Adherence To Exercise Programs For Older
Adherence To Exercise Programs For Older
Adherence To Exercise Programs For Older
Journal of
PHYSIOTHERAPY
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jphys
Research
K E Y W O R D S A B S T R A C T
Adherence Question: How has adherence been measured in recent prospective studies focusing on adherence to
Older people exercise programs among older people? What is the range of adherence rates? Which factors are
Physical activity associated with better adherence? Design: Systematic review of prospective studies that had a primary
Exercise
aim of assessing adherence to exercise programs. Participants: Older people undertaking exercise
Physiotherapy
programs. Intervention: Exercise programs. Outcome measures: Measures of adherence, adherence
rates and factors associated with adherence. Results: Nine eligible papers were identified. The most
common adherence measures were the proportion of participants completing exercise programs (ie, did
not cease participation, four studies, range 65 to 86%), proportion of available sessions attended (five
studies, range 58 to 77%) and average number of home exercise sessions completed per week (two
studies, range 1.5 to 3 times per week). Adherence rates were generally higher in supervised programs.
The person-level factors associated with better adherence included: demographic factors (higher
socioeconomic status, living alone); health status (fewer health conditions, better self-rated health,
taking fewer medications); physical factors (better physical abilities); and psychological factors (better
cognitive ability, fewer depressive symptoms). Conclusion: Older people’s adherence to exercise
programs is most commonly measured with dropout and attendance rates and is associated with a range
of program and personal factors. [Picorelli AMA, Pereira LSM, Pereira DS, Felicio D, Sherrington C
(2014) Adherence to exercise programs for older people is influenced by program characteristics
and personal factors: a systematic review. Journal of Physiotherapy 60: 151–156]
ß 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Australian Physiotherapy Association. This is an open
access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jphys.2014.06.012
1836-9553/ß 2014 Published by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Australian Physiotherapy Association. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/).
152 [(Figure_1)TD$IG]
Picorelli et al: Exercise program adherence among older people
Table 1
Characteristics and findings of the studies included in the review (n = 9).
Dorgo14 Community volunteers aged Exercise sessions targeted Group 1: Retention rate was higher in the
>60 (yr) participating in one cardiovascular fitness, strength, 90% 14-wk retention rate peer mentor group
of two intervention groups in muscle mass, power, agility and 25 (SD 5) of 35 sessions Participation rates were
a randomised trial flexibility. attended by completers (72%) significantly higher in the
n = 60 75-min group sessions, 3/wk x Group 2: student mentor group (p = 0.008)
14 wk 77% 14-wk retention rate
Group 1: peer mentors 29 (SD 4) of 35 sessions
Group 2: student mentors attended by completers (82%)
Flegal13 ‘Generally healthy’ seniors Group 1: yoga, 90-min class/wk Group 1: The adherence differences
participating in one of two and home practice daily 86% completed study between the yoga and the exercise
intervention groups in a Group 2: outdoor aerobic Among Group 1 completers: group did not reach statistical
randomised trial walking class, 60 min/wk and at 77% classes attended significance (for percent
n = 91 home 5/wk home exercise on 64% of days attendance (p = 0.056) and for
Group 2: percent days practiced out of all
81% completed study days possible, t = –1.822, p = 0.073)
Among Group 2 completers: Home practice sessions lasted an
69% classes attended average of 38 min for the yoga
home exercise on 64% of days group and 56 min for the exercise
(76% of the prescribed 5 d/wk) group (t = 3.8, p = 0.0003)
Class attendance was significantly
(p < 0.05) correlated with baseline
measures of depression, fatigue
and physical components of
health-related quality of life
Jancey12 Insufficiently active adults Walking, strength and flexibility 65% completed the program A multivariate model found that
aged 65 to 74 yr recruited from exercise sessions conducted in 30 77% of those who didn’t non-completion was significantly
the Australian federal local neighbourhoods using social- complete the program ceased associated with lower
electoral roll cognitive theory incorporating participation in the first 3 mth socioeconomic status (OR 0.4,
participating as the self-efficacy factors. 95% CI 0.19 to 0.83), overweight
intervention group in a 2 sessions/wk x 6 mth (OR 2.29, 95% CI 1.01 to 5.19),
randomised trial insufficient physical activity at
n = 248 baseline (OR 2.40, 95% CI 1.30 to
4.43), lower walking self-efficacy
scores (OR 0.77, 95% CI 0.66 to
0.89) and higher loneliness scores
(OR 1.03, 95% CI 1.01 to 1.07)
McAuley18 Sedentary adults aged 60 to Group 1: Walking group 88% completed the programs Attendance rates did not differ
75 yr participating in one of Group 2: Stretching and toning Group 1: significantly between treatment
two intervention groups in a program 56 d (SD 15) average groups (p = 0.30)
randomised trial 3 sessions/wk x 6 mth attendance 18 mth follow up physical
n = 174 Group 2: activity score did not differ
58 d (SD 13) average significantly between groups
attendance Structural equation modelling
indicated significant paths from
social support, affect and exercise
frequency to efficacy at 6 mth.
Efficacy, in turn, was related to
physical activity at 6-mth and 18-
mth follow-up. The model
accounted for 40% of the variance
in 18-mth activity levels
154 Picorelli et al: Exercise program adherence among older people
Table 1 (Continued )
Rejeski9 People aged 70–89 yr who Walking aiming for 150 min/wk, 71% of sessions attended in mth Month 1 to 2: a multivariate
were at elevated risk of and ‘limited’ training for balance 1 to 2 model explained 10% of
disability participating as the and strength. 61% of sessions attended in mth variability in adherence with
intervention group in a Mth 1 to 2: group exercise, 40- 3 to 6 significant predictors: lung
randomised trial 60 min sessions, 3/wk, plus Average of 3.7 sessions/wk in disease (est –10.9, SE 4.5,
n = 213 weekly group behaviour mth 7 to 12 p = 0.017) and low barriers to
counselling sessions, monthly efficacy score (est 2.1, SE 0.8,
telephone contact and home p = 0.010)
exercise sessions. Month 3 to 6: a multivariate
Mth 3 to 6: group exercise, 2/wk, model explained 10% of
behaviour counselling sessions, variability in adherence, with
monthly phone call. significant predictors:
Mth 7 to 12: optional centre- pacemaker (est 23.75, SE 11.91,
based sessions, 1/wk, monthly p = 0.047), slower 400 m walk
phone contact. times (est –2.30, SE 1.00,
p = 0.020), less than high school
education (est –9.4, SE 4.2,
p = 0.027). 21% of variability
explained when prior
attendance added
Month 7 to 12: a multivariate
model explained 13% of
variability in adherence, with
significant predictors:
pacemaker (est 1.8, SE 0.8,
p = 0.029) and tiredness (est 0.3,
SE 0.1, p = 0.014), 48% of
variability was explained when
prior attendance added
Sjosten15 Community-dwelling people Group and home exercise, Average of 58% (SD 30) of group Univariate analyses: lower age,
aged >65 yr who had fallen in psychosocial group activities and exercise sessions attended low self-perceived risk of falling
the past yr participating as lectures. 47% of participants were highly at home and better functional
the intervention group in a Exercise targeted balance, adherent (> 66% adherence ability were strongest predictors
randomised trial strength and respiratory rates) with group sessions of exercise group adherence.
n = 293 function. Mean 3 (SD 2.1) home exercise Using less than four prescription
45-min sessions, 2/mth, plus sessions completed/wk medicines was significantly
home exercise, 3/wk. associated with home-exercise
adherence
Multivariate analysis: Low self-
perceived probability of falling at
home (OR 1.6, 95% CI 1.0 to 2.6)
and good physical functional
abilities (OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.5 to
4.8) were significant predictors
of exercise group adherence
Stineman10 Older people who had fallen Exercise targeted fitness, 87% attended 4+ of 7 classes On-site exercise adherence was
and visited an emergency balance, strength and flexibility. 73% attended all 7 classes better than home
department participating as Mth 1: on-site group classes, 78% exercised at home for 7 of Univariate predictors of full
the intervention group in a 1/wk. the 12 wk (via diary) adherence to on-site exercise:
randomised trial Mth 2–4: exercises at home, 1% exercised 3 times/wk at advanced age, non-African
n = 102 3 session/wk, plus 1 on-site home for all twelve weeks (via Americans, males, high school or
class/mth, plus 1 home visit from diary) higher education, living alone,
a trained community worker/ SF-36 score, lower BMI, fewer
mth. comorbidities, fewer
medications, physical function,
physical role function, perceived
general health, 6 MWD, less
depression, fewer psychometric
medications and MMSE scores
Multivariate analysis: Living
alone associated with full
adherence to on-site exercise
(adjusted OR = 3.0, 95% CI 1.1 to
8.1). Depressed mood was
associated with decreased
adherence to on-site exercise
(adjusted OR = 0.85, 95% CI 0.72
to 1.0)
Analysis of factors associated
with adherence to home
program not undertaken due to
low adherence rates
Sullivan-Marx17 African American women Warm-up, walking intervals, 71% completed program Completers had lower scores on
needing assistance in ADL lower extremity exercises, cool Among completers: the depression scale than non-
participating in an down and deep breathing. 48% attended 3+ x/week completers (p = 0.004)
observational study 30 to 50-min group sessions, 71% attended 2+ x/week
n = 52 3/wk x 16 wk.
ADL = activities of daily living, est = estimate, MMSE = Mini Mental Status Exam, SF-36 = short form 36, 6 MWD = six-minute walk distance.
Research 155
between studies difficult. This hampers progress toward under- contexts, to raise commitment to exercise among the largely
standing exercise adherence in older people, as well as how to sedentary population of older people with their multiple illnesses
enhance it. Adherence to centre-based exercise programs is and functional deficits.10,17
relatively easy to document but adherence to home-based exercise A limitation of this review is that the results of the individual
currently relies on self-report, which may overestimate or observational studies may have been confounded by the presence
underestimate actual exercise frequency and duration. In the of other variables that were associated with both participant
future, technology may enable more accurate measurement of characteristics and exercise adherence rates. Social and psycho-
adherence in home-based physical activity studies. logical variables, such as motivation and social support, were not
Given the variability in measurement of adherence it was not measured in all studies and may explain larger amounts of
possible to meaningfully compare adherence rates across studies. variance in exercise adherence than the measured variables.
However, it was noted that retention and adherence rates in most Furthermore, the pragmatic decision to limit this review to the last
of the included studies were suboptimal. ten years of research may have impacted on the results.
The apparently higher rate of adherence to centre-based Understanding the variables that influence adherence to
programs provides challenges for the widespread implementation exercise among older people is very important for clinical
of exercise programs. Some programs combine group and home- physiotherapists because low rates of adherence are likely to
based aspects. This may be a feasible and cost-effective solution. limit the benefits obtained from exercise. Exercise adherence in
Given the limitations of this review, this issue requires further older people is multifactorial, involving demographic, health-
investigation. related, physical and psychological factors. The range of predictors
A number of person-level factors were found to be associated of exercise adherence underscores the need for health profes-
with greater adherence rates. Interestingly, reduced mental sionals to consider these findings in designing strategies to
wellbeing appeared to present a greater barrier to exercise enhance exercise adherence in this vulnerable population.
adherence than reduced physical wellbeing.10 People at risk of
depression were less likely to adhere to prescribed programs.
What is already known on this topic: Physical activity has a
Physical activity is potentially beneficial for fatigue and depres-
range of benefits for older people. In particular, structured
sion, so future intervention could specifically target adherence in exercise programs can prevent falls and increase strength.
this group of people. The concept of loneliness also requires more However, older people’s adherence to exercise interventions
investigation. This group of people might require more encour- declines over time.
agement, affirmation and feedback.11,12 What this study adds: In studies of exercise interventions for
Adherence is promoted by the belief that an intervention will be older people, few studies measure adherence the same way.
effective (the outcome expectancy), as well as the belief that the Few studies report very high adherence, but adherence is
individual is capable of following the requirements of the generally higher in supervised programs. Factors associated
intervention (the efficacy expectancy).13 It has been postulated with greater adherence include: higher socioeconomic status,
living alone, better health status, better physical ability, better
that people with greater adherence may engage in other health-
cognitive ability and fewer depressive symptoms.
promoting behaviours. Thus, adherence may be a marker for a
personality type, or related to motivation or goal-directed
behaviours. Self-efficacy, which may relate to motivation, is the
eAddenda: Appendix 1 can be found online at doi:10.1016/
perceived confidence in one’s ability to accomplish a specific
j.jphys.2014.06.012
task.13 Self-efficacy has been shown to affect exercise adoption and
Ethics approval: Not applicable.
maintenance.11 Therefore, intervention programs should develop
Competing interests: Nil.
and nurture this characteristic to enable individuals to continue
Source(s) of support: Nil.
with the program.
Acknowledgements: Nil.
Several of the studies included in this review used a range of
Correspondence: Catherine Sherrington, The George Institute
strategies in an effort to enhance adherence. Strategies to promote
for Global Health, The University of Sydney, Australia. Email:
adherence included: making instructions to subjects simpler and
csherrington@georgeinstitute.org.au
less demanding; addressing cognitive-motivational factors such as
self-efficacy and health beliefs; offering social support and
reinforcement; and providing reminders.13 Dorgo and colleagues14 References
showed that the peer-mentoring model has the potential to be a
1. Garber CE, Blissmer B, Deschenes MR, Franklin BA, Lamonte MJ, Lee IM, et al.
cost-effective method of reaching out to older adults, engaging American College of Sports Medicine position stand. Quantity and quality of
them in physical exercise programs for extended periods and exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory, musculoskeletal, and
improving their health and fitness. The assistance of professional neuromotor fitness in apparently healthy adults: guidance for prescribing exercise.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2011;43:1334–1359.
trainers with extensive experience would be costly, especially in 2. Gillespie LD, Robertson MC, Gillespie WJ, Sherrington C, Gates S, Clemson LM, et al.
long-term programs with high numbers of participants, while Interventions for preventing falls in older people living in the community. Cochrane
older adult peer mentors assisting on a volunteer basis would Database Syst Rev. 2012;9:CD007146.
3. Liu C-J, Latham NK. Progressive resistance strength training for improving physical
significantly reduce program costs. Appropriate activities should
function in older adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;3:CD002759.
be carefully planned before program implementation to best suit 4. Howe TE, Rochester L, Jackson A, Banks PM, Blair VA. Exercise for improving
the specific needs of aged individuals. Good reachability and balance in older people. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011;11:CD004963.
continuous motivation might also increase participation.15 Thus, a 5. Macchi C, Polcaro P, Cecchi F, Zipoli R, Sofi F, Romanelli A, et al. One-Year Adherence
to Exercise in Elderly Patients Adherence to Exercise in Elderly Patients Receiving
major responsibility of physiotherapists and other exercise Post acute Inpatient Rehabilitation After Cardiac Surgery. Am J Phys Med Rehabil.
prescribers is to educate people on the importance and value of 2009;88(9):727–734.
exercise, as it relates to optimal physical function, wellness and 6. Dolansky MA, Stepanczuk B, Charvat JM, Moore SM. Women’s and Men’s Exercise
Adherence after a Cardiac Event: Does Age Make a Difference? Res Gerontol Nurs.
quality of life.16 This review has focused on factors associated with 2010;3(1):30–38.
adherence rather than interventions designed to enhance adher- 7. Findorff MJ, Wyman JF, Gross CR. Predictors of Long-Term Exercise Adherence in a
ence. Therefore, these suggestions about enhancing exercise Community Sample of Older Women. J Women’s Health. 2009;18(11):1769–1776.
8. Seguin RA, Economos CD, Palombo R, Hyatt R, Kuder J, Nelson ME. Strength training
adherence need further investigation in clinical trials. and older women: a cross-sectional study examining factors related to exercise
Future research targeted at older people should be designed to adherence. J Aging Phys Activ. 2010;18:201–218.
incorporate specific strategies that will enhance the recruitment, 9. Rejeski WJ, Miller ME, King AC, Studenski SA, Katula JA, Fielding RA, et al. Predictors
of adherence to physical activity in the Lifestyle Interventions and Independence
adherence and retention of people from diverse cultures and ethnic for Elders pilot study (LIFE-P). Clin Interventions Aging. 2007;2(3):485–494.
backgrounds. Future work in this area should also address 10. Stineman MG, Strumpf N, Kurichi JE, Charles J, Grisso JA, Jayadevappa R. Attempts
behavioural motivation, as well as social and environmental to reach the oldest and frailest: recruitment, adherence, and retention of urban
156 Picorelli et al: Exercise program adherence among older people
elderly persons to a falls reduction exercise program. The Gerontologist. 15. Sjosten NM, Salanoja M, Piirtola M, Vahlberg TJ, Isoaho R, Hyttinem HK, et al. A
2011;51(1):59–72. multifactorial fall prevention programme in the community-dwelling aged: pre-
11. Fielding RA, Katula J, Miller ME, Abbot-Pillola K, Jordan A, Glynn NW, et al. Activity dictors of adherence. Eur J Public Health. 2007;17(5):464–470.
adherence and physical function in older adults with functional limitations. Med 16. Forkan R, Pumper B, Smyth N, Wirkkala H, Ciol MA, Shumway-Cook A. Exercise
Sci Sports Exerc. 2007;39(11):1997–2004. adherence following physical therapy intervention in older adults with impaired
12. Jancey J, Lee A, Howat P, Clarke A, Wang K, Shilton T. Reducing attrition in physical balance. Physical Therapy. 2006;86(3):401–410.
activity programs for older adults. J Aging Phys Activ. 2007;15:152–165. 17. Sullivan-Marx EM, Mangione KK, Ackerson T, Sidorov I, Maislin G, Volpe ST, et al.
13. Flegal KE, Kishiyama S, Zajdel D, Haas M, Oken BS. Adherence to yoga and exercise Recruitment and retention strategies among older African American women
interventions in a 6-month clinical trial. BMC Complement Altern Med. enrolled in an exercise study at a PACE program. The Gerontologist. 2011;51(1):
2007;7(37):1–7. 73–81.
14. Dorgo S, King GA, Brickey GD. The application of peer mentoring to improve fitness 18. McAuley E, Jerome GJ, Elavsky S, Márquez DX, Ramsey SN. Predicting long-term
in older adults. J Aging Phys Activ. 2009;17:344–361. maintenance of physical activity in older adults. Preventive Med. 2003;37:110–118.