Handout One
Handout One
Handout One
PRESENTATION CONTENTS
4/26/2023 Chem3081 1
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDIES
4/26/2023 2
UNIT ONE
1. Symmetry and Group Theory
INTRODUCTION
Group Theory is a mathematical method by which aspects of
a molecules symmetry can be determined.
The symmetry of a molecule reveals information about its
properties (i.e., structure, spectra, polarity, chirality, etc…).
It can be grouped into three categories:
Getting to know groups: contain explicit definitions and
examples of groups
Group applications: to understand applications of group
theory.
Group history : focuses on the history of group theory
3
symmetry operations.
Symmetry is a fundamental concept of major importance
in art, mathematics, and all areas of natural science.
In the context of chemistry, once we know the symmetry
of a molecule, it is often possible for us to draw qualitative
information about its physical and chemical properties.
Then again, we must also express them scientifically. This
could be done with help of symmetry elements & symmetry operations.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 4
Cont...d
It is the relationship between parts of an object
4/26/2023 Chem3081 5
Symmetry Operations and Symmetry
Elements
A symmetry operation is an action that leaves an object
4/26/2023 Chem3081 6
It is also called non-translational movement of
an object that produces a new orientation that is
indistinguishable from the original object.
Example 1: Look at the rotation of the following object by 900
4/26/2023 Chem3081 7
Example 2: Consider the molecule of water: Take a molecule
of water and rotate it by 180° about an
axis passing through the central O atom (between the two
H atoms). After a rotation, it will look the same as before.
1200
4/26/2023 Chem3081 9
All these symmetry operations are performed about
a symmetry element.
Symmetry Element
A Symmetry element is a geometrical entity (axis, point,
line or plane) with respect to which the symmetry
operation is performed.
Hence,
Each symmetry operation has a corresponding
symmetry element.
All these operations leave at least one point of the
molecule unmoved.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 10
Example 1:
In a rotation, the line of points that stay in the same
place constitute a symmetry axis; in a reflection the
points that remain unchanged make up a plane of
symmetry.
z
(xz)
y O
H H
x
(yz)
4/26/2023 Chem3081 14
I. C1 operation (rotation by 360°)
☞ Results in the same molecule that we have started
with. Because it does nothing or has no effect. Hence
it is an identity operation.
II. Two consecutive C2 (rotation by 1800) operations about
the same axis result in identity.
i.e. C2 x C2 = C22 = E
III. Likewise three consecutive C3 operation,
i.e. C3 x C3 x C3 = C33 = E
The product of multiple symmetry operations can
give the identity.
Successive operations leads to identity (Cnn = E).
4/26/202315 Chem3081 15
Example: Consider the following
4/26/2023 Chem3081 16
2. Rotational axis, Cn
A simple rotation about an axis passing through
the molecule.
That is, if rotation of a molecule by 360o/n results in
an identical configuration, the molecule is said to have
an n-fold rotational axis (or n-fold axis of rotation).
It is denoted as Cn
Cn is a rotation of (360/n), where n is order of the
rotation. Or
(It is called the total number of operations).
Hence, C2 = 180° rotation, C3 = 120° rotation, C4 = 90°
rotation, C5 = 72° rotation, C6 = 60° rotation, …
C2 is called a binary rotation
4/26/2023 Chem3081 17
Example 1:
H2O molecule possesses two-fold rotation axis, i.e. if the
operation is performed twice all the atoms are back to
their initial position.
Therefore, H2O molecule has a C2 axis.
Hence, rotation by 1800(2/n, n = 2) is a symmetry
operation and the axis about which the rotation
takes place is the symmetry element.
☞☞ A Cn axis is often called a "proper" rotational axis
and the rotation about it is a "proper" rotation
(one or more rotations about the axis).
4/26/2023 Chem3081 18
☞ When n > one, symmetry axis exist. So some molecules
have more than one Cn axis, hence the one with the
largest value of n is called the principal axis, and is
usually the z-axis.
Note that by convention rotations are counterclockwise
about the axis.
Example 2:
4/26/2023 Chem3081 23
However, we can see a case where the horizontal plane of
reflection results in a change in the two axial carbonyls,
but not the equatorial carbonyls, as shown below.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 24
4. Inversion, or Inversion Center, i
It involves passing each atom through the center of
the molecule. That is,
☞☞ If an atom has coordinate (x, y, z) then it has
coordinates (-x, -y, -z) after inversion.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 26
Other molecules that has an inversion center
4/26/2023 Chem3081 27
5. Improper Rotation, Sn or rotation-reflection)
It is a composite operation-occurring in two steps:
i.e. rotation of the molecule through a certain angle
followed by a reflection in the plane perpendicular
to the rotation axis.
The symbol Sn, where n is order of the rotation.
The symmetry element for Sn is the rotation axis.
The rotation-reflection operation consists of rotating
through an angle 360°/n about the axis, followed by
reflecting in a plane perpendicular to the axis.
Note: S1 is the same as reflection , and
S2 is the same as inversion
Example: Consider four-fold improper4/26/2023
rotation,
Chem3081
S4 in CH4. 28
The operation consists of 90° rotations about an axis
bisecting two HCH bond angles, followed by a reflection.
However, neither the 90° operations nor the reflection
alone is a symmetry operation for CH4.
Therefore, the accurate definition of improper
rotation is a proper rotation followed by inversion.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 31
Summary:
An S1 axis - a rotation through a full 360° followed
by a reflection in the horizontal plane is equivalent
to a horizontal reflection alone. Therefore,
☞ S1 and σh are the same. So the symbol σh is used
instead of S1.
Similarly,
☞ An S2 axis - a rotation through 180° followed by
reflection in the horizontal plane is equivalent to an
inversion, and the symbol i is used rather than S2.
Shortly,
S1 is equivalent to σ, and S2 is equivalent to i.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 32
Multiple Application of Symmetry Operations
Symmetry operation can be applied multiple times.
For example, a C3 rotation may be applied twice.
Returning to BF3 we can consider C32 rotation, which
consists of two applications of the C3 rotation.
C32 = C3C3
4/26/2023 Chem3081 33
If we apply the C3 rotation one more time (for a total of
three applications) the geometry returns to the starting
structure. In other words we can write: C33 = C3C3C3 = E
4/26/2023 Chem3081 35
Other Examples: Consider the following figure
4/26/2023 Chem3081 36
But
4/26/2023 Chem3081 37
What about C34 ?
⇒ Only C , C
3
2,
E are separate and distinct operations.
3
Similar arguments can be applied to any proper axis of
order n.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 38
The Symmetry Point Groups
A group, G
Any set or collection of elements, which together with
some well defined combining operation that obey
a certain set of rules is called a group. Or
A group, G is a set of elements A, B, C, ... connected
by a combination rule (written as a product, for
example A.B).
Properties of a Group
Elements of a group must obey the following rules:
R 1. Combination of any two elements of the group must
produce an element which is also a member of the group.
This is the closure property. 4/26/2023 Chem3081
☞ For all elements A and B of the group G, A.B = C; is also
an element of the group G.
Mathematically Closer property of sets.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 40
First operation
C2V E C2 σV σ’V
E E C2 σV σ’V
Second operation
C2 C2 E σ’V σV
σV σV σ’V E C2
C2 E
σ'V σ’V σV
4/26/2023 Chem3081 43
Point groups
The symmetry operations that characterize the various
different shapes of molecules define mathematical
groups referred to as point groups. Hence,
Molecules that possess the same set of symmetry
elements belong to the same point group.
It is also convenient to classify molecules with the same
set of symmetry elements by a label.
So that molecules with the same label belong to the
same point group.
Example: Consider symmetry elements of H2O molecule.
We find that it has: E, One C2 axis, & Two σv planes.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 44
The set of this four symmetry operations generated by
these elements is said to form a symmetry group or
point group. Therefore, they characterize the point
group C2v for water.
Point groups get their name from the fact that at
least one point in space remains unchanged for all
operations in the group.
Classification of point groups
When we say a molecule belongs to a certain point
group, it means that the molecule possesses a specific,
self-consistent set of symmetry elements.
The most common point groups are described below
with illustrative examples. 4/26/2023 Chem3081 45
1. Point Groups with low symmetry
Groups that possess only one or two symmetry elements.
These are: C1, Ci and Cs.
C1: has only identity element: In other words there is
no symmetry.
Cs: has identity and a mirror plane alone: The symmetry
is restricted to a mirror plane.
Ci : has identity and inversion center alone.
2. Point Groups with high symmetry
These are groups with a large number of characteristic
symmetry elements. This includes: Octahedral, Oh,
Tetrahedral, Td & Icosahedra, Ih.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 46
3. Point Groups with an n-fold rotational axis, Cn
After groups with high or low symmetries have been
eliminated by inspection, the remaining point groups
should be assigned by looking for characteristic
symmetry elements, such as an n-fold rotation axis.
These groups include the groups: Cn, Cnv & Cnh
Cn: it has identity & n-fold rotation axis.
Cnv: identity, Cn axis & vertical mirror planes, σv..
Cnh: identity, an n-fold rotation axis and a horizontal
mirror plane, σh.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 47
Note that presence of certain symmetry elements may
be implied by the presence of others; thus in C2h, the
operations C2 and σh jointly imply the presence of a
center of inversion, i.
4. Dihedral point groups
Molecules possessing nC2 axes perpendicular to the
principal axis. These group includes: Dn, Dnh and Dnd
Dn: If there are no mirror planes, the molecule belongs
to the Dn point group.
Dnh: The presence of a mirror plane perpendicular to
the principal axis results in the Dnh point group.
Dnd: In addition to the elements of Dn, possesses n
diagonal mirror planes, σd.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 48
Determining the Point Group
Summarized rules for classification of molecules in to
point groups.
The number & nature of the symmetry elements in a
given molecule are denoted by its point group.
The point group has labels such as Cn, Cnv, Cnh, Dn,
Dnh, Dnd etc.
These symbols are called the Schonflies Symbols.
These point groups are conventionally divided in to:
C groups, D groups & Special groups.
Therefore, using these symbols and based on the
following rules we can classify molecules in to point groups.
1. Determine whether the molecule belongs to a special
group such as: Td, Oh, Ih , Dh, or Cv Chem3081
4/26/2023 49
☞ If the molecule is linear, it will be either Cv or Dh..
☞ If it has infinite number of two-fold rotation axes
perpendicular to the Caxis, it will fall in to point
group Dh; if not, it is Cv.
2. If the molecule is not linear, it may belong to a point
group of high symmetry: Td, Oh, or Ih.
3. If 1 or 2 is not found to be the case, look for a proper
axis of rotation of the highest order in the molecule.
☞ If none is found, the molecule is of low symmetry,
falling in to point group: Cs , Ci , or C1.
☞ The presence of mirror plane or an inversion center
will distinguish among these point groups.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 50
4. If Cn axes exist, select the one of highest order. If the
molecule also has S2n axis, with or without an
inversion center, the point group is Sn.
5. If no Sn exists, look for a set of n two-fold axes
perpendicular to the major Cn axis.
☞ If no such set is found, the molecule belongs to
either of Cn , Cnh, or Cnv.
☞ If σh plane exists, it is of Cnh point group even if
other planes of symmetry are present.
☞ If no σh plane exists and a σv plane is found, the
molecule belongs to Cnv point group.
☞ If neither the horizontal nor the vertical planes
are found, the point group is4/26/2023
simply Cn.
Chem3081 51
6. If in (5) nC2 to Cn is found, the molecule belongs to
either Dn, Dnh, or Dnd point group.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 53
• No σh, so the possibility of C3h is ruled out.
• But there are three σv’s.
Thus, the point group is C3v.
Alternative Method for Determining Point Group
There are much quicker ways of assigning the point
group. However, the most popular one is to use a flow
chart.
The flow chart contains all of the point groups discussed
above as well as a few other not commonly encountered.
Follow the following flow chart for assigning the point
group.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 54
4/26/2023 Chem3081 55
4/26/2023 Chem3081 56
Worked Examples
polarity,
However, there are symmetry elements that rule out the presence of a
4/26/2023 Chem3081 58
permanent electric dipole in molecules.
1. Molecule cannot be polar if it has an inversion center.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 59
Generally, a molecule cannot be polar if it belongs to any of the following
point groups.
Chiral molecules are optically active i.e. they can rotate the plane of
polarized light.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 60
A chiral, molecule and its mirror image partner are called
enantiomers.
Enantiomeric pairs can rotate the plane of polarized light by
equal amounts but in opposite directions.
According to group theory, for chirality the molecule should not
have an improper rotation axis.
Generally, a molecule is not chiral if
1. It possesses an improper rotation axis, Sn.
2. It belongs to the groups Dnh or Dnd (but it may be
chiral if it belongs to the groups Dn).
3. It belongs to Td or Oh.
Example: SiCl4 or Ni(CO)4 belongs to Td are not
4/26/2023 Chem3081 61
chiral.
► Remember that, mirror plane alone is equivalent to an S1
axis and inversion center is equivalent to an S2 axis.
► Therefore, molecules with either σ or i have improper
rotation axes and hence cannot be chiral.
► Note that, a higher-order improper-rotation axis is not also
present.
Example: quaternary ammonium ion has neither a
mirror plane (S1) nor an inversion center (S2), but it
does have an S4 axis. So it is not chiral.
4/26/2023 Chem3081 62