Clinical Outcomes in Patients With Scaphoid Non Un
Clinical Outcomes in Patients With Scaphoid Non Un
Clinical Outcomes in Patients With Scaphoid Non Un
Injury
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/injury
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Introduction: Non-union is a prevalent complication of scaphoid fractures. Late diagnosis is common and has a
Vascularized clinical impact due to functional limitations for the patient. Multiple treatments have been proposed to manage
Medial this complication, ranging from conservative (i.e., orthopedic) to surgical treatment. The vascularized medial
Femoral
femoral condyle technique has shown satisfactory clinical and paraclinical results, mainly in presence of avas
Scaphoid
Nonunion
cular necrosis of the proximal pole but data regarding functional outcomes and patient satisfaction is scarce.
Case series This case series aims to describe the clinical and patient-reported outcomes in a consecutive series of patients
Technique with non-union of the proximal third of the scaphoid treated with vascularized medial femoral condyle
technique.
Methods: Case series reporting results for a consecutive – initial cohort of patients who presented with a non
united fracture of the proximal pole of the scaphoid, avascular necrosis of the proximal pole was documented by
CT od MRI imaging preoperatively in all patients. Measurement instruments include the q-DASH and PRWE
questionnaires, radiographic images, goniometry, and assessment of grip strength.
Results: Twelve consecutive patients are included and they represent the initial cases for all surgeons involved;
bone union was obtained in 10 patients (83%) after a mean follow-up time of 31 months (6–72), successful
improvement in the range of motion and grip strength was documented. A high rate of satisfaction expressed by
the patient was obtained, with an average score in Q-DASH of 17.3 and 20.1 in PRWE.
Conclusions: The vascularized medial condyle technique in cases of nonunion of scaphoid fracture is a repro
ducible treatment in clinical terms, both in imaging and functional terms, and in patient satisfaction. The
learning curve is flat for a dedicated multi surgeon team.
Introduction burden for the health system and impacts the productivity of this pop
ulation [5]. One of the main characteristics of this fracture is the subtlety
The incidence of fractures of the hand and wrist is increasing. The of the symptoms, associated with the difficulty of imaging diagnosis
increase is in part due to more active lifestyles and sports practice in the through conventional radiographs, which explains why 10 and 25% of
general population [1]. The scaphoid is the most frequently fractured of these fractures are not diagnosed at the time of the injury and remain
the carpal bones in the adult and pediatric population [2,3], corre unrecognized until non-union symptoms appear [6]. The primary
sponding to approximately 60 to 90% of all carpal fractures in the complications of scaphoid fractures are non-union, osteonecrosis, carpal
working age [4]. This fracture also represents a considerable economic instability, and arthritis [7].
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2023.04.014
Accepted 12 April 2023
Available online 14 April 2023
0020-1383/© 2023 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
L.A. García-González et al. Injury 54 (2023) 110727
Regarding non-union, its incidence is 2/100,000 and 0.4/100,000 with an unstable nonunion, absent or minimal arthrosis and avascular
for men and women, respectively, corresponding to 10–15% of all necrosis of the proximal pole.
scaphoid fractures. These numbers place scaphoid non-union as the most The protocol was presented to and authorized by the institutional
frequent complication after a fracture [8]. Any fracture that persists for Research and Ethics Committee. All patients signed a specific informed
more than six months is considered non-union [9]; in this anatomical consent for this study.
scenario, non-union is a relevant complication due to secondary func First, a review of the clinical records was conducted to establish the
tional limitation. Risk factors for the development of scaphoid reason for consultation and mechanism of trauma. Patients were con
non-union have been identified, such as the no use of a splint, tacted by phone, and then interviewed and examined at the clinic.
anatomical location (i.e., proximal fractures), soft tissue interposition, Sociodemographic characteristics and the variables to measure the
fracture comminution, and proximal pole fracture displacement with clinical and functional outcomes were collected.
associated instability and/or avascular necrosis [10]. Proximal pole As instruments for measuring the clinical variables, radiographs
fractures are related to vascular supply interruption of the scaphoid and taken at the time of the follow-up indicated for the present study were
secondary avascular necrosis [8]. used, with the aim of assessing graft integration according to Hanne
The use of bone grafts has been proposed as a therapeutic option mann criteria, [24] using the institutional radiographic imaging com
since 1920 with satisfactory results [11]. This treatment modality in puter program: Kanteron Systems S.L.U.
cludes non-vascularized bone grafts (NVBGs), which in presence of In addition, motion arcs and grip strength were measured on patients
avascular necrosis have a union rate as low as 47% [12]. Therefore, available for in-person follow-up.
vascularized bone grafts (VGB) have gained traction because of their Patients’ satisfaction was assessed by two questions during the
biological properties to provide vascular flow [13,14]. Vascularized interview: “If necessary, would you have this surgery done on you
bone grafts can be pedunculated or free. Pedunculated bone grafts again?” and “Are you overall satisfied with the function of your hand for
consist of a bone segment of an adjacent bone (i.e., radius) that is rotated work and daily life duties?”; functional outcomes were collected through
to fill the scaphoid bone defect, maintaining vascular supply to the the disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand questionnaire – shortened
transferred bone. However, in cases of carpal collapse or humpback version (Q-DASH) [25,26] and the patient-rated wrist evaluation ques
deformity, pedunculated bone graft has lower union rates (50%) [15]. tionnaire (PRWE) [20,27]. The Q-DASH includes 11 items, 8 aimed at
Additional challenges related to pedicle length, graft handling in case of reintroduction to daily, social and work life, and 3 assessing symptoms.
scaphoid deformity, and the association of soft tissue or distal radius The second questionnaire has 15 questions, of which 5 questions
trauma may preclude the use of local bone graft. correspond to pain measures and 10 questions evaluate wrist function in
Free bone grafts can overcome these difficulties by using a bone daily activities. Out of the two questionnaires, the score of 0 was the best
segment that receives vascular supply when anastomosed [16]. Among and 100 was the worst. Both questionnaires have been validated for
the surgical techniques, the vascularized medial femoral condyle tech Spanish language application in previous studies. Post-operative com
nique described by Doi et al. represents one of the most used methods to plications were also explored and reported.
treat this condition. The technique fits a vascularized bone segment into The data obtained were entered into an Excel database (Microsoft®
the scaphoid bone defect, providing vascular supply by the radial artery Excel® for Microsoft 365 MSO version 2110 compilation
microvascular anastomoses. It represents one of the most used methods 16.0.14527.20234), means and standard deviation were calculated
to treat this condition [17].This technique has been evaluated in several where applicable.
publications regarding its ability to consolidate, showing percentages of
effectiveness close to 90% [18–20], and mean consolidation times be Surgical technique
tween 12 and 22 weeks [20]. However, the scientific literature sup
porting the technique in terms of function and patients’ satisfaction is With the patient under general anesthesia, in supine position, the
lacking. No clinical trials compare the vascularized bone graft surgical wrist is approached through a volar incision following the Flexor Carpi
techniques in this scenario. radialis (FCR) tendon (Fig. 1A). At this point, the lunate bone is evalu
After non-union, avascular necrosis and progressive degenerative ated by fluoroscopy and it is determined if there is extension deformity,
changes might occur. Radio carpal osteoarthritis is reported in up 100% correcting it if necessary. The scaphoid is exposed via a volar capsu
of cases [21,22] with cyst formation, bone resorption, and scaphoid lotomy, fragments are debrided and final shape and size of the defect is
humpback deformity [16] leading to articular wrist collapse (SNAC: determined (Fig. 1B). The vascularized medial femoral condyle harvest
scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse) and dorsal intercalated segment technique in avascular necrosis of scaphoid fractures begins with a
instability (DISI) secondary to the scaphoid proximal pole extension longitudinal medial incision centered on the distal portion of the vastus
with the lunate bone [16]. The pathological mechanisms above have
functional implications for the patient regarding wrist mobility, grip
strength and interference with daily activities [23]. Thus, the treatment
[7] and the scientific evidence supporting the different surgical tech
niques are crucial to improving overall treatment success.
This study aims to describe the clinical and patient-reported out
comes of patients with scaphoid non-union and avascular necrosis,
treated with the vascularized medial femoral condyle technique by a
team of four different hand surgeons and to document the involved
learning curve process.
2
L.A. García-González et al. Injury 54 (2023) 110727
medialis that extends from the knee joint line proximally 20 cm (the
ipsilateral femur was chosen for use of a crutch or cane in the opposite
hand if necessary after surgery) (Fig. 2A). The vastus medialis muscle is
identified at its medial border and elevated from the fascia of its
compartment, then the descending genicular and medial genicular
vessels are identified, to subsequently select the larger of the two that
supplies the periosteum and the bone of the medial femoral condyle.
Next a vascularized cortico-cancellous bone graft is extracted based on
this pedicle and of sufficient size to fill the scaphoid defect (Fig. 2b and
C).
The graft is contoured to fit the scaphoid defect, correcting the
humpback deformity (if any) and restoring normal scaphoid length.
Positioning is confirmed by fluoroscopy examination and fixation is
carried out with a headless compression screw (2,3 to 3,0 mm in
diameter) (Fig. 3A to D) . Following this, the radial artery and
concomitant veins are exposed proximally and end-to-side artery repair
is performed on the radial artery, and end-to-end venous repair is per
formed on the concomitant veins (Fig. 4). Finally, blood flow through
the anastomosis to the graft is confirmed. The operated upper limb is left
immobilized for 6 to 10 weeks. [17,20,28,29]. Antithrombotic therapy
was instated with low molecular weight heparin for 1 week after surgery
and then discontinued.
Results
Fig. 2. A: Surgical approach to medial condyle of the femur. B and C: Deep dissection and graft isolation.
3
L.A. García-González et al. Injury 54 (2023) 110727
Discussion
Fig. 5. T2 images in MRI depicting avascular necrosis of the proximal pole of the scaphoid.
4
L.A. García-González et al. Injury 54 (2023) 110727
present results that are comparable to the results reported in our study. [6] Reigstad O, Grimsgaard C, Thorkildsen R, Reigstad A, Røkkum M. Scaphoid non-
unions, where do they come from? The epidemiology and initial presentation of
Additionally, it has been reported in the literature that the arc of
270 scaphoid non-unions. Hand Surg 2012;17(03):331–5.
movement necessary for normal wrist function is 40 to 45◦ in extension [7] Imaging and treatment of scaphoid fractures and their complications. In:
and 35 to 40◦ in flexion, which makes the results obtained at this level Taljanovic MS, Karantanas A, Griffith JF, DeSilva GL, Rieke JD, Sheppard JE,
successful. [4] editors. Seminars in musculoskeletal radiology. Thieme Medical Publishers; 2012.
[8] Jones Jr DB, Bürger H, Bishop AT, Shin AY. Treatment of scaphoid waist nonunions
Finally, in the publication by Keller et al., a mean preoperative DASH with an avascular proximal pole and carpal collapse: a comparison of two
score of 59 points was reported in this same intervention, which vascularized bone grafts. JBJS 2008;90(12):2616–25.
decreased statistically significantly (p = 0.03) to 11 points at the end of [9] Compson J. The anatomy of acute scaphoid fractures: a three-dimensional analysis
of patterns. J Bone Joint Surg Brit Vol 1998;80(2):218–24.
the proposed 16-month follow-up, as well as well as the mean PRWE [10] Szabo RM, Manske D. Displaced fractures of the scaphoid. Clin Orthop Relat Res
score went from 62 points preoperatively to 30 points at 16 months of 1988;(230):30–8.
follow-up [20], the latter being a result similar to that scored by the [11] Russe O. Fracture of the carpal navicular: diagnosis, non-operative treatment, and
operative treatment. JBJS 1960;42(5):759–68.
patients in our study. [12] Merrell GA, Wolfe SW, Slade III JF. Treatment of scaphoid nonunions: quantitative
As mentioned above, this series represents the initial cases for all meta-analysis of the literature. J Hand Surg Am 2002;27(4):685–91.
surgeons involved, all cases were operated by two teams working [13] Tu Y-K, Bishop AT, Kato T, Adams ML, Wood MB. Experimental carpal reverse-flow
pedicle vascularized bone grafts. Part II: bone blood flow measurement by
simultaneously, surgical time decreased from 6 h to 3,5 h. Complications radioactive-labeled microspheres in a canine model. J Hand Surg Am 2000;25(1):
included one wound hematoma (case 1), one hardware pain that 46–54.
required removal (case 2) and two persistent nounions (cases 2 and 3), [14] Tu Y-k, Bishop AT, Kato T, Adams ML, Wood MB. Experimental carpal reverse-flow
pedicle vascularized bone grafts. Part I: the anatomical basis of vascularized
the authors think that the learning curve is not steep and that this is a
pedicle bone grafts based on the canine distal radius and ulna. J Hand Surg Am
reproducible procedure for variable experienced hand surgery teams 2000;25(1):34–45.
with interest and training in microvascular surgery. [15] Chang MA, Bishop AT, Moran SL, Shin AY. The outcomes and complications of 1, 2-
The limitations of our study are the lack of comparison with preop intercompartmental supraretinacular artery pedicled vascularized bone grafting of
scaphoid nonunions. J Hand Surg Am 2006;31(3):387–96.
erative clinical and satisfaction variables, the small sample size and the [16] Al-Jabri T, Mannan A, Giannoudis P. The use of the free vascularised bone graft for
lack in knowledge regarding the time of fracture consolidation due to nonunion of the scaphoid: a systematic review. J Orthopaed Surg Res 2014;9(1):
the missed follow-up of the patients until the moment of contacting them 1–9.
[17] Doi K, Oda T, Soo-Heong T, Nanda V. Free vascularized bone graft for nonunion of
for the present study. However, we consider that this is one of the few the scaphoid. J Hand Surg Am 2000;25(3):507–19.
studies that includes objective and subjective variables to assess the [18] Ditsios K, Konstantinidis I, Agas K, Christodoulou A. Comparative meta-analysis on
success of the surgical procedure performed as a strength. the various vascularized bone flaps used for the treatment of scaphoid nonunion.
J Orthopaed Res 2017;35(5):1076–85.
[19] Elgammal A, Lukas B. Vascularized medial femoral condyle graft for management
Conclusion of scaphoid non-union. J Hand Surg (Eur Vol) 2015;40(8):848–54.
[20] Keller M, Kastenberger T, Anoar AF, Kaiser P, Schmidle G, Gabl M, et al. Clinical
and radiological results of the vascularized medial femoral condyle graft for
Satisfactory results may be obtained in terms of consolidation, range scaphoid non-union. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2020;140(6):835–42.
of motion and grip strength in patients treated with a vascularized [21] Lindström G, Nyström Å. Natural history of scaphoid non-union, with special
medial condyle technique after non-union of scaphoid fractures. More reference to “asymptomatic” cases. J Hand Surg 1992;17(6):697–700.
[22] Gelberman RH, Wolock B, Siegel DB. Current concepts review: fractures and non-
over, patients reported a high rate of satisfaction.
unions of the carpal scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg A 1989;71:1560–5.
[23] Lynch NM, Linscheid RL. Corrective osteotomy for scaphoid malunion: technique
Declaration of Competing Interest and long-term follow-up evaluation. J Hand Surg Am 1997;22(1):35–43.
[24] Hannemann P, Brouwers L, Dullaert K, van der Linden E, Poeze M, Brink P.
Determining scaphoid waist fracture union by conventional radiographic
All the authors of the paper entitled: “CLINICAL OUTCOMES IN examination: an analysis of reliability and validity. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg
PATIENTS WITH SCAPHOID NON-UNION TREATED WITH THE VAS 2015;135(2):291–6.
CULARIZED MEDIAL FEMORAL CONDYLE TECHNIQUE. A CASE SE [25] Luc D. The DASH questionnaire and score in the evaluation of hand and wrist
disorders. Acta Orthop Belg 2008;74(578):81–5.
RIES”, declare that none of us has any conflicts of interest regarding the [26] García González GL, Aguilar Sierra SF, Rodríguez Ricardo RM. Validación de la
contents of the current study or any other whatsoever. Versión en español de la escala de función del miembro superior abreviada: quick
dash. Revista Colombiana de Ortopedia y Traumatología 2018;32(4):215–9.
[27] Gómez-Eslava B, Rodriguez-Ricardo MC, Serpa JC, Fajury R, García-González LA.
References Cross-cultural adaptation and validation of the translated patient-rated wrist
evaluation score. J Wrist Surg 2021;10(04):303–7.
[1] Jerrhag D, Englund M, Karlsson MK, Rosengren BE. Epidemiology and time trends [28] Larson AN, Bishop AT, Shin AY. Free medial femoral condyle bone grafting for
of distal forearm fractures in adults-a study of 11.2 million person-years in Sweden. scaphoid nonunions with humpback deformity and proximal pole avascular
BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2017;18(1):1–8. necrosis. Tech Hand Up Extrem Surg 2007;11(4):246–58.
[2] Hove LM. Epidemiology of scaphoid fractures in Bergen, Norway. Scand J Plast [29] Chaudhry T, Uppal L, Power D, Craigen M, Tan S. Scaphoid nonunion with poor
Reconstruct Surg Hand Surg 1999;33(4):423–6. prognostic factors: the role of the free medial femoral condyle vascularized bone
[3] Jørgsholm P, Thomsen N, Besjakov J, Abrahamsson S, Björkman A. MRI shows a graft. Hand. 2017;12(2):135–9.
high incidence of carpal fractures in children with posttraumatic radial-sided wrist [30] Krastman P, Mathijssen NM, Bierma-Zeinstra SM, Kraan G, Runhaar J. Diagnostic
tenderness. Acta Orthop 2016;87(5):533–7. accuracy of history taking, physical examination and imaging for phalangeal,
[4] Dias J, Brenkel I, Finlay D. Patterns of union in fractures of the waist of the metacarpal and carpal fractures: a systematic review update. BMC Musculoskelet
scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Brit Vol 1989;71(2):307–10. Disord 2020;21(1):1–24.
[5] Schaub TA, Chung KC. Systems of provision and delivery of hand care, and its
impact on the community. Injury 2006;37(11):1066–70.