Chandraprakash Pareek Research Paper ICETISD 24 M.Tech
Chandraprakash Pareek Research Paper ICETISD 24 M.Tech
Chandraprakash Pareek Research Paper ICETISD 24 M.Tech
(Received month date, year; Revised month date, year; accepted month date, year).
Abstract: Concrete is mainly used popular building material in the world. The demand of concrete
for today’s infrastructural expansion is increasing gradually. Since the plain, unreinforced concrete
is a brittle material, with a low tensile strength and a low strain capacity. Addition of steel fiber can
increase strength properties. FRC provides better tensile strength than plain concrete. Fiber
introduced in concrete also works as a crack arrester and crack width reducer in concrete.
Aggregate and cement are the major component of concrete. Use of Granite Dust (GD)/sludge,
marble dust, fly ash such industrial waste materials as a replacement of cement provides several
advantages, such as improved strength and durability properties, and environmental benefits related
to the disposal of waste materials. Sometimes concrete structures have to survive in adverse
conditions under chemical attacks like chloride attack, sulphate attack and acid attack. These
chemical attacks affect the durability of concrete structure.
In this study, a viewpoint is made to use of granite dust as partial replacement of cement in
concrete with addition of steel fibers, and an attempt has been made to investigate the strength and
durability parameters of concrete. For preparation of control concrete, IS method of mix design is
adopted and considering this a basis, mix design for replacement method has been made.
Replacement level of 20% by the weight of cement is selected for the study concern to replacement
method and addition of various percentages (0%, 0.5%, 1% & 1.5%). Large range of curing periods
starting from 14 days, & 28 days are considered in the present study. Normal curing in tap water
and the environmental simulation for chloride attack 5% NaCl solution was prepared.
This study deals with; strength properties based performance analysis of modified steel fiber
concrete. Total 108 specimens were cast. It includes 12 controlled mix concrete cube specimens
(0% steel fiber), 12 controlled mix concrete cylinder specimens (0% steel fiber) and 3 controlled
mix concrete beam specimens (0% steel fiber) and 81 specimens with above percentage of steel
fiber. The specimens have been prepared of the Mix-Design M30 grade concrete based on IS
10262:2009. Cube specimens of the dimensions 150×150×150 mm, cylinder specimens 300mm
(length) × 150mm (dia.) and beam specimens of dimensions 100×100×500 mm. Results are
obtained in form of compressive strength, split tensile strength and flexural strength.
1
ETISD-2024
Keywords: Granite dust, Marble dust, Fly ash, Steel fiber, Compressive Strength, Split Tensile
Strength and Flexural Strength.
Concrete is the most popular building material in the ductility. If the fibers like steel fibers which are strong
world. After aggregate cement is the major component of enough and perfectly bonded to the material, permits the
concrete. The yearly production of cement is nearly 3 FRC to carry noteworthy stresses over a relatively large
billion tons. The construction industry relies heavily on strain capacity in post cracking state. Different types of
cement for production of concrete. Nearly 8% of the steel fibers can be used to reinforce concrete. Steel fibers
global CO2 emission is contributed by cement industries. are generally classified on their manufacturing process.
Disposal of the sludge by land filling is causing serious Figure 1.1: Different Types of Steel fibers
2
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
cracks developed in the concrete structures and corrode above percentage of steel fiber. The specimens have been
the reinforcement provided in the concrete and thus the prepared of the Mix-Design M30 grade concrete based
deterioration of structure starts and the durability of on IS 10262:2009. Cube specimens of the dimensions
structure get affected. Although use of steel fibers 150×150×150 mm, cylinder specimens 300mm (length)
reduced the generation of cracks but still there is some × 150mm (dia.) and beam specimens of dimensions
deterioration due to the chloride attack on concrete. 100×100×500 mm were cast. Normal curing in tap water
Mostly the chloride attack is seen in structures those are and the environmental simulation for chloride attack 5%
immersed in saline water or situated near saline water. NaCl solution was prepared. Strengths tests at two
It is hoped that this research will help in some way to different ages 14 & 28 days were conducted.
improve knowledge by bringing out the results of an Mix-Design M-
30
experimental program carried out to evaluate the
effectiveness of using a mixture of GD by the 20% Tests to analyze Mix-
Strength Proportioning
weight of cement as alternative for cement with addition
of steel fiber (0%, 0.5%, 1% & 1.5%) for production of
low cost concrete. As a basis for in-depth understanding
of the performance of this concrete, this research was
Curing For Compaction
geared towards checking its basic mechanical and 14 & 28 Days Factor Test
Initial 30 Min Lime saturation factor (ratio Not greater than 1.02
168 + 2 hr. (7 days) India (p) Ltd, 5-8B, Nagpur Industrial Estate, Kamptee
33
Road, Uppalawadi, Nagpur – 440026, India.
672 + 4 hr. (28 days) 43
Table 2.3: Mechanical Properties of Steel Fiber
Requirements of
Length 50 mm
Particulars
IS: 8112
Aspect Ratio 66.67
Total Loss on Ignition (% by
Not more than 5.0 Tensile Strength 1195 MPa
mass)
greater than 5
4
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
Table 2.4: Chemical Composition of steel fiber Table 2.6: Chemical Properties of Granite Dust
Black, White,
1 Colour
Grey, Red, Pink D. Aggregates: Aggregates are important constituent of
concrete mix. Aggregates are generally thought of as
2 Shape Texture Irregular
inert filler within a concrete mix. But a closer look
3 Mineralogy Crystalline reveals the major role and influence aggregate plays in
the properties of both fresh and hardened concrete.
4 Particle Size < 90 micron Changes in gradation, maximum size, unit weight, and
moisture content can all alter the character and
5 Odour Odourless
performance concrete mix.
6 Specific gravity 2.37 E. Superplasticizer: The Superplasticizer used in the
experiment for preparation of Mix-Design is Master
7 Appearance Fine
Glenium® SKY 8233. It is a High-performance super
plasticizer based on PCE (Polycarboxylic ether) for
concrete.
Granite dust has some chemical components same as
cement that’s why it’s used as the replacement of cement 2.2 Mix Proportioning of M-30 Concrete:
in concrete. Table 2.6 shows the chemical components of Mix proportions considered with addition of steel fiber
granite dust. by 0%, 0.5%, 1% & 1.5% volume of concrete and a fixed
ETISD-2024
20% replacement of cement with granite dust in M-30 I) Coarse aggregate 2.74
Grade Concrete. 2) Fine aggregate 2.74
Table 2.7: Stipulations for Proportioning
Water absorption:
Grade Designation M30
1) Coarse aggregate 0.5 %
OPC 43 grade
2) Fine aggregate 1.0 %
Type of cement conforming to IS
8112 Free (surface) moisture:
MasterGlenium® SKY
Chemical admixture
8233
6
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
Table 3.1 shows values of compaction factor for the For 28 Days NaCl Curing
different values of steel fiber content in concrete.
Concrete without fiber has high compaction factor
whereas concrete with maximum fiber content showed Figure 3.3: % Weight Increased of Cylinders Due to
lowest compaction factor. NaCl Curing of 28 days
For 14 Days NaCl Curing It was observed from Figure 3.4 that minimum
compressive strength was obtained at 0% addition of
steel fiber (26.665 N/mm2) while optimum
compressive strength was obtained at 1% addition of
steel fiber (42.44 N/mm2) at 14 days curing of cubes.
It was also observed from Figure 3.4 that minimum
compressive strength was obtained at 0% (29.33
N/mm2) while optimum compressive strength was
obtained at 1.5% addition of steel fiber (49.95
N/mm2) at 28 days curing of cubes.
Figure 3.6: Compressive Strength of Cubes (NaCl Curing) Figure 3.7: Percentage Strength Increased (NaCl Curing)
It was observed from Figure 3.6 that minimum It was observed form Figure 3.7 that optimum
compressive strength was obtained at 0% (22.55 percentage increment in compressive strength of
N/mm2) while optimum compressive strength was concrete was 55.85% (form 0% to 1% addition of
8
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
steel fiber) at 14 days of curing. While it was also compressive strength between water and NaCl curing,
observed that optimum percentage increment in
compressive strength of concrete was 74.68% (from for 14 Days. Maximum variation is 8.87% with 0.5%
0% to 1.5% addition of steel fiber) at 28 days curing. steel fiber and minimum variation is 0.55% with 1.5%
NaCl 28 Days)
Figure 3.9 shows the percentage variation of
ETISD-2024
Figure 3.11 shows the percentage variation of strength It was observed from Figure 3.13 that optimum
between water and NaCl curing, for 28 Days. percentage increment in split tensile strength of
Maximum variation is 10.01% with 0% steel fiber and concrete was 127% (from 0% to 1.5% addition of
minimum variation is 04.44% with 0.5% steel fiber. steel fiber) at 14 days of curing. While it was observed
that optimum percentage increment in split tensile
3.2.5 Split Tensile Strength Test strength of concrete was 108% (from 0% to 1.5%
obtained at 1.5% addition of steel fiber (7.07 N/mm2) at It was observed from Figure 3.14 that minimum split
14 days curing of cubes. tensile strength was observed at 0% addition of steel
fiber (1.69 N/mm2) while optimum split tensile strength
It was also observed from Figure 3.12 that minimum was obtained at 1.5% addition of steel fiber (5.66
split tensile strength was obtained at 0% (3.53 N/mm2) N/mm2) at 14 days of curing of cubes.
10
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
It was observed from Figure 3.15 that optimum 11.51% at 1% steel fiber and maximum variation was
percentage increment in split tensile strength was 84% at 0% steel fiber content in concrete.
234% (from 0% to 1.5% addition of steel fiber) at 14 (d) Comparison of split tensile strength (Water &
days of curing. While it was also observed that NaCl 28 Days)
optimum percentage increment in split tensile strength Figure 3.18: Split Tensile Strength Comparison of
of concrete was 101.54% (from 0% to 1.5% addition
of steel fiber) at 28 days curing. Cylinders (Water & NaCl 28 days)
(c) Comparison of split tensile strength (Water &
NaCl 14 Days) Figure 3.18 shows the comparison of split tensile
strength between water and NaCl curing of cylinders. It
is observed from figure that water curing cylinders have
more split tensile strength than NaCl curing cylinders
after 28 days of curing, for each respective steel fiber
content percentage.
Figure 3.20: Flexural Strength of Concrete Beams fiber, due to this the bond between matrix and fiber is
more effective and stress transfer is more proficient.
It was observed from Figure 3.20 that minimum
flexural strength was obtained at 0% (3.2 N/mm2) (4) Performance of concrete is also examined under the
while optimum flexural strength was obtained at 1.5% chloride attack after 14 & 28 days curing in NaCl
(6 N/mm2) addition of steel fiber at 28 days or curing.
solution. It was observed that deterioration in weight of
It was observed from Figure 3.21 that optimum concrete didn’t occur after 14 & 28 days curing in NaCl
percentage increment in flexural strength of concrete
was 87.5% (from 0% to 1.5% addition of steel fiber) solution.
at 28 days curing. References
1) A. A. Farah, S. A. Saad, A. K. Izian and S. N. Azizi,
Figure 3.21: % Flexural Strength Increased "Effect of tropical climate to compressive strength
of high performance fiber reinforced concrete," 5th
(1) Compressive strength of concrete increased with
Brunei International Conference on Engineering
addition of steel fiber (0% to 1.5%) after 14 days & 28
and Technology (BICET 2014), Bandar Seri
days with or without chloride attack. it was also observed
Begawan, 2014, pp. 1-4.
that optimum percentage increment in compressive
strength of concrete was 59% for 14 days curing and 2) A. E. Abalaka and A. D. Babalaga, “Effects of
70.30% after 28 days curing (from 0% to 1.5% addition Sodium Chloride Solutions on Compressive
of steel fiber). Addition of steel fiber changed the brittle Strength Development of Concrete Containing Rice
failure into ductile failure and also enhanced the Husk Ash” ATBU Journal of Environmental
toughness of concrete mix that resulted as improvement Technology, Vol. 4, Issue 1, December 2011, pp.
(2) Split tensile strength also increased when percentage 3) A. Ghaffar, A. S. Chavhan and R. S. Tatwawadi,
of steel fiber (0% to 1.5%) added in concrete after 14 & “Steel Fibre Reinforced Concrete” International
28 days curing with or without chloride attack. The Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology
optimum percentage increment in split tensile strength (IJETT) Vol. 9, Issue 15, Mar 2014, pp. 791-797.
was 127% for 14 days curing and 108% for 28 days
4) A. H. Hosmani and S. B. Cholekar, “An Experimental
curing without chloride attack. This trend observed
Investigation on Concrete Produced by Replaing
because modulus of elasticity of matrix is much lower
Cement with Industrial Red Mud with Addition of
than steel fiber, due to this the bond between matrix and
Steel Fibers Subjected to Chloride Attack” The IUP
fiber is more effective and stress transfer is more
Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol. 9, Issue 3,
proficient.
September 2016, pp. 044-053.
(3) It was also noted that flexural strength of concrte
increased gradually with addition of steel fiber (0% to 5) A. M. Shende, A. M. Pande and M. G. Pathan,
1.5%) and minimum flexural strength was obtained at “Experimental Study on Steel Fiber Reinforced
0% (3.2 N/mm2). 6 N/mm2 optimum flexural strength Concrete for M-40 Grade” International Refereed
was obtained with addition of 1.5% steel fiber after 28 Journal of Engineering and Science (IRJES) Vol. 1,
days of curing. This trend was observed because Issue 1 September 2012, pp. 043-048.
12
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy
6) A. Nahak and S. Dash, “A Study on Strength of Research and Applications (IJERA) Vol. 2, Issue 3,
Concrete with Partial Replacement of Cement with May-Jun 2012, pp. 075-078.
Saw Dust Ash and Steel Fibre” International
13) G. P. Arulraj, A. Adin and T. S. Kannan, “Granite
Journal of Engineering Research & Technology
Powder Concrete” IRACST – Engineering Science
(IJERT) Vol. 4, Issue 3, March 2015, pp. 134-137.
and Technology: An International Journal (ESTIJ)
7) C. H. Srinivasa and Venkatesh, “Optimization of Vol.3, Issue 1, February 2013, pp. 193-198.
Granite Powder used as Partial Replacement to
14) H. Xu, Y. Zhao, L. Cui and B. Xu, “Sulphate attack
Cement in the Design of Ready Mix Concrete of
resistance of high-performance concrete under
M20 Grade using IS10262:2009” International
compressive loading” Journal of Zhejiang
Journal of Engineering Research & Technology
University-SCIENCE A (Applied Physics &
(IJERT), Vol. 4, Issue 01, January 2015, pp. 104-
Engineering), 2013-14, pp. 459-468.
111.
15) K. Soman, D. Sasi and K. A. Abubaker, “Strength
8) C. O. Sorensen, E. A. Berge, P. E. Saga and A.
Properties of Concrete with Partial Replacement of
Østvold, “Factors Affecting the Efficiency of Fibers
Cement by Granite Quarry Dust” International
in Concrete on Crack Reduction” Open Journal of
Journal of Engineering Research & Technology
Civil Engineering, 2013, 3, pp. 80-85.
(IJERT) Vol. 3, Issue 9, September 2014, pp. 344-
9) D. Maruthachalam and J. Muthukumar,"Mechanical 348.
Performance of Recycled PET Fiber Reinforced
16) L. N. Vairagade and V. M. Bhedi, “Comparison of
Concrete with Low Volume Fraction," International
Strength between Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete
Journal of Structural and Civil Engineering
and Conventional Concrete” International Journal
Research, Vol. 2, No. 2, May 2013, pp. 101-108.
on Recent and Innovation Trends in Computing and
10) E. Rubaninbacheran and N. Ganesan, “Durability Communication (IJRITCC) Vol. 3, Issue 2,
Studies on Fibre Concrete Using Partial February 2015, pp. 05-10.
Replacement of Cement by Granite Powder”
17) M. E. Allam, E. S. Bakhoum and G. L. Garas, “Re-
International Journal of Emerging Technology and
Use of Granite Sludge in Producing Green
Advanced Engineering (IJETAE) Vol. 4, Issue 6,
Concrete” ARPN Journal of Engineering and
June 2014, pp. 443-452.
Applied Sciences, Vol. 9, Issue 12, December
11) G. Elangovan, “Experimental Study of Concrete by 2014, pp. 2731-2737.
Partial Replacement of Cement with Granite Dust
18) M. Karthick and K. Nirmalkumar, “Durability
Powder” International Journal on Engineering
Properties of High Strength Self Compacting
Technology and Sciences (IJETS), Vol. 2, Issue 6,
Concrete using Silica Fume and Quarry Dust”
June 2015, pp. 025-028.
International Journal of Scientific Engineering and
12) G. Murali, C. M. V. Vardhan, G. S. priya, P. Sruthee Applied Science (IJSEAS) Vol. 2, Issue 4, April
and P. Charmily, “Influence of Steel Fiber on 2016, pp 389-395.
Concrete” International Journal of Engineering
ETISD-2024
19) M. N. Bajad, C. D. Modhera and A. K. Desai, 26) R. Vasudev and B. G. Vishnuram, “Studies on Steel
“Factors Affecting the Properties of Conglasscrete” Fibre Reinforced Concrete – A Sustainable
IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering Approach” International Journal of Scientific &
(IOSR-JMCE) Vol. 11, Issue 2 Ver. IV Mar- Apr. Engineering Research (IJSER) Vol. 4, Issue 5, May
2014, pp. 043-048. 2013, pp. 1941-1944.
20) M. V. Mohod, “Performance of Steel Fiber 27) S. A. Mahadik, S. K. Kamane and A. C. Lande,
Reinforced Concrete” International Journal of “Effect of Steel Fibers on Compressive and
Engineering and Science (IJES) Vol. 1, Issue 12, Flexural Strength of Concrete” International
December 2012, pp. 01-04. Journal of Advanced Structures and Geotechnical
Engineering (IJASGE) Vol. 3, Issue 4, October
21) M. Shanmugaraja, “Strength and Durabilitry of
2014, pp. 388-392.
Fibre Reinforced Quarry Dust Concrete”
International Journal of Innovations in Engineering 28) S. D. Jayswal, A. G. Hansora and A. A. Pandya,
and Technology (IJIET) Vol. 6, Issue 2, December “Effect of Steel Fibres on Compressive & Tensile
2015, pp. 406-408. Strength of Concrete using M-Sand as Fine
Aggregate” International Journal of Engineering
22) N. Shireesha, S. B. Murugan and G. N. Kumar,
Research & Technology (IJERT) Vol. 4, Issue 5,
“Experimental Studies on Steel Fiber Reinforced
May 2015, pp. 189-194.
Concrete” International Journal of Science and
Research (IJSR) Vol. 4, Issue 9, September 2015, 29) Siddharth and S. Munnur, “Experimental Study on
pp. 598-602. Strength Properties of Concrete using Steel
Fiber and GGBS as Partial Replacement of
23) P. L. Chowdary, “Strength Properties of Effect of
Cement” International Journal of Engineering
Waste Granite Powder on the Compressive Strength
Research & Technology (IJERT) Vol. 4, Issue 1,
of Concrete” An International Journal of Science,
January 2015, pp. 436-440.
Computer Science and Engineering & Technology
(JECET) Vol. 4, Issue 24, June 2015, pp. 716-727. 30) T. F. Kala, “Properties of Granite Powder Concrete”
1st International Conference on Infrastructure
24) P. Maca, J. Zatloukal and P. Konvalinka,
Development, UMS Surakarta, 1–3 Nov 2013, pp.
"Development of Ultra High Performance Fiber
276-283.
Reinforced Concrete mixture," 2012 IEEE
Symposium on Business, Engineering and 31) Y. Divakar, S. Manjunath and M. U. Aswath,
Industrial Applications, Bandung, 2012, pp. “Experimental Investigation on Behavior of
861-866. Concrete with the Use of Granite Fines”
International Journal of Advanced Engineering
25) R. Reju and G. J. Jacob, “Investigations on the
Research and Studies (IJAERS), Vol. 1, Issue 4,
chemical durability properties of Ultra High
July-Sept., 2012, pp. 084-087.
Performance Fiber Reinforced Concrete” 2012
International Conference on Green Technologies 32) V. S. Vairagade, K. S. Kene and N. V. Deshpande,
(ICGT), Trivandrum, 2012, pp. 181-185. “Investigation of Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete
on Compressive and Tensile Strength” International
14
Template for Evergreen - Joint Journal of Novel Carbon Resource Sciences & Green Asia Strategy