Revitalisation
Revitalisation
Revitalisation
net/publication/321583061
Conference Paper in WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment · September 2017
DOI: 10.2495/SC170131
CITATIONS READS
3 320
3 authors:
Martina Peřinková
VŠB-Technical University of Ostrava
21 PUBLICATIONS 8 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Ivona Dlábiková on 13 April 2020.
ABSTRACT
Historic public cemeteries, thanks to their social function, are an integral part of urban areas. They
exemplify a relationship and respect for values which were created by previous generations. A relatively
large extent of the historic public cemeteries, founded during the 18th and 19th century, have been
preserved until now in the Czech Republic. Some of them could be extended to fulfil their social
function to this day. But some of them, thanks to fast development, have appeared in central zones of
urban areas and therefore have ceased to fulfil their original function. Other cemeteries ceased their
activity and instead, housing estates, factories or parks were created. In some cases, the original ethical
principles were not respected. Questions arise here: what is and what will be the fate of historic public
cemeteries which cease to fulfil their function? How will the outcome be handled by representatives,
investors and conservationists? The aim of this article is to explain the influence of urban structures on
cemeteries as well as how cemeteries influence urban structures and adaptation of these areas to meet
its current needs and the needs of the society. It will also give a prognosis for the further development
of cemeteries within towns.
Keywords: cemetery, urban area, Czech Republic, grave, cemetery wall.
1 INTRODUCTION
Cemeteries are places built and shaped by the gradual adding of new graves over a long time.
Their location is thus formed by the rules and laws from the past, earlier than other
surrounding buildings were built. Cemeteries have experienced different time eras and styles;
they are like time capsules [1]. In cities, cemeteries are often attached to a park or garden or
they alone create a garden among which graves are located. Each cemetery is different, not
due to poor arrangement, but because their location within the city is different, and therefore
they all meet different needs. This is essential for the proper functioning and operation of
cemeteries.
The prognosis for individual cemeteries cannot be determined in general: each of them is
unique and fills different needs in the city in terms of certain size, location, faith and links to
the funeral buildings and other parts of the city. That is why we will focus on three specific
cemeteries in a European city and find out how they are fighting for their place in the present
time of growing infrastructure and overcrowding. The following examples can offer
examples of ideas for revitalising and renewing other cemeteries.
2 HISTORY
First row graves were located outside residential areas (on nearby roads, etc.), but with the
onset of Christianity they moved closer to homes or became part of the church (nearby or
within it). In the 2nd century, grave burial became highly popular (as a legacy to pre-Christian
culture and Christianity) [1]. In 789 Charles the Great issued a decree that prohibited the
cremation of bodies, with a punishment of the death penalty. This ban was respected in
Europe for more than one-thousand years. From the 11th century, burials started to change
in the Czech Lands: instead of burials in remote areas, they were happening closer to city
centres. From the 12th century onwards, we can notice an increase in churches with
cemeteries. Thus, cemeteries became a common part of towns and villages [2].
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
doi:10.2495/SC170131
148 The Sustainable City XII
Medieval cemeteries have been referred to as public spaces which can serve as
marketplaces [3]. But the idea of the bustling marketplace in a church cemetery is at odds
with everything we know about burial and respecting the deceased, However, before that,
both in Europe and elsewhere in the world, a cemetery stretching around the church in the
middle of the village could have become a marketplace at times if there were no other
alternatives due to the lack of free space. Similarly, early Christians that hid during times of
persecution in the Roman catacombs had to come to terms with the fact that their meetings
and ceremonies were taking place in burial sites. Otherwise, medieval Europeans avoided
graveyards and only visited them with a mixture of respect and fear, even though they had
more frequent and intensive experiences with death than we have today [4].
Cremation was brought back to society by various activists. The main credit for this
belongs to the organised movement ‘Supporters of Cremation’ which began in the middle of
the 1870s. Cremation associations, established during this time in Germany, Great Britain,
the Netherlands and the USA, sped up the reintegration of cremation when it became possible
to transform wishes into reality – the opening of the first modern crematorium (in 1876 in
Milan and Washington after the changing of medical laws) [5].
In 1782, Josef II reformed the funeral business by creating the Dvorský decree which
influenced burial in the former Austro-Hungarian Empire, which contained the Czech
Republic (then known as Czechoslovakia). Among the most important regulations which
influenced the development and planning of cities and towns in the Czech Republic was the
establishment of cemeteries away from urban centres. After eight centuries, graveyards cease
to be a part of the community. This is also the time when the law dictating the compulsory
building of walls around cemeteries was approved as well as the recommendation to separate
cemeteries from villages by a forest, hill or river [6]. Thus, around European cemeteries walls
were built, separating the worlds of the living and the dead. This law still exists in Catholic
circles. Calvinist and Lutheran cemeteries in Holland and Scandinavia are not normally
surrounded by fences and graves remain unmarked. However, Catholic cemeteries, as well
as public cemeteries in countries with Catholic tradition, are clearly fenced, with marked
grave sites and eye-catching monuments [4].
Over time, some cemeteries approached towns due to the development of built areas, and
in some cases, they even became a part of them again, this time in peripheral suburbs rather
than urban centres. However, many of them have remained isolated in areas that least affect
the surrounding public spaces, and that are least affected by surrounding public spaces.
It is therefore questionable whether the removal of cemeteries from urban centres is the
right thing, or whether we should find ways to integrate cemeteries back into towns and to
make people more aware of their existence. Given the increase in vandalism and the lack of
interest in some of cemeteries the answer is clear: only those which are still functioning today
and have something to offer a visitor should receive the public and religious interest which
they deserve either as a final resting place or because there are representative of the rich
sepulchral art of the past.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Sustainable City XII 149
any dominant features; each Chapel Tomb is a dominant item on its own (Fig. 1). Some tombs
are leaning on the monastery wall and therefore look more significant. Thus, the monastic
wall here is also a dominant feature, but it competes with small, detailed white graves. The
cemetery has a dominating exterior and the cemetery metal gate acts as a small door;
however, after you cross the border to the church, it immediately takes a step back and we
find ourselves in a majestic place.
The cemetery is divided into two floors: one of them is at the entrance to the monastery
and tin the direction of the parking lot and the other is slightly lower, where it is possible to
walk around the monastery and gardens. Each section is visibly separated: a monastery with
a fitted marble room close to it, ordered with longitudinal paths, along which you can walk
into the green area of gardens with a view of the entire city and the sea (Fig. 2). The cemetery
itself is defending its place as much as the terrain has been allowing, on one side it is limited
by the cemetery walls, behind which you can see a parking lot. On the other side is sharply
Figure 1: Chapel graves in the cemetery in Nice around the outer peripheral cemetery wall.
(Source: Ivona Dlábiková.)
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
150 The Sustainable City XII
Figure 2: Views of the sea from the cemetery in Nice. (Source: Ivona Dlábiková.)
sloping ground from the side by the monastery wall to the road, however it is not losing any
of its value. Its white marble interior with beautifully sculpted statues and concrete paths
gives a sense of purity and timelessness. There are no trees or grass: every square inch is used
as part of the graves, plinths, cornices, steps and gravestones. In ‘The White City’, Henry
Matisse, a well-known artist, rests and he has been immortalised by The Museum of Henry
Matisse, just near the cemetery. We can also see little spires from the palace of Queen
Victoria from the cemetery, dating back to the days of the Belle Époque from which the
period of her government was derived and where a considerable part of the construction of
the city originated. The Palace, called Regina by the local inhabitants, is formed by the
original cluster of homes, united into one complex with the same front. Currently, they are
luxurious private apartments with a sea view and a private swimming pool.
The part of the town of Cimiez where the cemetery is located is very old; the Colosseum,
which is still there, comes from the Roman times and it is said to be the smallest amphitheatre
in France, with a capacity of 5,000 spectators. Once, it served only in the town of Cemenelum
where the Roman baths were. Only the excavations of these places were preserved can be
found in the Archaeological Museum there. This entire district with the graveyard, ruins of
the Roman baths, a small amphitheatre, a palace, a park, the museum of Henry Matisse and,
at the edge the monastery, a cemetery with a garden all stretch high above the city.
From the gardens, you can see the centre of Nice and the acropolis of the former castle
called “Castle Hill” protruding from the coast. From this place, you can see almost all parts
of the city and its borders, which are shown by the steep hills. This district once was a village,
but today it is a part of the town of Nice, connecting with the centre via a long boulevard with
a road lined by trees in the residential area descending down to the wider centre. This was
built at the time of the reconstruction of Paris following the example of Haussmann. The
wide boulevards and extensive promenades along the coastline called Promenade des Anglais
were then created. One side is defined by the faces of the residential blocks and on the other
side there is stony beaches and a view of the horizon over the sea. The town of Nice also has
a part called Old Town Vielle with the building of the court and the building of the opera
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Sustainable City XII 151
house, which was burned down and then rebuilt in 1881. This part is full of salespeople in
shops and a market with domestic crops. The newer construction is linked to the old town by
a promenade along the Paillon River which flows under cobbled paths and a park. From the
other side, the old town is regressing into the Castle Hill. The castle is no longer there, only
the foundations from the days of Celtic and Roman settlements remain. Today, there are
gardens with a view and also the castle and Israeli cemetery. These two cemeteries are located
near to the centre of the town, although they were brought up to the height of the acropolis.
Otherwise, there are a further thirteen cemeteries mostly adjacent to the part of the church in
the suburbs. The area is mountainous and the town is surrounded by the Alps. In the
framework of the town the cemetery in the monastery in Cimiez is on the borders, but it has
good contact with it because of its high position. It looks as if it is watching the life of the
city from a distance.
Its location is multiplied by the surrounding excavations and buildings. Thus, it occupies
an honourable place over the city like the cemetery on Castle Hill. It is therefore obvious that
our ancestors used to bury the dead in important places. Certainly, this was due to the specific
coastal areas where it would not have been appropriate to put a cemetery, due to the risks that
come with being near water. Practical reasons certainly play a big role there, however we can
see great differences in understanding the cemetery as the stone city, next to which there is
an independent garden and a park unlike the cemeteries in Central Europe, where they
themselves are designed as the place with trees, grass and flowers, unifying a park, garden
and a cemetery in one. Such a unity creates a certain space between the individual deceased;
it mirrors the sacred groves established by the Slavs where they used to bury their deceased
[7]. In Europe, this tradition has been encountered again in the form of forest cemeteries [8].
On the other hand, the cemetery in Cimiez in Nice is like a room where you can go and see
the deceased; it corresponds to the concept of “living forever”. A room for the rest of the
deceased, a room for a walk through a garden with a generous view and a monastery for
prayer. These separate parts then form a single cemetery, which if one was to go through,
they would feel the journey and the sequence of it.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
152 The Sustainable City XII
Figure 3: The Cemetery in Meidling directly next to the train station. (Source: Ivona
Dlábiková.)
Figure 4: The chapel in Vienna in Art Nouveau style, Zentralfriedhof, Vienna. (Source:
Klára Frolíková Palánová.)
generous areas between graves serve as space for future burials. The chapel itself dominates
due to its height, and it is visible even from the more distant parts of the cemetery. We can
always know what awaits us at the end of the journey to the centre of the cemetery. But the
cemetery is located at the edge of the town, so the name ‘Central’ then loses its significance
in relation to the city. The Cemetery in Meidling is situated in the residential area with a large
park and is close to the Schönbrunn Palace Gardens, which are then connected to the
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Sustainable City XII 153
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
154 The Sustainable City XII
routes, shopping centres and administrative structures. The space is limited by walls, which
isolates it from the rather close public space. It is a place for relaxation, thinking, meditation
and prayer. The management of the cemetery have tried to link the two worlds by opening a
café and gift shop, and a map of the graves of famous people was made.
On the other hand, there are the cemeteries on the borders of the capital city, intended
purely for burial, which are now disappearing, are perishable and, given the high degree of
cremation in Prague (98%), they no longer fulfil their purpose. How do we aim for the future?
How do we re-integrate them into the public space of the city?
Figure 5: The arcade corridor and the base of Basilica of St Peter and Paul at Vyšehrad.
(Source: Klára Frolíková Palánová.)
Figure 6: Olšany cemetery, less frequently attended part, Prague. (Source: Klára Frolíková
Palánová.)
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Sustainable City XII 155
6 SUMMARY
Burial is an integral part of every society. The growth of cemeteries depends entirely on the
deceased. The mentality, ceremonial rituals, method of burying (inhumation or cremation)
and their symbolism are largely influenced by time, place and also by various events such as
the development of human activities, for example warfare [9]. From the 18th century, Europe
experienced large changes in the health sector. The improvement of hygiene conditions and
nutrition led progress in medicine to a significant reduction in mortality [10]. People started
to die in hospitals, not at home as it used to be before. Thus, death alienated us. The
phenomenon of death appears to be independent of the time [11]. It will always be here, only
our view on it is changing. The considerable influence on the current behaviour in society
means that the desacralization of burying has increased in the course of the last century. That
is why it is necessary to look for new directions of cemeteries so that they would be a fully-
fledged part of our cities even in the current century.
Some of the selected cemeteries, like many others, e.g. Vyšehrad, part of Olšany cemetery
and Meidling, and also the cemetery in Nice, work as fully-fledged parts of the urban areas,
yet they are enclosed by walls and have limited opening hours. From the point of view of the
public space: if we can see it according to the definition of a “non-personal part of urban
settlements, where people meet who do not know each other personally or are known only
categorically” [4], we find out that this model of cemetery fulfils that. However, if we add
the sociological definition, which adds a condition of legal access for all that is under the
normal conditions [4], we come across gateways which close the cemeteries after the opening
hours. This is the difference between Lutheran and Catholic cemeteries at present. According
to the condition “the loss of public positions” (Kovář et al. [4]), which the religion in the
Czech Lands recorded in the last 50 years and then consequent high rates of atheism which
have caused a change of the moral values of society, it cannot be dealt with differently. Other
deterioration of our cemeteries appeared with the production and distribution of monuments
and frames and even entire tombs made of synthetic stone with a very imperfect shape, colour
and processing, especially in its early days, but conspicuous even with the best processing,
which is not substantially different in price from natural stone [12].
Whereas the cemeteries are not public spaces in the truest sense of the word, they are an
essential part of an urban area [4]. The experience shows that people visit cemeteries no
matter what their location (see displaced Vyšehrad cemetery, or the cemetery remote from
the city centre in Nice), but the likelihood of visits depends on what they can offer. Former
Director of Administration of Prague Cemeteries, Martin Červený, describes the situation as
follows: “Because of the high number of cremations there is decreasing interest in grave
places. Partly the function of cemeteries is changing. People go there for a walk or to seek
quiet” [13]. So, the whole image of the cemetery is changing, gradually there is a declining
number of graves and the premises are becoming more like a city park which people go to
for a walk. As inspired by the interest in sepulchral art, funeral/ cemetery tourism is also
growing. As an example, the aforementioned Vienna Central Cemetery, where buses full of
tourists arrive who tour perfectly decorated gravestones of famous personalities with a map.
A similar trend is developing at the cemeteries in the Czech Republic. For a long time
Vyšehrad cemetery in Prague worked similarly (where e.g. the Čapek brothers are buried, as
well as the opera singer Ema Destinnová and also Milada Horáková, who have symbolic
graves there). A great potential is laid in Olšany cemetery due to the position in the city, but
also due to the extraordinary sepulchral art and the personalities that are buried there. The
Administration of Prague Cemeteries (SPH) have already worked out a plan for their
reconstruction and they have already established the educational trails around and about the
cemetery. Furthermore, the Administration of Prague Cemeteries (SPH) wants to build a café,
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
156 The Sustainable City XII
for example, which would serve not only to mourning guests, but to visitors and tourists. A
similar one already operates in the Berlin Kreuzberg. Prague Lesser Town cemetery, after a
total revitalisation, launched guided tours [13].
Many cemeteries, however, got stuck in development, lacking an imaginary half-step
towards the world of the living. This may be just the restoration, revitalisation, revival – such
as the building of a new background premises not only for the maintenance of the cemetery,
but for visitors too. Each cemetery can be proud of its long history, the prominent location or
the quantity of personalities, even though that was not their original purpose. Not country,
but mainly urban cemeteries (cemeteries in the larger cities) “suffer” from lack of interest
from a secularised society, law attendance and subsequent decline which is an attractive space
for vandalism (Fig. 7). Neglected companies are bad reminders of the present day.
There seems to be a fundamental need to rethink their future direction and if they no longer
fulfil their purpose, they should be converted gradually to a park with reference to their
original purpose. To maintain the piety of the place, they should display the names of the
dead into the walls or tiles and expose artistically valuable gravestones. This idea is offered
for example at the cemetery in Ostrava-Hulváky which has not been used for burials and has
not allowed ash storage since the 1950s. Its original plan was disrupted by its partial
cancellation and substitution of the bustling street and new building of Vítkovice Ironworks.
If, however, the unceasing interest is recorded, it would seem to be more than appropriate to
complement the existing cemeteries with the possibility of new forms of burials, especially
ash storage. In a country with an abnormally high rate of cremation and with a high number
of crematoria as well as cremations, this seems to be a further possible way to maintain the
current necropolis, therefore keeping their original purpose. The construction of
columbarium, graves for storing the urns or spaces for epitaph plates and of memorial
scattering meadows which are enjoyed with great interest allow continued functioning of the
premises of cemeteries and convert them into the 21st century.
Figure 7: The current state of the cemetery in Ostrava – Mariánské Hory, the view of the
Vítkovice Ironworks through the cemetery. (Source: Klára Frolíková Palánová.).
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
The Sustainable City XII 157
7 CONCLUSION
The sanctity of the place and its meaning today, which the Roman Catholic Church has been
spreading for centuries, evokes an exceptional experience when entering the necropolis. Piety
is not distorted, even by the funerals and graves of extraordinary personalities, it is supported
as it provides a new sense of cemeteries for today’s society, particularly at The Central
Cemetery in Vienna, The Olšany in Prague, in Nice and at the Vyšehrad. The tribute in
treating the past as well as the present supports cultural, but also national, sentiments and
helps to educate younger generations. The awareness that remains in their subconscious helps
to eliminate vandalism which often occurs at the peripheral cemeteries.
The renewal of the necropolis with facilities for visitors also proves beneficial, particularly
in more distant locations. If the place for the dead is combined with the needs for the living,
there is a positive interaction and experience of an exceptional moment when “visiting” our
loved ones, as well as when relaxing and meditating. In these moments, a wall is not an
obstacle, but defines it as a sacred place, allowing for warning and instruction from the
different authorities which look after that location. Increasing the quantity of gates will help
the accessibility of the area without building a barrier in the city, and, at the same time, more
sites will be available, even those which are normally ignored by the visitors (the oldest part
of Olšany cemetery). Last but not least, in the cemeteries which do not serve to the funeral
tourism only and are not in an appropriate location for walks, there is a need to supplement
them and to ensure the new forms of burial. There is the possibility of storing ashes so that
they can continue to fulfil their function for which they have been set up for originally, such
as the establishment of columbarium in unused chapel tombs, the establishment of the
memorial scattering meadows in locations of defunct graves, or allowing urn storage in the
area of the existing tombs.
We can take the example of the cemeteries in Nice, where there are separate places for
the deceased and then there is another “area” in the form of a garden or a park; one using this
additional element can get away from the death which is looking at them in the form of
gravestones. The graves are then placed one next to the other, unusually dense in comparison
with those in Central Europe. The space is given by the garden itself. We can take as an
example the cemetery of Meidling because of the courage which is shown by having a
location directly next to a railway station that they can live together. We appreciate that it
has not been transformed into a park or that they avoided building new premises, as it happens
at the time of the rapid construction. It has lived on its own even next to the busy road and
fully serves its original function. It is not a directly public space, but it lives within the
environment and offers a place for a quiet contemplation away from the busy world.
Vyšehrad cemetery has a long history, first a place on the upper position for a stay of princes
and today, a place for eternal rest of important personalities. Such a position has been being
built for centuries, but we can notice how important places for the living changed to an
important place for the dead. The cemetery has literally an exceptional position. Why should
the word cemetery evoke abandoned, not maintained, aside and a sad place to most people in
society today? With the exception of the country cemeteries in churches that keep their
traditions and rules, the urban cemeteries are usually a place which many people do not
attend, unless it is the holidays. These are the places without rules, which not kept tidy. The
places like Vyšehrad or Olšany cemeteries are the opposite examples. The shelter for the
dead is dignified and the living can admire it. The cemetery deserves an important place in
today’s society.
The cemetery as a unit in a town in the framework of time seems to be stagnant. It is
changing slower than the rest of the city, so let us give it more time and space, as with the
other buildings; it used to be here before and will stay longer than we will.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)
158 The Sustainable City XII
REFERENCES
[1] Frolíková-Palánová, K., Kovář, J. et al., Burying as Part of Life in the European
Context. Architecture in perspective VI., Germany: TTP Ltd, pp. 39–43, 2014.
[2] Nešporová, O., About death and burying, The center for study of democration and
culture, p. 226, 2013.
[3] Ariés, P., The hour of our death., Prague: Argo, p. 86, 2000.
[4] Kovář, J., Peřinková, M., Špatenková, N. et al., The cemetery as a public space,
Ostrava: Gasset & VŠB-TU Ostrava, pp. 61–62, 2014.
[5] Association of friends of cremation. Online. www.pohreb.cz/spolecnost-pratel-zehu.
Accessed on: 30 Jul. 2017.
[6] Kotrlý, T., Funeral service, the legal ensure of piety and dignity of human remains,
Linde Prague, p. 171, 2013.
[7] The source, regional newspapers of civic association Genius Loci, Sacred groves,
Online. pramen.info/c/1305/posvatne-haje.htm. Accessed on: 20 Jun. 2017.
[8] The forest of memories. Online. www.lesvzpominek.cz. Accessed on: 10 Jul. 2017.
[9] Moreaux, P., Birth, life and death of cemeteries, Le Bouscat: L’Esprit du temps, p.7,
2009.
[10] Špatenková, N. et al., About the last human things, Prague: Galén, 2014.
[11] Ariés, P., The western attitudes toward death: From the Middle Ages to the present,
London: John Hopkins University press, p. 1, 1974.
[12] Almer, J., The need for a new adaptation of Prague cemeteries, Prague: Pensions of
the capital city of Prague, 1928.
[13] The date on cemetery? Prague wants to have the coffee bar between graves and more
benches. Online. praha.idnes.cz/zmeny-na-prazskych-hrbitovech-det-/praha-zpravy.
aspx?c=A141215_2124492_praha-zpravy_mav. Accessed on: 20 Jul. 2016.
WIT Transactions on Ecology and The Environment, Vol 223, © 2017 WIT Press
www.witpress.com, ISSN 1743-3541 (on-line)