Credit Appraisal and Risk Management of
Credit Appraisal and Risk Management of
Credit Appraisal and Risk Management of
i|P age
CREDIT APPRAISAL AND RISK MANAGEMENT
OF
UTTARA BANK LIMITED
Submitted To:
Ms. Sreyoshi Ahmed
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
Submitted by:
Md. Junayet Hossain
Id: 09204058
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
ii | P a g e
Letter of Transmittal
Dear Madam,
This is to inform you that, I have finalized with my report naming as “Performance credit
appraisal and risk management of Uttara Bank Limited”, I have tried to implement my learning
of Bachelor of Business Administration in the practical field with due sincerity and would like to
thank you for giving me the opportunity to have the chance to work on this report. Despite many
limitations I have tried my level best to address the major and in depth issues in making this
paper accurate and reliable. If you have any further enquiry concerning any additional
information I would be very pleased to clarify that.
I, therefore, pray and hope that you will be kind enough to accept this report as fulfillment of the
requirement for the BBA degree.
Thanking you.
Sincerely yours,
……………………
Md. Junayet Hossain
Id: 09204058
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
iii | P a g e
Acknowledgement
First and foremost, I would like to pay my gratitude to the almighty Allah, the most Merciful, the
Beneficent, for blessing me with good health and tenacity of mind to complete the requirements
for the degree.
Many people have been responsible in making this report. . I extend my most sincere thanks and
gratitude to my academic supervisor Ms Sreyoshi Ahmed, lecturer, BRAC Business School,
BRAC University, for the subsequent advice and valuable guidance towards completion of the
report.
I most sincerely express my thanks and gratitude to Mr. Biplab Kumar Halder, Manager,
Sadarghat Branch, Uttara Bank Ltd., for giving me the opportunity to prepare this report. I shall
ever remember the affectionate care rendered by him and for the constant guidance he provided
to me for completing the report. He has been extremely kind to lend me his valuable time
whenever I needed.
I am extremely grateful to the Uttara Bank Limited staffs for allowing me to pursue my
internship and continuous support for the entire work. I recall with thanks and gratitude the
inspiration and support provided by Mr. Abul Kalam Azad, Principal Officer and A.K.M
Taher Uddin Mahmud Senior officer of that Branch who assisted me with his valuable time
and suggestions and with relevant documents. Thanks are also due to all of my colleagues of
Bank Asia for their help and valuable advice.
iv | P a g e
Executive Summery
This report is basis on the entire process of credit approval and the credit risk assessment system
of Uttara Bank Limited and identifying the positive aspects as well as the shortcomings of that
credit scheme. After completing of BBA program of BRAC Business School, I have completed
my internship in Uttara Bank Limited (Sadarghat Branch), one of the largest and reputed private
commercial bank in Bangladesh and went under a rotation program in different department of
Uttara Bank Limited (UBL). I worked with some officers and some departments sincerely. But I
mainly gave emphasis on the bank’s credit appraisal and recovery policy. The objective was to
analyze the criteria of UBL’s such as loan distribution sector, interest rate of loan, the bank’s
capability to recover load during stipulated time and the management efficiency regarding
classified loan. The primary activities carried out by the credit department of UBL include
evaluation of loan application, preparing necessary documents for the loan approval, monitoring
the loan after disbursement and ensuring its repayment and finally initiate classification in case
of non-recovery.
Credit proposals are appraised critically by Uttara Bank Limited. The customer at the branch of
the bank place credit proposals. When customers come with a credit proposal, the credit
department of the Branch makes an open discussion with customer on different issues of the
proposal to judge the worthiness of the proposal and the customer. If the proposal seems to be
worthwhile in all respects then the proposal is placed before the credit committee of the bank.
After threadbare discussion, if the committee agrees in principle the proposal is sanctioned as per
the delegated business power of the branch.
The execution of documents in proper from and according to the requirements of law is known
as documentation. The documentation does establish a legal relationship between the lending
bank and borrower. The terms and condition of loans and advances, the securities charged and
the repayment scheduled is recovered in writing proper documentation for safeguard the future
interest of the bank.
v|P age
Credit management is an integral part of banking business. The making of credit and advances
has always been prominent profitable function of bank. Sanctioning credit to customer and other
out of fund as its disposal is one of the principal services of modern Bank. Advances by UBL
made in different forms such as overdraft, cash credit bill purchased and discounted etc. UBL
deals with the money from the depositor repayable on the demand. UBL usually grant short –
terms advances which are utilized to meet the working capital requirement of the borrower.
The incessant fall –out of international credit market due to world economic meltdown resulting
in sluggish growth has put significant pressure on financial performance of banks and financial
institutions worldwide. UBL achieved continuous growth almost all arenas of its business amid
this economic crisis, facing intensified competition of the industry. The bank remained
financially strong by dint of its continued focus on the vision of becoming country’s finest
corporate body providing excellent and need-based customer service.
vi | P a g e
Table of contents
SL Contents Page number
Chapter 1 Introduction 1
1.1 Origin of the report 2
1.2 Objective of the report 2
1.3 Scope of the report 3
1.4 Methodology 3
1.5 Limitation of the study 4
vii | P a g e
Chapter 5 SWOT analysis 50
Chapter 6 Major Findings, Recommendations and conclusion 53
References 58
viii | P a g e
List of abbreviations
UBL : Uttara Bank Limited
DSC : Dhaka Stock Exchange
CSE : Chittagong Stock Exchange
DD : Demand Draft
TT : Telegraphic Transfers
LC : Letter of credit
SME Loan : Small and Medium Enterprise Loan
USAID : United States Agency for International Development
SEDF : South Asia Enterprise Development Facility
IFC : International Finance Corporation
CCS : Consumers Credit Scheme
MMS : Monthly Saving Scheme
ix | P a g e
Chapter-1
1|Page
Chapter-1: Introduction
General Objective
The general objective of the study is to fulfill requirement of the Graduation under the
Bachelor of Business Administration program of BRAC University as per university policy.
Specific Objective:
The specific objective of this reports are:
1. To bring together information regarding the entire process of credit approval.
2|Page
2. To achieve knowledge regarding the system of credit risk assessment.
3. To find out the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats of the bank as well as
the flaws or drawbacks regarding the services and solution offered.
4. To detect the positive aspects as well as the shortcomings of the credit approval and the
credit risk assessment process
5. To identify methods to improve the quality and standard of the products offered to the
customers
1.4 Methodology
Selection of the Topic:
The topic was approved by my respective advisor and my on-site supervisor. It was
thoroughly discussed with them and my respective advisor provided me a format so that a
well-organized report can be prepared.
Sources of data
There are two types of data I collect for that report and those are
1. Primary Sources:
Face to face conversation with the respective officers
Direct Observation
Practical desk work
3|Page
2. Secondary Sources:
Annual report of UBL
Internal server and external websites of UBL
Relevant books, research paper and journals
Theoretical books of the related banking sector
4|Page
Chapter-2
5|Page
Chapter-2: Overview of Uttara Bank Limited
6|Page
Corporate Information
Name Uttara Bank Limited
Nature of Business Banking service and profit oriented
Date of Incorporation 29.06.1983
Chairman Md. Azharul Islam
Number of Branches 220
Total Asset TK. 104,559,589,957
Authorized Capital Tk. 5,000,000,000
Paid up Capital Tk. 3,306,449,088
E-mail Uttara@citecho.net
Web site www.uttarabank-bd.com
7|Page
Missions of UBL are given bellow:
To provide high quality financial service
To provide excellent quality customer service
To maintain corporate and business ethics.
To become a trusted repository of customers money and their financial advisor.
To make their stop superior and rewarding to the customers.
To display team sprite and professionalism.
To have a sound capital base.
8|Page
2.4 Different Wings of Uttara bank ltd.
9|Page
Asset & Liability Management
Department
Establishment Division General Services Department
Transport Department
Stationery & Records Department
Engineering Department
Information & Communication Technology MIS Department
(lCT) Division Development & Support Department
Card Department
Corporate Banking Division Credit Marketing Department
Credit Business Development
Department
10 | P a g e
2.5 Highlights on the overall activities of the Bank for the year ended 2012
and 2011
11 | P a g e
2.6 Features of UBL
The bank is committed to turn all its activities as per council board. UBL through its steady
progress and continuous success has earned the reputation of being one of the leading private
sector banks of the country. The distinguishing features of UBL are as follow:
All its activities are conducted on interest banking system according to council board.
Establishment of participatory banking instead of banking in debtor creditor relationship.
Investment is made though deterrent modes permitted under council board.
Investment income of the bank shared with depositors according to a ratio to endure a
reasonable fair rate of return on their depositors.
It aims are to introduce a welfare oriented banking system and also to establish equity
and justice in the field of all economic activities.
It extends economic and financial services to the poor , helpless and height income group
of the people for their economic up liftman particularly in the rural areas.
It plays a vital role in human resource development and employment generation
particularly for the unemployed youths.
Its aim is to achieve balanced growth and equitable development of the country through
diversified investment operations particularly in the priority sector and in the less
developed.
It extends cooperation to the poor the helpless and the height income group for their
economic development.
12 | P a g e
2.7 Functions of UBL
The operations of Uttara Bank Limited are divided into three major categories:
a. Mobilization of deposits.
b. Receipts and payment of cash.
c. Handling transfer transaction
d. Operations of clearing house
e. Maintenance of accounts with Bangladesh band and other bank
f. Collection of cheque and bill
g. Issue and payment of Demand Draft, telegraphic transfers and payment order
h. Executing customers standing instructions
i. Maintenance of safe deposit lockers
j. Maintenance of internal accounts of the bank
While doing all the above noted work UBL issue cheques-book, Deposit account opening form,
SS card, Ledgers, Cash book, Deposit account ledgers, preparation statement of accounts. Pass
Book, Balance of different accounts and calculated profits.
13 | P a g e
2. Foreign Exchange Business
Foreign Exchange Business plays a vital role in providing substantial revenue on the bank
income pool.
Opening letter of credit against commission for importing industrial agricultural and
other permissible items under council board.
Opening letter of credit on the principle of sale, on the principle of under wage earner
scheme.
Handling of export /import document.
Negotiation of export and import document when discrepancy occurs.
Financing import under import board.
Financing to export on profit or loss sharing
Handling inward and outward remittance.
3. Other activities
The UBL performs the following task for the welfare of the nation. There are some points which
is below:-
Income generating scheme for the unemployed youth of the nation.
Monorom sale center for marketing homemade garment, handicraft and other items.
Education scheme for assisting poor scholar student to case and help them to continue
their study.
Health scheme for fulfillment of health needs of rural people.
Uttara University was established to extend service to the student.
14 | P a g e
2.8 Operational Network Organogram
Management Hierarchy
Chairman
↓
Board of Director
↓
Managing Director
↓
Deputy Managing Director
↓
Senior Executive Vice President
↓
Executive Vice President
↓
Senior Vice President
↓
Vice President
↓
Senior Assistant Vice President
↓
First Assistant Vice President
↓
Assistant Vice President
↓
Senior Executive Officer
↓
Executive Officer
↓
Principal Officer
↓
Senior Officer
↓
Junior Officer
↓
Assistant officer
15 | P a g e
2.9 Services & Products
UBL is a service oriented financial institution. The main function of the bank is to provide
services to its clients. The bank offers various products and services to the clients to attract them.
The first primary job of the bank is to collect deposit from its clients and other prospective
clients who still have not opened their accounts at the bank. They offer different accounts at the
bank. They offer different interest rates to the different accounts. The bank also provides credit
facilities to its clients. In fact the deposits are collected to lend some money to the people to
make profit. Also the foreign exchange department opens the L/C to its clients and thus collects
L/C commissions from its clients and thus makes a huge profit of its own.
UBL offers many products and services to its clients on their satisfaction. It has a good
reputation in the banking sector by continuously updating product and service qualities. A bank
cannot be able to make its desirable progress without the satisfaction of its customers. That’s
why UBL always gives preference to its client satisfaction and made significant progress through
its operation such as deposit mobilization, credit management, foreign trade etc.
SERVICES:
1. Personal Banking:
Amongst private sector banks, UBL has already made its mark in the personal banking segment.
2. Corporate Banking:
UBL offers a full range of tailored advisory, financing and operational services to its corporate
client groups combining trade, treasury, investment and transactional banking activities in one
package. Whether it is project finance, term loan, import or export deal, a working capital
requirement or a forward cover for a foreign currency transaction, UBL’s corporate banking
managers will offer clients the right solution. Customers will find top class skills and in depth
16 | P a g e
knowledge of market trends in UBL’s corporate banking specialists, speedy approvals and
efficient processing fully satisfying client’s requirements-altogether a rewarding experience.
4. SME Services:
Since inception, the UBL has held socio economic development in high esteem and was among
the first to recognize the potentials of SME’s.
17 | P a g e
preparing the required documents in acceptable formats. In this regard, the Uttara Bank SME
unit has been working in close collaboration with the USAID, the SEDF an IFC managed multi
donor facility and the World Bank.
5. Online Banking Services:
Online banking services are designed to provide better services to its clients. Previously UBL
used PC bank but now they use world class software named Flora to avail this service to their
customers. This allows them to give prompt service to their valued clients. Flora is a universal
banking solution that meets the customer’s needs in retail, corporate and investment banking.
Under this system, the bank is capable of doing, for example, the following transactions:
18 | P a g e
Fund transfer
Make utility bill payment
Open and close term deposit
Request for cheque book and account statements
Place stop- cheque request
Make loan repayment
Inquire interest and foreign currency rates and many more.
PRODUCTS:
1. Personal loan:
As part of establishing a personal banking franchise of UBL, the bank has successfully launched
personal loan. The product is a term financing facility to aid them in their purchases of consumer
durables or services. Depending on the size and purpose of the loan, the number of installments
varies from 12 to 48 months.
2. Car loan:
The car loan is a term financing facility to individuals to aid them in their pursuit of has a car of
their dream. The facility becomes affordable to the clients as the repayment is done through fixed
installments facility period. Depending on the size purpose of the loan, the number of
installments varies from 12 to 60 months. In case of brand new cars, the loan tenure will be
maximum 72 months.
3. Vacation loan:
Vacation loan is a term financing facility to individuals to aid them in their hunt for spending a
vacation in the country or abroad. The facility becomes affordable to the clients as the repayment
is done through fixed installments facility period. Depending on the size and purpose of the loan,
the number of installments varies from 12 to 48 months.
19 | P a g e
4. Any purpose loan:
UBL introduced “Any Purpose Loan”. Now the client can get loan up to tk. 5,00,000 to spend it
any way he/she chooses to. The client may avail of this loan facility in any UBL’s branches. As a
result this facility is also available at the KBR of UBL.
5. SME Loan:
For small and medium size of business or enterprises Uttara Bank Limited provides some SME
loans. And they are-
20 | P a g e
6. Corporate Banking Products:
Securitization of assets:
UBL intends to take up the challenge of securitization of assets and play a significant role in
ensuring that securitization of assets becomes a normal part of the range of financial instruments
available for organizations who can count on a steady, but piecemeal, flow of revenue and want
to translate this stream into cash resources with which to carry out further lending activities to
new customers. Some practical issues still need to be settled such as those conceding pricing, or
the legal framework, but it is expected that, as UBL and other institutions pursue more such
securitization activities these will be resolved.
Syndication of funds:
At UBL, the Syndication and structured Finance Unit was setup on October 30, 2004.This unit
effectively closed two syndicated deals in the first and second quarters of 2004. The syndications
and Structured Finance team as a business unit soon followed up by closing another deal totaling
tk. 2.10 billion for a large local corporate. The year 2004 being the first full year of operation for
the team ended on a high note as UBL was able to close three syndicated deals as the Lead Bank,
two deals as the Co arranger and several other deals as a participant.
21 | P a g e
7. Uttaran Consumer-Credit Scheme
UBL started Uttaran Consumers Credit Scheme from 1996.UBL offers opportunity of financial
assistance for –
22 | P a g e
8. Monthly Benefit Scheme (MBS)
UBL has introduced monthly benefit scheme for the prudent persons having ready cash
and desiring to have fixed in income on monthly basis out of it without taking risk of loss and
without en-cashing the principal amount.
Deposits Products
At present Uttara Bank Limited has the following deposit product that has been offered to
general public:
1. Current Account
The client can enjoy maximum flexibility and convenience when he/she opens a current account
with us.
23 | P a g e
2. Savings Account
The Savings Account allows the client to have interest income on his/her deposit whilst the
account can be used for your transaction purposes. He/she can draw a maximum number of two
cheques per week; exceeding this number will forfeit the interest for the month. UBL offers a
competitive interest rate (6.00%) on the account. Also there is no requirement for a minimum
balance to be maintained in the account to be eligible for the interest. Interest is applied to the
account on half-yearly rests.
24 | P a g e
4. Fixed Deposit account
Clients can open Fixed Deposit Accounts for 3 months, 6 months, 1 year or for longer term. UBL
offers competitive interest rates. Clients can Place their deposit under lien with UBL and take a
loan, buy shares or open an overdraft account to meet their cash requirements. Interest rates on
deposits vary from time to time.
5. Others Accounts
Foreign Currency Account for private individual/firm/organization:
Any person/firm/organization who earns foreign currency can open Foreign Currency
Account with UBL.
Payments in foreign currency may be made freely abroad from this account and local
payment in Taka may also be made from this account.
Bank pay interest provided the accounts are maintained in the form of term deposit for minimum
period of 90 days.
Foreign Currency Account for Bangladeshi Nationals Working and earning abroad:
No initial deposit is required.
A/c holder nominates his nominee to operate the account.
25 | P a g e
The account holder can freely transfer entire amount in foreign currency anywhere he
chooses or can convert into Bangladesh Taka currency.
Funds from this account may also be issued to the account holder up to his entitlement for
the purpose of his foreign travels in usual manner.
26 | P a g e
Chapter-3
27 | P a g e
Chapter-3: Job Details, Observation & Learning’s
3.1 Job Details
Accounts Division
As an Intern, I was very lucky that I got chance to work on various section of a bank. That helps
me to improve my knowledge about banking activities. I work on four different divisions on
UBL. Now I will briefly describe my job details bellow-
28 | P a g e
2. Credit Division
The main activities of the bank are done by the Credit division. This division is all about giving
loans and managing the risk of the investment. This department exercises the lending function;
therefore, distribute its funds among various assets in a manner as to drive sufficient income. The
different tasks in this division are as follows:
3. Accounts Division
Accounts division is one of the most important divisions in the branch. The officers of this
division do all accounts activities of branch. The officers match daily position with the daily
affaires. The task I done in this division are:
29 | P a g e
Chapter-4
30 | P a g e
Chapter-4: Credit Approval and Risk Management
The word credit comes from the Latin “Credo” meaning, “I believe”. It is a lenders trust in
persons/firms/company’s ability or potential ability to command goods or services of another in
return for promise to pay such goods or services of another in return for promise to pay such
goods or services at some specified time in the future. The making of loans and advances has
always been prominent profitable function of bank. Sanctioning credit to customers and others
out of the funds at its disposal is one of the principal services of a modern bank.
Credit Appraisal is a process to ascertain the risks associated with the extension of the credit
facility. It is generally carried by the financial institutions which are involved in providing
financial funding to its customers. Credit risk is a risk related to non repayment of the credit
obtained by the customer of a bank. Thus it is necessary to appraise the credibility of the
customer in order to mitigate the credit risk. Proper evaluation of the customer is performed this
measures the financial condition and the ability of the customer to repay back the loan in future.
Generally the credits facilities are extended against the security know as collateral. But even
though the loans are backed by the collateral, banks are normally interested in the actual loan
amount to be repaid along with the interest. Thus, the customer's cash flows are ascertained to
ensure the timely payment of the principal and the interest.
In Banks and Financial Institutions, Credit Risk is considered as an essential factor that needs to
be managed. Credit Risk is the possibility that a borrower or counter party will fail to meet its
obligations in accordance with the agreed terms. Credit Risk, therefore, arises from the Bank’s
dealings with or lending to corporate, individuals and other Banks or Financial Institutions.
31 | P a g e
Procedure of Disbursement of Loans & Advances
To have crystal clear idea about the credit management of Uttara Bank Limited.
Uttara Bank Limited credit policy contains the views of total macro-economic development of
the country as a whole by way of providing financial support to the Trade, Commerce and
Industry. Throughout its credit operation Uttara Bank Limited goes to every possible corners of
the society. They are financing large and medium scale business house and industry. At the same
time they also take care entrepreneurs through its operation and lease finance and micro-credit,
small loan scheme etc.
1. Charging of interest is flexible depending on insisting of the proposal and the customer.
2. It takes care and maintaining proper “Mix” of Short, Medium and Long term finance for
a period not exceeding five years.
3. Uttara Bank Limited put emphasis on the customer.
4. It takes care of diversity in credit portfolio.
32 | P a g e
4.1.2 Credit Sanctioning Authority of Uttara Bank Limited
Uttara Bank Limited believes in decentralization of power and authority as because of the evil
duel subordination may creep in the chain of command. Its authority is not well defined and
properly implemented with a view to ensuring prompt efficient services to its multiple plans
spread far and wide, the bank envisages delegation of optimum power to its executive and
officials at different level of operation.
In order to implements the system of delegation of power effectively and to drive the desired for
the bank as well as the executive concerned, bank has develop a system to ensure that delegated
authority by the executive can be evaluated realistically and qualitatively.
The basic guideline they follow to achieve the objective of delegation of authority is-
The Managing Director can exercise all the powers vested in other executives
of the bank.
The Managing Director may suspend exercise of delegated power of any
executive through specific or general order.
Other than Managing Director, the delegation of powers is exercise by the
executive through specific or general order.
Delegated powers are expected to be exercise by the authorized executives judiciously keeping
the bank interest in mind. In exercising the powers so delegated authorized executives shall also
have credit restrictions as governed by banking company act, Bangladesh Bank for exercising the
delegated power-
33 | P a g e
2. The enterprise of the borrower must be viable and profitable. Proposal of the
borrower must be evaluated properly and carefully so as to ascertains its
profitability.
3. The borrower must have the capital and capability for utilizing credit properly
and profitably.
4. No sanctioning officer can sanction any credit to any of his near relations to
any firm/company where his relations have financial interest.
5. A customer to who credit is to be allowed; should be far as possible within
the command area.
6. There shall be no power to sanction clear advance.
In addition to the formal credit appraisal, the credit of Uttara Bank Limited tries to judge the
possible client based on some criteria. These criteria are called the C’s of good and bad loans.
These C’s are described below:
1. Character Make sure that the individual or company you are leading to the
Outstanding integrity.
2. Capacity Make sure that the individual or company you are leading to have
3. Conditions Understanding the business and economic conditions can and will
4. Capital Make sure that the individual or company you are leading to have an
34 | P a g e
Appropriate level of investment in the company.
5. Collateral Make sure that there is a “Second way out” of a credit but do not
7. Communication Share credit objectives credit decision making both vertically and
8. Contingencies Make sure that you understand the risk, particularly the downside
Possibilities and that the structure and price the loan consistently
9. Complacency Do not rely on past history to continue. Start alert to what can go
10. Competition Do not get swept away by what others are doing.
a) Liquidity
b) Profitability.
c) Purpose of loan.
d) Nature of loan.
e) Source of repayment.
f) Diversification of investment.
35 | P a g e
g) Policy of Central Bank.
h) Education and dealings lender.
In approval process the Bank segregates its Relationship Management from the Approving
Authority. The existing approval authorities are Head of Branch, Zonal Head, Head Office Credit
Committee, Executive Committee of the Board of Directors and Board of Directors as per their
delegation of business powers defined in later section. The recommending or approving
executives shall take responsibility for and be held accountable for their recommendations or
approval. Delegation of approval limits shall be as per policy guidelines that all proposals where
facilities are up to 15% of the bank’s capital shall be approved at the CRM level, facilities upto
25% of the capital shall be approved by Managing Director & CEO subject to the limit approved
by the Board of Directors.
The Branch Marketing Team comprising of Executives and Officers shall market the clients and
then prepare credit appraisal memo as per the prescribed format and within the purview of the set
rule/policy guideline of the Bank. In case it is within the delegated business power of the Head of
Branch, the concerned Executive / Officer will place it to the Head of Branch who will make
judgment (qualitative and quantitative judgment) and if found viable then he/she will approve the
Loan otherwise he/she may reject it or forward it to the Zonal Head / Head of Corporate /
Commercial Banking at Head Office.
The concerned Executive / Officer at Zonal Office on receipt of the proposal will prepare a credit
appraisal memo as per the prescribed format and within the purview of the set rule / policy
guidelines and then place it to Zonal Head who will make Judgment (qualitative and
quantitative) and if found viable then he will approve the facility, if it is within his business
delegated power otherwise he may reject it or forward it to the Head of Corporate / Commercial
Banking at Head Office along with his recommendations. The Proposal on receipt by the Head of
36 | P a g e
Corporate / Commercial Banking will forward it to the Head of Credit who in turn distribute it to
the respective Credit Officer at the Head Office for scrutiny, analysis and prepare a Office Note /
Memo with due diligence along with their observations / results of analysis and to place it before
the Head Office Credit Committee. In Head Office Credit Division, separate Credit Officers are
designated for looking after the proposal of separate Branches. The Head Office Credit
Committee depending upon the delegated business power shall either approve it (or reject it if
not found viable) or place it to the Executive Committee of Directors / Board of Directors.\
Any declined credit proposal may be presented to the next higher authority for reassessment /
approval. However, there shall be no appeal process beyond the Managing Director & CEO.
Document Checklist
The approved document checklist must be maintained for every credit facility, which contains:
a) Details of all general and specific requirements
b) The dates on which these were submitted and complied with
c) The location of these documents.
37 | P a g e
4.5 Credit Administration & Disbursement Authority:
The Disbursement Authority has been separated from Approval authority. The Disbursement
Authority is vested upon the Credit Administration Division (CAD). The flow chart for
disbursement process is given below:
APPROVAL AUTHORITY
Approval letter
HEAD OF HEAD OF
CAD BRANCH
38 | P a g e
The Credit Administration function is critical in ensuring that proper documentation and
approvals are in place prior to the disbursement of loan facilities. The functions of Credit
Administration are strictly segregated from Relationship Management/Marketing in order to
avoid the possibility of controls being compromised or issues not being highlighted at the
appropriate level.
4.5.1 Disbursement:
Security documents are to be prepared in accordance with approval terms and to be
legally enforceable through the enlisted/ competent lawyer. Standard loan facility
documentation’s are to be drafted / prepared by the legal counsel.
Disbursements under loan facilities are made when all loan and security
documentation is in place and clean CIB report obtained from Bangladesh Bank. All
formalities regarding large loans and loans to Directors are guided by Bangladesh
Bank circulars and related section of Banking Companies Act. All Credit Approval
terms must be met. The checklist certificate is to be signed by Credit In-charge and
Head of Branch. In order to cope with the revised policy, the disbursement authority
will be vested to the Head of Credit Administration Division up to Tk. 5.00 Crore
above which will be vested to the Additional Managing Director/ Deputy Managing
Director. In the absence of the Additional Managing Director/ Deputy Managing
Director the power may be exercised by the Head of CRMD.
39 | P a g e
Appropriate insurance coverage is maintained (and renewed on a timely basis) on
pledged/ Hypothecated as security.
Security documents are held under strict control, preferably in locked fireproof
storage and with joint control.
The Loan Administration unit of the division will establish and maintain a comprehensive data
base on all credit exposures, and monitor consolidated movements as these are reported through
copies of transaction sheets and summaries. It conducts portfolio analyses for the purpose of
evaluating portfolio performance and detecting any deterioration in the risk exposures. Summary
reports and recommendations are submitted to the Credit Committee for appropriate action or
policy decisions.
40 | P a g e
The credit review unit of the division is responsible for reviewing the credit process to ensure
that approved policies and procedures are being effectively being implemented throughout the
Bank.
These applications require assessments in line with the revised Credit Risk Grading System
(CRGS) framework. This is a comprehensive analytical process that examines the following
areas for potential risks:
Borrower -ownership, ownership structure, past financial performance, management
capability and depth, credit history & deposit account performance.
Industry-vitality and prospects (sales volume trends in relation to demand levels), level of
competition, buyer-supplier leverages and threats, cost and pricing structure, entry
barriers and threats of new entries/substitution.
Financial Package-type and purpose of assistance required, tenor, terms and conditions
Security-quality and quantity
Furthermore, potential risk exposures and any migrating factors must be disclosed in the
analysis. These risks are invariably fall into the following categories:
41 | P a g e
Supplier/Buyer Leverages: Any customer or supplier concentrations are addressed, as
these could have a significant impact on the future viability of the borrower.
Historical Financial Analysis: Analyses of a minimum of 3 years historical financial
statement of the borrower are presented. Cash flow, profitability and leverage trends are
analyzed.
Projected Financial Performances: A projection of the borrower’s future financial
performance are provided, indicating the sufficiency or lack thereof of cash flow to
service debt repayment, Loans are not granted if projected cash flow is insufficient to
repay debts.
Account Conduct: For existing borrowers, the historic performances in meeting
repayment obligations (trade payments, cheques, interest and principal payments, etc.)
are assessed.
Loan structures: The amount and tenors of financing proposed are justified based on the
projected repayment ability and loan purpose. Excessive tenor or amount relative to
business needs increases the risk of fund diversion and may adversely impact the
borrower’s repayment ability.
Security: A current valuation of collateral is obtained and the quality and priority of
security being proposed are assessed. Loans are not be granted based solely on security,
Mitigating Factors: Risk factors (margin, sustainability, leverage /gearing, over-
stocking, rapid growth/acquisition/expansion, management changes or succession issues,
customer or supplier concentration, lack of transparency or industry issues) are identified
in the credit assessment.
The Bank rates its individual risk exposures continuously until these have been discharged
through full payment or otherwise written off. However, actual account performances are an
additional consideration in classifying the exposures into one of the following eight categories:
42 | P a g e
industry.
Account Performance: Account is cooperative, pays on time, and provides non-loan business.
Security: Facilities are fully secured by cash deposits, government bonds or an unconditional
guarantee from a top-tier international bank or financial institution.
43 | P a g e
Special mention (BB):
Industry/Business & Financials: These borrowers deserve management’s close attention because
of consecutive losses over two years with the potential to have negative net worth, excessive
leverage.
Account Performance: Account is paying, but may be delayed by less than three months from
time to time.
Security: Security position could be less than satisfactory if default occurs longer than 3 months.
An aggregate score would be 55-64
Substandard (B):
Financial condition is weak, and capacity or inclination to repay is in doubt. These weaknesses
jeopardize the full settlement of loans.
An aggregate score would be 45-54.
44 | P a g e
45 | P a g e
46 | P a g e
47 | P a g e
4.8 Recovery of Non-Performing Loans & Investments
The NPL Recovery Unit is responsible for all accounts assigned to it by the Credit Committee.
The units are staffed by seasoned senior officers who undertake the following activities:
Check the accounts thoroughly and establish business prospects; and find out the best
way to recover the Bank’s exposure with the least possible losses.
Restructure those accounts which are deemed to be cooperative and in temporary distress,
and monitor their performance closely until they have substantially complied with the
revised terms including payment of at least six months’ installments; rehabilitated
accounts may be returned to the originating front offices for regular monitoring and
supervision after this prescriptive period.
Preparation of accounts with security, whose operations are active but the owners are
uncooperative, for legal action; coordinate with the Bank’s legal counsel and/or external
lawyers in the filing and prosecution stage; execute final judgment as may be determined
by the courts. For these types of accounts, the NPL Unit may recommend further
accounting treatments (such as additional loan loss provisions) depending on the
perceptions concerning the Bank’s security position. Blacklist the borrowers to ensure
they are not entertained for future accommodations in the future.
Prepare accounts without any security, whose operations are either active or inactive and
the owners are uncooperative, for attachment of personal assets through legal means; as
above, coordinate with the legal agents of the Bank until the cases are resolved.
Recommend write-off for accounts with no hope of recovery, and blacklist the borrowers
to ensure they are never entertained in the future. The Board have the sole authority to
approve write-offs
48 | P a g e
4.9 Internal Audit & Compliance
All front office lending outlets are audited regularly (at least bi-annually) as an independent
check of their activities. However, more frequent inspections and audits are conducted if
situation is demand. Particular attentions are paid to the corporate and Authorized Dealer (AD)
branches which are expected to originate and maintain the bulk of the credit and investment
portfolios. Compliance Requirements are:
Bangladesh Bank Circulars and other regulations are maintained and updated regularly.
Guidelines with regard to CIB reporting, provisioning and write -off of bad and doubtful
debts, and suspension of interest accrual are strictly enforced. These require the approval
of the. Board, as recommended by the MD-CEO.
The performance of all external service providers (e.g. property appraisers, lawyers,
insurers, CPAs, etc.) are reviewed on a periodic basis.
49 | P a g e
Chapter-5
50 | P a g e
Chapter-5: SWOT Analysis
SWOT analysis is an important part for evaluating the company’s Strength, Weakness,
Opportunity, and Threats. It helps the organization to identify how to evaluate its performance
and scan the micro environment.
As I was engaged to identify the current position of Uttara Bank Limited in the competitive in
the market, it is very necessary to have the SWOT analysis to identify the Strength, Weakness,
Opportunity, and Threats of UBL. This is one of the popular way by which one get take
necessary action to improve their business because SWOT analysis is completely depend on the
market. The SWOT analysis of UBL is given below:
Strength (S)
Weaknesses (W)
51 | P a g e
Long management hierarchy.
UBL has no promotional tools for their clients.
Lack of Technological Advancement
Lack of success plan.
Opportunity (O):
Threats (T):
52 | P a g e
Chapter-6
53 | P a g e
Chapter-6: Major Findings, Recommendations and conclusion
Major Findings
In most of the cases, if a client comes to take loan, the questionnaire form filling becomes
hard for him as it is too long and it takes a lot of time.
Duration of time for preparing appraisal report after submitting and managing all the
documents and papers, the loan operation department takes almost three months and in
some cases, it cross three months and takes 5 or 6 months. The problem is that within this
time period, project that was viable for that time becomes obsolete getting loan and
starting business.
Lack of proper updated technology is another problem. This is the age of information
technology (IT) all the activities are computerized. Though Uttara Bank has its own
networking system but that system is not up to date.
There is lack of experienced engineers for the electronic devices.
Political violence is a crucial limiting factor. Though, the Uttara Bank is not a State
owned bank, however the local politics may effect to granting the loans by giving various
types of pressure.
There are lack of motivations to the mid and lower level officers. It seems they are
unsatisfied with remuneration and other benefits they get.
In a few cases, I have seen that the right person is not placed in the right place.
Sometimes inefficient allocations of resources have created a huge amount of bad debt.
There is political interruption in sanctioning loan.
Lack of co-ordination among the various departments is also a big problem of this bank.
There is also lack of team speed.
There is trade union but that is politically influenced.
54 | P a g e
Recommendations
Uttara Bank Ltd is one of the first leading banks in Bangladesh. Its major operations are profit,
growth, development and welfare oriented. Management system of this bank is fully democratic.
It always maintains the rules declared by Bangladesh Bank. Uttara Bank training institute
provides training facilities to its medium & junior level officers of the bank and also provides
executive development & internship programs. This is my observation that there are some areas
where UBL should improve and those are:
The number of customer is increasing. To keep the commitment UBL must increase its
manpower. So the customer gets their result without wasting time.
UBL should take necessary action to motivate its officers to encourage them to work hard
to make them believe that they are also a part of the team and the bank does think about
them.
Management should place right person in the right place.
MIS cell should be developed through internal, tax e-mail etc.
Accounting system of the Bank should be high tech software base.
Fund management of the Bank should be more efficient. This will reduce the average
cost of working fund.
Productivity measurement should be done from time to time through developing
customer services.
Stuck up advances should be reduced through more recovery at lower rate of interest.
Officers who are working on Credit risk management & Project finance procedure, they
should give attention on timing of sanctioning finance because demand of any kind of
product is being flexible. So if other thing is remaining constant, sanctioning procedure
should not be delayed.
UBL should take necessary step to increase their network facilities.
ATM card facilities are not easy of UBL. So they are losing their many potential
customers. So I think UBL should take necessary step to easy their ATM card facilities
for their customers.
55 | P a g e
Conclusion
So as a private bank UBL is trying it’s best to extend their service to the public. UBL, Main
Branch provides all kinds of commercial banking services to its customers. Foreign Exchange
department is doing well in rending all the services related to the international trade and
remittance. Though the advance of Main Branch is high, the Credit department will be in a good
position if the Branch able to recover that. General banking is engaged in cash receipt, payment,
cheque clearing, opening accounts, deposit scheme, and local remittance etc. So if the UBL
wants to continue a profitable business and position itself as one of the top bank in the bank
arena then it has to earn the trust of their assets and must be concerned about their commitment
to the customers.
As concluding remark the bank is able to attain a leading role with the 31 years success story but
to remain unrivalled among new generation banks, the bank must face new challenges. The bank
must make a positive attempt to be more outward looking in their goals and aware of what is
happening. They must also emphasize on the domestic scenario more closely and analyze any
certain trends and strategies of their competitors. The bank must accept any failures and think of
56 | P a g e
them as an objective to pursue future goals instead of blaming such failures on other factors and
in this way the Bank will be able to keep on playing its important roles in our economy.
57 | P a g e
References
58 | P a g e