EARTH 1998 – MOVIE ANALYSIS

Q: Do you think films can be studied as historical documents which provide an

insight into the societies which made and watched them? Critical analysis.

Ans: Yes, the best way to memorize things and through films we can feel emotions
which can deeply affect us, but it should be unbiased and show both perspectives.
Films helps us understanding of the culture, and changes in the society overtime.

Q: Who are the film's main protagonists and antagonists? How and why do you
think partition affected the lives of these protagonists/antagonists in the movie?
How do you see them transformed into the movie? (Discuss in detail)

Ans:

Q: What are Historical and Cultural references used in the movie? Is history
treated fairly, or twisted to suit the filmmakers' purposes? Debate and discuss.

Ans:

Q: What interesting facts or ideas does the movie bring to mind? To what
contemporary events does the film refer? What will you remember?

Ans:

Help me in my university assignment of the course "Pakistan History". Following are the
instructions: Film Review Questions: Guidelines/ Instructions: Give "textual evidence"
from the movie to support your argument. The evidence(s) can be in the form of a
dialogue/quote, a scene from a movie, or even a setting. You can also make
contemporary connections to justify the statement that you are writing. Please dont
write romanticize statements because it wont gain you many marks. Try to avoid
copy/pasting from your friends/ class-fellows because you can be failed on plagiarism
grounds. Get a hard copy of it before entering the class tomorrow. Answers should be
typed in font 12, Time New Roman, Double Space(2.0) in Docx format. Answer should
be 300-600 words each question. It can even be above 600 words. 1. Do you think films
can be studied as historical documents which provide an insight into the societies
which made and watched them? Critically analyze. 2. Who are the film’s main
protagonists and antagonists? How and why do you think partition affected the lives of
these protagonists/antagonists in the movie? How do you see them transformed into
the movie? (Discuss in detail) 3. What are Historical and Cultural references used in the
movie? Is history treated fairly, or twisted to suit the filmmakers’ purposes? Debate and
discuss. 4. What interesting facts or ideas does the movie bring to mind? To what
contemporary events does the film refer? What will you remember? answer the first
question

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

To answer the question "Do you think films can be studied as historical documents
which provide an insight into the societies which made and watched them?" let's break
it down into key aspects:

1. Films as Historical Documents

Films can indeed be studied as historical documents, but they must be approached
with a critical lens. Movies often reflect the values, beliefs, and concerns of the society
in which they are produced. Directors and writers embed cultural, political, and social
realities of their time into the narratives, characters, and settings. For example, a film
set in post-Partition India or Pakistan might portray the trauma of migration, communal
violence, and the impact of colonialism, thus providing viewers with an understanding
of how people of that time perceived those events.

2. Textual Evidence from Films

In many cases, the dialogues or actions in a movie can reveal historical sentiments. For
instance, in movies like Gandhi (1982) or Manto (2018), the protagonists express their
frustrations, hopes, or fears, which mirror the struggles of the broader population. In
Gandhi, we see scenes depicting protests against British rule, representing the
collective movement toward independence. In Manto, the dialogue often references
the Partition and the emotional devastation that came with it, reflecting societal
divisions.

3. Filmmakers’ Perspective

However, films are not objective records of history. Filmmakers interpret history based
on their ideological leanings or artistic visions. For example, while some directors might
seek to faithfully depict historical events, others may romanticize or dramatize them for
cinematic effect. This is why, although films offer valuable insights into the societies
that produced them, they should not be taken at face value.
A critical example is how Partition is portrayed in films like Earth (1998). The director,
Deepa Mehta, uses the story to delve into the communal violence and the personal
losses experienced by people of various faiths. The film gives a vivid depiction of the
emotional and physical toll of Partition on society. But it also reflects the filmmaker’s
perspective, which emphasizes certain themes (e.g., Hindu-Muslim unity, personal
betrayal) while perhaps omitting other historical nuances.

4. Contemporary Connections

In some cases, filmmakers also make a conscious effort to draw parallels between past
events and contemporary issues. For instance, films about British colonialism might
implicitly criticize modern forms of neo-colonialism or inequality. These films often
resonate with modern audiences because they tap into ongoing social or political
struggles, using the past as a mirror to reflect the present.

5. Conclusion

In conclusion, films can indeed be studied as historical documents, as they provide

insights into the cultural and social contexts of their time. However, because they are
shaped by the filmmakers’ interpretations, they should be analyzed critically and
alongside more traditional historical sources. The ability of a film to depict the
emotions, conflicts, and ideologies of the time makes it a valuable but imperfect
window into history.

4o

You said:

Talking about the movie "Earth (1998)", tell me who are the protagonists and
antagonists of this film

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

In Earth (1998), directed by Deepa Mehta, the protagonists and antagonists are shaped
by the socio-political turmoil of the Partition of India in 1947. The film, based on Bapsi
Sidhwa’s novel Cracking India, portrays the lives of ordinary people as they are torn
apart by communal violence and shifting loyalties.
Protagonists

1. Lenny: Lenny, an 8-year-old Parsi girl, is the central protagonist. Through her
innocent eyes, we witness the unfolding horrors of Partition. As someone from a
neutral, non-communal background, Lenny is shielded from the violent divisions
occurring around her, making her an observer of the events. Her character
symbolizes innocence and purity, untainted by the religious and political strife
around her.
2. Shanta (played by Nandita Das): Shanta, Lenny’s Hindu nanny, is another key
protagonist. She represents love, compassion, and humanity, existing above the
communal hatred engulfing India. Shanta is kind-hearted and caring, making her
one of the most beloved characters in Lenny’s life. However, as the Partition
unravels, Shanta’s fate is tragically altered, reflecting the loss and vulnerability
faced by millions during this time.
3. Dil Nawaz (played by Aamir Khan): Initially, Dil Nawaz, a Muslim ice-candy
vendor, appears to be a kind-hearted, romantic figure who harbors affection for
Shanta. As a friend to both Hindus and Muslims, he initially stands as a symbol
of hope, transcending communal boundaries. However, as the violence
escalates and Dil Nawaz loses his sisters in the communal riots, he transforms
into a more complex character, struggling with grief and a desire for revenge.

Antagonists

4. Communal Violence: The true antagonist in Earth is not a singular person but
the pervasive communal hatred and violence that consumes people. The
Partition of India led to mass displacement, killings, and brutality based on
religious identities. This violence drives the characters' transformations,
corrupting even those who once sought peace and coexistence.
5. Dil Nawaz’s Transformation: While Dil Nawaz starts as a protagonist, his
descent into vengeance makes him an antagonist by the film's end. His deep-
seated pain from the loss of his sisters during the riots pushes him to betray
Shanta, leading to her tragic abduction. His transformation symbolizes how the
trauma of Partition tore apart relationships and turned love into hatred.
6. Communalism and Religious Extremism: In the broader context,
communalism serves as the antagonist, as Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs—once
friends—are driven apart by extremist ideologies. This division is illustrated
through various characters, such as the once-united group of friends who
splinter into opposing sides as tensions rise. The film shows how these external
forces of religious and political extremism manipulate individuals into
committing acts of betrayal and violence.
Impact of Partition on the Protagonists and Antagonists

Partition affects the lives of all these characters deeply:

• Lenny loses her innocence as she watches the people she loves turn on each
other. She also feels guilt for inadvertently revealing Shanta's hiding place,
which leads to Shanta’s capture.
• Shanta, the embodiment of love and kindness, becomes a victim of the
communal hatred she tried to avoid. Her tragic fate represents the countless
women who were abducted, assaulted, or killed during the Partition.
• Dil Nawaz, initially a hopeful and compassionate figure, is consumed by
bitterness and revenge. His transformation into an antagonist illustrates how
personal loss and communal violence destroyed the moral fabric of individuals.

Character Transformation in the Movie

The protagonists are transformed by the trauma and chaos of Partition. Shanta, the
loving nanny, becomes a symbol of the innocent lives destroyed by the violence. Dil
Nawaz, on the other hand, undergoes a more negative transformation, from a romantic
figure into someone driven by revenge. These character shifts highlight how Partition
not only affected physical boundaries but also the emotional and psychological
boundaries within people.

In conclusion, Earth portrays the Partition’s profound impact on its protagonists and
antagonists, demonstrating how communal violence and personal grief led to the
breakdown of human relationships and transformed individuals in devastating ways.

4o

You said:

i have to do my assignment based on the film "Earth (1998)". Solve question 2 for my
assignment

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

To answer question 2 of your assignment, based on Earth (1998), here’s how you can
analyze the protagonists and antagonists and explore how Partition affected them:
Question 2: Who are the film’s main protagonists and antagonists? How and why
do you think Partition affected the lives of these protagonists/antagonists in the
movie? How do you see them transformed in the movie?

In Earth (1998), directed by Deepa Mehta, the characters' lives are deeply shaped by the
historical and political context of Partition. The film primarily focuses on the impact of
the communal violence that took place during the division of India into two nations—
India and Pakistan—and how it altered personal relationships, communities, and
individuals.

Protagonists

7. Lenny (The Narrator)

o Character Overview: Lenny is a young Parsi girl who serves as the film’s
narrator and central protagonist. The film is told from her innocent
perspective as she witnesses the violent and tragic events of Partition
unfold. Lenny represents innocence and neutrality, as the Parsi
community remained largely unaffected by the direct religious violence.
o Impact of Partition: While Lenny is shielded from the violence, she
becomes a witness to the crumbling relationships and growing tensions
around her. She observes the growing animosity among her friends and
community. The most significant transformation in Lenny’s character is
the loss of her innocence. She is forced to confront the brutal reality of
human cruelty when she unintentionally betrays Shanta’s hiding place,
leading to her abduction. This event leaves her scarred, as she realizes
the irreversible damage caused by her actions and the violence around
her.
8. Shanta (Played by Nandita Das)
o Character Overview: Shanta is Lenny’s Hindu nanny, and she is depicted
as kind, gentle, and beautiful. She forms the emotional core of the story
and is loved by the men around her, regardless of their religious
affiliations. Shanta symbolizes peace and humanity, and her nurturing
presence provides a sense of security to Lenny.
o Impact of Partition: As a Hindu woman in a divided society, Shanta is
vulnerable to the growing communal hatred. Though she tries to remain
neutral and above the religious conflict, Partition changes everything.
Shanta’s life is irreversibly affected when she is abducted by Muslim
men, including Dil Nawaz, who betrays her out of vengeance. This marks
her transformation from a symbol of love and purity to a victim of violence
and communal hatred. Shanta’s fate reflects the countless women who
were abducted, raped, or killed during Partition. Her abduction
 symbolizes the deep, personal toll that the political division took on
individuals.

Antagonists

9. Dil Nawaz (Played by Aamir Khan)

o Character Overview: Dil Nawaz is initially portrayed as a hopeful,
romantic figure, often referred to as the "Ice Candy Man." He is in love
with Shanta and is friends with both Hindus and Muslims. However, as
the communal violence escalates, he becomes a much darker figure.
o Impact of Partition: The loss of his sisters during the riots profoundly
affects Dil Nawaz, transforming him from a peace-seeking individual into
someone consumed by anger and a desire for revenge. His grief turns into
a deep hatred for Hindus, leading him to betray Shanta despite his love
for her. This transformation highlights the psychological and emotional
trauma that Partition inflicted on people, turning friends into enemies. Dil
Nawaz’s character is symbolic of how the events of Partition corrupted
even those who once valued human relationships over religious identity.
10. Communalism and Religious Violence
o Character Overview: While no singular person can be identified as the
overarching antagonist, communal hatred and religious extremism serve
as the true antagonists in the film. The religious divisions between
Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs, fueled by political forces and violent riots,
tear apart communities and friendships.
o Impact of Partition: The real enemy in Earth is the communal violence
that corrupts every character's sense of humanity. This is most evident in
the transformation of the once peaceful and united community into one
fractured by distrust and betrayal. Religious identities become the
defining factor in people’s actions, and the bonds between characters
are broken by the weight of history. The escalation of violence and
division forces individuals to make brutal choices, often leading them to
commit atrocities against those they once loved or respected.

Character Transformations in the Film

The characters in Earth undergo profound transformations as a direct result of Partition:

• Lenny shifts from an innocent, sheltered child to someone burdened by the

knowledge of the horrors that unfolded around her. The moment she realizes
that she unwittingly betrayed Shanta marks her loss of innocence.
 • Shanta transforms from a nurturing figure to a tragic victim. Her abduction
symbolizes the loss of humanity and compassion in the face of widespread
violence.
• Dil Nawaz transitions from a romantic and idealistic man into someone driven
by rage and vengeance. His transformation into an antagonist represents how
communal violence can destroy personal relationships and twist love into
hatred.

Conclusion

The lives of the protagonists and antagonists in Earth are deeply affected by the
Partition of India. The political and religious violence of the time destroys friendships,
love, and community bonds, transforming characters in tragic and irreversible ways.
Lenny’s innocence, Shanta’s compassion, and Dil Nawaz’s love are all shattered by the
communal hatred that erupts around them. The film shows how Partition didn’t just
divide a nation but fractured the very humanity of its people.

This answer can be adapted to your assignment, ensuring it meets the word count and
guidelines. Let me know if you need further adjustments!

4o

Messages beyond this point are only visible to you

You said:

Now answers question 3 and 4 keeping the guidelines in mind

ChatGPT said:

ChatGPT

Question 3: What are the Historical and Cultural references used in the movie? Is
history treated fairly, or twisted to suit the filmmakers’ purposes? Debate and
discuss.

In Earth (1998), Deepa Mehta weaves a narrative around the Partition of India, one of
the most traumatic events in South Asian history, where millions were displaced and
religious identities became flashpoints for violence. The film is rich with historical and
cultural references that reflect the era's complexities and divisions.
Historical References

11. Partition of India (1947):

o The film is set during the tumultuous months leading to the Partition of
India, a real historical event where British India was divided into two
independent nations, India and Pakistan. This division led to mass
migration and communal violence, especially between Hindus, Muslims,
and Sikhs.
o Mehta showcases the violent riots, the mass displacements, and the fear
that gripped people during this period. For example, a crucial scene
where the once-friendly neighborhood of Lahore disintegrates into chaos
and fear highlights the real historical events.
12. Communalism:
o The film reflects the communal divide that was exacerbated during
Partition. Relationships between Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs, once built
on trust and friendship, collapse under the weight of religious identity.
This aspect is deeply rooted in historical realities, where once-
multicultural cities like Lahore, Amritsar, and Delhi saw friends turn into
enemies.
o The dialogues between characters reflect the growing mistrust. For
instance, Dil Nawaz, who initially defends his Hindu friends, later
becomes a victim of the hatred swirling around him, echoing the
communal bitterness of the time.
13. Abductions and Violence against Women:
o A significant historical reference in the movie is the abduction and sexual
violence against women during Partition. It is estimated that over 75,000
women were abducted and raped during this time. Shanta’s abduction by
Muslim men towards the end of the film is a reflection of this horrifying
reality, showing the extent to which women were dehumanized and used
as pawns in communal conflicts.

Cultural References

14. Lahore's Cultural Fabric:

o The multicultural environment of Lahore, where the movie is set, is a
reflection of the real cultural diversity that cities like Lahore, Delhi, and
Karachi once enjoyed before Partition. Hindu, Muslim, and Sikh friends
are shown celebrating life together, despite belonging to different
religions. This cultural coexistence, seen in the early part of the movie,
starkly contrasts with the disintegration that follows.
 o The film features characters from different religious backgrounds who
share jokes, food, and cultural practices, symbolizing the syncretic
culture that existed in pre-Partition India. For example, the Parsi
community, represented by Lenny’s family, remains neutral and
somewhat insulated from the religious turmoil. Their neutrality reflects
the historical position of Parsis during the Partition.
15. Gender Dynamics and Patriarchy:
o The film references the role of women in Indian society, focusing on how
they were particularly vulnerable during times of political instability.
Shanta’s character is central in depicting this vulnerability. Despite her
initial position as a caregiver and nurturer, she is ultimately powerless in
the face of communal violence.
o The film also subtly critiques the patriarchal structures within both Hindu
and Muslim societies, showing how women’s bodies were used as a
battleground for communal vengeance.

Is History Treated Fairly?

Earth offers a largely fair portrayal of historical events, with the filmmakers aiming to
show the human side of Partition rather than focusing solely on political or military
perspectives. Deepa Mehta does not shy away from depicting the brutality and chaos
that erupted during Partition, using personal stories to reflect larger historical truths.
The emotional trauma, the violence, and the religious hatred are depicted with raw
honesty, making the film a powerful reflection of this period.

However, one could argue that certain elements are dramatized for cinematic effect.
For example, Dil Nawaz’s transformation from a peaceful man to a vengeful antagonist
is somewhat accelerated to serve the film’s dramatic arc. His betrayal of Shanta, while
realistic, could be viewed as symbolic of how personal relationships were often
sacrificed to communal hatred. Some critics may argue that such portrayals simplify
the complex motivations behind people’s actions during Partition.

Twisted for Filmmakers’ Purposes?

While the film does justice to the historical context, certain aspects may be seen as
exaggerated for emotional impact. For instance, the romantic tension between Shanta
and Dil Nawaz is used to heighten the eventual betrayal. This might not reflect historical
accuracy but serves the filmmaker’s goal of illustrating the emotional costs of Partition.
Additionally, the portrayal of the Parsi community as neutral observers could be seen
as somewhat romanticized, as even smaller communities were not entirely immune to
the effects of Partition.
In conclusion, Earth treats history fairly by focusing on the human experiences of
Partition, though some elements are dramatized to suit the filmmakers’ storytelling
purposes. The film succeeds in capturing the emotional devastation of the time while
ensuring that the historical events remain central to the narrative.

Question 4: What interesting facts or ideas does the movie bring to mind? To what
contemporary events does the film refer? What will you remember?

Earth (1998) is a film rich in emotional depth and historical reflection. It brings several
interesting facts and ideas to the forefront, many of which resonate with both past and
contemporary events.

Interesting Facts or Ideas

16. The Fragility of Human Relationships in the Face of Communalism:

o One of the most striking ideas the film presents is the fragility of human
relationships when tested by communal violence. The once-friendly
bonds between Hindus, Muslims, and Sikhs shatter under the pressure of
Partition. This idea is personified in the relationship between Dil Nawaz
and Shanta. Initially, Dil Nawaz represents a bridge between
communities, but as the violence escalates, he succumbs to hatred,
betraying Shanta. The film explores how historical and political forces can
tear apart personal relationships.
17. Women as Victims of Communal Violence:
o The abduction and violence faced by Shanta at the end of the film
underscore the particular vulnerability of women during times of conflict.
This idea resonates with how women’s bodies were politicized and used
as symbols of religious honor during Partition. It also reflects a broader
historical pattern where women are disproportionately affected by war
and communal violence, a fact that remains relevant in contemporary
conflict zones worldwide.
18. Neutrality and Privilege:
o The Parsi community in Earth, particularly Lenny’s family, enjoys a certain
privilege and detachment from the horrors unfolding around them. This
neutrality is explored in the film, showing how certain communities or
groups can remain insulated from political turmoil while others bear the
brunt of violence. This brings to mind contemporary discussions around
privilege, where certain groups remain unaffected by societal conflicts
due to their socio-economic or religious status.
Contemporary Events Referenced

19. Religious and Ethnic Violence:

o While Earth is set during the Partition of 1947, the communal violence
depicted in the film echoes many contemporary conflicts. The religious
tensions in India and Pakistan remain relevant today, with periodic
eruptions of violence between different religious communities. The rise of
religious nationalism in both countries and the persecution of minority
groups are contemporary issues that mirror the divisions shown in the
film.
20. Refugee Crises:
o The film's depiction of mass migration during Partition can be compared
to modern-day refugee crises around the world. The scenes of people
leaving their homes, often with only the clothes on their backs, resemble
images from war-torn regions like Syria, Afghanistan, and Myanmar. Earth
brings to light the universal theme of displacement and the trauma that
comes with being forced to leave one’s homeland due to political
upheaval.
21. Gender-Based Violence in Conflict Zones:
o The violence against women depicted in Earth remains a relevant issue in
contemporary conflicts. Whether in war zones like Syria, Ukraine, or
regions affected by terrorism, women continue to be victims of
abduction, rape, and assault. The film reminds us of the gendered nature
of violence in conflicts, where women are often targeted as part of larger
political and communal agendas.

What Will You Remember?

Earth leaves a lasting impression because of its raw portrayal of human suffering and
the personal costs of Partition. The scene that lingers in the mind is the one where Dil
Nawaz betrays Shanta, leading to her abduction. This betrayal encapsulates the
broader betrayal of humanity that occurred during Partition, where neighbors, friends,
and lovers turned against one another.

Another unforgettable aspect is Lenny’s transformation from an innocent child to

someone who bears witness to unspeakable horrors. Her realization that she
inadvertently caused Shanta’s abduction is a powerful reminder of how innocence can
be shattered by the actions of others.

In conclusion, Earth brings to mind the fragility of human relationships, the vulnerability
of women in conflict, and the contemporary relevance of the issues it portrays. It leaves
the viewer reflecting on the cost of communal violence and the ways in which history
continues to repeat itself.