed randomly in two groups:
during the telephone interventions, such as - Intervention Group (GI): Telephone educational
breastfeeding benefits and techniques, cultural intervention. In addition to the assistance and
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
Chaves AFL, Ximenes LB, Rodrigues DP, Vasconcelos CTM, Monteiro JCS, Oriá MOB. 3
routine individual service activities provided by the the admission to the obstetric ward, the puerperal
child-friendly hospital professionals, the women women were approached about their consent
received an educational intervention by telephone. to participate in the research, after receiving
The intervention consisted of a telephone call explanation on the objectives and benefits thereof.
lasting seven minutes, on average, made by an Subsequently, the participants answered a form
experienced nurse and lactation educator, in which containing sociodemographic, obstetrical and
she initially introduced herself and recalled the breastfeeding data and the BSES-SF, which assessed
approach in the rooming-in, in order to establish the participants’ maternal self-efficacy. At the end
a bond with the infant. Subsequently, using a form of the study, the following primary outcomes were
that followed the principles of the Motivational assessed: self-efficacy of women in breastfeeding,
Interview (MI), the evoking-informing-evoking duration and exclusivity of breastfeeding.
technique was used, which is recommended to The BSES-SF was validated in Brazil, with
change patients’ behaviors in a collaborative way, Cronbach’s alpha of 0.74, showing to be a
based on their motivation . At each call, guidance
(8)
reliable instrument(11). It is composed of 14 items
was given on two items on the scale to which women randomly distributed in two domains (technique
showed lower self-efficacy in the rooming-in; these and intrapersonal thoughts) related to maternal
guidelines were based on the instrument created confidence in breastfeeding, which has a Likert
by the researcher, based on the Breastfeeding Self- type scale ranging from 1 to 5 points. Mothers are
Efficacy Scale - Short Form (BSES-SF) (9)
and in the classified as follows: Low efficacy: 14 to 32 points;
Serial Album “I can breastfeed my child”(10), which Average efficacy: 33 to 51 points; High efficacy: 52
addressed issues on technique and interpersonal to 70 points. This instrument is self-applied when
thinking on breastfeeding. The doubts of the women the participant has the ability to read and answer to
were solved and, when necessary, they were guided the questions. In view of the public involved in this
to seek the institution’s milk bank. research, the application was through an interview
- Control Group (CG): Women received only the conducted by the researchers.
routine guidelines of the child-friendly hospital, that In the second phase, the intervention was
is, individual routine service activities. made to the IG women through three telephone
After the initial approach to the women in the contacts within one month, in the days previously
rooming-in, the randomization was performed in established with the patients, being at 7 days, 15
“blocks”, 13 blocks of 10 puerperal women and days and 30 days after childbirth. In the third phase,
one block of two puerperal women. This type of also by telephone, the evaluation of the primary
randomization was important for equitable initial outcomes was performed based on BSES-SF and on
distribution between groups to facilitate logistics a specific form developed by the authors, applied to
in collecting data from subsequent phases. both groups.
Randomization occurred by a computerized Of the 132 participants evaluated for eligibility,
algorithm performed by a first statistician. Thus, only 77 composed the final sample due to the
each puerperal woman was allocated to participate discontinuity criteria, in which there was 40.9% of
in a group based on chance, that is, with the loss, as detailed in Figure 1.
same chance of being distributed in one of the The data obtained were compiled in the
comparison groups. Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS)
This research involved a team, encompassing program, version 20.0. Continuous variables were
nurses and nursing academics, previously trained expressed as medians with a 95% confidence
to evaluate outcomes. These people were blinded interval, and categorical variables in absolute and
as well as the statistician responsible for the relative frequencies. For the comparisons between
analysis. However, the researcher responsible for the groups, we used the chi-square, Fisher, Pearson
the intervention and the research participants were and Mann-Whitney U tests.
not blinded. The study was approved by the Ethics and
The research was divided into three phases. Research Committee of the Federal University of
The first phase took place on a day-to-day basis in Ceará (Opinion 1,026,156) and registered in the
the recruitment of puerperal women for a period Brazilian Registry of Clinical Trials (ReBEC) (UTN:
of three months in the rooming-in unit. During U1111-1180-5341).
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
4 Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem 2019;27:e3140.
Calculated sample
114 participants
to possible losses
132 participants
(100% of the foreseen
sample)
Randomization
Allocation of
66 participants
patients
66 participants
Intervention Group
Control Group
7-day
Educational
Session
56 (84.%) participants
Losses: 10 (15.2%)
- Did not answer/phone off (9)
- Stopped breastfeeding (1)
15-day
Educational
Session
Follow-up
49 (74.2%) participants
Losses: 7 (10.6%)
- Did not answer/phone off (6)
- Stopped breastfeeding (1)
30-day
Educational
Session
43 (65.1%) participants
Losses: 6 (9.1%)
- Did not answer/phone off (6)
- Stopped breastfeeding (0)
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
Chaves AFL, Ximenes LB, Rodrigues DP, Vasconcelos CTM, Monteiro JCS, Oriá MOB. 5
Table 1 - Sociodemographic and obstetric data of the participants. Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, 2015
Intervention (n=66) Control (n=66)
Variable p-value‡
Md*±SD †
n(%) Md*±SD† n(%)
Occupation 0.738**
Parity 0.541¶
No 1 (3.1) 5 (19.2)
*Median; †Standard deviation; ‡p-value; §Mann-Whitney test; || Minimum wage: R$ 788.00, 2015, Brazil; ¶Chi-square test; **Fisher’s exact test
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
6 Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem 2019;27:e3140.
decrease. With regard to the fourth month, most women On the other hand, marital status influenced
in the IG remained in BF when compared to the CG, but maternal self-efficacy in breastfeeding. Women living
it was not statistically significant. with their partner may have increased self-efficacy in
breastfeeding, since partner support may be a protective
98
p*=0.109 of utmost importance to guarantee qualified attention
94
achieve a positive repercussion in the beginning and
duration of BF.
92
Among the women of the IG, there was a
90
predominance of occupation as housewives; however,
88
this difference between the groups did not significantly
86
influence breastfeeding. Nevertheless, the literature
84
points out that this aspect may favor exclusive
82
Baseline 2 months 4 months breastfeeding, considering that women who work out of
Intervention Group Control Group home feel more distressed with the child’s adaptation to
a new food pattern and offer the bottle prematurely(16).
*Mann-Whitney U Test
Despite the greater predominance of primiparous
Figure 3 - Intergroup comparison of duration of
women in the CG, no difference was identified in the
breastfeeding over time. Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, 2015
groups regarding maternal self-efficacy in breastfeeding.
Primiparity is, in most cases, identified as a risk factor
The intergroup comparison of the exclusivity of BF
for low self-efficacy in breastfeeding, which may have
indicates that both groups (CG/IG) presented minimal
repercussions on adherence to this practice(6,16). Thus,
differences regarding the exclusivity of BF at two and
these mothers need to receive care from the beginning of
four months (Figure 4). Thus, it is evident that the
prenatal care through counseling, educational activities
educational intervention did not influence the exclusivity
and a practical approach aiming at a better performance
of BF.
in their first experience in breastfeeding.
The educational intervention did not influence
120 breastfeeding at two months (p = 0.773). However, it
p*=not significant
100 was effective at four months, increasing the self-efficacy
80 of breastfeeding among mothers of the IG. Similar
p*=0.98
60 results were found in a pilot study conducted in Canada,
p*=0.573
40 which developed an intervention focused on self-efficacy
0
difference between the groups in the self-efficacy until
Baseline 2 months 4 months the second month; however, the mothers belonging
Intervention Group Control Group to the IG presented higher levels of self-efficacy in
breastfeeding at four and eight weeks after delivery
*Pearson’s Chi-Square
compared to mothers of the CG(17).
Figure 4 - Intergroup comparison of exclusive
Thus, in the short term, mothers tend to maintain
breastfeeding over time. Fortaleza, CE, Brazil, 2015
high self-efficacy in breastfeeding regardless of
intervention. This may be related to pre-existing factors,
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
Chaves AFL, Ximenes LB, Rodrigues DP, Vasconcelos CTM, Monteiro JCS, Oriá MOB. 7
the time. A recent research has pointed out that there telephone support developed by trained nurses, focused
are several factors that contribute to discontinuation of on self-efficacy in breastfeeding and based on the
exclusive breastfeeding (low milk production, difficulty in approach of MI increases the mothers’ self-efficacy in
attachment, breast complications and lack of confidence breastfeeding and increases the duration of BF, but does
in breastfeeding)(13). Thus, in order to overcome this not influence the exclusivity of BF.
complex challenge, health professionals need to expand The most relevant contribution of this research is
their area of intervention so that interventions address to make evident that telephone support consists of a
different problems. viable technology in the promotion of BF, especially if it
In the face of globalization, nursing has been using is used as an educational component, and that can be
Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) as idealized and applied in the health services with the aim
a way to develop care in the different health settings, and of improving the rates of BF and EBF.
the telephone is an effective tool for communication(19). However, it is important to point out that the
In the present study, the intervention performed by telephone should be considered as a form of support in
telephone was developed during four weeks through the the assistance to mother and child to promote BF, and
guidance of a trained nurse. Comparing the findings of should not replace direct contact, attention and care of
this study with an American study in which a telephone professionals to this binomial.
intervention was carried out by lactation consultants The high sample loss rate (40.9%) is a limitation
certified by the International Board of Lactation of this study, which restricts the generalization of the
Consultant Examiners (IBLCE) for up to 72 hours after
effects. However, this RCT is a pioneering initiative in
delivery, one can identify better BF and EBF rates in the
Brazil that may not only fill this gap in the literature but
Brazilian study. The duration of breastfeeding was 4.3
also increase the knowledge of limitations that can be
weeks shorter in the IG than in the CG (p = 0.08), which
adjusted in future replications.
was also observed at 30 and 90 days (p = 0.10 and p =
0.08, respectively). The duration of EBF was 4.7 weeks Conclusion
shorter in the IG than in the CG(20).
Although the previously presented studies show The results of this study provide positive evidence
significant limitations, such as specific public and small on the effectiveness of professional telephone support
sample size, the findings allow us to understand that for the promotion of BF. This short-term educational
educational interventions carried out for a short period intervention was able to increase self-efficacy and
show gaps in their efficacy . (4)
duration of BF, but did not influence exclusivity. It
The only study found in the literature conducted is believed that this research can contribute to the
for a short period that obtained a satisfactory result in innovation of the care methodology, considering that
the duration and exclusivity of BF had as intervention it is a new possibility of strategy to be added to those
a telephone follow-up aimed at the specific difficulties already used in the health services. However, further
of the mothers, being developed by nurses that were research is needed to explore and identify the reasons for
lactation consultants up to four weeks after delivery. persistently low EBF rates and to test new interventions
Mother of the IG were more likely to maintain BF at either that seek to improve these rates.
one month (OR: 1.63) or at two months (OR: 1.48).
The intervention provided a higher rate of mothers in References
EBF in the IG at one month (OR = 1.89, p = 0.003) .
(21)
The factors that may have contributed to these positive 1. Almeida JM, Luz SAB, Ued FV. Support of breastfeeding
findings were the fact that professionals were certified by health professionals: integrative review of the literature.
as lactation consultants and the very characteristic of Rev Paul Pediatr. [Internet].2015 Sep [cited Nov 15,
the intervention, that is, being focused on the problems 2017];33(3):355-62. Available from: http://www.scielo.
and doubts of the puerperal women. br/pdf/rpp/v33n3/en_0103-0582-rpp-33-03-0355.pdf
On the other hand, surveys that had representative 2. Boccolini CS, Boccolini PMM, Monteiro FR, Venâncio SI,
samples and whose interventions were developed for a Giugliani ERJ. Breastfeeding indicators trends in Brazil
long period had a significant effect on BF (22-24)
, evidencing for three decades. Rev Saúde Pública. [Internet].2017
the importance of postpartum follow-up, a period seen Sep [cited Sep 29, 2018];51:108. Available from:
as critical in relation to breast problems and difficulties, h t t p : / / w w w. s c i e l o. b r / p d f / r s p / v 5 1 / 0 0 3 4 - 8 9 1 0 -
which favors the woman to wean prematurely. rsp-S1518-87872017051000029.pdf
Thus, these results show that an educational 3. Guimarães CMS, Conde RG, Gomes-Sponholz FA, Oriá
intervention carried out by means of short-term MOB, Monteiro JCS. Factors related with breastfeeding
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
8 Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem 2019;27:e3140.
self-efficacy immediate after birth in puerperal adolescent. 11. Uchôa JL, Gomes ALA, Joventino ES, Oriá MOB,
Acta Paul Enferm. [Internet].2017 Mar [cited Sep 29, Ximenes LB, Almeida PC. Sociodemographic and obstetric
2018];30(1):109-15. Available from: http://www.scielo. history in maternal self-efficacy in nursing: a study in
br/pdf/ape/v30n1/en_1982-0194-ape-30-01-0109.pdf panel. Online Braz J Nurs. (Online). [Internet].2014 Sep
4. Oriá MOB, Dodou HD, Chaves AFL, Santos LMDA, [cited Nov 4, 2017];13(4):645-55. Available from: http://
Ximenes LB, Vasconcelos CTM. Effectiveness of educational www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=361441682017
interventions conducted by telephone to promote 12. Dodt RCM, Ferreira AMVF, Nascimento LA, Macêdo AC,
breastfeeding: a systematic review of the literature. Joventino ES, Ximenes LB. Influence of health education
Rev Esc Enferm USP. [Internet]. 2018 [cited Sep 29, strategy mediated by a self-efficacy breastfeeding serial
2018];52:e03333. Available from: http://www.scielo. album. Texto Contexto Enferm. [Internet].2013 Jul/Sep
br/pdf/reeusp/v52/1980-220X-reeusp-52-e03333.pdf [cited Nov 23, 2017];22(3):610-8. Available from: http://
5. Efrat MW, Esparza S, Mendelson SG, Lane CH. The www.scielo.br/pdf/tce/v22n3/en_v22n3a06.pdf
effect of lactation educators implementing a telephone- 13. Amaral LJX, Sales SS, Carvalho DPSRP, Cruz GKP,
based intervention among low-income Hispanics: a Azevedo IC, Ferreira MA Junior. Factors that influence
randomised trial. Health Educ J. [Internet].2015 [cited the interruption of exclusive breastfeeding in nursing
July 10, 2018];74(4):424-41. Available from: https:// mothers. Rev Gaúcha Enferm. [Internet].2015 [cited
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4771064/ Nov 20, 2017];36(spe):127-34. Available from: http://
6. Flax VL, Negerie M, Ibrahim AU, Leatherman S, www.scielo.br/pdf/rgenf/v36nspe/en_0102-6933-rgenf-
Daza EJ, Bentley ME. Integrating group counseling, cell 36-spe-0127.pdf
phone messaging, and participant-generated songs and 14. Machado MCM, Assis KF, Oliveira FCCO, Ribeiro AQ,
dramas into a microcredit program increases Nigerian Araújo RMA, Faisal-Cury A, et al. Determinants of the
women’s adherence to international breastfeeding exclusive breastfeeding abandonment: psychosocial
recommendations. J Nutr. [Internet].2014 [cited July factors. Rev Saúde Pública. [Internet].2014 Dec [cited
12, 2018];144(7):1120-4. Available from: https://www. Nov 12, 2017];48(6):985-94. Available from: http://www.
ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4481538/ scielo.br/pdf/rsp/v48n6/0034-8910-rsp-48-6-0985.pdf
7. Srinivas GL, Benson M, Worley S, Schulte E. A 15. Rodrigues AP, Padoin SMM, Paula CC, Guido LA. Pre-
clinic-based breastfeeding peer counselor intervention natal and puerperium factors that interfere on self-efficacy
in an urban, low-income population: interaction in breastfeeding. Rev Enferm UFPE on line. [Internet].2013
with breastfeeding attitude. J Hum Lactation. Apr/Jun [cited Nov 20, 2017];7(esp):4144-52. Available
[Internet].2015 Aug [cited Oct 25, 2018];31(1):120- from: http://www.scielo.br/pdf/ean/v18n2/en_1414-
8. Available from: http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pd 8145-ean-18-02-0257.pdf
f/10.1177/0890334414548860?casa_token=963XRzC 16. Margotti E, Epifanio M. Exclusive maternal breastfeeding
pzHkAAAAA:AjL98NHh8VZIDH7K6fypeb2ThvZI4Z6oO_ and the Breastfeeding Self-efficacy Scale. Rev RENE.
yQhd3urLIINjzW1DjKBSH22NMWNS20BL40YdKUJoeEodE [Internet].2014 Sep/Oct [cited Nov 20, 2017];15(5):771-
8. Lima TM, Nicolau AIO, Carvalho FHC, Vasconcelos CTM, 9. Available from: http://www.periodicos.ufc.br/rene/
Aquino PS, Pinheiro AKB. Telephone interventions for article/view/3240/2495
adherence to colpocytological examination. Rev. Latino- 17. Mcqueen KA, Dennis CL, Stremler R, Norman CD. A
Am. Enfermagem. [Internet].2017 Feb [cited Nov 12, Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial of a Breastfeeding Self-
2017];25:e2844. Available from: http://www.scielo.br/ Efficacy Intervention With Primiparous Mothers. J Obstet
pdf/rlae/v25/0104-1169-rlae-25-02844.pdf Gynecol Neonatal Nurs. [Internet].2011 Jan/Feb [cited
9. Dodt RCM, Ximenes LB, Almeida PC, Oria MOB, Dennis Nov 21, 2017];40(1):35-46. Available from: https://www.
CL. Psychometric assessment of the short form version jognn.org/article/S0884-2175(15)30518-9/pdf
of the Breastfeeding Self-Efficacy Scale in a Brazilian 18. Margotti E, Margotti W. Factors related to Exclusive
sample. J Nurs Educ Pract. [Internet].2012 Aug [cited Breastfeeding in Babies born in a childfriendly hospital in a
Sep 29, 2018];2(3):66-73. Available from: http://www. capital of Northern Brazil. Saúde Debate. [Internet].2017
sciedu.ca/journal/index.php/jnep/article/view/627/553 Jul [cited Oct 25, 2018];41(114):860-71. Available from:
10. Dodt RCM, Joventino ES, Aquino PS, Almeida PC, Ximenes http://www.scielo.br/pdf/sdeb/v41n114/0103-1104-
LB. An experimental study of an educational intervention sdeb-41-114-0860.pdf
to promote maternal self-efficacy in breastfeeding. Rev. 19. Barbosa IA, Silva MJP. Nursing care by telehealth:
Latino-Am. Enfermagem. [Internet].2015 Jul/Aug [cited what is the influence of distance on communication?
Nov 12, 2017];23(4):725-32. Available from: https:// Rev Bras Enferm. [Internet].2017 Fev [cited Dec 17,
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4623736/ 2018];70(5):978-84. Available from: http://www.scielo.
pdf/0104-1169-rlae-23-04-00725.pdf br/pdf/reben/v70n5/pt_0034-7167-reben-70-05-0928.pdf
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae
Chaves AFL, Ximenes LB, Rodrigues DP, Vasconcelos CTM, Monteiro JCS, Oriá MOB. 9
www.eerp.usp.br/rlae