2 Classification
2 Classification
2 Classification
DISEASES
PRESENTED BY,
PERIODONTICS
1
CONTENT
1. INTRODUCTION
2. DEFINITION
3. USES OF CLASSIFICATION
4. NEED FOR CLASSIFICATION
5. HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF CLASSIFICATIONS SYSTEM
6. CLINICAL CHARACTERISTICS PARADIGM [1870 -1920] 7.
CLASSICAL PATHOLOGY PARADIGM [1920 – 1970]
8. INFECTION /HOST RESPONSE PARADIGM
9. CURRENT CLASSIFICATION SYSTEMS OF PERIODONTAL DISEASES
10. CHANGES IN THE CLASSIFICATION FOR PERIODONTAL DISEASES
11. FUTURE CHALLENGES IN THE CLASSIFICATION OF PERIODONTAL
DISEASES
12. CONCLUSION
13. REFERENCES
2
INTRODUCTION
Understanding of the etiology and pathogenesis of oral disease and conditions is continually
changing with increased scientific knowledge.The initial classification systems were based on
the clinical features of the diseases (1870-1920).Then came the concept of classical pathology
(1920-1970).Presently – concepts of infectious etiology of periodontal diseases and host
response (1970).Most important landmark – current understanding of periodontal diseases
was the work done by Loe et al (1986) on natural history of periodontal diseases, and
observed that progression of periodontal diseases naturally without interfering.
Diagnosis is defined as the act of identifying a disease from its signs and symptoms, whereas
classification is defined as the act or method of distribution into groups. Here we are dealing
with the periodontal condition which is clinically characterized by three symptoms: loss of
connective tissue attachment, loss of alveolar bone support, and inflamed pathological
pockets.
On the basis of these three symptoms one diagnostic name for this condition would be
appropriate, e.g. destructive periodontal disease. However, if age, distribution of lesions,
degree of gingival inflammation, putative rate of breakdown, response to therapy, etc., are
also taken into account, numerous diagnostic names are needed. In order to be able to
communicate about patients, clinicians have always felt the need for diagnostic names and
classifications for these diseases, preferably on the basis of putative etiologic factors. At
present, controversies about definitions of diseases continues, not only in the periodontal field
but also in medicine.
Our understanding of the etiology and pathogenesis of oral diseases and conditions is
continually changing with increased scientific knowledge. In light of this, a classification can
be most consistently defined by the differences in the clinical manifestations of diseases and
conditions because they are clinically consistent and require little, it any, clarification
by scientific laboratory testing.
DEFINITION
3
NEED FOR CLASSIFICATION
periodontal diseases can be placed into three dominant paradigms .They are 1. Clinical
characteristics paradigm
4
CLINICAL CHARACTERISTICS PARADIGM [1870 -1920]
Very little was known about the etiology and pathogenesis of periodontal diseases back then.
Accordingly, the diseases were classified almost entirely on the basis of their clinical
characteristics supplemented by unsubstantiated theories about their cause. At the time, one of
the main debates about the nature of periodontal diseases was whether they were caused by
local or systemic factors. Most authors considered these diseases to be primarily caused by
local factors whereas some believed that systemic disturbances played a dominant etiological
role. Many of the advocates for the etiological role of local factors also acknowledged that in
some cases both local and systemic factors were important.
In the late 1800s and early 1900s clinicians used case descriptions and their personal
interpretation of what they saw clinically as the primary basis for classifying periodontal
diseases. Their opinions survive in the literature in the form of written abstracts or summaries
of the proceedings of these meetings. Indeed, John M. Riggs(1811–1875), an American dentist
who lectured so widely on the treatment of periodontal diseases that periodontitis was called
‘Riggs’ disease’ by many of his colleagues, rarely published any papers on the subject. Riggs’
thoughts and opinions were most often summarized by others
Formal papers on the classification of periodontal diseases were rare in the late 1800s and
early 1900s. Typical publications on the subject usually represented the opinion of a single
person who almost always based the classification on clinical observations and theoretical
explanations of causation.
This was due to ‘... feeble vascular action ...’ and trauma from tooth brushing or other
sources
‘The gum retires slowly ... and the alveolar border, deprived of nutrition at the point of
pressure, is consentaneously absorbed.’ Davis apparently believed that calculus
exerted mechanical pressure on the gingiva causing the alveolar bone to resorb
because of lack of nutrition
5
3. Riggs disease the hallmark of which was loss of alveolus without loss of gum
1. Constitutional gingivitis
It including mercurial gingivitis, potassium iodide gingivitis and scurvy
Now termed necrotising ulcerative gingivitis [NUG] but he never used the term 3.
Simple gingivitis
This was associated with the accumulation of debris that eventually led to calcic
inflammation of the peridental membrane.
This was associated with salivary or serumal calculus. There was generalised pattern
of destruction of alveolar bone. The destruction usually occurred slowly. Now this is
known as chronic periodontitis
This condition shared many features with ‘calcic inflammation of the peridental
membrane’ but there was an irregular pattern of destruction and not much dental
calculus. Destruction of the alveolar bone can occur slowly or rapidly. In a later
publication, Black replaced the term ‘phagedenic pericementitis’ with ‘chronic
suppurative pericementitis’.
6
Demerits
• Little or no scientific evidence was used to support the opinions of the clinicians of
the time.
As the field of periodontology began to mature scientifically in the first half of the 20th
century, many clinical scholars in both Europe and North America began to develop, and
argue about, nomenclature and classification systems for periodontal diseases. What emerged
from this was that there were at least two forms of destructive periodontal disease
inflammatory and non inflammatory [degenerative or dystrophic]. It was primarily based on
the over interpretation of histopathological studies from a group of Viennese investigators led
by gottlieb and orbans.
Gottlieb postulated that certain forms of destructive Periodontal disease were due to
degenerative changes in the periodontium. He believed that he had discovered histological
evidence of an impairment in the continuous deposition of cementum [ie cementopathia].This
cemental defect was presumably initiated by the degeneration of the principal fibres of the
periodontal ligament that eventually resulted in detachment of connective tissue from the
tooth followed by resorption of adjacent bone Gottlieb’s ideas were probably widely accepted
because they appeared to explain the long standing and perplexing clinical observation that
some young patients with relatively clean mouths had massive and localized bone loss with
only minimal or no overt signs of gingival inflammation.
7
Degenerative or atrophic –
1. diffuse alveolar atrophy
2. paradental pyorrhoea
3. occlusal trauma
DEMERITS
• No microbial analysis.
1. Gingivitis [little or no pocket formation ;it can include ulcerative form – vincents ]
B. Systemic
- Pregnancy
- Diabetes
- Other endocrine dysfunctions
-Tuberculosis
-Syphilis
-Nutritional disturbances
- Drug action
-Allergy
-Hereditary
- Idiopathic etc
2. Periodontitis
8
B. Complex [secondary to periodontosis ] –etiologic factors similar to
periodontitis ;cases have little ,if any calculus .
Degeneration
I. Periodontosis [as a rule attacks young girls and older men ;often caries immunity]
A. Systemic disturbances
- Diabetes
- Endocrine dysfunctions
- Blood dyscrasias
- Nutritional disturbances
- Nervous disorders
B. Hereditary
C. Idiopathic
Atrophy
9
Hypertrophy
I. Gingival hypertrophy
- Chronic irritation
Traumatism
I. Periodontal traumatism
A. Occlusal trauma
[Periodontology 2000 vol 30 ;2002 .9- 23] DEMERITS
• Conclusion that some forms of periodontal diseases were caused by non inflammatory or
degenerative process was primarily based on over interpretation of histopathological
studies.
• No scientific basis for retaining the concept that there were non – inflammatory or
degenerative forms of destructive periodontal diseases.
WHO expert committee on the dental health in 1961 suggested that etiology plays secondary
and accessory part in classification . Clinical assessment lacks sufficient precision to serve as
a foundation for classification. The most valid basis for classification is therefore one based
on general pathology.
10
MERITS
acute
periodontal abscess
chronic
DEMERITS
GINGIVITIS
A. Acute Gingivitis
a. Acute specific - ulceromembrane gingivitis , herpectic gingivitis,coccal gingivitis
11
B. Chronic Gingivitis
a. Chronic non specific – chronic edematous gingivitis
b. Chronic hyperplastic gingivitis
c. Chronic atrophic gingivitis
PERIODONTITIS
Periodontal abscess
• Simplified – considered both specific and non specific inflammatory changes • Also
considered host responses .in small percentage of cases ,lab procedures may defines
an alteration in host responses ,which may be a factor or the presence of infection
predominantly by over particular group of organism.
DEMERITS
Not stated about periodontal traumatism
predisposing circumstances
2. local irritation
12
3 . Bacteria
PRICHARD 1972
- NUG
- Herpetic gingivostomatitis
- Desquamative gingivitis
- Oral ulcers
-gingival enlargement
-periodontal abscess
- periodontal traumatism
-primary traumatism
-secondary traumatism
MERITS
DEMERITS
13
PAGE AND SCHROEDER [ 1982]
• Prepubertal periodontitis
1. Generalised
2. Localized
• Juvenile periodontitis
I Juvenile periodontits
A Prepubertal periodontitis
II Adult periodontis
IV Refractory periodontitis.
14
TOPIC’S CLASSIFICATION – 1986
ACUTE CONDITIONS
1. Gingivitis
b) Non-specific
2. Periodontitis
a) Periodontal abscess
b) Pericoronitis
CHRONIC CONDITIONS
1. Gingivitis
a) Plaque- associated
b) Symptomatic
2. Periodontitis
a) Simplex (adults)
15
b) Complex
- Generalized forms
Prepubertal
- Localized forms
c) Symptomatic
3. Recession
MERITS
DEMERITS
Marginal gingivitis
16
Gingival enlargement
B. Inflammation with Surface Destruction
- NUG
- Herpetic gingivostomatitis
- Desquamative gingivitis
- Oral ulcers
Prepubertal – localised /
generalized
Juvenile periodontitis
Post-pubertal periodontitis
B. PERIODONTAL TRAUMATISM
Primary traumatism
Secondary traumatism
C. PERIODONTAL ABSCESS
MERITS
Useful in teaching
17
DEMERITS
• Age-dependent criteria.
• Rate of bone destruction
JOHNSON ET AL.1988
-Gingivitis
-Periodontitis
- Adult type
- Postjuvenile
- Early onset
- Juvenile
18
- Localized
- Generalised
a) Acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis
b) Acute abscess
c) Pericoronitis
Traumatic occlusion
Disuse atrophy
• Trauma
Habits ,accidents
MERITS
• May be useful in differential diagnosis.
• Gingival hyperplasia could be fitted into various categories.
DEMERITS
• Age-dependent criteria in diagnosing diseases.
• Rate of progression is considered.
SUZUKI [1988]
➢ GINGIVITIS
• ANUG
➢ PERIODONTITIS
• Adult periodontitis
19
• Rapidly progressing periodontitis
o Type A
o Type B
• Juvenile periodontitis
• Postjuvenile periodontitis
• Prepubertal periodontitis
MERITS
• Age of the patient
• Rate of bone destruction is considered.
• Rapidly progressing periodontitis is again subclassified . i.e RPP type A and
RPP type B
DEMERITS
• Non-validated age-dependent criteria.
• Not considered periodontal abscess
• Not considered periodontal – endodontal lesions.
• Occlusal trauma not included.
Gingivitis
• Childhood gingivitis
Periodontitis
• Adult Periodontitis:
Possible sub-groups:
– High risk
– Normal risk
20
– Refractory periodontitis
– Pre-pubertal periodontitis
* Localized
* Generalized
I. Adult periodontitis.
•Prepubertal
– Generalized or localized
• Juvenile
– Generalized or localized
• Down’s Syndrome
• Diabetes – Type I
This classification was based on the infection/ host response paradigm depended heavily on
periodontitis),
iii. There was extensive crossover in rates of progression of the different categories of
periodontitis. Rapidly progressive periodontitis was a heterogeneous category.
iv. There was extensive overlap in the clinical characteristics of the different categories of
periodontitis.
vii. Finally, different forms of periodontitis proposed in the classification shared many
microbiologic and host response features, which suggested extensive overlap and
heterogeneity among the categories.
Genco (1990)
• Periodontitis in adults.
• Periodontitis in juveniles
– Localized form
22
– Generalized form
• Miscellaneous conditions
Ranney (1993)
Gingivitis
• Non-aggravated
• Related to HIV
• Gingivitis, non-plaque
Periodontitis
• Adult periodontitis
– Non-aggravated
– Neutrophil abnormality
– Related to HIV
– Related to nutrition
• Periodontal abscess
• This system includes not only forms of gingivitis & Periodontitis other than those
caused by plaque but also modifying factors, for ex. Systemic aggravating factors,
general diseases status, viral infections & so on.
• Adult periodontitis
24
th
Begins before the 4 decade of life, rapid rate of progression of disease, altered host response
is seen.
• Necrotizing periodontitis
All the above-mentioned classification systems have been widely used by clinicians and
research scientists throughout the world, unfortunately they have been many shortcomings
including:
Hence, the need for a revised classification system for periodontal diseases was emphasized
and in 1999, the international workshop had considered designing a new classification system.
25
INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP FOR THE CLASSIFICATION OF
THE PERIODONTAL DISEASES BY THE AMERICAN ACADEMY
OF PERIODONTOLOGY (AAP) 1999
Gingival Diseases
Chronic Periodontitis
Localized
Generalized
Aggressive Periodontitis
Localized
Generalized
Gingival abscess
Periodontal abscess
Pericoronal abscess
26
Endodontic-periodontal lesion
Periodontal–endodontic lesion
Combined lesion
✓ Occlusal trauma.
1. Puberty-associated gingivitis
3. Pregnancy associated
a. Gingivitis
b. Pyogenic granuloma
27
4. Diabetes mellitus associated gingivitis B.
1. Leukemia-associated gingivitis
2. Other
2. Drug-influenced gingivitis
a.Oralcontraceptive–associatedgingivitis
b. Other
B. Other
A. Neisseria gonorrhoeae
B. Treponema pallidum
C. Streptococcus species
D. Other
3. Varicella zoster
B. Other
gingival erythema
C. Histoplasmosis
D. Other
B. Other
A. Mucocutaneous lesions
1. Lichen planus
2. Pemphigoid
3. Pemphigus vulgaris
4. Erythema multiforme
5. Lupus erythematosus
6. Drug induced
7. Other
B. Allergic reactions
a. Mercury
29
b. Nickel
c. Acrylic
d. Other
a. Toothpastes or dentifrices
3. Other
A. Chemical injury
B. Physical injury
C. Thermal injury
1 .GINGIVITIS 2. (a) hormonal effects of pregnancy. (b) and (c) By medications. (b)
antihypertensive drug, nifedipine, (c) By cyclosporine,
30
I. Gingival diseases
31
2. Gingival diseases modified with systemic factors
a. associated with endocrine system
a) Gingivitis in pregnancy
b) Pyogenic granuloma
2) Other diseases
b) Other medications
b. Others
32
B. Gingival lesions not induced by plaque
1. Gingival diseases of specific bacterial etiology a.
d. Others
b. Others
33
a. Changed mucous membrane
1) Lichen planus
2) Pemphigoid
3) Pemphigus vulgaris
4) Erythema multiformis
5) Lupus erythematosus
6) caused by medications
7) Others
b. Allergic reactions
1) Material in restorative dentistry
a) Mercury
b) Nickel
c) Acrylic
d) Others
2) Reaction to:
a) Toothpaste
b) Mouthwashes
c) Additives in chewing gum
d) Nutritive substitutes
3) Others
a. Chemical
b. Physical
c. Thermal
A. Localised
B. Generalised
34
III. Aggressive periodontitis (AP)
A. Localised
B. Generalised
1. Acquired neutropenia
2. Leukaemia
3. Others
2. Down’s syndrome
4. Papillon-Lefevre syndrome
5. Chediak-Higashi syndrome
9. Cohen’s syndrome
11. Hypophosphatasia
12. Others
35
V. Necrotizing periodontal diseases
A. Gingival abscess
B. Periodontal abscess
C. Pericoronal abscess
3. Fractured root
1. Recession
b. Approximally
5. Gingival enlargement
36
a. Pseudo-pockets
PERIODONTITIS
Periodontitis is defined as “an inflammatory disease of the support- ing tissues of the teeth
caused by specific microorganisms or groups of specific microorganisms, resulting in
progressive destruction of the periodontal ligament and alveolar bone with increased probing
depth formation, recession, or both.”
37
Classification of the Various Forms of Periodontitis
• Adult periodontitis
• Refractory periodontitis
• Adult periodontitis
38
• Early-onset periodontitis
• Necrotizing periodontitis
- Tissue necrosis with attachment and bone loss
DEMERITS
• Chronic periodontitis
• Aggressive periodontitis
Chronic Periodontitis
Chronic periodontitis in the 1999 classification has replaced the term adult periodontitis.
39
• It is associated with the following:
stress.
CLASSIFICATIONS
TREATMENT
1. Plaque control
2. scaling and root planing
3. correction of local plaque retentive factors
4. antimicrobial chemotherapy
5. periodontal surgery
6. supportive periodontal therapy
40
CHRONIC PERIODONTITIS
Aggressive Periodontitis
Aggressive periodontitis replaces the category ‘early onset periodontitis’ which in the 1989
AAP and 1993 European classification embraced a number of diseases affecting young
patients.
41
Aggressive periodontitis may be further classified into localized and generalized forms
3. debridement
1. Hematologic disorders
a. Acquired neutropenia
b. Leukemias
c. Other
42
2. Genetic disorders
d. Papillon-Lefèvre syndrome
e. Chédiak-Higashi syndrome
f. Histiocytosis syndromes
i. Cohen syndrome
Hypophosphatasia
l. Other
Causes
Associated with disorders of blood or blood forming organs such as neutropenia, leukemia ,
or genetic disorders
Generalized and localized forms of severe destruction of bone and connective tissue tooth
support
Treatment
43
C
GINGIVAL ABSCESSES
Etiology:
(i) Irritation from foreign substances,
toothbrush bristle
44
(ii) Apple core
(iii) Lobster shell forcefully embedded into the gingiva.
PERIODONTAL ABSCESSES
Depending on the cause of acute infectious process, two types of periodontal abscess occur:
A. Periodontitis-related abscesses:
B. Non-periodontitis-related abscesses:
Periodontal diseases
Clinical findings
45
4. Swelling is generalized and located around the involved tooth and gingival margin. Seldom
with a fistulous tract
5. Pain is usually dull, constant and less severe than in a periapical abscess. Pain is localized
and patient usually can locate the offending tooth
Radiographic findings
Response to treatment
2.Subgingival debridement.
46
PERICORONAL ABSCESSES
History 1. Caries, fracture, toothwear
2. Restorative and endodontic treatment
Clinical findings
Radiographic findings
1. Apical radiolucency
2. Endodontic or post perforations
Response to treatment
1. Responds poorly, or not at all to periodontal treatment
• NUG has been previously classified under “gingival diseases” or “gingivitis” because
clinical attachment loss is not a consistent feature
• NUP has been classified as a form of “periodontitis” because attachment loss is present •
Recent reviews of the etiologic and clinical characteristics of NUG and NUP have suggested
that the two diseases represent clinical manifestations of the same disease, except that distinct
features of NUP are clinical attachment and bone loss.
47
• As a result, both NUG and NUP have been determined as a separate group of •
➢ Symptoms are
-halitosis
➢ Etiology
➢ Risk factors
➢ Histopathology
48
fibrin ,perished epithelial cells ,leukocytes ,erythrocytes and bacteria -connective
tissue beneath contains widened and proliferating vessels and a dense infiltrate of
neutrophilic granulocytes, plasma cells ,and macrophages , invasive fusobacteria
and spirochetes
• Rapid attachement loss ,often without formation of deep pocket Sockets ,but with the
possibility of bony sequestration
• In the case of advanced periodontal disease, the infection may reach the pulp
through the apical foramen.
• Scaling and root planing removes cementum and underlying dentin and may lead to
chronic pulpitis through bacterial penetration of dentinal tubules.
49
• periodontitis-affected teeth have been scaled and root planed with no evidence of
pulpal involvement.
Endodontic–Periodontal Lesions
periapical lesion originating in pulpal infection and necrosis may drain to the oral
cavity through the periodontal ligament, resulting in destruction of the periodontal
ligament and adjacent alveolar bone.
• This may present clinically as a localized, deep, periodontal probing depth extending
to the apex of the tooth .
• Pulpal infection also may drain through accessory canals, especially in the area of
the furcation, and may lead to furcal involvement through loss of clinical
attachment and alveolar bone.
- Retrograde pulpitis ,if and when the plaque front within a periodontal pocket
reaches the apex or accessory pulp channels
- Spread of an endodontic [periapical] infection into the periodontal ligament .
50
1. Tooth anatomic factors
3. Root fractures
cemental tears
✓ Occlusal trauma
1. Primary occlusal trauma
51
OCCLUSAL TRAUMA
Excessive occlusal forces do not lead to plaque associated periodontal diseases and attachment
loss,but they may accelerate the progression of already existing periodontitis.
-Primary occlusal trauma - periodontal injury due to excessive occlusal forces in a normal
tooth supporting apparatus [normal bone and attachment level]
• The 1989 classification did not include a section on gingival diseases and lesions
• The section on dental non-plaque induced diseases includes a wide range of disorders
that affect the gingiva
• Epidemiological data and clinical experience suggest that the form of periodontitis
found in adults can also be seen in adolescents
• It is did not imply that this diseases was non-responsive to this treatment.
• Also it was concludes that rate of progression should not be used to exclude people from
receiving the diagnosis of chronic periodontitis.
52
• there is considerable uncertainty about arbitrarily setting an upper age limit for patients
with so called early onset periodontitis therefore it was decided to discard
classification terminologies that were age dependent or required knowledge of rate of
progression.
• RPP designation has been discarded and the patients are assigned to either generalized
aggressive periodontitis or chronic periodontitis categories
• most of the patients who have been given the diagnosis of generalized prepubertal
periodontitis actually had one of the varieties of systemic conditions that interfere with
resistance to bacterial infections
▪ Refractory periodontitis was not a single disease entity, therefore it was concluded that
it could be applied to all forms of periodontitis
• category has been retained since it is clear that destructive periodontal disease can be
manifestation of certain systemic diseases
• Diabetes mellitus and cigarette smoking are not included as they are significant
modifiers of all forms of periodontitis
Replacement of “Necrotizing ulcerative periodontitis” with “Necrotizing
periodontal diseases”
• Both NUG and NUP might be manifestation of certain systemic diseases such as HIV,
and then it was more appropriate to place them under manifestation of systemic
diseases
53
• The reason that this was not done was there are many factors other than systemic
diseases that appear to predispose to development of NUG and NUP such as
emotional stress and cigarette smoking
• Since periodontal abscess present special diagnostic and treatment challenges, they
deserve to be classified apart from other periodontal diseases
• These are not separate diseases; they are important modifiers of the susceptibility to
periodontal diseases or can dramatically influence outcomes of treatment.
classification was based on four dimensions, i.e. extent, severity, age, and clinical
characteristics.
If teeth are missing, the class description should still reflect the clinical image of the patient.
Therefore it was decided for cases with£14 teeth to omit the class semi-generalized and to
change the number of teeth for the generalized class to 8–14
Permanent ⁄ mixed n<14 Primary dentition
dentition No. of
teeth present n>14
54
Classification based on severity of disease per tooth. The fact that either attachment lossor
bone loss can be used for the classification of severity implies that although it may be
important to know the actual root length in a given patient radiographs are not a prerequisite
for the classification of severity.
Classification based on the severity of disease per tooth. The mean estimated root length
based on the literature is approximately 12 mm; in the case of incidental disease, the severity
category at that particular tooth is mentioned
55
• Next, the extent category is determined by counting the number of teeth with the most
severe condition;
• Diagnosis on the basis of clinical characteristics is added if
applicable; • Diagnosis on the basis of age.
✓ As we enter the postgenomic era with our increased understanding of the bacteria
associated with periodontal infections and the genetic factors controlling host responses to
56
these infections ,it would seem that a more mechanistic or etiological classification could
be devised.
✓ One of the main problems associated with any attempt at subclassifying this or other forms
of periodontitis ,is that these infections are polymicrobial and polygenic.
✓ The clinical expression of these diseases is altered by important environmental and host
modifying conditions
✓ It may eventually be possible to subclassify the multiple forms of chronic periodontitis into
discrete microorganism /host genetic polymorphism groups such as;
57
CONCLUSION
58
REFERENCES
➢ Purpose and problems of periodontal disease classification. Perio 2000. 2005; 39: 132
59