Net Zero Report 20-5-2024

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 36

INDIA’S

JOURNEY
TO NET ZERO
A CONCEPTUAL
FRAMEWORK
FOR ANALYSIS
Ajay Shankar | Sanchit S Agarwal | Taruna Idnani
INDIA’S JOURNEY TO NET ZERO
A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
FOR ANALYSIS

Ajay Shankar| Sanchit S Agarwal | Taruna Idnani


© The Energy and Resources Institute 2024

SUGGESTED CITATION
Shankar A, Agarwal S S, and Idnani T. 2024. India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework
for Analysis, New Delhi: The Energy and Resources Institute.

For more information and suggestions:


Contact
Dr Sanchit Saran Agarwal
Email: sanchit.agarwal@teri.res.in
Ms Taruna Idnani
Email: taruna.idnani@teri.res.in

Editorial and design


Mr Abhas Mukherjee
Mr Mannu Mahto

The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI)


Darbari Seth Block, IHC Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi 110 003, India
Tel.: +91 11 2468 2100 or 2468 2111 | Fax: +91 11 2468 2144 or 2468 2145
Email: mailbox@teri.res.in | Web: www.teriin.org
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This paper is an initiative of TERI’s taskforce on India’s journey to net zero and just transitions
under the ambit of Institute’s work on Energy Transitions. We are immensely grateful to TERI’s
taskforce colleagues who have given their inputs and suggestions for conceptualizing this
discussion paper. We are grateful to Mr R R Rashmi, Distinguished Fellow, TERI for his valuable
suggestions and inputs. We would like to thank Mr Girish Sethi, Mr A K Saxena, and Mr
Arupendra Nath Mullick for their guidance and valuable insights. We would also like to express
our gratitude to TERI colleagues, Mr Varun Grover, Dr Rahul Chakraborty, Mr Sharif Qamar,
Dr Saswata Chaudhury, Ms Meenu Saini, Mr Mayank Aggarwal, and Mr Sobhanbabu PRK for
their inputs.
We would like to thank Director General, TERI for her vision in conceptualizing this initiative and
encouraging and motivating TERI colleagues in their endeavours.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis iii


Industry Charter for Near Zero
Emission Ambition Instituted by TERI

TERI’s Industry Charter for Near Zero Emissions Ambition by 2050, instituted in the year 2020,
is a coalition of like-minded industries bound in their voluntary pledges to reduce greenhouse
gas (GHG) emissions and united in their belief in the role of industries in achieving the Paris
Agreement goals.
The Coalition shares best practices, facilitates outreach and communicates technology and
business models on industrial decarbonization among key stakeholders such as industry groups,
global organizations, government and financial institutions.
The findings, analysis and outlook from the paper “India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual
Framework for Analysis” will be helpful for the Coalition in their annual and long-term
planning. It will also aid in the allocation of resources towards credible actions on their
decarbonization pathways.

iv India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


From the Desk of
Director General, TERI
While global climate change challenges impact all, India is at the forefront of the transition
to a sustainable future. Hon’ble Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi has envisioned a pathway
towards decarbonization, promoting a greener economy and building a resilient future. At COP26
in Glasgow in 2021, he made the landmark announcement that India would become net zero
by 2070.
The transition to a low carbon economy is gaining momentum. Achieving net zero is a tall order
but India is committed to achieving its target. India is at an early stage of development with our
per capita emissions being considerably lower than the world average. India aspires to meet the
dual objectives of becoming a developed economy by 2047 while reducing the carbon intensity
of the economy and achieving net zero by 2070.
While 2070 appears far off, we at TERI have taken the lead in setting up a Task Force to work
towards the journey to net zero. This paper, “India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework
for Analysis” examines the transition journey for each of the major GHG emitting sectors in India.
It delineates a pathway to the peaking of emissions and subsequent decline through the lens of
delinking growth from an increase in carbon emissions.
This is an initial exercise of sketching a pathway to net zero and putting forward a conceptual
framework of analysis. The intent is to begin the dialogue on what is involved in achieving the net
zero ambition. Each of these sectors needs more comprehensive analysis, generation of scenarios,
and associated climate finance imperatives. It suggests in-depth studies that would be crucial for
further comprehension and planning.
While the path ahead is complex and challenging, collaboration among all stakeholders would
be key to its success. We believe this study opens up opportunities for meaningful deliberations,
reflections, and further research.
We welcome your invaluable thoughts and suggestions which would immensely help in shaping
the journey ahead.

Dr Vibha Dhawan
Director General, TERI

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis v


vi India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS..........................................................................................................................................iii
From the Desk of Director General, TERI................................................................................................................v
LIST OF FIGURES........................................................................................................................................................ix
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS.........................................................................................................................................xi

1.0 INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................................1
1.1 Objective of the Paper....................................................................................................................................... 2
1.2 Conceptual Framework..................................................................................................................................... 3

2.0 CARBON FREE ELECTRICITY.................................................................................................. 6


2.1 Emissions from Electricity Sector in India..................................................................................................... 6
2.2 Key Strategies for Electricity Decarbonization in India ............................................................................. 7
2.3 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Electricity..................................................................................... 9

3.0 SECTORAL TRANSITIONS TO NET ZERO THROUGH GREEN ELECTRICITY........................ 10


3.1 Surface Transport..............................................................................................................................................10
3.1.1 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Transport ......................................................................13
3.2 RESIDENTIAL COOKING................................................................................................................................14
3.2.1 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Cooking..........................................................................14

4.0 HARD-TO-ABATE SECTORS ..................................................................................................15


4.1 Industry...............................................................................................................................................................15
4.1.1 Studies needed for green hydrogen - Industry................................................................................17
4.2 Shipping...............................................................................................................................................................17
4.2.1 Studies needed......................................................................................................................................17
4.3 Aviation...............................................................................................................................................................17
4.4 Agriculture..........................................................................................................................................................17
4.4.1 Studies needed......................................................................................................................................19

5.0 CONCLUSION.......................................................................................................................20

6.0 REFERENCES........................................................................................................................ 22

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis vii


viii India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Country-wise per-capita GHG emissions..........................................................................................1
Figure 2: Total GHG emissions at the global level............................................................................................2
Figure 3: India’s per capita emissions illustrative pathways...........................................................................3
Figure 4: India’s sectoral emissions share...........................................................................................................4
Figure 5: India’s energy sector emissions ..........................................................................................................5
Figure 6: Electricity emissions pathways illustration.......................................................................................7
Figure 8: Trend of EV penetration among newly registered vehicles in Delhi...........................................10
Figure 7: National trend of EV penetration........................................................................................................10
Figure 9: Change in share of ICE vehicles and EVs and decline of carbon emissions
per unit of electricity..............................................................................................................................12
Figure 10: Transport emissions pathways illustration........................................................................................13
Figure 11: Industry emissions pathways illustration..........................................................................................16
Figure 12: Agricultural sector emissions ..............................................................................................................18

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis ix


LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

AWD Alternate Wetting and Drying


CCS Carbon Capture and Storage
CCUS Carbon Capture Utilization and Storage
CEA Central Electricity Authority
CNG Compressed Natural Gas
COP Conference of Parties
CSP Concentrated Solar Thermal
DISCOM Distribution Company
ESO Energy Storage Obligation
ESS Energy Storage System
EU European Union
EV Electric Vehicle
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GHG Greenhouse Gas
GW Gigawatt
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
kWh Kilowatt Hour
LDV Light Duty Vehicle
LPG Liquefied Petroleum Gas
LULUCF Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry
MHDV Medium and Heavy-Duty Vehicles
MOEFCC Ministry of Environment, Forest, and Climate Change
MtCO2eq Million Tonnes of Carbon Dioxide Equivalent
MW Megawatt
NDC Nationally Determined Contributions
PMSY Pradhan Mantri Suryodaya Yojana
PNG Piped Natural Gas

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis xi


PSP Pumped Storage Plant
RE Renewable Energy
RE-RTC Renewable Energy Round-The-Clock
RPO Renewable Purchase Obligation
UNFCCC United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

xii India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


1
INTRODUCTION

In the landmark 2015 Paris Agreement on Climate Change adopted at The Conference of the
Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) 21, or COP
21, all the 196 nations parties to the UNFCCC resolved to limit global mean temperature rise to
well below 2°C and pursue efforts towards restricting temperature rise to 1.5°C. According to
the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), temperature rise should not cross 1.5°C
(IPCC, 2023).
At COP28 in November 2023, the IPCC warned that with current policies, global warming was
set to cross 3°C (UNEP, 2023). This would be an unmitigated disaster. To avoid this, immediate
and deep emissions reductions were imperative. The G20 Summit held under India’s Presidency
in September 2023 in its declaration reiterated “…commitment to achieve global net zero GHG
emissions/carbon neutrality by or around mid-century…”
At COP26, held at Glasgow in 2021, Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi announced that by 2030
India would create 500 GW of fossil fuel free power generating capacity and would reduce the
emissions intensity of its GDP by 45% from its 2005 level (MEA, 2023). This is one of the highest
increases in ambition of responsible climate leadership in the short run.
The Prime Minister also announced that India would become net zero by 2070. This gives India an
additional 10 years from 2060, the year that China has announced for achieving net zero. This is
reasonable as India is still at an early stage of development.
Figures 1 and 2 represent per capita and total emissions on a global level (Crippa et al., 2023).

Russia 17.99
USA 17.90
China 10.95
EU 27 8.09
Global Total 6.76
Brazil 6.05
Indonesia 4.47
India 2.79

0 5 10 15 20
tCO2eq/capita

Figure 1: Country-wise per-capita GHG emissions

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 1


Russia and the USA have one of highest per capita emissions followed by China. India’s per capita
emissions are much lower than the global average of 6.76 tCO2eq. India is still a developing nation
and has a long journey ahead in becoming a developed country. China leads the global emissions
share followed by the USA. India has the third largest emissions while the European Union (EU) is
a close fourth.

China 15685
USA 6017
India 3943
EU 27 3588
Russia 2580
Brazil 1310
Indonesia 1241
Internaonal shipping 751
Internaonal aviaon 426

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000 18000


MtCO2eq

Figure 2: Total GHG emissions at the global level

1.1 Objective of the Paper


India seems to be on track towards achieving its 2030 goal of having 500 GW of fossil fuel free
power generating capacity. It has launched a highly ambitious National Hydrogen Mission. This
Mission is rapidly taking shape and is being well funded. This would position India well to undertake
decarbonization of the hard-to-abate sectors.
This, therefore, seems the right time to begin analysis and discussion on how India’s journey to
net zero could be undertaken and what it would entail. This paper is a preliminary attempt in this
direction. It assumes that India in the coming decades would become a developed country. It
would have their levels of per capita incomes, and consequently energy consumption.
It looks at the sectors which account for major shares of India’s GHG emissions. For each sector it
attempts a conceptual framework for analysis of the feasible transition to net zero. The underlying
premise is that decoupling of the rise in carbon emissions from growth would be the key to
moving towards net zero. This study takes into account factors which would lead to inflection
points for decoupling. It is not a comprehensive study with modelling and financial projections
under different scenarios. It attempts to delineate the kind of detailed sector-wise modelling and
working out of financial implications for each scenario that would need to be undertaken. There
would be a need to keep revisiting these exercises every few years as technological developments
and movements down the cost curves are highly uncertain and unpredictable.

2 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


1.2 Conceptual Framework
For purely analytical purposes, it is assumed that India’s per capita income and per capita energy
consumption would reach current EU levels at some point of time in the future when India catches
up and becomes a developed country. Net zero would be possible only with the decoupling of
growth from increase in carbon emissions. India’s per capita CO2 emissions would rise, reach a
peak, remain steady at a plateau, and then decline.
The time to reach the peak would depend on the complete penetration of carbon free technologies
and would be different for different sectors ranging from a few years to decades.
The emissions would peak in a sector only when all the incremental energy demand would be met
without using fossil fuels in that sector. Decoupling of growth in a sector from increase in carbon
emissions would occur. This is the critical inflection point.
Once the peak is reached, emissions will plateau. This would mean that the emissions would
remain at their peak level till the time the existing carbon emitting systems continue to function.
But in the period after which the emissions have peaked, energy consumption would continue
to rise. Emissions are then expected to decline once the carbon emitting technologies begin
getting phased out of the system. As seen from Figure 3, the peak can be reached early through
a sharper trajectory R1, or emissions can peak gradually through path R2, but a much higher level,
as development would continue, more emissions would have occurred during the slow transition
pathway. The peak in both the trajectories would remain either for a shorter or longer duration and
decline would occur through paths D1 or D2, respectively. The decline of emissions could be fast,
as shown in paths D1a or D2a, or gradual, as shown in paths D1b or D2b depending upon the rate
of phase out of fossil based technologies, which would again vary from sector to sector.
Per capita emissions (tCO2eq)
Per capita emissions (tCO2eq)

D1b D2b
R1
R2
D2a
D1a

Year Year

Figure 3: India’s per capita emissions illustrative pathways


While emissions would decline, per capita energy consumption would continue to rise. Growth
would get decoupled from carbon emissions. This decoupling would lead to net zero once carbon
free energy begins replacing all fossil fuel-based energy consumption in a sector.
The higher the level of emissions at the time of peaking in a sector, the greater would be the cost
of bringing the emissions down to zero as the number of carbon emitting plants. to be retired
in any sector would be larger. To illustrate, at current levels, China would need to close down
about 1390 GW of thermal power whereas India would have to close down only about 243 GW at
current levels.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 3


India has the late mover’s advantage. Investment in creating lumpy long term carbon emitting
capital assets need to be scrutinized through the prism of the future trajectory of the retirement
of such assets. This would require assessing least cost options for reaching net zero in a sector
through life cycle costing. Stakeholders need to engage with this issue and evolve a consensus
on how to do so. Government would need to keep developing appropriate policy instruments to
incentivize least cost investment decisions in the economy.
Energy efficiency is a low hanging fruit. It results in modest decoupling of growth from increase
in carbon emissions. This is because the same level of service can be delivered with less energy
consumption, or the same energy can deliver more service output. In both scenarios, increase in
energy consumption and emissions becomes lower. However, for the achievement of net zero, the
use of fossil fuels would need to end altogether.
In the subsequent sections, the decarbonization pathways of the major sectors are delineated.
These are:
• Electricity,
• Surface transport,
• Residential cooking, and
• Hard-to-abate sectors—industry, shipping, aviation, and agriculture.
The decoupling between sectoral growth and carbon emissions which will be the key to the
transition to net zero will be examined.
India’s total GHG emissions, excluding land use and land-use change and forestry (LULUCF),
amounts to 3132 MtCO2eq (NITI Aayog, 2024). Figure 4 represents the emissions from different
sectors and their share in total emissions (NITI Aayog, 2024).

2.34%
8.41%

Energy
13.44%
Agriculture
Waste
Industrial Processes and
75.81% Product Use

Figure 4: India’s sectoral emissions share

4 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


Figure 5 represents the break-up of India’s energy sub-sector emissions. The total emissions from
energy sector in 2019 is about 2375 MtCO2eq. From Figure 5, it can be inferred that electricity
production has a 52% share of energy sector (1240 MtCO2eq) emissions followed by industry and
transport (NITI Aayog, 2024).

1400
1240
1200

Electricity producon
1000 Manufacturing industries and construcon
Transport
Residenal
800 Commercial-Instuonal
MtCO2eq

Refinery
Fugive
600 Biomass burnt for energy
Manufacturing of solid fuels
405 Agriculture/Fisheries
400
315

200 159
110
83
36 15 9 3
0

Figure 5: India’s energy sector emissions

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 5


2 CARBON FREE
ELECTRICITY

2.1 Emissions from Electricity Sector in India


Emissions from electricity sector is 1240 MtCO2eq which amounts to 39.5% of India’s total
emissions in 2019 (NITI Aayog, 2024). The power sector is the single largest emitter of CO2 in
India. The average emission per unit of electricity in 2019–20 is estimated to be 0.668 kgCO2/kWh.
India is at an early stage of development and would catch up with the advanced economies. Its
per capita GDP and electricity consumption would reach their levels. Its per capita electricity
consumption is low at 1255 kWh in 2020–22, about one-third of the global average (CEA, 2021). For
conceptual analysis, we are assuming that India’s electricity consumption is going to rise and will
ultimately reach European levels. Europe’s per capita electricity consumption was 6687 kWh in
2021 (Climate equity monitor, n.d.). Hence, about 1.4 billion population would be expected to have
an electricity consumption of about 9362 billion kWh ultimately. As India, in due course, becomes
an advanced economy, its electricity consumption is likely to grow by 5–6 times and peak when it
reaches present EU levels, a reasonable assumption for purposes of analysis.
For India to achieve net zero, full decarbonization of the electricity sector would have to take place.
This would require decoupling of increase in electricity production and consumption from carbon
emissions from the electricity sector. This would be achieved by the generation of electricity from
non-fossil fuel sources. India’s per capita electricity consumption would then increase, yet its
carbon emissions per unit of electricity would decline. The CO2 emission intensity would decline
with an increasing share of electricity generation without the use of fossil fuels.
The share of generation from non-fossil fuel sources in total electricity generation is 21.7% in 2023
(MOP, 2023). India aims to achieve its 500 GW of non-fossil fuel capacity target by 2030. The
share of non-fossil fuels in installed capacity is already 43% as of May 2024 (MOP, 2024). As the
share of non-fossil fuel sources would rise, the carbon emissions per unit of electricity would
decline. The key inflection point would be reached when all additional demand is met from non-
fossil fuel sources. This would require success in grid scale storage so that demand can be fully
met when the sun is not shining, and renewable energy (RE) generation is inadequate.
India’s electricity sector decarbonization would have the following trajectory:
1. Once all incremental electricity demand is met by non-fossil resources and no new investment
in thermal plants is needed, emissions will peak. The peak could be reached through different
paths, either steeply (R1), i.e., the penetration of non-fossil energy resources is faster for
electricity production, or gradually through (R2), i.e., penetration of non-fossil resources is
slower. In path R2, the peak would be reached at a much higher emissions level, as with

6 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


growing electricity demand, more emissions would be released due to slower penetration of
non-fossil generation technologies.
2. The total emissions would remain at a peak, till the existing thermal fleet is functional in the
system. These thermal plants could remain there for a shorter duration and decline through
D1 or could remain there for a long time and decline through D2.
3. Once the existing thermal plants start getting decommissioned, the total emissions would
start to decline. The decommissioning can be rapid with emissions declining steeply through
D1a or D2a, or slow with the emissions declining gradually, through D1b or D2b.
The electricity emissions pathways illustration is represented in Figure 6.
Electricity emissions (MtCO2eq)

Electricity emissions (MtCO2eq)


D1b D2b
R1
R2
D2a
D1a

Year Year

Figure 6: Electricity emissions pathways illustration

2.2 Key Strategies for Electricity Decarbonization in India


a.) Energy storage
The key for the decarbonization of India’s electricity sector lies in being able to meet all incremental
demand from non-fossil fuel sources. For this to happen, success in creating large-scale grid
storage is essential. India has created a competitive industry structure in renewables. The cost of
solar power in India is amongst the cheapest in the world.
Storage is needed as generation from renewables, solar and wind, is intermittent. At certain times
of the day, renewable generation would be more than the demand. The storage of excess RE
would be necessary to prevent losing electricity, which has zero marginal cost.
Then if demand is to be met without the use of fossil fuels when RE generation is not taking place,
this can be done only by using stored RE. Stored RE has to be large enough to provide reliable
supply at all times of the day and throughout the year. Once this happens round-the-clock carbon
free electricity supply on a large scale would become a reality.

b.) Nuclear power


Nuclear power is a good stable source of fossil fuel free electricity generation with no carbon
emissions. With storage, it can provide round-the-clock reliable supply to meet varying demands

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 7


during the day across the year. The share of nuclear power in electricity in India is 1.7% (MOP,
2024). This can be increased. In the long run, having a reasonable share of nuclear power in
the fossil fuel-free energy mix would be prudent. The cost of nuclear power from domestically
designed and constructed plants is amongst the lowest in the world. The pace of development
could be scaled up as the supply of fuel is no longer a constraint due to India having obtained the
clearance of the Nuclear Suppliers Group for the import of nuclear fuel.

c.) No new investments in thermal power plants


Solar energy along with storage has become cost effective as compared to new coal. Investing in
solar plus storage could be the least cost option going forward. The tariffs discovered in Renewable
Energy-Round-the-Clock (RE-RTC) tenders have proven to be highly competitive, with recent bid
tariffs ranging between `4.25 and Rupee Foradian4.43 per unit (Renewable Watch , 2024 ). This
is notably lower than the `5.2 per unit discovered in a recent bid for supply from coal-based
projects (Shetty, 2023). Repeated tendering for large grid scale projects would be essential for
accelerating the pace of creation of energy storage systems. With competition and scale, costs
of storage may decline significantly. As of November 2023, more than 8 GW of energy storage
systems (ESS) tenders have been awarded with more than 60% of this capacity being allocated in
2023 alone (IEEFA, 2023).
To support and develop a market for storage systems, the Ministry of Power implemented energy
storage obligations (ESO) as a distinct and compulsory element of renewable purchase obligations
(RPOs). According to the policy document, there is a stipulated annual increase in ESO for all
obligated entities, beginning at 1% in FY2023–24 and reaching 4% in FY2029–30 (MOP, 2022). The
Ministry of Power has also come up with the National Framework for Promoting Energy Storage
Systems (MOP, 2023). The objective of this framework is to develop an ecosystem for ESS to be
able to supply reliable carbon free green electricity. A TERI study on India’s 2030 decarbonization
target (Shankar, Saxena, and Idnani, 2022) has prioritized storage technologies while giving
preference to pumped storage plants (PSP) and concentrated solar thermal (CSP) with storage
(Shankar, Saxena, and Mazumdar, 2024a). TERI has carried out detailed studies on these two
technologies, i.e., PSP and CSP with storage (Shankar, Saxena and Mazumdar, 2024b). The Solar
Energy Corporation of India (SECI) has announced that it plans to issue tenders for a concentrated
solar thermal storage project of 500 MW round-the-clock green energy in the next year (ET, 2024).
The transition away from coal in India will depend on the speed, cost, and scale of the creation of
large-scale grid storage. As confidence in the ability to meet full demand only from renewables
and storage grows and as it becomes clearer that this is the cheaper way of meeting additional
demand, the development of new thermal plants would end.

d.) Decommissioning of thermal power plants


Once RE along with storage is being created on the scale needed to meet all additional demand,
then total emissions from electricity would peak. Decommissioning of thermal power plants
thereafter would be the way to get to net zero. There would be costs. A just transition needs to be
carefully planned in the coming years.
Policy and regulatory measures would be required to implement the decommissioning of plants.
The costs incurred in the process could be offset partially, or fully, by diversifying and gradually

8 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


transforming coal companies into green energy companies. Coal India is cash-rich with a huge
land bank. This land could be repurposed for use in other productive and revenue generating
activities. Effective programmes for reskilling workers for the post coal economy in the coal mining
areas need to be designed. Initial pilot project need to be undertaken when coal production from
a particular mine ends and the mine is closed.

2.3 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Electricity


The following detailed studies would be needed on an ongoing basis to get greater clarity on the
feasible pathways for achieving a carbon emissions free electricity system:
• Generate alternative scenarios of demand growth and undertake modelling exercises to
determine timelines and cost implications for the installation of RE and large-scale grid
storage for reaching the inflection point when reliable supply for additional demand would
not need new thermal capacity.
• Feasible pace of creating new nuclear capacity. Trajectory of cost reduction to make life cycle
cost comparable to RE plus storage.
• Feasible options for transition of Coal India and thermal power companies, NTPC and others,
into green fossil fuel free energy companies.
• Studies and pilot projects with stakeholder consultation for repurposing of land of exhausted
coal mines for productive use and revenue generation.
• Costs of just transition away from coal: loss of jobs, royalties to the states. Feasibility of
meeting these partially or fully with repurposing of land and revenue generation from other
economic activities.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 9


3 SECTORAL TRANSITIONS
TO NET ZERO THROUGH
GREEN ELECTRICITY

3.1 Surface Transport


India’s transport emission is about 315 MtCO2eq (NITI Aayog, 2024), which is about 10% of total
national emissions.
Electrification would be the driver of transport decarbonization in India. This is the case in Europe
and California.
16
Number of EVs In Lakhs
14
The rising share of electric vehicles (EVs) in India
12
is represented in Figure 7 (MoRTH). 10
8
EV adoption in Delhi shows a highly positive 6
trend, represented in Figure 8 (MoRTH). Apart 4
2
from the three-wheelers with more than 70% 0
2021 2022 2023
of EVs in annual registrations, electrification of
Year
buses has been phenomenal with almost 46% of
new registrations being EVs. Figure 7: National trend of EV penetration

12 90
80
10
70
% of EV (3W and Bus)

8 60
50
% of EV

6
40
4 30
20
2
10
0 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023

2W 4W LGV MHGV Total 3W Bus

Figure 8: Trend of EV penetration among newly registered vehicles in Delhi

10 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


Blending of biofuels for use by vehicles is similar to energy efficiency as an intermediate option
to lower carbon intensity. Vehicles which run only on biofuels are carbon free as biofuel is a
renewable source of energy. But if forests are cut for sugarcane plantations to get ethanol as a
biofuel, then the negative impacts far outweigh the benefits. Similarly, if price signals for biofuel
lead to diversion of food crops for human beings for biofuels, this is an outcome which must be
avoided. India does not have the land and water endowments for biofuel to be a significant option
for decarbonization of transport.
The decarbonization path of road transport would be as follows:
I. The share of EVs in new sales rises rapidly.
II. All new vehicles on the road become electric.
III. Share of RE in electricity rises. Per passenger kilometre emissions begin to decline.
IV. Electricity becomes carbon free making all EVs carbon free.
V. Heavy-duty trucks become green hydrogen trucks.
VI. Once all new vehicle sales are of EVs or hydrogen trucks, the emissions will reach their peak
and plateau.
VII. The emissions would begin to decline, with the phasing out of existing internal combustion-
based vehicles.
VIII. As the economy grows, passenger kilometres will rise. The corresponding per kilometre
emissions will rise, plateau, and then decline towards zero.
Once sales of new vehicles are entirely electric and hydrogen-based heavy-duty trucks, carbon
emissions from road transport will peak. The existing vehicle fleet of petrol/diesel/compressed
natural gas (CNG)/hybrid will begin to retire simultaneously and once these vehicles age and are
fully phased out of the system, the direct carbon emissions from vehicles would become zero. But
overall carbon emissions from electricity generation have to peak, decline and become zero for
the same effect to be seen in road transport. The peak and decline of carbon emissions from road
transport would depend upon the penetration of green vehicles reaching 100% on the one hand
and the electricity system getting fully decarbonized.
Figure 9: represents a stylized (a) trajectory of change in percentage of internal combustion engine
(ICE) vehicles and EVs; and (b) the parallel decline in carbon emissions per unit of electricity.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 11


100

Pathway towards 100% EV penetraon

Percentage

Decline share of ICE vehioles

Time
Decline in per unit of electricity emissions

0.7 0.668
0.658
0.6
0.548
0.5 0.477
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0

30
-2

-2

-2

-3

20
19

20

26

29

d
20

20

20

20

n
yo
Be

Figure 9: Change in share of ICE vehicles and EVs and decline of carbon emissions per unit of electricity
The Indian Railways have a 3% share of transport emissions. They have announced their intention
to reach net zero by 2030. This could be achieved with the following measures:
• Completion of full electrification of Railways for all passenger and freight movement.
• Electricity consumed by Railways would have to become carbon-free by 2030. For this the
use of captive solar power generation with green energy open access would be necessary.

12 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


Figure 10 represents the expected emissions trajectory in the transport sector. Emissions can
reach their peak through two trajectories R1 or R2 depending on trajectories of EV penetration.
In case of pathway R2, the emissions will peak at a much higher level, as number of vehicles will
continue to rise due to rising demand, and more emissions will be released, by the time the electric
and hydrogen based vehicle penetration takes place at a slower pace. In the transport sector,
emissions are expected to decline after reaching a peak and not stay at a plateau. The emissions
would follow path D which would be gradual. The retirement of old vehicles is a continuing
process. Once all new vehicles are electric, the older internal combustion engines which would
be retiring would result in the decline of total emissions from the sector straight away.
Transport emissions (MtCO2eq)

R1
R2 D2
D1

Year

Figure 10: Transport emissions pathways illustration

3.1.1 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Transport


a. Electric vehicles
• Scenarios on EV penetration of having the dominant market share and then complete market
share.
» 2 wheelers
» 3 wheelers
» 4 wheelers
» Bus
» Light duty vehicles
• Provision of charging infrastructure to keep pace with the growth of EVs.
• Study of challenges and policy instruments for achieving 100% share of EVs.
• Estimation of additional electricity demand required for the EVs and impact on the demand
curve. Distribution Companies (DISCOMs) to incorporate this in their demand projections.
• Technical and commercial implications of converting roads into electric highways.

b. Heavy duty trucks


Green hydrogen is presently seen as the viable substitute for fossil fuels in heavy-duty trucks.
Technological development of batteries for heavy duty trucks is being pursued. Incentives needed
for the replacement of heavy-duty diesel trucks by hydrogen vehicles.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 13


3.2 RESIDENTIAL COOKING
Residential cooking in India utilizes multiple fuels with varying proportions in rural and urban
households. Currently, urban dwellings use liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), piped natural gas
(PNG), and limited application of electric cooking, in households with higher incomes. In rural
areas, LPG and biomass are the main cooking fuels with LPG rapidly replacing biomass due to the
Ujjwala programme.
The adoption of electricity for cooking and electricity becoming carbon free would be the twin
drivers for the decarbonization of cooking. The use of electric cookstoves at the household level in
place of gas for cooking would be the key challenge. The person cooking must find the experience
of using an electric cookstove for all traditional Indian dishes satisfactory.
Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi recently announced the Pradhan Mantri Suryodaya Yojana
(PMSY) 2024, under which 10 million households will be provided with solar PV panels. This would
enable a faster transition towards electric cooking especially in the households of the weaker
sections for whom the price of an LPG cylinder appears high. Electricity in comparison is cheaper.
A few states are giving free units of electricity to households, ranging from 100 to 300 units per
month. The price signal for use of electricity is strong. But change in consumer perception and
experience is a prerequisite for large scale switch over from gas to electricity for cooking.
The use of biogas as a renewable source of energy for cooking has potential. But production and
reliable supply of biogas for cooking along with a viable business model needs to be successfully
demonstrated in some pilot projects. Scaling up would become a feasible option only after
successful implementation of pilot projects with consumer satisfaction.

3.2.1 Studies Needed for Decarbonization of Cooking


• Getting electric cooking stoves out in the market which find acceptance from consumers as
a replacement for gas for cooking of traditional food preparations.
• Explore feasibility of aggregation and cheaper supply of induction stoves through DISCOMs
through a programme design based on the successful LED promotion programme.
• Pilot projects to develop a robust scalable model for biogas production and use for cooking
in rural homes.
• Estimation of additional electric demand for cooking and its incorporation in DISCOMs
demand planning.
• Feasible policy instruments for phasing down the use of LPG, for the complete decarbonization
of residential cooking.

14 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


4 HARD-TO-ABATE
SECTORS

Hard-to-abate sectors are those in which current levels of technology and costs today are such
that decarbonization appears difficult. These sectors include industry, shipping, aviation, and
agriculture. In some sectors such as agriculture, carbon sinks will be the primary or the only
solution for achieving net zero.
India has plans to transition towards Green Hydrogen economy. The Ministry of New and Renewable
Energy (MNRE) has launched Green Hydrogen Mission (MNRE, 2023) which will build capabilities
to produce at least 5 million metric tonne (MMT) of green hydrogen per annum by 2030, with
potential to reach 10 MMT per annum with growth of export markets. It is envisaged that green
hydrogen production, supply, and uses would create the ecosystem and the domestic capacities
for rapid scaling up by the end of this decade. The Mission aims to develop and scale up green
hydrogen production technology and make it affordable and widely accessible.

4.1 Industry
India’s industry emissions (manufacturing industries and construction) is about 405 MtCO2eq
(NITI Aayog, 2024), which is about 13% of total national emissions. The industrial sector accounted
for 56% of total energy consumption in 2021–22 (BEE, 2022). Approximately half of all industrial
carbon emissions originate from the following six large industrial segments:
a) Iron & Steel
b) Cement
c) Aluminium
d) Fertilizer & Ammonia
e) Pulp and Paper
f) Petrochemicals
The CO2 emissions from the industrial sector can primarily be attributed to combustion of fossil
fuels in furnaces and boilers, process emissions and electricity usage in the plants.
The main pillars of industrial decarbonization are:

a.) Industrial electrification (non-fossil/RE)


Industrial electrification involves transitioning industrial processes away from the use of fossil
fuel-based energy to electricity to the extent it is technically feasible. As electricity production
moves towards becoming carbon free, these industrial processes would in parallel start becoming
carbon free.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 15


b.) Solar thermal
The use of solar thermal power for low/medium temperature heating in industrial processes has
considerable potential as a substitute for fossil fuels. This is a low hanging relatively neglected
fruit. It needs to be promoted with appropriate policies to evolve in partnership with industry.

c.) Green hydrogen


Green hydrogen has great potential for the decarbonization of hard-to-abate sectors. India is
implementing an ambitious Green Hydrogen Mission. To illustrate, the use of green hydrogen can
be the key to the decarbonization of fertilizer and steel production.
As India makes its transition to becoming a developed economy, high growth in industrial
production would take place. The emissions would continue to rise till the time additional energy
demand for industrial production is met completely by carbon free electricity, solar thermal, and
green hydrogen. Emissions would then peak. The emissions would remain at their peak till the
time that the existing carbon-intensive technologies continue to function. The emissions would
begin to decline when the carbon emitting industrial units are phased out of the system.
A stylized trajectory is shown in Figure 11. The pace of rise and decline of emissions would depend
upon the rate of penetration of green technologies and then the closure of carbon emitting plants.
The emission rise and decline can happen in multiple trajectories, as shown in Figure 11, R1 for a
steep rise, R2 for a gradual rise. In case of path R2, the emission will peak at a higher level, as the
demand for industrial products will continue to rise with India’s growth journey. Conceptually, the
peak could remain for a shorter duration and emissions could decline using either D1a (steep) or
D1b (gradual), while the peak could also stay for a long time and emissions could then decline
rapidly using path D2a, or gradually using path D2b.
Industry emissions (MtCO2eq)

Industry emissions (MtCO2eq)

D1b D2b
R1
R2
D2a
D1a

Year Year

Figure 11: Industry emissions pathways illustration

To shift to a greener path and decouple growth from increase in emissions would be a difficult
challenge for each industry. Technologies for doing away with the use of fossil fuels in production
need pilot projects to discover the cost. Pilot projects need to be taken up in each industry
segment as the technology for lower carbon or carbon free production emerges. India could try
and be on the global frontier in decarbonization of industry.

16 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


The products manufactured in the pilot plants without using fossil fuels would be more expensive
than the ones in the market using fossil fuels. The transition to having all new plants becoming
carbon free would pose many complex challenges for policymakers.
Deciding on the policy for the closure of existing plants would be even more challenging. So
much would depend on the costs at that point of time.

4.1.1 Studies needed for green hydrogen - Industry


• Prepare implementation design for pilot projects and demonstration plants using green
hydrogen for production of green carbon free fertilizer and steel. Assess financial support
required.
• Mapping of optimal locations for green hydrogen production based on various factors
including water needs and availability.
• Proramme design for production of green hydrogen from biowaste.
• After initial pilot projects, an assessment of scenarios for the likely decline of costs with larger
volumes.
• Feasible policy instruments for scaling up with cost implications. scaling up with cost
implications.

4.2 Shipping
Green hydrogen or green ammonia made from green hydrogen are potential carbon-free
substitute fuels for engines in shipping. In the shipping sector, pilot projects may be started to
discover costs for both.
From an air and water pollution perspective all inland waterways should become fossil fuel-
free under a national programme. Smaller boats can use electric engines and the larger ones,
hydrogen-based fuel.

4.2.1 Studies needed


• Green hydrogen as the substitute for fossil fuels in shipping either as direct use or as green
ammonia.
• Studies on complete switchover to green fuels: Affordable and feasible policy instruments.

4.3 Aviation
In the aviation sector, India may have to follow global trends. The key is development of planes by
the global majors, Boeing and Airbus, which can run on biofuel or hydrogen. For short haul flights,
even electric routes might be feasible.
India could also choose to become more ambitious. It could begin a programme for development
of hydrogen-based engines for aviation either on its own or in partnerships with others global
players.

4.4 Agriculture
The agriculture sector is the main source of CH4 and N2O emissions. Methane (CH4) emissions

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 17


occur mainly due to livestock rearing and rice cultivation. The agriculture sector contributes
13.4% of the total national GHG emissions which is about 420 MtCO2eq (NITI Aayog, 2024). The
sub-sectoral emission bifurcation is shown in Figure 12 (NITI Aayog, 2024)

250
223
Agriculture emissions (MtCO2eq)
200

150

100 88
73

50 28
8
0
Enteric Fermentaon Agricultural soils
Rice Culvaon Manure Management
Field Burning of Agricultural Residues

Figure 12: Agricultural sector emissions

a.) Addressing emissions from enteric fermentation


In 2019, emissions from livestock category accounted for about 223 MtCO2eq. The total livestock
population is 535.780 million and rising and so are the emissions (DAH, 2019).
The mitigation options for reducing emissions from enteric fermentation are changes in feed of
livestock and improvements in dietary contents. High-quality pasture has been shown to lower
methane yield by 12–51% as compared to traditional low-quality grazing systems.
There is, however, no technical solution for complete mitigation of emissions. Carbon sequestration
by creating sinks would be required to achieve net zero ultimately.

b.) Emission reduction from rice cultivation


In India, approximately 47.6 lakh hectares of land are under rice cultivation (PIB, 2020). Methane
emissions from rice cultivation systems vary depending on existing ecological and environmental
conditions. In 2019, emissions from rice cultivation amounted to 73 MtCO2eq.
The potential mitigation strategies for reducing emissions from rice cultivation are a System for
Rice Intensification (SRI) and Direct Seeded Rice (DSR) or Alternate Wetting and Drying (AWD).
These techniques lead to a reduction of 30%–50% emissions and co-benefits such as improvement
in soil health and reduction in water use, i.e., around 10%–20% without reducing yield.
However, for achieving net zero altogether carbon sinks would have to be the solution.

c.) Emission reduction by using biowaste as a renewable source of energy to


reduce fossil fuel use

18 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


The quantum of crop residues from India’s farm economy is about 500–680 million tonnes out of
which 180–240 million tonnes is surplus crop residue every year. In most parts these residues are
used as fodder. These residues are a rich source of renewable organic carbon that can be used
to produce fuel, chemicals, biochar, or petrochemical feedstock. Developing biochar from crop
residues is a good substitute for coal in thermal power plants. Biochar cofiring has the potential to
reduce the CO2 emissions from coal burning in thermal power plants, by 165 MT annually, i.e., 7%
of overall emissions by India (Anand, Pathak, Kumar, & Kaushal, 2022).

d.) Emissions from manure management


The government is promoting the usage of dung-based manure. Manure management initiatives
have the potential to generate biogas equivalent to 50% of India’s present LPG consumption
and produce bio-slurry equivalent to 44% of India’s Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Potassium (NPK)
requirement. The potential opportunities for the conversion of cow dung into commercial
applications include emissions from manure value chains, conversion of cow dung to biogas, and
setting up of biogas-based energy generation for dairy plants (PIB, 2019).

4.4.1 Studies needed


• Feasible change in feed of livestock to reduce emissions.
• Design a programme for use of cow dung as a renewable source of energy with zero methane
emissions.
• R&D for biotechnological or thermochemical routes for efficient use of crop wastes.
• Design a programme to use all the crop waste, that is being burnt and causing a spike in air
pollution, to produce pellets and for their use as a substitute for coal in thermal plants.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 19


5
CONCLUSION

The pathway to decarbonization of electricity has some clarity. Modelling exercises and alternative
scenarios with cost implications which are reasonably realistic can be generated. These can
be revised and updated as the transition unfolds. Peaking of emissions from electricity can be
achieved without additional costs and may even result in some cost savings.
Reducing emissions from their peak to zero would have costs. But there could be potential gains
if the transition is well planned, and these may offset partially or even fully the costs from the
phasing out of thermal power and consequent closure of coal mines at a future date. This would
need ongoing analysis and stakeholder consultations in the coming years.
Electrification of surface transport creates the pathway for reduction of emissions in tandem
with the decarbonization of the electricity sector. As emissions from electricity reach zero and all
transport becomes green, about 50% of our present emissions would get eliminated.
For the hard-to-abate sectors, it is too early to see the contours of the journey to net zero. Pilot
projects for downstream use of solar thermal and green hydrogen in different segments need to
be implemented. Some clarity on the higher cost resulting from the giving up of the use of fossil
fuels as well as the potential for cost reduction with scale would emerge on completion of pilot
projects. A view on the affordable pathways to net zero in each of the hard-to-abate sectors could
then emerge under alternative scenarios.
Some emissions are expected to continue in segments where hydrogen and electricity cannot
be a full substitute for the existing use of fossil fuels. Cement is a good example. No substitute
is available to replace cement and no technological advancement has taken place to fully
decarbonize its manufacturing process.
The absorption of such residual emissions would be a challenge. Creation of sinks through
afforestation would be one option. Carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon capture
utilization and storage (CCUS) would be the other options. These may need to be utilized for the
last steps in the journey to becoming net zero.
This paper is a simplified macro view of the pathways to net zero in the major GHG emitting sectors
and sees the transition through the prism of decoupling of growth and increase in total energy
consumption from carbon emissions which would peak, plateau and then decline to become
net zero.
Each sector has complexity and would need detailed modelling, generation of alternative
scenarios with timelines and cost implications. Alternative policy instruments for facilitating and

20 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


accelerating the transition would need to be designed with stakeholder consultations. A long-
term net zero perspective backed by increasingly rigorous analysis would make it easier to take
optimal decisions which steer us to the least cost pathways towards net zero.
It is hoped that this paper would generate interest and the process of undertaking the detailed
sectoral studies envisaged in the paper would begin. Discussions on these studies would help
in the emergence of some consensus on the way forward and contribute to India continuing
to display climate leadership while accelerating its transition to becoming a developed globally
competitive green economy.

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 21


6
REFERENCES

1. Anand, A., Pathak, S., Kumar, V., & Kaushal, P. (2022). Biochar production from crop residues, its
characterization and utilization for electricity generation in India. Journal of Cleaner Production,
1333074. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.133074\
2. Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE). (2022). National Energy Data: Survey and Analysis Retrieved from
https://beeindia.gov.in/sites/default/files/Energy%20Data%20Management%20Report%20_pdf.pdf
3. Central Electricity Authority (CEA). (2021). All India Electricity Statistics. General Review 2023.
Retrieved from Ministry of Power, Government of India: https://cea.nic.in/wp-content/uploads/
general/2022/GR_Final.pdf
4. Crippa, M., Guizzardi, D., Pagani, F., Banja, M., Muntean, M., Schaaf E., Becker, W., Monforti-Ferrario,
F., Quadrelli, R., Risquez Martin, A., Taghavi-Moharamli, P., Köykkä, J., Grassi, G., Rossi, S., Brandao
De Melo, J., Oom, D., Branco, A., San-Miguel, J., Vignati, E., GHG emissions of all world countries,
Publications Office of the European Union, Luxembourg, 2023, doi:10.2760/953332, JRC134504
5. Climate Equity Monitor (n.d). Electricity Generation by Countries. Retreived from https://
climateequitymonitor.in/resource-consumption-electricity.html
6. Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying (DAH). (2019). 20th Livestock Census.Retrieved
fromhttps://dahd.nic.in/sites/default/filess/Key%20Results%2BAnnexure%2018.10.2019.pdf
7. Economic Times (ET) (2024, March 4). SECI to issue 500 MW of concentrated solar-thermal power
project. Retreived from https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/renewable/seci-to-issue-
tender-for-500-mw-concentrated-solar-thermal-power-project/108189940
8. Institute of Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) (2023). Energy Storage: Connecting India
to Clean Power on Demand. Retrieved from https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/2023-12/Energy%20
Storage_Dec23.pdf
9. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (IPCC). (2023). Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report.
Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, H. Lee and J. Romero (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland,
pp. 35-115, doi: 10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647
10. Ministry of External Affairs (MEA). (2023). National Statement by Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi
at COP26 Summit in Glasgow. Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India.Retrieved from
https://www.mea.gov.in/Speeches-Statements.htm?dtl/34466/National+Statement+by+Prime+Ministe
r+Shri+Narendra+Modi+at+COP26+Summit+in+Glasgow
11. Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE). (2023). National Green Hydrogen Mission. Retrieved
from National green hydrogen mission: https://cdnbbsr.s3waas.gov.in/s3716e1b8c6cd17b771da7739
1355749f3/uploads/2023/01/2023012338.pdf
12. Ministry of Power (MoP). (2022). Renewable Purchase Obligation and Energy Storage Obligation
till 2030. Retrieved from Renewable purchase obligation and energy storage obligation trajectory
till 2029-30: https://powermin.gov.in/sites/default/files/webform/notices/Renewable_Purchase_
Obligation_and_Energy_Storage_Obligation_Trajectory_till_2029_30.pdf

22 India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis


13. Ministry of Power (MoP). (2023). National Framework for Promoting Energy Storage Systems.
Retreived from https://powermin.gov.in/sites/default/files/webform/notices/National_Framework_for_
promoting_Energy_Storage_Systems_August_2023.pdf
14. Ministry of Power (MOP). (2023). Annual Report 2022-2023. Retreived from https://powermin.gov.in/
sites/default/files/uploads/MOP_Annual_Report_Eng_2022-23.pdf
15. Ministry of Power (MoP). (2024). Power Sector at a Glance. Retreived from https://powermin.gov.in/
en/content/power-sector-glance-all-india
16. Ministry of Road Transport & Highways (MoRTH). Retrieved from National Register: Vehicles Data:
https://vahan.parivahan.gov.in/nrservices/faces/user/login.xhtml
17. National Institution for Transforming India (NITI) Aayog. (2024). India Climate and Energy Dashboard.
National Institute of Transforming India. Retrieved from https://iced.niti.gov.in/
18. Press Information Bureau (PIB). (2019). Shri Parshottam Rupala releases NDDB's subsidiary for
manure management: Retrieved from https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1844770
19. Press Information Bureau (PIB). (2020). Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare. Sowing area
coverage under Kharif crop: Retrieved from https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1644178
20. Renewable Watch. (2024). REMCL declares winners of its 750 MW renewable projects. Retrieved from
https://renewablewatch.in/2024/02/02/remcl-declares-winners-of-its-750-mw-renewable-projects/
21. Shankar, A., Saxena A., and Idnani T. (2022). Roadmap to India's 2030 decarbonisation target. New
Delhi. The Energy and Resources Institute. Retreived from https://www.teriin.org/sites/default/files/
files/Roadmap-to-India-2030-Decarbonization-Target.pdf
22. Shankar, A., Saxena, A., & Mazumdar, R. (A). (2024). Pumped Storage Plants-Essential for India's
energy transition. New Delhi: The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI). Retrieved from https://teriin.
org/sites/default/files/2024-01/Pumped%20Storage%20Plants%20Discussion%20Paper%202023.pdf
23. Shankar, A., Saxena, A., & Mazumdar, R. (B). (2024). Concentrating Solar Power plants with storage:
Deployment Essential Now. Retreived from chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/
https://teriin.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/CSP_Report_2024_New.pdf
24. Shetty, S. (2023). RE-RTC tariffs outshine coal bid at 4.0-4.5 per unit says ICRA. Solar Quarter.
Retrieved from https://solarquarter.com/2023/12/11/re-rtc-tariffs-outshine-coal-bids-at-rs-4-0-4-5-
per-unit-says-icra/
25. United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). (2023). UNEP Gap Emissions Gap Report 2023.
Retreived from https://www.unep.org/resources/emissions-gap-report-2023

India’s Journey to Net Zero: A Conceptual Framework for Analysis 23

You might also like