ملف الشعر كامل كل قصائد
ملف الشعر كامل كل قصائد
ملف الشعر كامل كل قصائد
Realism and Detail: Victorian poetry frequently displayed a keen interest in the minutiae of
daily life and a detailed portrayal of reality. This attention to detail is exemplified by the works
of Robert Browning, who used dramatic monologues to delve into the psychology of his
characters.
Moral and Social Concerns: Victorian poets often expressed a strong sense of morality and
social responsibility. They grappled with the moral challenges of their time, such as the effects
of industrialization, urbanization, and social inequality.
Social Class and Morality: Victorian poetry often dealt with issues of social class and
distinctions, highlighting the contrast between different strata of society and the moral
dilemmas they faced.
The Industrial Revolution, with its far-reaching effects on society, provided poets with a wealth
of material and inspiration. These poets responded in diverse ways, expressing their hopes,
critiques, and concerns through their work. As a result, the literature of this period is rich with
reflections on the social, environmental, and emotional impact of this transformative era.
During the Victorian era, there was a significant interest in the past, particularly in the Middle
Ages, which is often referred to as a sense of "medievalism." This interest in medievalism
manifested in various aspects of Victorian culture, including literature, art, architecture, and
even politics.
Matthew Arnold
Matthew Arnold, a prominent Victorian poet and critic, had a distinctive philosophy of poetry
that he articulated in his critical writings. Arnold's views on poetry can be summarized as
follows:
The Function of Poetry: Arnold believed that the primary function of poetry was to provide
moral and intellectual guidance to society. He saw poetry as a means of elevating and
instructing the public. In his view, poetry had a significant role to play in shaping culture and
moral values.
Classical and Hellenistic Influences: Arnold was influenced by classical and Hellenistic ideas of
art and beauty. He admired Greek culture and believed that Greek literature and art
represented the highest ideals of human expression. He sought to incorporate classical
aesthetics into Victorian poetry.
Critique of Romanticism: Arnold was critical of the excesses of Romanticism, particularly its
intense subjectivity and emphasis on emotional self-expression. He believed that poetry
should strike a balance between emotion and intellect, and that it should engage with the
world's intellectual and social issues.
The "Touchstone" Method: Arnold introduced the concept of the "touchstone" in literary
criticism. He argued that critics should use a limited number of classic works as touchstones to
judge the merit of contemporary literature. This approach emphasized the enduring value of
the classics and their role in setting a standard for literary excellence.
Cultural Critique: Arnold's philosophy of poetry was closely linked to his broader cultural
critique. He expressed concerns about the moral and intellectual decline of society, especially
in the face of rapid industrialization. He believed that poetry could help address these issues
by promoting intellectual and moral growth.
Matthew Arnold's philosophy of poetry emphasized the moral and intellectual function of
poetry in shaping and elevating society. He advocated for poetry that incorporated classical
ideals, engaged with social issues, and was subject to rigorous and objective critical
evaluation. Arnold's views played a significant role in shaping the direction of Victorian poetry
and literary criticism.
What is the difference between the definition of poetry according to
Wordsworth, Matthew Arnold, and TS Eliot?
William Wordsworth: Wordsworth was a prominent figure in the Romantic movement, and his
definition of poetry is closely tied to Romantic ideals. He believed that poetry should be a
spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings and emotions. His famous concept of "emotion
recollected in tranquility" emphasizes the role of memory and reflection in poetic creation.
Wordsworth saw poetry as a means of capturing the ordinary and the everyday, making it
extraordinary through the power of imagination. In essence, he valued the emotional and
imaginative aspects of poetry, emphasizing the relationship between the poet and nature.
Matthew Arnold: Matthew Arnold, a Victorian poet and critic, had a more intellectual and
critical approach to poetry. He saw poetry as a form of criticism of life and believed that its
primary function was to provide moral and intellectual guidance. Arnold's concept of "the best
that has been thought and said" reflects his belief in the high cultural and intellectual standards
that poetry should uphold. He advocated for poetry's role in addressing the moral and social
concerns of his time, promoting culture and education as a means of achieving a more
enlightened society.
T.S. Eliot: T.S. Eliot, a modernist poet and critic, had a highly complex and multifaceted view of
poetry. He emphasized the importance of tradition and the need for poets to engage with the
literary past. Eliot's "Tradition and the Individual Talent" essay highlights his belief in the poet's
place within a broader literary tradition. He also introduced the concept of the "objective
correlative," which stressed the importance of using concrete and specific imagery to convey
emotions and experiences. Eliot's poetry often explores spiritual and existential themes,
reflecting his personal journey toward religious faith.
In summary, Wordsworth valued the emotional and imaginative aspects of poetry, Arnold
emphasized poetry's role as a critic of life and society, and Eliot stressed the importance of
tradition, the use of objective correlative, and the intellectual and spiritual dimensions of
poetry. Each poet's definition of poetry reflects the values and concerns of their respective
literary movements and historical contexts.
من هنا تبدء المحاضرات اليومية
The Victorian age: is an era of realism
The Victorian era, the era of novels such as the writer Richard Dickens, "Hard Times"
Also Victorian Poets of the Realist Movement such as :
The Industrial Revolution that affected on society and how society suffered from that
revolution, how hard the workers "the hands" were living and suffering.
And How nature was suffering from the dust and factory pollution
The philosophy of society at that time was materialist philosophy and the conflict between
classes, as the higher class was controlling the lower class and make them struggling (from hand
to mouth) and according to "Marxist theory" it should be Equality between classes.
The conflict also appeared between religion and science, as several scientific theories appeared
at that time, such as Darwin’s book The Origin of Species, and how the ideas that were in the
book were against religion.
Also, many people at that time tried to apply scientific theories to religious texts, so there was
a reaction from the clergy. This showed a conflict between science and religion, as many people
began to doubt the existence of the Creator. So the Oxford movement is a religious movement
appeared in the Victorian era by Cardinal Newman.
They believed that too much materialism and too much industrialism would lead to the
decline of society and lead to a move away from faith, so they said we must not lose our faith
and not doubt of Creator "GOD".
This was reflected in the poetry of the Victorian era, where many poets called for holding on
faith and adherence to faith.
The other topic is women
In the Victorian era, there were the first steps of feminism. There were women who wrote
literary works, such as Emily Brontë, but she published her works under an unknown nickname
because society at that time did not accept literary works by women. In the Victorian era, there
was a spotlight on the suffering of women, as they were voiceless or with a weak voice, and
woman was not free and ruled by the man (her father, brother, or husband). woman was always
as if she were something under the authority of a man, as if she was slave in the (Patriarchal
society)
Also, the poets of the Victorian era were interested in the same thing as the poets of the
Romantic era, which is interest in the past (interest in the Middle Ages). However, the poets of
the Romantic era were interested in aspects of beauty, such as the beauty of nature or the
beauty of women, while the poets of the Victorian era were interested in reviving something
that had been lost in the Victorian era, such as land scape of nature missed because industrial
revolution and others things missed like " Loss of faith " , chivalry , courage, and Respect
women. It was used to compare with what was missing in the Victorian era as a form of criticism
of society, that society had become worthless and decayed.
Nature in the Romantic era was different from the vision of romanticism in the Victorian age
The Romantics saw the beauty of nature as idealized (nature worship) and women as angels
While the Victorians viewed nature as something that had become lost in civilization, where
there was smoke , dust and the effects of pollution and the industrial revolution, women were
viewed as an oppressed being, without a voice, and as a slave under the authority of men.
Therefore, the Victorians used views of nature and women as elements that had become lost
to them, and as a form of criticism of society and the philosophy of the era in That Time (A
Critique of the Materialist Philosophy of the Age) Where people were victims of their time.
Victorin is divided into two parts The first section is the beginning of the Victorian era, poets by
Raphael, who appeared in the aesthetic movement Where they write for beauty over meaning,
such as the poem Blessed Damozel by Dante Gabriel Rossetti The purpose of writing poems
was the doctrine of aesthetics, art for art's sake The second section is the end of the Victorian
era, such as Tennyson and Matthew Arnold, where their school of poetry followed the
(Didactics) approach, which is that a literary work must carry a message or a moral lesson. They
wrote poetry in order to criticize life, criticize society, and for highlighting on society’s problems
as a kind of reform of society. Also, one of the things that society was suffering from was the
distinction between social classes (Marxism), where the owners of the money, the upper class,
were the ones controlling the fate of the lower class, the workers who did not have enough for
their daily sustenance, and the suffering of that lower class (the workers). Their names are
Charles Dickens (The Hands), and there is a quote. From his book Hard Times as a description of
their economic situation (from hand to mouth). The wages they receive from those with money
are only enough for food.
Victorian era writers were interested in realistic social issues and society problems.
“No poet, no artist for any art has his complete meaning alone”
• Past and present influence each other like a flowing river
• Literature has a unity, all influence each other, The old is influenced by the new, and the
new is influenced by the old.
• There is a function for death poets “historical Awareness”
• The past is not isolated from the present, but is modified by new literary works.
• It is impossible to evaluate any poet or writer without referring to the great figures of
ancient literature
“Novelty is better than repetition”
- Ancient literature is a Tradition influences it, the New poets, writers are influenced by it,
Ancient literature also for evaluation and judgment Not for a repetition of their themes
and topics. It is not a reformulation, but a school and an approach that they must follow.
- The writer must be creative by relying on the basis that is ancient literary works.
- The ancient writers “ the famous Poets” are not dead, but alive in their knowledge and
should be emulated.
The idea of Timelessness of literature, for all times.
3. The poem "the love song of Alfred Prufrock" by T.S. Eliot
This poem is considered one of the first poems of the modernist era in terms of style,
language, and ideas. For example, it represents the image of the modern man who must take
care of his appearance and clothing. this poem also contains an application of the philosophy of
poetry that he presented in his article (Traditions and Individual Talents), its connection
between literary works in the past through several revelations in the poem. For example, Eliot
begins his poem with verses from Dante's work (The Divine Comedy) in the third part "Inferno",
the verses in which Dante meets another character, Gedo. The poet compares the character of
Prufrock to the character of Gedo, but Gedo was literally in hell, while Prufrock is in another
hell, since the idea of hell in the past is different from the idea of hell in modernity, Prufrock is
not in a literal hell like Gedo, but rather his life and his condition make him live in a miserable
life like a hell it is a sense of hell not literal.
Also the connection in both cases we have women, in the Divine Comedy the woman's
function was to purify Gedo from sins to move him from hell into heaven. On the other hand,
the woman here is different from the woman in Victorian poetry. The woman in Eliot's poem is
different, as it shows the image of the superficial modern woman who only cares about
appearances and superficiality, but inside she is empty.
” in the room the women come and go/Talking of Michelangelo"
Here is a different view of women, not like the past, as Eliot used this allusion to explain that
women in the modern era have begun to pretend to be educated and talk about
Michelangelo, but they are superficial and empty on the inside. It is kind of irony upon modern
woman.
………. ……….. ………..
The style used in this poem is stream of consciousness, where the poet narrates the story as it
is without organization, and without order, not like a dramatic monologue. We see the
character of Prufrock moving from one place to another directly and suddenly, from the street
to the hotel and then to the bar, and he moves directly to several places. Direct narration
(stream of consciousness).
…………….
The description became not of a natural landscape, but rather of a cityscape, filled with illness,
stress and unhappiness
"when the evening is spared out against the sky/ like a patient etherized upon a table"
A modernist description of a cityscape rather than a landscape, where the evening is like a
helpless, drugged, sick person.
……….
The term "flâneur" originated in 19th-century France and is often associated with the writings
of Charles Baudelaire and later developed by various thinkers, including Walter Benjamin. The
flâneur is a figure of urban observation and leisurely wandering, particularly associated with
city life.
This is a French literary phrase used to refer to a person who walks around and describes the
places he wanders in. Eliot presents the character of Prufrock, who was walking around the city
and describing places such as the streets and the cheap hotel, and provides an accurate
description even of the cat scratching her back on the window.
…………….
Absurdity
In many verses in the poem, the poet repeats the concept of time (repetition of time).
"And indeed there will be time/for the yellow smoke"
"there will be time to murder and create,
And time for all the works and days of hands"
"Time for you and time for me
And time yet for hundred indecisions"
"And indeed there will be time/for wonder, Do I dare? Do I dare?"
The poet presents the idea of routine and absurdity, the absurdity of repeating time without
purpose, And the idea of endless pain, and the idea that life is meaningless. It is one of the
characteristics of the philosophy of the modern era (Absurdism).
" I have measured out my life with coffee spoons"
Comparing his life with a coffee spoon, where the poet depicts life as trivial and meaningless,
without benefit such as the triviality of using a coffee spoon. It is a worthless thing like life. It
is another image of the absurdity of life.
The allusions
The poet T. S. Eliot mentioned several characters in the poem as an allusion to reflect the
triviality of Prufrock's life and insignificants by comparison between allusion characters with
prufrock character.
The first allusion is the use of a stanza from the Divine Comedy, one of Dante's works, where
the poet Eliot used the character of Gedo in order to compare the "literal hell" that Gedo was
in and the idea of the hell that Prufrock was living in (sense of hell). It is not a literal hell like
Gedo's hell, but rather the feeling of hell.
"though I have seen my head (grown slightly bald) brought in upon a platter"
The allusion to the character of john the Baptist from the Bible, who was brave and challenged
the king and said to him, “You are not just, so he was killed by the king.” Here the poet compared
the cowardly character of Prufrock to the character of the brave Yahiya the Baptist, who was
not afraid of the king.
"And I have seen the eternal Footman hold my coat, and snicker,
And in short, I was afraid"
An allusion of the character of Jesus Christ (Lord Servant), who, despite the simplicity of his life,
is an important person for many people, but Prufrock is afraid and useless.
"To say: I am Lazarus, come from the death
Comeback to tell you all, I shall tell you all"
Another allusion of the character of "Lazarus" from the Bible, he died for three or four days, and
his wife came to Christ and begged him to bring him back to life, so Christ brought him back to
life and said what he saw after death. Here the poet links the character of Lazard with the
character of Prufrock, who walks like a dead man who has already lost himself and has nothing
to lose.
"No! I am not prince Hamlet, nor was meant to be"
Here is another reference (allusion) to the character of Prince Hamlet from the play by
Shakespeare, where Hamlet was hesitant like Prufrock, and despite Hamlet's great hesitation in
making the decision to take revenge on his uncle, in the end, he did something "killed his uncle",
he achieve something, but Prufrock compared to Hamlet, remained hesitant and more than
Hamlet as Prufrock did not do anything until the end he did not do it.
Dandy character
"My morning coat, my collar mounting firmly to the chin,
My necktie rich and modest, but asserted by simple pin-
They will say: "But how his arms and legs are thin!")"
In these verses above, the poet intends to criticize the modern man (Irony) about the modern
man who has begun to care only about his appearance and clothes without paying attention to
the true value inside the human, as from inside he is just an empty person (Dandy person).
A writer who is against women in his literary works is often described as misogynistic. Misogyny
refers to a strong dislike, contempt, or prejudice against women. If a writer consistently portrays
women in a negative light or harmful attitudes towards women through their writing, they may
be labeled as misogynistic.
” in the room the women come and go/Talking of Michelangelo"
Eliot used this allusion to explain that women in the modern era have begun to pretend to be
educated and talk about Michelangelo, but they are superficial and empty from inside. It is
kind of irony upon modern woman. So he considered against women "misogynistic".
It is the Irish sense, as the poet used Irish words or "O sages standing in God's holy fire"
phrases in his poems in order to introduce them " Come from the holy fire, perne in a gyre,
into English literature. It is (mythology) in order to And be the singing-masters of my soul."
say we are here, we are as Irish people, we are also in this poem we see kind of perspective of
here. It is a kind of peaceful cultural style as a Sufism, The Holy fire that purifies the soul from the
response to the British occupation of Ireland, so the material world, as the poet separates from the
poet used Literature as a means of affirming Irish material world and becomes a practitioner of
identity and he rejected the method of war and spiritual actions (Spiritual Art) as a type of a healing
blood. power for the soul in order to achieve immortality.
Through artistic teachings, as the Byzantine city
represents spiritual art, so here we find the Sufi
touch.
And fastened to a dying animal
And fastened to a dying animal
Here the poet describes the body as a
It knows not what it is; and gather me
“dead animal.” It is a metaphor of the
Into the artifice eternity.
body and materialism that at the end will
finish and are not immortal.
and gather me
Into the artifice eternity.
unlike that physical action unlike the dying
generation "dying animal", there is the old man
who seeking about spiritual Art as "artifice" it is
positive "spiritual art" and not something negative
it is not a materialistic art but it is the spiritual art
by (singing master) where he could obtain
immortality by making immortal spiritual Art.
…………….
My bodily form from any natural thing, "Of hammered gold and gold enameling"
But such a form as Grecian goldsmiths make
Of hammered gold and gold enameling "To lords and ladies of Byzantium
……………….. Of what is past, or passing, or to come."
To lords and ladies of Byzantium
Of what is past, or passing, or to come. It is a form of immortality, where the poet looks to
a promising future with the hope of obtaining
immortality by practicing spiritual artistic work
that will remain immortal.
Therefore, the poet made his journey to the
Byzantine city. It is a journey to search for
immortal spiritual art. It is a journey to search for
immortality. The poet left the superficial material
world that does not follow immortal artistic values
and went to a city that respects spiritual artistic
values (the transition from the material world to
the spiritual world).
"Richard Cory" first appeared in the American poet Edwin Arlington Robinson's 1897 collection, The Children of
the Night. In four brisk stanzas, "Richard Cory" tells the story of a wealthy man who often strolls the streets of a
poverty-stricken town whose residents all envy his seeming glory. Yet the poem's final line reveals that, despite
seeming to have everything he could want, Cory kills himself. The poem's thematic interests in wealth, poverty,
and the elusive nature of happiness are deeply tied to its historical context: a series of economic depressions
that struck the U. S. in the 1890s.
The poet Robinson was interested in ancient traditions, interested in the Middle Ages "Medievalism", and also
interested in ancient myths and the past poetic form. We see this clearly in his poetry collection (Captain Craig).
The poet introduced the past form into modern poetry by adding a modern style and modern themes, in the
form as if it were a sonnet form "Old poetry", but with modern topics and modern language and style.
Why did the poet use that form? Why he was interested in past form and medieval traditions?
Because the poet believed that the past represented the era of success and heroism, but now, in the era of
modernity, that era of success has ended, the American dream has been corrupted, and the era has become the
era of failed people, it is the age of materialism and superficiality. Therefore, in many times, the poet invokes in
his poems the character of a failed man, such as the character of the "Prince of Failure", and the character of
(( Richard Cory)) is one of those characters represented by the poet. Or, for example, he represents a fictional
city like the (Tilbury Town), in which there are people who are not heroes but rather failures people.
The poet believed that getting success should be through the experience of failure, like a person who enters a
dark tunnel and walks in the darkness, but at the end of the tunnel sees the light (success). He meant that a
person must obtain success by gaining experience and benefiting from the sins and mistakes that he committed
previously, in short. (Success through failure).
It was a kind of criticism of the modern era, in which the American dream ended and was corrupted, and the era
of (Footman) ended, and now the era has become the era of materialism and superficiality.
By the way, Robinson was the first who introduced psychological philosophy into American literature, specifically
into poetry, even before Freud's theory.
"Whenever Richard Cory went down Town"
In the first verses, the poet represents the character of (Richard Cory) and described him as a rich
man with an elegant appearance and social status, a person who owns everything, from the
outside as if he were as a prototype.
because of his appearance, people thought "Cory" had everything and they wished they could be like
him. But in the end they discovered that he was a failure, and his reality that he was empty from inside,
at the end he killed himself (suicide) .Here the poet refers to the corruption of the American dream and
the decay of society, as they thought that the American dream, which was (every person, regardless
of his race and social class, can work and achieve a decent life, prosperity, development,
progress, humanity, and helping others) all of these dreams has ended and has become
corrupted because of the times it has become the era of materialism and people became
concerned with only getting money and Superficiality, so society lost values and lost humanity.
The poet emphasizes that the society must have spiritual values far from materialism in order to achieve
the American dream.
The poet brings up the character of Corey as an example and model of the American people at that time,
who were only interested in money and material things, but he had something essential missing, which
was true and spiritual values. Therefore, he was a failure and a superficial person, representing the
decadence of society at that time.
"Cory" killed himself in the tragic end "suicide", indicating the psychological philosophy
in Robinson's poetry, where he was the first who introduced psychological philosophy into American
literature, specifically into poetry, even before Freud's theory. The suicide of Richard Cory serves as a powerful
commentary on the limitations of judging a person's happiness or well-being based solely on external factors. It
reminds us that appearances can be deceiving, and individuals may be grappling with personal challenges that
are hidden from the public eye.
I myself am hell;
nobody's here-
……………………..
A mother of skunk with her column of kittens swills the garbage pail
it is a reference from the poem The Dark Night: Stanzas Of The Soul By Saint. John Of The
Cross:
O guiding night!
O night more lovely than the dawn!
O night that has united
the Lover with his beloved,
transforming the beloved in her Lover.
In addition, it represents the obscene seen, sexuality, the night of post-modern time.
the poet meant he also was losing his sanity just like those people that I'm rated them each
one of them they lost certain acts certain aspects I myself lost my sanity including myself
when I watched such obscene seen wouldn't be acceptable.
And the line “my mind’s not right” considers as a typical example of confessional poetry, it's a
clear confession.
……………………..
A car radio bleats,
“Love, O careless Love. . . .” I hear
my ill-spirit sob in each blood cell,
as if my hand were at its throat. . . .
I myself am hell;
nobody’s here—
“Love, O careless Love", is a reference to “A popular blues song” of that time written by W.C.
Handy and performed by Bessie Smith (1925), in which the narrator threatens to kill his or her
wayward lover. The song was performed with slight variations of lyrics by many musicians
before Lowell wrote this poem in 1959.
the poet meant that every blood cell in his body was suffering, weeping, it is image full
description of his illness and depression.
"I myself am hell" is a reference to an echo of Satan speaking in John Milton's Paradise Lost:
“Which way I fly is Hell; myself am Hell” (Book 4, line 75)
The poet described his feeling, he meant I am loneliness, "I am alone" in the illness like a hell.
only skunks, that search
in the moonlight for a bite to eat.
They march on their soles up Main Street:
white stripes, moonstruck eyes’ red fire
under the chalk-dry and spar spire
of the Trinitarian Church.
I stand on top
of our back steps and breathe the rich air—
a mother skunk with her column of kittens swills the garbage pail
She jabs her wedge-head in a cup
of sour cream, drops her ostrich tail,
and will not scare.
Now move on to another character, the animal character the poet Speaking of “night time” under the
moonlight (dark hour), it also reflects depression. He sees the moonlight reflecting on the skunk's eyes,
reflecting the color red (violence).
It is the sense of action, there is effort in that animal and there is eagerness, while the poet himself
lacks that action and lacks that enthusiasm, and lost his passion, and he is learning the lesson from the
mother skunk. When animals cross the street and go to church, it is a sense of hope that a reference
to the people go to the church to confess as (Spiritual purification) because committing sins. The
image of hope is reflected in the skunk, which gave the poet a lesson in the sense of action and taking
care of her children unlike the poet himself. the mother of skunk that was under the church gives us a
human lesson that she was taking care of her children and was not afraid of anything in order to provide
food for her children.
In summary, this poem is a confession by the poet of the state of depression that he lives in, in
addition to a criticism of the lives of post-modern people, as he provided a description of the
way people live in the city in the time of modernity, where women care about their beauty, men
care about money, and people practice sexual immorality in the streets in the cars, and many
lost their humanity and became worse than animals. And The smelly animal, the skunk, is better
than a human as people began losing their humanity and we should take a lesson from that
animal. The animal became more humanity than human.
All of that images in the post-modern age are rejected by the poet, as the modern way of life
makes him feel more and more depressed Because he is sensitive and touchy, all of these things
makes him feel psychologically disturbed and lives in mental illness.
Colonel Shaw
is riding on his bubble, 16
he waits
for the blessèd break.
A paperweight,
My face a featureless, fine 3
Jew linen.
As a seashell.
They had to call and call 14
And pick the worms off me like sticky pearls.
Dying
Is an art, like everything else.
I do it exceptionally well. 15
‘A miracle!’
That knocks me out. 19
There is a charge
I am your opus,
I am your valuable,
The pure gold baby 23 not included
Ash, ash—
You poke and stir.
Flesh, bone, there is nothing there—— 25
A cake of soap,
A wedding ring, 26
A gold filling.
The yew tree points up. It has a Gothic shape. Horror image (Gothic)
The eyes lift after it and find the moon.
The moon is my mother. She is not sweet like Mary. Negative image for the moon
Her blue garments unloose small bats and owls.
How I would like to believe in tenderness –
The face of the effigy, gentled by candles,
Bending, on me in particular, its mild eyes.
The poet Sylvia Plath criticized her family and attacked them, as she depicted the moon
in a negative way, with a strange shape and a blue color full of Gothic and darkness, as a
symbol of her mother, or the (Virgin Mary) The poet gave her the image of wearing blue
clothes (an image of sadness), while the Virgin Mary usually wore white cloths, but Plath
depict virgin Mary in negative way. In addition, she depicted the black Yew tree, which is
usually found in graves, as a symbol of her father. This reflects the suffering inside her mind,
as she was suffering from a psychological illness and reflects her hatred for her family and
her attacks on them. The poet depicted the (Yew tree) as having a scary shape, and that this
tree is usually found in the church or grave, so it symbolizes death and sadness. In addition,
she depicted the moon with a strange shape and a blue color, while usually the moon is
bright and beautiful, but that beauty does not work with Plath, as everything that Plath
sees in her eyes that is blue or black represents a terrifying image (Gothic) represents
sadness and death. Another image of Gothic is the image of fog (mists) that Plath presented
as imagined that she sees the fog as having the shape of a strange body and a frightening
shape. (Gothic) is something related to the poet’s mind and reflects her psychological illness
and suffering. The poet also depicted the church bell, which usually gives the image of a
sense of rebirth, a sense of safeness, and a sense of religion, but this bell does not work with
Plath, as if she was someone who missed the train, the time was done for her, and no one
around her can save her, and nothing around her can make her feel happy. Even the church
and the clergy were criticized by Plath for being silent, watching her suffering and her pain
without doing anything, without offering any help for her, and looking at her suffering with
enjoyment.
In Breughel's Icarus, for instance: how everything turns away "the Fall of Icarus"
Quite leisurely from the disaster; the ploughman may
Have heard the splash, the forsaken cry,
But for him it was not an important failure; the sun shone
As it had to on the white legs disappearing into the green
Water, and the expensive delicate ship that must have seen
Something amazing, a boy falling out of the sky, No reaction , No body care
Had somewhere to get to and sailed calmly on.
The general idea about the poem, its belong to Ekphrastic poetry:
The general idea of the poem is individual suffering and the lack of interest for others suffering.
When you suffer, you will suffer alone and no one will notice that and no one will care about that
suffering. Even the poet himself, when others suffer, does not care about their suffering. The
poem focuses on personal suffering and the lack of concern of others individual suffering and
individual pain. When a person is exposed to a certain disaster, other people continue with their
daily routine as if nothing had happened.
The poem contains a reference to three paintings to depict individual suffering and the
indifference of others, the sense of indifference.
The general idea of the three paintings is that they are from different eras, but they present the same
idea from ancient times until later eras (individual suffering) and the lack of concern for others. Since
the myth of Icarus and even before the birth of Christ, and even after the birth of Christ, individual
suffering and the lack of concern for others continue.
If you are in the past, or in modern times, you will see the same sense of indifference.
The second section, the poet continues the physical description of the church and the things
inside the church, as he describes the place in which in the church mothers wash children after
birth (baptizing children), and describes the platform in the church, and gives the physical
details of the church without metaphysical aspect.
The last two lines of the second section, we must memorize them. Here is a clear mockery of
the church and a clear insult to the church, as the poet criticizes the church and that he paid a
small amount of money to enter and watching the church as a kind of insult and
underestimation of the value of the church, as the poet considers that the church represents
a material aspect without spiritual value. It is a criticism of the system of Religious men and
reflects the extent of the poet’s skepticism about religion, as the poet was secular and some
critics said that he was an atheist.
The third section, the poet points out that it is not the first time that he enters the church and
sees it with this physical appearance and sees it empty of people, and he always reaches the
same conclusion and feels the same material feeling towards the church and that it has no real
spiritual value and that this place (the church) is not worthy to standing inside it as it does not
deserve to visit it or to be In it, the poet points out that there is no benefit from the church and
wonders about the purpose of the church’s existence and what its future will be like. Will it be
in the future like a historical place full of historical tools or just like a museum that we will visit
it only for watching not for worshiping.
The poet continues to describe the material things in the church (mockery and insult to the
church) and as a place that represents bad luck (unlucky places). In the lines of the poem, the
poet wonders about the future of the church. Will it be just a place for rent? This description
reflects the materialistic nature of the modern era and its distance from spirituality.
The fourth section, the poet describes after the disappearance of religion (after darkness) we
will expect that it will continue to be just a social traditional place where women come with
their children to take a blessing from a certain stone in the church for the purpose of Baptizing
a child, this is indicating that there remains something psychological inside the person, make
him belong to that kind of holy places, in addition, meaning that he becomes a place only for
traditional social practices. The poet points out that one day that faith and superstition will
disappear, end, and die, and it will be a place abandoned, neglected, abandoned, surrounded
by weeds, without importance and without spirituality.
The fifth section, the poet continues to describe the church as an old, abandoned place, and
day by day it becomes more and more old and destroyed. The poet wonders about who will
continue to visit this abandoned place (the church) and he gives reviews about the people who
worked in the church and usually practiced religious rituals, such as the people who used to
beat the drum during Prayer, people interested in historical things and antiques, people
interested in Christmas and birthday gifts, or someone like me (the poet) who is not interested
in this place, like me who is not interested in the spiritual value of church , all of these
questions and reviews represent the lack of importance of the church to the poet.
The sixth section, the poet describes people’s feelings about the sanctity of this place and how
desperate people come looking for psychological help and people who come from a far place
for the purpose of finding a sense of spirituality, such as birth ceremonies, children’s baptisms,
marriage ceremonies, or even burial ceremonies after death, all of which take place in the
church, and these may be the reasons that The church was built for these matters. The poet
depicts the church as being like a (special shell) that may contain something valuable. Here,
there is a change and a turning point in the poet’s opinion towards the church, as he refers to
the feeling of sanctity, psychological comfort, and sanctity when he is in this place (the church),
indicating that our attachment to those places is a psychological attachment. Where he
describes that place perhaps deserving a such respect, and he is silent in the presence of that
courtyard (the church), where there is a change in the poet’s opinion towards the church and a
contradiction. The last two lines of this section, he described the church as a barn (as a kind of
insult to the church), but also might be a place worthy of respect and benefit, as this was a
shift in the poet’s opinion. (barn in worth)
The seventh section, we must be memorized these lines completely. This also represents the
turning point in the poet’s opinion, as the poet continues with that turning point in his opinion
by describing the church as a place that has its sanctity and respect, and described it as the place
that make us feel comfortable and feel spiritual , and make our souls linked to our destinies, as
it connects us to destiny (to the God), as the human being, may be religious by nature, and his
feeling of sanctity towards this possibility may be something innate as human nature, and this
belief cannot be ignored, as every person by his nature has a feeling of searching for God and
seeks spirituality, as there is a stimulus within the person that pushes him to that feeling, as
the poet here refers to the importance of the church. Its value to people's lives from a holy
standpoint and from a traditional social side. Since this stanza contradicts the whole idea of the
poem and the poet’s shift in his belief and his opinion toward the importance of the church and
religion, this contradiction may give the impression that the poet was a skeptic and Agnostic, or
secular. Some critics said that he was a secularist and others said that he was an atheist. There
is an opinion that because the church previously disrespected (bad treatment) with his family,
so the poet no longer loved the church and dislike it as a reaction.
At the beginning of the poem, the poet prides about his origins and glorifies his
African origins, as the poet is American from African origins (a black African). He
did not see Africa, which he considered it his roots and the country of his ancestors.
Black African Americans represented a minority in USA, so they created their own
movement in art and literature to represent their culture and proof their cultural
identity.
This type of art and literature contains negative and positive aspects at the same
time and is a mixture between the two cultures, the culture of the African roots
and the culture of the new homeland "America" so they are in the middle in
(Betweeness).
Therefore, at the beginning of the poem, we clearly see a tone of boasting and
glorifying his African origins, as the poet describes Africa as a beautiful, charming,
land and wonderful country and celebrates it as if it were the Heaven of Eden, as a
kind of proof of cultural identity, but at the end of the poem this tone differs by
indicating that they integrated and mixed with the culture of the dominant
American society and fused with the new society with new culture (Hybrid).
"So I lie who all day long"
Therefore, we see the poet’s contradiction in the poem. At one times he relies on
his heavy heritage and cultural identity, and at other times he says that he is lying
to himself, as he now lives in America and integrates and mixed with them and will
be like them (turning point, switch point), as the poet refers to the transformation
of their nationalism into American nationalism, and also to the transformation of
their religion into Christianity.
The poet depicts their Case, the Case of black Africans, like the Case of Jesus Christ,
as they suffered, oppressed, and were killed just like the suffering and oppression
of Jesus Christ.
Therefore, the poet depicted that Christ should be black man like them not white
because he lived the same suffering as they lived and was tortured as they were
tortured and killed as they were killed.
from the psychological side, the poet has internal conflict, internal contradiction
and suffering as he suffers from a clash of cultures (the culture of African roots and
ancestors) with the dominant American culture, the Minorities with Majorities.
This has led to a psychological conflict within him.
In the second stanza, the poet describes Africa, which he has not visited and
imagines it as something that lives with him and feels inside him, things that haunt
him and the sound that he tries to deny, but it remains stuck inside him and control
his feelings because it represents his origins, roots, and cultural identity.
"So I lie, who always hear"
He does not want to hear those voices that haunt him, and he closes his ears in
order to avoid hearing that voices. He does not want to hear the injustice upon
black people, the sound of their suffering, and how they were subjected to torture,
racism, and slavery.
We see the poet's contradiction and how he is in (Betweeness) a contradiction that
the poet lives within himself, as he is stuck between his African origins and being
an American citizen, so it is the suffering of belonging. They are afflicted with the
curse of blackness.
"with the dark blood dammed within" = the curse of blackness "black blood" the
African root and identity.
"Dear distress, and joy allied" = in Betweeness
"where they surge and foam and fret" = paradoxical image, suffering.
We find this paradoxical image in the literature of minorities as they lived with the
dominant majority society "American", as the minorities try to prove their cultural
identity, and on the other hand, show the tone of suffering and internal conflict
and their suffering from slavery and racism, which will finally lead them to
integration and mixed with American society, where the poet indicates that he will
become an American citizen like them and his culture melts with their culture, so
that they can coexist and live together in society, even they abandon their religion
and change their religion into the Christian religion, and this turning point is in
order for them to be accepted by American society this is the idea of (noble Savage)
where he feels that he is less than them and feels inferior because his African
origins, so they merge with the culture Americans in order to feel that they are
equal to them with nationalism. It is an example of an identity conflict.
The poet invoked images of animals in the poem, as animals reflect African culture,
and the land of Africa is famous with a lot of animals and is characterized by the
diversity of animals, as this is considered their cultural heritage. The poet depicts
those sounds (animal sounds) as he hears them inside himself and he is in pain and
in an internal conflict because now he is in a contradiction (betweeness). Now he is
becoming more and more transformed day after day into American culture, the idea
of (Third space) and the idea of (hybridity).
"Doff the lovely coats you wear" = Third space and Hybridity
"Doff this new exuberance" = Third space and Hybridity
It is representing the idea of the “hybridity” as the poet gradually sheds his skin,
abandons his origin, and becomes turning into a new culture like the American
people (Noble Savage) to acceptable and living between them.
So I lie, who find no peace
Night or day, no slight release
From the unremittant beat
Made by cruel padded feet
Walking through my body’s street.
Here the poet brings up the internal conflict within himself, inside the Black African-
American and their feeling that they are slaves and suffering from racism. The poet
explains how his roots and his ancestors became slaves in America, where they
came to the land of America to as workers in agriculture and factories, but they
were tied up and they were treated as slaves and they suffered from racial racism,
slavery, and class and ethnic differences. The poet clarify That he wants to release
his feelings because they were suffering from injustice and inequality.
So I lie, who never quite
Safely sleep from rain at night—
I can never rest at all
When the rain begins to fall;
Like a soul gone mad with pain
It is a Metaphor, represents the condition of the black Africa people in America and
how they are living in (Betweeness) and suffer from the internal conflict inside
them. It shows the idea of (the hybridity) of the Minority culture that has immersed
itself and melted in the Dominant culture the Majority and has become something
hybridity.
Quaint, outlandish heathen gods
Black men fashion out of rods,
The poet depicts themselves (The African) as strangers in this society the new
society(USA) , he is a stranger in American land (The Suffering of Belongings).
My conversion came high-priced;
I belong to Jesus Christ,
Preacher of humility;
Heathen gods are naught to me.
This is representing an example the idea of (the Noble Savage), a turning point in
their culture and even a shift in their religion, where they changed to Christianity
in order to be accepted and integrate with American society and become American
citizens, as the poet refers to them abandoning the worship of Paganism that his
ancestors (the Africans) had previously worshiped.
Where previously, as minorities, they felt alienated as strangers among the
majorities the dominant American society, and they did not feel cultural
integration until they became like them and worshiped like their Christian
religion.
Here is also a criticism where the poet points out that they converted their religion
not for the sake of religion and not because they considered Christianity is the
correct religion, but for the sake of social and cultural integration in order to be
socially accepted and live as equals with the Americans. This is an example of
(Noble Savage).
The idea of "Black blood", the poet hopes that the person whom they follow his
religion, the Prophet Jesus Christ, would be (a black man) like them, Not White,
but black like African Negros as they carry the same Case like Jesus Christ as the
same cause of suffering and injustice of Jesus Christ, and the people who killed
Christ in the past is the same people are torturing them and killing them today. This
represents criticism as black people suffer from racism, racial discrimination, and
slavery by the White American society.
American literature is a mixture is a (Melting pot), The term "melting pot" came
into general usage in the United States after it was used as a metaphor describing
a fusion of nationalities, cultures and ethnicities in Israel Zangwill's 1908 play of
the same name (The Melting pot). A melting pot is a monoculture metaphor for a
heterogeneous society becoming more homogeneous, the different elements
"melting together" with a common culture, through the influx of foreign elements
(Immigration from different regions into America) with different cultural
backgrounds. It can create a harmonious hybridized society known as cultural
amalgamation. In the United States, the term (Melting pot) is often used to describe
the cultural integration of immigrants to the country.
As the American art, with all its types, painting, music, and literature, is the
melting of several diverse cultures (such as African, Asian, Mexican, and European
culture), all of them melted into a new culture, which is American culture. This
term was coined by a playwright who gave this description of American literature
and argued that it is a mixture of several civilizations within the new civilization,
which is American (American Mosaic).
All day long and all night through,
One thing only must I do:
Quench my pride and cool my blood,
The poet brings up his roots by referring to (black blood). It is a kind of post-colonial
literature, as the writer from the third space does not completely neglect his roots
and origins, nor is he completely against the new culture. Therefore, he combines
the two cultures "mixed", whereby cultural fusion and melting of cultures with each
other is as if it were (melting pot) This creates a kind of mixture culture.
ملخص لكل القصيدة باختصار
In summary, the poet shows a contradiction in his poem, and this contradiction
reflects the same contradiction experienced by African-American blacks, as they
suffer in an internal conflict because their origins, roots, and cultural identity as
Minorities, have merged with American culture and created them as a hybridity
culture in a New space " New culture", it is the Third space.
They changed their culture, their way of speaking, and even a turning point in their
religion (to Christianity) in order to be accepted (Noble Savage) in American
society as the Minority African culture fused with the dominant American culture.
However, they suffered from double consciousness, where they spoke things while
inside them were other things. They appeared to be formed from the new
American culture, but they Within them and in their hearts there is a Nostalgia for
their roots and heritage, which led to an internal conflict within black Africans (a
crisis of belonging) it is a type of nostalgia for the culture of the past, their land and
their original cultural heritage (Africa).
This is the case for all Minorities in America under the dominant culture, as some
critics have argued that American literature in particular and all types of art in
general, are Mixed (multiple containers) with all types of art (music, drawing,
literature and so on) as the American cultures are a mixture of several cultures
(European, African, Mexican, and Chinese) All of them merged into a new hybridity
culture that created the Third space.
) اللي ردنلياه أستاذ مصطفى بالمحاضرة حول (مقالة ربط القصيدة مع قصيدة تي اس اليوت ويست الند.. من هنا
COUNTEE CULLEN'S "HERITAGE": A BLACK "WASTE LAND" by DAVID K. KIRBY.
Heritage can be seen as Parallel story of waste land by T.S. Eliot. it deals with the
same basic dilemma as the Eliot poem in terms of modern individual aware of his
reach heritage yet stranded in a sterile, conformist culture (the American one) and
because it shares with that poem some similar imagery of suffering.
It is of significance that the persona spends his days recumbent, dreaming of the
sights and sounds of his native country. that makes a parallelized caught between
two culture.
his African Heritage pre-occupies him yet he must conform to the dictates of the
white culture (Dominant culture).
Quaint, outlandish heathen gods
Black men fashion out of rods,
Clay, and brittle bits of stone,
In a likeness like their own.
these lines show the sacrifice of person that he has made to be accepted for the
sake of the white culture and over the black gods of Africa.
"Wishing He I served were black,"
"The Black Christ", The Biblical Christ is referred to as a "man of sorrows," and
certainly the black, by nature of his status in a white culture, is a man of sorrows in
a secular sense.
Lord, I fashion dark gods, too,
Daring even to give You
Dark despairing features where,
To show the practice of the lost religion of his forefathers and equally unable to
worship the white man's Christ, the persona has taken the significant features of
the two public modes of worship and has made from thema private variety.
All day long and all night through,
One thing only must I do:
Quench my pride and cool my blood,
Lest I perish in the flood.
the flood of pride will burst forth and overwhelm him, washing away the props of
whatever stability he may have acquired.
In the least way realized
They and I are civilized.
similarity between "Heritage" and "The Waste Land" is apparent, both poems
deal with the gap that exists between contemporary man, who is sensitive to his
cultural heritage.
in addition, both poems refer to the idea of a sterile society.
Modernist poets and many writers had spoken about the subject of (the sterility of
spirituality) and the complexities of belonging and identity, which is why it is called
(A Black Waste Land), where the idea of (Dryness) in T. S. Eliot’s poem means
spiritual dryness and identity crisis in the shadow of the sterile materialistic society
that lacks spirituality and values.
The poet indicates that they must be united, join hands, be brothers, and they must
help each other in order to rise, create their glory, and prove their cultural identity.
"Shall we beguile their limbs with mellow flute,
Not always bend to some more subtle brute;
We were not made eternally to weep."
The poet believes in prophecy about the future, as he believes that blacks people in
the future will have a high status in society and the situation will not remain as it is,
as the poet indicates that they were not created to remain subservient or to be
slaves, so that we do not continue to cry and weeping and feel inferior to others.
the poet calls for waken, renaissance, work, and call for action to prove identity,
to change their situation and to get a higher position in society, and calling for
them not to remain the least valuable class in society (inferior), but rather to
become (superior). Also This is the poet’s prophecy about the future of African-
American blacks, and this is what actually happened now days.
We must not remain followers to them, and we must take our own action in order
to export our culture and cultural identity. This is the attitude of most African-
American poets belonging to the Harlem Renaissance movement that stared in the
New York City – Harlem Manhattan, in 1920s also named "New Negro
Movement".
“The night whose sable breast relieves the stark,
White stars is no lesser lovely being dark,”
Bright stars in the dark sky refers to black & white people. the beauty of the bright
stars won’t be obvious without the dark background. This image represents the
idea that black people should live with white people as brothers, one
complementing the other, like the white star that does not shine without the black
background of the sky, the idea of integration and harmony as the poet wants to
clarify the idea that they are equal to whites in rights and equal to them in the same
Importance and the same value.
And there are buds that cannot bloom at all
In light, but crumple, piteous, and fall;
So in the dark we hide the heart that bleeds,
And wait, and tend our agonizing seeds.
The poet presents a poetic image of flowers that do not appear in the morning and
only appear at night, it is reference to (blackness) and the idea of (black power),
where the poet wants to convey an idea, by the description of that just as God
created a rose that blooms and shines in the morning, there is also a rose that
blooms, grows, and blooms at night, it means we are equal Black and white as God
create the White people and so the Black people as being a Black is not a sin, so
we should live in the same community without racism. Also another image, which
is the image of agonizing seeds, as the poet means that one day they will grow and
become prosperous. the poet believes in a prophecy, so It is the poet’s prophecy
about the future of African Negroes, which is that the situation will not remain as
it is, as it is a clear reference to the black African as they will be equal to whites and
be effective in society. This is the poet’s prophecy about the future of blacks which
is that the situation will not remain as it is, and that black Africans will have great
importance in the future and a higher position in society, and they will prove
themselves and their cultural identity as higher people in society, do not remain
the lower. Also the idea of equality instead of racism as the poet means that we
are both black and white are citizen with equal rights and no one less than the other.
We find that this issue of proving cultural identity is a topic repeated by Minorities
writers under the control of the dominant Majority in America, such as Arab
Minorities as well, for example the Arabic American poet Naomi Shihab in her poem
"my father and the Fig Tree" and many others poems.
I have a memory.
It swims deep in blood,
a delta in the skin. It swims out of Oklahoma,
deep the Mississippi River. It carries my
feet to these places: the French Quarter,
stale rooms, the sun behind thick and moist
clouds, and I hear boats hauling themselves up
and down the river.
1. Identify examples of color imagery in the poem. What effect does this imagery create? Give text evidence
in your answer.
2. In line 64 (bolded), the speaker refers to “beaten silver paths.” To what does this image refer, and how is
it connected to the “silver blades and crosses” (bolded) in lines 45-46?
3. What does DeSoto represent to the speaker? What particular words or images reveal the most about the
speaker’s feelings toward DeSoto?
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
In this poem, the poet (woman poet) directly criticizes the European colonial project and also
indirectly criticizes the Native people themselves, how they easily integrated with colonialists and
controlled them.
This poet usually writes in the style of tall stories. Sometimes, She used the method of narration
through the character (Flaneur) and wrote a lot about memories of the South in order to prove their
cultural identity, like most minority writers in America. The poet has used imageries as a poetic style
as (frame story) in most of her poems. For example, she presented in her poems Many images about
animals. Most American writers and poets the Native American poets and Minorities poets wrote
with this poetic image about animals. The poet represents a tribe from the South Creeks (Creeks: a
specific indigenous tribe) They belong to the Native American. Also the place she was talking about
is (Mississippi), and how is the journey of many Native Americans from Mississippi to New Orleans,
it is a modern history of that journey or moving of Native people from different places to the cities
of America, such as their movement from Mississippi river to New Jersey, and New Orleans where
they descended from different tribes.
The poetic image of animals is not a reference to real animals. For example, the horse is depicted as
frozen, referring to the similarity between them (the Native) and animals, as an animal such as a
horse with high value, which represents equestrianism and which is characterized by action, has
now become frozen, without action, without real values (valueless). Usually, Animals use as
metaphor like the horse for glorification, but here metaphors are used for criticism.
A second important poetic image, where the poet depicts a black woman holding white children,
and the poet indicates that the mother has become without real spiritual value and is merely a
device or a machine for bringing children, as the woman has been transformed under the capitalist
system as if she were just a machine and tool for giving children.
The poem contains the idea of colonialism, as she represented the character of Desoto, the Spanish
military leader who occupied and colonized many lands, for wealth and Gold, as he represents the
symbol of colonialism.
At The beginning of the poem, she talks about the south, as the south, for the poet, is her
Memories and traditions, Nostalgia for the south, as it refers to the place of the Creeks tribe, most
of whom were killed or displaced from their original places by the hand of colonialism. They treat
them as slaves (racism) It is criticism for colonialism.
The poet imagines herself as if she entered a certain market preceded by the France word
(European colonialism). She saw in the market a blue horse, as the horse should be represented a
great value to them, but the poet depicted the horse as frozen (The Native people), as it had become
worthless and useless, not like the previous time, where there was spiritual, and cultural value. this
is the idea of colonialism that restricted them, restricted the Native people, as the poet imagines as
if there is an area in which there is a horse frozen without value because it is now under the control
of the colonizers, and this is a metaphor for the situation of the Native people under the control of
the European colonizers who colonized the land of the Native people and killed them and treated
them as slavery. It is the idea of the decline of spiritual values.
This spiritual decay and vanishing which they were subjected is due to the European
(Spanish) occupation that restricted them and killed them, the idea of “madness”, since the
colonists like (De Soto) were crazy about wealth and gold and were always searching for
it and killing people in order to obtain it, as the poet says to whom like De Soto that you
came and colonized us and killed us for the sake of gold, but we do not have the gold that
is in your imagination and dreams, and the poet says that they are now restricted and
cannot speak under the control of the European colonizers.
Here is a reference to the bloodshed which the colonists brought and how they used those
tools to kill the indigenous people, as the (ivory) represents the Europeans colonizers, and
the red stone represents the Native people of the land of America, representing their
traditions, and historical heritage.
(ivory) represents the European settlers and (red stone) represents the customs of the
Native people.
European settlers are inbred violence while The native people were created with peace.
This shows the contradiction between the two (Duality) between the culture of the violent
occupier (European settlers) and the culture of the peaceful ones The native one, the
people were occupied.
The poet brings up the idea of racism and slavery to which the Native people were subjected by
the European colonialists, and how they transported them from different places, from the
Mississippi River to the New Orleans region, and how they all drowned, referring to the sinking of
the ship that was carrying a large number of Native people, Other Creeks boarded ships in New
Orleans and were taken up the Mississippi River. On this journey, one steamboat was stuck by
another ship, and approximately 300 Creeks died. which is believed that accident was occurred
intentionally by the American government in order to kill them. where they killed them in the sea.
My spirit comes here to drink.
My spirit comes here to drink.
Blood is the undercurrent.
Here the repetition is not only to attract attention, but also to show that they had spiritual value, and
how they (The Native) have now become dead under the European colonialism.
Here, the poet invokes the idea of the Binary between the master and the slaves, the ruler
and the convict, the white European colonialists who occupied and colonized the land
of the Native people and killed them, in addition, they treated them with racism and
slavery. The poet represents her southern ancestors, the Native people, and the poet brings
back the idea of the Memory of the South, as a researcher and explorer of the cultural
identity of the South.
The character of De Soto, the European-Spanish military leader who was the leader of the
process of occupying many areas in American Lands and is also known as the “fortune
hunter.” He traversed the entire world from far land in order to search of gold and killed
many of the Native people and enslaved them. It is as if the poet says that you are the one
who seek wealth and gold and are killing us for the sake of gold, you will not find any of gold
because we do not have these material things and these material things do not mean
anything to us. She also depicts how when they occupied them, killed them, took the women
as slaves, and used them as tools for sexual matters as "machine". The idea is not only the
character of De Sato himself, but all the occupiers carry the same colonial ideology and
exploit people and use them as slaves, they were searching for resources, and seek wealth
from various kinds, and gold is one example of it. De Soto was "delusion" to possess gold
and to dance with elegant Ladies.
This poem is based on memory, the Memory of the South, as everything about the past remains
present in their memory and culture identity.
trolley cars on beaten silver paths, line 64
graves that rise up out of soft earth in the rain,
shops that sell black mammy dolls
holding white babies.
Out of use, the people of New Orleans beaten by use, only able to take them to far places. The
native did not resist the invaders, but they were helping them, harmonious relationship.
This is the opposite of the image that represents what people were looking for, such as
the colonial military commander (De Soto), who was searching for gold and did not find
any of the gold for which he killed them. This is also an image of indirect criticism of the
Native Americans themselves, as they are easily controlled by the occupier and how
They became merge with the colonialists who tortured them and treated them as slaves.
How women were used for sexual purposes by white colonizers and women became
pregnant with white children and holding them. How did Native women give birth of
children for the occupying people the white!!!
The second Wave (the second group): Most of them are Arab Muslims, after World War II,
and after the turbulent political conditions, the Palestinian situation, and the Israeli
occupation of Palestine, where many Arab Muslim poets immigrated to America. We see the
features of politics poets in the poems of the poets of the second wave, and they focus on the
Arabic culture, as they were on Contact with Arab culture, unlike the poets of the first wave.
The third Wave (the third group): Post-modern poets, they are similar to the second wave. In
this Wave, they were not only Muslims, but Arabs of various sects. There are writers and poets
with a high level of education, including professors and academics, as they believed in
Multiculturalism. They were in the middle (in betweenness) and did not neglect their culture
and at the same time, they were not more connected with it. They wrote many literary works to
bring their culture to export their Arabic culture within American culture, as American literature
is (Milton Pot) a pot containing many diverse cultures, they believe in (Neo-liberalism), as they
wanted to prove their cultural identity within the American Mosaic. For much of the
Minority culture is integrated under the umbrella of the Majority American culture.
One of the poets of the third wave is Naomi Shihab, an Arab American poet of Palestinian origin
(her father is Arab Palestinian, her mother is American). She followed the style of cultural
pluralism (Multiculturalism) as a poetic style in her works, she presented a style characterized
by the concept of cultural pluralism and cultural integration. She has a novel in which Arab
culture is also presented through language, using Arabic phrases in English literature such as
(Siti and Hajji) as a type of export of Arab cultural identity in the West to prove Arab cultural
identity.
Naomi Shihab was celebrating that she is (multicultural), as she has an American mother of
German origin and an American of Arab origin, and she was celebrating multiculturalism.
There are also poets within the third group, but they did not follow the style of cultural pluralism
and cultural integration, but rather, on the contrary, they do not believe in that idea, such as the
Syrian writer Mohja Kahf, who wrote in a tone of resistance towards America and did not
believe in the idea of cultural integration, such as the poetry collection that she wrote entitled
(Emails from Scheherazade) and mostly, Her poems are titled (Hijab Scene), as she appears to
be a strong, self-reliant independent woman and shows the tone of revolution and resistance.
It presented a different Scheherazade from the traditional Scheherazade. It presented a
strong, modern Scheherazade who uses a computer in the style of a modern woman. Sheherazade,
presented by Mohja Kahf, was not writing letters, but rather writing bombs, as she was writing
in the spirit of resistance and not cultural integration.
The most important themes of Arab American poets are identity crisis, nostalgia for the
past, race, feminism, and cultural traditions.
Minority poets in America share the themes of identity crisis, Proof of identity, nostalgia for
their roots, and their sense of injustice under the dominance of the American majority, as their
definition of literature is that literature is an art that reflects the reality, the real life.
Therefore, Arab-American poets want to export their culture, fill their space, and explain their
culture to others, as the Arab writers in America reflect the image of Arab culture, it is kind of
saying (we are here, we talk about our culture, and we know our culture more than others
who write about our culture). Some of them also tried to export their culture through the
language, where they exported some of the Arabic words to the English language, like
Naomi Shihab, where she wrote the phrases (Allah) , (Siti) and (Joha) with the same Arabic
dialect written in English forms.
Translated literature also appeared, as some of them wrote in their mother tongue and translated
it into English.
...................................................................................................................................................
The title of the poem contains symbolism and a poetic image that expresses Arab cultural identity,
as the fig tree reflects the Palestinian Arab land and reflects nostalgia for Arab roots.
In this stanza (the cherry), which represents the American land and reflects the American identity, and
her father prefers the fig tree, which represents their land, origins, roots, and Arab-Palestinian culture.
Here, also, the Arab culture is exported through a story from the ancient Arab traditions (Juha). It is a
kind of (Frame Story), which is a second and different story within the story to give the idea of
Arab identity and to give the idea of wisdom and a moral message. It is also a story that represents
Arab customs , tradition and culture.
Here, is the idea of generational elements, that her father is from a different
generation from the past generation and the girl is from a different
generation from the new generation that does not know or understand the
value and significance of the fresh figs (figs of the past). This new
generation does not taste the taste of the figs of the past. Here the poet gives
a scene of a conversation between her (the daughter) and her father. It was
as if her father was telling her that he wanted the same figs that existed
in their land in the past, the natural, fresh figs. It was a kind of nostalgia
for the past and adherence to their roots, the figs that represented their
cultural identity.
Here also is the idea of abundance, goodness, and nature (the idea of
greatness and goodness), as the natural fig tree is the one that contains
goodness and blessing, not the dried fig. Here, also, is an indication that the
new fig is dry and devoid of spirituality, unlike the old the natural fig.
Years passed, we lived in many houses,
none had figtrees.
We had lima beans, zucchini, parsley, beets.
"Plant one!" my mother said.
but my father never did.
He tended garden half-heartedly, forgot to water,
let the okra get too big.
"What a dreamer he is. Look how many
things he starts and doesn't finish."
They see several homes in America, but none of them feel like their home. They do not feel a
sense of belonging there, as they belong to the Palestinian Arab home their origin home. Where
her father felt that he was living in instability in (misplacedness and displacedness).
Her father is a dreamer and unrealistic (he lives in dreams) as he hopes to plant Palestinian
Arab figs on American land, and the reality is deferent it is impossible to plant Arab figs on
American land and the idea that America has become occupied by materialism and that it is
impossible to see a garden of fig tree in The American land like the one which her father dreams
of, as this land is not their origin land and not the land of fig tree and it is full of materialism.
This leads us to an important connection, where there is another dreamer man, Colon Shaw,
in the poem (For the union dead by Robert Lowell), where he also sought the dream of creating
equality between black Negroes and whites and for them to live in peace and justice, but he got
nothing as there was Racism in American society, injustice continues, and the dream is not
fulfilled.
Both of them were unrealistic dreamers and did not achieve their dreams under the
prevailing materialism in America.
The last time he moved, I got a phone call,
My father, in Arabic, chanting a song
I'd never heard. "What's that?"
He took me out back to the new yard.
Her father was on the phone with her and was singing an Arabic song to her that reflects Arab
customs and culture as a form of nostalgia for the past and as a form of recommendation not
to forget our roots and cultural identity (identity crisis).
the metaphorical layer immediately draws attention to the significance of the fig tree. Fig trees
are often laden with symbolism in various cultures and literary traditions. They can represent
abundance or nourishment, but here it represents fertility and homeland. By calling it a "figtree
song," the speaker suggests that there's something inherently musical or harmonious about the
scene or experience they're describing. Tokens are memory of her homeland.
Here is homesickness and (feeling alienated) where the father was in (Home Sick condition), the
(Token) Here is an image of something else, something more realistic in Dallas, where he did
not find anything to complete his identity and it was a symbol.
The idea of planting the Arabic fig tree on American land is typically (the third space)
In this poem we see the idea of (the third space), where the father dreams of seeing the Palestinian
Arab fig tree planted in a garden on American land.
In post-modern literature, intertextuality has prevailed in literature and goes beyond even the
written text. (Intertextuality with things) is a symbolism for something else. It may be a specific
thing, such as a building that reflects a symbolism for something else, or a specific food that
reflects a culture and cultural identity. A specific image may be a language and representation.
The topic is bigger than the image itself and carries deep messages.
Most of Shihab’s poems contain a father. Naomi Shihab presented the image of a friendly,
compassionate father and her good relationship with him. This differs from the image of the
father presented by Sylvia Platt, the cruel, ill-fated father (bad image of father) and her bad
relationship with him as she hated him and described him as a Nazi.
The poet Naomi Shihab presented another poem entitled (Arabic Coffee), in which she sits with
her father and her father tells her stories, where Arabic coffee represents not only a drink, but
rather an Arab cultural and social identity. It is a kind of proof of cultural identity and
nostalgia for the past.
The themes of Minorities in America share the same topics, common themes such as the
identity crisis, nostalgia for the past, and exile, such as the themes of black African-American
poets and their writing against racism and give the topic of their identity such as (Black is power,
Black is beauty) in the Harem Renaissance in New York, and this appeared in all types of art of
them, not just poetry. But also music, drawing and all other types of art. Also, the Native
America and their writings that reflected the injustice and racism they were subjected and the
genocide carried out by the Europeans against the American Native people. Arab Americans
also share similar themes of identity crisis, Racism, injustice, nostalgia for the past and the
attempt to prove cultural identity. This type of literature reached its peak in the fifties of the
twentieth century. It is a type of literary revolution in various kinds of writings, one of them is
poetry.
Most of the WILLIAM BUTLER 's writings contain a sense of Irishness. William Butler is a poet
of Irish origin. His poetry belongs to (post-World War I literature) and landmark of Modernity.
After World War I, he was affected by World War I and the horrors of war and how many people
were killed. This poem, along with T. S. Eliot's poem (Love Song) and the poem (The Waste
Land), are considered landmarks of modern poetry as an example of modernism, as they share
the idea of how people have culturally moved away from the center, and the loss of spirituality
and values among people in the modern era, and there is no center to which they belong.
The poet William Butler presented the Irish poetic image when he wrote a book called (Vision)
that contains much of the history of the Irish and the mythology of the Irish, their traditions
and customs.
Also in this poem there is an Irish sense. For example, he presented an Irish poetic image, which
is (Gyre), which means that in the belief of the Irish, a great event occurs every two thousand
years, such as the birth of Christ. On the other hand, he wants to give the idea of pessimism
prophecy about what is coming, under The destruction of the World War.
They were waiting for another great event another coming, waiting for the “savior,” but the
poet means that they are in this bad situation after two thousand years, the opposite will
happen. The “savior” will not come, but the bad and the destructive will come (anti-Christ).
The poem contains a call to the kind of spirituality and a sense of loss of spirituality. This poem
can also be linked with the idea of the poem (Dover Beach) by Matthew Arnold, as it contains
a criticism of the ugly face of the industrial revolution and the ugly face of knowledge and the
scientific revolution, as it led people to move away from faith and people moving away from
spirituality. The poet presents A pessimistic image without hope, as the whole world was in
chaos ( in Anarchy) and in a state of cultural and social collapse, and society was without a
center and heading towards the worst, in this point there is a contrast to TS Eliot’s poem, which
contains a kind of hope after the dark tunnel.
The poet wonders how the best people began to lose their faith. Even the clergy lost insight
into faith and lost spirituality. So what about the rest of the people!!?? It is a pessimistic poetic
image of the situation after the World War.
(Spiritus Mundi) Here the methodological meaning is a reference to the second coming,
which is a negative and bad coming, not like the first coming.
A gaze blank of this creature provides evidence of how hopeless the situation is.
In the poem, the poet employed a different Christian narrative (upside down) by presenting
the image of the opposite in an inverted manner, where the poet depicts an ugly creature, an
ugly animal, crawling (Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born? ) in the place of Christ’s
birth (Bethlehem) in order to do the opposite of what Christ did, in order to spread destruction.
It is a pessimistic prophecy of the future, where What is coming is not good, but what is coming
is negative and bad.
the second coming presents a black vision of the future of humankind, where morality is now
turning into a nightmare (decline of morality).
the second coming raises the question of sowing the planting of the seeds of their own
destruction. we are who bring the destruction for ourselves.