Transformer Differential Protection Calculation
Transformer Differential Protection Calculation
Transformer Differential Protection Calculation
2008 Page 1 of 21
CONFIDENTIAL
RELAY SETTING CALCULATION FOR DIFFERENTIAL AND The information contained
REF. in this document is not to
be communicated either
directly or indirectly to any
person not
authorised to receive it.
Page 2 of 21
CONTENTS
2 CALCULATION FOR P122 FOR HV SIDE REF PROTECTION. ..................................................3
2.1 STABILISING RESISTOR ..............................................................................................................4
2.2 METROSIL NON-LINEAR RESISTOR REQUIREMENTS ........................................................4
2.3 SETTINGS .........................................................................................................................................6
3 CALCULATION FOR P632 RELAYING FOR TRAFO. DIFFERENTIAL PROTN..........................6
3.1) CALCULATION OF LDIFF>.............................................................................................................8
3.2) CALCULATION OF LR,M1..............................................................................................................9
3.3) CALCULATION OF I DIFF >> .........................................................................................................9
3.4) CALCULATION OF LDIFF>>>......................................................................................................10
3.5) CALCULATION OF SLOPE M1 ..................................................................................................10
3.6) CALCULATION OF IRM2..............................................................................................................12
3.7) CALCULATION OF SLOPE M2 ..................................................................................................12
3.8) OP. MODE RUSH RST........................................................................................................................14
3.9) RUSHI (2FO) I (FO) ...........................................................................................................................14
3.10) SETTINGS ...................................................................................................................................14
3.11) DIFFERENTIAL OPERATING CHARACTERISTIC DIAGRAM ..............................................................15
3.12) DIFFERENTIAL HARMONIC RESTRAINT PLANE ..............................................................................15
4 CALCULATION FOR P632 TIME OVERCURRENT PROTECTION (TOC) ................................16
CT DETAILS
Transformer HV Side Phase CT
Ratio: 350/1 A
Class: 10 P 15
Burden: 15VA
Line CT secondary resistance, Rct (at 75° C): 3.02
Lead Resistance between Line CT and REF relay RL: 0.7
(= 7 /km x 100m /1000m)
Cable Resistance: 7 /kmCable Length: 100m
To ensure stability limits, the Maximum through fault level should be considered as 16 times the rated
current of the protected transformer winding.
= 16 x 75 x 106 x 1
3
3 x 132 x 10 350
= 15 A
As per the specification 1.3,2, the primary fault setting for the 132kv faults shall be between 10 to 20% of
the rated current of the protected winding.
Therefore we recommend the relay setting Is to be set at 10% of the rated current of the protected
winding,(Neglecting metrosil current at setting voltage) Therefore relay current setting,
Since 10P class CTs are being adopted for REF the above setting is needs to be checked at site for the
CT mismatch during various loading conditions.
Where:
Vp = Peak voltage developed by the CT under internal fault conditions
Vk = Current transformer knee point voltage
Vf = Maximum voltage that would be produced if CT saturation did not occur
'f = Maximum internal secondary fault current
Rct = Current transformer secondary winding resistance
RL = Maximum lead burden from current transformer to relay
RST = Relay stabilizing resistor
Calculation:
Vf = If (RCT + 2RL + RST + Rr)
= 15 x (5.28 + 1.8 + 1141 +0.1 )
= 17222.7 V
The value given by the formulae is near to 3kV peak, Metrosils should be applied. Metrosils are
connected across the relay circuit and serve the purpose of shunting the secondary current
output of the current transformer from the relay in order to prevent very high secondary
voltages. Metrosils are externally mounted and take the form of annular discs.
The Metrosil unit recommended for use with this 1Amp CT's is of Type :600A/S1/S256
C = 450, B = 0.25
The table below shows the metrosil units for 1 Amp CT’s.
Page 6 of 21
2.3 SETTINGS
Stabilizing
Resistance, Rstab 1141
DATA:
Settings:
Hence, it shall be ensured that the following settings are adopted by the relay after
programming the rating, CT ratio in the relay.
HV Side CTs are connected to the CT input "a" and LV Side CTs are connected to the CT input "b".
Here the Vector group of the Transformer is YNd1. YNd1 Transformer introduces a phase shift of 30° in
the secondary side. Hence a phase shift of 30° is required in the primary side to have proper vector
group correction.
Setting of vector group matching function does not require any calculation. Only the characteristic
vector group number needs to be set
Hence the selected Vector group ends a-b = 1 (Which corresponding to 30°
phase shift)
3.1) CALCULATION OF ldiff>
Differential initial setting should be set above the steady - state magnetizing current of the
transformer. Unbalanced current checking in regarding with the tap changer position on highest and
lowest tap positions.
Differential Current At Highest tap And Lowest tap With Selected CT Multiplier:
= 0.08 Iref
= 0.148 Iref
Available setting = 0.1 to 2.5 Iref (insteps of 0.01)
This setting is the intersection of the first section of the tripping curve with the load line occurs
at a restraining current, which is a function of the setting of the basic threshold value Idiff
l RM1 = 0.5 x Idiff
I RM1 = 0.075 Iref
This setting is to be set just above the inrush current rms value so that blocking of the triple
slope characteristic by second harmonic restraint or by saturation detector is removed.
Hence for fast fault clearance, ld>>> could be set below the current for a fault at the
transformer terminals; such a fault involves the bus fault level as it is not limited by the
winding impedances. However, to prevent operations during transformer charging, ld>>>
should always be set equal to or higher than ld>>.
This is set greater than the Transformer inrush current and below the fault at the transformer
terminals. (Assuming bus fault level higher than 15 Iref)
This is the second section of the tripping characteristic covers the load current range, so that in
this section we must reckon not only with the transformer magnetizing current, which appears
as differential current, but also with differential currents that can be attributed to the
transformation errors of the current transformer sets.
The second section of the tripping characteristic forms a straight line, the slope of which
should correspond to the cumulative total error of the participating current transformer
sets. The curve slope m1 can be set.
The differential and restraining current variables for each measurement system are calculated
from the current variables after amplitude and vector group matching. The following equation is
used to calculate the differential and restraining current.
ld>0.15 m1=0.3
The differential current on relay during full load current on highest and lowest tap
position of Transformer is well out side the operating region with selected ld>0.15, m1
=0.3
This is the second knee point of the tripping characteristic determines the end of the
Overcurrent zone in the direction of increasing restraining current in fault free operation.
It can be as high as four times the nominal current in certain operating cases - such as when a
parallel transformer has failed. It is recommended to set half the maximum through fault
current.
The third slope region is set to have a large slope to cater for heavy through fault current.
During the maximum through fault condition, if one side CT saturates, the differential current
seen by the relay is 3.34 A
Slope of the third section m2 and the transition point between the second & third sections IR,
m2. Both these are set such that the third section has a large slope beginning well above rated
the current to cater for heavy through fault conditions.
= 6.69 x 1.066
= 7.13 Iref
Maximum through fault current:
Differential current on with safety factor 1.5 = 1.31 x 1.5 = 1.96 Iref
Restraining currents
Restraining current =
7.7+ 7.13 = 7.415 Iref
2
The recommended selected m2 setting recommended = 0.7 Iref
The differentia! and restraining current variables for each measurement system are
calculated from the current variables after amplitude and vector group matching, The
following equation is used to calculate the boundary of the operating region. Since the
restraining current is greater than 1.5
Magnetizing - inrush current is characterized by large harmonic components that are not
noticeably present in short circuit current.
The ratio of the second harmonic components to the fundamental wave for the
differential currents serves as the blocking criterion of differential protection.
However, all required figures will be recorded during Transformer energisation process
and if necessary pick-up setting is to be fine-tuned after a harmonic analysis of the
inrush current captured during Transformer charging.
3.10) SETTINGS
Menu Text Setting
1) ldiff> 0.15 Iref
2) ldiff>> 10 Iref
3) ldiff>>> 15 Iref
4) m1 0.3
5) m2 0.7
6) IR, m2 3.3
Through faults are not detected by differential protection of Transformer.If the through fault
persists of longer duration, the transformer gets damaged by Thermal stresses.
• Fault currents
Fault currents on pri. Side and sec. Side of power transformer are different for Ph-Ph fault.
Lower value should be selected for setting of O/C.
This can result in damage to the transformer. The copper losses increase in
proportion to the square of the per unit fault current. If the current is limited only by
the reactance of the transformer, the duration of external short-circuits that a transformer can
withstand without damage is relatively short. Phase overcurrent protection is an important
protection that can be used to clear the transformer before the transformer is damaged.
A short-circuits between the phases will cause a substantial fault current. The magnitude of the
fault current depends mainly on the source impedance and the leakage impedance of the
transformer.
Hence, the flux density is proportional to the ratio between the voltage and the frequency.
Overvoltage, or underfrequency, or a combination of both, will result in an excessive flux
density level.
In two-winding transformers, the low voltage winding is normally placed close to the
core and the voltage across this winding gives a good representation of the flux density
in the core. However, depending on the design, the flux flowing in the yoke may be
critical for the overfluxing capability of the transformer.
For power transformers with fixed direction of the load flow, the voltage to the V/Hz
protection function should therefore be taken from the feeder side.
Heat accumulated in critical parts during a period of overexcitation will be reduced
gradually when the excitation retains the normal value. If a new period of overexcitation
occurs after a short time interval, the heating will start from a higher level. The
overexcitation protection function should therefore have a thermal memory. In
P632, the cooling time constant is settable within a wide range.
The general experience is that the overexcitation characteristics for a number of power
transformers are not in accordance with standard inverse time curves. In order to make
optimal settings possible, a transformer adapted characteristic is available in P632.
The function should in the first place be configured to a three-phase voltage input if
available. It then uses the positive sequence quantities of voltages and currents.
It should be noted that analogue measurements should not be taken from any winding
where OLTC is located
Fault conditions
The greatest risk for overexcitation exists in a thermal power station when the generator-
transformer block is disconnected from the rest of the network.
Overexcitation can occur during start-up and shut-down of the generator if the field current is
not properly adjusted. Loss-of load or load-shedding can also result in overexcitation if the
voltage control is not functioning properly.
Loss of load or load-shedding at a transformer substation can result in overexcitation if
the voltage control is insufficient or out of order. Low frequency in a system isolated from the
main network can result in overexcitation if the voltage regulating system maintains normal
voltage.
Page 18 of 21
Information on the cooling time constant Tcool should be collected from the power
transformer manufacturer.
Example on overexcitation capability curve and V/Hz protection settings for power transformer
Overfluxing protection evaluates the ratio V/f of voltage to frequency referred to nominal
values. The overfluxing measurement is not enabled unless the voltage and frequency are within the
limits for admissible values.
Page 19 of 21
If the overfluxing value is found to exceed the threshold, a timer stage is triggered. Once this
stage has elapsed, a signal is issued.
The setting must have a continuous falling profile, with no rising points.
After a start, the elapsed starting time is accumulated in a buffer. If the starting drops out, the
buffer memory will be discharged. The discharge gradient is determined by the set cooling
time. If there is another starting, the buffer memory will be recharged. If the
accumulated starting time reaches the tripping time determined by the P63x then the trip signal
is issued.
When using phase-ground voltage, the nominal value in the P63x could not be set accurately,
as the Vnom setting does only provide a step size of 1V.
With respect to neutral displacement of isolated starpoints, possible voltage dips in Petersen
coil compensated systems, or similar "bad" measuring conditions, the use of a phase-phase
voltage is generally recommended.
Page 21 of 21
When overfluxing occurs, the core becomes partially saturated and the resultant magnetizing
current waveforms increase in magnitude and become harmonically distorted. Such waveforms
have a significant 5th harmonic content, which can be extracted and used as a means of
identifying the abnormal operating condition.
The 5th harmonic blocking threshold is adjustable between 10 - 80% differential current.
This element can be used to initiate tripping in event of prolonged pick up of a 5th harmonic
measuring element. It is not expected that this type of overfluxing condition would be detected
by the AC overfluxing protection.
This form of time delayed tripping should only be applied in regions where geomagnetic
disturbances are a known problem and only after proper evaluation through simulation testing.