Munication
Munication
Munication
Communication
Strategic
Communication
Public relations at work
and by Routledge
52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, NY 10017
The right of Jane Johnston and Leanne Glenny to be identified as authors of this work
has been asserted by them in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the Copyright,
Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised
in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter
invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or
retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers.
Overview vii
Index 315
Overview
vii
viii Strategic Communication
Part 3: Theory
Chapter 10: Theory: Where learning starts
It all starts with theory—which is why we think we should end with it! This
chapter explains the value of theory in better understanding strategic commu-
nication and PR. It uses a novel approach to introduce the reader to theory
by presenting a selection of more than 30 theories, many illustrated, explain-
ing how they’re used, where to find them throughout the book and the key
theorists behind the theory. Here’s where you look up answers to the ‘sticky
notes’ that are stuck around the book, marked with the following icon .
Theories in this chapter are explained briefly and without fuss, so they’re
easily understood, intended to be used as a ‘theory-pedia’ (like Wikipedia)
where you ‘drop in’ whenever you need to understand a particular theory.
We think you’ll find this expanded glossary-style chapter useful as an ongoing
reference in future study.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Dr Raveena Singh for her
work in previous iterations of Chapter 6: Research, measurement and evalu-
ation, Sarah Mason, from HSPR, for her contribution to Chapter 9: Tactic
selection and content creation, and Clara Zawawi’s contribution to an earlier
version of Chapter 1.
Our thanks are also extended to the anonymous reviewers for their insights
and advice which have strengthened the final text.
xii Strategic Communication
introducing strategic
communication and public
relations
3
4 Foundations and the working environment
will examine the changing nature of the discipline, the people who carry out
public relations and strategic communication roles, its widespread adoption
across many industries, and growth in the field within the tertiary sector and as
a profession. First, however, we’ll provide some simple explanations that will
help you navigate this book. We’ll explain some of the commonly used terms
and provide some definitions.
Quick tips are used to provide you with extra readings or online
places to check out.
Next, we explain some of the words and phrases in the book that are
widely used in the profession. The language in this book is kept pretty
simple, but we need to make sure we’re all ‘on the same page’ in clarifying
everyday words—like society, public, communication, audience, stakeholder
and strategy. Simple words? Yes, but, believe it or not, their meanings are
often confused or disputed. Journalist and military strategy expert Richard
Halloran (2007) says if five government people were put in a room and asked
to come up with a definition for ‘strategic communication’, eight different
answers would be given! And these, he argues, would be ‘mostly bureaucratic
gibberish’ (2007, p. 5). For definitions to be useful they need to be clear and
6 Foundations and the working environment
Word Definition
Strategy The determination of the basic long-term goals of an
enterprise, and the adoption of courses of actions and the
allocation of resources necessary to carry out these goals
(Chandler, in Nickols 2015).
Communication A reciprocal process of exchanging signals to inform,
persuade or instruct, based on shared meanings and
conditioned by the communicator’s relationship and the
social context (Cutlip & Center 2009).
Public A group of people linked through a shared interest in an
issue, whose motivation to act varies depending on their
awareness of the issue, the level of concern held and the
constraints that limit action.
Stakeholder Any group or individual that can affect or be affected by the
realisation of an organisation’s purpose (Freeman 1984).
Audience A number (large or small) of people who are united by their
participation in media use (adapted from Hartley 2002).
Society A group of people whose members interact, live in a
definable area and share a range of cultural norms,
practices, values and matters of kinship (Little 2016).
Community A group of people who interact with one another, within
a bounded geographic territory [or in an online virtual
space], whose members often share common values, beliefs,
or behaviours (Neal 2014).
Organisational The effective management of mutually beneficial exchanges
Relationships in which organisations and publics strive for the same
shared goals (Lock 2019).
to the point. In Table 1.1 we present simple definitions for key words in this
field—there are many to choose from. Our selections are sometimes abridged
but all are close to the original or our own work.
But language is a rather plastic thing. Words change meaning over time, in
different cultures and across different disciplines. Reasons for the emergence
Introducing strategic communication and public relations 7
And the Public Relations Institute of New Zealand’s (PRINZ) definition is:
In this book we will introduce a broad range of concepts that cover many
fields, because the reality is you may find yourself working in industries you
didn’t dream of—anything from local government, to craft beer brewing,
to water management, to the pharmaceutical industry, fast foods or food
security—all need professional communication. The versatility of communi-
cation graduates is one of their greatest assets. As we will see throughout this
book, the roles and tasks of the practitioner range from working on business
strategies, to writing and telling stories, to researching and delivering reports,
to developing campaigns that create change or start a trend.
While the organisational perspective of strategic communication and PR
is among the best-known pathways for the undergraduate to take, we also
point to the non-organisational route that helps with both understanding and
applying it. British public relations scholar Lee Edwards (2018, p. 2) points
out that ‘[i]nstitutions and individuals, from churches, emperors and kings
to scientists, politicians, army generals, merchants and slaves, have long used
public relations–style tactics, even if they were not formally labelled as such’.
Others—such as Australian academic Kristin Demetrious (2014)—have noted
how the rise of activism has provided an alternative pathway for public commu-
nication techniques to be practised; a pathway that is now well-integrated
into PR education in the Asia–Pacific region (Johnston & Zawawi 2004). So,
while we focus primarily on the organisational perspective in this book, we
need to be open-minded about the breadth of public relations and strategic
communication in all sectors, including advocacy and activism. We explore this
in much more detail in Chapter 2. Wherever you end up practising—a large
or small corporate, a local or national sporting team, a government depart-
ment, a community progress association or a small start-up—most of the same
principles will apply.
central tenet of relationships (Lock 2019). Zaharna describes how ‘since rela-
tionships and communication are intricately interlinked, relationships are
most distinctively described as defining communication’ (cited in Lock 2019,
p. 3). Relationships are said to exist through ‘shared narratives of reciprocal
expectations’ (Winkler & Wehmeier 2018, p. 147). In other words, all parties
understand the communication because they share in its process and its meaning.
This is nicely put by the PRINZ in a video ‘What is Public Relations?’, which
states: ‘You can’t have a good relationship without good communication, good
behaviour and mutual understanding’ (PRINZ 2019).
One of the biggest challenges to this reciprocal relationship
is the fact that ‘reciprocal expectations’ between parties might
relationship not be very balanced. The theory of relationship management
management is useful in explaining the importance of partnerships that go
deeper than a transactional relationship or a simple communication
process.
Nowhere is this better illustrated than in the way people’s data are collected
by companies. Here, questions arise such as: what if communication is clear on
the surface, but information is used for another purpose? What if it is coopted
by an organisation into its data banks and used for predicting behaviour or
shared with another party? This is where the ‘reciprocal expectations’ might not
measure up. A study by the Annenberg School for Communication reported
in The New York Times found that organisations that are more transparent
about why they collect people’s details and how they use them find it easier to
maintain trust (Singer 2015). Where problems arise is in lack of transparency
and creeping practices that people feel they cannot control.
Data-mining is not new to public relations. Johnston and Zawawi discussed
it in 2000, in its early years (2000 p. 14). Twenty years later we point out
that, as then, the strategic communication and PR role needs to ensure that
relationship and reputational damage is not a casualty of using people’s infor-
mation without transparency. This is far more complex and difficult to manage
today, with the vastly expanded field now driven by artificial intelligence (AI)
and algorithmic practices an accepted part of business and social culture the
world over. We discuss this further as an issue in Chapter 3, an element of
privacy in Chapter 4, a cause for crisis in Chapter 5 and as a significant devel-
opment in research in Chapter 6.
Introducing strategic communication and public relations 11
Figure 1.2 Taking a look at who’s who in the zoo. Who’s doing what in strategic
communication and PR. Photo by Andre Mouton, Unsplash.
12 Foundations and the working environment
for short or extended periods, depending on the need. In-house roles exist in
every sector—from government (e.g. health sector) to political advisors and
press secretaries, to large, medium and small businesses, not-for-profit organ-
isations and non-government organisations. Within organisations, many titles
may be used to cover the myriad roles and tasks in communication and media,
especially where a team is employed. For example, some in-house commu-
nication and media departments now have so-called ‘proactive’ and ‘reactive’
teams to work in different ways. A proactive story, for instance, might be about
a campaign launch; a reactive team might focus on a threat to the industry.
The consultant role means you will work for a variety of clients, typi-
cally off-site for much of the time. This role requires you to keep a close
account of time spent on each client, with billing and account-keeping usually
managed in fifteen-minute blocks. One obvious benefit of this approach is the
variety of work this allows in terms of job locations, the variety of people
worked with and development on different accounts and in fields of exper-
tise across the client-base. Consultancies will usually include a range of skill
sets among their employee-base—some more creative, others highly media-
skilled, or corporate- or consumer-focused. An example of a large global
consultancy is Hill+Knowlton, which has 80 offices worldwide. It describes
its 2000 employees as ‘strategists, content creators and master storytellers’
(Hill+Knowlton 2020). If we look at how this organisation positions itself in
the market, we see that many of the key terms and themes we have explored in
this chapter are applied—it’s all about publics, communication and strategy.
What’s also important is the power it ascribes to the public. Here’s a short
part of its pitch:
We believe that every corporate, every brand, every client has a public and
today’s public is more powerful than ever before. They have the power to topple
CEOs, reshape corporate and brand strategy, influence government policy, kill
products and create unicorns. Today’s public demands truth, transparency and
the highest behavioral standards. (Hill+Knowlton 2020)
Smaller agency The Red Republic, based in Brisbane but with a national
and international presence, positions itself as ‘communication, design and
digital specialists’, listing the following services in its repertoire:
Introducing strategic communication and public relations 13
• Public relations
• Social media management
• Influencer management
• Event management
• Brand activations
• Sponsorships and collaborations
• Graphic design and branding
• Creative and art direction
• Photography and videography
• Content creation
• Crisis and issues management
• Corporate communications. (The Red Republic 2019)
This is quite a list and reflects the diversity and breadth of services that
public relations and communication agencies increasingly offer in the modern
media and communication world. But the broad range of consultancies also
varies enormously and many specialise in specific types of work and clients.
This means if you are seeking an internship or a job in a consultancy it’s import-
ant to know where you would best fit and to ensure your interests and expertise
align with any agency you approach. You can gain a strong understanding of
what consultancies do by viewing their current clients and campaigns online.
You can learn a lot by lurking.
In either a consultant or an in-house capacity, the strategic communica-
tion or PR job is multi-faceted. Just as other fields, like medicine and law,
have generalists and specialists, so too with strategic communication and
PR. Doctors may be general practitioners, neurologists, cardiologists, obste-
tricians or many other named practice roles. Similarly, public relations and
strategic communication provides for the specialist and the generalist working
within all sectors, from corporate, government and politics to community
and not-for-profits. They may call themselves practitioners (or experts if that
applies) in crisis communication, event management, social media manage-
ment, political communication or public affairs/lobbying and so on. We’ve
listed key fields of practice (some overlapping) in Table 1.2.
This multi-skill base will require technical and management or problem-
solver skills. Most people in the industry will need to master the technical
14 Foundations and the working environment
mid-1980s, this had skyrocketed to $170 million nationally (Tymson & Sherman
1987). This growth paralleled the broad acceptance of public relations and the
value of its practice in the region, illustrated in the development of professional
associations and the emergence of public relations at the tertiary education level
(Sheehan 2014).
Professional associations—the Public Relations Institute of Australia (PRIA)
and the Public Relations Institute of New Zealand (PRINZ)—developed
during the 1950s. The (state-based) Australian Institute of Public Rela-
tions was founded in Sydney in late 1950 with 22 members, while the first
Victorian chapter was created soon after, in 1952, with 40 members drawn
from banks, insurers, airlines, the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial
Research Organisation (CSIRO), government departments, oil companies and
car manufacturers. These two chapters joined forces in 1960 to form a loose
federation (Sheehan 2014) and other state chapters soon joined. At around the
same time as developments were occurring in Australia, PRINZ was formed
in New Zealand in November 1953, with membership drawn primarily from
state and municipal bureaucracies.
It therefore comes as no surprise that public relations as an academic
field also emerged around this time. Ernest Sommerlad’s book Mightier than
the Sword: A Handbook on Journalism, Broadcasting, Propaganda, Public Rela-
tions and Advertising (1950) was among the earliest Australian literature in
the field, featuring a foreword by the Vice-Chancellor of Sydney University,
Stephen Roberts, who wrote: ‘This book opens an entirely new field because
no adequate handbook for the use of students, or those desiring to enter
the writing professions, has ever appeared in Australia’ (in Sommerlad 1950,
p. vii). While the book was a poor show of how public relations was under-
stood—with expressions such as ‘crooked publicity’, ‘bags of tricks’ and even
‘palpable malpractice’ used to describe its impact on journalism (Johnston
& Macnamara 2013, p. 3)—it nevertheless showed it was on the academic
radar. Other books dedicated to public relations followed. They included
The Australian Public Relations Handbook, edited by Thomas Dwyer (1961),
written as an industry handbook, followed more than a decade later by the
first Australian dedicated PR textbook, Public Relations Practice in Australia,
edited by PR scholar J.D.S. (David) Potts in 1976 (Johnston & Macnamara
2013). Potts was to later become the first professor of public relations in
18 Foundations and the working environment
1. Technician
2. Emerging Practitioner
3. Manager
4. Director
5. Executive Leader.
Each stage in the framework includes details about competency levels, a list
of potential job titles, knowledge and performance outcomes, a list of required
skills, salary band, and rewards and recognition benchmarks for both agency
and in-house roles (PRIA 2016, p. 5).
In 2018, the Global Alliance for Public Relations and Communication
Management—a not-for-profit organisation based in Switzerland—launched
the first Global Capability Framework, based on research led by British
academics and including input from Australia, Argentina, Canada, Singapore,
South Africa, Spain, Sweden, the UK and the USA. The framework is based on
research with practitioners, educators and employers about what public rela-
tions is capable of and how it can best fulfil its potential (Global Alliance 2018).
It is summarised below.
20 Foundations and the working environment
Conclusion
Morris and Goldsworthy describe public relations as a fragmented and diffuse
industry, scattered across all parts of the economy and society in thousands of
small cells (2008, p. xi). They say that, while it operates ‘under many aliases’
with ‘its border territories’ with other communication and marketing disci-
plines blurred or disputed, it has an incontrovertible allure (2008, p. xi). Why?
Perhaps it’s because, as they point out, ‘whatever is in the news or in vogue is
often closely associated with PR’ (2008, p. 8). Or perhaps it’s because there
remains some mystery about it. ‘PR is perhaps the ultimate postmodern
industry. No one knows what it really is but it sounds interesting!’ (2008, p 13).
As we will examine throughout this book, strategic communication and PR is
indeed a very interesting pursuit—it is also multi-faceted and complex. Commu-
nication relies heavily on research and planning—and this means planning for
the unexpected. It needs to be deliberate, organised and proactive, yet also
responsive and flexible. It also comes with a collective responsibility for those
entering the field because of the significant influence it wields within society.
Businesses, governments, lobby groups and community action groups seek to
motivate, persuade and influence others regarding their practice and their goals
and, as we will examine in the following chapters, this brings with it responsibil-
ities to those around us—to local communities, the enviornment, other citizens
and the democratic framework in which the field functions. It works in an envi-
ronment in which there are often developments and changes that present benefits
and challenges—such as the rise in data-mining, which can assist our friends in
22 Foundations and the working environment
marketing but challenge our ethics and relationships with our publics. Strategic
communication and PR need to navigate the world we live in and steer a course
that is ethical, transparent and strongly communicated. We are reminded how
‘A large and diverse PR industry may be the most realistic and effective way
of putting across the different views and representing the different interests of
society’ (Morris & Goldsworthy 2008, p. ix). We will keep this aim in mind as we
work through the next nine chapters.
References
Australian Government Job Outlook (2019a). Public Relations Professional. Retrieved from https://
joboutlook.gov.au/Occupation?search=Career&code=2253
Australian Government Job Outlook (2019b). Public Relations Manager. Retrieved from https://
joboutlook.gov.au/Occupation?search=Career&code=131114
Cutlip, S.M., Center, A.H. & Broom G.M. (2009). Cutler & Center’s Effective Public Relations
(10th edn). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall/Pearson Educational International.
Demetrious, K. (2014). Community Engagement & The Third Sector. In J. Johnston &
M. Sheehan (eds), Public Relations: Theory & Practice (4th edn.) (pp. 259–285). Sydney: Allen
& Unwin.
Dewey, J. (1927). The Public and its Problems. New York: H. Holt & Co.
Edwards, L. (2018). Understanding Public Relations: Theory, Culture & Society. London: Sage.
Fawkes, J., Gregory, A., Falkheimer, J., Gutiérrez-García, E., Halff, G., Rensburg, R., Sadi, G.,
Sevigny, A., Sison, M.D., Thurlow, A., Tsetsura, K. & Wolf, K. (2018). A Global Capability
Framework for the Public Relations and Communication Management Profession. Huddersfield:
Global Alliance for Public Relations and Communication Management.
Freeman, R.E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Boston: Pitman.
Garber, M. (2012). 55555, or, How to Laugh Online in Other Languages. The Atlantic
(12 December; Technology section). Retrieved from www.theatlantic.com/technology/
archive/2012/12/55555-or-how-to-laugh-online-in-other-languages/266175/
Global Alliance (2018). Global Capabilities Framework at WPRF in Oslo. Retrieved from www.
globalalliancepr.org/news/2018/4/24/press-release-on-global-capabilities-framework-for-
public-relations-and-communication-management
Good Universities Guide (2019). Good Education Group. Retrieved from www.gooduniversities
guide.com.au/
Hallahan, K., Holtzhausen, D., van Ruler, B., Verc̆ic̆, D. & Sriramesh, K. (2007). Defining
Strategic Communication. International Journal of Strategic Communication, 1(1), 3–35.
Halloran, R. (2007). Strategic Communication. Parameters, (Autumn), 4–14. Retrieved from
http://media.leeds.ac.uk/papers/vp012358.html
Hartley, J. (2002). Communication, Cultural and Media Studies: The Key Concepts. London: Routledge.
Hill+Knowlton (2020). Hill+Knowlton Strategies: About Us. Retrieved from www.hkstrategies.com/
Introducing strategic communication and public relations 23
Johnston, J. & Zawawi, C. (2000) What is public relations? In J. Johnston & C. Zawawi (eds),
Public Relations: Theory and Practice (pp. 3-23). Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
——— (2014). An Overview of Public Relations. In J. Johnston & M. Sheehan (eds), Public Rela-
tions: Theory and Practice (pp. 3–19). Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
Johnston, J. & Macnamara, J. (2013). Public Relations Literature and Scholarship in Australia:
A Brief History of Change and Diversification. PRism, 10(1), 1–16.
Ledingham, J.A. & Bruning, S.D. (1998). Relationship Management in Public Relations: Dimen-
sions of an Organization–Public Relationship. Public Relations Review, 24(1), 55–65.
Little, W. (2016). Introduction to Sociology (2nd Canadian edn). BC Open Textbooks. Retrieved from
https://opentextbc.ca/introductiontosociology2ndedition/chapter/chapter-1-an-introduction-
to-sociology/
Lock, I. (2019). Explicating Communicative Organization–Stakeholder Relationships in the
Digital Age: A Systematic Review and Research Agenda. Public Relations Review, 45(4).
Morath, K. (2008). PRide and PRejudice: Conversations with Australia’s public relations legends.
Elanora: Nuhouse Press.
Morris, T. & Goldsworthy S. (2008). PR—A Persuasive Industry? Spin, Public Relations and the
Shaping of the Media. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Neal, Z.P. (2014). Community. Oxford Bibliographies. Retrieved from www.oxfordbibliographies.
com/view/document/obo-9780199756384/obo-9780199756384-0080.xml
New Zealand Education (2019). Think New. Retrieved from www.studyinnewzealand.govt.nz/
Nickols, F. (2012). Strategy: Definitions and Meaning. Distance Consulting. Retrieved from
https://nickols.us/strategy_definition.htm
PRIA (2018). Global Capabilities Framework. Retrieved from www.pria.com.au/index.cfm/education/
global-capabrk/
——— (2019). What Is PR? What Is It? Retrieved from www.pria.com.au/public-relations/
what-is-it/
PRINZ (2019). What Is Public Relations? Retrieved from www.prinz.org.nz/About/What-is-Public-
Relations
PRSA (2012, April 11). Public Relations Defined: A Modern Definition for the New Era of Public
Relations. Retrieved from http://prdefinition.prsa.org/index.php/2012/04/11/the-modern-
definition-of-public-relations/
Sheehan, M. (2014). A Brief History of Public Relations in Australia and New Zealand. In
J. Johnston & C. Zawawi (eds), Public Relations: Theory and Practice (pp. 20–48). Sydney:
Allen & Unwin.
Singer, N. (2015). Sharing Data but Not Happily, The New York Times (4 June). Retrieved from
www.nytimes.com/2015/06/05/technology/consumers-conflicted-over-data-mining-
policies-report-finds.html
The Red Republic (2019). Welcome to the World of the Red Republic. Retrieved from https://
theredrepublic.com/
Tymson, C. & Sherman, B. (1987). The Australian Public Relations Manual. Sydney: Millennium.
Winkler, P. & Wehmeier, S. (2018). On Harrison White: Rethinking Relations in Public
Relations. In Ø. Ihlen & M. Fredriksson (eds), Public Relations and Social Theory (2nd edn)
(pp. 149–169). London: Routledge.
24 Foundations and the working environment
Communication at work
25
26 Foundations and the working environment
Classifications of organisations
Let’s start with a closer look at the sectors themselves and what types of
organisations, institutions, associations and groups (discussed generically as
‘organisations’ within this book) fit within each. On initial viewing, the three
sectors appear to be quite distinctive, but on closer examination we can see that
Communication at work 27
an organisation can have characteristics from multiple sectors. The clear delin-
eations of the past have gone. Not all public sector organisations are the same,
and nor are those in the private or public sectors. Consider Figure 2.1 and
note the wide variety of organisations arranged around the circular spectrum.
Some sit in the centre and fit the common description of their sector, such
as government departments (public sector), corporations (private sector) and
charities (not-for-profit or NFP sector). Others are closer to, or straddle, one
of the other sectors, such as communes (public/not-for-profit sectors), social
enterprises (not-for-profit/private sectors) and public–private partnerships.
Public sector organisations are government-owned organisations. The
most obvious of these are government departments, such as Health, Defence,
Treasury and Agriculture. However, governments also have autonomous state
agencies which generally administer and provide advice on specific functions,
such as the Australian Electoral Commission and the New Zealand Film
Commission. State-owned enterprises, such as Australia Post and KiwiRail,
Figure 2.1 Organisations in the three sectors. Source: adapted from Mintzberg
(2016). Photo by Louis Reed, Unsplash.
28 Foundations and the working environment
Political Apolitical
Undertaken Politicians Public sector communication
by Political party operatives staff
Political and media advisers Public servants/bureaucrats
Lobbyists
Goals Political ends Governance/administrative
ends
Messages Partisan Non-partisan/impartial
Persuasive Factual, transparent
Selective Persuasive (in terms of policy
Electioneering implementation)
Source: Glenny (2020, p. 88).
ultimately, get (re)elected at the ballot box. Citizens are a key stakeholder
group, but there is also a need to communicate with groups in the private and
not-for-profit sectors, other political actors, parliamentary committees and
the media.
At the heart of their communication lies the building of trusted and trusting
relationships based on openness, honesty and opportunities for all to partici-
pate. The idea of building relationships in political communication could be
argued as being too idealistic. Scholars critiquing the use of public relations in
politics often take a more cynical view, seeing it as a mechanism for one-way
communication that aims to use the media and well-crafted messages to gain
favourable publicity, avoid negative publicity, control the information to the
political actors’ advantage and manage a positive presentation of one’s image.
Although Strömbäck and Kiousis argue that this reflects a ‘narrow understand-
ing of public relations’ (2011, p. 9), it is from this perspective that the notion
of ‘spin’ emerges. The term is used to imply that a favourable bias has been
given to the information being disseminated. Used to describe the tactics of
political campaigning and of government media relations, Andrews argues
that the term spin ‘is now one of the most overused, and arguably least mean-
ingful, words in use in political communication’ (2006, p. 31). This is not to
say that information is never manipulated or biased, but accusations of spin
Communication at work 31
Ministerial staff
Standing beside, or sometimes between, the politician and the media and other
stakeholders are the electoral staff and the political and media advisers to the
ministers of parliaments in Australia, New Zealand, Canada, Britain and other
democratic parliamentary systems. Ministerial staff are political appointees
who provide support on policy, strategy and media, working with politicians,
other political staff and public servants. Exercising considerable influence over
the communication activities of politicians, the specialist advisers counsel on
media strategies and the construction of narratives, undertaking a variety of
activities, such as:
• briefing journalists
• writing media releases
• arranging interviews and media conferences
• monitoring the media
• researching
• management or oversight of website and social media platforms.
Public service agencies are often large and complex organisations, requiring
substantial communication support. In 2019, some of the largest federal govern-
ment employers of communication and marketing staff were the Australian
Tax Office (493 staff) and the Department of Human Services (286 staff) (now
called Services Australia) (Australian National Audit Office 2020, pp. 14–15).
Annual reports to the New Zealand Parliament over the years 2013–2018
showed a 60 per cent rise in staffing numbers, with some attributing this to
increased demands for information and others claiming that it is about restrict-
ing information to the media (Pennington 2019). When you consider the
number of departments and agencies across federal and state governments,
and the thousands of local councils around Australia, you can see how s ignificant
the demand is for specialists in the public sector.
The growing use of social media to reach out to citizens, with all its benefits
and challenges, has warranted the implementation of policies throughout all
levels of government. Policies typically cover both the professional and personal
use of social media, listing protocols for approvals, standards of behaviour and the
processes for moderation. Guidance is also presented for public servants regard-
ing how to manage social media effectively and efficiently and how to establish
and evaluate valid objectives and outcomes. Social media is largely used to dis
seminate information. For example, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade
uses its Smart Traveller Facebook and Twitter accounts to provide information
for safe travel, including alerts regarding dangerous areas to avoid. Many of
the emergency service organisations use social media in times of crises to keep the
community up to date, pushing out the latest information as circumstances change.
Other government social media sites provide capacity for citizen engagement,
such as the sharing of missing children reports from police, reporting damaged
footpaths to councils and facilitating community views on policy reviews.
The relationship between political and public service communication can
be complex. The public service communicator works in a very political envi-
ronment and a clear distance needs to be kept between communication that
explains what the government is doing and communication that justifies what
the government is doing. For example, the public service communicator needs
to explain citizens’ responsibilities in terms of submitting their tax returns, but
he or she does not engage in justifying or defending why the government made
a controversial change to taxation laws.
36 Foundations and the working environment
Coronavirus communication
In January 2020, the outbreak of the Coronavirus COVID-19 in Wuhan, China,
received intense media coverage, reporting fears that the contagion would
spread throughout the world. Even at that early stage, constant updates in
media about how many were infected and where patients were located
flooded both mainstream and social media—not all of it accurate or from
reliable sources. As the virus spread, and countries started shutting their borders
and restricting citizen movements, government communication was central
to keeping the public updated with factual information, providing information
about preventative measures, and reassuring citizens that the government
was working on control measures. Communication efforts faced the difficult
balancing act of asking the public to radically change its behaviours while
preventing panic.
Initial government communication efforts included a website with informa-
tion and fact sheets targeting different audiences such as health professionals,
parents, schools and universities and for staff in industries such as airlines and
cruise ships. As the seriousness of the circumstances developed, govern
ment ministers and health authorities gave daily media conferences, the web
presence grew, advertising and social media campaigns were developed, and
the media became saturated with information. In the rapidly developing situa-
tion, some communication activities were more successful than others, showing
the importance of clear messaging and source credibility.
Consumer relations
Much of the focus of the corporate communicator is on consumer groups,
where the aim is to seek positive attention for the organisation and its products,
share information with consumers and listen to their needs and concerns. In
this respect, the lines between strategic communication, public relations and
marketing communication overlap, requiring all specialist communicators to
work together in connecting with consumers. Consumers see all communica-
tion from the organisation as emanating from a single voice—they don’t see
the different PR and marketing messages, and neither should they. Internally,
however, the balance of responsibilities between the communication team and
the marketing team will depend on the structure and approach of the organi-
sation. Although there is no formally agreed delineation between the roles of
communication and marketing practitioners, historical differences have centred
around a focus on consumers and sales for marketing and all other stakeholders
for corporate communication. This is also reflected in integrated market-
ing communication (IMC), a concept largely driven by the advertising and
38 Foundations and the working environment
Investor relations
The two major sources of income for a for-profit organisation are sales and
investment. Therefore, a stakeholder with equal importance to consumers
in the corporate sector is the shareholder, or investor. Financial relations (or
investor relations) is a specialised field of strategic communication, managed
in-house by the corporate communicator or outsourced to an agency with a
focus on the finance community. While the shareholders themselves sit at the
centre of this important group, the financial media and investment advisers
provide a crucial bridge between the organisation and the investors. The
central focus for the communicator in this field is the provision of information
regarding the financial standing of the organisation, which can often include
dealing with acquisitions and mergers. Two key channels through which this
is done are the Annual Financial Report and the Annual General Meeting.
While both activities require a collaborative effort across the organisation, the
communication practitioner may play a lead role in their coordination and
the framing of key messaging.
Public financial information is often organised through an ‘investor
relations’ page on the company website, with quarterly and annual reports,
share and dividend information, management announcements, disclosure
policies and resources for the media. Other communication activities could
include preparing presentations, engaging with analysts and arranging company
visits and webcasts. Communication staff need to have a good understanding of
corporate finance, accounting and law and to be across the legal requirements
for reporting to the stock exchange. Above all, there is a need for accurate,
open and timely information. The survival of the company is dependent on
its financial situation, so by reassuring investors and others that it is a stable
organisation, financial relations can help build and maintain the company’s
good reputation.
40 Foundations and the working environment
These competing voices, and the ability for experts to contribute to deci-
sion-making can be seen as benefits of a more inclusive approach to public
policy—an approach that contributes to a ‘healthy democracy’ (Mulcahy 2015,
p. 6). Additionally, it could be argued that private sector organi-
sations’ involvement in public policy discussions stems from their
responsibility as corporate citizens contributing to public debate to corporate
achieve the best outcomes for society. However, from a more prag- citizenship
matic view, the main aim is to influence political decision-making
in terms that will be of benefit to their operations. This notion of
‘influence’ leads to concerns about the power of corporations and their impact
on governments, and hence democracy, with suggestions of ‘routinely low
ethical standards’ (Davidson 2015, p. 615).
Public affairs can sit within a corporate affairs or legal department in the
organisation but, due to its focus on communication, it is typically considered
to be a strategic communication function. A range of tactics are employed:
meetings with key political and public service contacts, speeches and presenta-
tions, publication of proposals, petitions, collaborations with other private and
third sector organisations, media interviews and pitches, and campaigns.
Lobbying is the specific tactic of reaching out to key government officials,
either political or bureaucratic, in order to influence policy and legislative
decision-making to the benefit of the organisation. The technique is used by
both private and not-for-profit sector organisations, often with opposing views
but also providing opportunities for collaboration where their interests align.
Lobbying is a growing industry in many democracies and needs to be under-
taken ethically and transparently, with absolutely no room for bribes, preferential
treatment, bias, nepotism or ‘special’ deals. Lobbyists are typically those indi-
viduals or organisations set up to represent a third party. Employees of private
sector organisations involved in lobbying activities are therefore not required to
register (see below) but should still maintain the highest ethical standards.
The Lobbying Code of Conduct was introduced by the Australian Govern-
ment in July 2008 to guide best practice and register lobbyists so government
representatives know when they are being approached by individuals with
vested interests. Individual states have also been establishing their own codes
and registers. Individuals and entities representing foreign governments and
political organisations and individuals are also required to register their
42 Foundations and the working environment
Working together to pursue both common goals and individual goals, organ-
isations form strategic alliances through the sharing of skills and resources. The
partnerships can be with another business, with a government body or with a
not-for-profit organisation and are strategic as they are focused on fulfilling
Communication at work 43
uncertainty, citizens mobilise to fight for causes and changes in society. And
corporations are increasingly interested in aligning themselves with those
good causes. But troubling the not-for-profit sector are the competition to be
heard in an environment of information overload, reductions in funding and
increased ‘compassion fatigue’, whereby many individuals disconnect emotion-
ally as they become overwhelmed by stressful messages or feel that nothing is
being achieved. Others, however, remain impassioned and active in causes and
fights to build a healthier and more sustainable society. Technology positively
facilitates some of these connections by spreading information and healthy
debate to a much broader audience. But technology can also encourage lazy
activism that fails to achieve significant change (i.e. slacktivism), and it can
be a disruptive force that contributes to misinformation, gives prominence to
unrepresentative voices and creates disharmony within communities.
The Bad: A fake online fundraising campaign, set up one day after the death of
two men in the New South Wales bushfires on New Years’ Eve in 2019, acquired
almost $4000 before being shut down (Black 2020).
The key aim expressed here is the building of valuable and useful
networks of social connections, in which trust and mutual benefit
result in improved circumstances for all involved, and potentially
social
for society. These networks are considered as an asset—a social
capital
capital—where the ‘social contacts affect the productivity of individ-
uals and groups’ (Putnam 2000, p. 19). There is a similarity here with
46 Foundations and the working environment
the power to mobilize can be just as important as the power that wealth or
positions of authority can bring . . . Armed with their innate social media skills
and tremendous passion for the causes they believe in, these young activists are
showing the world just how much power they can wield, especially now that
they have the ear of the world’s decision-makers. (Sudhaman 2020)
Social enterprises
Sitting on the border of the not-for-profit sector and the private sector are the
social enterprises, which have an interesting mix of communication require-
ments aligned with both NGOs and corporations. A simple definition, which
Communication at work 49
focuses on social enterprise as being a process rather than an entity, states that it is
‘established using a business model designed to deliver services for the purpose
of providing a social benefit, rather than to provide a profit’ (Productivity
50 Foundations and the working environment
Despite the recent growth of social enterprises, little research has been
conducted into their communication needs and activities. Research partici-
pants in the 2016 report into Australia’s social enterprise sector recognised
that a lack of knowledge and investment in marketing and communication
limited the development of their enterprises (Barraket et al. 2016, p. 49).
Nevertheless, strategic communication and PR are as relevant to this sector
as to all others and should address the marketplace (where most funding will
be obtained) but also all other stakeholders with an interest in the enterprise.
Partnerships and collaboration with other non-profit organisations, corpo-
rations and government bodies may also be productive in terms of resources
and funding. Networking—face to face and online—also creates opportuni-
ties for investment and other valuable assistance in business processes and
communication. Social enterprise intermediaries, such as Social Enterprise
Auckland, are organisations established to assist entrepreneurs by providing
resources, support, leadership, events and networking. Communication is
essential to all these connections, using tactics from both the private and
non-profit sectors.
Communication at work 51
Conclusion
This chapter has shown how strategic communication plays a role in so
many elements of society, from the large, multinational corporation to the
local council and the teen activists starting movements of their own. While
communication may not always be performed effectively, the benefit of well-
planned activities that help organisations achieve their missions cannot be
understated. Opportunities abound for those who understand the value of
communication that brings people and organisations together, that unites
more than it divides, and that achieves clarity of understanding in an ethical
and transparent manner.
We started the chapter by considering how organisations are gener-
ally grouped into three categories, the public, private and not-for-profit
sectors, while noting that there are some shared characteristics. Public sector
communication has unique challenges in communicating with a broad and
sometimes uninterested public, whether it is seeking support at an election
or implementing a policy designed to improve citizens’ lives. The private
sector organisation’s end goal of making profits for its owners or sharehold-
ers can be enhanced through purposeful communication with consumers,
investors, the community and other significant stakeholders. And the third
sector, with its diverse organisations and noble ambitions of serving their
members or the community, also depends on clear communication to achieve
its strategic intent.
For those looking to work in the field of strategic communication, special
interests and passions can be combined with communication skills and knowl-
edge to provide rewarding careers in the public, private and not-for-profit
sectors. You may be seeking a ‘cut and thrust’ career as a high-flying corporate
communication practitioner, have a passion for politics or specialist fields of
government, or want to make a difference in social or animal welfare. Strategic
communication is advantageous to all.
References
Aggerholm, H.K. (2018). Cocreation of meaning. In R.L. Heath & W. Johansen (eds), The Inter-
national Encyclopedia of Strategic Communication. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Communication at work 53
Andrews, L. (2006). Spin: From Tactic to Tabloid. Journal of Public Affairs, 6(1), 31–45.
Australian National Audit Office (2020). Defence’s Management of its Public Communications and
Media Activities. Retrieved from www.anao.gov.au/work/performance-audit/defences-
management-its-public-communications-and-media-activities
Baines, P. (2011). Political Public Relations and Election Campaigning. In J. Strömbäck & Kiousis,
S. (eds), Political Public Relations: Principles and Applications (pp. 124–126). New York, NY:
Routledge.
Barraket, J., Mason, C. & Blain, B. (2016). Finding Australia’s Social Enterprise Sector 2016.
Swinburne: Social Traders & Centre for Social Impact Swinburne.
Black, M. (2020). NSW Bushfire Victims’ Family Gutted After Online Scammers Set Up
Fake Fundraiser in Their Name. ABC News (2 January). Retrieved from www.abc.net.au/
news/2020-01-02/fire-victims-family-outraged-at-fake-online-fundraiser/11837920
Campaigns of the World (2019). The Cybersmile Foundation Launched a Campaign #Trolling
IsUgly Featuring Chessie King. Campaigns of the World. Retrieved from https://campaign
softheworld.com/digital/the-cybersmile-foundation-trolling-is-ugly-featuring-chessie-king/
Carey, J.W. (2009). Communication as Culture: Essays on Media and Society (6th edn). New York,
NY: Routledge.
Cousens, L. & Bradish, C.L. (2018). Sport and Corporate Partnerships. In D. Hassan (ed.),
Managing Sport Business: An Introduction (2nd edn, Vol. 1) (pp. 421–439). London: Routledge.
Davidson, S. (2015). Everywhere and nowhere: Theorising and researching public affairs and
lobbying within public relations scholarship. Public Relations Review, 41(5), 615–627.
Demetrious, K. (2013). Public Relations, Activism, and Social Change: Speaking Up. New York, NY:
Routledge.
——— (2014). Community Engagement and the Third Sector. In J. Johnston &
M. Sheehan (eds), Public Relations Theory and Practice (4th edn) (pp. 259–285). Crows Nest:
Allen & Unwin.
Ferguson, D.P. (2018). Nongovernmental Organisation (NGO) Communication. In R.L. Heath
& W. Johansen (eds), The International Encyclopedia of Strategic Communication. Hoboken, NJ:
John Wiley & Sons.
Galloway, C. (2014). Integrated Marketing Communication. In J. Johnston & M. Sheehan
(eds), Public Relations: Theory & Practice (4th edn) (pp. 108–136). Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
Gen, S. & Wright, A.C. (2013). Policy Advocacy Organizations: A Framework Linking Theory
and Practice. Journal of Policy Practice, 12(3), 163–193.
Glenny, L. (2020). Politics and Policy: Relationships and Functions Within Public Sector
Communication. In V. Luoma-aho & M.J. Canel (eds), The Handbook of Public Sector Commu-
nication (pp. 81–96). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Heath, R.L. (2018). Activism. In R.L. Heath & W. Johansen (eds), The International Encyclopedia
of Strategic Communication. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Johnston, K.A., Lane, A.B., Hurst, B. & Beatson, A. (2018). Episodic and Relational Commu-
nity Engagement: Implications for Social Impact and Social License. In K.A. Johnston &
M. Taylor (eds), The Handbook of Community Engagement (pp. 169–186). Hoboken, NJ: John
Wiley & Sons.
54 Foundations and the working environment
Johnston, K.A. & Lane, A.B. (2018). Building Relational Capital: The Contribution of Episodic
and Relational Community Engagement. Public Relations Review, 44(5), 633–644.
Lilleker, B.G. (2006). Key Concepts in Political Communication. London: Sage Publications.
Lerbinger, O. (2006). Corporate Public Affairs: Interacting with Interest Groups, Media, and Govern-
ment. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Macnamara, J.R. (2012). Public Relations: Theories, Practices, Critiques. Frenchs Forest, NSW:
Pearson Australia.
Mason, M. (2019). Rugby Australia Does the Right Thing by Sponsors. Australian Financial
Review (8 May). Retrieved from www.afr.com/companies/media-and-marketing/israel-folau-
rugby-australia-does-the-righ-thing-by-sponsors-20190508-p51lbk
McNair, B. (2018). An Introduction to Political Communication (6th edn). London: Routledge.
Mintzberg, H. (2016). Organizations Around Public, Private, Plural (blog post, 3 June). Retrieved
from https://mintzberg.org/blog/three-sectors
Mosley, R. (2014). Employer Brand Management. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.
Mulcahy, S. (2015). Lobbying in Europe: Hidden Influence, Privileged Access. Transparency Interna-
tional.
Pennington, P. (2019). Government’s Public Relations Teams Rapidly Expanding. New Zealand
Herald (24 July). Retrieved from www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=
12252394
Productivity Commission (2010). Contribution of the Not-for-Profit Sector. Research Report.
Canberra: Australian Government.
Putnam, R.D. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York,
NY: Simon & Schuster.
Senate Standing Committee on Economics (2008). Disclosure Regimes for Charities and Not-for-
Profit Organisations. Canberra: Senate Printing Unit, Parliament House.
Smith, M.F. & Ferguson, D.P. (2010). Activism 2.0. In R.L. Heath (ed.), The Sage Handbook of
Public Relations (2nd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
Social Enterprise Auckland (2020). What is Social Enterprise? Retrieved from www.social
enterpriseauckland.org.nz/what-is-social-enterprise/
Sorkin, A.R. (2018). BlackRock’s Message: Contribute to Society, or Risk Losing Our Support.
The New York Times (15 January). Retrieved from www.nytimes.com/2018/01/15/business/
dealbook/blackrock-laurence-fink-letter.html
South Australia, Department of Premier and Cabinet (2019). Marketing Communications
Guidelines. Retrieved from www.dpc.sa.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/97116/Marketing-
Communications-Guidelines-effective-1-July-2019.pdf##marketingguidelines
Strömbäck, J. & Kiousis, S. (2011). Defining and Mapping an Emergent Field. In J. Strömbäck
& S. Kiousis (eds), Political Public Relations: Principles and Applications (pp. 1–32). New York,
NY: Routledge.
Sudhaman, A. (2020). Davos 2020: Four Themes as WEF Confronts Capitalism’s Legacy.
PRovoke (blog post, 25 January). Retrieved from www.holmesreport.com/long-reads/article/
davos-2020-four-themes-as-wef-confronts-capitalism’s-legacy
The Ethics Centre (2018). Ethics Explainer: Social License to Operate. Retrieved from https://
ethics.org.au/ethics-explainer-social-license-to-operate/
Communication at work 55
The Fashion Law (2018). ‘Un-branded’ . . . How Consumers Outgrew Traditional Branding.
Retrieved from www.thefashionlaw.com/home/un-branded-your-reliance-on-traditional-
branding-is-old-news-friends
United Nations Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (n.d.). My Life as a Refugee. Retrieved
from https://mylifeasarefugee.org/
World Economic Forum (WEF) (2020). Meet the Teenage Change-makers Making Waves
at Davos 2020. Retrieved from www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/01/the-teenage-change-
makers-at-davos-2020/
Chapter 3
56
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 57
What is an issue?
We are surrounded by issues every day, often without consciously considering
them in any depth, or even clearly identifying them. Determining what an issue
is, and how it impacts an organisation’s business practice and reputation, is an
essential function. The communication practitioner is not just the mouth of
the organisation, but also its eyes and ears, constantly monitoring the external
environment for issues that may impact on its success. Threats to an organi-
sation’s reputation, adjustments in public policy, technological advancements,
and changes in societal behaviours and attitudes have the potential to disrupt
the regular operations of a business. This is theorised in systems theory, which
explains how an organisation receives and interacts with information from its
environment and, in return, impacts on that environment. Early intervention
in these issues, through action and communication, may prevent or reduce
outcomes that are detrimental to the business.
Heath’s definition, from over two decades ago, still provides a clear and
simple description of an issue as ‘a contestable point, a difference of opinion
regarding fact, value, or policy, the resolution of which has consequences for
the organization’s strategic plan’ (1997, p. 84). This definition remains useful
in a time when new technology has empowered all citizens, including NGOs and
activists, giving them an increased ability and a louder voice to openly express
and debate expectations around corporate behaviour (Jaques 2012, p. 38). For
example, online petitions and social media campaigns can pressure businesses
58 Foundations and the working environment
While the introduction of the internet and mobile phones was disruptive,
a more recent example is the introduction of ride-sharing services such as
Uber, which have severely disrupted the taxi industry. The latest generation of
disruptive technologies are wide-ranging and include AI and machine learning,
robotics, 3D printing, and blockchain technology (Cag 2019). These innova-
tions have potential consequences for the strategic plans of many organisations
and need to be monitored and managed.
which also ‘involve external parties . . . have no black and white or “right”
answer . . . happen in public or in the news media’ and have the potential to
become crises if not managed well (2016, p. 40).
Many issues arise through a gap in expectations around political, economic,
social, technological, legal and environmental conditions, or PESTLE. Issues
often span more than one of these categories and can be categorised in differ-
ent ways; however, a PESTLE analysis, as illustrated below, is a useful tool
for examining the organisation’s external environment. The prominence of
issues will wax and wane over time and they may be initiated by businesses, by
governments or by activists. They may also be either driven by broader social
debates or emerge from more specific changes to public policy and legislation.
Some examples are provided in Table 3.1.
FACT CHECK
Think about current public issues and debates that may have an impact
on universities. For example, has your university moved to a smoke-free
zone? Is it generating its own power?
60 Foundations and the working environment
Complex and diverse views typically accompany any issue, and organisa-
tions that take a carefully considered position in order to gain the support of
some stakeholders risk alienating others. As issues are contestable points
of difference, exposed through gaps between stakeholder expectations and
organisational performance (Issues Management Council n.d. (b)), organi-
sations need to closely manage key issues to protect their strategic interests
and reputation.
such as straws and cutlery, creating a momentum in public opinion and forcing
businesses to seek alternatives.
The life cycle of issues, as first identified by Crable and Vibbert (1985),
assists in the identification and analysis of issues, and can help direct commu-
nication activities at each of the five stages. At any point in time (and not
necessarily in a linear order) an issue may be:
At each stage, the actors involved in the issue have different understand-
ings, positions, motivations and preferred outcomes, and communication
priorities will therefore vary. In progressing an issue through the different
stages, four ‘communicative strategies’ have been identified by Coombs and
Holladay: definition, legitimisation, polarisation and identification (2018,
pp. 82–84; Coombs et al. 2019, p. 38). In the early stages there is a need to
define the issue, which is typically done in terms that favour the position and
outcome desired by the issue manager’s organisation. Once those terms have
been settled, there is a need to legitimise both the issue and the issue manager,
showing that the issue is authentic and valid, and that the issue manager has a
legitimate role to play. If the communication efforts to define and legitimise
the issue are not successful, the issue may return to a dormant stage rather
than becoming current or critical.
Moving an issue to a current or critical stage requires using media (paid,
earned, shared or owned) to create awareness of the issue and involve more
individuals and organisations. Communication efforts may be initially directed
towards attempts to polarise people into choosing one side or another in the
64 Foundations and the working environment
Figure 3.1 The decision to close Uluru to climbers involved years of issues
management. Photo by Holger Link, Unsplash.
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 65
day of closure, 26 October 2019, there was considerable news and social media
coverage using spokespeople to explain the cultural and safety reasons for the
change and counter the arguments against their decision.
governments around the world to manage a similar, but even more serious risk.
Due the large number of people affected by these risks, the communication is
predominantly one-way, although communication with healthcare providers
is encouraged.
Risk communication can serve a range of purposes:
Risk has been identified as ‘a subjective judgement’ in that people will assess
the risk in different ways. As a result, ‘risk communication should be built
upon understanding the risk perceptions of stakeholders’ (Coombs et al. 2019,
p. 39). At the same time, organisations need to understand how the risk percep-
tions of stakeholders can be increased through media. The way the
news media and social media prioritise and potentially amplify issues
is explained in agenda-setting and framing theory. Problematic agenda
framing and messaging can pose significant threats to an organisa- setting and
tion’s operations and reputation, reinforcing the need for continual framing
was not technically withdrawn (Kuo & Yu 2019). By that stage, the protests
had broadened to include demands for direct elections, the resignation of Lam
and inquiries into police brutality (Bradsher 2019). The pressure of the crisis
on government was substantial but it also impacted significantly on businesses,
citizens and tourists as it continued.
For a not-for-profit organisation, loss of reputation in a crisis can also have a
financial impact on fundraising, with donors losing trust and withdrawing their
support. The ripple effect of poor crisis management can be seen in the Oxfam
GB case from the UK. In 2018, there were allegations of sexual misconduct
by Oxfam GB staff during the 2010 Haiti earthquake recovery effort (Charity
Commission 2019). Soon after these claims were made public, further claims of
misconduct, but also of management covering up the scandal, were made and
a government investigation was commissioned (Charity Commission 2019).
Following the publicity that ensued regarding both the scandals and the organ-
isation’s management of the crisis, an 85 per cent increase in whistleblower
reports within the charity sector was noted (Swerling 2019). The report into
the investigation was critical of Oxfam’s conduct, concluding, in part, that
‘focusing on avoiding negative or critical media coverage when incidents have
happened will not fulfil the trustees’ duty to protect a charity’s reputation, nor
serve the shared responsibility to uphold the reputation of charity as a whole’
(Charity Commission 2019, p. 33).
As can be seen in these examples, crises can develop from a variety of situ-
ations. Considering the different types of crises can assist in performing a
risk assessment on potential threats to an organisation. Crisis communication
scholar Timothy Coombs distinguishes two categories of crises: operational
crises and paracrises (Coombs 2018, p. 26). An operational crisis is one that
directly impacts on the operations of an organisation. A paracrisis is not yet a
full crisis but simply a challenge from a stakeholder that accuses the organisa-
tion of ‘acting in an irresponsible or unethical manner’ (Coombs & Holladay
2012, p. 408). Typically starting with social media claims, and then encour-
aged through the spreading of information on the internet, it becomes a full
crisis when a significant number of stakeholders start sharing similar concerns
and taking action (Coombs & Holladay 2012). There are numerous lists of
crises that can be used to analyse the threat to an organisation; the types
of crises Coombs lists can be seen in Table 3.3 below (Coombs 2017, p. 347).
70 Foundations and the working environment
Operational Crises
Operational Disasters such as floods, fires, and health emergencies
disruptions from that limit or prevent routine operations.
disasters
Workplace Some form of violence against employees or clients in
violence the workplace.
Unexpected loss of Sudden loss of a leader within an organisation due to
key leadership death, illness or unexpected resignation or termination.
Malevolence A person or group of people purposely attack an
organisation, such as sabotaging operations or products.
Technical-error Failure of technology that leads to a serious accident or
accidents or faulty and dangerous product, such as a gas explosion at
product harm a factory or contamination of a food product.
Human-error Accident or product harm caused by the mistake of one
accidents or or more employees of the organisation, such as an error
product harm in administration that creates financial harm.
Data breach Private and confidential information is accessed, stolen
(physically or electronically) and/or used without
authorisation.
Organisational Management decisions and actions that may place
misdeeds stakeholders at risk or knowingly violate the law, such as
a banking institution or telecommunications company
charging fees for services that are not provided.
Scansis Scandal-crisis. Moral outrage accompanies the crisis, and
stakeholders make judgements about injustice and greed.
Paracrises (challenge crises)
Faux pas A well-intentioned management decision or action that
stakeholders perceive negatively, such as a misguided
statement in a speech or an ad that unintentionally
patronises a specific group of people.
Rumours False information is circulated about the organisation or
its products with the intention of causing harm, such as
fake online reviews.
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 71
will provide the team a stable platform from which to work and to guide them
through the processes.
Communication plays a crucial role in the response stage of a crisis, provid-
ing swift and unambiguous information for the organisation to rectify the
situation. Stakeholders outside the immediate area of impact also need to be
kept informed. They will have a variety of emotional reactions, such as anger,
mistrust, fear, shock and sadness, and responding in a compassionate manner
will be essential. Highlighting the importance of communicating during the
response
the notion of trying to control the crisis itself is at best optimistic, and at worst
futile. But attempting to control your own crisis communication is absolutely
a legitimate objective. (Jaques 2016, p. 111)
and their investors. This can often be seen in definitions of CSR, such as that
of the Australian Human Rights Commission:
There are many definitions for the complex notion of CSR but, despite
subtle differences, a number of features stand out. These include:
Different terms are used to describe CSR or its related activities. They
are often used interchangeably but sometimes have subtle but important
differences.
Figure 3.3 CSR responsibilities to the market, the workplace, the environment and
the community.
76 Foundations and the working environment
• Triple bottom line—in business, the ‘bottom line’ used to refer to the
balance at the bottom of a company’s financial statement. Many compa-
nies are also adding society and the environment to their ‘bottom lines’ of
reporting (also expressed earlier in the chapter as People, Profit, Planet).
• Corporate community involvement—focuses primarily on a
company’s contribution to the community, along with an expec-
tation that the involvement produces a return benefit to the
corporate company.
citizenship • Corporate citizenship—where the organisation is viewed as
a citizen of the community in which it operates, with similar
responsibilities to those of all citizens.
non-profit sector is typically on the receiving end of much of the CSR activity
of businesses, but it is also watching the corporate sector closely and is vocal in
its criticism of practices it feels are irresponsible. For example, over the years a
chorus of voices called for clearer sugar labelling on soft drinks and other food
and beverages. Non-profit organisations such as Choice (2019), Parents’ Voice
and the Public Health Association of Australia (Martin 2019) campaigned and
addressed the media, placing pressure on businesses to change their practices
and on governments to change legislation. Taking a more proactive approach,
there are increasing numbers of partnerships between non-profit organisations
and businesses to address social issues together. For instance, World Vision
Australia has been working with Jetstar for over ten years on programs to support
Indigenous Australian and developing communities (World Vision 2020).
The last two decades have seen not only a growth in the practice of CSR
but also the emergence of global partnerships and initiatives to help compa-
nies implement and report. The United Nations has been at the centre of
much of this with the launch of the UN Global Compact in 2000, under which
companies agree to sign up to ten ‘principles that address responsible corpo-
rate citizenship’ (www.unglobalcompact.org/United Nations Global Impact
2020). Underpinned by the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights,
the principles are organised into four categories: Human Rights, Labour,
Environment and Anti-corruption. There has been a steady increase in the
number of Australian companies signing up for the Global Compact, from
28 companies in 2008 to 166 by mid-2019. At that time, twelve companies were
also registered in New Zealand.
Since 2010, the UN Global Compact has continued to work in c ollaboration
with an independent organisation, the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI),
to set standards and improve reporting on CSR initiatives. The focus is on
measurement of the same three factors that are the focus of CSR: economic,
environmental and social performance. Due to the significant number of
organisations involved, the GRI framework has become the global standard
for reporting.
The global focus on CSR was further strengthened in 2015 when the
United Nations created the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (United
Nations Sustainable Development Goals n.d.). The plan contains seventeen
80 Foundations and the working environment
Figure 3.4 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Source: Maria Gershunu,
Public Domain.
goals (see Figure 3.4) and 169 targets to end poverty, build economic growth
and address social and environmental issues. As in the true spirit of CSR, these
goals are not legally binding but, rather, are voluntary targets for governments
and organisations to work towards.
The International Organization for Standardization, based in Switzerland,
has developed a standard known as ISO 26000, which gives organisations another
source for CSR guidance and clearly aligns with both the Sustainable Develop-
ment Goals (above) and the other models outlined in this chapter. The aim of
this specific international standard is not to impose requirements but, rather, to
guide organisations on how they can operate ethically and transparently while
considering stakeholder expectations and applicable laws (ISO n.d.).
CSR theories
Just as the topography of CSR definitions is multidimensional, so too is that
of CSR theory. There is no single theory to explain CSR. Rather, numerous
theories and approaches from a range of disciplines have been applied depending
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 81
Conclusion
Issues management is at the heart of strategic communication and PR within
corporations, government agencies and not-for-profit organisations alike.
Shifts in society, through technology, media, globalisation, the environment
and political unrest, have intensified the need for organisations to be fully aware
of how these changes can influence the achievement of their strategic goals
and how prudent management of issues, risk and crises can mitigate threats and
leverage opportunities. Organisations need to earn and protect their places
within societies when there are growing expectations about their responsibili-
ties to the communities, employees, the marketplace and the environment.
For the communication manager to be able to manage all problems (wicked
or otherwise) knowledge of, and skills in, issues management and its related
field of CSR are essential, as they provide the strategic foundation for all other
communication efforts. When successfully implemented, they build and protect
corporate reputations and strengthen relationships and trust with stakeholders,
providing a favourable environment for clear, effective and mutually beneficial
communication.
References
Abitbol, A. & Lee, S.Y. (2017). Messages on CSR-dedicated Facebook Pages: What Works and
What Doesn’t. Public Relations Review, 43(4), 796–808.
Australian Government (2018a). Modern Slavery Act 2018. Retrieved from https://www.
legislation.gov.au/Details/C2018A00153
——— (2018b). Tackling Wicked Problems: A Public Policy Perspective. Retrieved from
https://www.apsc.gov.au/tackling-wicked-problems-public-policy-perspective
Australian Human Rights Commission. (2008). Corporate Social Responsibility and Human Rights.
Australian Human Rights Commission Retrieved from https://www.humanrights.gov.au/
our-work/corporate-social-responsibility-human-rights
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 85
Bradsher, K. (2019). Hong Kong’s Approach to Protesters: No More Concessions. New York
Times (19 July). Retrieved from www.nytimes.com/2019/07/19/world/asia/hong-kong-
protests-carrie-lam.html
Cag, D. (2019). 11 Amazing Examples of Disruptive Technology, Richtopia. Retrieved from
https://richtopia.com/emerging-technologies/11-disruptive-technology-examples
Charity Commission (2019). Oxfam GB: Summary of Inquiry Findings and Conclusions. Charity
Commission for England and Wales. Retrieved from www.gov.uk/government/publications/
charity-inquiry-oxfam-gb
Christensen, C. (2019). Disruptive Innovation. Retrieved from http://claytonchristensen.com/
key-concepts/
Converse (2018). Converse Pride Collection. Retrieved from www.converse.com.au/unleashed/
article/converse-pride-collection/
Coombs, W.T. (2012). Ongoing Crisis Communication: Planning, Managing, and Responding
(3rd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
——— (2013). Crisis and Crisis Management. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public
Relations (pp. 217–220). Thousand Oaks, SA: SAGE Publications.
——— (2017). Crisis Public Relations Management. In R. Tench & L. Yeomans (eds), Exploring
Public Relations: Global Strategic Communication (4th edn) (pp. 343–361). Harlow: Pearson
Education Ltd.
——— (2018). Ongoing Crisis Communication: Planning, Managing and Responding (5th edn).
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
——— & Holladay. S.J. (2018). Social Issue Qua Wicked Problems. Journal of Communication
Management, 22(1), 79–95.
——— Holladay, S.J. & Tachkova, E. (2019). Crisis Communication, Risk Communication, and
Issues Management. In B.R. Brunner (ed.), Public Relations Theory: Application and Under-
standing (pp. 31–48). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley & Sons.
Crable, R.E. & Vibbert, S.L. (1985). Managing Issues and Influencing Public Policy. Public Rela-
tions Review, 11(2), 3–16.
Deloitte (2015). A Crisis of Confidence. Retrieved from www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/
us/Documents/risk/us-aers-global-cm-survey-report.pdf
——— (2018). Progress, Prospects and Impact: How business is preparing for the Modern Slavery Act.
The 2018 Annual Review of the State of CSR in Australia and New Zealand. Retrieved from
https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/nz/Documents/risk/2018_state-csr-
report-final.pdf
——— (2019). Stronger, Fitter, Better: Crisis Management for the Resilient Enterprise,
Retrieved from www2.deloitte.com/uk/en/pages/risk/articles/2018-global-crisis-management-
survey.html
Du, S., Bhattacharya, C.B. & Sen, S. (2010), Maximizing Business Returns to Corporate Social
Responsibility (CSR): The Role of CSR Communication. International Journal of Manage-
ment Reviews, 12(1), 8–19.
Friedman, M. (1970). The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits. The New
York Times Magazine (13 September). Retrieved from https://graphics8.nytimes.com/
packages/pdf/business/miltonfriedman1970.pdf
86 Foundations and the working environment
Garriga, E. & Melé, D. (2013). Corporate Social Responsibility Theories: Mapping the Territo-
ries. In A.C. Michalos & D.C. Potts (eds), Citation Classics from the Journal of Business Ethics
(pp. 69–96). Dordrecht: Springer.
Godoy, M. (2014). In Europe, Ugly Sells in the Produce Aisle, The Salt, NPR. Retrieved from
www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/12/09/369613561/in-europe-ugly-sells-in-the-
produce-aisle
Golob, U., Verk, N., Ellerup-Nielsen, A., Thomsen, C., Elving, W. J. & Podnar, K. (2017). The
Communicative Stance of CSR: Reflections on the Value of CSR Communication. Corporate
Communications: An International Journal, 22(2), 166–177.
Google (2019). Our Operations Are Designed to Get the Most Out of Technology, Without Using More
Resources. Retrieved from https://sustainability.google/environment/
Heath, R. L. (1997). Strategic Issues Management: Organizations and Public Policy Changes.
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
——— (2009). Strategic Issues Management: Organizations and Public Policy Challenges
(2nd edn). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
——— (2013). Issues Management. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public Relations
(pp. 496–498). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
——— (2018). Strategic Issues Management: Organizations Operating in Rhetorical Arenas. In
Ø. Ihlen & R.L. Heath (eds), The Handbook of Organizational Rhetoric and Communication
(pp. 385–399). Hoboken, NJ: Wiley & Sons.
ISO (n.d.). ISO 26000 Social Responsibility. Retrieved from www.iso.org/iso-26000-social-
responsibility.html
Issues Management Council (IMC) (n.d. (a)). Professional Standards. Retrieved from https://issue
management.org/learnmore/professional-standards/
——— (n.d. (b)), Issue Management Defined. Retrieved from https://issuemanagement.org/
learnmore/clarification-of-terms/
Jaques, T. (2012). Is Issue Management Evolving or Progressing Towards Extinction? Public
Communication Review, 2(1), 35–44.
——— (2016). Crisis Proofing: How to Save Your Company from Disaster. South Melbourne: Oxford
University Press.
Johnston, J. (2016). Public Relations and the Public Interest, Routledge: New York.
Jones, B.L. & Chase, W.H. (1979). Managing Public Policy Issues. Public Relations Review, 5(2),
3–23.
Katsonis, M. (2019). What’s So Wicked About Wicked Problems. The Mandarin (13 May).
Retrieved from www.themandarin.com.au/108345-wicked-problem/
Kuo, L. & Yu, V. (2019). Carrie Lam Says extradition Bill Is ‘Dead’ But Will Not Withdraw
It. The Guardian (9 July). Retrieved from www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/09/hong-
kong-carrie-lam-says-extradition-bill-is-dead-but-stops-short-of-withdrawal
Lee, D. (2018). Girls Should Be Equal to Boys in Advertising (Kelloggs Nutrigrain—That’s the
Problem). Change.org. Retrieved from www.change.org/p/kellogg-girls-should-be-equal-
to-boys-in-advertising-kelloggs-nutrigrain-that-s-the-problem
Lemert, J.B., Mitzman, B.N., Seither, M.A., Cook, R.H. & Hackett, R. (1977). Journalists and
Mobilizing Information. Journalism Quarterly, 54(4), 721–726.
Issues, risk, crises and corporate social responsibility 87
Mackey, S. (2014). Virtue Ethics, CSR and ‘Corporate Citizenship’. Journal of Communication
Management, 18(2), 131-145.
Martin, L. (2019). Review Calls for Sugar Labels to Show Images of Teaspoons of Sugar. The
Guardian Australia (20 August). Retrieved from www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/
aug/20/review-calls-for-sugar-labels-to-show-images-of-teaspoons-of-sugar
Meade, A. (2019). ‘Waves of Fury’: The Backlash that Led Advertisers to Desert Alan Jones. The
Guardian Australia (24 August). Retrieved from www.theguardian.com/media/2019/aug/24/
waves-of-fury-the-backlash-that-led-advertisers-to-desert-alan-jones
Passion Lilie. (2019). About Us. Retrieved from https://passionlilie.com/pages/about-us
Propper, S. (2019). Here Are the Companies that Use Social Media Best for Sustainability
Marketing. GreenBiz (1 February). Retrieved from www.greenbiz.com/article/here-are-
companies-use-social-media-best-sustainability-marketing
Public Affairs Council (n.d.). Issues Management. Retrieved from https://pac.org/issues_management
Schooley, S. (2019). What is Corporate Social Responsibility? Business News Daily (22 April).
Retrieved from www.businessnewsdaily.com/4679-corporate-social-responsibility.html
Swerling, G. (2019). Charity Whistleblowing Surges in Wake of Oxfam Scandal, Charity
Commission Says. The Telegraph (4 July). Retrieved from www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/
07/04/charity-whistleblowing-surges-wake-oxfam-scandal-charity-commission/
Tench, R., Verc̆ic̆, D., Zerfass, A., Moreno, A. & Verhoeven, P. (2017). Communication Excellence:
How to Develop, Manage and Lead Exceptional Communications. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
The Walt Disney Company. (2017). Corporate Social Responsibility Update 2017. Retrieved from
https://thewaltdisneycompany.com/app/uploads/2017disneycsrupdate.pdf
Toshiba Global (2019). CSR Management. Retrieved from www.toshiba.co.jp/csr/en/csr_
management/management.htm
United Nations Global Compact (2020). The World’s Largest Corporate Sustainability Initiative.
Retrieved from www.unglobalcompact.org
United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (n.d.). The Sustainable Development Agenda.
Retrieved from www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/development-agenda/
WHO (World Health Organization) (2019). Risk Communication. Retrieved from www.who.int/
risk-communication/background/en/
World Vision. (2020). Corporate Partnerships. Retrieved from www.worldvision.com.au/corporate-
partnerships/our-partners
Chapter 4
88
Ethical and legal practice 89
You may notice that in that last sentence we refer to professionals, rather than
practitioners. This is done deliberately. While there is much debate as to whether
or not the communication industry can be called a profession, we argue that
there is always a need for practitioners to operate professionally. By this we
mean that acting professionally involves maintaining high levels of specialist
knowledge and skill, performing a service of value to society and upholding the
law and high standards of ethical behaviour—regardless of whether the individ-
ual is a member of an industry association or not.
What does all of this mean for the communication practitioner? What
ethical and legal standards are expected of them professionally, and where
do those standards come from? In this chapter, we explore current thinking
behind strategic communication and PR ethics and the codes of conduct that
guide practice. But we’ll also take a look at the theoretical side of ethics, which
will help explain how different approaches guide our thinking. This will hope-
fully help you interpret that uneasy sensation you feel when something just
doesn’t seem right and help guide your ethical decision-making. The chapter
then turns to the legal obligations facing the communication practitioner,
giving overviews of key legislation that impacts on practice, including contract,
defamation, copyright and privacy law.
An overview of ethics
Ethics is a branch of philosophical study that considers ‘what ought to be the
grounds and principles for right and wrong human behaviour’ (Johannesen,
Valde & Whedbee 2008, p. 265). Often described as what is right, good, fair
or just, ethics places an additional responsibility on us to not simply do what
is convenient and easy. Ethics goes beyond what is required by the law. Some-
thing may be legal, but not necessarily ethical. For example, think about two
people who share a joint bank account, where the rules of the account mean
that either person can withdraw cash without the permission of the other. If, in
a heated argument, one of the account holders withdraws all of the money, that
would be legal. However, it would not generally be considered ethical.
Let’s consider the same principle at an organisational level. During 2018
and 2019, the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannua-
tion and Financial Services Industry investigated the Australian banking system
90 Foundations and the working environment
Figure 4.1 Ethics is the study of principles that determine whether human behaviour
can be judged as right or wrong. Photo by Tumisu, Pixabay.
Ethical and legal practice 91
debate about communication ethics, here they will be treated as part of the
overall picture of ethical practice. While advances in technology have provided
new techniques for communicating, the principles underpinning communica-
tion ethics remain solid. New ethical challenges are constantly arising—for
example, as technological developments such as machine learning challenge
the way we collect and use information (see Chapter 5 for further examples).
But this is why it is important to understand the foundational principles of
ethics, which can be applied to these new situations and guide communication
practitioners through the quagmire of contemporary communication ethics.
The codes and the procedures for the handling of ethics complaints for the
PRIA and PRINZ are on their websites. Every member of both associations is
required to agree to abide by the respective codes of ethics. PRIA members are
also required to agree to accepting any findings of an independent inquiry. This
technically allows the PRIA to publicly announce and publicise ethics findings.
Professional associations also encourage continuing ethics education through
publications, seminars and the accreditation of tertiary PR and communication
courses. Members of the PRIA, more specifically, are encouraged to display the
Code of Ethics, attach it to proposals, educate their staff and report cases of
unethical behaviour.
The PRIA also has another code, which addresses issues for Registered
Consultancy Groups. Consultancies can join the PRIA as organisational
members rather than as individuals, and this code is designed to address the
94 Foundations and the working environment
If you take a closer look at the codes of ethics of the professional asso-
ciations, you probably won’t be surprised by much if any of the content. Of
course, you would expect practitioners to tell the truth, be fair and do no harm
to others. Your family, your education and your community have led you to
understand that these are the ethical standards guiding most people in a civil
society. To a certain extent, you will already have an inherent knowledge of
ethical ‘rules’ and can sense when something may not be quite right.
This perspective of ethics as ‘rules’, or a type of duty to society, comes
from the ethical approach known as deontology. The word ‘deontologi-
cal’ derives from the Greek for ‘that which is binding’. This perspective
says you are duty-bound to act in a certain way, irrespective of whether the
Ethical and legal practice 95
One area in which this is clearly demonstrated is the action of CSR and
CSR communication, as discussed in Chapter 3.
Not surprisingly, utilitarianism is not free from criticism either. Some
believe that the concept of the ends justifying the means is too simplistic. For
example, should your corporation participate in philanthropy—handing money
over to those in need in society? Or should it spend the money producing a
better product that would yield a greater good not only for the organisation
but for society?
FaCT CheCk
Consider a situation in a workplace crisis where you are asked to delay
revealing some news in order to avoid community panic. You are told
that, once controls have been put in place, the public can be made
aware but, until then, it would be dangerous to say anything. when
confronted by an unrelenting media pack, would you mislead or lie to
them if required? reflect on how you came to your decision.
Ethical and legal practice 99
Waller says that ‘you can’t tell whether an act is right or wrong just by
observing the act itself; instead, you must look at the person performing the
act’ (2008, p. 103). So, rather than focusing on the act or the consequences, as
in the two previous approaches, virtue theory focuses on the character of the
actor. The virtuous person is the one who consistently does right acts for
the right motives. It’s not just about doing the right act, but about doing the
right act with the right motivation.
Virtue theory has its genesis in the writings and teaching of the ancient
Greek philosopher Aristotle, who talks about the virtuous person as sitting
between two extremes or two vices—the vice of excess and the vice of deficit
(Neher & Sandin 2007). He argues that there is a ‘golden mean’ between excess
and deficit which can be determined by reason. For example, he lists courage
as a virtue, sitting between an excess, recklessness, and a deficit, cowardice.
Another virtue is self-control. While we can see that self-indulgence is an
extreme to be avoided, Aristotle argues that, equally, self-denial should also be
avoided. It’s about finding the ‘golden mean’ or the balance—and we do that
through reason (Neher & Sandin 2007).
The main criticism of this ethical approach is that virtues do not provide
the guidance that other ethical principles do. How do we determine what a
virtue is? Even though Aristotle says this can be ascertained through reason,
he agrees that ‘it is no easy task to be good. For in everything it is no easy
task to find the middle’ (Aristotle 2009, p. 36). He stresses that it is not just
important to do the right action, ‘but to do this to the right person, to the
right extent, at the right time, with the right motive, and in the right way’
(2009, p. 36).
Virtue theory is not incompatible with either consequentialist or duty-
based ethics. All three approaches discussed here are useful to the practitioner
questioning the ethics of any situation.
Ethical decision-making
Strategic communication and PR professionals are often confronted with
complex situations in which the ‘right’ ethical approach is unclear. An ethical
dilemma is one in which a choice needs to be made against competing
Ethical and legal practice 101
principles, values, interests and priorities, sometimes with all options being less
than desirable. While the philosophical approaches of duty, utility and virtue
may be of some assistance in this, other more practical processes have been
suggested for ethical decision-making.
Parsons outlines five fundamental principles for behaving ethically: veracity,
non-maleficence, beneficence, confidentiality and fairness (2016, p. 18). Based
on those principles, she poses the following questions that can be used by indi-
viduals and teams reflecting on the ethics of a communication task or campaign
and assist them in making a decision:
These questions provide a good start to identifying and defining what the
ethical dilemma is—an essential step towards finding an appropriate solution.
From there, however, there are further considerations as to what factors may
influence the decision, who will be impacted by the decision, and which of our
stated values and principles are relevant to the situation. Two key processes
that can be used to assist in working through ethical dilemmas are the Potter
Box and the Ethical Decision-Making Guide of the Public Relations Society of
America (PRSA 2019). Figure 4.2 presents summaries of both of those models,
showing the similarities in the methods.
Each of the methods consists of stepping through a number of stages,
reflecting on different elements that can influence decision-making. The Potter
Box is designed in quadrants that can be used in a group or individual situa-
tion to brainstorm ideas relating to the situation, the values of the individual
or the organisation (such as professional and moral values), the principles that
are relevant to this situation (such as using deontological or utilitarian princi-
ples), and the existence of loyalties to key stakeholders (Christians et al. 2017).
The PRSA framework uses a list of clearly established and agreed values and
principles to move through a similar process.
102 Foundations and the working environment
Figure 4.2 Ethical decision-making models: Potter Box and the PRSA Framework.
Source: adapted from Christians et al. (2017); PRSA (2019).
Ethical and legal practice 103
Contracts
Contracts typically form a large part of the administrative work in both agency
and in-house roles. Every practitioner will at least have a personal employment
contract that lists their obligations in their workplace. For agency workers,
clients will also enter into contracts regarding the specific work they are seeking.
Both agency and in-house practitioners may also need to draw up contracts
with external specialists, service providers and suppliers for work that they need
to outsource. So it’s important to think about both sides of the contract—that
is, the provision of services and the hiring of services.
Essentially, a contract is an agreement that outlines the obligations of all
parties in the collaboration. While it is best to have a professional contract in
writing, they can exist in oral or implied forms or a combination of these ways.
For a contract to be valid, however, it generally needs to contain the elements
in Table 4.2.
For regular activities pre-designed contracts may be all that’s needed,
but these should be checked by a contract specialist. It’s worth checking the
internet for generic contract templates, as many can be found online, such as
contracts for one-off photography or graphic design services. These include
details such as:
Professional negligence
Strategic communication and PR professionals are engaged for their expertise
in the field and this brings a requirement that they undertake their duties with
due care and skill. An action for damages can be brought against any profes-
sional who acts negligently. This does not mean that a successful outcome
must be guaranteed, as there are often other factors that can impact on the
Ethical and legal practice 105
all professionals need to ensure that they act with care and diligence, only
offer advice that they are qualified to give and minimise risk-taking where
clients are involved.
Consumer protection
Work in strategic communication and PR often requires building relations
with consumers, usually performed in collaboration with the marketing team.
Awareness of laws that specifically deal with consumer protection is therefore
essential. In New Zealand, consumers are protected by the Fair Trading Act
1986 and the Consumer Guarantees Act 1993. In Australia, the Competition and
Consumer Act 2010 (CCA) and the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), which is
Schedule 2 of the Act, protect consumers from corporations that are misleading
or deceptive in their conduct and/or representation. These laws are adminis-
tered by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. The CCA
is Australian Commonwealth legislation that applies to corporations only, and
state and territory governments have therefore enacted their own consumer
protection laws to cover other dealers, often under the label of ‘Fair Trading’
laws. To ensure some national consistency, however, under each state’s legis-
lation the ACL applies as law within their jurisdiction also. For example, in
South Australia the Act is the Fair Trading Act 1987, which is administered by
the Consumer and Business Services section in the Attorney-General’s Depart-
ment. Check the appropriate legislation and website in your own jurisdiction.
Consumer protection laws at national (section 18 of the ACL) and state
levels prohibit misleading and deceptive conduct—even conduct that is likely
to mislead or deceive. For communication and PR professionals, this creates
the need to ensure that content creation and message development include fair
representations of the goods or services being promoted. The legislation does
not define the terms ‘misleading’ and ‘deceptive’, but case law (see Weitmann
v Katies Ltd (1977)) generally accepts that to mislead means to ‘lead astray in
action or conduct, to lead into error, to cause to err’ and to deceive means
to ‘cause to believe what is false’. The legislation says ‘mere puffery’ would
generally not be considered misleading, as the claims would be so fanciful or
superlative that nobody would be reasonably misled by them. The caution here
for communication professionals is that, if in any doubt, it is worth seeking
Ethical and legal practice 107
advice before publishing. Section 29 of the ACL also provides more specific
detail and examples of false and misleading representation.
Intellectual property
Intellectual property (IP) is defined by IP Australia as ‘property of your mind
or proprietary knowledge’ (IP Australia n.d.). Generally speaking, IP laws
involve the protection of rights concerning creative outputs and efforts. They
can be very complex, but there are two main areas relevant for communication
practitioners: copyright and trade marks.
Copyright
Copyright law protects the expression of ideas—not the ideas themselves. That
is, it exists once the idea is expressed in one or more specific formats listed
in the legislation. The relevant laws are Australia’s Copyright Act 1968, New
Zealand’s Copyright Act 1994 and amendments that have been made to both.
Unlike trade marks (which are explained next), there is no requirement to
register copyright in Australia or New Zealand (whereas copyright law in the
USA calls for IP to be registered). The protections exist as soon as the idea is
expressed in ‘works’ that are literary, dramatic, musical or artistic, or in ‘subject
matter other than works’, which include sound recordings, cinematographic
films, television and sound broadcasts and published editions of works. The
works must be original but they do not need to be of literary or artistic merit to
qualify for copyright protection.
In fact, copyright has been found
to be included in a phone book
listing, a list of numbers and even
in a colour. In Australia, copyright
expires after 70 years; it depends
on the type of work as to whether
this is after it was published or
after the author dies. After that
time it is said to move into the Figure 4.3 The absence of the copyright
‘public domain’ and may be used symbol does NOT mean that the material is
without permission. in the public domain.
108 Foundations and the working environment
Holding copyright gives the owner (usually the creator of the work,
but rights can be transferred to another) certain rights to reproduce, adapt,
broadcast, publish, perform and/or distribute the work, or to sell or license
the copyright to another party. Conversely, if copyright is not owned by an
individual, these actions could result in an infringement. There are some
subtle differences in the rights that are held and the legislation should
therefore be checked for specific cases. Some subject matter other than
works may have multiple elements that are covered by copyright, such as
a television broadcast that could have separate copyrights over the script,
the music, the story, design elements and other factors. Whether you are
protecting your own copyright or seeking permission to use the creative
works of others, you need to understand how the law applies in each situa-
tion. This is equally pertinent to the use of creative material in online/social
media platforms.
Trade marks
Australian law defines a trade mark as
New Zealand’s Trade Marks Act 2002 describes trade marks as ‘any sign
capable of (i) being represented graphically; and (ii) distinguishing the goods
or services of one person from those of another person’. A trade mark can be a
logo or slogan—such as Nike’s swoosh symbol and its ‘just do it’ slogan—but
it can also include a ‘letter, number, word, phrase, sound, smell, shape, picture,
movement, aspect of packaging, or a combination of these’ (IP Australia 2019).
The company’s name, or a domain name, however, are not trade marks and
need to be registered separately.
While it is possible to hold a trade mark without registering it, it is more
difficult to defend against any infringements. By registering a trade mark, you
have exclusive rights to its use. For a trade mark to be registered, it must be
distinctive, describe the specific goods or services to be covered by the trade
mark, and specify the ‘class’ of goods or services to which they belong. The
trade mark will only be granted for the class or classes that are nominated
within the application. So, for example, a trade mark registered for clothing
will not prevent another company using a similar trade mark for a different
type of product. A trade mark registration may also be removed if it is not
actively used.
Defamation
The laws of defamation attempt to balance the rights of people to speak
freely with the rights of people to protect their reputation. The principles
of defamation are similar across all jurisdictions. All states in Australia have
separate defamation laws, which were (for the most part) made uniform in
2006. New Zealand has the Defamation Act 1992, which is similar to the
Australian laws. For a defamation to have occurred, three factors need to
be evidenced:
110 Foundations and the working environment
1. the material was published in any form—that includes in hard copy, online
or broadcast
2. a person was identified
3. the material conveyed a meaning which tends to:
– lower that person’s reputation
– leads people to ridicule, avoid or despise that person, or
– injures that person’s reputation in a business, trade or profession.
For the material to be defamatory, it need only suggest or imply defama-
tory issues; it does not need to expressly state them (Butler & Roderick 2015,
pp. 33–36).
A claim for defamation can be defended by the publisher of the material
under a series of defences, the primary ones being:
• that the material was substantially true (with the onus of proof on the
publisher)
• that it was fair comment or opinion (rather than stated fact)
• the publisher was covered by qualified privilege (which has developed into
a media-related defence)
• fair report of proceedings of public concern (e.g. courts).
One consideration of defamation is that, even though a publication may
have been defamatory, if the content has not reached a wide or important
audience then it may be best to simply ignore it. If legal action is instigated,
there is the potential for the material to reach an even greater audience through
the publicity, further damaging the reputation of the individual. The phenome-
non of drawing increased attention to something that you are trying to supress
has become known as the ‘Streisand effect’ following an effort by singer Barbra
Streisand to have a photo removed from a website. The photograph was one in
a series used to highlight coastal erosion, but in doing so it revealed her home.
Prior to her legal action, the photograph had only been downloaded six times,
but the publicity surrounding the case drew hundreds of thousands of people to
the website. Streisand also lost the legal case (Masnick 2015).
Defamation laws apply equally to all publications, including social media.
A case may be brought against someone who has published a potentially defam-
atory remark in a Facebook post or a tweet, for example. A more contentious
area of the law, however, relates to responsibility for the comments posted
Ethical and legal practice 111
R
One of the most highly publicised defamation cases in recent years was that of
actor Rebel Wilson’s case against Bauer Media. Wilson asserted that her repu-
tation had been damaged due to claims made in a popular tabloid magazine
that she had lied about her personal details and history. The court found in her
favour on the basis that the information published was not true. The wide reach
of the publication was also considered to be a factor in the judge’s decision.
While the initial record payout awarded to Wilson was later reduced signifi-
cantly, she was reported as saying that ‘at the end of the day the jury restored
my reputation, I’ve moved on personally and professionally’ (Byrne 2018).
Spam
Spam presents a field of consumer law that is important for the communi-
cation professional and the limitations of their practice. The Spam Act 2003
regulates the sending of ‘unsolicited commercial electronic messages’ (spam).
112 Foundations and the working environment
The legislation covers emails, phone calls, text and video messages to mobile
phones, and instant messaging; however, it was written before the common use
of bots for marketing purposes, so caution should be exercised and the intent of
the law considered when using any new technology. In Australia, the legislation
is enforced by the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA),
which publishes useful guides for industry.
Section 6 of the Act outlines exactly what a commercial electronic message
is; in general terms, however, it is one that either advertises, promotes or offers
to supply goods or services, land or business opportunities, or assists others to
dishonestly obtain property belonging to another person.
According to the Act, commercial electronic messages must:
The best way for organisations to protect themselves against being guilty
of spamming is to ensure that they have consent to contact the individuals
and organisations with whom they are communicating. Generally speaking,
by signing up to a mailing list or subscription service, the recipient expresses
consent to receive that information—such as when you’re asked to give your
email to a clothing retailer at the point of purchase. However, in some cases
permission can be inferred based on a relationship between two parties. For
example, if the organisation deals with an individual on an ongoing basis, then
consent to receive messages may be inferred. Additionally, an organisation
can send a commercial electronic message to an email address that has been
published elsewhere. But in both situations, the message must relate directly
to the relationship that you already have or to the recipient’s line of work
(Australian Communications and Media Authority n.d.).
The organisation must keep records of who has consented in case they are
called upon to provide it as evidence. Using a double opt-in process—whereby
a consumer’s initial consent to opt-in is followed up with a message asking
them to confirm their consent—is also a good practice for organisations.
While public directories can be used to contact people with marketing
messages, an organisation sending messages needs to ensure that there is an
Ethical and legal practice 113
obvious and strong connection between the individual they are sending to and
the product or service that is the subject of the message. In these cases, the
message must be sent to a specific person and not to a generic email address or
contact number.
Exemptions are provided in the Act for registered charities, educational
institutions (in some cases), government bodies and political parties. It is
also possible to contact recipients with factual messages that are not deemed
‘commercial information’, such as product recalls.
Privacy
Closely related to the consent elements within the Spam Act 2003 is the law
of privacy, although this also extends into broader areas of communication
activity. The relevant legislation in this area in Australia is the Privacy Act
1988 and The Privacy Amendment (Enhancing Privacy Protection) Act 2012. The
Acts apply to all businesses and not-for-profits that have an annual turnover
of more than $3 million, although they can also apply to smaller businesses,
particularly in the area of the provision of health services.
At the core of the Privacy Act are the Australian Privacy Principles (APPs),
which guide private and public sector organisations regarding the handling of
‘personal’, ‘sensitive’, and ‘health’ information. This specifies that:
The thirteen principles in the APPs can be found on the website of the
Office of the Australian Information Commissioner (OAIC), divided into five
categories: consideration, collection, dealing with, integrity of, and access to
personal information (OAIC 2019b). The principles describe the standards,
rights and obligations concerning:
Conclusion
Poor ethical and legal practices can threaten the reputation of the strategic
communication and PR industry. As you start your professional career, it is
essential that you recognise and comprehend the standards of behaviour
expected of you so you can represent the industry well and contribute to
your organisation, to your clients and to society. A clear set of personal and
professional values will build your reputation and make you stand out in
the crowd. This chapter has given you a start to building your knowledge
of the ethical challenges you may face, why they are problematic and how
you can reflect on them to produce sound decisions in the face of uncertainty.
Industry codes of ethics are important, but you need to understand how they
have emerged and how to deal with dilemmas that go beyond their guidance.
The chapter has also given you a start to understanding some key legal
obligations and responsibilities that you will face as a practitioner. An under-
standing of the fundamentals will alert you to potential problem areas and help
avoid legal challenges. Expertise can always be accessed if needed. Remember,
the laws both protect your rights and outline your responsibilities.
Ethical and legal practice 115
References
Aristotle (2009). The Nicomachean Ethics. (D. Ross, Trans.) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Retrieved from https://epdf.pub/the-nicomachean-ethics.html.
Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) (n.d.). Avoiding Sending Spam.
Canberra: Australian Government. Retrieved from www.acma.gov.au/avoid-sending-spam
Bowen, S.A. (2016). Clarifying Ethics Terms in Public Relations from A to V, Authenticity to
Virtue. Public Relations Review, 42(4), 564–572.
Butler, D. & Rodrick, S. (2012). Australian Media Law (4th edn). Sydney: Thomson Reuters.
Byrne, E. (2018). Rebel Wilson’s Legal Battle Ends as High Court Rejects Appeal over Defama-
tion Payout. ABC News (16 November). Retrieved from www.abc.net.au/news/2018-11-16/
rebel-wilson-loses-high-court-bid/10503644
Cave, A. (2017). Deal That Undid Bell Pottinger: Inside Story of the South Africa Scandal.
The Guardian (6 September). Retrieved from www.theguardian.com/media/2017/sep/05/
bell-pottingersouth-africa-pr-firm
Christians, C.G., Fackler, M., Richardson, K.B., Kreshel, P.J. & Woods, R.H. (2017). Media
Ethics: Cases and Moral Reasoning (10th edn). New York, NY: Routledge.
Harrington, J. & James, S.B. (2017). Bell Pottinger Agrees Six-point Plans as Lawyers Say Economic
Apartheid Campaign ‘Arguably Breached Ethical Principles’. PR Week (4 September).
Retrieved from www.prweek.com/article/1443541/bell-pottinger-agrees-six-point-plan-
lawyers-say-economic-apartheid-campaign-arguably-breached-ethical-principles
Hayne, K.M. (2018). Executive Summary, Interim Report: Royal Commission into Misconduct in the
Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry. Retrieved from https://financial
services.royalcommission.gov.au/Documents/interim-report/interim-report-exec-summary.pdf
——— (2019). Final Report: Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation
and Financial Services Industry (Vol. 1). Retrieved from www.royalcommission.gov.au/sites/
default/files/2019-02/fsrc-volume-1-final-report.pdf
IP Australia (2019). Understanding IP. Canberra: Australian Government. Retrieved from
www.ipaustralia.gov.au/understanding-ip
——— (2019). Understanding Trade Marks. Canberra: Australian Government. Retrieved from
www.ipaustralia.gov.au/trade-marks/understanding-trade-marks
Johannesen, R.L., Valde, K.S. & Whedbee, K.E. (2008). Ethics in Human Communication
(6th edn). Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press.
Johnston, C. (2017). Bell Pottinger Expelled from Trade Body for South African Campaign. BBC
News (4 September). Retrieved from www.bbc.com/news/business-41151361
Kim, S. (2013). Astroturfing. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public Relations (pp. 954–956).
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc.
Masnick, M. (2015). For 10 Years Everyone’s Been Using ‘The Streisand Effect’ Without Paying;
Now I’m Going To Start Issuing Takedowns. TechDirt (15 January). Retrieved from www.
techdirt.com/articles/20150107/13292829624/10-years-everyones-been-using-streisand-
effect-without-paying-now-im-going-to-start-issuing-takedowns.shtml
McElreath, M. (1997). Managing Systematic and Ethical Public Relations Campaigns (2nd edn).
London: Brown & Benchmark.
116 Foundations and the working environment
working in a
media-dominated world
117
118 Foundations and the working environment
(Post-)Converging media
This era of media has confirmed the end of a time in which different mediums
existed in isolation. These were once viewed as single ‘silos’—individual
mediums that operated and were used separately from each other. Take, for
example, TV—watched only on television sets; newspapers—read only as printed
matter; books—read only in bound volumes. Now, those who use media—and
Working in a media-dominated world 119
These are all answers only data can give you (Dietrich 2019). In measur-
ing your data you will automatically use research and evaluation techniques.
These can range from using our own evaluation tools (such as Hootsuite’s
social media monitoring), which can be done in-house, or outsourcing to
big media intelligence and data technology companies such as iSentia. Data
analytics and social listening are now both big business (there are many
companies that do this work) and good for business (it affects your bottom
line and your relationships with your publics). We will consider how to use
data and listen to audience feedback in the next chapter.
122 Foundations and the working environment
Figure 5.2 TikTok used this image on its COVID-19 information page. Source:
TikTok (2020).
The rise in mobile phone usage, the mobility of media and the popularity
of apps show clearly that what changes are not our cultural practices, but the
delivery systems that bring them to us. For example, we still listen to music, but
the delivery of the music changes: from radio, to vinyl, to cassettes, to CDs, to
MP3s, to Spotify or other streaming services (and radio and vinyl are back in
vogue again). So, in short:
124 Foundations and the working environment
Delivery technologies come and go all the time, but media persist as layers
within an ever more complicated information and entertainment stratum . . .
once a medium establishes itself as satisfying some core human demand, it
continues to function within the larger system of communication options.
(Jenkins 2006, p. 14)
In only a few years, our converged media culture has become about enter-
tainment, economic, social and political exchanges; how we understand just
about every part of the world. Figure 5.3 illustrates some of the major develop-
ments that have become central to global media activity over this period. And,
as smartphones and other mobile devices are rarely turned off in the modern
media economy, so too the work of those employed in this digital economy has
become a virtually 24-hour-a-day industry.
1. Universal literacy: a familiarity with using basic digital tools such as office
productivity software, image manipulation, cloud-based apps and content,
and web content authoring tools.
2. Creative literacy: includes all aspects of universal literacy and adds more
challenging technical skills that lead to the production of richer content,
including video editing, audio creation and editing, animation, an under-
standing of computational device hardware, and programming—along with
digital citizenship and copyright knowledge.
Working in a media-dominated world 125
Figure 5.3 Global media since the smartphone. Source: adapted from OfCom
(2018) original graphic (UK stats); Deloitte (2019b) (Australian stats); Paul (2020).
Infographic courtesy of Joel Hawkins.
126 Foundations and the working environment
If universal literacy is the basic stuff that everybody should have (hence the
name), we can determine that, as professionals, we need to do more. In fact,
strategic communicators need to combine both the other two fields: creative
literacy calls for specialist media knowledge and skills, infused with innovation,
originality and a touch of the artistic; disciplinary literacy calls for an understand-
ing of specialist fields, with the capability of interpreting and translating these
fields to both the broader community and targeted, niche audiences. Creative
literacy needs to be something the communication and PR professional builds
on for life. Disciplinary literacy can change, as workers move from industry to
industry. For example, you may work in the field of science in one communica-
tion role and the travel industry in another, each calling on specific knowledge
of that particular field.
The World Economic Forum (WEF) has identified creativity as an essen-
tial component of media literacy for the 2020s (Alexander et al. 2017). This was
highlighted in a report that examined the most important job skills for 2020,
with creativity coming third after problem-solving and critical thinking. The
full list of the WEF’s job skills is shown in Table 5.1.
Creativity is so important because, although machines are taking over so
many human activities and automation is bolstering efficiency, they cannot
replace human imagination. ‘Put another way, embedded in effective digital
literacy training is the spirit of learners as creators. Digital tools themselves are
merely enablers, pushing the envelope of what learners can create’ (Alexander
et al. 2017, p. 2). This is also about convergence cultures at work. Conver-
gence is not about media appliances—rather, it occurs both within individual
consumers and through their social interactions with others, with fragments
of information extracted from within the flow of media and transformed into
something else (Jenkins 2006, p. 4). Digital media literacy experts say it is
how people ‘contribute to the local and global knowledge ecosystem, learning
Working in a media-dominated world 127
2020 2015
1. Complex Problem Solving 1. Complex Problem Solving
2. Critical Thinking 2. Coordinating with Others
3. Creativity 3. People Management
4. People Management 4. Critical Thinking
5. Coordinating with Others 5. Negotiation
6. Emotional Intellience 6. Quality Control
7. Judgment and Decision Making 7. Service Orientation
8. Service Orientation 8. Judgment and Decision Making
9. Negotiation 9. Active Listening
10. Cognitive Flexibilty 10. Creativity
through the act of producing and discussing rich media, applications, and
objects’ (Alexander et al. 2017, p. 2).
The application of this to people moving into the communication industry is
pretty clear. You need to bring to your role both media skills and a critical under-
standing of how they work, and this calls for one other key characteristic of the
media worker for 2020 and beyond—adaptability. The New Media Consortium
points out that digital media literacy calls for more than knowing how to use
mobile devices, software and media-creation tools. It also calls for the capacity
to intuitively adapt and adjust to new digital environments, and to develop habits
that cultivate lifelong learning about media, aiming for a continuous mastery of
new skills. This requires critical judgement in selecting digital tools and eval-
uating how your contribution impacts within the potential reach of your work
(Alexander et al. 2017). Without high-level proficiencies in media production
and a critical understanding of what’s going on in media, you cannot expect to
become good at the job of working in and using media in your professional life.
Some universities have identified the importance of digital media literacy
across the whole student cohort. This has resulted in some excellent online
tools being made available, not just to communication PR and media students,
or even to the student body of the university that developed them, but to
the wider community. These provide some useful open-access resources for
128 Foundations and the working environment
• All Aboard: this is national collaborative project from the Irish higher
education sector. It aims to empower individuals who use technology to
support their work, study or other aspects of living in a digital age.
• Digital Essentials: this is a series of online modules developed by the
University of Queensland, Australia for building digital skills for success in
study and work.
• Domain of One’s Own (DoOO): this is an initiative by the University of
Mary Washington in the USA that provides students’ modules to develop
advanced digital fluency skills.
• 23 Things: this is a self-directed course in digital knowledge run by the
University of Edinburgh, Scotland. It seeks to expose the user to a range
of digital tools for helping with personal and professional development as
a researcher, academic, student or professional.
Emoticons such as ;-) and acronyms such as LOL (‘laughing out loud’—which
has just celebrated its 25th birthday) add useful elements of non-verbal commu-
nication—or annoy people with their overuse. (n.d.)
Working in a media-dominated world 129
Figure 5.4 It’s official! The world loves emojis. Source: adapted from Image by
Pixaline, Pixabay.
A multimedia world
The emoji is an excellent example of how images have taken the place of words.
Text is no longer enough for communication in the 2020s. Media is now over-
whelmingly visual and multimedia. News media outlets work hard to respond
to this demand. For example, The New York Times now publishes at least fifteen
multimedia pieces per day (McCoy 2017). In Australia, the ABC and other
media organisations now standardly incorporate text, sound, images and video
in multimedia packages. They also distribute their stories via a range of plat-
forms—so you can get your news via a phone app, on radio, TV, or online; in
real-time or in catch-up. When stories are told and distributed in different
ways, using a range of platforms, it is called a transmedia approach.
Vision rules and this is unlikely to change. What will change is the scope
and variety of ways vision is used. One study predicts that video will account for
more than 80 per cent of all internet traffic by 2022 (Cisco 2019). PR and corpo-
rate communication now de-emphasise text in favour of a more visual approach
(McCoy 2017). But for visuals to work they need to be strong, engaging and
appropriately pitched to your target audience. It’s important, therefore, to have
a visual strategy, and this should be planned around the most appropriate media
package for the platform and audience. Visual communication encompasses
everything from illustration, to graphics, charts, photos, video, GIFs, animation
and, increasingly, virtual reality or augmented reality, or any mixture of these.
For social media, you might lean toward micro-narratives, GIFs and video,
whereas for audiences and industries in which homepage visits are common,
you might beef up your interactive content. And of course, you’ll want to
ensure all your content is mobile-friendly. (McCoy 2017)
Visual content retains audience attention for longer. It is also more easily
understood and shareable. Interactivity, too, grabs and extends audience
engagement. The importance of vision has resulted in a highly specialised
industry, with some creative media agencies focusing on developing visual
content and unpacking complex stories into easily understood visual packages.
Agencies such as Killer Visual Strategies and Visual Capitalist use strong visuals
in many different forms—from infographics to animations—to tell complex
stories. Visual Capitalist says the company ‘exists for one reason—to help make
Working in a media-dominated world 131
this complex world a little easier to understand’, combining big data, visuals
and storytelling.
Their inclusion of big data means that complex data sets can be distilled
into one or more simple images, thus simplifying the information transfer
from producer to consumer. So, for example, topics such as ‘The Geogra-
phy of the World’s Top 50 Billionaires’, ‘Where Investors Put Their Money
in 2018’ or ‘The World’s Largest 30 Economies in 2030’ can be illustrated in a
single infographic or chart. This illustrates what is known as ‘data visualisation’,
described as ‘the process of displaying data/information in graphical charts,
figures and bars’ (Technopedia n.d.). During COVID-19, graphs and info-
graphics were widely used to explain complex concepts and information that
was rapidly changing. We use an infographic from the Australian Government
in Chapter 10. PC Magazine says data visualisation isn’t really as mysterious
as it may seem, even though many users have been reluctant to use the new
tools and technology. ‘It’s really just a general term that applies to any graphic
that explains the significance of a new insight or data set visually rather than
simply numerically’ (Rist 2018). Technically a simple pie chart is data visualisa-
tion. Some of the free access data visualisation tools include Tableau Public and
Tableau Gallery, Google Data Studio and Microsoft Power.
But, of course, not all images come from data. Photographs and video capture
quite different vision and very different experiences to data-driven formats.
For decades images have stopped the world—the moon landing, war atrocities,
human rights movements, political events, sporting moments and so on. And
despite being constantly bombarded with images via social media—yes, we do
love all those puppies and kittens—people are still ready to stop and take notice
of certain ‘great moments in time’. The world was enthralled in March 2019
when the image of New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern was projected
onto the world’s tallest building, Dubai’s Burj Khalifa, following terror attacks
132 Foundations and the working environment
The many beautiful and quirky photographs that were posted now also
appear in Outback Queensland’s blogs and other online media assets. This
approach to content creation and curating is discussed more in Chapter 9.
Vision might rule in multimedia, but audio is also on the rise. Podcasts,
radio and audio books have never been more popular (Edison 2019). While radio
and audio books have a long history of popular use, the podcast is a relative
newcomer to the media world, first launched in 2004 (Watson n.d.). One US
study found that more than half the population in the USA had listened to
podcasts, illustrating how podcasts had ‘crossed into the mainstream’ of media
(Edison 2019). This rise in popularity of the podcast has been attributed to
many causes, including ease of access, mobile capability and the emotional
connection people have to stories. Podcasts are also extremely adaptive:
prevalent in mainstream media, such as the ABC and BBC, widespread in
indie media and also popular with corporates, such as Heineken and General
Motors, for telling owned stories. The range of podcasts is also part of their
appeal, covering just about any subject you can think of—from political satire
and critique, to sport, investigative journalism, true crime, fashion, medita-
tion and business.
Locating and connecting with these two groups isn’t too difficult—some
channels work better for journalists, others more so for influencers. You can
approach them directly via their email or social media; through online services
like Sourcebottle; via some specialist PR and communication agencies such
as HooZu and Hello Social (linking influencers to clients); or by using a
recognised media source such as Margaret Gee’s Australian Media Guide or
Telum Media.
Let’s take a closer look at these two groups.
Influencers
When Jenkins talked of convergence culture in 2006, the word ‘influencer’
as we know it today did not exist. While the term is certainly not new—
in fact its original reference has been traced to ancient descriptions in
astrology—Dictionary.com has only listed the term influencer since 2016
(Solomon n.d.). As lexicographer (dictionary writer) Jane Solomon points
out: ‘The word influencer has been used in English since the mid-1600s,
though of course back then it wasn’t a job title’ (Solomon n.d.). Now the
term is used to describe an individual who influences behaviour and attitudes,
often associated with brand associations and the purchasing of products or
Working in a media-dominated world 135
Figure 5.6 The way the term ‘influencer’ trended upward after 2017.
services. We looked at the word using Google Trends and found that prior
to 2017 there wasn’t much interest in the word at all, as the screenshot in
Figure 5.6 shows.
‘Influencer’ is reasonably synonymous with other job titles such as
brand ambassador, thought leader, knowledge broker, opinion shaper, taste-
maker, SMI (social media influencer) and expert. If you are really interested
in the number of synonyms, you can check out Power Thesaurus, which
lists 88 synonyms for the word influencer! More important than the title,
however, is what influencers can do for the strategic communication profes-
sional. Influencers are connected. They have large or specifically targeted
online followings. They provide what is often considered ‘authentic’ media
material—although as numbers of influencers have grown they have attracted
criticism for their lack of authenticity. This cohort of media workers is so
varied that communication professionals need to be prepared to do their
homework when seeking an influencer’s endorsement—whether for political
leverage, fashion endorsement or sports following. Influencers have expanded
from an organic concept, in which people posted content and others followed
out of fun, to a thriving business of what is now called ‘branded content’
whereby the influencer is paid for promoted mentions. This is explored in
more detail in Chapter 9.
136 Foundations and the working environment
Journalists
The role of the journalist is considerably more established than that of the influ-
encer. Popular culture shows journalists working on newspapers, magazines
Working in a media-dominated world 137
Media tools
You might choose to go with a journalist or influencer, or alternatively approach
your audience directly through your owned social media (or a mix of all three).
Working in a media-dominated world 139
Using the PESO model, you can determine the best options and mix them
up. A wide range of tools and methods are available to reach your audiences,
which incorporate many of the elements we have looked at in this chapter and
elsewhere in the book: multimedia, storytelling and enabling your audience to
co-create using different channels. Although we cannot examine all of these
in this chapter, we will briefly look at three key media tactics (which are also
included alongside a wide suite of tactics in Chapter 9):
• providing an overview for your team of what content needs to get out there
• making sure you keep up regular posts across a range of channels
• ensuring posts are planned ahead (in case you call in sick or take leave)
• allowing you to double up at busy times and use less urgent posts (like
historic or testimonial posts) at quieter times
• targeting your posts to the channels that reach the people you most need
to reach.
140 Foundations and the working environment
You need to fish where there are fish. In social media terms, that means to be
where your audience and community already talk about you, your competitors,
and industry topics, and engaging with them there. (2018)
She provides the following tips for connecting with a social media audience.
• Search. Take your top ten keywords and search for them on Google and
through a social listening tool such as BuzzSumo. Where do conversa-
tions around those topics occur? Look for specific social media responses,
community sites, news articles and blogs.
• Analyse. Google Analytics can provide some metrics for you. Log on and
look at your referral report. Which social channels send you the most traffic?
• Survey. Conduct an audience survey and ask them to share where they get
their information online and which social channels they use.
Figure 5.8 Social media content calendars let you plan your content distribution over
the month. Source: infographic courtesy of Tess Johnston.
Working in a media-dominated world 141
Media releases/alerts
Probably the best known of all media tools, used to connect with the news
media, is the media release. Also called a ‘press’ or ‘news’ release, these announce
the news of the day directly to the news media and other key stakeholders
(such as researchers or government departments). Most large organisations
include media releases on their website, listed under media-dedicated links
such as ‘News’ or ‘Media’. The central rule of producing an effective media
release is to write, where possible, in news style. This means you need to
read and analyse media style so you can pick up the similarities. News stories
strive to answer six basic questions: Who? What? When? Where? Why?
How? (the 5-Ws and H). Ideally, the first four of these will be covered in
the first few paragraphs of a media release. News is usually written using
a style called the inverted pyramid, which prioritises the key points at the
top of the story (at the widest part of the pyramid), followed by the remain-
ing information in descending order of importance. The logic behind this
style is that the newsworthiness of the story is clear from the first paragraph.
From a PR and strategic communication perspective, it means that a well-
written release is more likely to run verbatim or near-verbatim. Quotes are an
important part of a media release, and they should come from someone autho-
rised and senior in your organisation. Some elements of release style include
the following elements:
Media conferences
The media conference (also called a press or news conference or ‘presser’) may
be called for a wide variety of reasons, generally to make a big announcement.
Ideally, in a strategic communication and PR role, you’ll be in a position to
proactively arrange media conferences, with plenty of time to plan and prepare,
and to check that everything is in place. Sometimes, however, a media confer-
ence will be called in haste—for example, to explain a disaster or crisis. All
media conferences are different, so there is no set list of who should be invited
or when to hold them: for instance, a presser called by a state or federal govern-
ment department or emergency service during the bushfires of 2020 will be
different to the many called to update on the COVID-19 pandemic in the same
year; different again to a sporting final like the Australian Open tennis or the
AFL or NBL Grand Final. The invitation list should be sent to journalists and
bloggers/influencers who will be interested in covering the event and, impor-
tantly, to the media outlets that reach your organisation’s target publics.
Media power
The complex and demanding media environment presents a massive amount of
opportunities—it also presents a lot of challenges, such as how to stand out in
Working in a media-dominated world 143
the crowd. Beyond this, however, are the negative, even destructive, elements
of the world of media technology. These include:
• the power held by the major media companies
• privacy issues
• data breaches and cyber security
• trolling
• fake news
• hate speech
• addictive media behaviour
• online bullying.
Scholars and those in public office, such as regulators and politicians, have
become increasingly alert to the challenges of online technology and media
usage, and there are new and emerging laws and regulations being developed
and changing all the time. However, the pace at which media is developing and
changing (think of Lil Miquela, for example) is often too quick for the laws
and regulations to keep up. MIT Technology Review reports that ‘[w]e haven’t
come to grips with what is ethical, let alone with what the laws should be, in
relation to technologies such as social media’ (Wadhwa 2014).
The issue of online news production has become one such legal and regu-
latory challenge as media producers have battled with online giants Google,
Facebook (and others) which aggregate their news stories without paying
for them and unfairly compete for the advertising dollar. In April 2020, after
months of trying to negotiate a voluntary code of conduct with Google and
Facebook, the Australian Government decided it would develop a manda-
tory code to cover the ranking of news content, sharing of data and sharing of
revenue generated from news (Haydar, 2020). The proposal, to be developed
by the Australian Consumer and Competition Commission (ACCC) in draft
form for consultation later in 2020, would be enforced through penalties and
sanctions. The move to force the tech giants to pay for Australian news content
was reported to be ‘the world’s toughest crackdown on the unfair market
dominance of digital platforms’ (Scarr 2020).
Also at the centre of much criticism of online media is the notion of true
participation and participatory culture. Critical scholars say the promise that
144 Foundations and the working environment
Our smartphones track our movements and habits. Our Web searches reveal
our thoughts. With the wearable devices and medical sensors that are being
connected to our smartphones, information about our physiology and health
is also coming into the public domain. Where do we draw the line on what is
legal—and ethical? (Wadya 2014)
be too willing to trust in mathematical models because they believe these will
remove human bias. However, as algorithms replace human processes they are
not held to the same standards and often remain unchecked. As a result, algo-
rithms can be used to decide things like who gets a job interview, who gets
granted parole and who gets a loan—not something you necessarily want left
to a machine (Knight 2017).
Thus, while metrics-driven algorithms provide great opportunities for
the communication and marketing industries in terms of predicting patterns
of behaviour and purchasing, they come with hidden issues. This requires
communication practitioners, who work at the interface of IT and consumer
roles, to keep abreast of what’s going on and to do their best to maintain ethical
practice. Microsoft has developed a simple mnemonic for those working at the
AI interface: FATE (fairness, accountability, transparency, ethics).
Unfortunately, all the data that is stored means, inevitably, that data
breaches sometimes occur, placing the issue of privacy under close scrutiny.
A Facebook breach in September 2018 saw 29 million users’ accounts
impacted as the cyber-attackers used an automated program to move from
one friend to the next (ABC News 2018). Profile details such as birth dates,
employers, education history, religious preference, types of devices used,
pages followed and recent searches and location check-ins were stolen (ABC
2018). The attack was described as ‘a complex interaction of multiple bugs’
at a time when Facebook was already facing multiple government investiga-
tions into its privacy and data-sharing practices (Matsakis & Labowski 2018).
This was said to be ‘a reminder about the dangers posed when a small number
of companies like Facebook . . . are able to accumulate so much personal
data . . . without adequate security measures’ (ABC 2018). This is discussed
further in Chapter 4.
Conclusion
Much has occurred in the decade-and-a-half since Jenkins and others popular-
ised the idea of convergence and media participation. Since then, other media
scholars have chosen different ways of describing media, such as ‘porous’,
‘hybridised’ and ‘interlinked . . . along a continuum’ (Turner 2016, p. 125).
Media scholar Graeme Turner says the media ecology in which we now operate
146 Foundations and the working environment
has been ‘re-invented’ (2016). The idea of true participation has been chal-
lenged, because while much of the world participates in media, it does so at
a price: the price of privacy and relinquishing data to others. Nevertheless,
participation in media is now part of our cultural life. In various ways, audi-
ences have become a part of the media process, not only at the end as a receiver
but often and regularly along the media continuum.
With tools like the smartphone, and with the capacity to engage in online
media in so many ways in this ‘Platform Society’ (van Dijck et al. 2018), the
opportunities for strategic communication are virtually endless. The challenge
for the industry, and for you as a practitioner, will be staying abreast of change,
regulations and laws that emerge; conducting ethical practice where laws may
not yet exist; and being discerning about what media is best for what situation.
Finally, as boundless as it appears to be, the media is only part of the commu-
nication equation. Face-to-face, personalised communication will always have
a place in successful and strategic communication practice. We examine this
elsewhere in the book and look at a broad list of tactic choices in Chapter 9.
References
ABC (2018). Facebook Cyber Attack Sees Data Stolen from 29 Million Accounts in its Largest
Ever Data Theft. ABC News (14 October). Retrieved from www.abc.net.au/news/2018-10-
13/facebook-hack-saw-data-stolen-from-29-million-accounts/10373030
Alexander, B., Adams Becker, S., Cummins, M. & Hall Giesinger, C. (2017). Digital Literacy in
Higher Education, Part II: An NMC Horizon Project Strategic Brief, 3(4). Austin, TX: The New
Media Consortium.
Chen, A. (2017). The Fake-News Fallacy. The New Yorker (4 September). Retrieved from www.
newyorker.com/magazine/2017/09/04/the-fake-news-fallacy
Cisco (2019). Cisco Visual Networking Index: Forecast and Trends, 2017–2022. White Paper.
Retrieved from www.cisco.com/c/en_au/solutions/service-provider/visual-networking-
index-vni/index.html
Deloitte (2018a). Behaviour Unlimited: Mobile Consumer Survey 2018, The Australian Cut.
Retrieved from file:///F:/New%20PR%20text/Media%20chapter/DELOITE--tel-inbound-
mobile-consumer-survey-2018-report-2.pdf
——— (2019a). Mobile Consumer Survey 2019: Unwired, Unrivalled, Unknown, The Australian Cut.
Retrieved from http://images.content.deloitte.com.au/Web/DELOITTEAUSTRALIA/
%7B3a35a2e7-7ce2-4cc9-b7b2-3472be4267a7%7D_Deloitte_Global_Mobile_Consumer_
Survey_2019.pdf
Deuze, M. (2012). Media Life. Cambridge: Polity
Working in a media-dominated world 147
Dietrich, G. (2014). Spin Sucks: Communication and Reputation Management in the Digital Age.
Hoboken, NJ: Pearson Education.
——— (2018). FOMO is Not the Deciding Factor. PRSA Content Connection (9 April).
Retrieved from https://contentconnection.prsa.org/resources/articles/fomo-is-not-the-
deciding-factor
——— (2019). The PESO Model as it Relates to Professional Development. Spin Sucks
(14 March). Retrieved from https://spinsucks.com/communication/pr-pros-must-embrace-
the-peso-model/
Edison (2019). The Infinite Dial. Edison Research (6 March). Retrieved from www.edison
research.com/infinite-dial-2019/
Emojipedia (2018). FAQ: How Many Emoji Characters Are There? Retrieved from https://
emojipedia.org/faq/
Forbes (2017). New to Working with Journalists? 10 Tips for Telling your Story. Forbes
(17 January). Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/forbesagencycouncil/2017/01/17/new-
to-working-with-journalists-10-tips-for-telling-your-story/#2e06e0944bc2
Haydar, N. (2020). Facebook and Google to Face Mandatory Code of Conduct to ‘level playing
field’ with Traditional Media. ABC (20 April). Retrieved from www.abc.net.au/news/2020-
04-20/facebook-and-google-to-face-mandatory-code-of-conduct/12163300
Hjarvard S. (2008). The Mediatization of Society: A Theory of the Media as Agents of Social and
Cultural Change. Nordicom Review, 29(2), 105–134.
Jenkins, H. (2006). Welcome to Convergence Culture. Blog post (19 June). Retrieved from
http://henryjenkins.org/blog/2006/06/welcome_to_convergence_culture.html
——— (2007). Transmedia Storytelling. Blog post (21 March). Retrieved from http://henryjenkins.
org/blog/2007/03/transmedia_storytelling_101.html
Johnston, J. (2007). Media Relations: Issues & Strategies. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
——— & Rowney, K. (2018). Media Strategies: Managing Content, Platforms and Relationships.
Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
Katz, M. (2018). CGI ‘Influencers’ Like Lil Miquela Are About to Flood Your Feed. Wired,
(1 May). Retrieved from www.wired.com/story/lil-miquela-digital-humans/
Knight, W. (2017). Biased Algorithms are Everywhere, and No One Seems to Care. MIT Review
(12 July). Retrieved from www.technologyreview.com/s/608248/biased-algorithms-are-
everywhere-and-no-one-seems-to-care/
Matsakis L. & Labowski I. (2018). Everything We Know About Facebook’s Massive Security
Breach. Wired (28 September). Retrieved from www.wired.com/story/facebook-security-
breach-50-million-accounts/
McCoy, E. (2017). Visual Communication is Transforming Marketing—Are You Up to Speed?
Forbes (12 May). Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/forbescommunicationscouncil/2017/
05/12/visual-communication-is-transforming-marketing-are-you-up-to-speed/#2c0ea9eb6f7c
Microsoft (n.d.) FATE: Fairness, Accountability, Transparency, Ethics. Retrieved from www.microsoft.
com/en-us/research/group/fate/
OfCom (2018). Communications Market Report. Retrieved from www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/
pdf_file/0022/117256/CMR-2018-narrative-report.pdf
148 Foundations and the working environment
research, measurement
and evaluation
151
152 Process, planning and implementation
and impacts refer to the intended and unintended impacts of the campaign
on the organisational goals and on society. In order to determine what inputs
and outputs should be, and what outcomes and impact actually are, strategic
communication practitioners conduct research.
This input–output–outcome–impact framework can be aligned with a stra-
tegic communication planning, implementation and evaluation process that
will be discussed in Chapter 8. This provides a clearer picture of what needs
to be researched and when that research should be undertaken. When those
decisions are made, the practitioner can choose the most appropriate research
methods and techniques to collect the information. These relationships are
demonstrated in Figure 6.2. More detail on the planning process within this
diagram is given in Chapter 8, Figure 8.1.
Input research
Input research provides the communication practitioner with a practical road
map. It can indicate what problems or opportunities actually exist, what the
perceptions and beliefs of the relevant publics are, and what tools or methods of
communication would be most effective in helping the organisation achieve its
objectives with those publics. Input research thus provides a basis for strategy
and planning.
At the start of the process there is a need to gather as much information as
possible on the issue or situation to be researched. Therefore, the vital first step
in research is to clarify the organisation’s objectives and the role that communi-
cation can play in achieving them.
Exploratory research techniques are then used to collect all relevant infor-
mation on the situation, the organisation and the publics. This reveals gaps in
the information at hand and indicates to the practitioner or the organisation
what other information is needed. Research gathered from existing sources is
known as secondary research, but additional, new research, known as primary
research, may also be required.
Useful information can be obtained by investigating the factors that
influence the current situation both within and outside the organisation.
Internally, organisational documentation can shed light on strategic intent,
the outcomes of previous communication activities, important stakeholders
and the resources available. The PESTLE framework, discussed in Chapter 3,
can be used to assist in the constant environmental scanning that will identify
external political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental
factors relevant to the organisation and its operations. For example, informa-
tion can be sought about proposed legislation or the introduction of a new
technology which impacts on the current situation. Consider, for instance,
the objective of Osteoporosis Australia in increasing the bone health of the
Australian population. Input research could uncover that vitamin D deficiency
is a significant issue, that the success of anti-cancer campaigns has reduced
the public’s understanding of the need for sunlight exposure in supplement-
ing vitamin D levels, and that young mothers are a high-risk group. This
could then result in a campaign to increase levels of awareness among certain
target publics.
156 Process, planning and implementation
The opinions and attitudes currently held by the organisation’s key publics,
such as the young mothers above, also need to be identified. Questions a
researcher should ask include:
Output research
During the output phase, research can reflect on the delivery of messages,
allowing the practitioner to fine-tune or modify the plan as it is implemented in
order to achieve greater success with outcomes. Output research gathers infor-
mation on the appropriateness and quality of the messages and the activities
that can be fed back into the strategy development or implementation phases
to improve the campaign.
Information sought during the output phase of the research could also
include quantitative data such as the number of messages sent to the media
and the number of activities designed, the messages placed and activi-
ties implemented, and who received the messages and participated in the
activities (particularly important in countries with multicultural populations).
Continuing the osteoporosis example given above, output research could test
the interpretations of the messages to determine the need for refinement, as
well as gather statistics on how many times the messages appear in women’s
magazines or lifestyle programs.
Output research checks that the channels of communication, such as radio,
television, newspapers, magazines, the internet and social media, brochures,
workshops, community meetings and viral videos—in other words, the total
communication mix—were correctly chosen and designed for the particular
158 Process, planning and implementation
Outcome research
Outcome research measures and evaluates what the outputs have achieved
in terms of a change in the awareness, understanding, attitude or behaviour
of the target publics (Watson & Noble 2014). Evaluation should reflect the
size and direction of that change from an agreed and predetermined bench-
mark. It not only indicates the level of success or failure of the program or
campaign but can also demonstrate how effective planning and communication
have been.
In order to undertake outcome research effectively, evaluation criteria must
be established at the beginning of the planning stage, prior to implementation
of the program. The criteria should be dictated by the program’s objectives,
which must be set in observable, measurable and time-specific terms. For
example, using the osteoporosis example, evaluation criteria may be set at
achieving a 20 per cent growth in awareness among women aged 18–45 in a
twelve-month period. Measurement tools and methods used to set a bench-
mark prior to the campaign launch can then be replicated at the end of the
program to determine whether the outcomes have been achieved. This will
ensure that the most appropriate techniques are used to gather information
and that the research measures the most important aspects, providing useful and
relevant feedback on the success of the program.
Outcome research also measures the extent to which the original
campaign objectives were met, providing a sound basis from which to begin
planning future campaigns. It is crucial that evaluation findings be used and
fed back into the program on a continual basis (Watson & Noble 2014, p. 58).
Accurate documentation of the processes and decisions undertaken through-
out a campaign assists in the evaluation of current, and the development of
future, programs.
Research, measurement and evaluation 159
Impact research
In more recent research about measurement and evaluation, the importance of
measuring the impact of the communication activity on the organisation and
on society has been highlighted (Buhmann & Likely 2018; Macnamara 2018;
Macnamara & Gregory 2018). While the awareness, attitude or action of the
publics may have been influenced by the campaign (outcomes), the signifi-
cance of this to the organisation also needs to be assessed. In other words,
did this improve reputation, increase the financial standing of the organisa-
tion, or create efficiencies and savings? At the same time, did the outcomes
have a positive effect on society, such as resolving a community problem or
improving wellbeing? While some of these impacts may be easy to measure
(e.g. organisational cost savings), others may require more detailed qualitative
research to assess.
Input research
• A reputation tracking survey (built by Cision) targeting both consumers and
business partners.
160 Process, planning and implementation
Output research
• Media analysis of coverage generated by public relations efforts to identify
general themes as well as ‘influential advocates and detractors’.
• Tracking of website usage data and its relationship to media coverage.
Outcome research
• A campaign tracking survey to measure levels of outcomes such as aware-
ness, sentiment, exposure and alignment with the company mission.
Figure 6.3 Fighting puppy farms through strategic communication research and
evaluation. Photo by Berkay Gumustekin, Unsplash.
Research, measurement and evaluation 161
Research methods
As mentioned above, an organisation can obtain the information it seeks
through both formal and informal research, using qualitative and quantita-
tive methods. In addition, the practitioner may make use of primary research,
which is original research conducted by or for an organisation; or second-
ary research, which utilises others’ findings or material. Within all these
methods, a wide range of techniques is available to the researcher to gather
information.
Formal Informal
Qualitative Environmental monitoring
Analysis of existing data Analysis of information from:
Analysis of feedback Archives
Audits of communication and social Case studies
media Diaries
Content analysis Electronic databases
Ethnographic studies Expert review
Focus groups Interviews (unstructured)
In-depth interviews Libraries
Organisational culture study Panel discussions
Quantitative and qualitative Testimonials
Internet and social media analytics
Media content analysis
Social media analysis
Quantitative
Media metrics (circulation,
readership, viewers)
Web statistics (views, clicks)
Surveys
Audience analysis
Pre-testing (messages and tactics)
Readership studies and statistics on
distribution
Benchmark studies
Readability studies
Records and databases (e.g. incoming
phone calls, chatbot interactions
and other messages and complaints)
164 Process, planning and implementation
blurred and may shift depending on how the techniques are employed. For
example, surveys are frequently statistical and therefore quantitative; however,
open-ended questions that are then analysed and interpreted could take a more
qualitative approach. A research plan will not be limited to one method or
technique but will use a range of tools, depending on the desired outcomes and
accuracy level, the timeframe and the budget.
Surveys
Surveys are frequently used research techniques in strategic communication
and PR. They involve giving a standardised questionnaire to a selected group of
people, chosen to represent a larger research population. They provide a conve-
nient way of gathering data about the target publics’ knowledge, expectations,
attitudes, opinions and beliefs and are administered through questionnaires.
Surveys can be used to set benchmarks before a campaign as they can be easily
Research, measurement and evaluation 165
replicated in the evaluation phase to assess the level of change and measure the
outcomes and impact of the activity.
A scientifically constructed sample using random probability sampling
techniques will enable generalisations to be drawn from the results. In prob
ability sampling, the total population is known and there is an equal chance
of any member being selected in the sample. For example, the population
may be first-year students at a specific university with a smaller sample being
generated by a program that randomly selects 500 students for surveying. Non-
probability methods are used when the total population is difficult to define
and the researcher, for various reasons, subjectively selects a sample for study.
For example, the desired total population may be 18- to 25-year-old females,
but for speed and convenience the researcher selects a sample of 50 students
from a single university class. As such, these methods are more subjective in
their approach and results cannot not be presented as a true reflection of the
wider population; however, this type of research will still offer useful insights
into attitudes and behaviours.
Communication and PR practitioners should understand the core concepts
of this type of research and be able to undertake simple surveys. However, a
systematic, precise approach and subsequent analysis often requires a profes-
sional pollster or research company. Professional research organisations such
as Colmar Brunton (www.colmarbrunton.com.au) and Australian Survey
Research (https://aussurveys.com) can assist organisations with the design
and implementation of surveys and other research tools, as well as providing
detailed analysis of the data gathered.
Online questionnaires are preferred for many surveys and can be delivered
via websites, blogs and social networking sites. Additional costs can be encoun-
tered in software development, but online surveys are generally viewed as more
cost-effective than other methods, and low-cost tools that are easy to adapt
are increasingly available. For example, SurveyMonkey (www.surveymonkey.
com) provides a basic service at no cost or more advanced capabilities for a
fee. This is probably the most popular current easy research tool, with around
40 million customers at last count (Pickavance & Turner 2019). There are
many survey tool options available, including:
• SurveyMonkey
• AskNicely
166 Process, planning and implementation
• Formstack
• SurveyGizmo
• Google Forms
• Qualtrics.
The tools vary in their complexity and functionality and typically have
some form of interface with Facebook, Twitter or QR codes, as well as email
and websites (Pickavance & Turner 2019).
While the speed of response is good for online surveys, problems can be
encountered with the technical capability of the audience, response quality,
privacy issues, viruses and accuracy of sampling. Despite these limitations,
online delivery remains popular, as other methods of delivering surveys have
their own challenges. The popularity of the telephone survey is waning, with
response rates limited due to factors such as competition in the telemarketing
sector and spam regulations. Face-to-face surveys may result in higher response
rates but are costly and labour-intensive. Depending on your research needs,
small surveys, such as those that you complete in a store when you sign up for
membership, may provide useful data.
Questionnaire design can impact the accuracy of the results. Closed-ended
questions provide the respondent a list of answers from which to choose, while
in open-ended questions the respondent is asked to give an answer that requires
some comment. Scales allow respondents to fit their answers into a quantifi-
able category. Various techniques are available, such as the Likert scale, which
requires the respondent to select from a range of answers from ‘strongly agree’
to ‘strongly disagree’. See Figure 6.4 for examples of differently structured
questions in a survey.
Interviews
In-depth interviews, structured or semistructured, are conducted with specifi-
cally chosen people or samples within the target public, using questions that are
generally pre-tested and asked of all respondents, requiring detailed explanation
in response. They give the practitioner insight into the respondents’ attitudes,
beliefs and actions regarding an issue or as a result of program messages and
activities. Due to the time-consuming nature of interviews, sample populations
are significantly smaller than those reached by questionnaires. While they
could be used to gain information from broad publics, they are particularly
Research, measurement and evaluation 167
useful to gauge specialist opinion from key industry or sector leaders, such
as school principals on directions in education, or judges on how the media
represents justice issues.
Focus groups
Focus groups, a form of qualitative research, are popular in communication
research. They typically consist of groups of eight to twelve individuals who
share similar characteristics. The interviewer or facilitator moves the discus-
sion in the necessary direction while avoiding irrelevant discussion and without
imposing their own views on the group. Focus group facilitators are adept at
ensuring that all members of the group are heard rather than allowing the dis
cussion to be hijacked by a vocal minority. Focus group discussion enables the
practitioner to collect preliminary information from the target audience about
message comprehension and acceptance. This technique can be used for various
purposes, including pilot studies, pre-testing of key messages and evaluating
changes in attitudes or knowledge in the target audience. For example, focus
groups are used by politicians to test and inform political messages, advertising
and image-building strategies before, during and after political campaigning.
Environmental monitoring
Trends that may affect an organisation can be identified and systematically moni-
tored to assess whether they threaten its successful functioning. Scanning and
tracking are environmental monitoring processes. Scanning involves ongoing
observation of general trends in the environment, while tracking concerns the
constant monitoring of specific opportunities or threats in the environment that
affect organisations. Monitoring the content of online newsgroups, chatrooms,
blogs, websites and social networks can identify the views of others, providing
information to inform program development or evaluation. Online tools and
methods for scanning and tracking the environment include those that can be
used in-house at low cost, and others that can be outsourced, such as:
• Google Trends
• Google Alerts
• tracking Twitter and Instagram hashtags
• Brandwatch
Research, measurement and evaluation 169
• Mention
• Rapid Miner.
Organisations can also examine responses to their own online activity, such
as measuring page views, time onsite, bookmarks and search engine effective-
ness. Debate about what should and should not be measured is ongoing, with
techniques constantly being developed (see the International Association of
Measurement and Evaluation of Communication). Proprietary tools, such as
Facebook Insights, are specific to each social media platform, whereas Google
Analytics can be used across many platforms to gather information such as
content, conversion, and social and advertising analytics. Technology compa-
nies such as Salesforce and Hootsuite offer social media monitoring platforms
that assist practitioners in the management of social media posts and include
measurement and evaluation functions.
Monitoring the news media establishes the extent of coverage of an organi-
sation’s messages, with an emphasis on reach (the total number of target public
members exposed to the message) and frequency (the number of times the
target public was exposed to the same message). The formality of this technique
can range from detailed, using complex database management techniques, to
informal, such as a collection of press clippings. There are numerous commer-
cial providers of this service. Two of the largest are iSentia and Meltwater, which
search print, radio, television, internet and social media, providing reports to
clients on the coverage of both their organisation and issues relevant to their
operations. Media monitoring informs an organisation of what has been covered
in the media, measuring some of the outputs of a public relations effort; however,
for a more detailed evaluation, a content analysis should also be undertaken.
170 Process, planning and implementation
Communication audits
Communication audits use a range of research tools to evaluate the effec-
tiveness of an organisation’s internal and external means of communication,
examining factors such as channels of communication, messages, stakeholder
satisfaction and the communication structure and/or ethos of the organisation.
Research, measurement and evaluation 171
Case studies
Case studies investigate situations within their real-world context to produce
a depth of understanding that is not always available using other research
methods. Investigating a single or small number of cases to understand the
complexities of their unique circumstances can provide insights about, or an
evaluation of, an event or phenomenon (Yin 2018). Data is gathered from
multiple sources, including through observation, interviews, archival records,
documents and physical artefacts (Yin 2018). Sacrificing breadth for depth
of research, case studies are particularly useful in providing examples of best
practice in communication (Watson & Noble 2014, pp. 42–44).
• They measure cost rather than value, inaccurately equating advertising and
editorial publicity.
172 Process, planning and implementation
Research metrics
So, what can be measured?
In terms of news and social media coverage, the PRIA’s Media & Social Media
Content Analysis Guidelines (PRIA n.d.) provides templates to guide the record-
ing of activities and outputs. It suggests recording ‘the reach of each item,
a rating for tone and a rating for the achievement of five qualitative criteria
of their choice’. Those qualitative criteria should be selected in accordance
with the objectives of the activity. The guidelines also specify the need for
consistent and transparent use of the measures of reach (audience and reader-
ship figures) and tone (how the subject of the article or segment is characterised)
to ensure valid replicability of measures over time.
The PRIA Evaluation Implementation Matrix (PRIA 2017) and the AMEC
taxonomy (AMEC 2019c), both developed by Professor Jim Macnamara,
provide a more detailed list of possible metrics, each aligned with the various
phases of research and the methods that can be used to obtain the results. Key
metrics can be seen in Table 6.2.
These metrics are suitable for a range of news, organisational and social
media. Social media measurement has attracted a great deal of attention in
recent years due to the relative ease of recording statistics on these plat-
forms. Johnston and Rowney (2018, p. 125) present a useful categorisation of
social media and website metrics, emphasising the need to choose metrics
that align with campaign objectives. They classify the metrics in the follow-
ing manner:
Table 6.2 Key metrics for each stage of the research process
All research will produce data, but what makes it ‘big’? Three factors:
volume, variety and velocity (Oracle Australia n.d). Technology has allowed us
to collect large quantities of data from a wide variety of sources, with greater
speed than ever before. But the greater quantity and complexity of that data
creates a need for specialist techniques and tools to draw valuable and accurate
information in a timely manner. Many of the internet and social media plat-
forms use technologies, such as those used by Facebook Insights, in their
in-built analytics functions, and similar technologies sit behind Siri, Alexa
and ‘Hey Google’, using huge volumes of user information to improve search
functions and target advertising more effectively.
We can consider AI an umbrella term covering a number of technologies.
AI itself is not a new concept. In a general sense, it refers to the way that
computers are programmed to undertake tasks that could be considered ‘smart’,
making decisions based on the information (or data) that is fed into them.
ML is one aspect of AI, in which algo-
rithms are adjusted based on the data
that is being processed. The more
data that is fed in, the more refined
the algorithms become, producing
more precise outputs (Marr 2016).
Natural Language Processing
(NLP) uses ML to enable computers
to analyse, interpret and manipulate
language in the form of written and
speech data (SAS 2019). Themes
in the language can be identified,
providing the communication prac-
titioner with the ability to summarise
and infer trends in large amounts
of data. Other examples of the
use of NLP include online transla-
tion tools (such as Google Translate) Figure 6.5 AI, such as that used in Google
and language generation capabilities Mini, is being used for communication
such as those used by social media research. Photo by Charles Devulio,
bots (Marr 2019). Unsplash.
Research, measurement and evaluation 175
While some professions are concerned about the potential for machines
to take over their work, there are great advantages in that ‘AI will help
PR [and strategic communication] companies process their data at a rapid
speed, improving how PR companies perform their services’ (Whitaker 2017).
For example,
Royal Bank of Scotland uses text analytics, an NLP technique, to extract import-
ant trends from customer feedback in many forms. The company analyzes data
from emails, surveys and call center conversations to identify the root cause of
customer dissatisfaction and implement improvements. (SAS 2019)
Chair of the the Chartered Institute of Public Relations (CIPR) Artificial Intelli-
gence Panel (#AIinPR) in the UK, the benefits of this technology include:
• improved decision-making
• greater understanding of stakeholders and their motivations
• more informed and effective storytelling
• increased productivity in content creation, planning and reporting
• competitive advantage. (Waddington 2019)
For all the hype about these immense technological developments, however,
there continues to be a significant need for human-based analysis. A study
conducted by the CIPR in 2018 predicted that, by 2023, ‘38% of public rela-
tions skills could be complemented or replaced by AI . . . but key human traits,
like empathy, trust, humour and relationship building, cannot be automated’
(O’Neill 2018). Warning of the limitations of automated analysis, Comcowich
argues that ‘media analysis requires evaluation of subject, positioning, messag-
ing, and issues—evaluations that only well-trained human analysts can perform
with an acceptable level of provision’ (Comcowich 2019). The challenge is that
the limits of technology are far from being reached and the future remains
unknown. The contemporary practitioner must be competent in data manage-
ment, keep abreast of the technological developments and know what services
to employ (e.g. in-house or outsourced) when situations arise.
AI
A study titled The Effects of AI on the Professions: A Literature Repository was
published by the CIPR in the UK in 2020. This review marks an important turning
point in the awakening of the communication industry to the impacts AI
will have on the work being delivered and the skills required. It highlights the
need for thorough exploration of workforce issues, education and training,
communication ethics and the ‘organisational and societal role that public
relations professionals will have in the future’ (Gregory & Virmani 2020, p. 9).
Accompanying the report is a literature repository containing approximately
170 reports, books, articles and videos on the impact of AI on the professions,
which not only informed the study but provides easy access to information on
the topic for both practitioners and academics.
Research, measurement and evaluation 177
Research organisations
As outlined in this chapter, research requires considerable expertise, which may
sometimes be beyond the level of knowledge of the communication practi-
tioner. In those instances, there are many private and public organisations in
Australia and New Zealand that can undertake research in support of an organ-
isation’s communication and public relations activity. The key is to ensure that
those contracting the services of specialists can clearly articulate the research
need and assess the quality of the services being provided.
The Australian Social and Market Research Society, the Association of
Market and Social Research Organisations and the Research Association New
Zealand publish directories that list and describe the services supplied by
companies and independent researchers. Filters can be applied to search for
expertise in research methods such as focus groups and surveys, or researchers
that specialise in specific tasks such as employee satisfaction surveys, corporate
reputation measurement, market segmentation and website evaluation.
Conclusion
This chapter has shown that there is a clear need for research and evaluation in
the establishment and completion of communication activities and campaigns.
But, in doing so, it also shows the complexity involved and skills required to
do this research effectively. With so much information now available, there is a
need to be careful and selective in accessing and using data to ensure campaigns
are well informed and accurately evaluated. So, in research and evaluation, as in
any other activity undertaken by communication practitioners, responsible and
ethical practice is paramount. The practitioner needs to guard against decep-
tion, confidentiality issues and dishonesty in the collection of data, ensuring
that research processes are transparent to all involved. In the analysis and
presentation of results, it is important to ensure the focus remains on the stated
objectives. The same pool of techniques and metrics can be used across all
the various stages: inputs–outputs–outcomes–impacts. Selection of the most
appropriate tools should consider how the objectives can be measured but will
also depend on the research culture within the organisation, the available time
and budget and the requirements of the project. The increasing availability
178 Process, planning and implementation
of raw and big data sets can be both advantageous and overwhelming, but we
need to be smart about how to draw useful information out of them in the most
expedient way. Quality of research and evaluation information will usually be
more valuable than quantity. The challenge for strategic communication and
public relations practitioners continues.
References
AMEC (International Association for the Measurement and Evaluation of Communication)
(2019a). Barcelona Principles 2.0. Retrieved from https://amecorg.com/barcelona-principles-
2-0/
——— (2019b). The Definitive Guide: Why AVEs Are Invalid. Retrieved from https://amecorg.
com/2017/06/the-definitive-guide-why-aves-are-invalid/
——— (2019c). A Taxonomy of Evaluation Towards Standards. Retrieved from https://amecorg.
com/amecframework/home/supporting-material/taxonomy/
Babbie, E.R. (2016). The Practice of Social Research (14th edn). Boston, MA: Cengage Learning.
Buhmann, A. & Likely, F. (2018). Evaluation and Measurement. In R.L. Heath & W. Johansen
(eds), The International Encyclopedia of Strategic Communication (pp. 625-640). Hoboken, NJ:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Cision (2020). Gumtree Classifies PR Success with Measurement and Cision Insights. Retrieved from
www.cision.co.uk/resources/success-stories/gumtree-cision-insights/
Comcowich, W. (2019). 4 Key PR Measurement Trends to Expect in 2020. Retrieved from https://
glean.info/4-key-pr-measurement-trends-to-expect-in-2020/
Fanning, E. (2019). 3 CRM Examples to Inspire Your CRM Strategy. Sendinblue (21 August).
Retrieved from https://blog.sendinblue.com/crm-examples-to-inspire-crm-strategy/
Gregory, A. & Virmani, S. (2020). The Effects of AI on the Professions: A Literature Repository.
London: Chartered Institute of Public Relations. Retrieved from https://cipr.co.uk/CIPR/
Our_work/Policy/CIPR_Artificial_Intelligence_in_PR_panel.aspx
Johnston, J. & Rowney, K. (2018). Media Strategies: Managing Content, Platforms and R elationships.
Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
Macnamara, J.R. (2016). Organizational Listening: The Missing Essential in Public Communication.
New York, NY: Peter Lang.
——— (2017). AVEs (Advertising Value Equivalents)—8 Reasons NOT to Use Them. Public Rela-
tions Institute of Australia. Retrieved from www.pria.com.au/public/38/files/Education/
Measurement%20&%20Evalution/AVE%208%20reasons%20not%20to%20use.pdf
Research, measurement and evaluation 179
——— (2018). A Review of New Evaluation Models for Strategic Communication: Progress and
Gaps. International Journal of Strategic Communication, 12(2), 180–195.
——— & Gregory, A. (2018). Expanding Evaluation to Progress Strategic Communication:
Beyond Message Tracking to Open Listening. International Journal of Strategic Communica-
tion, 12(4), 469–486.
Marr, B. (2016). What is the Difference Between Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning?
Forbes (6 December). Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2016/12/06/
what-is-the-difference-between-artificial-intelligence-and-machine-learning
——— (2019). 5 Amazing Examples of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in Practice. Forbes
(3 March) Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2019/06/03/5-amazing-
examples-of-natural-language-processing-nlp-in-practice/#51c76fa11b30
Newsom, D., Turk, J. & Kruckeberg, D. (2013). This is PR: The Realities of Public Relations
(11th edn). Boston, MA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
O’Neill, J. (2018). Humans Still Needed—CIPR Research Reveals the Impact of AI. Retrieved from
www.vuelio.com/uk/blog/humans-still-needed-cipr-research-reveals-the-impact-of-ai/
Oracle Australia (n.d). What is Big Data? Retrieved from https://www.oracle.com/au/big-data/
guide/what-is-big-data.html
Pickavance, M. & Turner, B. (2019). Best Survey Tools of 2020. Techradar (28 February).
Retrieved from www.techradar.com/au/best/best-survey-tools
PRIA (Public Relations Institute of Australia) (2017). Measurement and Evaluation Framework.
Retrieved from www.pria.com.au/education/measurement-evaluation/measurement-evaluation-
framework/
——— (n.d.). Media & Social Media Content Analysis Guidelines. Retrieved from www.pria.com.
au/public/38/files/Education/Measurement%20&%20Evalution/Social%20content%20
guidelines%20(2).pdf>.
SAS (2019). Natural Language Processing (NLP): What It Is and Why It Matters. Retrieved from
www.sas.com/en_au/insights/analytics/what-is-natural-language-processing-nlp.html
Stacks, D. & Bowen, S. (eds) (2016). The Dictionary of Public Relations Measurement and Research
(3rd edn). Institute of Public Relations. Retrieved from https://instituteforpr.org/wp-content/
uploads/Dictionary-of-Public-Relations-Measurement-and-Research-3rd-Edition1.pdf
Waddington, S. (2019). Kerry Sheehan on the Slow March of AI in PR. Corporate Communica-
tion, Public Relations, Marketing and Social Media (blog post, December 11). Retrieved from
https://wadds.co.uk/blog/2019/12/11/kerry-sheehan-on-the-slow-march-of-ai-in-pr
Watson, T. & Noble, P. (2014). Evaluating Public Relations: A Guide to Planning, Research and
Measurement. London: Kogan Page, Limited.
Whitaker, A. (2017). How Advancements in Artificial Intelligence Will Impact Public Rela-
tions. Forbes (20 March). Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/theyec/2017/03/20/
how-advancements-in-artificial-intelligence-will-impact-public-relations
Yin, R.K. (2018). Case Study Research and Applications: Design and Methods (6th edn). Thousand
Oaks, CA: SAGE, Publications.
Chapter 7
working strategically
Strategy sits at the heart of all public relations and professional communication
practice. It is both central and critical to successful communication practice,
underpinning just about everything else in the planning process—from tactics
to execution. In fact, without clear strategies, developing and implementing
communication tactics (outlined in Chapter 9) will have much less chance of
success. Why? Because strategies provide guidance and focus for everything
that follows. A useful way of understanding strategy is provided by Hax and
Majluf (1985, p. 12):
Literally, thousands of decisions are being made every day in large and complex
organizations. The only way to make them consistent is to establish some sense
of permanent strategic direction that provides a rich framework within which
those decisions can be made.
With this in mind, it’s no coincidence that the term ‘strategic’ is used to
describe so much practice in the daily agenda of the workforce—strategic plans,
strategic communication, strategic priorities and so on. It has almost become
a cliché because of its overuse. Nevertheless, we need to dig deep to really
understand what it means because it can mean the success or failure of an organ-
isation, a campaign and, of course, communication practice. When applied to
communication, strategy provides consistency, structure and cohesiveness. This
should be embedded in all communication within an organisation, whether
internally or externally directed. A key part of strategy, therefore, is the actual
process of communicating. In order to make communication achieve what we
180
Working strategically 181
the picture! Possibly the most difficult to visualise is the corporate context,
because these arenas are usually not as publicly played out, but a boardroom
scene will generally provide a setting for strategy in action. The strategy
is focused on the highest levels of the organisation and its overall purpose
and aims, just as military strategy is focused on the goals of the nation. And
so, strategy easily makes the jump from a military setting to those other
places and times where informed, purposeful and systematic choices need
to be made—to win on the sporting field, claim success in an election, keep
customers and employees loyal to a brand, or capture the hearts of people for
a cause.
Because the term ‘strategy’ can be used on its own, as a noun, or as an adjec-
tive to describe something else, as in strategic planning, directions, management
and communication, we tend to get a bit dulled to what the word really means.
And, to be fair, it is often just assumed or taken for granted. Equally problem-
atically, it also often gets confused with tactics. This is why we have dedicated
a whole chapter to explaining and exploring strategy—because it’s so central to
public relations activity and how successful professional communication needs
to be practised. For this reason, we first look at ‘strategy’ (as a noun) and, later
in the chapter, consider how it translates to our own field of strategic commu-
nication practice.
Scholars have been defining strategy for many years. Leading Professor of
Communication Carl Botan proposes three levels of strategy:
is more important—they all work together. Botan points out that ‘[a]lthough
grand strategy is at the top of the hierarchy, it is completely dependent on
tactics . . . and one or more strategies to give it substance’ (2018, p. 14). He
further points out that authority and guidance flow down from the grand
strategy, while substance and tangible outputs flow upwards from tactics and
campaign strategies. We’ve developed this in Figure 7.1.
While Botan’s hierarchy is not used by everyone (i.e. you won’t find the
expression ‘grand strategy’ in all texts), it is a useful way of thinking about
strategy for those engaged in the field of strategic communication and PR.
In this chapter, we will focus more on this concept of grand (or overarch-
ing) strategy. What Botan might refer to as a second-level strategy we label
the ‘operational level’ to avoid confusion and examine in more detail in the
campaigns and planning chapter (Chapter 8). Tactics—Botan’s third level—is
then explored in depth in Chapter 9.
Let’s take a look at some other business definitions of how strategy is seen
to direct a whole-of-organisation approach. Mintzberg and Water (1985, p. 259)
refer to strategy simply as
While useful, this list tends towards a marketing approach and does not
include a goal orientation. This was rectified by Tilley (2014) who created
a new set of ‘Six Ps’—specifically adapted for better understanding strategy
as it applies to public relations—including goal orientation, which she called
‘purpose’. The Six P approach provides a framework for understanding how
grand strategy is central to a whole-of-organisation approach, as outlined in
Table 7.1.
Each of the Six Ps provides insights into how to better understand the
overall or grand strategy. Together, they provide a holistic way of develop-
ing, adjusting and reorienting grand strategy in relation to the publics or
stakeholders that are important to an organisation.
It can be easier to understand these concepts when we apply them to organ-
isations with which we are familiar. Australian digital marketing company
King Kong undertook research into some of the most successful companies in
the world (Suby 2016). It found common threads of strategy related to:
Figure 7.2 Coca-Cola: known for brand consistency. Photo by Amos Bar-Zeev, Unsplash.
Figure 7.3 Nike sponsors BIKETOWN in the US city of Portland. Photo by Cat Mapper
(Max Ogden), Unsplash.
Flexible strategies
While these companies have each shown ‘pattern’ and consistency in various
ways, they have also shown flexibility and openness to change. Organisations
don’t plan their strategy and then walk away from it and hope for the best. It
needs to be managed as an organic concept. The world is changing so rapidly
that successful organisations must be agile and responsive to both the external
Working strategically 191
and internal environment and, importantly, listen to what their publics are
saying. Sull (2015) points out that because of developments and fluctuations in
technology, regulations, stakeholder choice, economic and competitor fluctu-
ations, the best-laid plans sometimes need to be reconfigured—this certainly
applies to strategy. Having a non-responsive strategy can result in, at best, a
rocky future, and at worst the demise of the organisation. As circumstances
change, as stakeholders make their views known, and as other elements come
into play, strategies must capture new information, make midcourse corrections
and ensure the timing is right to make tactical decisions. Sull recommends
that ‘[i]n fast-paced industries, companies should think of strategy as an itera-
tive loop with four steps: making sense of a situation, making choices, making
things happen and making revisions’ (2015, p. 57). This reinforces the need
for ongoing evaluation, as outlined in Chapter 6, and also links decisions about
strategy to issues management, as outlined in Chapter 3. Sull’s strategy loop is
adapted in Figure 7.4.
Figure 7.4 The strategy loop highlights how strategy should be in a constant state of
revision. Source: adapted from Sull (2015).
The strategy loop also shows how decisions are impacted by external
factors, including what competitors are doing, new or pending regulations and
laws, the impact of new technology, trends in stakeholder choice, and economic
fluctuations such as local currency variations and interest rates. Internal factors,
such as staffing, also need to be considered, especially with the changing labour
market being impacted by casual workforces and increased AI. Some of the
external factors, such as technology, are also internal factors. All of these—both
192 Process, planning and implementation
external and internal—should be monitored during the four phases. So, for
example, a university might consider the following external and internal factors:
• What are other universities doing in the marketplace? How are they
perceived? What are their points of difference?
• Are new laws being implemented or on the horizon that impact on inter
national enrolments, internal fee structures, or pay structures?
• Is the local financial currency high or low and will this impact on
international student numbers?
• How has changed technology impacted on the delivery of courses? Is there
demand for online or massive open online courses (MOOCs)? What tech-
nology is needed to teach and research effectively?
• What is the level of casualisation in the workforce and what are the
implications of this?
• Do the current staff have the expertise to break into high areas of demand
or specialised areas, or are upskilling and training, or new appointments,
required?
To further illustrate the strategy loop in action, let’s return to one of the
Fortune 500 companies: Apple. Apple points to the importance of ongoing
evaluation and refinement of its strategy. Here’s how they explain it:
[T]he first thing we ask is, what do we want people to feel? . . . Then we begin
to craft our intention. It takes time. There are a thousand no’s for every yes. We
simplify, we perfect, we start over . . . (Apple, in Kirk 2013)
But while Apple may have moved to the top of the pack due to its grand
strategy (Kirk 2013), this wasn’t always the case. In the 1980s the Apple II and
Macintosh series of home computers struggled to keep up with the competi-
tion, losing the battle against PC computers from IBM (Yeung 2018). ‘The
Working strategically 193
through all their options before choosing a single one, and experiment with
a number of strategies that are feasible even if they are unsure of the impli-
cations. (2008, p. 5)
Defining the vision and mission are critical before starting on strategic
elements. After all, what is the strategy trying to achieve if not the company’s
mission? And what is the mission if not an embodiment of the vision?
be accomplished (process and pattern). Miller explains: ‘In other words, the
mission statement is a way to express the vision in practical terms. It should be
concrete and include goal-oriented language’ (2014).
Values (sometimes called principles) underpin the standards the organisa-
tion holds firm. These are all about what the organisation stands for, reflecting
the journey it has taken to get where it is now and how it sees itself moving
forward. They are central to an organisation’s culture and overall philosophy
and are often expressed as a ‘values statement’. These are often used in ethical
decision-making processes, as discussed in Chapter 4.
Use of child labor is not permissible. Workers can be no less than 15 years
of age and not younger than the compulsory age to be in school. We will
not utilize partners who use child labor in any of their facilities. We support
the development of legitimate workplace apprenticeship programs for the
educational benefit of younger people.
Levi Strauss found that one of its contractors was employing children under
fifteen in a factory in Bangladesh. The easy solution would have been to replace
those workers, but the children’s wages may have supported an entire family. If
the children lost their jobs, they may have had to resort to begging. Levi Strauss
found a solution that supported the company’s values of empathy, originality,
integrity and courage: it paid the children to go to school, covering tuition,
books and supplies, while continuing to pay salaries and benefits. Levi Strauss
was driven by company values to find a strategic solution (Lumen Learning n.d.).
196 Process, planning and implementation
One thing to remember is that goals, objectives, strategy and tactics cannot
substitute for each other. That might seem logical, but you’d be surprised how
often one is used to describe the other—for example we found one definition
that says ‘goals refer to the objectives an organisation strives to achieve’. Kenny
reminds us that a list of goals is not a strategy even though they are sometimes
used interchangeably (2014). The differences are explained further in Chapter 6.
They are interconnected and interdependent, but they are not inter-changeable.
development). In this way, the major departments advise from their positions
of strength—importantly, communication and PR need to be part of the ‘big-
picture’ thinking of an organisation and, for that reason, should have a seat
at the executive table. As grand strategies need to be flexible, they need to
combine many long-term initiatives, responding to what’s been done in the
past, often with a view to improving the future. Sometimes this results in these
strategies being articulated over a set timeframe that builds in ongoing moni-
toring and evaluation and provides a way of measuring objectives and outcomes
at a finite point in time.
Grand strategies will, therefore, usually be explained using a logical pathway,
including any or all of the following elements:
• Vision
• Mission
• Values
• Objectives
• Outcomes
• Implementation and actions
• Monitoring and evaluation.
They are often presented publicly using strong images that support the
key themes and with easy-to-read tables and charts. In virtually all cases they
will explain the consultation process; this is particularly important for PR and
communication, as it refers to the way stakeholders are not only included in the
process but are also often central to the strategy’s purpose and position. In the
following examples, stakeholder communication underpins how the strategies
were advanced and developed. Each of these five- or ten-year strategies has
been summarised for this chapter and can be examined in more detail online.
Our natural, historic and Indigenous heritage places are valued by Australians,
protected for future generations and cared for by the community.
Figure 7.5 Vision flows into strategy, objectives and outcomes in the Australian
Heritage Strategy. Source: information from Australian Government (2015).
Figure 7.6 UNHCR Strategic Directions. Source: information from UNHCR (2017).
This keeps the grand strategy and specific campaign strategies on track.
Multinational soft-drink company PepsiCo put it like this: ‘The messages
articulate the strategic direction of the company and motivate people to move
behind it’ (MacKenzie, in Argenti et al. 2015). Strategic communicators there-
fore both drive and follow the grand strategic and larger organisational agenda.
As global transport group FedEx point out: ‘Communication is at the center of
everything. You can’t execute strategy if you can’t communicate about it’ (Glen,
in Argenti et al. 2015).
And, since communication is a core function of every human organisation,
communication takes you to the very core of all such organisations (Botan 2018).
Strategic communication managers will ideally be positioned to help devise
organisations’ grand strategies, to have that ‘seat at the (executive) table’, which
then makes the transition to the operational and tactical phases of strategy
straightforward. This calls for taking the lead in developing communication for
implementing policies and practices, and connecting and listening to publics,
whether they are customers, investors, news media, employees, volunteers,
community or school groups or others (Botan 2018).
At the start of the chapter, we looked at definitions of strategy. Let’s now
consider how strategy is applied to the field of communication in popular defi-
nitions. How do leading international scholars define strategic communication?
Botan defines it in the following way:
SC is the use of information flowing into the organization (research) to plan and
carry out a communication campaign addressing the relationship between an
organization and its publics. SC is research based and publics centred rather
than organisation or message centred. (2018, p. 8)
Working strategically 205
Conclusion
Strategy is the starting point for much organisational practice—planning,
implementation and, certainly, communication. If we return to Hax and
Majluf’s (1985, p. 12) observation at the start of this chapter, it’s easy to see
the link. As thousands of decisions are made every day in organisations, a clear
strategy is the only way to make these consistent and establish a clear direction,
which, in turn, provides a clear framework for future decisions. Communi-
cating these decisions, directions and frameworks falls to communication
professionals through the reports, communiques, white papers, memos, press
206 Process, planning and implementation
releases, social media, annual reports, videos and other tactics they specialise
in developing. Equally, if not more, important, however, is the public relations
or strategic communication role in advising on strategy—how it aligns with an
organisation’s structure and operations, connects with stakeholders, underpins
key performance indicators and, ultimately, maps and reflects the heart and
soul of an organisation.
This chapter has outlined why strategic communication needs to be
connected to the grand strategies of organisations. The next chapter will
develop themes from this chapter as strategy is put into practice at the planning
level. Using Botan’s three-tiered approach, we now move to level two, the oper-
ational level of strategic planning. Following that, Chapter 9 examines tactics
in detail, thereby delivering Botan’s trifecta and the most hands-on part of the
strategic communication role.
References
Argenti, P.A., Howell, R.A. & Beck, H.K. (2015). The Strategic Communication Imperative.
In Top 10 Lessons on Strategy: MIT Sloan Management Review (pp. 60–67). Boston, MA:
MIT Press.
Australian Government (2015). Australian Heritage Strategy. Retrieved from www.environment.
gov.au/system/files/resources/cb226e0d-ba51-4946-af5a-24b628958e79/files/australian-
heritage-strategy-2015.pdf
Australian Red Cross (2014). A Year In Review. Retrieved from www.redcross.org.au/annual
report_2014/year-in-review/who-we-are.html
Belicove, M. (2013). Understanding Goals, Strategy, Objectives and Tactics in the Age of
Social. Forbes (27 September). Retrieved from www.forbes.com/sites/mikalbelicove/
2013/09/27/understanding-goals-strategies-objectives-and-tactics-in-the-age-of-social/
#794445464c79
Botan, C. (2018). Strategic Communication Theory and Practice: A Co-creational Model. Hoboken,
NJ: Wiley Blackwell.
Christchurch City Council (2017). Christchurch Multicultural Strategy (2017–2021). Retrieved
from www.ccc.govt.nz/assets/Documents/The-Council/Plans-Strategies-Policies-Bylaws/
Strategies/Multicultural-Strategy.pdf
Dunn, M. (1996). Levels of War. Just a Set of Labels? Research and Analysis: Newsletter of the
Directorate of Army Research and Analysis, 10. Retrieved from www.clausewitz.com/readings/
Dunn.htm
Get up! (2019). About Us: Vision & Mission. Retrieved from www.getup.org.au/about/about-us
Kirk, J. (2013). Apple’s Grand Strategy. Tech Opinions (24 October). Retrieved from https://
techpinions.com/apples-grand-strategy/24375
Working strategically 207
Kolowich, L. (2019). 17 Truly Inspiring Company Vision and Mission Statement Examples.
Hubspot (17 February, last updated 19 February). Retrieved from https://blog.hubspot.com/
marketing/inspiring-company-mission-statements
Lumen Learning (n.d.). Module 3 Planning and Mission: Mission, Vision and Values, Princi-
ples of Management. Retrieved from https://courses.lumenlearning.com/wm-principlesof
management/chapter/reading-mission-vision-and-values/
Miller, B. (2014). Strategy, Mission, and Vision: How Do They All Fit Together? HR Daily
Advisor (9 September). Retrieved from https://hrdailyadvisor.blr.com/2014/09/09/strategy-
mission-and-vision-how-do-they-all-fit-together/
Mintzberg, H. (1992). Five Ps for Strategy. In H. Mintzberg and J.B. Quinn (eds), The Strategy
Process (pp. 12–19). Englewood Cliffs NJ: Prentice-Hall International Editions.
——— & Waters, J.A. (1985). Of Strategies, Deliberate and Emergent. Strategic Management
Journal, 6(3), 257–272.
Nickols, F. (2012). Strategy: Definitions and Meaning, Distance Consulting. Retrieved from https://
nickols.us/strategy_definition.htm
Sanford (2018). Annual Report: The Elements. Retrieved from www.sanford.co.nz/assets/
announcements/Sanford-Annual-Report-2018-web.pdf
Suby, S. (2016). 6 Top Marketing Strategies from Fortune 500 Companies. King Kong
(28 January). Retrieved from https://kingkong.com.au/6-top-marketing-strategies-from-
fortune-500-companies/
Sull, D. (2015). Closing the Gap between Strategy and Execution. In Top 10 Lessons On Strategy:
MIT Sloan Management Review (pp. 52–60). Boston, MA: MIT Press.
Tilley, E. (2009). Strategy and Planning. In J. Johnston & C. Zawawi (eds), Public Relations:
Theory and Practice (3rd edn) (pp. 171–205). Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
——— (2014) Strategy and Planning. In J. Johnston & M. Sheehan (eds), Public Relations: Theory
and Practice (4th edn) (pp. 77–107). Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
UNHCR The UN Refugee Agency (2017). UNHCR’s Strategic Directions (2017–2021).
Retrieved from www.unhcr. org/5894558d4.pdf
Volunteering New Zealand (2019). VNZ Strategic Plan (2019–2022). Retrieved from www.
volunteeringnz.org.nz/strategic-plan/
Yeong, N. (2018). The Marketing Strategy of Apple: A Concise Analysis. Version Daily
(26 January). Retrieved from www.versiondaily.com/the-marketing-strategy-of-apple-a-
concise-analysis/
Zerfass, A., Verc̆ic̆, D., Nothhaft, H & Page Werder, K. (2018). Strategic Communication:
Defining the Field and its Contribution to Research and Practice. International Journal of
Strategic Communication, 12(4), 487–505.
Chapter 8
The strategy has been set and the organisation has its direction. But what does
this mean for the communication manager and staff? How can communication
assist the organisation in reaching its aims? What does it need to do and how
does it do it? In this chapter we explore the planning process, moving from the
strategic level to the operational level—from the long-term thinking to what
you will do today.
Effective communication doesn’t just happen. It requires research, a
thorough understanding of the environment in which you are working, who
you are communicating with and what you are aiming to achieve. It needs
planning. Without a plan, your milestone birthday party would be a lonely
affair, in the wrong location, with no food or music. Instead, to ensure a
memorable celebration, you start to plan months ahead, thinking about what
location, guests, food, drinks and activities would make it a raging success.
You work out what can be achieved within your budget, choose a suitable
time and carefully craft your Facebook invitation to persuade everyone that it
will be a great night. And after the event, you sit back and reflect on the glory
of a successful party while thinking about what could be done even better
next time.
The processes you have used for your party are not that different from any
other form of planning activity. A common pattern to planning exists, whether
it be a business strategy, a government initiative, a program of advocacy or
208
Planning and campaign development 209
Figure 8.1 Examples of plans at the strategic, operational and tactical levels.
• A strategic plan outlines the broader vision, goals and objectives over a longer
time frame, typically three to five years, giving general direction to the
organisation. It specifies the priorities and broad strategies without stipulat-
ing the day-to-day activities needed to achieve them. This is what we have
outlined as the ‘grand strategy’ in Chapter 7, illustrated in the Australian
Heritage, Christchurch Multicultural and UNHCR examples of goal-
seeking, aspirational strategies. While this level usually focuses on the overall
organisational/corporate plan (or strategy), a corporate communication plan
that outlines the broader communication goals for the entire organisation
over a year or more could also be considered strategic. The same applies for
issues management, marketing and business unit strategies.
Planning and campaign development 211
Communication campaigns
From a communication perspective, the organisation’s strategic plans set the
direction for all lower-level, and shorter duration, operational communica-
tion plans. In a sense, the strategy for corporate communication will be like a
business plan for the communication department in a medium to large organ-
isation. This is sometimes referred to as a program, as it details a collection of
communication activities addressing a broader, more complex issue, targeted at
numerous publics over an extended period. It could encompass multiple inter-
related campaigns or constitute a single campaign with different phases.
At the operational level, communication campaigns serve a number of
different purposes. Taking their direction from the goals and objectives of the
strategic-level plans and programs, operational campaigns differ in that they
generally address single issues, in fixed time frames, with a clear start and end.
Different types of operational plans may guide a campaign, each with a slightly
different focus, but they follow similar frameworks and often overlap. The
broader issue, risk and crisis management of the organisation, for example,
could lead to operational plans for issue, risk and crisis communication, or
212 Process, planning and implementation
SOCIETY / ENVIRONMENT
INPUTS
PLANNING
Situation Publics Goal Action Admin Review
analysis analysis setting planning planning planning
• Problem or • Identification • Goals and • Messages • Schedules • Measurement
Opportunity • Analysis objectives • Tactics • Budgets plan
• Environment • Prioritisation • Action • Channels • Evaluation
plan
IMPLEMENTATION
Let’s start with the situation. Think about the big picture—the problem
that needs to be fixed or opportunity to be grasped. You need to accurately
identify what that problem or opportunity is and unpack the issues that sit
behind it—a process that is often overlooked in the hurry to get the campaign
off and running.
One method to assist in this analysis is represented in Austin and Pinkle-
ton’s approach to building a problem statement (Austin & Pinkleton 2015,
pp. 23–24), where they ask the six questions shown in Table 8.1.
Question Examples
What is the problem? Damaged reputation, declining
membership or sales, impending
legislation
Where is the problem occurring? Internal/external, local/national/
international, within certain groups
When is it a problem? Always/occasionally, seasonal,
cyclical
How did it become a problem? Lack of awareness, product quality,
ineffective relations
Who is the target and for whom is Specific stakeholders
this a problem?
Why does this threaten the The implications of the problem,
organisation’s ability to fulfil its threats to future operations or
mission? negative impacts on individuals
Now take a look outside the organisation. Smith suggests that you look at
four elements in the external environment: supporters, opponents, competitors
and external impediments (Smith 2017, p. 50). And he also recommends assess-
ing the visibility and reputation of the organisation. Informal desktop research
is a good starting point; however, additional primary research may be required.
Some quick questions to ask then would include:
216 Process, planning and implementation
Turning the focus inwards, start by looking at other plans that could inform,
guide or complement the one you are developing. Audit the performance of
your organisation and its communication and determine its capacity to take on
the work being planned. Some information may be easily available, but other
issues could require informal or formal research. Input from key stakeholders,
including management and employees, is valuable at this early stage. Questions
that could be investigated here include:
Now that you have a good idea of the problem and the external and internal
factors being encountered, attention can turn to the organisation’s publics—
drilling down into who they are, their interests, their preferred method of
engagement and the relationship they have with the organisation. Two main
steps are involved here: the identification and the analysis of the publics.
Publics can be identified in terms of broad categories such as employees,
consumers, community, media, government, suppliers and investors. But that is
just the start. Broad groups such as ‘the community’ or the ‘general public’ are
not helpful in a planning sense. Each of these categories can be broken down
into smaller and more well-defined characteristics using factors such as demo-
graphics, geographics and psychographics, or by their level of influence within
their own communities. For example, when considering government, are the
publics local, state-based, national or international? Do you need to engage
specific politicians, special committees or public servants? Which departments
218 Process, planning and implementation
and agencies? Or, for a not-for-profit campaign, are you targeting everyone
in your attempts to rescue abandoned puppies or do you want dog-lovers of
certain age groups with stable homes?
Once the publics have been identified, understanding their characteristics
and needs will assist in developing more accurate messages and tactics. Not
all publics will be interested in engaging with the organisation all the time.
Their level of interest and activity will vary across time, depending on the situ-
ation. For example, some publics will be highly engaged and interested in all
issues; others will be more active on single issues of interest; and some publics
may only attend to ‘hot issues’ that receive intense public interest
for short periods of time (Grunig 2013, p. 836). A useful theory
situational that addresses this is situational theory of publics (Grunig 2013,
theory of pp. 834–836; Aldoory & Sha 2007).
publics This theory considers publics to be either active or passive in the
way they seek out information (deliberate search or accidental encoun-
ter) and process it (the level of attention and thought). Three variables that will
influence their level of activity, presented from the public’s point of view, are:
If the public can answer yes to all three variables, they are considered to
be an active public, or even an activist public if they become involved by sharing
information. If they are missing one or two of the variables, then they could
be considered aware, latent or apathetic publics, with the potential to become
active. Figure 8.4 explains the differences between each of the publics, and
suggests actions and responses that organisations could take to assist publics to
be more active.
These stages of development may give some indication as to which publics
may be the most interested and active, but another factor to consider is the
power that the publics have over the organisation—be it political, economic or
social. An interest/power matrix (see Figure 8.5 below) maps these two factors
against each other. Plotting each public on the matrix can assist in determining
which ones to address first. The matrix can also be used to consider the most
appropriate communication strategies to use (Gregory 2007, p. 66).
Planning and campaign development 219
Figure 8.4 Stages of development of publics. Source: adapted from Smith (2017,
pp. 80–83); Aldoory & Sha (2007); Grunig (2013).
L
An analysis of key publics, in relation to the conservation aspect of the zoo’s
function, revealed key publics to be addressed.
• Young adults, school students, interstate and international visitors share the
passion of conservation but are not aware of the Zoo’s role in it (latent publics).
• National conservationists are not aware of the Zoo’s work and achieve-
ments (latent public).
• Potential sponsors are aware of conservation issues but prioritise other issues
within their CSR programs (apathetic public).
• Zoo volunteers are passionate about conservation but not sure how to help
(aware public).
performance, then the goal will focus on rebuilding and strengthening those
relationships. At this stage, no detail on how that will be done is given, just
the identification of a preferred end state. Goals can address organisational
reputations and relationships, or they could be task-oriented—‘concerned with
getting things done’ (Smith 2017, p. 106). A plan may have one or a few goals
but, to keep the focus, don’t have too many.
Objectives emerge from these goals, providing greater specificity about
what milestones need to be reached on the way to achieving the broader goal.
Each goal may therefore have multiple objectives but, again, the number needs
to remain manageable. Objectives are clear statements of intent and need to
be SMART—specific, measurable, achievable, relevant (or realistic) and time-
specific. In doing so, they set the direction for the tactics while also establishing
the parameters for measuring success.
Objectives need to focus on outcomes (what will be achieved) rather than
outputs (what will be done). To achieve specificity and make an objective useful,
numerous elements should be included.
Some potential goals and objectives for our Lakeview Zoo communica-
tion campaign are listed below. Note the relationships between the goals
and objectives, as well as the structure and the SMART elements in each of
the objectives.
Goal 1: Build a reputation as national leaders in animal conservation
(reputational goal).
• Objective 2.1: Attract 100 attendees to two key partnership events in the
next six months.
• Objective 2.2: Increase the satisfaction rate of Lakeview Zoo’s volunteer
brigade by 15 per cent over the next twelve months.
• Objective 2.3: Increase corporate sponsorship by 10 per cent over the next
twelve months.
Planning and campaign development 223
Until now you have resisted the temptation to come up with creative ideas
to reach out to your publics. But now that you have some direction from the
goals and objectives, you can get down to the tactical level to specify the actions
to be taken. In this step, consider three aligned elements that will determine
what you do to achieve the goals and objectives that have been set: the messages,
the tactics and the channels.
The first part of action planning is to decide on the messaging that will be
used to achieve the objectives. Again, this should be derived from the strategic
direction, such as a positioning statement or the direction given in the objec-
tives. Message strategies should be kept simple and consistent. A key message
that encompasses all publics and actions provides a common voice but can still
be tailored to fit each circumstance. It can be used in all aspects of the campaign
from printed material, to media interviews, speeches, websites and social media.
Careful crafting of the message will assist in it being accepted and retained
by the targeted audience. In other words,
[m]essages and the way they are conveyed are the starting point of the thinking,
attitude or behavioural change that the organisation is seeking. Badly done,
they can be the end point too. (Gregory 2000, p. 113)
• state facts
• highlight the virtue of something
• suggest a new way of doing something
• seek the audience’s agreement, advocacy about an issue or behaviour change.
224 Process, planning and implementation
At the same time, you should consider the ethical and legal consequences of
messages. Words and images/vision should not promise what cannot be deliv-
ered. They need to be clear and inoffensive, avoid jargon and, where necessary,
translate to other languages without causing confusion.
Messages can be both verbal and non-verbal, so cues such as logos,
colours, symbols and music can complement or replace words in messaging.
Think of the power of an advertising jingle that sticks in your head or the
power of the colour red for Coke, KFC, Vodafone and Qantas.
Messages need to be developed with the audience in mind—
they need to tap into the interests of the public, not be driven by
The Hierarchy
the needs or perspectives of the organisation. Understanding how
of Effects
model messages are received and processed by the audience will assist in
developing messages with impact (Austin & Pinkleton 2015). The
Hierarchy of Effects model explains how people move through
stages of understanding, first needing to be aware of a product or
The Elaboration issue before they can form an attitude and preference for it, which,
Likelihood in turn, may lead to a behaviour change.
theory The Elaboration Likelihood theory shows us that our messages
are more likely to be considered more intently by audiences who feel
they have a stake in the issue being addressed, while others who use
a more peripheral route to processing information will lean more
Diffusion of
heavily on the credibility of the source rather than the content of the
Innovation message (e.g. Diffusion of Innovation).
Messages can have various types of structures, including:
– related messages:
° ‘I can’t fight for your mate’s life if I’m fighting for mine’
° ‘Everyone deserves to be safe at work’
° ‘Make it socially unacceptable for any of your mates to threaten or
assault an ambo’.
Key messaging for this campaign will be about the work and achievements in
conservation, but this will be adapted for each audience depending on the
factors above as well as the objectives. For example, to increase volunteers’
satisfaction rating, the key message can be tailored to show how they contrib-
ute personally to the global conservation movement. This might also include
providing t-shirts with the key message so they can showcase the cause and
also show off their involvement. Potential sponsors could be given emotional
messages that show the threat to global conservation if the Zoo’s work is not
maintained. Targeting school children with the messages, to show they can
be part of the solution, potentially targets both holiday volunteers and school
sponsorships.
L
Numerous actions could be taken to address each of the objectives separately,
or a single action could address multiple objectives. Actions addressing the first
objective,
could include:
These actions may also address some of the other objectives or comple-
ment other actions.
The deciding factor is clarity: a clear structure will facilitate logical imple-
mentation.
L
Let’s look at some of the objectives for the Lakeview Zoo discussed earlier to help
select the channels. If we are to reach young adults from our city, then relevant
communication channels could be through social media, most likely Instagram
and YouTube, or events that they attend, such as music festivals, perhaps using
visual displays and roving ambassadors. For social media it’s important to use a
range of channels and hashtags such as #Lakeviewzoo. To reach the local and
international visitors who are already at the Zoo, communication channels could
228 Process, planning and implementation
Figure 8.6 Using hashtag #gianttortoise and this image would be simpler than
trying to describe this tortoise in words. Photo by Dušan Smetana, Unsplash.
Planning and campaign development 229
Now that the actions have been planned, the administrative requirements
for implementation need to be specified. Schedule and budgets are central to
this step of the planning process, but related to this is the need to consider the
human and material resources required and the allocation of responsibilities to
individuals to ensure the tasks are done. This is the project management phase.
One of the first considerations will be whether there is a need to establish
separate phases in the campaign. If the campaign is particularly complex, has
many parts working simultaneously or is spread over a long time, the division of
actions into phases may assist in keeping the project on track. Phases allow for
grouping activities into smaller elements with shorter time periods, allowing
monitoring and adjustment as the larger project continues.
Schedules ensure that everyone is aware of what is happening and provide
frameworks for discussions in team meetings. In that sense, schedules provide an
avenue for communication between multiple parts of the organisation involved
in the project. The schedules not only specify the deadlines for each activity
but also show the relationships between each element to achieve maximum
coordination and impact from an integrated approach. They list each activity
in the order in which they need to be undertaken, highlighting the schedul-
ing of simultaneous activities. The schedule also specifies milestones, such as
planning meetings, the end of phases, approval deadlines, evaluation activities
and the production and distribution of materials.
Schedules serve as the framework for monitoring and controlling a project.
Various tools can be used to map out the schedule, from a simple to-do list or
spreadsheet to more complex software programs, such as Microsoft Project,
that manage the resources and budgets as well. These are often based on
Gantt chart methods, which display the activities to be completed in a vertical
list on the left side of the chart. The total time required for implementation is
mapped across the top of the chart and broken into manageable time frames,
230 Process, planning and implementation
It is not just about costs. The budget should also specify whether there
will be any income to offset those costs (such as sponsorship, entry fees, sales
of merchandise) and what portion of the activity the company will need to
cover. This could also include where you have ‘in-kind’ support, such as where
a butcher provides meat for a fundraising event at no cost but expects signage
on the tent and program. You would mark this as no cost if that was the case,
but it could still be included in the overall budget to give visibility of their
involvement.
Primarily a budget will forecast the expenses and income; it should
then be used as a monitoring tool to keep track of the actual costs. In this
way, savings made in some areas may be reallocated to others as the plan is
being implemented. The use of a spreadsheet, or other program that allows
you to insert formulae for the subtotal and totals, will allow for easier adjust-
ment as the project continues. A simple example of a budget is shown in
Figure 8.8.
The organisation’s financial standing should always be considered and,
in the case of not-for-profit organisations, care needs to be taken to avoid
overspending or being seen to be wasting the valuable resources of the organi-
sation. When resources are few, there is a need to be creative in your approach
to budgets and to look for opportunities to save or to bring in additional
funds. Budget saving ideas include the use of volunteers, asking for
donations from attendees, seeking corporate sponsorship or sharing
costs through collaboration with like-minded organisations. For non- cause-
marketing
profits, the adoption of a cause-marketing approach can be very
useful as well.
232 Process, planning and implementation
L
The time constraints set by the objectives will dictate the total length of this
campaign, but some activities may need to fit around timelines set by third parties,
such as the conservation awards and music festivals. Each tactic will need to be
broken into more specific tasks and milestones, and monitoring and evaluation
activities will also need to be included. Considering the financial status of the Zoo,
care will need to be taken in the selection and funding of the tactics.
Planning and campaign development 233
In the final step, plans need to be prepared for the monitoring, measure-
ment and evaluation of the communication campaign. This is a straightforward
procedure which lists the actions that will be taken to determine the extent
to which the objectives have been met. More detailed information about the
research involved in measurement and evaluation is provided in Chapter 6.
The focus in this chapter is on the details that need to be included at the end
of the written plan.
Two main processes need to be mapped in the review phase: the measure-
ment of outputs and the evaluation of outcomes. Both are valuable but they
serve different purposes. Outputs, the activities that ‘reach and engage the target
public/s’ (PRIA 2017, p. 2), are measured in terms of the material produced and
the numbers reached. In this way, the strategic communication and PR practi-
tioner can account for what has been done. But to assess what has been achieved,
there needs to be an evaluation of outcomes, ‘what the target public/s take out
of communication and initial responses . . . and . . . what sustainable effects the
communication has on the target public’ (PRIA 2017, p. 2).
The plan for measuring outputs should include the expected metrics and
timeline of key activities—how they will be measured and what are accept-
able benchmarks. For example, quantitative information about the amount
of coverage in news media, or the number of newsletters, social media posts
or event attendees, gives an indication of the work that is being done. At the
same time, further information should be collected regarding responses to
messaging and the effectiveness of the channels of communication to assess
whether changes need to be made to the plan while it is being implemented.
The scheduling of the measurement is important; while final statistics and
results are useful at the end of the campaign, measurement should also
be taken periodically, which is often referred to as tracking research or
monitoring.
234 Process, planning and implementation
The plan for evaluation could also be phased throughout the implemen-
tation, assessing the effects on the publics at key milestones in the campaign.
Measuring outcomes is more difficult because they are often less tangible,
but they should tie in to your objectives. The objectives set at the start of the
planning process will dictate what outcomes need to be evaluated and accept-
able levels of success. For example, if the objective is to achieve a 20 per cent
growth in awareness over a six-month period, then a survey to see how much
the targeted public knows about the issue or product would be appropriate.
As the measure is in terms of growth, there will need to be similar research
conducted before the campaign starts to provide a benchmark. A clear align-
ment between the objectives and the evaluation needs to be made explicit in
the plan.
The key to planning the monitoring and evaluation of this campaign is to anchor
it in the objectives (see p. 222). For example, for the objective of increasing
awareness of the 18- to 35-year-old local residents, a number of tasks will
need to be undertaken, including establishing the baseline level of awareness
before the campaign starts and the replication of the same measurement tool
at the end of the campaign. However, as the objective attempts to change
their knowledge of the conservation plan, messages may need to be tested
and modified in the planning or early implementation phases for greater
impact.
Tools such as surveys will be needed to evaluate the awareness, attitude
and behavioural changes sought in the objectives, but reporting on outputs
throughout the implementation will also give management some confi-
dence that the campaign is proceeding to plan. Statistics on social and news
media activities, reach and engagement may be useful for this purpose. For
example, tracking hashtags and the sharing of key messages can provide
insights.
Planning and campaign development 235
Conclusion
There is an old adage of unknown origin, often attributed to Benjamin Franklin,
that says: ‘The person who fails to plan, plans to fail’ (O’Toole 2018). No matter
who said it, it rings true. But equally, a good plan is just the starting point. Once
the implementation starts, previously unknown factors will place unexpected
Planning and campaign development 237
References
Aldoory, L. & Sha, B-L. (2007). The Situational Theory of Publics: Practical Applications,
Methodological Challenges, and Theoretical horizons. In E.L. Toth (ed.), The Future of
Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management: Challenges for the Next Genera-
tion (pp. 339–356). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Austin, E.W. & Pinkleton, B.E. (2015). Strategic Public Relations Management: Planning and
Managing Effective Communication Programs (3rd edn). New York, NY: Routledge.
Brunner, B.R. (2019). Public Relations Theory: Application and Understanding. Hoboken, NJ: John
Wiley & Sons.
Coombs, W.T. & Holladay, S.J. (2018). Innovation in Public Relations Theory and Practice:
A Transmedia Narrative Transportation (TNT) Approach. Journal of Communication
Management, 22(4), 382–396.
Gregory, A. (2000). Planning and Managing Public Relations Campaigns (2nd edn). London: Kogan
Page.
——— (2007). Involving Stakeholders in Developing Corporate Brands: The Communication
Dimension. Journal of Marketing Management, 23(1–2), 59–73.
238 Process, planning and implementation
——— (2017). Strategic Public Relations Planning and Management. In R. Tench & L. Yeomans
(eds), Exploring Public Relations: Global Strategic Communication (4th edn) (pp. 168–195).
Harlow: Pearson Education Limited.
Grunig, J.E. (2013). Situational Theory of Publics. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public
Relations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
O’Toole, G. (2018). The Quote Investigator. Retrieved from https://quoteinvestigator.com/2018/
07/08/plan/
PRIA (Public Relations Institute of Australia) (2017). Measurement and Evaluation Framework.
Retrieved from www.pria.com.au/education/measurement-evaluation/measurement-
evaluation-framework/
Smith, R.D. (2017). Strategic Planning for Public Relations (5th edn). New York, NY: Routledge.
Sull, D. (2015). Closing the Gap between Strategy and Execution. In Top 10 Lessons on Strategy:
MIT Sloan Management Review (pp. 52–60). Boston, MA: MIT Press.
Chapter 9
239
240 Process, planning and implementation
the best outcomes in terms of objectives, goals, strategies and plans for the
organisation.
To give you a sense of the vast choice of tactics, we’ve put together our
‘Top 100 Tactics’ later in the chapter. This is not intended to be a compre-
hensive list (that would be impossible); it’s just a sampler of the many tactics
available for selection by the strategic communication practitioner. We’ve also
explained how tactics work in a bit more detail, providing a range of examples
in the chapter. And we examine two critical parts of tactic development and
execution—content creation and distribution. The creation of most tactics
and how these are distributed to the audience incorporate both the creative and
technical skills that you need to bring to the strategic communication mix.
Controlled/uncontrolled tactics
There is a long-standing distinction in public relations between what are known
as controlled and uncontrolled communication tactics. Controlled communication
is managed right through delivery, from its creation to how it finally connects
with stakeholders—through things such as advertising, brochures, books and
events. Uncontrolled communication, on the other hand, involves third parties
who may change the communication during the process, and so it cannot be
managed right through the delivery stage. Traditionally, this was best represented
by media releases, sent to the news media and transformed into news outside the
control of the public relations practitioner. While this distinction does still exist,
the digital media environment has mixed up much communication activity so
that it is now often co-created or co-produced and the clear distinction between
creator/producer and audience/sender no longer exists. As we saw in the media
chapter, the contemporary converged and shared online media environment
means that many tactics are created by one person and then changed or adapted
as they move from person to person. Stories and content are shared; mash-ups
and memes are created. In the world of media, this is usefully expressed in the
PESO model outlined in Chapter 5 (Dietrich 2013). In that model, paid, earned,
shared and owned media are shown as overlapping (see Figure 5.1).
Whereas control of the message and distribution of content was once
considered paramount in strategic communication and PR, the lack of control
Tactic selection and content creation 241
has become one of the fundamental elements of content and distribution today.
Successful companies and other organisations realise that getting others to
co-create for them can be one of the most valuable tactics available. At the same
time, taking care with ‘owned’ tactic selection, combining different tactics in
the most strategic ways, and making sure these are timed and pitched appro-
priately can mean the difference between hitting your target and missing the
mark. We now take a look at how to go about tactic selection and how content
and distribution can be best managed.
Tactic selection
Carefully selected and combined tactics provide the opportunity to create
great impact and achieve our goals and objectives. Increasingly they are used in
combination because of the many platforms and delivery methods available to
reach different stakeholders. Where once a single media release to a journalist
may have achieved the simple purpose of letting the media and your audience
know your story, these days you’d also use Twitter to send the same message
because it’s so popular with media. However, while you’re at it, you might
as well repurpose your story for your owned platforms, such as Instagram.
A combination of the digital as well as traditional options can usually work
well to cover your bases. Strong tactics should take into account a range of
important issues such as timing, the context in which they will be used, cost,
opportunity, resourcing, reach and ethics. However, as Adams points out,
‘tactics should not be chosen using a shopping list approach . . . they must
relate to the stakeholders and must be part of an overall creative strategy’
(Adams 2014, p. 132).
As we saw in the previous chapter, tactics equate to ‘action planning’. They
are chosen to achieve the goals and objectives and to activate the strategy. In
their many and varied forms (see the Top 100 table below), they are also the
best way to deliver key messages and the stories that you want to tell. Story-
telling is now among the most popular tactics—this is made clear in our later
discussion on content creation. In the following case study, we take a look at
the stories and other tactics used by the natural cosmetic brand Burt’s Bees.
Here, we trace the brand’s strategy, first through its story and then through the
242 Process, planning and implementation
It began in Maine about 30 years ago. Burt the Beekeeper was happily
selling honey from the back of his truck. But fate had other ideas for the
bearded hero when he met Roxanne Quimby. Burt and Roxanne hit it off
and before long she was making candles with unused wax from Burt’s
beehives. From those original candles, to the iconic Beeswax Lip Balm, to over
180 products—Burt’s Bees has been guided by a single principle: Nature has
the best answers. (Burt’s Bees 2019a)
This is a great start to the story about Burt’s love of bees and everything
bee-worthy, which continues as the tactics seem to organically unfold. Burt’s
has partnered with Sydney’s Taronga Zoo to develop a conservation and
education observation exhibit. The key message is: ‘A world without bees is
unimaginable and we’re committed to supporting our buzzing friends’ (Burt’s
Bees 2019b). Burt’s has also committed to philanthropy by setting up the
‘Wheen Bee Foundation’—a not-for-profit that promotes awareness of the impor
tance of bees for food security. It explains what plants work best for bees and
the importance of bees in the pollination process and the survival of flowering
plants. A YouTube link on the website shows a raft of media coverage from
television, print and online showcasing the #BringBackTheBees campaign and
including an interview with Sydney-based artist and influencer Mulga painting
a cool mural that depicts the kinds of foods that would not exist without bees.
The campaign is also promoted by nude nutritionist and influencer Lyndi
Cohen, who explains how ‘pollination is responsible for one in every three bites
Tactic selection and content creation 243
of foods that we eat’ and also conducts some vox-pop interviews with passers-
by in the Sydney streets. The campaign is a fundraiser, committing $1 for each
limited-edition lip balm that’s sold. The website houses YouTube, Instagram,
Twitter and Facebook social media links.
That’s at least twelve tactics on our count—and we didn’t even look that hard!
(Also note, that’s just the Australian story—the website provides language-
specific links to 21 countries, many featuring different stories and campaigns.
You might want to go international and look at the others.)
Figure 9.1 Joel Moore aka Mulga (right) and another artist paint the
#BringBackTheBees mural as part of the campaign of the same name in Sydney
(on the corner of York and Wynyard streets). Source: Burt’s Bees.
244 Process, planning and implementation
Figure 9.2 Content creation and curation are both part of the storytelling mix.
Adapted from SketchBubble (n.d.).
246 Process, planning and implementation
This approach of
• creating
• composing
• curating
• crowdsourcing
acknowledges the many and varied ways content is created and co-created,
shared, integrated, modified, enhanced, published and distributed. Each of the
four Cs adds a layer to help explain how content can be developed at the organi-
sational and individual level, in institutional and personal contexts. Online media
content grows daily. What we need are tools to better understand and manage
the proliferation of content and how we can use it, ethically and strategically, as
communication practitioners seeking to benefit and contribute to this culture.
Delivery methods
We’ve already begun talking about delivery methods as part of the sharing
and participatory approach to content. But how does this work in practice? And
how do we choose the best methods of message or content delivery? As digital
marketing expert Kevin Cain (n.d.) points out:
248 Process, planning and implementation
It’s only after you have created something great that the real work begins as you
try to figure out all of the best ways of delivering that content to your target
audience. After all, no matter how good your content is, it’s never going to get
consumed unless that content reaches your audience.
You will be familiar with many of the delivery methods available to distrib-
ute your content: social media, email, video sharing and that old favourite—the
post! You’ll also have seen how businesses use these methods to connect with
you through paid advertising on social media. You might have even found a
direct mail in your letter box at the last election (this method is on its way out
but still pops up at election times).
Strategic communicators use these various delivery methods and many
more. They publish on their own websites and through email, distribute to the
online, print, radio and television news media, create billboard or bus shelter
signage (part of ‘ambient’ publicity or advertising—see this explained in the
Top 100), seek sponsorships and even use skywriting (where the sky is, literally,
the limit!). Cain suggests the following tips for content distribution:
a teaser out and driving traffic back to base—this is also a major function
of social media.
3. Social media channels. Due to the massive choice of social media channels
you have to be selective and focus on the ones that will work best for you.
The key is to aim for a select number of channels that will have the highest
impact with your target stakeholders. Typically, in Australia and New
Zealand, this might include a combination of the following main channels:
Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, TikTok and YouTube (plus any
of the major up-and-coming channels). In other countries, like China, you
would use WeChat or Weibo. You need to do your homework on which
of these your target stakeholder groups engage with. Social media is one of
the best-known tactics to raise brand awareness, foster engagement and
develop a community. It’s also a great way to get others to co-create or
share your story. For example, see how Twitter is used by Ariana Grande
and Bernie Sanders in Chapter 10.
4. eNewsletter. Newsletters have always been a great way to deliver content
and raise awareness about lots of stories. The eNewsletter is a simple and
effective method for making contact with stakeholders, driving website
traffic and encouraging engagement. Aim to keep eNewsletters regular—
weekly usually works best—for regular updates. Keep the content short and
pithy, new and fresh so that you grow your numbers.
5. Influencers and journalists. This list includes bloggers, consultants,
analysts, so-called ‘thought leaders’ and others who influence s takeholders
by connecting with them. These people will usually be chosen because
they have clout and reach that you probably don’t. Building strong rela-
tionships with influencers and journalists enables you to distribute your
content via them, with two huge advantages: first, it creates an opportu-
nity to get your content out to the influencer’s large audience and, second,
it gives your content the added authority of being shared by that third
party (Cain n.d.).
Content creation and distribution are two sides of the same coin, meaning
they work in parallel and are equally important. Together they make up a
crucial part of the tactics tool-kit.
Although in the past branding has been more associated with market-
ing than public relations, this relationship approach to content marketing
Tactic selection and content creation 251
Figure 9.4 Muay Thai kick boxing in Cambodia—pick the sponsor! Photo by Pablo
Reballedo, Unsplash.
252 Process, planning and implementation
motorsports, ice-hockey, martial arts, e-sports, skiing, flying, cliff diving and
more. While Red Bull receives extensive media coverage, its tactics are about
associating the brand image, the Red Bull, with a ‘feeling’ (lifestyle or image)
rather than a drink, and developing a community among its followers.
Conclusion
If you thought communication tactics began and ended with social media,
we hope we’ve convinced you to think again! Don’t misunderstand—we love
social media! However, it is only part of the media and communication mix,
representing just some of the tactics that are available to the communication
practitioner. Tactics are not chosen at random, nor should they just reflect what
you as a practitioner are most comfortable with—they should be strategically
selected to achieve a purpose, synchronise with and complement each other
and reach the target audiences you need to reach. Because of this, they will
differ from campaign to campaign, organisation to organisation, just like the
Burt’s Bees and Red Bull examples in this chapter—different objectives and
campaigns, and very different tactics.
Brisbane communication company BBS reminds us of the relationship
between tactics and the other functions in the strategic communication mix,
noting: ‘If you think of the plan as a journey, the objective is the end of the
path, the strategy is the direction that path takes and the tactics are what you do
along the path’ (BBS 2016). What you do along the path is choose, create,
develop, curate and deliver tactics—this is easily among the most exciting and
268 Process, planning and implementation
creative of all the communication roles. But if these are to be executed effec-
tively, they need to be supported by a solid foundation at the start of the journey
and along the path, and this calls for research, strategy and planning.
References
Adams, P. (2014). Tactics. In J. Johnston & M. Sheehan (eds), Public Relations: Theory & Practice
(pp. 108-136). Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
BBS Communication (2016). Strategy and Tactics: Why it’s Important to Know the Difference. Retrieved
from www.bbscommunications.com.au/strategy-tactics-important-know-difference/
Burt’s Bees (2019a). Our Story: It’s Your Typical Beekeeper Meets Artist Story. Retrieved from
www.burtsbees.com.au/about-us/
——— (2019b). Outreach: Sweet Partnership to Save the Bees. Retrieved from www.burtsbees.com.
au/sweet-partnership-to-save-the-bees/
Cain, K. (n.d.). Making Contact: How You Deliver Your Content Matters. Convince & Convert.
Retrieved from www.convinceandconvert.com/content-marketing/making-contact-how-
you-deliver-your-content-matters/
Foo, S. (2020). Branded Content vs Content Marketing (All You Need to Know). SpeechSilver
(6 January).
Jenkins, H. (2007). Transmedia Storytelling. Blog post (21 March). Retrieved from http://henry
jenkins.org/blog/2007/03/transmedia_storytelling_101.html
Phillips Group (2020). What We Do. Expertise. Retrieved from www.phillipsgroup.com.au/
Rosenbaum, S. (2010). Why Content Curation is Here to Stay. Mashable (4 May). Retrieved from
https://mashable.com/2010/05/03/content-curation-creation/
SketchBubble (n.d.). Content Creation: What is Content Creation? Available from www.
sketchbubble.com/en/presentation-content-curation.html
Stein, M. (2019). Branded Content vs Content Marketing: What’s the Difference? VeraContent
(13 March). Retrieved from https://veracontent.com/2019/03/13/branded-content-vs-
content-marketing/
Villi, M., Moisander, J. & Joy, A. (2012). Social Curation in Consumer Communities: Consumers
as Curators of Online Media Content. Advances in Consumer Research, 40, 490–495.
Weissman, C.G. (2017). Why the Once Darling Storify is Coming to an End. FastCompany
(12 December). Retrieved from www.fastcompany.com/40506878/why-the-once-darling-
social-service-storify-is-coming-to-an-end
Wolff, A. & Mulholland, P. (2013). Curation, Curation, Curation. Proceedings of the 3rd Narrative
and Hypertext Workshop (pp. 1–5). Paris: ACM.
Zhong, C., Shah, S., Sundaravadivelan, K., & Sastry, N. (2013). Sharing the Loves: Understand-
ing the How and Why of Online Content Curation. Proceedings of the Seventh International
AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media (pp. 659-667). Retrieved from file:///F:/
Curating%20media/Journal%20articles/Sharing%20the%20loves.pdf
Part 3
Theory
Chapter 10
If learning starts with theory, then why put this chapter at the end of the book,
you may ask? There are two reasons for this: first, we understand that both
theory and the idea of theory can be daunting, so we think many students might
find theory easier to understand after the more practice-focused chapters;
second, you will have seen throughout the book that we have used sticky notes
to highlight many theories along the way. This has enabled you to read about
these theories in different contexts, in an applied way. This final chapter is
therefore set up so you can go directly to the theories flagged in the sticky notes
and learn a bit more about each of them. We’ve linked the theories—listed
alphabetically—back to where they sit in the book by providing page refer-
ences, and also included short explanations, related theories and key theorists
for you to further investigate. Due to the scope and range of theories that can
be applied to public relations, this chapter presents short ‘chunks’ of theories
and how they can be applied in practice. This cannot provide the depth of
knowledge you will need to write an essay or learn the complexity of any single
theory, but we think that, at an introductory level, it’s more useful to provide
you with the fundamentals of theories and their application, rather than dense
theoretical explanations or critiques that can bog you down. The chapter is
intended to be referred to as needed rather than read in a single session—kind
of like a ‘theory-pedia’ style chapter that we encourage you to drop in and
out of when you see a theory in the book and want to know more about it. We’d
rather you take away ideas from this chapter and use them as starting points for
further reading (we’ve added a few pointers for this at the chapter’s conclusion).
271
272 Theory
This is why we’ve suggested your theoretical journey starts here, because, in
a way, it does.
The word ‘theory’ comes from the Greek word ‘theōrein’, which means ‘to
look at’ (orgtheory, n.d.) or ‘theōria’, which means to ‘contemplate or speculate’
(Etymology Dictionary, n.d.). Following these definitions, we use theories to
examine, test, speculate about and explain things. Theories have been used
to test gravity, the speed of light, general relatively, evolution and other big
things. Most theories are not quite so grand, but they are still important in
providing a framework for examining what we do in the social sciences, human-
ities and business. Formal theories (and concepts and models), like the ones we
examine in this chapter, are recognised by specific academic disciplines. Of
course, there are also informal theories which we use to explain everyday life—
you might have a theory that if person A comes to a party, person B might get
upset; if you eat a tub of ice-cream every night you might put on weight; or, if
you don’t do much work in class you’ll get a pretty ordinary grade. We’ll stick
with formal theories in this chapter, but we remind the reader that theories
are simply tools to help us work out problems, get to know a subject better or
explain an issue, phenomenon or the reason for a specific outcome.
Why theory?
More than a century ago, educational theorist and philosopher John Dewey wrote
about the importance of connecting theory with practice; in doing so, he prior-
itised the need for reflective practice. Though his writing focused on education,
philosophy and democracy, there is much we can learn in strategic communi-
cation from his conceptions of the theory–practice nexus. Dewey argued that
reflective learning breaks down distinctions between thought-and-action and
theory-and-practice, and that it was a mode of inquiry central to experiential
learning (in Saltmarsh, 2011). Dewey’s approach to theory has much merit for
today and for our field—using it as a way of reflecting on practice, rather than
prescribing practice. As such, theory is one kind of experience; it is what Dewey
saw as an intermediate phase of inquiry, summed up in the following way:
As we live our lives, we confront problems which invoke the need for inquiry
and, often, there is a need to devise a tool of explanation and amelioration.
Theory is that tool, generated by these encounters. (Hildebrand 2018)
Theory: Where learning starts 273
Agenda setting theory Agenda setting theory centres on how the mass
media selects and prioritises news. In turn, people look to the media for
indications of where they should focus their attention and what issues are
priorities, based on the emphasis the media places (or does not place) on
issues. While personal beliefs, one-to-one discussions and peer groups also
Theory: Where learning starts 275
influence public opinion, the agenda setting theory focuses on the role of
the mass media in the process. Agenda setting recognises the role of news
gatekeepers—those people who choose what is important and newsworthy
and then determine its position among competing news stories. In tradi-
tional media, this gatekeeping role is undertaken by people such as news
editors and chiefs of staff. However, social media influencers and other
online thought leaders are also modern-day agenda setters, leading opinion
in everything from fashion to politics. An added dimension to this theory is
agenda building, which brings in other levels of influence that put issues
on the public agenda and influence public policy through publishing on
these issues. A related theory is framing or second-level agenda setting.
How it’s used: For public relations, agenda setting and agenda building enable
organisations to contribute to the public agenda by making their stories
rise to the top of the pile. We can consider two ways of getting involved
in agenda setting or agenda building: either proactively generating news,
issues or events, or reactively responding to news, issues and events. Both
are equally relevant and important as strategic communication tools. When
aiming to get your story onto the news agenda, consider those times of
the year when journalists are on the lookout for seasonal stories—like
Christmas. In 2019, Gold Coast Health’s Facebook page ran two upbeat
videos, having fun while working up to Christmas, sending key messages
about health and safety. Both videos were picked up by local television and
newspapers. Their public relations manager explained:
The rationale behind the videos was to show doctors and nurses as human
beings, using music as a way to relieve stress for positive mental health. It also
promotes a ‘they are just like me’ mentality as part of an effort to improve
health literacy and communication between patients and clinicians. The
Christmas videos continued the messaging, as the hospital enters its busiest
time of the year around the festive season when the Gold Coast’s tourist
population swells and people may be faced with longer waiting times. Not
only did this style of social media activity promote earned media coverage,
Gold Coast Health saw an average 10-fold increase in viewers and around a
20-fold increase in engagement and positive sentiment in its owned media.
(Sullivan 2019)
276 Theory
In this book: see pp. 67, 227, 287, 290, 291, 306.
See also: framing theory; mediatisation.
Look up: Max McCombs & Donald Shaw; Everett Rogers & James Dearing.
How it’s used: Often used in a product marketing sense, understanding how atti-
tudes develop and lead to actions can help the communicator develop and
target messaging for the best effect. An appeal to an audience’s emotions
can be more effective if the message is about a charitable cause or a luxury
product. An appeal to cognitions, however, may be necessary if the message
is about solving a problem or purchasing a hi-tech product. Electioneering
typically sees a mix of both affective and cognitive appeals to win over the
public vote.
or service assistance that can help a community grow its skills or improve
access to resources, economic development and quality of life. Capacity
building is typically associated with assisting communities to help them-
selves, often incorporating assistance from government or non-government
organisations (NGOs). While external organisations often lead in capacity
building, engaging and involving community members has been found to
be a crucial component of capacity building as they can identify local gaps,
strengths, opportunities, and priorities (Cavaye n.d.). This makes social and
human capital central components of capacity building.
all of its stakeholders. However, this needs to balance the cost of corpo-
rate citizenship activities against the cost of manufacturing and marketing
products and services in a responsible manner. Increasingly this balance
is aligned with the related concept of social enterprise. International
standards associations such as Transparency International and Social
Accountability International provide frameworks for developing best
practices in the area of corporate citizenship.
How it’s used: It is not difficult to imagine how corporate citizenship works for
public relations—in fact it should be embedded in corporate strategies.
Corporate citizenship impacts on relationships with all stakeholders—
consumers, employees, investors and competitors. Online ratings and
rankings have made corporate citizenship all the more transparent, placing
an added pressure to perform at this level. Deakin University’s Centre for
Sustainable and Responsible Organisations provides many examples of
corporate citizenship and CSR. An example of how corporate citizenship
works alongside social enterprise is outlined in the ‘Thankyou’ story in
Chapter 2.
In this book: see pp. 41, 60, 76, 79, 256, 284–5, 305.
See also: CSR; social enterprise.
Look up: Malcolm McIntosh; Transparency International.
Critical theory Critical theory (also called critical social theory) is a set of
theoretical frameworks that consider injustice and oppression in society and
culture, suggesting how to create possibilities for the freedom and equality
of people and values. It emerged in Germany in the 1930s as a theory that
critiqued, rather than explained, society. It criticises the way people are
influenced to think by capitalist and neo-liberalist cultures, particularly
by powerful players that either control the mass media or dominate other
communication methods. Critical race theory has grown alongside (or
out of) it and calls out the injustices faced by minority groups. An associ-
ated theory is the public sphere, which once considered how public places
enabled people to come together to discuss social problems and political
action and to form public opinion. A problem with public sphere theory
was that it was exclusionary towards minority groups and so it was revised
to account for how multiple publics exist in multiple public spheres.
Theory: Where learning starts 279
How it’s used: Critical theorists argue that public relations assists corporations
and governments to maintain a privileged position in society, by excluding
voices from public debate. This theory calls for organisations and institu-
tions which are big and powerful to carefully consider how their actions may
manipulate or distort communication, or publics through communication.
Because critical theory focuses on critiquing capitalism and neo-liberalism,
and the exploitation that results from them, public relations should be
aware of the relationship dynamic and asymmetries that exist in the society
of which they are a part.
How it’s used: While cultivation theory originally examined violence on tele
vision, it has been expanded and updated to examine related fields of video
games and reality TV. Some sectors or industries have expanded their
communication into television to showcase what they do and their commit-
ment to social and political good. For example, police (e.g. The Force),
280 Theory
customs (e.g. Border Patrol), lifesaving (e.g. Bondi Rescue) and the courts (e.g.
Court Justice) have been the basis of recent service-based reality-TV shows.
While these may move a long way from the original research conducted
decades ago, they nevertheless show how industries or sectors can cultivate
their public profiles and contribute to public perceptions of their role in
society through television.
How it’s used: The fragmented and diversified platforms available in the online
environment means communication and PR must be smart and strate-
gic in how they generate their own content, curate the content of others
and encourage co-creation by other users. Because the best endorsements
are those external to the organisation, organisations can make the most
of audience media usage and get them to help tell the organisational
story. The widespread use of influencers, and data collection that can
predict online behaviour, are both strategic communication tools that
have evolved out of the broader access to the internet. But practitioners
need to be mindful about how they manage other people’s privacy and
personal data.
Theory: Where learning starts 281
How it’s used: As with the democratisation of media, the new online economy
means that organisations must find their way around in the digital space.
The use of digital platforms is now central to how many businesses,
governments and third sector organisations conduct activity, connect
with stakeholders and communicate. The activities of the ‘big five’ online
giants, listed in the previous entry, provide ample illustration of how this
theory is put into practice. The disruptions and innovations of the online
economy have impacted the way people consume news, gain access to
banking, download and use other people’s work, interact socially and learn.
The so-called ‘sharing economy’ is part of this. Beginning with platforms
such as Airbnb and Uber, this has changed the conventional view of a
market-based economy. Likewise, the aggregation of news by the major
tech companies like Facebook and Google has altered traditional models
and expectations of ‘pay as you go’ for news and information.
How it’s used: Influencers increasingly play a role in recommending new ideas,
concepts, products and services. Once an idea is picked up and shared,
it’s easy to see how this theory can work in practice. This is how fashions
change and take hold, and why clothing, food and other businesses seek out
people to share their feedback on social media. This theory can be used to
learn about what’s trending socially by using analytics tools such as Union
Metrics, Meltwater, Brand Mentions and AgoraPulse.
new words for old—for example, climate change for global warming; queue
jumpers for asylum seekers. In turn, words become accepted into language
because of their dominance across many sectors. In strategic communica-
tion and PR, it’s important to be mindful that, because you are in charge
of messaging, the words you use count. People must understand your
language and the context in which you mean it—otherwise it can result in
confusion. Likewise, your words should honestly represent the content of
your message.
How it’s used: This theory has been applied to studies across many industries
and sectors, from health care to marketing. In advertising and market-
ing, central processing will usually result in longer-term commitment to
a brand or product. In the digital marketplace, if consumers are used
to buying online they are more likely to connect via the central route to
purchase a product because they care more about the message, it is more
relevant to them and they are more at home on the platform. Motivation
284 Theory
and ability have been found to promote central processing and higher
elaboration. If consumers are not usually online purchasers, on the other
hand, they will need to be persuaded by other elements in the online space,
such as a star-ratings, cheap prices, free shipping and the visual pull of the
image. Then again, they might just go to the shop to buy the product!
(Yocco 2014).
How it’s used: One way we see this theory in action is through pro bono work.
Latin for ‘the public good’, pro bono publico (usually shortened to pro bono)
is understood to be work by industry specialists or professionals, under-
taken at no cost (or reduced cost) for worthy causes. Fields such as the law
and medicine are known to work pro bono for good causes, but public rela-
tions and marketing consultancies also conduct pro bono work. The PRIA
lists pro bono work as one way practitioners can update their continu-
ing professional development. Public interest was the driving force when
sporting stars came out in droves to offer financial support to victims of
the devastating bushfires in Australia in 2019–2020. Among those who got
behind the cause was tennis star Nick Kyrgios, who pledged $200 for every
Theory: Where learning starts 285
ace he hit during the 2019–2020 summer season. Others followed Kyrgios’s
lead, donating funds based on their aces served in tennis and tries scored
in rugby. Tennis Australia also supported the cause, launching the ‘Rally
for Relief’ to raise funds for the Red Cross. Kyrgios told the media: ‘We’ve
got the ability and the platform to do something like that. My hometown
is Canberra and we have the most toxic air in the world . . . It’s bigger than
tennis’ (New Daily 2019).
How it’s used: This theory has sparked ongoing debate and discussion about
whether symmetry can be truly located, or whether asymmetrical public
relations is more the norm and truly achievable. This theory, then, may
be described as aspirational—that is, we can aspire to excellence and this
must begin with honest and productive long-term relationships with
publics.
Four models The ‘four models’ approach to public relations was first theo-
rised by James Grunig and Todd Hunt (1984). The models, which have
been the subject of much review and debate over the years, are as follows:
How it’s used: Since there are four models, we will look at how symmet-
rical public relations works. It is probably best understood in the
context of community or public consultation. Successful consultations
can be measured by listening to and accommodating public feedback
into organisational plans and policies. For example, this could occur
through organisational listening in the workplace where staff are unhappy
about certain structural issues—positive outcomes could include adjust-
ments to work conditions, more staff employed or better staff benefits.
Another example is where a local government body meets with community
members to hear grievances about a proposed development. Outcomes
could include changes to the proposal to respond to community demands,
such as adding a ‘greening’ requirement to the development. The level
of accommodation and compromise by the organisation will determine if
the response is symmetrical or asymmetrical.
Ariana Grande showed her support for candidate Bernie Sanders. He, in
turn, used his Twitter account to frame this support around his social justice
agenda.
In this book: see pp. 39, 67, 227, 275, 290, 291.
See also: agenda setting; mediatisation.
Look up: Erving Goffman; Robert Entman.
How it’s used: As the diagram shows, the model begins with gaining attention
and works through all stages to action (usually the purchase or adoption
of a product or service). The stages can also be translated in the following
order: think, feel, do. It centres on using persuasion and influence to get
consumers to act in a certain way and relate to consumables, experiences or
services—for example, in selecting make-up, alcohol, holidays, new phones,
a new car—just about anything that gives you that ‘need to have’ feeling.
Knowledge economy In the information age, the global economy has shifted
towards an economy based on intellectual capital or workers’ knowledge.
Knowledge economies (or knowledge-based economies) in advanced
industrial nations typically have a higher level of intellectually intensive
activities than service-, agriculture- and manufacturing-based economies.
Examples of knowledge economy activities include research, technical
support and consulting, supported by a strong focus on education and inno-
vation. New ideas and products, including patents, are indicators of a shift
to a knowledge economy. The knowledge economy is closely related to
concepts of the information age and the network society. The World
Bank defines knowledge economies as having:
How it’s used: The focus on education and innovation, research and develop-
ment, computing and technology are all indicative of the priorities in a
knowledge economy. Public relations and communication professionals
are knowledge and information workers who communicate about inno-
vation, sometimes innovating themselves. The industry sits at the centre
of knowledge economies and networked societies because communicating
acts as a central link for knowledge exchange between so many sectors,
stakeholders and ideas.
Mediatisation This theory describes how social institutions are affected by,
and seek to adapt to, the media. The original context for examining and
understanding mediatisation was at the interface between politics, political
communication and the media, and the impact media had on the develop-
ment of policies and institutional communication. As such, the news media
was said to have altered the way politics was communicated, to ensure politi-
cians get media attention and stories are framed according to their narrative
agendas. It has since evolved from a purely political communication theory
to a more general sociocultural concept of how society is shaped by the
world of media and how people have adapted. A related concept is ‘media
logics’, which refers to how media is prioritised, processed and commu-
nicated. In the digital media environment, mediatisation now crosses all
aspects of culture and the adaptation continues. Mediatisation has been
likened in impact to globalisation and commercialisation.
How it’s used: Successful political leaders have become masters of using media
to get their messages across. This includes the rise in the ‘celebrity’ politi-
cian—people like Boris Johnson, Donald Trump, Emmanuel Macron and
Justin Trudeau. This celebrity status ensures their presence in mainstream
media and most are now masters at using social media (or their public rela-
tions teams are). In the case of US President Donald Trump, his pervasive
social media-fuelled communication has become legendary, resulting in
his cult-like status and following among his fans and voters. Trump has
become one of the most mediatised people of our age; as one critique put
it, ‘[n]o other president has so thoroughly dominated the press as Trump
manages to do, largely because of his extremely active posting habits and
his bombastic writing traits’ (Diggit 2017).
In this book: see pp. 32, 117, 128, 276, 280, 288, 306, 307.
See also: agenda setting and priming; framing; network society.
Look up: Kent Asp; Stig Hjarvard.
Narrative theory This theory (also known as narratology) is about the study
of narratives and their structures. It centres on how narratives provide
meaning-making on individual, social and cultural levels, shaping our life
experiences. Narrative theory emerged from literary studies but has many
Theory: Where learning starts 291
How it’s used: For strategic communication, narrative theory translates to brand
narratives, which are about how organisations or brands present themselves
through their stories. It helps if you have a fun, authentic story to kick-start
the brand narrative. Our example in Chapter 9 of Burt’s Bees provides a
narrative of two people meeting and brainstorming the now highly success-
ful natural beauty range. That story, as we note in Chapter 9, cuts across
many cultures. There are many other stories throughout the book that
illustrate how narratives are used.
In this book: see pp. 32, 33, 40, 130, 244, 257, 265.
See also: framing theory; brand narrative.
Look up: Mieke Bal; Paul Wake.
How it’s used: The simplest way to use news values in communication and PR
is to consider how they will feature in your stories. News values might be
292 Theory
considered a bit vague at times (good news/bad news) but they are worth
keeping in mind as you think about what stories will resonate with your
audience. In particular, in the list above think about audiovisuals and share-
ability, which have grown exponentially in importance in recent years. At
the same time, don’t overlook conflict; whether it’s a story you want to
share or one you hope won’t be shared, stories that include conflict often
attract attention.
Figure 10.3 The South Australian Government uses social media to listen to
community views on policies such as its draft Youth Action Plan.
In this book: see pp. 156, 186, 204, 244, 286, 298, 305.
See also: relationship management; issues management; rhetoric.
Look up: Joshua Barbour; Jim Macnamara.
context due to its close historical associations with religion, warfare and
politics—and sometimes all of these together.
How it’s used: War posters were among the most popular forms of propa-
ganda used by all governments during World Wars I and II. There are
also propaganda posters associated with many internal revolutions. While
propaganda is more associated with twentieth century historical events, it
was used more recently as a tactic that was called out by critics following
the ‘war on terror’ in Iraq. When the USA announced in 2003 that Iraq had
weapons of mass destruction, the omission of facts, fabrication of truths and
deception illustrated that propaganda remains a communication tool that
Figure 10.4 Left: Posters were called ‘weapons on the walls’, playing a major role
in enlisting troops and boosting morale. This Australian armed services poster
was used to encourage enlistment (1916). Source: State Library of South Australia.
Right: The ‘America under communism’ illustration is the front cover of an
anti-communist Catholic comic book called ‘Is this Tomorrow’, published by the
Catechetical Guild Education Society of St Paul, Minnesota, USA (1947).
Theory: Where learning starts 295
How it’s used: Public interest is a term that is used to argue or justify an
outcome. In its simplest form, the expression ‘it’s in the public interest’
is commonly used. It is widely cited in politics, media and legal decision-
making. In journalism it is associated with media reporting practices that
are intended to hold powers to account, with public interest journalism
associated with ‘quality’ or ‘investigative’ reporting. Public interest
communication has been described as central to how public interest
is framed and how different interests are communicated or expressed
in society (Johnston & Pieczka 2018). Public interest can be communi-
cated as a form of public argument, through persuasive or information
296 Theory
Figure 10.5 This ‘Know the signs’ poster was used during the early part of the
Australian Government information campaign when the main target audience was
travellers. It was published on 2 March 2020, two weeks before officially closing the
borders to non-residents. Source: Australian Government, Department of Health.
Theory: Where learning starts 297
1. control mutuality
2. trust
3. commitment
4. satisfaction
5. exchange relationships
6. communal relationships.
or doctor who didn’t speak or listen to you, or a vet who was mean to your
cat! With the rise of ecommerce, many industries have had to adapt to the
online environment to manage their relationships. Out of this has grown
tactics such as online personalised chat that helps you manage a negotiation
or purchase and the development of loyalty programs.
In this book: see pp. 10, 21, 60, 175, 204, 227, 251, 292–3.
See also: organisational listening; social capital; CSR.
Look up: Mary Ann Ferguson; John Ledingham & Stephen Bruning; Linda
Hon & James Grunig.
How it’s used: Rhetoric is about skilfully using language to convey a meaning
and achieve a purpose—this can be to persuade, inform or motivate.
Rhetorical devices are used to evoke emotion and responses. Winston
Churchill, British Prime Minister during World War II, was famous for
his political speechmaking and use of rhetoric. In an essay entitled ‘The
Scaffolding of Rhetoric’ written in 1897 (available online), he begins by
saying: ‘Of all the talents bestowed upon men, none is so precious as the
Theory: Where learning starts 299
In this book: see pp. 99, 184, 223, 227, 264, 293, 295.
See also: ethos, pathos and logos.
Look up: Aristotle; Robert Heath; Douglas Eyman.
Semiotics This is the study of signs and symbols within specific cultures.
It involves signs, which directly refer to what people see, such as photo-
graphs; and symbols, which are learned codes, such as language. Audiences
decode images and words according to their own personal, cultural or
social terms of reference to obtain their own meaning of a message.
Semioticians (scholars who study semiotics) propose that messages
consist of denotative meaning,
which is literal, and connota-
tive meaning, which involves
the internal associations each
receiver brings to the message.
Other meanings can be ambig-
uous, when a message has
multiple literal meanings, and
polysemic, in which multiple
associations may vary among
individuals and cultures.
Johnson & Johnson in 2007. Johnson & Johnson, which had trademarked
the symbol, filed a lawsuit against the charity organisation, demanding it
stop using it (Saul 2007). Many symbols and signs are taken for granted,
working in social contexts to keep things clear and avoid chaos, accidents or
misunderstandings. These include road signs, like STOP and GIVE WAY;
‘open’ and ‘closed’ shop signs; signs for male and female restrooms; exit
signs; and ‘do not’ swim, surf, climb etc. signs. Commonly identified and
trademarked symbols in business include McDonald’s golden arches, the
Nike swoosh, the Apple apple and Red Bull’s bull.
Situational theory This theory is based on the idea that the level of recog-
nition, involvement and the ability to affect a situation will determine
how people behave in relation to that problem, issue or situation. People
become active publics only if they are sufficiently motivated to be involved
and if they have the ability to find and consider information about how
their interests may be affected. They also need to feel they can achieve
something about the situation at hand. Grunig and Hunt (1984) identified
three key factors that determine the level of advocacy of publics in relation
to their situation:
1. problem recognition, in which people know something should be done
about a situation and think about what to do
2. constraint recognition, when people perceive there are obstacles that
limit their ability to do something about a situation
3. level of involvement, or the extent to which people perceive that what
an organisation does involves them.
Grunig later added two dependent behavioural variables: information
seeking and information processing, also known as active and passive
communication behaviour.
How it’s used: Situational theory is a useful tool in the early stages of a strate-
gic communication and public relations campaign, particularly during the
situation analysis. It can help determine the extent to which stakeholders
Theory: Where learning starts 301
Figure 10.7 Climate Protests in 2019 saw schoolchildren walk out of school and
protest for their futures. Photo by Markus Spiske, Unsplash.
Social capital theory Social capital has been called the ‘glue’ that binds people
together. Essentially, it is about the collective and shared value people bring
to a community or society. Making connections among people, building
reciprocal relationships, collaboration, trust and community, are the bases
of social capital theory. It takes two main forms.
Social contract theory This theory is about the ‘contracts’ people have with
their society. It is about a consensual exchange between citizen and state,
centring on the idea that people live according to an agreement or under-
standing about their obligations to the society in which they live. Likewise,
Theory: Where learning starts 303
How it’s used: The social contract is played out every day in society. Some soci-
eties call on citizens to perform civic duties like serving in the armed forces
for a period of time, or taking part in jury duty. Others are more implicit in
everyday events and activities, such as:
The issue with the social contract is that, if you don’t uphold your part of
the social contract, you can be sanctioned by fines or other legal penalties.
However, the social contract is a two-way contract and governments are
also required to respond to the needs of their citizens. Civic unrest can, and
does, result where citizens do not believe their governments are doing their
part. For example, see the situational theory example of climate protests
outlined earlier.
How it’s used: The original idea of two-step flow theory was that media and
influencers were separate. Today, the two are highly connected. Mass and
interpersonal media have now been merged—online media is now ‘mass-
personal’. While news is generated by media organisations (e.g. the ABC)
or from aggregated sources (e.g. Apple news), information more broadly
is sought out through personalised sources and friends in online media.
Strategic communication and PR practitioners use this theory when they
identify and use opinion leaders or influencers to amplify their organisa-
tions’ messages. Think about where you take your cues from in voting,
holiday destinations or where to go for coffee. The tweet about Ariana
Grande used previously in the chapter is an example of how influencers are
used to affect voting behaviour.
Uses and gratifications theory While there are continuing debates about
whether it is a ‘theory’ or an ‘approach’, uses and gratifications are
relevant to gaining a deeper understanding of individuals’ use of media.
The theory is audience-centred as it concerns how audiences actively
choose which media to use in order to gratify their social and psycho-
logical need for information, entertainment, social connection, attention
and recognition, to escape from routine or to pursue some other goal.
It moves away from the belief that audiences are passive receivers of
information. Instead, it seeks to understand their motivations for using
a chosen medium and the satisfactions that are gained through both the
process of using that medium and from its content. Differences in moti-
vations and the types and levels of activity are acknowledged, recognising,
for example, that some media use is more habitual than consciously
selected. The theory stemmed from research in the 1950s by Katz, who
was interested in what people did with media rather than what media did
to people.
How it’s used: Early research focused on the news media of the day—
television—through which mass audiences could be reached quickly and
easily. Using more recent digital technologies, attention has now also
turned to the motivations behind the selection and use of the plethora of
media platforms used by today’s diverse and fragmented audiences. For the
contemporary communication practitioner, uses and gratifications theory
can assist in identifying which individuals use which platforms for what
purposes, reaching out to connect with them in the most effective and
efficient manner. For example, delivery of detailed information could be
more appropriate on a website, whereas a tweet could direct the audience
to that site, and the information could be repurposed for a media platform
used for entertainment. The theory also reminds the practitioner of the
competition from other sources in addressing the satisfaction needs of
their audiences.
How it’s used: There is no quick fix for wicked policy problems, but some say
that many social and economic problems lie somewhere on a continuum
between ‘tame’ and ‘wicked’ (Australian Government 2018). In addition,
policy problems may move along the continuum over time, for example,
the issue of tobacco control. Decades ago, all levels of government and
NGOs in Australia broadly agreed on the scope of the smoking problem
and the need for it to be strategically controlled. This was put into force
in 1997 by the National Tobacco Strategy which included regulation to
control promotion, and develop taxation, warnings, cessation services,
Theory: Where learning starts 309
Conclusion
Theories provide ways of thinking, seeing and understanding the world. In this
chapter we’ve drawn from the theories mentioned throughout this book, and
added a few others, drawn from theories in media and communication, sociol-
ogy, political science, psychology, ethical philosophy and public relations. By
developing each theory with a short factual account, a ‘how it’s used’ applied
section, suggested similar theories for further investigation, and key theorists,
we’ve intentionally kept the entries compact but as comprehensive as possible.
This is only the start of your journey into strategic communication and related
theory. For further exploration of theory in these fields, we recommend Robert
Heath and Winni Johansen’s comprehensive International Encyclopedia of Stra-
tegic Communication (Heath & Johansen 2018). Some other useful resources
include the Purdue Writing Lab; the Centre for the Study of Theory and
Criticism at Western University, Canada; The Ethics Centre, Sydney; the
Science Media Centre, Wellington; and the Project Narrative at Ohio
State University. Other useful books and journals can be found in the list of
references and further readings, below.
A few final words on theory. Remember it relates to strategy, planning,
tactics, research and ethics—in other words, theory helps with all of these, in
310 Theory
this book, and more. As this chapter has illustrated, when we apply theory and
put it into practice, it can assist in developing organisational thinking, includ-
ing strategy and planning; in making ethical choices; and in tactic selection.
Theory, like research, is an important starting point in strategic communica-
tion and public relations, but it doesn’t stop at the beginning. Theories can
assist the process as we brainstorm our way through research, campaigns,
issues, crises, planning or tactic development. Finally, a willingness to explore
theory and a capacity to understand how it can help provide a depth of
understanding will distinguish the thinkers and problem-solvers in our industry.
Those people, in turn, will find their way into the future leadership roles in
business and industry, politics and government, and the third sector, in our
complex and rapidly changing society.
Eyman, D. (2015). Digital Rhetoric: Theory, Method, Practice. Ann Arbor, MI: University of
Michigan Press.
Fanning, E. (2019). 3 CRM Examples to Inspire Your CRM Strategy. Sendinblue (21 August).
Retrieved from https://blog.sendinblue.com/crm-examples-to-inspire-crm-strategy/
Fawkes, J. (2012). What is Public Relations? In A. Theaker (ed.), The Public Relations Handbook
(4th edn) (pp. 3–20). Oxford: Routledge.
Foodbank (2019). Cause-related Marketing. Retrieved from www.foodbank.org.au/support-us/
partner-with-us/cause-related-marketing/?state=qld
Freeman, R.E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Government of South Australia (2020). YourSAy. Retrieved from https://yoursay.sa.gov.au/
Grunig, J.E. (ed.) (1992). Excellence in Public Relations and Communication Management. Mahwah,
NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
——— (1997). A Situational Theory of publics: Conceptual History, Recent Challenges and
New Research. In D. Moss, T. MacManus & D. Verc̆ic̆ (eds), Public Relations Research: An
International Perspective (pp. 3–48). London: International Thomson Business Press.
——— (2005). Situational Theory of Publics. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public Relations,
Vol. 2 (pp. 778–780). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
——— & Hunt, T. (1984). Managing Public Relations. New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Habermas, J. (1989). The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Harcup, T. & O’Neill, D. (2016). What Is News? News Values Revisited (Again). Journalism
Studies, 9(1), 1470–88.
Hazleton, V. & Kennan, W. (2000). Social Capital: Reconceptualizing the Bottom Line. Corporate
Communications: An International Journal, 5(2), 81–86.
Heath, R.L. (2005). Rhetorical Theory. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public Relations,
Vol. 2 (pp. 749–52). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Heath, R. & Johansen, W. (2018). The International Encyclopedia of Strategic Communication.
Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Blackwell.
Hildebrand, D. (2018). John Dewey. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (last updated
1 November). Retrieved from https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/dewey/
Hon, L. & Grunig, J. (1999). Guidelines for Measuring Relationships in Public Relations. Retrieved
from www.instituteforpr.org/wp-content/uploads/Guidelines_Measuring_Relationships.pdf
Jowett, G.S. & O’Donnell, V. (eds) (2012). Propaganda and Persuasion (4th edn). Thousand Oaks,
CA: Sage.
Joyce, S. & Thomson, I. (2000). Earning a Social Licence to Operate: Social Acceptability and
Resource Development in Latin America. CIM Bulletin, 93(1037), 49–53.
Katz, E., Blumler, J. & Gurevitch, M. (1974). Utilization of Mass Communication by the Indi-
vidual. In J. Blumler & E. Katz (eds), The Uses of Mass Communication: Current Perspectives on
Gratifications Research (pp. 19–34). Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Kenton, W. (2019). Knowledge Economy. Investopedia. Retrieved from www.investopedia.com/
terms/k/knowledge-economy.asp
Ledingham, J. (2005). Relationship Management Theory. In R. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public
Relations (pp. 740–43). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Ledingham, J. & S. Bruning (2000). Public Relations as Relationship Management: A Relational
312 Theory
Approach to the Study and Practice of Public Relations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Luoma-Aho, V. (2009). On Putnam: Bowling Together—Applying Putnam’s Theories of Commu-
nity and Social Capital to Public Relations. In Ø. Ihlen, B. Van Ruler & M. Fredriksson (eds),
Public Relations and Social Theory (pp. 231–51). New York, NY: Routledge.
Mackey, S. (2009). Public Relations Theory In J. Johnston & C. Zawawi (eds), Public Relations:
Theory and Practice (3rd edn) (pp. 47–77). Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
Macnamara, J. (2012). Public Relations: Theories, Practices, Critiques. Sydney: Pearson.
Maslow, A. (1943). A Theory of Human Motivation. Psychological Review, 50(4), 370–96.
McCombs, M. (2004). Setting the Agenda: The Mass Media and Public Opinion. Cambridge: Polity.
——— & D.L. Shaw (1972). The Agenda-setting Function of Mass Media. Public Opinion Quar-
terly, 36(2), 176–87.
——— Shaw, D.L. & Weaver, D. (1997). Communication and Democracy: Exploring the Intellectual
Frontiers in Agenda-setting Theory. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
McKie, D. (2005). Critical Theory. In R.L. Heath (ed.), Encyclopedia of Public Relations, Vol. 2
(pp. 226–68). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Moloney, K. (2006). Rethinking Public Relations: PR, Propaganda and Democracy. London:
Routledge.
New Daily with AAP (2019). Kyrgios Centre-stage as Sports Stars Crank Up Bushfire Relief
Efforts. New Daily (4 January). Retrieved from https://thenewdaily.com.au/news/national/
2020/01/04/nick-kyrgios-bushfire-sports-fundraising/
Orgtheory (n.d.) Etymology of Theory. Retrieved from https://orgtheory.wordpress.com/
2006/07/11/etymology-of-theory/
Petty, R. & Cacioppo J. (1986). Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to
Attitude Change. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.
Putnam, R.D. (2000). Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York,
NY: Simon & Schuster.
Rittel, H.W.J. & Webber, M.W. (1973) Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy
Sciences 4, 155-169.
Ryte Wiki (2019). AIDA. Retrieved from https://en.ryte.com/wiki/AIDA
Rogers, E.M. & Dearing, J.W. (1988). Agenda-setting Research: Where Has It Been, Where Is
It Going? In J.A. Anderson (ed.), Communication Yearbook 11 (pp. 555–94). Newbury Park,
CA: Sage.
Saul, S. (2007). Johnson and Johnson Sues Red Cross over Symbol. The New York Times (August 9).
Retrieved from www.nytimes.com/2007/08/09/business/09cross.html
Saltmarsh, J. (2011). Education for Critical Citizenship: John Dewey’s Contribution to the
Pedagogy of Community Service-Learning, in J. Saltmarsh & E. Zlotkowski, Higher Educa-
tion and Democracy: Essays of Service-Learning and Civic Engagement, (pp. 41-55). Philadelphia:
Temple University Press.
Scheufele, D. (1999). Framing as a Theory of Media Effects. International Journal of Communi-
cation, 49, 103–22.
Schneider, F. (2013). Getting the Hang of Discourse Theory: An Introduction to the Field.
Politics East Asia (6 May). Retrieved from http://www.politicseastasia.com/studying/getting-
the-hang-of-discourse-theory/
Theory: Where learning starts 313
315
316 STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION
Australian Communications and Media civil society 28, 43, 94, 289, see also third
Authority 112 sector organisations
Australian Heritage Strategy 199–200 Coca-Cola 188
Australian Red Cross 196–7, 285 Colgate 189
AVE see advertising value equivalents collective intelligence 119–20
communication audits 163, 170–1, 216
Barcelona Declaration 152–3, 171 communities 44–7, 77, 199, 201–2, 277, 302,
Bell Pottinger 96 304–5
Botan, Carl 182–3, 204–5 online 246, 302
brand 12, 13, 38–9, 83, 182, 185, 249 community 35, 44–6, 39, 48, 175, 190, 193,
and Apple 193 200, 204, 217, 255, 284, 286, 293, 302,
and Coca-Cola 188 304–5
and influencers 134–5 action group (CAG) 28, 305
image 15, 78 and CSR 75–6, 77, 81
journalism 15, 259 consultation 255, 277, 305
management 15, 34, 39 engagement 33, 34, 45–6, 235
narratives 244, 291 service announcement 255
branded content 38–9, 135, 250–2 community capacity building theory 46, 273,
branding 13, 34, 38, 138, 189, 250, 254 276–7, 302, 304
budgets 14, 151, 164, 208, 216, 226, 229–32 consequentialism 97–8, 100
Burt’s Bees 241–3, 253, 257, 258, 262, 291 consultants/consultancy 11–3, 31, 93–4
consumer(s) 145, 159–60, 203, 217, 266,
campaign(s) 31, 34, 51, 78, 96, 158–60, 283–4, 288
182–4, 208–38, 309, see also protests as media consumers 306
anti-smoking 308–9 as prosumers 119
Apple see Apple as stakeholders 278
Burt’s Bees see Burt’s Bees behaviour 263, 274
Coronavirus see Coronavirus, see also consent 112
COVID-19 law 106, 111
Coca-Cola see Coca-Cola of Colgate 189
Converse see Converse of Nike 189–90
Lakeview Zoo see Lakeview Zoo of Starbucks 189
management 34 of Thankyou 51
Nike see Nike protection 106–7
objectives 172 relations 37–9
osteoporosis see osteoporosis relationship management 175, 297
propaganda 294 content 221, 240–1, 244–7, 263, 264, 266,
case studies 163, 171 267, 280
cause-marketing 231, 255, 277, 284 analysis 163, 169, 171, 172
Christchurch calendars 211
multicultural strategy 200–1 composing 246–7
shootings 131–2 creation 13, 15, 34, 176, 245, 247
churnalism 128 crowdsourcing 246–7, 256
Index 317
fact checks 5, 20, 40, 58, 59, 74, 76, 98, 103, investigation 69
111, 136, 142, 156, 169, 192, 196, 205, laws 78, 103, 106
222, 243 officials 96
fact sheet 36, 357, 258, 260 Queensland 277
fake news 99, 128, 143, 152, 257 South Australian 293
five Ps 184 strategies 199–201, 217–8
focus groups 163, 168, 171, 177 grand strategy 182–5, 192–3, 194, 196,
Folau, Israel 43 198–201, 203–4, 239
formal research 161, 162, 163, 216, 256 Grunig, James 285–6, 297–8, 300, 301
four models 285–6, 301, 306 Gumtree 159–60
framing 39, 67, 227, 275, 287–8, 290, 291,
292 hashtag 8, 118, 175, 228, 249, 258
hierarchy of effects model 224, 276, 284,
Gantt chart 229–30 288–9
GetUp! 197 hierarchy of plans 209, 211
GIF 130, 189, 258 Hill+Knowlton 12
Global Alliance for Public Relations history 14–18, 133, 145, 186, 267, 291,
and Communication Management 293
19–20 Hong Kong protests 68–9
Global Capability Framework 19–20
goal(s) 6, 30–1, 42, 45–6, 80, 158, 181–2, impact research 159–60
184, 185, 187, 194, 196, 198, 203, 205, influencer 16, 44, 133–6, 142, 160, 242, 249,
209, 2010, 223, 227, see also objectives 258, 275, 280, 282, 306
in Christchurch’s Multicultural Strategy infographics 130–1, 144, 250, 258
200 informal research 161
in crisis planning 235 in-house 11–3, 19, 104, 161, 168, 170,
setting 213–14, 220–2 230
Google 8, 74, 78, 111, 131, 140, 143, 144, input(s) 38, 153–4, 173, 198, 213, 246
151, 161, 193, 258, 274, 280, 281 input research 155–7, 159–60, 173, 175,
Alerts 168 212, 214, 216
Analytics 140 integrated marketing communication 8, 15,
Forms 166 37–8, 250
Hey Google 174 integrated planning and research cycle 154,
Mini 174 212–14
News 156 intellectual property 107–9, 281
Translate 174 interest/power matrix 218–9
Trends 136, 144, 168, 169 International Organization for
Government 27–8, 29–43 Standardization 80
Australian Federal 296, 308–9 interviews 266, 259, 261
Christchurch City Council 200–1 media 33, 34, 49, 138
codes of conduct 91 research 163, 166–8, 171, 266
COVID-19 warnings 36, 65, 68 investor(s) 278
decision-making 60 relations 16, 39–40
Index 319
Instagram 44, 51, 132, 136, 168, 189, 227, machine learning 58, 91, 144–5, 173
243, 249, 260, 267 media 12, 13, 16, 49, 117–146, 156,
issues 21, 29, 31, 40, 46–8, 57–60, 82, 83, 159–60, 169, 240, 241, 242, 244,
138, 156, 161, 169, 197, 201, 203, 246, 248–9, 252, 252–5, 259–60,
214–5, 216, 218, 250, 274–5, 287, 265–7, 274–5, 278, 279, 280, 281,
293 287, 290, 295, 306, 307, see also
management 13, 14, 16, 21, 40, 60–5, 175, social media
186, 210, 293 agenda 31
communication 62–5, 210 alert 141
channels 121, 134, 139, 244, 249, 252
Jenkins, Henry 119–20, 129, 134, 145, 244, conference 33, 34, 36, 139, 142, 260
273 convergence 119, 120
Jetstar 77 democratisation of 274, 280, 281
job Entertainment & Arts Alliance 91
outlook 3–4, 14 financial 15, 39
skills 126 in planning 223, 225, 227–8, 231, 236
titles 15–6, 19, 134–5 in politics 30–2, 33–6, 40–2
Johnson & Johnson 299 in research 163, 170, 171, 172, 173
Jones, Alan 68 language of 128–9
journalism 8, 15, 17, 94, 137, 138, 254, 255, literacy 124–8, 129
257, 259, 266 kit 260
public interest 295 management 13, 31
model (PESO) 120–2, 128, 137, 139,
Kant, Immanuel 95 227, 240, 252
knowledge economy 137, 289 monitoring 111, 121, 160, 169, 252
multi- 130–3, 139, 266
‘Lakeview zoo’ 214, 216, 220, 222, 225, 226, organisations 111, 130, 133, 144, 274,
227–8, 232, 234 280, 306
language 6, 8, 46, 118, 201, 224, 243, 274, power 142–5
282–3 platform 169, 170, 260, 264, 307
and framing 287 relations 16, 30, 32, 34,137, 141, 211,
and rhetoric 298 260
and natural language processing 174 release 33, 34, 137, 139, 141, 142, 173,
clear 261 240, 241, 260
of media 128–9 training 260
Lil Miquela 136, 143 mediatisation 32, 117, 276, 280, 288, 290,
LinkedIn 51, 249 306, 307
listening 121, 127, 140 metrics 140, 145, 163, 164, 172–3, 233
organisational 46, 156, 186, 204, 244, ministerial staff 29, 33, 34, 42
285–6, 292–3, 298, 305 mission 160, 185, 194–6, 197–8, 199, 203,
tools 140, 293 209, 215, 217, 220, 228
lobbying 16, 40–2, 49, 259 statements 194–5, 220
320 STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION
narrative 32, 40, 257, 265, 290 corporate 42–3, 160, 202
brand 244, 291 public-private 27
theory 290–1 with UNHCR 201
natural processing language 174–5 Passion Lilie 77, 83
negligence 99, 104–6 persuasion 83, 99–100, 283, 288, 293, 300
news 32, 34, 40, 51, 67, 108, 118–20, 130, PESO 120–1, 137, 139, 227, 240, 252
133–4, 137–8, 139, 140–3, 156, 157, 168, PESTLE 59, 61, 155, 216
169, 170, 172, 173, 228, 240, 244–5, 257, philanthropy 16, 73, 76, 98, 239, 242, 262
259, 260, 262, 263, 265, 266, 274–5, 281, Phillips Group 251
287, 306 photograph(y) 13, 104, 131, 132, 133, 262,
aggregation 143, 156, 281, 306 299
conference see media, conference pitching 138, 262
fake see fake news planning models 154, 212, 213, see also
Google 156 research model
-letter 249, 261 platform society 117, 146, 281
media see media news podcasts 133, 156, 262, 263
organisations see media organisations
political economy 274, 279, 281
-paper 118, 119, 133, 136, 157, 245, 257,
Potter Box 101–3
259, 261, 262, 275
power 12, 41, 47, 73, 81, 83,197, 218–9, 273,
release see media release
278–9, 282, 286
stories 141, 142, 143, 275
media 142–5
values 291–2
privacy 79, 93, 95, 101, 113–4, 144–5, 166,
NGO (Non Government Organisation) 28,
280, 281, 295
45, 47–8, 57, 198, 277, 308, see also third
private sector 26–8, 36–43, 76
sector, see also civil society
problem 56, 58, 152, 156, 159, 161, 189,
Nike 109, 189–90, 244, 250, 300
214–5, 220, 263, 272–3, see also wicked
problems
organisational relationships 6
organisational listening see listening social 278
osteoporosis 155 -solver 13–14, 20, 46, 126–7, 252
Outback Queensland 132–3 statement 215
outcome research 158, 160 recognition 218, 300–1
outcomes 33, 35, 40, 41, 45, 46, 50, 153–4, propaganda 293–5, 300
173, 200, 202–3, 213, 221, 233–4, 286, publics 7, 16, 81, 83, 155–6, 185, 186–7, 189,
292, 297 194, 201, 203, 204, 205, 2013, 217–20,
outcome research 158, 160 223, 227, 235, 278–9, 285–6, 295, 297,
outputs 153–4, 162, 169, 172, 173, 182, 183, 300
213–4, 233, 234, 239, 264, 292 public interest 83, 284, 295–6
output research 157–8 Public Relations Institute of Australia (PRIA)
Oxfam 69 7, 17, 19, 91–3, 153, 164, 172, 284
Public Relations Institute of New Zealand
participatory culture 119, 143–4, 280 (PRINZ) 7, 17, 91–4
partnership 10, 50, 123, 222, 255, 258, 262 Public Relations Society of America (PRSA)
COVID-19 and TikTok 297 7, 101–3
Index 321
public sector 26–7, 29–36, 76, see also sentiment analysis 170–1, 175
government situation analysis 214–17, 300, 313
situational theory 48, 218, 300, 304
qualitative research 159, 162–4, 168, 263 six Ps 185, 194
quantitative research 162–4, 171, 233, 263 SMART objectives 173, 221, 222
questionnaire 164, 166–7, 263 smartphone 122–4, 125, 144, 146, 266
quick tips 62, 73, 94, 108, 120, 131, 133, SMI see influencer
164 social capital theory 45–56, 273, 277, 298,
302, 304
radio 68, 130, 133, 169, 228, 255, 256, 259, social contract theory 302–4
262, 263, 265 social enterprise 27, 28, 48–51, 278, 284
Red Bull 250, 251–2, 254, 265, 300 social licence to operate 37, 304, 305
Red Republic 12–3 social media 8, 32–5, 36, 40, 43, 44, 47, 49,
relationship management 10, 21, 60, 175, 64–5, 119, 120–1, 130–1, 134, 138–9,
204, 227, 251, 292, 293, 297 143, 163, 169, 170, 172–4, 175, 189, 190,
relationships 10, 15, 16, 21, 30, 32, 37, 42, 227–8, 243, 258, 264, 267, 275, 281, 282,
43, 79, 118, 137, 138, 186, 189, 220–1, see also media
285, 297–8 and crisis planning & communication
research 151–78, 185, 186, 204, 212–17, 67–8, 69, 235–6
233–4, 256, 262–3, 266, 298, 307, and CSR 83
309–10, see also qualitative, see also and defamation 110–1
quantitative and listening 292–3
and data see data and mediatisation 209
as a tactic 49 and two-step flow of communication 206
and the Global Capabilities Framework calendar 139–40, 211
20 campaign 51, 57, 226, 292–3
in copyright 108 curation 245, 246
in social enterprise 50 ethics 90
in the public sector 34 influencer see influencer
rhetoric 99, 184, 223, 227, 264, 293, 295, management 13
298–9 networking 16
rhetorical studies 292 plan 211, 212
rhetorical theory 298–9 platforms/channels 20, 31, 32, 49, 108,
risk 21, 34, 43, 65–7, 71, 103, 105, 106, 226, 244, 249
165, 194, 211 spam 111–13, 166
assessment 69, 235 sponsorship 13, 16, 34, 42–3, 73, 222, 231,
at- 284 250, 251, 253, 254, 258, 264
management 60, 65–7 stakeholder(s) 6, 30, 37, 39, 60, 61, 68–71,
matrix 66 72, 196, 199, 203, 212, 305
taking 194 engagement 20, 34
values 304
Sanford 202–3 stakeholder theory 82, 305
semiotics 129, 282, 283, 299 Starbucks 189
322 STRATEGIC COMMUNICATION
sticky notes 5, 10, 31, 32, 37, 41, 45, 46, 51, two-step flow of communication 226, 280,
57, 60, 67, 73, 76, 82, 83, 84, 96, 99, 282, 306
117, 118, 124, 129, 137, 144, 156, 193,
218, 221, 223, 224, 226, 227, 231, 273, Uluru 64
274 United Nations (UN) 44, 79, 80, 201, 277,
stock exchange 39 301
storytelling 139, 176, 241, 245, 250, 265 United Nations Global Compact 80
strategy 180–206, 6, 12, 34, 38, 175, 209–10, United Nations Sustainable Development
211–4, 239, 241, 267 Goals 79–80
and communication 201–5 Universal Declaration of Human Rights 79
defined 183–4 user-generated content 38, 245, 266
grand 182–3 uses and gratifications theory 227, 307
‘helicopter view’ of 196
loop 191 values 6, 21, 60, 71, 76, 82, 94, 97, 101, 132,
military 5, 182 185–7, 194–8, 250, 277, 199–202, 220,
National Tobacco 308–9 250, 302, 305
six principles of (six Ps) 185–7 civic 277
visual 130 news 291–2
Strauss, Levi 195 virtue theory 99–100
Streisand effect 110 vision 130, 131–4, 224, 265, 266
surveys 162, 163, 164–6, 171, 175, 177, 234 organisational 186–7, 194–8, 199, 200–3,
209, 210, 267
tactics 239–67, 26, 31, 41, 47, 49, 139, 181–3, vision statement 194
212–13, 221, 223–8 Volunteering New Zealand 198
controlled/uncontrolled 240–1
selection 241–3 websites 20, 31, 33, 34, 36, 39, 45, 62, 114,
top-100 252–67 121 141–2, 223, 236, 245, 248–9, 254,
technician 14, 19 259, 260, 267, 286, 307
television 107–8, 118, 137, 169, 228, 242, and advocacy/activism 49
248, 250, 255, 256, 264, 265, 275, 279, and investor relations 39–40
280, 307 company 51, 74, 77, 159–62, 242–3, 244
terror attack 131 in research 165, 166, 168, 172, 177
Thankyou 51, 278 government 42, 113
third sector 26, 28, 41, 52, 281, see also civil professional associations 91, 93
society WeChat 249
Thunberg, Greta 47, 253 Weibo 249
TikTok 118, 123, 249, 260 wicked problems 83–4, 193–4, 295, 297, 308,
trade marks 107, 109 309
Turner, Graeme 145–6 Wilson, Rebel 111
Twitter 35, 51, 96, 132, 137, 166, 168, 175, World Vision 77
189, 241, 243, 249, 258, 267, 287–8
threading 246 YouTube 227, 242, 243, 249