0% found this document useful (0 votes)

30 views214 pages

KK RDB Final English Report

Uploaded by

Arjun Shishir

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

0% found this document useful (0 votes)

30 views214 pages

KK RDB Final English Report

Uploaded by

Arjun Shishir

We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.

Available Formats

Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

You are on page 1/ 214

GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA

EVALUATION OF WORKS CARRIED OUT BY

KALYANA KARNATAKA REGION
DEVELOPMENT BOARD (KKRDB) IN 2021-22

KARNATAKA MONITORING AND EVALUATION AUTHORITY

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING, PROGRAMME MONITORING AND STATISTICS
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
MARCH 2024
EVALUATION OF WORKS CARRIED OUT BY
KALYANA KARNATAKA REGION
DEVELOPMENT BOARD (KKRDB) IN 2021-22

PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR
DR. BASWARAJ KUMNOOR

CENTRE FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT

BENGALURU

KALYANA KARNATAKA REGION DEVELOPMENT BOARD

GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA

KARNATAKA MONITORING AND EVALUATION AUTHORITY

DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING, PROGRAMME MONITORING AND STATISTICS
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
MARCH 2024
©Karnataka Monitoring and EvaluationAuthority, 2024

Published For:

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

#542, 5thFloor, 2nd Gate
M.S. Building, Dr. Ambedkar Veedhi
Bengaluru– 560 001

Published By:

Centre for Sustainable Development

#381, 2nd Floor, 100 ft. Road
H.A.L 2nd Stage
Indiranagar
Bengaluru - 560038

Typeset & Printed by

S.P.C Enterprises.
#36, N S Ayyangar Road,
Seshadripuram,
Bengaluru – 560 020.
srislm666@gmail.com
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We would like to express our sincere thanks to Dr. Shalini Rajneesh, IAS, Additional Chief
Secretary, Planning, Programme Monitoring and Statistics Department, Government of
Karnataka for her guidance and support. We also would like to thank Karnataka Monitoring
and Evaluation Authority (KMEA), Planning, Programme Monitoring and Statistics
Department, Government of Karnataka for providing an opportunity to conduct this
evaluation study. Specifically, we would like to thank Smt. Sushama Godbole, IAS,
Chief Evaluation Officer, Sri. Brijesh Kumar Dikshit, Ex-Chief Evaluation Officer,
KMEA, Dr. Syeda Fathima, Additional Chief Evaluation Officer, KMEA, Sri. T
Shashidhar, Administrative Officer, KMEA and Dr Manjunatha A V, Director
(Evaluation), KMEA, Smt. Savitha Dayanand, Associate Director, KMEA for their
constant guidance, support, timely suggestions and excellent inputs in formulating and
preparing this study. We also would like to thank the Officers and Staff of Karnataka
Monitoring & Evaluation Authority for their cooperation and Support.

We would like to thank Shri Anirudh Sravan Pulipaka IAS, Secretary, Kalyan Karnataka
Regional Development Board (KKRDB), Smt.Praveena Priya David, Additional Director,
KKRDB, Smt.Sujata.S.Kalagi, Deputy Director, KKRDB, Sri.Hanamanth.S Assistant
Director, KKRDB, Executive Engineer and Asssitant Executive Engineer of all six
Districts (Kalaburagi, Bidar, Yadgir, Raichur, Ballary, Koppal), KKRDB for their
enthusiastic and unstinted support and timely information.

We also would like to thank the Administrative, Technical, and Planning officers at both
the Taluk and District Levels, as well as the Beneficiaries from all districts, for their
outstanding support, encouragement, and timely provision of information during the
preparation of the study.

A special mention must be made of the Executive Engineer and Assistant Executive
Engineer from Agency of all the six districts in the state where the evaluation study was
conducted who were kind enough to encourage and provide exceptional support to our
survey team.

Finally, we would like to thank Dr A Ravindra, IAS (Retd), Former Chief Secretary,
Government of Karnataka and Chairman, Centre for Sustainable Development (CSD),
Principal Investigator, Engineering Team, Survey Team, Research Analysts and Internal
Auditors of CSD who worked on this assignment meticulously and completed the study.

[Dr R Srinivas PhD]

Executive Director
Centre for Sustainable Development
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Executive Summary ................................................................................................... 01

1. Inroduction ............................................................................................................. 13
1.1. Organizational Review ..................................................................................... 15
1.2. Key objective of the KKRDB .......................................................................... 15
1.3. KKRDB Mission .............................................................................................. 16
1.4. Physical and Financial Performance of KKRDB ............................................. 16

2. Theory of change ................................................................................................... 19

3. Evaluation Scope, purpose & Objectives ............................................................ 21

3.1. Scope ................................................................................................................ 21
3.2. Purpose ............................................................................................................. 21
3.3. Objectives ......................................................................................................... 22

4. Evaluation Framework ......................................................................................... 23

4.1. Approach .......................................................................................................... 23

5. Literature Review .................................................................................................. 27

6. Evaluation Methodology ....................................................................................... 29

6.1 Data collection and field visits .......................................................................... 29
6.2 Data analysis ...................................................................................................... 29

7. Results and Discussion .......................................................................................... 33

7.1. In-depth interviews (IDI) ................................................................................. 33
7.2. State level officers ............................................................................................ 33
7.3. District level officers ........................................................................................ 34
7.4. Taluk level officers........................................................................................... 36
7.5. Field data on FGDs .......................................................................................... 39
7.6. Objective 1: Findings ....................................................................................... 42
7.7. Objective 2: Findings ....................................................................................... 43
7.8. Objective 3: Findings ....................................................................................... 74
7.9. Objective 4: Findings ....................................................................................... 79
7.10.Objective 5: Findings....................................................................................... 87

8. Case Study ............................................................................................................ 107

8.1. Case study 1: Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree
college located adjacent to Ashraya colony and Kallura thanda in Afzalpur taluk,
Kalaburagi district. ........................................................................................ 109
8.2. Case study 2: Construction of staff quarters for Group C and D (Total 5 quarters of
2 BHK capacity) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla village, Sedam taluk, Kalaburagi
District. …..…………………………………………………………………110
8.3. Case study 3: Development of tank/lake (continued) located at centre of
Lingsugur town, Raichur district.................................................................... 111

8.4 Case study 4: Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts from Kabbaragi,
Kushtagi taluk, Koppal district (From Forest Department) ….......................112

9. Findings and Recommendations ..................................................................... 1123

9.1. Key findings ................................................................................................... 114
9.2. Key Recommendations .................................................................................. 140

10. Lab Report: Quality Check Report ................................................................... 145

11. Field Photographs .............................................................................................. 1767

Reference ..................................................................................................................... 181

Annexure -1: Questionnaires of the Study............................................................. 1823

Annexure -2: CSD ECO Team.............................................................................. 18297

LIST OF TABLES
Table No. Title Page No.
District wise Physical and Financial Progress report of the Kalyana
1. 17
Karnataka Region for 2021-22 (Rs. In Lakh)
2. Theory of change 19
3. Evaluation matrix 24
4. Primary data collection levels and stakeholders 30
5. List of state level officers interviewed 33
6. List of District level officers interviewed 35
7. List of taluk level officers interviewed 36
FGD groups and their composition (Focus Group Discussion (FGDs)
8. 39
– Total 6)
9. Main Sector 41
Sector-wise number of projects distributed in all the 6 districts in
10. 42
KKRDB Region (in %)
11. Status of work in KKRDB Region in (in %) 42
12. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Bidar district 45
13. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Kalaburagi district 51
14. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Yadgir district 56
15. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Bellary district 62
16. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Koppal district 65
17. Status of work and date of visit of project site in Raichur district 69
18. Status of allocation and expenditure of works in all the six districts 75
19. Quality and purpose of the works of Bidar districts 80
20. Quality and purpose of the works of Kalaburagi districts 81
21. Quality and purpose of the works of Yadgir districts 82
22. Quality and purpose of the works of Bellary districts 83
23. Quality and purpose of the works of Koppal districts 85
24. Quality and purpose of the works of Raichur districts 86
25. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Bidar district 88
26. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Kalaburagi district 91
27. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Yadgir district 95
28. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Bellary district 98
29. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Koppal district 102
30. Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Raichur district 105
31. Quality of work and stakeholder’s opinions for all 60 projects 116
32. Sector-wise findings and recommendations (Health) 123
33. Sector-wise findings and recommendations (Education) 125
34. Sector wise findings and recommendations (Infrastructure) 1231
35. Sector wise finding and recommendations (Agriculture/Irrigation) 134
Sector wise finding and recommendations (Social infrastructure/
36. 136
drinking water/Sports/Others)

LIST OF FIGURES
Fig.No. Title Page No.
1. Location of Kalyana Karnataka Region, Karnataka 14
2. Organization structure of KKRDB 15
3. Physical and Financial progress of KK Region (in %) 17
4. District-wise physical progress in the KK region in 2021-22 18
5. District-wise financial progress in the KK region in 2021-22 18
6. Main Sector 42
LIST OF PHOTOS
Sl. No. Title Page No.
1. Work site inspection at Bidar district 47-50
2. Work site inspection at Kalaburagi district 54-55
3. Work site inspection at Yadgir district 58-60
4. Work site inspection at Bellary district 63-64
5. Work site inspection at Koppal district 67-68
6. Work site inspection at Raichur district 71-73
Improvement of Kamshetty Talab tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of
7. 90
Bidar District
Creation of additional manifold and upgradation of 72 bedded ICU
8. wards at BRIMS Bidar. Out of 72 beds they are using 50. 22 beds 90
were kept in store
9. Tata technologies lab at Kalaburagi 93
10. Open gym at guest house in Kalaburagi 93
Infrastructure facility created at the ITI collage in Chincholi Taluk
11. 93
Kalaburagi District
Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara Ambigara Chowdaiah
12. 93
Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi
13. Indoor stadium at Yadgir 97
14. Walking path at Yadgir 97
15. Providing of Oxygen Cylinder Jumbo at Yadgiri 97
Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of Karanigi village,
16. 97
Yadgir
Construction of 2 class rooms and compound for Vivekananda
17. 100
Government High School, Ranipet, Hospet
Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean drinking water unit
18. and smart class for Government High School, Regulator Camp, 100
Kampli
Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts from Kabbaragi,
19. 104
Kushtagi taluk (From Forest Department)
Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Sirur village,
20. 104
Yalburga MLA Constituency
Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD camp
21. (Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur taluka 107
of Raichur Dist.
22. Construction of Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village, Mavi Taluk 107
Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree college
23. 110
located in Afzalpur taluk, Kalaburagi district
Development of tank located at centre of Lingsugur town, Raichur
24. 111
district
Trees planting along Kabbaragi – Kapilatheertha road, Kushtagi taluk,
25. 112
Koppal district
Development of public park in Basavakalyana Ward no 24 Mahadevi
26. 177
Colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath Colony
Construction of Check Dam for the Kamalavathi River and CC Road
27. construction in the Kadcharla village and Lake Development at 177
Madana village in Kalaburagi
Construction of bridge cum barrage across Mullamari rivers between
28. Kanakpur to Garmpalli village in Chincholi taluka of Kalaburagi 178
district
Drinking water facility unit (OHT & PIPELINE) at the Vadthaya
29. 178
Thandya Kalaburagi
Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for boys/girls and post-matric and
pre-matric boys/girls hostels of District Backward Classes and
30. 179
Minorities and Social Welfare Department Model Residential School
(Navodaya), Yadgir
Construction (pending) activities of indoor stadium of Shahapur town,
31. 179
Yadgir
LIST OF ACRONYMS

AEE Assistant Executive Engineer

BEO Block Education Officer
CCDI Comprehensive Composite Development Index
CDI Comprehensive Deprivation Index
DDPI Deputy Director of Public Instruction
FGDs Focus Group Discussion
IDI In-depth Interview
GIS Geographic Information System
KMEA Karnataka Monitoring & Evaluation Authority
KKRDB Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board
KKR Kalyana Karnataka Region
KRIDL Karnataka Rural Infrastructure Development Limited
REESI Relevance, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Sustainability, Impact
PWD Public Works Department
PFP Physical and Financial Performance
SCP Special Component Plan
TSP Tribal Sub Plan
Executive Summary

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Background

Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB), functioning under Planning,

KKRDB is implementing the development works through various departments/agencies like

Public Works Department (PWD), Irrigation Department, Department of Health, KRIDL and
so on. The works of the Board being implemented by the Board, they can be categorized into
social sector and non-social sectors. The progress of these works is being reviewed and
monitored both at the district level as well as at the Board level.

Key objective of KKRDB

• Accelerate the holistic development of the most backward region of the state
represented by 41 Assembly constituencies.
• To achieve a balanced regional development on par with the developed districts of the
state.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 1

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Evaluation objectives

The objectives of the evaluation study are as follows:

1. To assess the number of works carried out by KKRDB across various sectors such as
health, education, agriculture, irrigation, roads and bridges, water supply, sanitation
etc., in 2021-22.
2. To examine the present status of work, completed and in progress.
3. To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sectors and
beneficiary groups.
4. To check the quality of works.
5. To examine the immediate impact of the works undertaken during 2021-22 in terms
of benefit to the people and region.
6. To provide suggestions for better allocation of funds in future action plans as well.

Evaluation methodology

The study is evidence driven, based on a rigorous evaluation design and standards. The
overall approach towards execution of the study consists of four steps– 1. Study materials
preparation, 2. Data collection with field visits, 3. Data analysis using applicable statistical
tools, and 4. Evaluation of schemes and programmes. Study materials preparation stage: It
included literature review, organizational review, physical and financial review, theory of
change, evaluation matrix, developing questionnaire, checklist and conducting pilot studies.

Field visits were made, beneficiaries were interviewed, conducted physical checks and
observations, held in-depth interviews with officials, conducted focused group discussion
with beneficiaries, case study analysis, and collected secondary data on physical and financial
progress. Data analysis: Analyzed socio-economic data, beneficiary data, economic

2 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Executive Summary

valuation, social valuation, strength and weaknesses, trends and challenges. Based on the
objectives of the study we have applied the below mentioned statistical analysis/tools by
using statistical software packages, like “Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) and
MS Excel”. Generally, we have used ratio, Cost Benefit Analysis, t-test has used to find out
the significant level of the quality of work, work stage, facility utilization, fund allocation,
expenditure and other related statistics methods (Mean, Percentage, Ratio, etc.,). Regression
and correlation tests were not conducted due to lack of data. The questionnaire provided by
KMEA was not supporting to analyze both regression and correlation. Evaluation of schemes
and programmers: Evaluated the works or schemes implemented by KKRDB, developed
socio-economic index, REESI framework and also developed recommendations.

IDIs are conducted with KKRDB officials which includes state (2 persons), district (6
persons) and taluk level officers (12 persons) across six districts and headquarters. Officers
are covered from education, health, irrigation, tourism, PWD, social welfare, irrigation and so
on. In addition, conducted 6 FGDs and documented 4 best practices in the Kalyana
Karnataka Region.

Results and discussion

KKRDB planned to implement 2,241 works with an allocation of Rs. 1,47,332 lakhs in the
year 2021-22 in six districts viz Bellary, Bidar, Kalaburagi, Koppal, Raichur and Yadgir.
According to data available on the KKRDB website, so far it has completed 1,178 (52.57 %)
works with a total expenditure of Rs. 93,068 lakhs (63.17 %) of the total allocation. Among
six districts highest works are carried out in Koppal (69.10 %) followed by Bidar (62.36 %)
due to more number of micro projects and constant monitoring by the respective departments.
Low performance had been observed in Kalaburagi (33.07 %) because of more number of
macro projects which are taking time to complete. In terms of financial expenditure Yadgir
ranks first (66.13%) followed by Bellary (64.98 %) because of good cooperation among other
line departments. The least expenditures are recorded in Kalaburagi and Raichur districts due
to less physical performance.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 3

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

frequent rain/flood, and financial releases from the department are major reasons for
incomplete projects. Not started projects are observed to be higher in Bellary (31 projects)
and Kalaburagi (31 projects) districts due to delay in administrative processes.

Analysis of 60 samples/projects (10 projects each from 6 districts) provided by the

KMEA/KKRDB shows that 62 percent of the projects are completed and 38 percent are
under progress in the KKRDB. Most of the projects completed belong to micro type.
According to the field survey, macro projects are taking longer time than estimated due to
frequent rain, shortage of labour, technicians, Unavailability of construction materials and
delays by contractors due to their health issues and financial constraints. It is noticed that
there are 73.33 % micro and 23.33 % macro level projects in Kalyana Karnataka Region
(KKR). Among them, 55 % are under social sector and 45 % are non-social sector. Further,
73.3 % projects are categorized as General, 20% SCP and 6.7% TSP.

Key findings
• Majority of the macro level projects have better access, appropriate size and aesthetic
appeal as compared to micro projects.

• Social infrastructure sector is having 97.3 % access, appropriate size and aesthetic
appeal and 83.8 % in drainage facilities. Access is defined as easy to approach the
project site.

• In the social sector all the facilities (access, drainage, hygiene, appropriate size and
aesthetic appeal) appear to be good and appropriate as compared to the non-social
sector projects. Most of the social category projects belong to education and health
where cleanliness is assured. Non-social sector projects include irrigation, drinking
water and roads, where drainage and hygiene are less maintained. It shows less
performance in drainage facilities (66.7%) as compared to other facilities in KKR
because sewage water is entering into tanks, action has to be taken to prevent this,
adequate attention has not given to the issue of sewage water entering into the tanks
and pollution, no proper drainage facilities are provided at roads and bridges. Overall,
Raichur performs better because most of them are social sector projects where quality
is maintained and Bidar ranks low due to a greater number of tanks and bridges where
cleanliness is given less importance.

• Non-social sector projects are being utilized more (59.3%) as compared to social

4 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Executive Summary

sector projects because non-social sector projects like irrigation, water supply, tank
development, park development and construction of roads & bridges benefit large
number of people/beneficiaries. Further, it is noticed that majority of SCP and TSP
are built at interior locations while general projects are built at exterior areas which
are more accessible to people like city and town center, bridges connecting between
two major towns/villages, classroom built for colleges, providing drinking water to
villages and construction of primary health centres at towns and village.

• Satisfaction levels for the particular projects are higher in the agriculture sector due to
the water availability in the tanks for most of the years and the developments of the
tank have led to enhanced water level.

• Agriculture sector shows 100.0 % in appropriate size, aesthetic appeal, access and
80.0 % in hygiene. Because of some places discharging sewage water into tanks.

• Stakeholders are happier with agriculture sector (100.0%) works because they are
getting 2 crops in the place of 1 crop per year and also water availability in the tanks
for longer period in the year. Due to development of tanks, water level in the nearby
borewells is getting enhanced up to 50 %. Before the tank development the depth of
borewell was 450-500 ft at present getting water at 200-300 ft.

• Social sector projects comes under education (such as classroom construction,

computer provision, compound construction for schools, hostels etc,) heath (such as
construction of primary health centres, drilling of borewell to PHCs, staff quarters
construction, providing oxygen cylinders and additional beds etc.), and sports (such as
construction of indoor and outdoor stadiums, walking path etc.,) have attracted
stakeholders’ interest more than non-social projects like construction of road, bridge
and pipeline related works.

• Stakeholders expressed good opinions on the projects completed under TSP such as
Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Sirur village, Yalburga MLA
Constiuency, Providing high-mask, raising school compound, levelling field, toilets
and other equipment to Government Model Higher Primary School, Hanumanala and
Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of Karanigi village.

• Lab test of construction materials such as plastics, wood, cement, iron etc., shows
good quality, and these materials are meeting the required standards (refer lab
reports).

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 5

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

• Stakeholders expressed that public awareness is required about the progress of

KKRDB projects which are implementing under various schemes in both urban and
rural areas.

Key Recommendations

The purpose of this study is to assess the progress of the schemes under the KKRDB for the
year 2021-22. Totally, 2216 schemes were sanctioned for all the six districts in the region
under five sectors- Health, Education, Agriculture/Irrigation, Infrastructure and Social which
included drinking water facilities, sports and tourism. Also included micro infrastructure
projects like construction of class rooms and laboratories for schools. Delays are noticed in
the execution of infrastructure works such as roads, bridges and other physical works.
Overall, we observed varied responses such as good, not good, satisfied, not satisfied, poor
and work yet to start (please refer the results and discussion section or Table 31). They
however want certain additional facilities and some specific action to be taken w.r.t each
work among 60 sample projects. Taking into account the feedback from the local people and
our own observations, the following recommendations are made for KKRDB to take actions
in the future if necessary.

Objective -I: To assess the number of works carried out by KKRDB across various
sectors such as health, education, agriculture, irrigation, roads and bridges, water
supply, sanitation etc., in 2021-22.

Recommendations

1. Based on the findings and observation from the projects, Construction of new class
room for Government High School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur MLA
constituency and Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for Government Pre-University
College, Maski Town, it is suggested to take up the projects related to construction of
additional classrooms in government school and colleges coming up in all the 6
districts because it will be beneficial to the students.

2. According to findings from a project, Supply of computers to Government High

School, Elubenchi village Bellary district, new action plans should consider
increasing the lab facilities with adequate computers in relevant Govt. High Schools
located in KKR.

6 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Executive Summary

3. Based on the findings from the project, Providing TATA Technologies Lab and
Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region, Kalaburagi, it is necessary to
take up an awareness programme for women so that they can make use of such a good
facility. Initially this project was designed for women only, due to less enrollment
numbers, presently provision to take the training has been made to men as well.

4. According to findings from the project, Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre-
University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga MLA Constiuency, Koppal, it is
suggested to provide funds to repaint the buildings of the college and also supply
water for the toilets constructed within the college premises.

5. Based on the analysis of the projects that belong to the education sector, it is
suggested to establish Special Education Zones in Yadgir and Raichur districts with
model schools and infrastructure to provide quality education focusing on establishing
Science, Technology, Engineering & Math (STEM) labs. The present programme of
IT infrastructure to be oriented towards establishing STEM labs as per National
Education Policy 2020.

6. Analysis of the projects belong to health sector such as providing Regular ambulance
in Bellary and Construction (pending) of Santapura community health centre in Aurad
taluk, Bidar, shows 24/7 ambulance facilities are required to all the PHCs located in
the KKR to facilitate patients in rural areas to be taken to hospitals whenever there is
an emergency.

7. According to the analysis of the project, providing Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) in

Yadgir, it is suggested to provide funds for other logistics like trolleys, space for
storage and operators/staffs. In addition, allot funds for operation and maintenance.

8. Under Irrigation sector, based on the observation from the project, Kamshetty Talab
tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District and Development of tank/lake located at
centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4) farmers complain about the entry of
municipal/sewage water into tanks, adequate attention has not been given to the issue
of sewage water entering into the tanks and polluting. Action has to be taken to
prevent the flow of sewage water into the tanks.

9. Based on the analysis of the project Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi
Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk Yadgir, it
is suggested to take action to increase the number of rooms and construct the public

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 7

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

toilets and drinking water facilities at the tourist places which facilitates tourists and
promotes local tourism.

Objective -II: To examine the present status of work, completed and in progress.

Recommendations

1. With respect to Sports, construction of indoor stadiums is taken up. Unfortunately,

2. Based on the observations of under progress projects such as Construction of Barrage

cum Bridge across Mullamari rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli village in
Chincholi Taluka, Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD camp
(Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur taluka of Raichur,
Development of tank/lake located at centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4) etc., it is
recommended that a proper supervision and monitoring mechanism be put in place.
Senior officers must regularly monitor the progress under various schemes and take
corrective action to complete the work as early as possible.

Objective -III: To check the quality of works

Recommendations

The lab test conducted for the projects by the Centre for Sustainable Development at the
project sites such as Construction (pending) of Santapura community health centre in Aurad
taluk Bidar, Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara Hiremath
Sansthana, Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk Yadgir, etc., were found to be satisfactory in the
quality of materials used for constructions.

8 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Executive Summary

Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16th Ward, Hagaribommanahalli Town, Bellary
were found to be unsatisfactory in terms of the quality during our visit to the field. It was
observed that they were using low standard materials for construction. Therefore, it is
suggested to give more attention for monitoring by the competent authority.

Objective - IV: To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sectors
and beneficiary groups.

Recommendations

2. It is suggested to construct an additional kitchen along with dining hall for the Mid
Day meal (Bisioota) facilities in Government High School, Kambattalli,
Harappanahalli.

3. It is suggested to create more awareness programme for women candidates about job-
oriented training programmes available freely or with limited fees.

4. Based on the findings from the project, Supply of computers to Government High
School, Elubenchi village, Bellary, computers distributed to schools are not meeting
the students’ requirements, therefore it is suggested to increase the number of
computers to the Government Schools and Colleges in the Kalyana Karnataka Region.

5. Social infrastructure projects will strengthen the networking of Farmer Producer

Organizations and Self-Help Groups for promoting agro processing, and other
economic activities. Therefore, it is suggested to give at least 20-30% more
importance to such type of projects in the future when developing a new action plan,
it will certainly help the women beneficiaries.

6. A major lacuna of most of the projects of KKRDB is the absence of adequate funds

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 9

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

for operation and maintenance (O&M). Unless these facilities are not created in the
projects, their utilization is adversely affected. Hence it may be ensured that necessary
provision is to be made in the budget to enable an efficient use of O&M system.

Objectives -V: To provide suggestions for better allocation of funds in future action
plans as well.

Recommendations

1. Analysis of all the 60 projects shows that, micro level social category projects are
performing better in education, health, social infrastructure, drinking water, and other
sectors (refer key findings section for the list of projects). Moreover, these projects
are meeting the demands of local communities in the region. Therefore, it is
recommended to increase at least 25-35 % or more such micro level projects in the
future action plans in all the 6 districts that fall under Kalyana Karmataka Region.

Objective- VI: To examine the immediate impact of the works undertaken during 2021-
22 in terms of benefit to the people and region.

Recommendations

1. Drinking water facility provided through pipelines and overhead tanks to villages
located in Bidar, Kalaburagi and Raichur shown positive impacts among local
communities especially women members. Therefore, it is recommended to increase
30-40% more such projects in all the districts where there is a need for drinking water.

2. Construction of walking foot path in Yadgir and Providing and fixing open gym
Equipment and construct open yoga Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi Guest House in
Kalaburagi city. Open gym at guest house, Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara
Ambigara Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi, Park development at Ward no
24 Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk, Bidar,
Construction of walking path near indoor stadium in Shahapur town, Yadgir etc., are
bringing the happiness among the users particularly the senior citizens. They are
finding positive impacts in terms of health, recreation, social tie-ups etc., from the
projects. Therefore, it is recommended to increase at least 20-25 % of such projects in
the cities and towns in Kalyana Karnataka Region.

10 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Executive Summary

3. The present study suggests to take up a larger study on all the projects implemented
since several years by KKRDB to assess the impacts, quality and longevity.

4. It is suggested to update the details of all the projects of KKRDB which are
completed and ongoing on ‘Project Portfolio Management System Software’. In
addition, update the details of approximate cost, Tender details, work statt time,
completion, pending details etc in ‘work soft’ software from time to time.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 11

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

12 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Introduction

1. Introduction

Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) belongs to the Planning,

Programme Monitoring & Statistics Department, Government of Karnataka. It was created in
2013 by making amendment to the Constitution of India, Article 371(J). Earlier it was known
as Hyderabad Karnataka Region Development Board, later in 2019 it has been renamed as
KKRDB. The KKRDB region covers 6 districts, namely Kalaburagi, Bidar, Raichur, Koppal,
Yadgir and Ballari having 41 assembly constituencies. The objective of the KKRDB is to
accelerate the development of the most backward region of the state and to achieve a
balanced regional development on par with the developed districts of the state. This was
preceded by following the recommendations of the High-Power Committee on Re-dressal of
Regional Imbalances under the aegis of Dr. D.M. Nanjundappa, also known as Nanjunadappa
Committee, constituted by Government of Karnataka to study the problems of regional
imbalances in the state. The committee based on the 35 socio-economic indicators which are
spread across five sectors such as agriculture, industry, economic infrastructure, social
infrastructure, financial and technical infrastructure. Among 32 taluks in Kalyana Karnataka
region, 22 talukas are categorized as most backward, 5 talukas as more backward and 2
talukas as backward, 3 talukas are forward taluks. The Committee developed a
Comprehensive Composite Development Index (CCDI) as a benchmark with appropriate
weights from the state's average development of 35 indicators to classify taluks as backward
and most backward taluks in the state. This CCDI highlights the need for promoting
development in this Kalyana-Karnataka Region. The Committee also made several
recommendations towards the development of social and economic infrastructure and on the
institutional framework to expedite the implementation of the developmental process in this
region.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 13

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Figure 1: Location of Kalyana Karnataka Region, Karnataka

KKRDB formed an implementation committee consisting of the Chairman, Secretary of the

Board, Deputy Commissioner/CEOs of Zilla Panchayaths, Administrator of Command Area
Development Authority and Deputy Commissioners of the six districts to assist in preparing
action plans for all-round development of socio-economic infrastructure across all taluks of
Kalyana Karnataka Region (Fig. 1).

14 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Introduction

Figure 2: Organization structure of KKRDB

Source: https://www.hkrdb.kar.nic.in/EN_Structure.html accessed on 18.12.2022

1.1. Organizational Review

KKRDB is implementing the developments works through various departments/agencies like
Public Works Department (PWD), Irrigation Department, Department of Health, KRIDL and
so on. The works of the Board being implemented by the Board, they can be categorized into
social sector and non-social sectors. The progress of these works is being reviewed and
monitored both at the district level as well as at the Board level. The administrative office is
located in Kalaburagi.

1.2. Key objective of the KKRDB

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 15

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

The KKRDB developmental works considers the following 5 sectors broadly for
improvement.
1. Agriculture
2. Industry
3. Economic infrastructure
4. Social infrastructure
5. Financial and technical infrastructure
The above-mentioned sectors cover both micro and macro projects implemented by KKRDB
through various agencies.

1.3. KKRDB Mission

The mission of the KKRDB is to achieve rapid inclusive growth and balanced regional
development with social justice for the six districts that come under Kalyana Karnataka
Region. The vision is to achieve this through Macro and Micro level planning by filling the
historical developmental gaps in such a way that the centres of growth and the peripheries
develop in tandems and in an interdependent manner. The KKRDB has adopted the Taluka as
a unit, taking guidance from Dr. Nanjundappa’s Report on Redressal of regional imbalance.
Funds for Micro Projects (60%) are allocated proportionate to the CDI (Comprehensive
Deprivation Index) for that Taluka and must be spent on critical Infrastructure and
institutional gaps. For Macro Projects (40%) funds are allocated sector wise by the Board, to
fill gaps in Macro sectors identified according to scale or scope or a combination of the two.

1.4. Physical and Financial Performance of KKRDB

16 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Introduction

Table 1 : District wise Physical and Financial Progress report of the Kalyana
Karnataka Region for 2021-22 (Rs. In Lakh)
District Physical progress Financial progress
Total Completed Under Not Allocation Expenditure
Works Progress Started
No. % No. % No. % In Lakhs In Lakhs %
Bellary 434 227 52.30 176 40.55 31 7.14 25546.79 16600.33 64.98
Bidar 356 222 62.36 130 36.52 4 1.12 19859.38 11266.8 56.73
Kalaburagi 499 165 33.07 303 60.72 31 6.21 45341.8 21584.45 47.60
Koppal 288 199 69.10 87 30.21 2 0.69 15876.02 10293.53 64.84
Raichur 332 168 50.60 157 47.29 7 2.11 23432.51 11785.89 50.30
Yadgir 321 195 60.75 124 38.63 2 0.62 15491.05 10244.74 66.13
KK Region 11 2 18.18 3 27.27 6 54.55 1784.928 1129.2 63.26
Total KK 2241 1178 52.57 980 43.73 83 3.70 147332.5 93067.71 63.17
Source: https://hykasoft.in/public/pdashboard.aspx Accessed 18.12.2022

Among six districts highest works are carried out in Koppal (69.10 %) followed by Bidar
(62.36 %). The lowest performance had been seen in Kalaburagi (33.07 %). In terms of
financial expenditure Yadgir ranks first (66.13%) followed by Bellary (64.98 %). The least
expenditures are recorded in Kalaburagi and Raichur districts. The key physical and financial
data is presented in Table 1 & Fig.3.

Figure 3: Physical and Financial progress of KK Region (in %)

Source: https://hykasoft.in/public/pdashboard.aspx Accessed 18.12.2022

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 17

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Figure 4: District-wise physical progress in the KK region in 2021-22

Source: https://hykasoft.in/public/pdashboard.aspx Accessed 18.12.2022

Among 819 completed works in the KK Region Yadgir ranks first with 21% and Kalaburagi
place at last with 12 % achievements (Figure 4).

Figure 5: District-wise financial progress in the KK region in 2021-22

https://hykasoft.in/public/pdashboard.aspx Accessed 18.12.2022

Financial progress is seen to be the highest in Bellary and Yadgir districts with 19% each
respectively followed by Koppal district with 18 %. Less financial progress is seen in
Kalaburagi and Raichur districts with 14% each respectively (Figure 5).

18 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Theory of Change

2. THEORY OF CHANGE
Based on the preliminary field visit and site checking on a pilot basis, the hypothesis was made. The following theory of change has been developed
based on the components of the works assigned for evaluation. The outputs are measurable, while outcomes may be perceivable in the medium -
long term after work implementation. The impacts are indicative and can be perceived only in the long term.

Table 2 : Theory of change

Inputs Sub type Outputs Outcomes Impact
• Project Education • Constructed class • Improved • Literacy level improved
management, rooms and toilets enrollment/admission • More participation of women
supervision, • Provided computers especially by girls/women • Enhanced competitive nature
quality control and other accessories • Students’ digital knowledge among students
• Established library and developed • Developed confidence on job
• Organizational furniture • Many students attempted to security and self-employment
• Management • Constructed clear competitive exams • Improves attendance and
hostels/guest houses • Helped students who are student-teacher interactions
• Technology • Training centres travelling far distances
• Increase self-employment
• Human Resource Health • ICU infrastructure • Save patients life • Improvement in health quality
strengthened • Improvement in health • Less expenditure on access
• More beds in the treatment • Easily accessible
hospital • Staff are accessible timely • Avoid travelling long
• Staff quarters • Patients feel confident during distances
constructed emergencies • Reduces child mortality ratio
• Oxygen cylinders are • Reduces spread of
provided communicable disease

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 19

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Irrigation • Tanks are rejuvenated • Water level improved in • Agriculture dependency

• Check dams are tanks increased
constructed • Provide irrigation to second • Reduced out migration
• Tanks beds are raised crop • Food security
• Fencing provided to • Farmers livelihood improved • Improvement in household
tanks • Ground water around tank is income
improved
Infrastructure • Roads are upgraded • Communication made easy • Increase in number of
• Bridges are built • Increase in business activities business/economic activities
• Buildings are • Faster access to health and (hotel, lodges, taxi services
constructed market facility etc)
• Parks are developed • Education system improved • Rural-urban network
strengthened
• Increase in traders’ network
• Increase official-people
interactions
Drinking • Borewells are drilled • Timely supply of water • Long life
water supply • Overhead tank • Hygiene/quality • Saves time
constructed • Avoid travelling long • Socio-cultural system
• Community tap system distances strengthened
established • Health system improved • Women feel safe and happy
• Access to quality water • Expenditure on health
reduced

20 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Evaluation Scope, Purpose & Objectives

3. EVALUATION SCOPE, PURPOSE & OBJECTIVES

3.1. Scope

The study covers all the six districts which belong to KKRDB of Karnataka namely Raichur,
Yadgir and Bidar, Ballary, Kalaburgi and Koppal. This study will pave the way for taking up
similar and larger studies covering larger sample with multiple sectors. Results and estimates
of this study will also give scientific evidence for the department to plan development
activities further and to develop the action plan and development plan for the region. The
important output expected is to have the methodology and tools to understand the impact of
various projects implemented across different sectors. The scope is also limited to understand
the Impact of limited sample interventions made by KMEA for selected sectors. The scope of
the work covers interviewing beneficiaries and also state, district and taluk level officers in
the state for the financial year 2021-22.

3.2. Purpose

The KKRDB receives funds from various schemes of government mainly for developmental
activities. Therefore, it is necessary to assess the quality, effectiveness and timeliness of the
developmental works to implement them strategically and also guide the board to improve on
selection of works and their importance to the society and environment. The major purpose
is:

• Quantitative Assessment of impact of the projects in terms of number of beneficiaries

of the project, number of jobs created, current usage of the infrastructure created viz.
the envisaged usage, improvement of service levels of water supply, sanitation,
improvement in access to education, health care, human capital, skill etc.
• Qualitative Assessment in terms of improvement in livelihood, quality of living and
social status

The inputs and insights developed out of this evaluation exercise will help to improve
efficiency, competitiveness, livelihood creation, resource conservation, education and
infrastructures also provide suggestions to develop action plan in future.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 21

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

3.3. Objectives

The objectives of the evaluation study are as follows

1. To assess the number of the works carried out by KKRDB across various sectors such
as health, education, agriculture, irrigation, roads and bridges, water supply, sanitation
etc., in 2021-22.
2. To examine the present status of work, completed and in progress.
3. To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sectors and
beneficiary groups.
4. To check the quality of works.
5. To examine the immediate impact of the works undertaken during 2021-22 in terms
of benefits to the people and region.
6. To provide suggestions for better allocation of funds in future action plans as well.

22 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Evaluation Framework

4. EVALUATION FRAMEWORK

4.1 Approach

The study followed the quasi-experimental design, it is an empirical interventional study used
to estimate the causal impact of an intervention on target population without random
assignment. In addition to this approach, the ‘before and after’ approach will be adopted. The
data pertained to before will be obtained from beneficiary or by assessing the physical
infrastructure. Also, beneficiary will be asked to recall his earlier knowledge as compared to
present knowledge i.e after implementation of the schemes and programmes. All the selected
stakeholders are considered for survey, IDI and observations.

A detailed evaluation matrix was developed based on the scheme objectives and evaluation
questions for the study and was approved by KMEA.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 23

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 3 : Evaluation matrix

Key Specific sub Data collection
Evaluation Indicators / success Analytical Method /
Evaluation questions for each Data sources methods / Analytical
criteria standards/ KPI Analysis method
Question Key Question tools

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)

Relevance
Need of Organizational Need for special Functioning of the KKRBD/State Browsing Descriptive analysis
KKRDB for structure and representation Board Department/Repre websites/documents/
regional Strength Coverage sentative Visiting offices
development Financial Amount of financial KKRDB/State Browsing Descriptive
and balance allocations allocation and budget websites/documents/ analysis/Ranking methods
with the rest of distribution across document/Represe Visiting offices
the state sectors ntative
Utilisation rate.
Allocations across Allocations to Action Plan Browsing Descriptive
the developmental Priority works like documents/Repres websites/documents/ analysis/Ranking methods/t-
works health, education entative Visiting offices test
and infrastructure
Effectiveness
Achievement of Execution and Quality and Beneficiary interest Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Qualitative and
targets, driving Monitoring of quantity of work and success rate /Beneficiary Interacting with Descriptive
factors and target works carried out beneficiary/observations Analysis/t-test
mitigating /FGDs/IDIs
challenges Timely Societal change Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Qualitative and
implementation /Beneficiary/ Interacting with Descriptive
Public interactions beneficiary/observations Analysis
/FGDs/IDIs

24 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Evaluation Framework

Efficiency
Cost benefit Physical and Total allocations Assets created Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
analysis financial Total expenditure /Budget analysis/Descriptive
allocations documents analysis
and Number of benefits Economic/social/ Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative analysis/t-test
achievement in terms of output environmental /Beneficiary/ Interacting with
benefits Public interactions beneficiary/observations
/FGDs/IDIs
Fund utilization Developing Creation of Number of Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
and capacity infrastructure facilities and infrastructures and /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
building opportunities beneficiaries Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation/Signifi
interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs cance test
vation
Knowledge Social and Social upliftment Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
co-creation educational change and knowledge /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
development Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation/Signifi
interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs cance test/Ranking method
vation
Output Physical Buildings, roads, No. of Development Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
produced achievements parks, constructions works /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
in terms of No. of Schools, Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation/Signifi
works rooms, interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs/Developme cance test/Ranking method
completed Increase in road vation ntal indices/Report
across sectors length cards
Health facilities
equipment
Knowledge Digital Competitiveness Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
enhancement literacy/effective /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
communication/pro Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation/Signifi
blem solving skills interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs/Developme cance test
vation ntal indices/Report
cards

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 25

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Impact
Outcomes- Facilities Social works and Increase in No. of Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
immediate created other development facilities created /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
works across sectors Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation/Signifi
Increase in health interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs/Developme cance
status vation ntal indices/Report
Increase in mobility cards
Outcomes- Infrastructure Physical assets and Reduction in Agencies/KKRDB Visiting site and officer Quantitative
Short term and knowledge mortality /Beneficiary/ Interacting with analysis/Descriptive
knowledge elevation Increase in learning Public beneficiary/observations analysis/Correlation
created outcome interactions/Obser /FGDs/IDIs/Developme
Increase in vation ntal indices/Report
agriculture cards
production

Outcomes- Resource and More income Reduction in gaps Public Developmental Qualitative
Medium term facility opportunities/invest across the sectors interactions/Obser indices/Report cards analysis/descriptive
availability ments Development of vation/Ranking analysis/ranking methods
talukas/ villages matrix
Outcomes-- Resource and Inviting Regional Public Developmental Qualitative
Long Term Infrastructure opportunities/invest development interactions/Obser indices/Report cards analysis/descriptive
facility ments Human vation/Ranking analysis/ranking methods
availability development matrix
Sustainability
Sustainability of Increase in More Investment & Rate of savings Agencies/KKRDB Developmental Qualitative
the project in Income opportunities Investment /Beneficiary/ indices/Report analysis/descriptive
the long run Savings and Sustainable Public cards/Social analysis/ranking methods
Investments Environment interactions/ interactions/News
Observation coverage

26 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Literature Review

5. LITERATURE REVIEW

Impact of developmental activities on health, education, agriculture, livelihoods, economic,

social, cultural and infrastructure. The various reports and archives are studied for the
evaluation particularly to address the gaps and challenges. A study by Tilak J (2003) on
Public Expenditure on Education in India pointed out that the education is a long-term
investment that contributes to socio-economic development quite significantly, besides being
an end in itself in human development. No nation goes bankrupt by investing in education of
her people (Tilak J (2003). At the same time, findings from Rao, et,al found that the more
spending alone won’t result in greater performance, but more important is whether the money
is spent wisely and more funding for schools which do not provide an adequate education, but
a transformation of the system so that there is good governance all around to ensure better
quality and greater efficiency in schools (Rao 2008).

The government and other partners ensure that future investment in adolescent health
programming continues to be framed around lessons learnt across India. Similarly, the
objective of the p-median problem is to locate a given number of facilities so that the total
travel distance (or time) between facilities and demand points is minimised which will benefit
to the community.

Gireesha (2003) article mainly studies the issues and concerns of regional development in
Hyderabad Karnataka presently known as Kalyana Karnataka. His observations are based on
qualitative analysis. The study noticed the regional imbalance and assumes significant global
decentralization trend. Dr. D. M. Nanjundappa committee had recommended establishing an
appropriate institutional set-up to accelerate the process of development in different sectors of
Hyderabad Karnataka. The study suggested that the policy makers and other stakeholders of
the region are required to allocate adequate funds, and implement target-oriented
development schemes in the region in order to achieve the goal of inclusive development in
the new millennium.

The study by Venkataramana (2018) on return to education in India and issues relating to the
growth imperatives in the Hyderabad Karnataka region examines the role of education in
both industrial growth and economic development. The study found female education is of
special significance in addition to primary education. The study suggested that the transport
department has role in enrollment of boys and girls. The better transportation services will

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 27

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

help to the students to go schools and colleges.

The study by Ratnakar (2013), concentrated on demographic, political, fiscal, cultural and
attitudinal differences in various regions in India. Geographic imbalances include the non-use
of the available capital at the optimal stage. The study noted that many agitations took place
right from the days of state re-organization in 1956 to redress the inequality created by
different political party and governments. The study concluded that the movement of people
for regional success among the people of Hyderabad Karnataka has genuinely brought
happiness. The People's revolution has really reinforced the political system. Therefore, the
developmental activities in health, education and social infrastructure are essential for the
holistic growth of Kalyana Karnataka Region.

Kalyana Karnataka is gaining international recognition and strengthening in economic and

political areas. The resolution aims to establish an institutional mechanism to develop the
region and promote inclusive growth to reduce inter-region and inter-district disparity in the
State of Karnataka (Shinde, 2021).

Summary
All the studies mentioned above suggest to reduce the disparities among all the districts in
Karnataka. The Government should give emphasis to education and health sector when
allocating budget, it will improve the knowledge and lifestyle of the rural poor in Kalyana
Karnataka Region. Many studies found special interest should be given to female education
in addition to promoting primary & higher education. An effective institutional mechanisms
and infrastructure networking is necessary for all the 6 districts in KKR region. One of the
study suggested that the policy makers and other stakeholders of the region are required to
allocate adequate funds, and implement target-oriented development schemes (example micro
level projects) particularly in education, health, infrastructure, drinking water and sports in
the region in order to achieve the goal of inclusive development in the new millennium.

28 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Evalution Methodology

6. EVALUATION METHODOLOGY

6.1 Data collection and field visits:

Visiting site, interviewed beneficiaries, conducted physical checks and observations, held in-
depth interviews with officials, conducted focused group discussion with beneficiaries, case
study analysis, and collected secondary data on physical and financial progress.

6.2 Data analysis:

Analyzed socio-economic data, beneficiary data, economic valuation, social valuation,
strength and weaknesses, trends and challenges. Evaluation of schemes and programmers:
Evaluated the works or schemes implemented by KKRDB, developed socio-economic index,
REESI framework and also developed recommendations.

a. Approaches and methods

Data collection for the study is relying on a mixed-methods approach. It started with official
interviews and pilot survey which helped us build the effective questionnaire.

b. Physical checks and observation of KKRDB works

This involved physically visiting and observing the various works implemented by KKRDB
in 2021-22. Data collected through checklist and direct observation of works. Interacted with
stakeholders and beneficiaries. Taken the photos and videos of works carried out at sites.
Crosschecked the physical and financial achievements with secondary data obtained from the
KKRDB. Measured the length and width of some roads and bridges, counted the books and
furniture at library, desks at classroom, health equipment at hospital, checked comfort facility
at toilets, pipelines for drinking water, irrigation and also entertainment and recreation
facilities provided at various places.

c. Primary survey and analysis

The interviews were conducted immediately after visiting the sites and making observation of
the works. This helped to cross check responses of beneficiaries and implementers. Data

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 29

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

collected through using a detailed questionnaire. It includes socio-economic parameters,

health, education, infrastructure, irrigation, income, lifestyle changes, knowledge
development and so on.

Based on the objectives of the study we have applied the below mentioned statistical
analysis/tools by using statistical software packages, like “Statistical Package for Social
Science (SPSS) and MS Excel”. Generally, we have used ratio, Cost Benefit Analysis, t-test
has been used to find out the significant level of the quality of work, work stage, facility
utilization, fund allocation, expenditure and other related statistics methods (Mean,
Percentage, Ratio, etc.,). Regression and correlation tests were unable to conduct due to
nonsupport of data. The questionnaire provided by KMEA was not supporting to analyze
both regression and correlation.

d. In-depth interviews (IDIs)

IDIs are conducted with KKRDB officials which includes state, district and taluk level
officers across six districts and headquarters. Officers are covered from education, health,
irrigation, tourism, PWD, social welfare, irrigation and so on. The checklist is used to collect
the data from officers.

Table 4 : Primary data collection levels and stakeholders

Method of
Level Stakeholders Total no. Total Sample
Data Collection
Beneficiaries Case Studies 4 Best Case 4 Case studies
District studies
level
Beneficiary Beneficiaries, FGDs 6 FGDs (1 6 FGDs (60-70 people)
level FGDs from each
district)
State level Secretary and IDI 2 IDI 2 Top level officials will
Director of the be intervened
Board
District Administration and IDI 6 IDI 12 Administrative and
level Planning officers Planning officers for
for every district every district
Taluk Administrative, IDI 12 IDI Administrative,
Level Technical and Technical and Planning
Planning officers officers for every three
for every three Taluks from selected
Taluk from district
selected district
In total 2 Case studies, 6 FGDs and 20 IDI are carried out during the study.

30 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Evalution Methodology

e. Limitation of the Study

1. As per the ToR, the present study is focused on only one year (2021-22), therefore the
observation and results are limited to one year.

2. The timeline for evaluation was limited to 3 months

3. The present study limited to 60 samples only therefore it cannot be generalized to all
the years.

4. Since, the evaluation period is short (one year), we could not find adequate number of
beneficiaries in all the sectors to assess the impacts.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 31

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

32 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

7. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

The primary survey was conducted in the selected 6 districts viz. Bidar, Kalaburagi, Bellary,
Raichur, Koppal and Yadgir to evaluate the projects implemented by KKRDB. As per the
TOR given by the KMEA, the survey has been conducted for the period of November 2022
to February 2023. The findings and observations are summarized and presented in the
following sections.

7.1. In-depth interviews (IDI)

7.2. State level officers
As indicated in the methodology section, there were Two state level officers were selected
and interviewed at the headquarter of KKRDB, Kalaburagi. According to Joint Director, the
KKRDB initiatives were highly helpful for distributing ambulances for various hospitals in
KK region, particularly during the COVID-19, when the health issues were major concern.
KKRDB fund was well utilized for this purpose and also constructing CHC and PHC at
various places including upgrading existing hospitals in the region. This was appreciated by
the doctors and patients and currently, the work is progressing fast in the region.

According to Superintendent Engineer many minor irrigation work/projects are started by the
KKRDB which includes lakes, parks near lakes, tank-bund raising, canal development and so
on and so forth. These type of works/initiatives (irrigation) helping in many ways, to name a
few, irrigation for agriculture, providing drinking water facility for various communities, and
recharging borewells and so on. Moreover, citizens staying near the parks and tanks are
getting recreation benefits which helps to improve their health condition. Some tourism
activities at park enhancing the income of local vendors and also hygiene of the region.
Developing tanks/lakes helping to fishery production which improves local economy.

Table 5 : List of state level officers interviewed

Date of
Sl. Gender Sector
Place Name Designation intervie
No. (M/F)
w
1 Kalaburagi Shankrappa Joint Director Male 1-02-23 Health
Mailari
2 Kalaburagi Suresh L Superintendent Male 2-02-23 Irrigation
Sharma Engineer

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 33

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

7.3. District level officers

a) Bellary (Health)
As pointed out by the District In charge Minister and DHO, the regular ambulance belongs to
Macro project, and they have purchased 10 ambulances during COVID time. The service is
extended free for all the patients. KKRDB helping to increase the CHC and PHCs in district.
One of the most awaited Jayadeva Hospital is under construction in the district. According to
official, KKRDB initiatives are very much helpful for improvement of health facilities in the
district.

b) Bidar (Irrigation)
According to department official, the irrigation department is handling many projects under
government schemes, mostly they are minor irrigation projects and they are focusing largely
on lakes development. Treating drainage water and rain water harvesting comes under this
department. He also pointed out that, after fixing the fencing for the lakes, pollution is
avoided. Once everything is ready, they allow these tanks for fishery production and which
will benefit local people and local economy largely.

c) Kalaburagi (Education)
As per the official. Mr. Shekarappa Biradar, DDPI in Kalaburagi, ITI colleges are upgraded
by TATA Technologies, before these initiatives, the students were going outside the city to
get the training. This is a macro project, and it will be handled by district in charge minister.
In this project they have purchased reversible desks, 5 computers, 2 printers, 2 computer
tables for Chincholi kunchavara ITI college. In addition, 40 computers are purchased for
afzalpur kalluru tanda degree college, these two projects are coming under micro type and
comes under MLA in charge. The upgradation works are getting faster through KKRDB
funds. Before this, the students from afzalpur Kalluru degree college were going to Kalburgi
for Computer training, but now they are getting in Afzalpur itself.

d) Raichur (PWD)
Raichur PWD handling many KKRDB projects, they include mainly health, sports and
education projects, construction and development of school grounds, construction of class
rooms. They belong to both micro and macro projects. All these projects are executed
through tendering process and bidding. The work will be assigned through AEE and bills will
be submitted through EE to DC office. Most of the projects here are under construction
including the stadium in Manvi.

34 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

e) Koppal (PWD/KRIDL)
KRIDL handling 4 micro projects they are education (3 projects) and sports (1 project).
According to School requirement, some of the works designed are changed and same has
been observed in Hanumanal Government School. According to official, they also replaced
Solar light instead of High mask light, also constructed a room and smart class. Indoor
stadium is under construction in Hanumasagar and it will be highly helpful for sports persons.
All construction works are progressing under the supervision of AEE. All projects are
socially and economically helpful for local people, students and sports persons in the district.

f) Yadgiri (Tourism)
Tourism department constructing mostly Yatri Nivas, this will be helpful for devotees and
tourist. The local people may get benefits from tourism and fare & festivals organized
seasonally; this activity will also boost the local economy.

Table 6 : List of District level officers interviewed

Sl. Gender Date of
Place Name Designation Sector
No. (M/F) interview
1 Bellary Janardhan H L DHO Bellary Male 26-01-23 Health
Executive
2 Bidar Tukaram Male 01-02-23 Irrigation
Engineer
Kalabura Shekarappa
3 DDPI Male 01-02-23 Education
gi Biradar
Channabasappa Executive
4 Raichur Male 30-01-23 PWD
Mekale Engineer
Rajashekar Executive PWD
5 Koppala Male 27-01-23
Kadvihal Engineer KRIDL
Assistant
6 Yadgiri Shalum Hussain Male 31-01-23 Tourism
Director

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 35

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

7.4. Taluk level officers

Table 7 : List of taluk level officers interviewed
Sl. Gender Date of
Place Name Designation Category Summary
No. (M/F) interview
Officials aware about computers distribution to 2 schools, but they are not known
about specification about those computers. He had mentioned that, these initiatives
will help teachers and students in getting computer knowledge. Moreover, it will
1 Bellary Channabasappa BEO Male 25-01-23 Education
increase the enrolment in the schools up to 20%. The main beneficiaries of this
projects are students He had expressed that BEO administration has limitation and
most of it decided by DDPI office.
1. The Officials are aware about this project.
2. Road width is 7 meter and thickness of the road is 3.5 inch.
3. The work order will be given to contractor and they will buy and use the
materials as per the standard and as work order.
Sudarshan PWD Road
2 Kudligi AEE Male 25-01-23 4. At every stage they will inspect the work.
Reddy Connectivity
5. These projects are very helpful, due to providing jobs to local people.
6. The black top road has been made which is connecting to Geddalagatte and
Katrahalli Villagers. This road is directly connecting to Bellary and Kudligi .
7. The major beneficiaries are students, farmers, drivers, patients and many more.
1. Before this project, people were throwing garbage and wastages to this lake, now
it is clean, so people are happy.
2.Currentlly fencing work is under progress which will help to prevent the damages
of the property.
3. Before developing this lake, the depth of the water level in the borewell was 400
3 Humnabad Shyamsundar AEE Male 01-02-23 Irrigation
to 500 ft now people are getting at 250 ft. This has helped the farmers to get a more
number of crops per year
4. The direct beneficiaries of this project are morning and evening walkers, sports
persons etc.
5.They have plan for fish farming in the lake to increase the local revenue.
1. The relevant official have the knowledge on this project and it comes under the
Water
4 Basavakalyana Shivakumar AEE Male 01-02-23 MICRO type.
supply
2. While rejuvenating the tank, they are fixing the water regulator, which will help

36 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

to store more water in the tank. This will help farmers to get 2 crops per years
instead of one crop.
3. In addition, this work is helping to livestock for water, ground water recharge,
recreation and many other purposes. While executing the work, they used the
locally available man power to provide the short-term employment.
1. The officials are aware about these projects and their involvement is partial.
2. They are inspecting each work at every stage.
3. This project purchased 30 reversible desks, 5 computers, 2 printers and 2
computer tables for Kunchavaram ITI college in Chincholi taluk.
5 Chincholi Anand AEE Male 31-01-23 PWD
4. Government is given emphasis to provide education and bring forward the local
people. Presently, it is working well, students are getting better education. All
instruments are given and are in working condition. Due to these facilities students
are happy and attending the classes regularly
1. They are inspecting in every stage of work also checking the quality of the
material.
2. This work is for construction of staff quarters for Group C and D staff.
6 Sedam Rakesh Kumar AMO Male 31-01-23 Health
3. Officials have mentioned that this will help the staff who are travelling from far
distances and getting less salary and also benefit the patients who visits PHC at
night.
1.Some of the projects were given to RWS Yalburga but they have transferred it to
others, Mallikarjun B Nayakwadi
2. Officials have not involved much in this project
Road
7 Yalaburga I S Hosur AEE Male 27-01-23 3. Providing drinking water facilities at schools and colleges benefit the teachers
Connectivity
and students for preparing mid-day meal and drinking
4. Students enrolments to schools and colleges will increase if water connection is
good
1. Some of the projects were given to PWD Kustagi and they were transferred to
Mr. Saeyed Sha Hasan Khadri
PWD/ 2. Officials have said their involvement is nothing, just assigned the work and
8 Kustagi Prabhu Naik AEE Male 27-01-23
PRED inspected
3. Subcontractors have involved much in the projects.
4. After constructing bridge across stream, crossing it is easier during rainy season.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 37

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

1. Infrastructure activities are given to Kendriya Vidyalaya School on temporary

basis in Adarsh school premises.
2. Kendriya vidyalaya is a main project in Sindhanur as education is concerned.
Sharanappa 30-01- 3. Students surrounding Kendriya Vidyalaya, Sindhanur are getting enrolling in the
9 Sindhanoor BEO Male Education
Vatagal 2022 school.
4. This project is economically strengthening the local people
5. At present school students don’t have ground to play and room to conduct any
program.
1. Some of the projects are given to subcontractor Mr. Amara Gundappa Meti.
2. Through KKRDB, the Lingasuguru lake getting improvement.
3. Improvement of lake has been enhanced the ground water level in the
10 Lingasaguru Vidyasagar AEE Male 30-01-23 Irrigation
surrounding areas
4. Moreover, lake improvement maintaining the hygiene in the surrounding areas
5. It is helping to improve the local tourism
Walking path about 800 m is constructed surrounding stadium. Tiles are used for
Assistant
11 Shahpur Raju Male 31-01-23 Sports construction of walking path. Nearly 200-300 people are using every day. Due to
Director
no traffic, senior citizen is coming here for walking, here they are feeling safe
Drilled borewell and supplying drinking water to village, no overhead tank facility,
supplying directly. Replaced the old water system with new one. Point collection
Basavaraj Water
12 Yadgiri AEE Male 31-01-23 facility is made, there are 6 points in the village. Everyday providing water at two
Ireddy Supply
times. Almost 800 households with a population of nearly 2500 people are getting
benefit. Largely women are happy by this service
Source: Field survey and observation.

38 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

7.5. Field data on FGDs

Table 8 : FGD groups and their composition (Focus Group Discussion (FGDs) – Total 6)
No. of people
Sl. participated Type of Category
Place Date Summary
No. (Male & participants
Female)
1 Regulator 30-01- 40 students, 4 Beneficiaries Education 1.In this school 2 rooms are constructed in which one is used for Smart Class. Students
Camp 2023 teachers (2 of this school are happy from this project.
Kampli, Men and 2. Another room is using for office purpose.
Bellary 2women). 3.The remaining students are sitting on the ground during classes.
4. Administration has observed increase in student’s enrollment.
5. Earlier students were going to Javuka Village for attending school and now they are
getting it here.
6. Parents are complaining that there is no high school here, after 7 th students have to go
long distances for attending the classes.
7. Students’ enrolment ratio getting increasing
8. Literacy level in the local area is increasing
9. Social awareness on education is raising
10. Girl students expressed their happiness for this project because they are getting
education in their village only
2 Kabbaragi, 27-01-23 2 villagers, Beneficiaries Agriculture 1. This project is coming under agriculture sector and implementing by PWD.
Koppala Contractors are villagers 2. From Kabbaragi to Kapila tirtha there is no proper road so this project is helping to
and forest and Tourist. improve road connectivity and also local developments.
officers. 3. Local economy and transactions are getting boost through this project.
4. The villagers are getting job after this project
5. Local people are demanding water connection to this tourist place

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 39

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

3 Navalkal, 31-01-23 Road user Road 1. This road connecting between Navalkal and Marat.
Raichur connectivity 2. Before this bridge construction, people were travelling from Shirvara road and it was
very difficult to communicate during rainy season.
3. Now the bridge is constructed and also widened the road.
4. People from Shiravara, Marat, Tuljaram Tanda are using this road to reach Hatti or
Raichur.
5. This road is highly useful for students and farmers.
6. Local business has been improved after this connectivity
4 Santhapura, 02-02-23 6 members in Beneficiaries Health 1. This project is useful for santhapura villagers.
Bidar that 4 male and are patients 2. Santhapura CHC is helping pregnant ladies and also new born babies during
2 female and emergency treatment and monthly check-ups. Before this, local people used to go to
private hospitals and Government hospital in BIDAR.
3. Medicine availability and treatments are good in this CHC
5 Garampalli, 02-02-23 4 Members 2 Beneficiaries Road 1. This is a Barrage project connecting between Kanakpur and Garampalli.
Kalaburagi Male and 2 of Road Connectivity 2. In this project, water regulators are fixed therefore there is an increase in groundwater
Female level in the surrounding areas
3. Surrounding fields are getting irrigation for crop production.
4. This water is using for drinking and domestic purpose as well.
5. Women’s and farmers are the major beneficiaries of this project
6 Shahapur, 31-01-23 6 members 6 Beneficiaries Sports 1. This project is useful for sport persons.
Yadgiri Male of Stadium 2. Daily walkers, youngsters, old age people, ladies and sports persons are getting
benefits
3. Before this, it was a kuccha and very difficult to use it during rainy season.
4. Sports persons and audiences have expressed the necessity of this project.

40 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) has done major works on social
infrastructure (61.7 per cent) followed by economic infrastructure and financial and technical
infrastructure (15.0 per cent each) in the Kalyana Karnataka region. It is observed that 70.0
per cent of the work has done to create social infrastructure in Bellary Koppala and Raichur
districts, it is highest work has done as compare to other districts in Kalyana Karnataka
region. Yadgiri and Bellary districts are zero or no work has done in agriculture sector and
also it is very least work has done in Kalyana Karnataka Region (Table 9 and Figure 6).

Table 9 : Main Sector

Kalyana
Main Sector Bidar Kalburagi Yadgiri Bellary Koppala Raichur Karnataka
Total
Agriculture 2 1 0 0 1 1 5
% 20.0 10.0 0.0 0.0 10.0 10.0 8.3
Economic
1 1 3 2 1 1 9
Infrastructure
% 10.0 10.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 10.0 15.0
Social
5 5 6 7 7 7 37
Infrastructure
% 50.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 70.0 70.0 61.7
Financial &
Technical 2 3 1 1 1 1 9
Infrastructure
% 20.0 30.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 10.0 15.0
Total 10 10 10 10 10 10 60
% 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
Source: Field survey. 2022-23.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 41

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Figure 6: Main Sector

Source: Field survey, 2022-23.

7.6. Objective 1: Findings

To assess the number of the works carried out by KKRDB across various sectors such
as health, education, agriculture, irrigation, roads and bridges, water supply, sanitation
etc., in 2021-22.

With respect to sectors wise distribution of projects concerned, the results show that, the
education (36.37%), Road & connectivity (13.33%) and health (11.67%) sectors has the
highest percentage of share covering/ distributed in all the selected sample districts.
Followed by, Water Supply (8.33%), Sports (6.67%), Irrigation (5%) and Agriculture and
Tourism 1.67 respectively. The below Table 10 gives the details of sector wise number of
projects distributed in all the 6 selected districts in KKRDB Region.

42 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 10 : Sector-wise number of projects distributed in all the 6 districts in KKRDB

Region (in %)
Road and Water
Agricultur Educatio Healt Irrigatio Sports Touris Other
Sub Type Connectivit Supply
e (%) n (%) h (%) n (%) (%) m (%) s (%)
y (%) (%)

Bellary NA 60 10 NA 20 NA NA NA 10
Bidar NA 30 20 10 10 10 NA NA 20
Kalaburagi NA 30 10 10 10 10 NA NA 30
Koppal 10 50 10 NA 10 NA 10 NA 10
Raichur NA 30 10 10 10 20 10 NA 10
Yadgir NA 20 10 NA 20 10 20 10 10
KK Region 1.67 36.67 11.67 5.00 13.33 8.33 6.67 1.67 15.00
Source: KKRDB 2022
Note: Since the overall data for KKRDB is not available, considered 60 samples provided by the KMEA for
categorization.

7.7. Objective 2: Findings

To examine the present status of work, completed and in progress

According to data provided by KMEA/KKRDB, four districts have completed 60% of the
projects (Bellary 60%, Kalaburagi 70%, Raichur and Yadgir 80% each) and rest of the two
districts (Koppal and Bidar 40% each) have completed 40% of the projects. Overall, more
than 61% of the projects are completed and 38 % are under progress KKR. The below Table
11 gives the details of district wise status of work in KKRDB region and respective
percentage. Table 11 : Status of work in KKRDB Region in (in %)

Districts Completed (%) Under Progress (%) Total

Bellary 60 40 100
Bidar 40 60 100
Kalaburagi 70 30 100
Koppal 40 60 100
Raichur 80 20 100
Yadgir 80 20 100
KK Region 61.7 38.3 100
Source: KKRDB 2022
Note: Since the overall data for KKRDB is not available, considered 60 samples provided by the KMEA for
categorization.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 43

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

The analysis shows that, three projects that are Construction (pending) of Santapura
community health centre in Aurad taluk, Improvement of Godavadi tank in Humnabad taluk
and Park development at Ward no 24 Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in
Basavakalyan taluk are under progress and rest of the projects (07) are completed in the
district. The some of the major reasons mentioned by the respondents are delay by contractor,
delaying of fund release, lack of availability of construction material etc., The below Table
12 gives the details of sector and type wise projects, stage & status of work, date of visit of
project site in Bidar district.

44 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 12 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Bidar district
Date of visit
Work stage as Work Status at the Project
of Project Project
Sl.No. Work Name Sector Type per data given by time of field visit completion
for starting date
KMEA/KKRDB (Dec 2022 -Jan 2023) date
investigation

1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab Education Macro Under Progress Physically Work 06.12.2022 04.06.2021 18.04.2022
and Workshop at Govt. ITI in completed
Kalyana Karnataka Region
2 Construction of Additional Two Education Micro Completed Physically Work 05.12.2022 24.01.2022 30.06.2022
Classrooms to Govt.High School at completed
Belur Village in Basavakalyan
Taluka.
3 Library and furniture facility to Pre Education Micro Completed Completed 07.12.2022 25-01-2022 18-07-2022
metric hostels at Humnabad town
4 Drilling borewell and providing Health Micro Completed Completed 06.12.2022 15.03.2022 31.03.2023
motor to Shedola, Chandanahally,
Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi (198 delay due
villages of Humnabad taluk to contractor)
5 Construction (pending) of Santapura Health Micro Under Progress First floor column 06.12.2022 04.11.2022 NA
community health centre in Aurad work under progress
taluk
6 Improvement of Godavari tank in Irrigation Micro Under Progress Under Progress 06.12.2022 15.03.2022 31.03.2023
Humnabad taluk ((198 delay due
to contractor)
7 Creation of additional manifold and Others Macro Under Progress Physically Completed 06.12.2022 16.06.2021 18.09.2021

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 45

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Upgradation of 72 beded ICU wards

at BRIMS Bidar.
8 Park development at Ward no 24 Others Micro Under Progress Work under progress 05.12.2022 04.05.2022 01.12.2022
Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18
Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan
taluk
9 Bridge construction on Aurad (S) Road & Macro Under Progress Physically completed 06.12.2022 10.04.2022 NA
village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli Cnnectivity
main road.
10 Imrpovement to Kamshetty Talab Water Micro Completed The work Physically 05.12.2022 NA NA
tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar Supply completed
District.

46 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Bridge construction on Aurad (S) village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli main road.

Construction (pending) of Santapura community health Construction of Additional Two Classrooms to Govt.
centre in Aurad taluk) High School at Belur Village in Basavakalyan Taluka

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 47

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Construction of Additional Two Classrooms to Govt.High School at Belur Village in Basavakalyan Taluka

Creation of additional manifold and Upgradation of 72 bedded ICU wards at BRIMS Bidar.

Drilling borewell and providing motor to Shedola, Improvement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund at
Chandanahally, Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District
villages of Humnabad taluk

48 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Improvement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District

Park development at Ward no 24 Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 49

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Providing TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region

Photos 1 : Work site inspection at Bidar district

When it comes to Kalaburagi district, the results show that construction of staff quarters for
Group C and D (2 BHK -05) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla, Sedam taluk, construction of
check dam cum CC Road on Kamalavati river, construction of check dam on local streams of
Kadacharla village and improvement of Madana village tank in Sedam taluk and construction
of barrage cum bridge across Mullamari rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli village in
Chincholi taluka are three works under progress. The rest of the projects are completed in
Kalaburagi district. Some of the major reasons mentioned by the respondents are delay in
handing over to site form health department to PWD, non-available of technicians, labour,
health issues of contractor are the some of the field issues mentioned by the respondents.
They are also considering to charge penalty at the time of the last bill for delaying. The below
Table 13 gives the details of sector and type wise projects, stage & status of work, along with
date of visit of project site in Kalaburagi district.

50 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 13 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Kalaburagi district
Work Status
at the time of
Work stage as Date of visit
field visit Project
Sl. per data given of Project Project completion
Work Name Sector Type (December starting
No. by for date
2022 - date
KMEA/KKRDB investigation
January
2023)
Providing TATA All 9 works
Technologies Lab and are completed
1 Education Macro Completed 05.12.2022 20.03.2021 09.11.2021
Workshop at Govt. ITI in & Handed
Kalyana Karnataka Region over
Providing 40 computers
and basic facilities to
Govt. Degree college
Work 17-03-
2 located adjacent to Education Micro Completed 07.12.2022 01-05-2022
Completed 2022
Ashraya colony and
Kalluratanda in Afzalpur
taluk
Purchasing 30 reversible
desks, 5 computers, 2
Work
printers and 2 computer
3 Education Micro Completed Physically 10.12.2022 14.06.2022 06.07.2022
tables for Kunchavaram
Completed
ITI college in Chincholi
taluk
Construction of staff Work not yet started
quarters for Group C and during visit, Delay
Work not yet
4 D (2 BHK -05) at Primary Health Micro Under Progress 11.12.2022 30.12.2022 due to handing over
started
Health Centre, Kodla, the site form Health
Sedam taluk. department to PWD

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 51

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Construction of check dam

cum CC Road on
Kamalavati river,
construction of check dam
Work under
5 on local streams of Irrigation Micro Under Progress 11.12.2022 13.06.2022 Work Under Progress
progress
Kadacharla village and
improvement of Madana
village tank in Sedam
taluk.
16 months’ delay.
Supplying erection, testing Balance work will be
and Commissioning of 2 attended and complete
TR AC’s with Copper by 31.08.2023. As
Tube & Refrigent gas, non-available of
Power Supply, Cable, Regional Technicians, labour,
6 Others Completed Completed 29.11.2022 30.12.2021
CPVC Drain Pipe and Fund health problem from
allied accessories to contractor side and
Hon’ble Judges Chambers proposal for penalty
No-1, 2 & 3 at High Court will be submitted
Bench Kalaburagi. shortly at the time of
final bill.
Providing and Fixing open
gym Equipments and
construct open yoga Regional Physically
7 Others Completed 13.12.2022 NA NA
Platform at Aiwan-E- Fund Completed
Shahi Guest House in
Kalaburagi city.
Construction (pending) of
Physically
Shivasharanara Ambigara
8 Others Macro Completed Completed 07.12.2022 19.03.2021 15.09.2021
Chowdaiah Memorial
final Bill Paid
Bhavan at Kalaburagi

52 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of Barrage
cum Bridge across
26.09.2022. Gate
Mullamari rivers between Road &
9 Macro Completed Not available 10.12.2022 10.01.2022 fitting was going on
Kanakpur-Garmpalli Cnnectivity
during visit
village in Chincholi
Taluka
Construction of OHT and
Water Physically
10 Pipeline at Vadatyatanda Micro Completed 10.12.2022 NA NA
Supply Completed
in Chincholi taluk

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 53

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Construction of check dam cum CC Road on Kamalavati river, construction of check dam on local streams of
Kadacharla village and improvement of Madana village tank in Sedam

54 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of OHT and Pipeline at Vadatyatanda in Chincholi taluk

Photos 2 : Work site inspection at Kalaburagi district

Yadgir district projects results show that, construction of walking path near indoor stadium in
Shahapur town and Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara
Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk are the two works under progress.
The rest 8 projects are completed in Yadigr district. The below Table 14 gives the details of
sector and type wise projects, stage & status of work, along with date of visit of project site in
Yadgir district.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 55

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 14 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Yadgir district
Work Status at
Work stage as per the time of field Date of visit of Project
Project starting
Sl . No. Work Name Sector Type data given by visit (December Project for completion
date
KMEA/KKRDB 2022 -January investigation date
2023)

Provision of additional 4 class rooms

1 and also construction of toilets to Govt. Education Micro Completed Completed 08.12.22 10-01-2022 02-12-2022
Women First Grade College, Yadgir
Construction of compound for
2 Chincholi Govt High School, Surpur Education Micro Completed Completed 17.12.22 10-01-2022 06-06-2022
taluk
3 Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) Health Macro Completed Work completed 08.12.22 21-05-2021 09-07-2021
Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for
boys/girls and post-matric and pre-
Completed but
matric boys/girls hostels of District
4 Others Macro Completed not using it 08.12.22 27-12-2021 24-03-2022
Backward Classes and Minorities and
now.
Social Welfare Department Model
Residential School (Navodaya).
Construction of box culvert on Road &
5 Micro Completed Completed 09.12.22 25-04-2022 02-06-2022
Anapura Marg of Karanigi village Connectivity

Bridge construction for the road

heading to scheduled caste field from Road &
6 Micro Completed Completed 08.12.22 10-01-2022 20-07-2022
Basavanna temple of Belagera village Connectivity
through village tank

Construction (pending) activities of Work physically

7 Sports Micro Completed 09.12.22 NA NA
indoor stadium of Shahapur town completed.

Side Kerb/Path
completed and
Construction of walking path near
8 Sports Micro Under Progress Cobbal Stone 09.12.22 NA NA
indoor stadium in Shahapur town
work under
progress

56 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of Tourist Guest house

near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara Earth work
9 Tourism Micro Under Progress 17.12.22 NA NA
Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura under progress.
Village, Shorapur taluk.
Giving drinking water supply to Work
10 Water Supply Micro Completed 17.12.22 NA NA
Vandganur village of Shorapur taluk Completed

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 57

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana,
Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk

Bridge construction on Aurad (S) village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli main road

Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of Karanigi village

58 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of walking path near indoor stadium in Shahapur town

Giving drinking water supply to Vandganur Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo)

village of Shorapur taluk

Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo)

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 59

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Provision of additional 4 class rooms and also construction of toilets to Govt. Women First
Grade College, Yadgir

Construction of compound for Chincholi Govt High School, Surpur taluk

Photos 3 : Work site inspection at Yadgir district

60 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Out of the 10 projects in Bellary district four projects are under progress those are,
Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean drinking water unit and smart class for
Government High School, Regulator Camp, Kampli, Construction of new classroom for
Government High School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur MLA constituency,
Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & Bund Work at District Stadium, Bellary and Construction
of bridge for the stream near Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote town. The remaining 6 projects
are completed in Bellary district. The below Table 15 gives the details of sector and type wise
projects, stage & status of work, along with date of visit of project site in Bellary district.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 61

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 15 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Bellary district
Work Status at
Work stage as per the time of field Date of visit Project
Sl. Project
Work Name Sector Type data given by visit (December of Project for starting
No. completion date
KMEA/KKRDB 2022 -January investigation date
2023)
1 Construction of 2 class rooms and compound Education Micro Completed Work completed 07-02-2023 14.03.2022 Actual Date
for Vivekananda Government High School, & Final Bill to be 13.05.2022
Ranipet, Hospet submitted to DC Completed Date
Office 13.09.2022
2 Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean Education Micro Under Progress Column work 30-01-2023 08.05.2022 03.10.2022
drinking water unit and smart class for under progress
Government High School, Regulator Camp,
Kampli
3 Construction of new class room for Education Micro Under Progress Plasting work 09-01-2023 10-02-2022 06-07-2022
Government High School, Kambattalli, going on
Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur MLA
constituency
4 Supply of computers to Government High Education Micro Completed Completed 25-01-2023 26-10-2021 29-10-2021
School, Elubenchi village
5 Supply of sports equipment to Government Education Micro Completed Completed 06-01-2023 28-10-2021 13-06-2022
High School, Thimmalapura village
6 Construction of toilets for both boys and girls Education Micro Completed Work Execution 09-01-2023 06-01-2022 01-06-2022
at Government High School, KVOR Colony, Completed
16th Ward, Hagaribommanahalli Town
7 Regular Ambulance Health Macro Completed Physically work 26-01-2023 NA NA
completed
8 Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & Bund Work Others Macro Under Progress Fencing work & 26-01-2023 01-04-2022 28-03-2023
at District Stadium, Bellary Bund work under
progress
9 Construction of bridge for the stream near Road & Micro Under Progress Old Bridge 25-01-2023 21.05.2022 20.10.2022
Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote town Connectivity Dismantling work
under progress
10 Road development from Katrahalli cross to Road & Micro Completed Work completed 09-01-2023 30-01-2022 27-07-2022
Geddalagatte Connectivity

62 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of new class room for Government High School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur
MLA constituency

Supply of computers to Government High School, Elubenchi village

Construction of toilets for both boys and girls at Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16 th Ward,
Hagaribommanahalli Town.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 63

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & Bund Work at District Stadium, Bellary

Construction of bridge for the stream near Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote town.

Road development from Katrahalli cross to Geddalagatte

Photos 4 : Work site inspection at Bellary district

The primary data analysis show that, the projects implemented by the KKRDB in Koppal
except two (Health and sports one each), all the remaining projects are completed in the
district and same has been given in Table 16 below. The major reason for delay is as the soil
condition is weak (Black Soil) also during rainy season they could not take up the work. The
below Table 16 gives the details on name of the projects, sector and type wise projects, stage
& status of work, along with date of visit of project site in Koppal district.

64 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 16 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Koppal district
Work Status at
the time of Date of visit
Work stage as per Project
field visit of Project Project
Sl. No. Work Name Sector Type data given by starting
(December for completion date
KMEA/KKRDB date
2022 -January investigation
2023)
1 Sapling of trees along the Agriculture Micro Completed Physically work 27-01-2023 NA NA
Kapilateertha Road, starts completed.
from Kabbaragi, Kushtagi
taluk (From Forest
Department)
2 Floor tiles fixing work at Education Micro Completed Physically 28-01-2023 03.12.2021 11.03.2022
Government Pre- Completed
University College,
Balutagi Village,
Yalburga MLA
Constiuency
3 Providing clean drinking Education Micro Completed Completed 28-01-2023 20.11.2021 24.01.2022
water unit to High
School, Sirur village,
Yalburga MLA
Constiuency
4 Construction of Education Micro Completed Work 30-01-2023 25.12.2021 04.05.2022
Anganavadi in Ward 33 Completed
(Ward 29), Gangawati
Town, Gangawati MLA
Constiuency

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 65

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

5 Providing high mask, Education Micro Completed Work 27-01-2023 15.11.2021 25.05.2022
raising school compound, completed
levelling field, toilets and
other equipment to
Government Model
Higher Primary School,
Hanumanala

6 Tata Technologies Lab Education Macro Completed Completed 27-01-2023 NA NA

and Workshops at
Government Industrial
Training Institute located
at Kalyana Karnataka
Region
7 Construction of Proposed Health Macro Under Progress Not available 27-01-2023 NA NA. Beds will
300 Bedded SJICR be supplied after
Hospital at Kalaburagi. constriction
works completes
8 Fitting wiring coat to hard Others Micro Completed Physically work 27-01-2023 28.02.2022 22.04.2022
passage at Kidadura completed.
village
9 Construction of road from Road & Micro Completed Physically work 28-01-2023 12.02.2022 11.08.2022
State Highway 130 Cnnectivity completed.
(Kudarikotagi) to PG
Centre and also fixing
street lights from
Yalburga to PG Centre,
Yalburga taluk
10 Construction of Indoor Sports Micro Under Progress Roof work 27-01-2023 03.01.2022 NA (As the soil
Stadium at Hanumasagara completed condition at is
weak (BC Soil)
also during rainy
season couldn’t
process the
work)

66 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre-University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga MLA Constituency

Construction of Anganavadi in Ward 33 (Ward 29), Gangawati Town, Gangawati MLA Constituency

Providing himask, raising school compound, levelling field, toilets and others equipment to Government
Model Higher Primary School, Hanumanala

Tata Technologies Lab and Workshops at Government Industrial Training Institute located at Kalyana
Karnataka Region

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 67

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Fitting wiring coat to hard passage at Kidadura village.

Construction of road from State Highway 130 (Kudarikotagi) to PG Centre and also fixing street lights from
Yalburga to PG Centre, Yalburga taluk

Construction of Indoor Stadium at Hanamasagara

Photos 5 : Work site inspection at Koppal district
The primary data analysis of Raichur district shows that, 5 projects are under progress, and
those are, construction of Stadium for Government High School, Balaganoora town, Maski
MLA Constituency, construction of Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village, Manavi Taluk,
development of tank/lake is located at centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4), construction of
Stadium in Manvi town (continued) and drinking water pipeline works from Hattigudda to
Vagaranala village, Maski MLA Constituency. Some of the reasons for delay are due to delay
in material supply and labour issue from the contractor, delay in issuing order and fund
release by the KKRDB. The below Table 17 gives the details on names of the projects, sector
and type wise projects, stage & status of work, along with date of visit of project site in
Raichur district.

68 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 17 : Status of work and date of visit of project site in Raichur district
Work Status at
Date of visit
Work stage as per the time of field Project
of Project Project completion
Sl. No. Work Name Sector Type data given by visit (December starting
for date
KMEA/KKRDB 2022 -January date
investigation
2023)
Providing Infrastructure to Govt
Adarsh School in PWD camp
Work Physically
1 (Proposed Temporary Govt Education Macro Completed 30-01-2023 24.03.2022 23.05.2022
Completed
Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur
taluka of Raichur Dist.
Construction of Stadium for
Government High School,
2 Education Micro Completed Not available 31-01-2023 10.10.2022 20.01.2023
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA
Constituency
Construction of 2 Laboratory
Work Physically
3 rooms for Government Pre- Education Micro Completed 31-01-2023 NA NA
Completed.
University College, Maski Town
NA (Due to delay
Construction of Veterinary Roof laid, curing
in material supply
4 Hospital at Byagavata village, Health Micro Under Progress Work Under 31-01-2023 02.01.2022
and labour
Manavi Taluk Progress
shortage)
Compound wall
work completed;
Development of tank/lake is pathway
5 located at centre of Lingsugur Irrigation Micro Under Progress protection wall 31-01-2023 08.04.2022 Jul-23
town (Part -4) completed. C.C.
drain under
progress.
Estimate for Shifting of 33KV
Single Circuit Line from
6 110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss Others Macro Completed Completed 30-01-2023 13.04.2022 28.05.2022
to Kurkunda 33/11kV Muss near
Eluragi village Sy No.7 for

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 69

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

construction of Proposed Govt

Kendriya Vidyalaya near Eluragi
village, Sindhanur.
Construction of bridge between
Road & Physically
7 Navalakal and Maratha, Manvi Micro Completed 31-01-2023 25.04.2022 10.07.2022
Cnnectivity Completed
taluk
NA (Rs44.03 lakh
bill uploaded on
13.03.2023
Construction of Stadium in Manvi Work Under
8 Sports Micro Under Progress 31-01-2023 22.10.2022 pending in
town (continued) Progress
KKRDB due to
cube test report
submitted)
10.01.2023 ((144
days delay due to
Drinking water pipeline works Contractor and 113
Water Pipe line work
9 from Hattigudda to Vagaranala Micro Under Progress 31-01-2023 01.01.2022 days delay due to
Supply completed
village, Maski MLA Constituency department delay
Total 257 days
delay)
10.11.2022 ( (140
days delay due to
Construction of clean drinking Contractor and 78
Water Roof level of RO
10 water unit at Kortakunda village, Micro Under Progress 01-02-2023 01.01.2023 days delay due to
Supply plant building
Raichur taluk department delay
Total 218 days
delay)

70 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Development of tank/lake (continued) located at centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4)

Construction of bridge between Navalakal and Maratha, Manvi taluk.

Construction of Stadium for Government High School, Balaganoora town, Maski MLA Constituency

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 71

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for Government Pre-University College, Maski Town

Estimate for Shifting of 33KV Single Circuit Line from 110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss to Kurkunda
33/11kV Muss near Eluragi village Sy No.7 for construction of Proposed Govt Kendriya Vidyalaya near
Eluragi village, Sindhanur

Construction of Stadium in Manvi town (continued)

Drinking water pipeline works from Hattigudda to Vagaranala village, Maski MLA Constituency

72 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Construction of clean drinking water unit at Kortakunda village, Raichur taluk.

Photos 6 : Work site inspection at Raichur district

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 73

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

7.8. Objective 3: Findings

To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sectors and beneficiary
groups
To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sector and districts, the study
undertaken and asked suitable question to the implementers, users and relevant stakeholders
to find out the impact of the projects with respect to need and adequacy of allocation. The
following Table 18 provides district and project wise details of allocation of the funds, ADM
amount v/s work order amount and percentage of work order amount, and expenditure v/s
percentage of expenditure/utilisation. To take an example, the Bidar district primary results
show that, out of the 10 projects, there are only three projects utilized more than 80
percentage of their allocated fund in the district and those projects are providing TATA
Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region (80%), creation
of additional manifold and Upgradation of 72 beded ICU wards at BRIMS Bidar (80%), and
Improvement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District (97.95%).
The rest of the projects are utilized their project funds less than 60 % of their allocated fund
for the same, which show the lack fund utilization of the project funds for better
implementation of the projects. For instance, the projects like drilling borewell and providing
motor to Shedola, Chandanahally, Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi villages of
Humnabad taluk, Bridge construction on Aurad (S) village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli
main road were utilized only 27.15 % and 38 % respectively. The details of need and
adequacy of allocation for all selected districts are given in the following Table 18.

74 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 18 : Status of allocation and expenditure of works in all the six districts
Percentage of
ADM Work Percentage
Expenditure/
Allocation Amount Order of Work Expenditure
Sl.No. Work Name Utilisation in
in Lakhs in Amount Order In Lakhs
Allocation of
Lakhs in Lakhs Amount
Fund
Bidar
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt.
145.65 145.65 145.65 100 116.52 80
ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region
2 Construction of Additional Two Classrooms to Govt.High
30 30 28.41 94.7 16.598 55.33
School at Belur Village in Basavakalyan Taluka.
3 Library and furniture facility to Pre metric hostels at
35 27.5 21.72 62.06 21.614 61.75
Humnabad town
4 Drilling borewell and providing motor to Shedola,
Chandanahally, Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi 15 13 6.55 43.67 4.073 27.15
villages of Humnabad taluk
5 Construction (pending) of Santapura community health
46 46 46 100 NA NA
centre in Aurad taluk
6 Improvement of Godavari tank in Humnabad taluk 104.99 104.99 102.148 97.29 58.517 55.74
7 Creation of additional manifold and Upgradation of 72
12.05 12.05 12.05 100 9.64 80
beded ICU wards at BRIMS Bidar.
8 Park development at Ward no 24 Mahadevi colony and
18 18 15.184 84.36 NA NA
Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk
9 Bridge construction on Aurad (S) village road from Bidar-
10 9.5 9.5 95 3.8 38
Munnakhelli main road.
10 Imrpovement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund at Hulsoor
50 50 49.304 98.61 48.976 97.95
taluka of Bidar District.
Kalaburagi
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt.
1042.44 1042.44 986.13 94.6 788.904 75.68
ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region
2 Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree
college located adjacent to Ashraya colony and 74.93 74.9 74.9 99.96 48.685 64.97
Kalluratanda in Afzalpur taluk
3 Purchasing 30 reversible desks, 5 computers, 2 printers and 6 6 5.07 84.5 NA NA

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 75

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

2 computer tables for Kunchavaram ITI college in

Chincholi taluk
4 Construction of staff quarters for Group C and D (2 BHK -
140 140 137.79 98.42 NA NA
05) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla, Sedam taluk.
5 Construction of check dam cum CC Road on Kamalavati
river, construction of check dam on local streams of
160 158.6 158.24 98.9 NA NA
Kadacharla village and improvement of Madana village
tank in Sedam taluk.
6 Supplying erection, testing and Commissioning of 2 TR
AC’s with Copper Tube & Refrigent gas, Power Supply,
Cable, CPVC Drain Pipe and allied accessories to Hon’ble 5 5 4.955 99.1 NA NA
Judges Chambers No-1, 2 & 3 at High Court Bench
Kalaburagi.
7 Providing and Fixing open gym Equipments and construct
open yoga Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi Guest House in 28.5 28.5 28.382 99.59 28.263 99.17
Kalaburagi city.
8 Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara Ambigara
100 100 97.41 97.41 96.83 96.83
Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi
9 Construction of Barrage cum Bridge across Mullamari
rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli village in Chincholi 500 500 494.8 98.96 434.453 86.89
Taluka
10 Construction of OHT and Pipeline at Vadatyatanda in
25 25 24.5 98 19.144 76.58
Chincholi taluk
Yadgir
1 Provision of additional 4 class rooms and also construction
75 75 75 100 60 80
of toilets to Govt. Women First Grade College, Yadgir
2 Construction of compound for Chincholi Govt High
25 25 25 100 20 80
School, Surpur taluk
3 Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) 35.61 35.61 25 70.2 24.096 67.67
4 Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for boys/girls and post-
matric and pre-matric boys/girls hostels of District
Backward Classes and Minorities and Social Welfare 183.67 183.67 183.67 100 181.833 99
Department Model Residential School (Navodaya).

76 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

5 Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of Karanigi

10 10 10 100 9.9 99
village
6 Bridge construction for the road heading to scheduled caste
field from Basavanna temple of Belagera village through 17.53 17.53 17.53 100 14.024 80
village tank
7 Construction (pending) activities of indoor stadium of
60 60 59.16 98.6 59.16 98.6
Shahapur town
8 Construction of walking path near indoor stadium in
75 75 59.6 79.47 NA NA
Shahapur town
9 Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi
Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village, 100 100 98.54 98.54 NA NA
Shorapur taluk.
10 Giving drinking water supply to Vandganur village of
15 15 12.23 81.53 12.225 81.5
Shorapur taluk
Bellary
1 Construction of 2 class rooms and compound for
23.69 23.69 19.35 81.68 NA NA
Vivekananda Government High School, Ranipet, Hospet
2 Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean drinking
water unit and smart class for Government High School, 9.27 9.27 6.87 74.11 3.262 35.18
Regulator Camp, Kampli
3 Construction of new class room for Government High
School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur MLA 10.6 10.6 10.056 94.87 7.114 67.11
constituency
4 Supply of computers to Government High School,
1.2 1.2 1.2 100 0.954 79.5
Elubenchi village
5 Supply of sports equipment to Government High School,
3.12 3.12 3.12 100 2.496 80
Thimmalapura village
6 Construction of toilets for both boys and girls at
Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16th Ward, 10 10 8.5 85 NA NA
Hagaribommanahalli Town
7 Regular Ambulance 141.1 131.075 131.075 92.9 131.075 92.9
8 Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & Bund Work at District
Stadium, Bellary 153.25 153.25 153.25 100 61.3 40

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 77

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9 Construction of bridge for the stream near Kalamma

60 60 59.377 98.96 NA NA
temple, Tekkalakote town
10 Road development from Katrahalli cross to Geddalagatte 100 100 96.415 96.42 48.034 48.03
Koppal
1 Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts from
23 15.431 15.431 67.09 15.431 67.09
Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk (From Forest Department)
2 Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre-University
10 10 10 100 9.9 99
College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga MLA Constiuency
3 Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Sirur
3.62 3.62 3.62 100 2.855 78.86
village, Yalburga MLA Constiuency
4 Construction of Anganavadi in Ward 33 (Ward 29),
13.56 13.56 13.56 100 13.424 99
Gangawati Town, Gangawati MLA Constiuency
5 Providing high mask, raising school compound, levelling
field, toilets and other equipment to Government Model 16.07 16.07 16.07 100 12.856 80
Higher Primary School, Hanumanala
6 Tata Technologies Lab and Workshops at Government
Industrial Training Institute located at Kalyana Karnataka 172.37 172.37 172.37 100 137.896 80
Region
7 Construction of Proposed 300 Bedded SJICR Hospital at
200.9 200.9 180 89.6 180 89.6
Kalaburagi.
8 Fitting wiring coat to hard passage at Kidadura village 50 50 36.59 73.18 36.046 72.09
9 Construction of road from State Highway 130
(Kudarikotagi) to PG Centre and also fixing street lights 170 170 166.55 97.97 166.37 97.86
from Yalburga to PG Centre, Yalburga taluk
10 Construction of Indoor Stadium at Hanumasagara 100 100 100 100 80 80
Raichur
1 Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD
camp (Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of 32.75 32.75 25.577 78.1 20.213 61.72
Sindhanur taluka of Raichur Dist.
2 Construction of Stadium for Government High School,
16 16 16 100 6.4 40
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA Constituency
3 Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for Government Pre-
University College, Maski Town 32 32 26.675 83.36 18.659 58.31

78 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

4 Construction of Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village,

30 30 27.825 92.75 14.898 49.66
Manavi Taluk
5 Development of tank/lake is located at centre of Lingsugur
100 100 99.92 99.92 61.666 61.67
town (Part -4)
6 Estimate for Shifting of 33KV Single Circuit Line from
110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss to Kurkunda 33/11kV
Muss near Eluragi village Sy No.7 for construction of 5.53 4.93 4.93 89.15 4.93 89.15
Proposed Govt Kendriya Vidyalaya near Eluragi village,
Sindhanur.
7 Construction of bridge between Navalakal and Maratha,
20 20 16.08 80.4 12.419 62.1
Manvi taluk
8 Construction of Stadium in Manvi town (continued) 100 100 97.915 97.92 NA NA
9 Drinking water pipeline works from Hattigudda to
19.74 19.74 19.74 100 14.217 72.02
Vagaranala village, Maski MLA Constituency
10 Construction of clean drinking water unit at Kortakunda
10 10 10 100 2.626 26.26
village, Raichur taluk

7.9. Objective 4: Findings

To check the quality of works
Quality of the projects in terms of access of the project, it is defined as easy to approach the project site, drainage facility, hygiene, size and
aesthetic appeal are concern, the beneficiaries are expressed their opinions based on use and observation. The responses are very different and
varies project to project. For instance, the access of the project for all the given projects in the Bidar district show that, majority of the
implemented projects are having good access (except two projects Table 19). Similarly, when it comes to drainage facility, hygiene, size,
aesthetic appeal, facility utilisation and project under use documented a combine response from the various stakeholders. The details of access of
the project, drainage facility, hygiene, size and aesthetic appeal for all selected districts are given in the following Table 19 to Table 24.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 79

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 19 : Quality and purpose of the works of Bidar districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds - Is the
Reasons
(Inclusive) Is the actual
Purpose Facility for
project work
Sl.No. Work Name Access Hygiene of the Utilisation changing
Drainage Aesthetic under use different
of the of the Size work (Full/Partial/No) the
facility appeal presently from
project project purpose
planned
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab
No
and Workshop at Govt. ITI in Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Full No It is same
Response
Kalyana Karnataka Region
2 Construction of Additional Two
Classrooms to Govt.High School at Class
Good No Clean Adequate Good Yes No Response No
Belur Village in Basavakalyan room
Taluka.
3 Library and furniture facility to Pre No No No
No No No No No No Response
metric hostels at Humnabad town Response Response Response
4 Drilling borewell and providing
Facilities
motor to Shedola, Chandanahally, No
Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Partial No yet be
Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi Response
provided
villages of Humnabad taluk
5 Construction (pending) of Santapura
No No Not
community health centre in Aurad Good Better Clean Adequate Good Full Pending
Response Response Good/No
taluk
6 Improvement of Godavari tank in Progress
No
Humnabad taluk Good No Clean Adequate Good Yes Full Good/Yes going
Response
good
7 Creation of additional manifold and
No No
Upgradation of 72 beded ICU wards Good Better Clean Adequate Good No Response Good/Yes Good
Response Response
at BRIMS Bidar.
8 Park development at Ward no 24 No
Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Not facilities
No No No No No No No No
Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan Good/No provided
taluk yet
9 Bridge construction on Aurad (S) Progress
No
village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli Good No Clean Adequate Good Yes Partial Good/Yes going
Response
main road. good

80 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 20 : Quality and purpose of the works of Kalaburagi districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds - Is the actual
(Inclusive) Is the
Facility work
Sl. project Purpose of
Work Name Access Hygiene Utilisation different
No. Drainage Aesthetics under use the work
of the of the Size (Full/Partial/No) from
facility appeal presently
project project planned
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop Good Better Clean Adequate Yes, very No Students No No Response
at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region good Response training
2 Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No No Response Not
Degree college located adjacent to Ashraya colony Response Response Good/No
and Kalluratanda in Afzalpur taluk
3 Purchasing 30 reversible desks, 5 computers, 2 Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Students Full Good/Yes
printers and 2 computer tables for Kunchavaram ITI teaching
college in Chincholi taluk
4 Construction of staff quarters for Group C and D (2 Good No Clean Adequate Good No No No Response Not
BHK -05) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla, Sedam Response Good/No
taluk. work
5 Construction of check dam cum CC Road on Good Yes Clean Adequate Good Yes Yes Full Good/Yes
Kamalavati river, construction of check dam on local
streams of Kadacharla village and improvement of
Madana village tank in Sedam taluk.
6 Supplying erection, testing and Commissioning of 2 No No No No No No No No Response No Response
TR AC’s with Copper Tube & Refrigent gas, Power Response Response
Supply, Cable, CPVC Drain Pipe and allied
accessories to Hon’ble Judges Chambers No-1, 2 &
3 at High Court Bench Kalaburagi.
7 Providing and Fixing open gym Equipments and Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Yes Full Good/Yes,
construct open yoga Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi going good
Guest House in Kalaburagi city.
8 Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara Ambigara Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Community No Response No Response
Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi
9 Construction of Barrage cum Bridge across Good No Clean Adequate Good Yes Yes Full Good/Yes,
Mullamari rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli going good
village in Chincholi Taluka
10 Construction of OHT and Pipeline at Vadatyatanda Good No Clean Adequate Good No Yes Full Good/Yes
in Chincholi taluk Response

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 81

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 21 : Quality and purpose of the works of Yadgir districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds - Is the
Is the
(Inclusive) actual
project Purpose Facility Reasons for
Access Drainage Hygiene Size Aesthetics work
Sl.No. Work Name under of the Utilisation changing the
of the facility of the appeal different
use work (Full/Partial/No) purpose
project project from
presently
planned
1 Provision of additional 4 class rooms Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No No change
and also construction of toilets to Govt. Response Response
Women First Grade College, Yadgir
2 Construction of compound for Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No No change
Chincholi Govt High School, Surpur Response Response
taluk
3 Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No No change
Response Response
4 Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No Partial No Not Good/No
boys/girls and post-matric and pre- Response
matric boys/girls hostels of District
Backward Classes and Minorities and
Social Welfare Department Model
Residential School (Navodaya).
5 Construction of box culvert on Anapura No No No No No No To store Partial No Not Good/Not good
Marg of Karanigi village Response water progress in works
6 Bridge construction for the road Good No Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No Not Good/Not good
heading to scheduled caste field from Response Response progress in works
Basavanna temple of Belagera village
through village tank
7 Construction (pending) activities of Good No Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No No change
indoor stadium of Shahapur town Response Response
8 Construction of walking path near Good Better Clean Adequate Good No Yes Full No No change
indoor stadium in Shahapur town Response
9 Construction of Tourist Guest house Good Better Clean Adequate Good No No No Response No Not Good/Not good
near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara Response Response progress in works
Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village,
Shorapur taluk.
10 Giving drinking water supply to Good No Clean Adequate Good No No No No Not Good/Not good
Vandganur village of Shorapur taluk Response progress in works

82 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 22 : Quality and purpose of the works of Bellary districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds - Is the
Reasons
(Inclusive) Is the actual
Facility for
project Purpose of the work
Sl.No. Work Name Access Utilisation changing
Drainage Hygiene of Aesthetics under use work different
of the Size (Full/Partial/No) the
facility the project appeal presently from
project purpose
planned
1 Construction of 2 class rooms Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Taching Full No No
and compound for Vivekananda change
Government High School,
Ranipet, Hospet
2 Construction of additional 2 Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Teaching and Full No No
class rooms, clean drinking drinking water change
water unit and smart class for
Government High School,
Regulator Camp, Kampli
3 Construction of new class room Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Taching Full No No
for Government High School, change
Kambattalli, Harappanahalli
Taluk, Jagalur MLA
constituency
4 Supply of computers to Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes To provide Full No No
Government High School, computer change
Elubenchi village knowledge to
students
5 Supply of sports equipment to Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes To provide No No No
Government High School, computer change
Thimmalapura village knowledge to
students
6 Construction of toilets for both Good Better No hygiene, Adequate Good No, there Toilet facility No No
boys and girls at Government because is no water for both response
High School, KVOR Colony, beside connection students and
16th Ward, School therefore teachers
Hagaribommanahalli Town household not under
drinage use now
water
flowing .
7 Regular Ambulance Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes for patients Full No

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 83

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

during response
emergency
8 Upgradation of Sitting Gallery Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes For sports Full No
& Bund Work at District aspirants and response
Stadium, Bellary audience
9 Construction of bridge for the Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Communication Full No
stream near Kalamma temple, between response
Tekkalakote town villages
10 Road development from Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Communication Full No
Katrahalli cross to Geddalagatte between response
villages/towns

84 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 23 : Quality and purpose of the works of Koppal districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds - Is the
Is the
(Inclusive) actual
project Facility
Access Drainage Hygiene of Size Aesthetics Purpose of the work
Sl.No. Work Name under Utilisation
of the facility the project appeal work different
use (Full/Partial/No)
project from
presently
planned
1 Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Conserve Partial No
from Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk (From Forest environment response
Department)
2 Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre- Good Better No hygine Adequate Good Yes Classroom Full No
University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga because response
MLA Constiuency beside
School
household
drinage
water
flowing .
3 Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Dringking Full No
Sirur village, Yalburga MLA Constiuency water response
4 Construction of Anganavadi in Ward 33 (Ward 29), Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Children Full No
Gangawati Town, Gangawati MLA Constiuency teaching response
5 Providing hi-mask, raising school compound, Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes School Full No
levelling field, toilets and other equipment to infrastructure response
Government Model Higher Primary School,
Hanumanala
6 Tata Technologies Lab and Workshops at Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Training Full No
Government Industrial Training Institute located at response
Kalyana Karnataka Region
7 Construction of Proposed 300 Bedded SJICR Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Treatment No Response No
Hospital at Kalaburagi. response
8 Fitting wiring coat to hard passage at Kidadura Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Communication Full No
village response
9 Construction of road from State Highway 130 Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Communication Full No
(Kudarikotagi) to PG Centre and also fixing street between response
lights from Yalburga to PG Centre, Yalburga taluk villages/towns
10 Construction of Indoor Stadium at Hanumasagara Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Sports aspirants No No
response

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 85

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 24 : Quality and purpose of the works of Raichur districts

Is the selection of site appropriate on these grounds -
(Inclusive) Is the
Facility
project Purpose of
Sl.No. Work Name Access Drainage Hygiene Size Aesthetics Utilisation
under use the work
of the facility of the appeal (Full/Partial/No)
presently
project project
1 Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Facility for No
camp (Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of Kendriya
Sindhanur taluka of Raichur Dist. Vidyalaya,
temporary
basis
2 Construction of Stadium for Government High School, Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Playground Full
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA Constituency for school
children
3 Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for Government Pre- Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Laboratory No
University College, Maski Town facility
4 Construction of Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village, Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Vaterinary No
Manavi Taluk purpose
5 Development of tank/lake is located at centre of Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Irrigation and Full
Lingsugur town (Part -4) recreation
6 Estimate for Shifting of 33KV Single Circuit Line from Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes No response Full
110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss to Kurkunda 33/11kV
Muss near Eluragi village Sy No.7 for construction of
Proposed Govt Kendriya Vidyalaya near Eluragi village,
Sindhanur.
7 Construction of bridge between Navalakal and Maratha, Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Easy Full
Manvi taluk commuting
between
villages
8 Construction of Stadium in Manvi town (continued) Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Sports Partial
promotion
9 Drinking water pipeline works from Hattigudda to Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes To provide No
Vagaranala village, Maski MLA Constituency safe drinking
water
10 Construction of clean drinking water unit at Kortakunda Good Better Clean Adequate Good Yes Safe drinking Full
village, Raichur taluk water

86 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

7.10 Objective 5: Findings

To examine the immediate impact of the works undertaken during 2021-22 in terms of
benefit to the people and region

Bidar District: The results of the primary analysis on quality of work, locations and design
of the work show that, the work carried out by the KKRDB is good and majority of the
projects are helping in many folds. For example, when we ask about the project on providing
TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region, the
respondents are given very positive feedback on its impact, to note a few, the stakeholders
said that, the technology and its related equipments are very much helpful, because, before
the initiative, the students use to go to the town or city to learn the computer knowledge, but
after the intervention not only students but also teacher are getting benefits. The other
stakeholder said that, the initiative of Tata Technologies in the ITI workshop is good, it is
providing a valuable opportunity for us to learn more about the use of computer and
computer related technology, which will be benefit for our career. Similarly, the response
from another respondent said that, as the student population in this government school is
increasing, the need for additional classrooms is evident. Providing these additional
classrooms will ensure that students can sit comfortably and listen to lectures without any
disturbances, this was noticed from construction of additional two classrooms to Govt. high
school at Belur village in Basavakalyan taluka. When it comes to library and furniture facility
to Pre metric hostels at Humnabad town, the respondents said that, the location of the school
is advantageous as it is easily accessible for the hostel students. Additionally, the furniture in
the school is not only well-designed but also of good quality which is helping to increase the
enrolment in terms of students. Similarly, a few of them mentioned that, it is useful for hostel
students who are taken admission to the hostel and they can read and write without any
disturbance. They also pointed out that, there is a need for proper maintenance system is
required for long and sustainability of the project. In spite of a few projects are under
progress in the selected district, the completed projects are providing the benefits to the
various group of the peoples. The details of immediate impact of the works undertaken for all
selected projects are given in the following Table 25.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 87

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 25 : Quality of works and stakeholders perception in Bidar district

If not, what Opinion about the location, Date of visit
Does the quality of work Opinion of 1st Opinion of 2nd
Sl.No. Work Name components are design and quality of work of Project for
look to be good? stakeholder stakeholder
lacking quality as expressed by stakeholders investigation
1 Providing TATA The technology provided It was very helpful for all Satisfied. Students can The initiative of Tata 06.12.2022
Technologies Lab and is satisfactory. the students. now get better practical Technologies in the ITI
Workshop at Govt. ITI exposure and hands-on workshop is good. It provides
in Kalyana Karnataka experience learning. a valuable opportunity for us
Region to learn more about the usage
of equipment, which will be
benefit for our career.
2 Construction of During observation, The The newly constructed Adequate facilities As the student population in 05.12.2022
Additional Two construction has been classrooms are spacious provided in the this government school is
Classrooms to carried out well. No cracks and equipped with good classrooms. increasing, the need for
Govt.High School at and leakages were found. facilities. They additional classrooms is
Belur Village in accommodate a larger evident. Providing these
Basavakalyan Taluka. number of students additional classrooms will
comfortably, helping in ensure that students can sit
creating an effective comfortably and listen to
learning environment. lectures without any
disturbances.
3 Library and furniture The facilities are of good Thoughtfully planned and Satisfied with the The location of the facility is 07.12.2022
facility to Pre metric quality. designed facilities to facility provided. advantageous as it is easily
hostels at Humnabad enhance the learning of Provision of more accessible for the hostel
town hostel students. However, subject oriented books students. Additionally, the
proper maintenance of the to the library, based on furniture in the school is not
facility is required the curriculum would only well-designed but also of
be beneficial for the good quality.
hostel students.
4 Drilling borewell and A well-functioning There is no Comfortable access. Satisfactory service. A value installation. 06.12.2022
providing motor to installation and found to drinking water Appears to be satisfying
Shedola, Chandanahally, be satisfactory facility and the residents’
Ghodavadi, Hilalapura health materials requirements.
and Jalasangi villages of provided to
Humnabad taluk Hilalpura

88 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

5 Construction (pending) Work is under progress. Provision of this additional A community health Construction appears to be 06.12.2022
of Santapura community The quality was found to ward will be extremely centre is an essential going well.
health centre in Aurad be satisfactory as inferred useful for the residents facility. Good progress
taluk from the lab report. so far
6 Improvement of A quality upgrade for the Good improvement of the Improved service. Good 06.12.2022
Godavadi tank in people. It is being well- facility.
Humnabad taluk maintained
7 Creation of additional During observation, the 50 The ICU beds are being used Good and ample Good and appreciative Beds 06.12.2022
manifold and beds are being used so far. now. The entire facility is provision of beds are easily available and the
Upgradation of 72 beded 22 are not in function yet. good facility is good
ICU wards at BRIMS The quality of the bed is
Bidar. found to be satisfactory
8 Park development at The work has not begun. No form of The work has not begun. The Not good Not good, Need Garden 05.12.2022
Ward no 24 Mahadevi The Garden area seems green cover surroundings are not being facility
colony and Ward no 18 dry. and cleaned well leading to
Hiremath colony in landscaping unhygienic conditions
Basavakalyan taluk is present.
9 Bridge construction on The bridge construction Many people are utilizing A good and much Good. Work is going in the 06.12.2022
Aurad (S) village road found to be satisfactory. this route and finding it needed improvement right direction
from Bidar-Munnakhelli time-saving. The ability to
main road. save time on transportation,
especially for agriculture
farming, is highly beneficial.
It allows us for increased
efficiency and productivity
in the agricultural sector.
10 Imrpovement to The quality of the work is The height of Good but it would be Good Due to heavy water flow 05.12.2022
Kamshetty Talab tank found to be unsatisfactory. the tank beneficial to raise the height during the rainy seasons, the
bund at Hulsoor taluka It has not been constructed should be of the tank slightly higher to water is overflowing, onto the
of Bidar District. properly. The height of the little bit high. prevent water from roads causing blockages.
tank is more than the ideal overflowing onto the road
height. Poorly cleaned. during the rainy season. This
Water does not last for adjustment would ensure
very long. hassle-free travel for the
villagers and reduce any
difficulties caused by water
accumulation.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 89

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Photos 7 : Improvement of Kamshetty Talab tank Photos 8 : Creation of additional manifold and
bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District upgradation of 72 bedded ICU wards at BRIMS
Bidar. Out of 72 beds they are using 50.22 beds
were kept in store.
.

Kalaburagi District: The Kalaburagi projects results show that, the initiative of TATA
technologies in the ITI workshop is good and trainers are getting more practical exposure,
students will learn computer and its related advance technology, which will help them to
build their careers. Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree college, the
students and teachers pointed out that, the equipments are very helpful and useful to the
school, because, students are using them in effectively to learn computer and computer
languages. The other project on construction of staff quarters for Group C and D (2 BHK -05)
at Primary Health Centre, Kodla, Sedam taluk, also one of the major initiatives by the
KKRDB and the beneficiaries pointed out that, the construction of staff quarters for Group C
and D are very useful and currently they are occupied by staffs and utilizing the facility. They
also pointed out that, after the construction of staff quarters they are accessible easily and
frequently than before, which is basically helpful to get the better health facility in time and
during the emergency. On the other hand, the project like construction (pending) of
Shivasharanara Ambigara Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi, show the negative
aspect of the projects, the respondent said that, Yes, project is good quality found to be
satisfactory, but there are many other issues associated with the project, to name a few, there

90 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

is no kitchen facility, balcony work is pending., no proper maintenance, electricity bills are
pending, and no signal board in the ring road though it is adjacent road are some of the major
issues with the said project in Kalaburagi. Even though there a few projects are under
progress in the Kalburgi district, the completed projects are providing the benefits to the
various groups of the peoples. The details of immediate impact of the works undertaken for
all selected projects are given in the following Table 26.

Table 26 : Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Kalaburagi district

Opinion about
the location,
Date of visit
Does the quality design and
Opinion of 1st Opinion of 2nd of Project
Sl.No. Work Name of work look to quality of work
stakeholder stakeholder for
be good? as expressed
investigation
by
stakeholders
Providing TATA The equipment’s Gives better Facilities are The initiative of 05.12.2022
Technologies Lab and provided are in practical exposure good. The TATA
Workshop at Govt. ITI in good working and helps in good students can now technologies in
Kalyana Karnataka condition. learning be exposed to the ITI
1 Region technology with workshop is
the amenities good. Trainees
and facilities will get more
provided. practical
exposure
Providing 40 computers The computers It is extremely Facilities are No Response 07.12.2022
and basic facilities to and facilities useful to the good. The
Govt. Degree college provided are students as they students can now
located adjacent to found to be can practice and be exposed to
2
Ashraya colony and satisfactoryand learn the technology with
Kalluratanda in Afzalpur all are in computer the amenities
taluk working language better. and facilities
condition. provided.
Purchasing 30 reversible The The facility that is Good facilities Good. Quality 10.12.2022
desks, 5 computers, 2 infrastructure provided is easily are provided is good
printers and 2 computer purchased are accessible
3 tables for Kunchavaram found to be
ITI college in Chincholi satisfactory and
taluk in working
condition.
Construction of staff The work had It will be very No Response No Response 11.12.2022
quarters for Group C and not yet begun at useful after the
D (2 BHK -05) at Primary the time of visit. construction work
Health Centre, Kodla, is complete. The
4
Sedam taluk. staff would be
readily available
during
emergencies.
Construction of check dam The (JCB) The completion of Good Good 11.12.2022
cum CC Road on excavation this dam would
Kamalavati river, process had been help in various
5 construction of check dam going on during uses across
on local streams of the time of visit. sectors.
Kadacharla village and Still work under
improvement of Madana progress.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 91

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

village tank in Sedam

taluk.
Supplying erection, testing The components Good quality No Response Quality is good 29.11.2022
and Commissioning of 2 supplied are materials are and components
TR AC’s with Copper found to be of being used. from trusted
Tube & Refrigent gas, good quality. brands are
Power Supply, Cable, being provided
6
CPVC Drain Pipe and
allied accessories to
Hon’ble Judges Chambers
No-1, 2 & 3 at High Court
Bench Kalaburagi.
Providing and Fixing open The equipment’s A good facility. It is a good Good 13.12.2022
gym Equipments and and construction Guests are using facility
construct open yoga of Yoga platform this govt.
7 Platform at Aiwan-E- are found to be provided facility
Shahi Guest House in satisfactory and very often
Kalaburagi city. in working
condition.
Construction (pending) of Quality is The facility No Response No Response 07.12.2022
Shivasharanara Ambigara satisfactory. provided is good
Chowdaiah Memorial However, there but there is no
Bhavan at Kalaburagi is no kitchen Kitchen facility in
space provided, Bhavan and it is
the surroundings finding difficulty
are of Poor in the during
maintenance, marriage time.
resulting in People are
growth of weeds ordering Outside
and unwanted Caterers.
8 grass pockets is
observed.
Pending works
and due in
Balcony works
and electricity
provision
respectively. No
signal board in
the ring road
though it is
adjacent road.
Construction of Barrage Work found to Useful for the A very helpful Good 10.12.2022
cum Bridge across be satisfactory. agricultural sector construction to
Mullamari rivers between Construction of as well as the the villages
9
Kanakpur-Garmpalli the gate was in residents.
village in Chincholi progress during
Taluka visit.
Construction of OHT and As per the The construction Provision of the Good 10.12.2022
Pipeline at Vadatyatanda information carried out is facilities is good.
in Chincholi taluk received and good.
from
observation,
10
work had been
done by JJM(ZP)
as mentioned on
the tank and not
by KKRDB.

92 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Photos 9 : Tata technologies lab at Photos 10 : Open gym at guest house in

Kalaburagi Kalaburagi

Photos 11 :Infrastructure facility created Photos 12 :Construction (pending) of

at the ITI collage in Chincholi Taluk Shivasharanara Ambigara Chowdaiah
Kalaburagi District Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 93

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Yadgir District: Head Master from the Govt. Women First Grade College, Yadgir,
expressed his opinion that, the provision of additional 4 class rooms and also construction of
toilets in the college premise is a good initiative by KKRDB, it is helping to improve the
congested conditions of the college, and the facility is now able to accommodate the students
adequately. Having sufficient space and facilities for students to utilize the resources
effectively and have a comfortable learning environment in the college and has helped many
students to get better education. When it comes to construction of compound for Chincholi
Govt High School, Surpur taluk, the beneficiaries said that, the compound construction is
good, after construction of the compound, outside individuals are no longer coming to the
area. Previously, they would use the space for drinking and smoking purposes. This change
indicates that the construction of the compound has effectively restricted access and deterred
unwanted activities in the school area. The other stakeholders pointed out that, the
construction of the compound has made a positive impact by preventing undesirable activities
such as playing cards and allowing cows to enter the premises. The improved maintenance of
the area ensures a cleaner and more organized environment for everyone especially for the
children to get better education. On the other hand, project on bridge construction for the road
heading to scheduled caste field from Basavanna temple of Belagera village through village
tank, the respondents have pointed out that, the side culverts are not built properly due to
which during rainy season water will flow on the road. Similarly, the local people also
pointed out same concerns about the issues of sides of the road are not constructed properly
as water comes onto the roads in rainy season in Belagera village. The projects are under
progress have some issues unable to provide services to stakeholders, in the Yadgir district,
the completed projects are providing the benefits to the various groups of the peoples. The
details of immediate impact of the works undertaken for all selected projects are given in the
following Table 27.

94 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 27 : Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Yadgir district

Opinion about
If not, what the location,
Does the quality Date of visit
components Opinion of 2nd design and
Sl.No. Work Name of work look to Opinion of 1st stakeholder of Project for
are lacking stakeholder quality of work
be good? investigation
quality as expressed by
stakeholders
1 Provision of additional 4 Quality is Good. Congested conditions Good amenities and Good 08.12.2022
class rooms and also satisfactory. No have been improved, and the facilities are provided.
construction of toilets to cracks were facility is now able to According to the
Govt. Women First Grade found. Painting accommodate the students students, both boys and
College, Yadgir works were in adequately. Designed with girls, the facilities are
progress during sufficient space and facilities very comfortable
the visit for students to utilize the
resources effectively and have
a comfortable learning
environment
2 Construction of compound The construction Good. It seems that after The construction of the Good 17.12.2022
for Chincholi Govt High of the compound construction of the compound, compound has made a
School, Surpur taluk wall is good. outside individuals are no positive impact by
longer coming into the preventing undesirable
premises. Previously, they activities of individuals
would use the space for within the premises.
drinking and smoking The improved
purposes. This change maintenance of the area
indicates that the construction ensures a cleaner and
of the compound has more organized
effectively restricted access environment for
and deterred unwanted everyone.
activities in the area.
3 Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) Oxygen They are easily available to They are readily Good 08.12.2022
Cylinders are the patients in the hospital. available for emergency
Provided Helps during emergencies treatment. There is no
shortage of oxygen
supply
4 Basic facilities (Water As per The water proofing is of no . Not good, not 08.12.2022
Proofing) for boys/girls and observation, problem, they were done properly

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 95

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

post-matric and pre-matric Water proofing mentioning about water

boys/girls hostels of District work is done and purifier problems for drinking
Backward Classes and found to be which is not working from
Minorities and Social good. No leaks many months.
Welfare Department Model were been
Residential School observed
(Navodaya).
5 Construction of box culvert Work had not Not usable Construction is not Service is not up to the Not usable 09.12.2022
on Anapura Marg of yet begun for the satisfactory. mark
Karanigi village new culvert. The
bill has been
claimed for the
old culvert.
6 Bridge construction for the The culverts on Construction Not Good Complaints by the Service provided 08.12.2022
road heading to scheduled the side are not is not residents on is not
caste field from Basavanna constructed satisfactory. overflowing of water on satisfactory.
temple of Belagera village properly. Water the roads are noted.
through village tank will overflow
onto the roads
during
monsoons.
7 Construction (pending) During the visit, A good facility to improve in Good progress on the Good, design 09.12.2022
activities of indoor stadium the work was on- sports and fitness construction so far. quality is good.
of Shahapur town going; almost
completed.
8 Construction of walking The construction Good improvement on the Improved pathway. It is Good 09.12.2022
path near indoor stadium in of pathway infrastructure. beneficial for residents’
Shahapur town founds to be usage.
good quality
9 Construction of Tourist Work is under Good, Tourists can use this Work is going well. Good 17.12.2022
Guest house near Sri Jadi progress at the facility during their visit and
Shantalingeshwara Hiremath time of visit. benefits at a much lower cost
Sansthana, Devapura Satisfactory
Village, Shorapur taluk. work so far.
10 Giving drinking water The work has They have not yet provided No progress on the Not satisfactory. 17.12.2022
supply to Vandganur village not yet begun the drinking water supply. work. The water supply
of Shorapur taluk provision by the govt. is
lacking due to it.

96 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Photos 13 :Indoor stadium at Yadgir Photos 14 : Walking path at Yadgir

Photos 15 :Providing of Oxygen Cylinder Photos 16 :Construction of box culvert on

Jumbo at Yadgiri Anapura Marg of Karanigi village, Yadgir

Bellary District: The primary results with regards to Bellary, about the construction of 2
class rooms and compound for Vivekananda Government High School, Ranipet, Hospet,
respondents felt that, the construction work is good and quality found to be satisfactory. The
KKRDB constructed only one class room, but enrolments are happening more than the usual
strengths. So, requested to construct one more additional class room to meet the requirement.
The other project on construction of bridge for the stream near Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote
town, the users pointed out that, the quality of bridge is found to be satisfactory but they need
to clear the demolished materials from the bridge. On the other hand, project on construction
of toilets for both boys and girls at Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16th Ward,
Hagaribommanahalli Town, the respondent pointed out that, the quality of the toilet facility
are not satisfactory, toilets are not in good condition, toilet doors latches are broken over all
the projects found to be in poor quality. The details of immediate impact of the works
undertaken for all selected projects in Bellary are given in the following Table 28.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 97

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 28 : Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Bellary district

Opinion about
the location,
If not, what Opinion of Date of visit
Does the quality of Opinion of 1st design and
Sl.No. Work Name components are 2nd of Project for
work look to be good? stakeholder quality of work
lacking quality stakeholder investigation
as expressed by
stakeholders
1 Construction of 2 class rooms and The quality of the Required Congested conditions Good facility Good 07-02-2023
compound for Vivekananda construction of the 1 additional class have been improved, provided.
Government High School, Ranipet, class room and room and the facility is now
Hospet compound is satisfactory able to accommodate the
with no cracks or students adequately.
damages found. As per Outside people are not
the work order there are entering in to the
two room to be campus because of
constructed but compound construction.
constructed only one
room had been
constructed.
2 Construction of additional 2 class Quality of work is found No drinking Construction of the Location not As per school 30-01-2023
rooms, clean drinking water unit and to be satisfactory. water supply is additional rooms is applicable location it is
smart class for Government High However, drinking water provided satisfactory. The implemented so
School, Regulator Camp, Kampli facility is not available drinking water facility is location is not
provided by Unnati applicable for this
scheme and not under work
KKRDB
3 Construction of new class room for Quality of work is found Quality of the Construction quality is Location not As per school 09-01-2023
Government High School, to be satisfactory writing board is good applicable location it is
Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, not adequate. implemented so
Jagalur MLA constituency Broken hinges of location is not
the windows are applicable for this
observed. work
4 Supply of computers to Government The computers supplied Quality of work No installation of the Location not Location not 25-01-2023
High School, Elubenchi village are in good working is good but the computers is done. applicable applicable
condition plan has been Facilities like UPS has
changed from not been provided.
what has been

98 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

specified in the
work order.
5 Supply of sports equipment to During observation, 4 As per work Students are able to use Location not Location not 06-01-2023
Government High School, computers are provided order only 4 the computer facility. applicable applicable
Thimmalapura village which in working computers are
condition. Sports provided but
materials have not been sports items are
provided. The money is not delivered
refunded back to
department.
6 Construction of toilets for both boys During observation, the Toilets have been No water supply is Location not It is located near 09-01-2023
and girls at Government High construction of toilets constructed but provided to the toilet applicable the city’s
School, KVOR Colony, 16th Ward, are found to be in bad there is no facility. drainage area
Hagaribommanahalli Town condition with the door provision of making it
latches broken. water. unpleasant
7 Regular Ambulance Functional and in good Provision of 10 Not Available Location not Location not 26-01-2023
condition ambulances are applicable applicable
during the
pandemic

8 Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & The Quality of work is People finding Good Good, in good 26-01-2023
Bund Work at District Stadium, found to be satisfactory comfortable sitting in location it is built
Bellary the gallery. Facility is
good.
9 Construction of bridge for the stream Quality of construction Need to clear the Construction is Location not Constructed at an 25-01-2023
near Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote is found to be demolished satisfactory but not the applicable usable and
town satisfactory materials from wastes have not been needed location.
the site. cleared.
10 Road development from Katrahalli Quality found to be Quality of work is good Good Location is good 09-01-2023
cross to Geddalagatte satisfactory

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 99

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Photos 17 :Construction of 2 class rooms and compound for Vivekananda Government

High School, Ranipet, Hospet

Photos 18 :Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean drinking water unit and
smart class for Government High School, Regulator Camp, Kampli

Koppal District: In Koppal district, the sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts
from Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk (From Forest Department), according to respondent the
saplings of trees have not yet started due to ongoing road construction, and contactor also
pointed out that, the saplings work will start after road work completion. With regard to floor
tiles fixing work at Government Pre-University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga MLA
constituency, fixing floor tiles are good, but scraps were not cleared in the campus and
painting has to be done, said the beneficiaries. Providing clean drinking water unit to High
School, Sirur village, Yalburga MLA Constituency, the school master said that, water quality
found to be satisfactory and good, earlier getting it from outside, it was difficult for both
drinking and cooking, now the facility is easy and helping the students to get clean drinking
water at school premises. Similarly, with respect to construction of proposed 300 bedded
SJICR Hospital at Kalaburagi, the respondent said that, not yet started and currently in under

100 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

progress, though the budget is allocated, bed hasn’t provided yet to the hospital. To providing
high-mask, raising school compound, levelling field, toilets and other equipment to
Government Model Higher Primary School, Hanumanala, the head master said that, instead
of high masking, agency constructed smart class, single large room for conducting
programme, constructed toilets and installed 10 solar lights in the school campus these are
some of the very good projects by the KKRDB and helping the community and students in
many folds. The details of immediate impact of the works undertaken for all selected projects
in Koppal are given in the following Table 29.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 101

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 29 : Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Koppal district

Opinion about the
Date of visit
If not, what Opinion of location, design and
Does the quality of work look to Opinion of 1st of Project
Sl.No. Work Name components are 2nd quality of work as
be good? stakeholder for
lacking quality stakeholder expressed by
investigation
stakeholders
1 Sapling of trees along the Work has not yet begun on the Construction of Good initiative on Good Good 27-01-2023
Kapilateertha Road, starts plantation front due to ongoing the road is in planting trees. It initiative
from Kabbaragi, Kushtagi road construction. progress. might attract tourists
taluk (From Forest resulting in the
Department) development of the
village.
2 Floor tiles fixing work at As per observation, the work on Scraps were not The new flooring and Good work Good 28-01-2023
Government Pre-University floor tiles is satisfactory but scraps cleared in the tiles are good. on
College, Balutagi Village, were not cleared in the campus campus after Painting work has to revamping
Yalburga MLA completion of the be done of the floor
Constiuency work.
3 Providing clean drinking Water quality is found to be Work quality is Procuring from Good Good 28-01-2023
water unit to High School, satisfactory good outside earlier for
Sirur village, Yalburga both drinking and
MLA Constiuency cooking purposes was
difficult. The
provision has made it
easier for daily needs.
4 Construction of Anganavadi Quality of the work found to be Good Good Good 30-01-2023
in Ward 33 (Ward 29), satisfactory.
Gangawati Town,
Gangawati MLA
Constiuency
5 Providing hi-mask, raising Work quality is satisfactory. Some changes are Good Good Good 27-01-2023
school compound, levelling However it is observed that instead made from what
field, toilets and other of high masking, the agency has is specified in the
equipment to Government constructed smart class, a single work order
Model Higher Primary large room for conducting
School, Hanumanala programmes, a toilet and installed
10 solar lights in the school
campus.

102 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

6 Tata Technologies Lab and The quality of the infrastructure The plan has been Good Good Good 27-01-2023
Workshops at Government provided is good and are in changed from the
Industrial Training Institute working condition. initial work order.
located at Kalyana changed
Karnataka Region
7 Construction of Proposed Although the budget has been This facility is Location Not Location Location Not 27-01-2023
300 Bedded SJICR Hospital allocated, the work has not begun given by Jayadeva Applicable Not Applicable
at Kalaburagi. yet. Beds would not be provided hospital Gulbarga Applicable
until the completion. Work Under
progress,
8 Fitting wiring coat to hard Quality is found to be satisfactory Road connectivity Good Good Good 27-01-2023
passage at Kidadura village work is ok
9 Construction of road from The road construction is found to Connectivity to public Good Good 28-01-2023
State Highway 130 be satisfactory transport is required.
(Kudarikotagi) to PG
Centre and also fixing street
lights from Yalburga to PG
Centre, Yalburga taluk
10 Construction of Indoor During monsoons, as the soil Construction in Good Good Good 27-01-2023
Stadium at Hanumasagara condition is weak (BC Soil), the progress
work could not be initiated., The
probable work completion date
will be on 30.07.2023

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 103

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Photos 19 : Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts from Kabbaragi,
Kushtagi taluk (From Forest Department)

Photos 20 :Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Sirur village,
Yalburga MLA Constituency

Raichur District: According to the school Head Master, providing infrastructure to Govt
Adarsh School in PWD camp (Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya Vidyalaya) of Sindhanur
taluka of Raichur Dist, the infrastructures are good in quality and satisfactory, students were
facing difficulty to enter this campus (Old campus), and requested to shift to the new building
at the earliest. The other project on construction of stadium for Government High School,
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA constituency, the users pointed out that the school
playground levelling is done and not the stadium’s, students are using this facility properly
and playing in the ground. Similarly, construction of clean drinking water unit at Kortakunda
village, Raichur taluk, the users pointed out that, there is no clean drinking water; filters are
not repaired from many months and currently no drinking water facility available for the
community. The many more details of immediate impact of the works undertaken for all
selected projects in Raichur are given in the following Table 30.

104 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Table 30 : Quality of works and stakeholders’ perception in Raichur district

Opinion about the
Date of visit
If not, what Opinion of location, design
Does the quality of Opinion of 1st of Project
Sl.No. Work Name components are 2nd and quality of
work look to be good? stakeholder for
lacking quality stakeholder work as expressed
investigation
by stakeholders
1 Providing Infrastructure to Govt The quality of the Students were facing The facility is good Good Good, design is 30-01-2023
Adarsh School in PWD camp infrastructure founds to difficulty to enter in and need to shift to good need to be
(Proposed Temporary Govt be satisfactory. this campus. the new building at shifted at the
Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur Requested to shift to the earliest. earliest
taluka of Raichur Dist. the new building at
the earliest.
2 Construction of Stadium for As per observations, Students are using Good Good 31-01-2023
Government High School, there was no Stadium this playground.
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA constrcucted. Only one
Constituency school playground is
found to be existing.
3 Construction of 2 Laboratory As per observations, The lab facility is The facility is Good 31-01-2023
rooms for Government Pre- the construction done good and it is useful good
University College, Maski Town for degree college not for the students for
for pre universities. practical.

4 Construction of Veterinary The construction Under construction No need to travel Good initiative Good 31-01-2023
Hospital at Byagavata village, quality is found to be for long distance for
Manavi Taluk good and the work is check up
still under progress
5 Development of tank/lake is The quality of Good, easy access Useful to the Good 31-01-2023
located at centre of Lingsugur town construction is found for the villagers for local people
(Part -4) to be good. their need
6 Estimate for Shifting of 33KV As per observation the Shifted properly Shifting is done and Good Good 30-01-2023
Single Circuit Line from shifting has done and people finds it is
110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss founds to be in safe now compared
to Kurkunda 33/11kV Muss near working condition. to earlier.
Eluragi village Sy No.7 for
construction of Proposed Govt
Kendriya Vidyalaya near Eluragi
village, Sindhanur.
7 Construction of bridge between As per observation, the Quality of Travelling to other Good Good 31-01-2023

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 105

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Navalakal and Maratha, Manvi quality is not construction is good side of the village
taluk satisfactory. found to be easier
but quality seems to
be not good.
8 Construction of Stadium in Manvi The construction of the Work under process After construction Useful to the Good 31-01-2023
town (continued) quality of stadium so only ground is work complete, local people
founds to be using local people can use
satisfactory and work this place regularly
is still under progress. for playing and
health fitness
9 Drinking water pipeline works As per observations, Only pipeline work No water supply Not 31-01-2023
from Hattigudda to Vagaranala there is no water done but there is no provided to this satisfactoryas
village, Maski MLA Constituency supply to the pipelines water supply given pipeline there no water
even after construction supply
work is completed
10 Construction of clean drinking As per observation, the Filter is not filtering There is no clean No proper Location is far from 01-02-2023
water unit at Kortakunda village, construction of clean properly drinking water. maintainence village
Raichur taluk drinking water unit is Filter not repaired
found to be satisfactory from many months.
but filter is not
functioning properly.

106 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Results and Discussion

Photos 21 : Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD camp (Proposed

Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur taluka of Raichur Dist.

Photos 22 : Construction of Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village, Manvi Taluk

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 107

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

108 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Case Study

9.CASE STUDY

8.1. Case study 1: Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree
college located adjacent to Ashraya colony and Kallura thanda in Afzalpur taluk,
Kalaburagi district.

This is a micro project (work code: KLB216231144), started in 2021-22. This project was
taken up and completed by Keonics Bengaluru. It is belonged to ‘Education sector’ and
categorized under SCP (social). This project considered, Government Degree College
located near to Ashraya Colony and Kallura Thanda, in Afzalpur town of Kalaburagi
district. The main intention of the project is to provide 40 computers and required basic
facilities to install them. Presently, all the facilities are given to the college with a total
cost of Rs. 48,685 lakhs. All 40 computers are installed and they are in working
condition. In addition, they have provided server facility, tables, chairs, UPS and internet
connection. Two computer training teachers are appointed to teach students. All degree
students studying in this college are happy with the work. Moreover, teachers and
administrations are satisfied with the work because they are getting good enrollment.
Earlier, there were 300 students, presently it increased to 500 students (approximately) in
the college. Moreover, before providing computers, students used to go to Kalaburagi for
studying computers but presently such facilities are given locally in Afzalpur. This has
saved their time and money which can be used elsewhere. These computer trainings are
completely free for the students of this Govt Degree College. Many students have
expressed joy because it will help them to clear various competitive exams. Also,
computer knowledge will help them get better jobs in the cities. Students and teachers felt
that such initiatives from KKRDB are required to other Govt. Degree Colleges in
Kalaburagi.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 109

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Photos 23 : Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to Govt. Degree college located
in Afzalpur taluk, Kalaburagi district

8.2. Case study 2: Construction of staff quarters for Group C and D (Total 5 quarters of
2 BHK capacity) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla village, Sedam taluk, Kalaburagi
district.
This is a micro project (work code: KLB2111233476), presently, it is under progress. This
project is implemented by PWD and It is belonged to ‘Health sector’, categorized under
‘General’ (social). The main purpose of this project is to construct staff quarters (total 5
quarters of 2 BHK capacity) for Group C and D employees working in the Primary Health
Centre, Kodla village, Sedam taluk, Kalaburagi district. The total cost of the project is Rs.
137.79 lakhs, presently work is going. Earlier, there were no such facilities in this primary
health centre. If there is emergency, staff were not available, patients used to go long distances
for the treatment. Construction of such staff quarters will help patients largely including staff
those who cannot afford rent outside. Staff are expressing that, due to quarters, we can stay
near to health centre and we will be available to both Doctors and patients as and when
required. Especially, the pregnant women and aged people will benefit from this kind of
facility if staff stays nearby. This project was appreciated by staff (group D & C), Doctors,
Nurses, patients (particularly pregnant women) and senior citizens of this area.

110 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Case Study

8.3. Case study 3: Development of tank/lake (continued) located at centre of Lingsugur

town, Raichur district.
This is a micro project (work code: RCH2119243126) started in 2021-22, developing by
PRED. This project belongs to irrigation sector and it is categorized under ‘General” (non-
social). This tank is located in the centre part of Lingsugur town, Raichur district. Currently, it
is under progress, 66 % of the financial budget (99.92 lakhs) has been utilized to construct
compound wall, pathway protection wall and the remaining work making C.C. drain is under
progress. After completion, they are planning to treat the sewage water which was entering
the tank. Earlier this tank was using for washing clothes and animal water drinking. The
present idea of rejuvenating the tank is appreciated by several local people because it
increases the beauty of the town, helps senior people for recreation and also increases the
ground water level (nearly 30-40%) in surrounding areas. The recreation facilities may also
increase the social network of local people. The construction activity of the project has
provided some employment to local people (200 people approximately). The senior citizens
and youth using this tank (become park) have expressed appreciation because it is easily
accessible.

Photos 24 : Development of tank located at centre of Lingsugur town, Raichur district.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 111

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

8.4. Case study 4: Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, starts from
Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk, Koppal district (From Forest Department)
This is a micro project (work code: KPL2121243368) started in 2021-22, it is developing by
PWD. This project belongs to ‘Agriculture Sector’ and it is categorized under ‘General’ (non-
social). This project located in Kushtagi taluk of Koppal district. The main component of the
project is to raise the trees along the Kabbaragi – Kapilatheertha road. Presently, this project
is completed with planting trees on both the sides of the road. The total cost of the project
was Rs.15.431 lakhs. The Koppal district administration is planning to develop Kapilateertha
for tourism therefore planting trees on both the sides of the road will definitely satisfy the
commuters travelling from different places. Also, the raising trees on road sides will
neutralize the temperature rise particularly in summer. Since, Koppal belong to arid region,
the plantation activities are highly needed. The local residents and regular commuter using
this Kabbaragi – Kapilatheertha road are satisfied with the work of KKRDB. Many
beneficiaries have expressed such activities required to Koppal district. The maximum
benefits can be observed from minimum expenditures.

Photos 25 : Trees planting along Kabbaragi – Kapilatheertha road, Kushtagi taluk,

Koppal district

112 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

9. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

KKRDB planned to implement 2,241 works with an allocation of 1,47,332 lakh in the year
2021-22 in six districts viz Bellary, Bidar, Kalaburagi, Koppal, Raichur and Yadgir.
According to data available on the KKRDB website, so far it has completed 1,178 (52.57 %)
works with a total expenditure of 93,068 (63.17 %) of total allocation. Among six districts
highest works are carried out in Koppal (69.10 %) followed by Bidar (62.36 %) due to more
number of micro projects and constant monitoring by the respective departments. The lowest
performance was seen in Kalaburagi (33.07 %) because it is observed to have more number
of macro projects in the district, where works get delayed. In terms of financial expenditure
Yadgir ranks first (66.13%) followed by Bellary (64.98 %) because of good cooperation
among other line departments. The least expenditures are recorded in Kalaburagi and Raichur
districts due to less physical performance.

Koppal, Bidar and Yadgir districts are performing better in physical progress in KKR,
according to data available for the period, they have completed 288, 222 and 195 projects in
the year 2021-22. Under progress projects are more in Kalaburagi (303 projects among 499),
Raichur (157 projects among 332) and Bellary (176 projects among 434) districts. Lack of
available construction materials, labour shortage, contractor delay, frequent rain/flood, and
financial releases from the department as major reasons for non-completion of the projects.
Not started projects are observed to be high in Bellary (31 projects) and Kalaburagi (31
projects) districts due to delay in administrative process.

Analysis of 60 samples/projects (10 projects each from 6 districts) provided by the

KMEA/KKRDB shows that 62 percent of the projects are completed and 38 percent are
under progress in the KKRDB. Most of the projects completed are belong to micro type.
According the field survey, macro projects are taking longer time than estimated due to
frequent rain, shortage of labour, technicians, unavailability of construction materials and
delays by contractors due to their health issues and financial constraints. It is noticed that
there are 73.33 % micro and 23.33 % macro level projects in Kalyana Karnataka Region
(KKR). Among them, 55 % are under social sector and 45 % are non-social sector. Further,
73.3 % projects are categorized as General, 20% SCP and 6.7% TSP.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 113

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9.1 Key findings

• Majority of the macro level projects have better access, appropriate size and aesthetic
appeal as compared to micro projects.
• Social infrastructure sector is having 97.3 % access, appropriate size and aesthetic
appeal and 83.8 % in drainage facilities. Access is defined as easy to approach the
project site. The remaining projects are located interior and household waste was
dumped near to project site.
• In the social sector all the facilities (access, drainage, hygiene, appropriate size and
aesthetic appeal) appear to be good and appropriate as compared to the non-social
sector projects. Most of the social category projects belong to education and health
where cleanliness is assured. Not-social sector projects include irrigation, drinking
water and roads, where drainage and hygiene are less maintained. It shows less
performance in drainage facilities (66.7%) as compared to other facilities in KKR.
Because, sewage water is entering into tanks and no proper drainage facilities are
provided at roads and bridges. Overall, Raichur performs better because most of them
are social sector projects where quality is maintained and Bidar ranks low due to a
greater number of tanks and bridges where cleanliness given less importance in the
district.
• Non-social sector projects are being utilized more (59.3%) as compared to social
sector projects. Because non-social sector projects like irrigation, water supply, tank
development, park development and construction of roads & bridges benefit large
number of people/beneficiaries than others. Further, it is noticed that majority of SCP
and TSP are built in interior locations while general projects are built in exterior areas
which are more accessible to people from city and town centers, bridges connecting
between two major towns/villages, classroom built for colleges, providing drinking
water to villages and construction of primary health centres at towns and village.
• Satisfaction levels for the particular projects are higher in the agriculture sector due to
the water availability in the tanks for most of the years and the developments of the
tank have led to enhance the water level.
• Agriculture sector shows 100.0 % in appropriate size, aesthetic appeal, access and
80.0 % in hygiene. Because some places are discharging sewage water into tanks.
• Stakeholders are happier with agriculture sector (100.0%) works because they are
getting 2 crops in place of 1 crop per year and also observed water availability in the

114 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

tanks for longer period in the year. Due to development of tanks, water level in the
nearby borewells is getting enhanced up to 50 %. Before the tank development the
depth of borewell was 450-500 ft at present getting water at 200-300 ft.
• Social sector projects those that come under education (such as classroom
construction, computer provision, compound construction for schools, hostels etc,)
heath (such as construction of primary health centres, drilling of borewell to PHCs,
staff quarters construction, providing oxygen cylinders and additional beds etc.), and
sports (such as construction of indoor and outdoor stadiums, walking path etc.,) have
attracted stakeholders’ interest more than non-social projects like construction of
road, bridge and pipeline related works.
• Stakeholders expressed positive opinions on the projects completed under TSP such
as Providing clean drinking water unit to High School, Sirur village, Yalburga MLA
Constiuency, providing high-mask, raising school compound, levelling field, toilets
and other equipment to Government Model Higher Primary School, Hanumanala and
Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of Karanigi village.
• Lab test of construction materials such as plastics, wood, cement, iron etc., shows
good quality, and meeting the required standards (refer lab reports).
• Stakeholders expressed that public awareness is required about the progress of
KKRDB projects which are implementing under various schemes in both urban and
rural areas.
• The below Table 31 provides the quality and perception of stakeholders in each
district

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 115

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 31 : Quality of work and stakeholder’s opinions for all 60 projects

Date of visit
Sl. of Project
Work Name Quality of Work Opinion of stakeholders
No. for
investigation
Bidar
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab and The equipment’s provided are found to be in working It’s found to be useful to the students. More practical 06.12.2022
Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka condition and of good quality. exposure and hands on experience will be benefitted
Region for us.
2 Construction of Additional Two Classrooms to The construction of the two rooms are of good quality The classrooms are spacious and equipped with good 05.12.2022
Govt.High School at Belur Village in with no cracks or damages were found. facilities. accommodate a larger number of students
Basavakalyan Taluka. comfortably providing for an effective learning
environment.
3 Library and furniture facility to Pre metric hostels The quality of the furniture’s appears to be of It is useful for hostel students who can read and write 07.12.2022
at Humnabad town satisfactory as no major broken/ damage furniture’s without any disturbance. Proper maintenance is
were found required.
4 Drilling borewell and providing motor to The bore well and the motor found to be in working Useful to local people and easy access for their needs 06.12.2022
Shedola, Chandanahally, Ghodavadi, Hilalapura condition and satisfactory.
and Jalasangi villages of Humnabad taluk
5 Construction (pending) of Santapura community Work was under progress at the time of field visit and Local people felt availability of ward room will be 06.12.2022
health centre in Aurad taluk Lab report qualityof the materials are found to be better once the health centre comes up.
satisfactory
6 Improvement of Godavadi tank in Humnabad The work of improvement of Godavadi Tank, found to Local people founds to be useful after the 06.12.2022
taluk be good. improvement of the Godavari tank
7 Creation of additional manifold and Upgradation The quality of the beds founds to be satisfactory. In The facility founds to be useful along with the ICU 06.12.2022
of 72 beded ICU wards at BRIMS Bidar. that 50 are being used and the remaining 22 are in the beds.
store room.
8 Park development at Ward no 24 Mahadevi Wok has not started and the garden seems dry. No cleanliness in the vicinity 05.12.2022
colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in
Basavakalyan taluk
9 Bridge construction on Aurad (S) village road The construction of bridge found to be satisfactory Many people are utilizing this route and finding it 06.12.2022
from Bidar-Munnakhelli main road. with no major damages. time-saving. The bridge saves time on transportation,
especially for agriculture farming, is highly
beneficial. It allows us for increased efficiency and
productivity in the agricultural sector.
10 Imrpovement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund at The quality of the work is found to be unsatisfactory. It would be beneficial to raise the height of the tank 05.12.2022

116 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District. It has not been constructed properly. The height of the slightly higher to prevent water from overflowing
tank is more than the ideal height. Poorly cleaned. onto the road during the rainy season. This
Water does not last for very long adjustment would ensure easier travel for the villagers
and reduce any difficulties caused by water
accumulation.
Kalaburagi
1 Providing TATA Technologies Lab and The equipment’s provided are in working condition It’s found to be useful to the students. More practical 05.12.2022
Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka and of good quality. exposure and hands on experience will be benefitted
Region for us.
2 Providing 40 computers and basic facilities to The computers and facilities provided are found to be Getting useful to the students where they can practice 07.12.2022
Govt. Degree college located adjacent to satisfactory and all are in working condition and learn computer language.
Ashraya colony and Kalluratanda in Afzalpur
taluk
3 Purchasing 30 reversible desks, 5 computers, 2 The infrastructure purchased are found to be This facility founds to be useful and easily accessible. 10.12.2022
printers and 2 computer tables for Kunchavaram satisfactory and in working condition.
ITI college in Chincholi taluk
4 Construction of staff quarters for Group C and D The Work has not started during visit. It Will be useful after the construction works 11.12.2022
(2 BHK -05) at Primary Health Centre, Kodla, completes, staffs can be available when emergency.
Sedam taluk.
5 Construction of check dam cum CC Road on The (JCB) excavation process had been going on If this work is completed successfully, the water 11.12.2022
Kamalavati river, construction of check dam on during the time of visit. Still work under progress.. supply can be utilized for various purposes, including
local streams of Kadacharla village and agriculture, drinking, and other domestic needs. This
improvement of Madana village tank in Sedam would not only support agricultural activities but also
taluk. provide a reliable and safe water source for the
community's daily requirements.
6 Supplying erection, testing and commissioning The components supplied are found to be of good The facilities provided are good. It is in working 29.11.2022
of 2 TR AC’s with Copper Tube & Refrigent quality. condition.
gas, Power Supply, Cable, CPVC Drain Pipe and
allied accessories to Hon’ble Judges Chambers
No-1, 2 & 3 at High Court Bench Kalaburagi.
7 Providing and fixing open gym Equipments and The equipment’s and construction of Yoga platform Guests are using this facility provided by the govt. 13.12.2022
construct open yoga Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi are found to be satisfactory and in working condition.
Guest House in Kalaburagi city.
8 Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara Quality is satisfactory. However, there is no kitchen The facility provided is good but there is no Kitchen 07.12.2022
Ambigara Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at space provided, the surroundings are of Poor facility in Bhavan and it is finding difficulty in the
Kalaburagi maintenance, resulting in growth of weeds and during marriage time. People are ordering Outside
unwanted grass pockets is observed. Pending works Caterers.
and due in Balcony works and electricity provision

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 117

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

respectively. No signal board in the ring road though it

is adjacent road..
9 Construction of Barrage cum Bridge across The bridge constructions found to be good. Many people are utilizing this route and finding it 10.12.2022
Mullamari rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli Gate construction was going on during the visit. time-saving, and useful for agriculture, local villagers
village in Chincholi Taluka for transportation.
10 Construction of OHT and Pipeline at As per the information received and from observation, The people are using and finding easy and useful 10.12.2022
Vadatyatanda in Chincholi taluk work had been done by JJM(ZP) as mentioned on the
tank and not by KKRDB.
Yadgir
1 Provision of additional 4 class rooms and also The quality of the construction of the 4 rooms founds Congested conditions have been improved, and the 08.12.2022
construction of toilets to Govt. Women First to be good with no cracks or damages found. During facility is now able to accommodate the students
Grade College, Yadgir visit the painting process was going on adequately. Having sufficient space and facilities for
students to utilize the resources effectively and have a
comfortable learning environment.
2 Construction of compound for Chincholi Govt The construction of the compound wall found to be After the construction of the compound, outside 17.12.2022
High School, Surpur taluk good with no cracks & damages. individuals are no longer coming to the area.
Previously, they would use the space for drinking and
smoking purposes. This change indicates that the
construction of the compound has effectively
restricted access and deterred unwanted activities in
the area.
3 Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) As per observation the cylinders are Provided and are Easily available to the patients in hospital during 08.12.2022
of good quality. emergency.
4 Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for boys/girls As per observation, Water proofing work is done and stakeholders mentioning about water purifier 08.12.2022
and post-matric and pre-matric boys/girls hostels found to be good. No leaks were been observed problems for drinking water which is not working
of District Backward Classes and Minorities and from many months.
Social Welfare Department Model Residential
School (Navodaya).
5 Construction of box culvert on Anapura Marg of The construction work not started. It looks old. Work was not started 09.12.2022
Karanigi village
6 Bridge construction for the road heading to As per observation, The quality found to be not Local people says that the sides of the road are not 08.12.2022
scheduled caste field from Basavanna temple of satisfactory due to the side culverts are not built constructed properly as water comes on the road in
Belagera village through village tank properly. During rainy season water will flow on the rainy season.
road.
7 Construction (pending) activities of indoor During the visit the work was completed 90% Improving in sports activities and founds to be useful 09.12.2022
stadium of Shahapur town for the Public
8 Construction of walking path near indoor The construction of the pathway found to be good The local people are utilizing the facility better 09.12.2022

118 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

stadium in Shahapur town quality.

9 Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi During visit, the work was under progress. Outside people can use this facility during their visit 17.12.2022
Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana, and will be useful at much lower cost
Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk.
10 Giving drinking water supply to Vandganur As per observation, work was not started. Drinking water facility are not provided. 17.12.2022
village of Shorapur taluk
Bellary
1 Construction of 2 class rooms and compound for The quality of the construction of the 1 class room and Congested conditions have been improved, and the 07-02-2023
Vivekananda Government High School, Ranipet, compound is satisfactory with no cracks or damages facility is now able to accommodate the students
Hospet found. As per the work order there are two room to be adequately. Outside people are not entering in to the
constructed but constructed only one room had been campus because of compound construction.
constructed.
2 Construction of additional 2 class rooms, clean The quality of the construction of the 2 class rooms The facility is now able to accommodate the students 30-01-2023
drinking water unit and smart class for and compound found to be satisfactory. Drinking adequately.
Government High School, Regulator Camp, water facility work was done by Unnati scheme not
Kampli under KKRDB during visit.
3 Construction of new class room for Government The quality of the construction of the new class room The facility is now able to accommodate the students 09-01-2023
High School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, found to be satisfactory. As per observation black adequately. Students and Staffs found that board
Jagalur MLA constituency board quality is not good so unable to write. quality is not good.
Classroom window hinges already broken.
4 Supply of computers to Government High The computers supplied are found to be in working Will get useful to the students after installation, where 25-01-2023
School, Elubenchi village condition and of good quality. Installation has not they can practice and learn computer skills.
done and UPS facility not provided
5 Supply of sports equipment to Government High As per observations, 4 computers are provided in the Staffs and Students are requesting to provide sports 06-01-2023
School, Thimmalapura village school. Sports materials are not provided. The money materials. Computers are being used by the students
is refunded back to department to learn the computer language.
6 Construction of toilets for both boys and girls at As per observations, the quality of the toilets is not In schools, toilet facility given but there is no water 09-01-2023
Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16th satisfactory. Toilet doors latches are broken and supply provided.
Ward, Hagaribommanahalli Town founds to be Poor quality.
7 Regular Ambulance As per observations the ambulances are provided and During emergency, people are finding easy available 26-01-2023
its Working functional of ambulance.
8 Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & Bund Work at The quality of the work founds to be satisfactory. People finding comfortable sitting in the gallery. 26-01-2023
District Stadium, Bellary Facility is good.
9 Construction of bridge for the stream near As per observations, the quality of bridge founds to be People are using this bridge and found to be useful. 25-01-2023
Kalamma temple, Tekkalakote town satisfactory but they need to clear the demolished but not cleared old demolished materials.
materials.
10 Road development from Katrahalli cross to The development of the road founds to be satisfactory. The road is good, it saves time. 09-01-2023

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 119

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Geddalagatte
Koppal
1 Sapling of trees along the Kapilateertha Road, As per observations, Saplings of trees work not started It’s good for sapling tress after the construction. As it 27-01-2023
starts from Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk (From due to ongoing road construction work. Amounthas is tourism, village be developed.
Forest Department) paid for Forest department therefore they mentioned
financially completed
2 Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre- As per observation, the fixing floor tiles works is fund flooring tiles is good, painting has to be done but 28-01-2023
University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga to be good. But scraps were not cleared from the scrap or old demolished materials are not removed.
MLA Constiuency campus location looks unclean
3 Providing clean drinking water unit to High The water quality found to be satisfactory. Earlier getting from outside was difficult for both 28-01-2023
School, Sirur village, Yalburga MLA drinking and cooking, now the facility is easy.
Constiuency
4 Construction of Anganavadi in Ward 33 (Ward The construction of the works is good and found to be People are using this and finds useful. 30-01-2023
29), Gangawati Town, Gangawati MLA satisfactory
Constiuency
5 Providing high -mask, raising school compound, As per observation, Work quality is satisfactory Staffs and Students are happy with the facility. 27-01-2023
levelling field, toilets and other equipment to However it is observed that instead of high masking,
Government Model Higher Primary School, the agency has constructed smart class, a single large
Hanumanala room for conducting programmes, a toilet and installed
10 solar lights in the school campus..
6 Tata Technologies Lab and Workshops at The quality of the infrastructure provided is good and It’s found to be useful to the students. More practical 27-01-2023
Government Industrial Training Institute located are in working condition. exposure and hands on experience will be benefitted
at Kalyana Karnataka Region for us.
7 Construction of Proposed 300 Bedded SJICR As per observations, Work was not started Under Will get benefitted if 300 beds will provide at the 27-01-2023
Hospital at Kalaburagi. progress, though the budget Is allocated. Bed hasn’t earliest.
provided till the completion.
8 Fitting wiring coat to hard passage at Kidadura The work quality found to be satisfactory, but they The road connectivity is being useful and finds 27-01-2023
village have not cleared the old materials. useful.
9 Construction of road from State Highway 130 The quality of the road construction found to be Road construction from Kudarikotagi to PG center 28-01-2023
(Kudarikotagi) to PG Centre and also fixing satisfactory. done, require bus facility.
street lights from Yalburga to PG Centre,
Yalburga taluk
10 Construction of Indoor Stadium at As per observation, the work is under progress. As the Good, Indoor stadium work under process 27-01-2023
Hanumasagara soil condition is weak (BC Soil) also during monsoon
season couldn’t process the work, The probable work
completion date will be on 30.07.2023
Raichur

120 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

1 Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School The quality of the infrastructure founds to be Students were facing difficulty to enter in this 30-01-2023
in PWD camp (Proposed Temporary Govt satisfactory. campus. Requested to shift to the new building at the
Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur taluka of earliest.
Raichur Dist.
2 Construction of Stadium for Government High As per observations, there was no Stadium Students are using this facility properly. Playing in 31-01-2023
School, Balaganoora town, Maski MLA constrcucted. Only a school playground is found to be the ground.
Constituency existing.
3 Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for As per observations, the construction done for degree The lab facility is good and it is useful for the 31-01-2023
Government Pre-University College, Maski college not for pre universities. students for practical.
Town
4 Construction of Veterinary Hospital at The construction quality is good and the work is still No need to travel for long distance for check up 31-01-2023
Byagavata village, Manavi Taluk under progress
5 Development of tank/lake is located at centre of The quality of construction is found to be good. Good, easy access for the villagers for their need 31-01-2023
Lingsugur town (Part -4)
6 Estimate for Shifting of 33KV Single Circuit As per observation the shifting has been done and Shifting is done and people finds it is safe now 30-01-2023
Line from 110kV/33/11kV Sindhanur Muss to founds to be in working condition. compared to earlier.
Kurkunda 33/11kV Muss near Eluragi village Sy
No.7 for construction of Proposed Govt
Kendriya Vidyalaya near Eluragi village,
Sindhanur.
7 Construction of bridge between Navalakal and As per observation, the quality is not satisfactory. Travelling to other side of the village found to be 31-01-2023
Maratha, Manvi taluk easier but quality seems to be not good.
8 Construction of Stadium in Manvi town The quality of the stadium founds to be satisfactory After construction work complete, local people can 31-01-2023
(continued) and work is still under progress. use this place regularly for playing and health fitness
9 Drinking water pipeline works from Hattigudda As per observations, there is no water supply to the No water supply provided to this pipeline 31-01-2023
to Vagaranala village, Maski MLA Constituency pipelines even after construction work completed
10 Construction of clean drinking water unit at As per observation, the construction of clean drinking There is no clean drinking water. Filter not repaired 01-02-2023
Kortakunda village, Raichur taluk water unit is found to be satisfactory but filter is not from many months.
functioning properly.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 121

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9.1.1 Health
Local communities are satisfied with the health sector, especially with supporting community
health centres. This facility helps people who are travelling long distances for treatment.
Earlier patients used to travel to district headquarters for treatment, presently with the help of
KKRDB initiatives several CHCs and PHCshave been constructed with labs, equipment,
ambulances, additional doctors, nurses, toilets and so on. However, some constructions are
pending as per example at Santapura community health centre in Aurad taluk, the
construction of Proposed 300 Bedded SJICR Hospital at Kalaburagi, the creation of
additional manifold and Upgradation of 72 bedded ICU wards at BRIMS Bidar and
Construction of the Veterinary Hospital at Byagavata village, Mavi Taluk. Such projects will
help to treat people locally. During the study visit, we found some challenges such as lack of
Quarters for Doctors, Nurses and Staff at the hospitals and PHCs, due to this they are unable
to provide treatment as and when required. Currently, the facilities provided are limited as
compared to requirements. Similarly, laboratories are set up at some places which don’t have
emergency services like CT scan, MRI, Dialysis etc. Children care units are found to be less.

122 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

Table 32 : Sector-wise findings and recommendations (Health)

Sl.
Districts Work Name Key Findings Recommendations
No
1 Bellary/Bellary Regular ambulance This work is completed under Macro Scheme. In this scheme, DHO Funds must be provided for operation and
region purchased 10 ambulances during Covid-19 and all are distributed to taluk maintenance.
hospitals coming under the Bellary district. These ambulances provide
free services during health emergency and highly helpful during the
pandemic. The health officials and local people have appreciated this
scheme.
2 Bidar, Aurad Construction (pending) of This is a micro project, currently under progress. During the field visit, it Presently the construction work is getting
Santapura community was 50 % completed. The local communities in Santapura village were delayed. Therefore, construction work
health centre in Aurad happy about the work. Because earlier they used to travel to Bidar and tobe speed up. In addition, staff quarters
taluk Humnabad for the treatment. With these initiatives, people can get and an ambulance may be provided to
treatment locally. It saves not only people life but also money and time. Santapura community health centre.
Many poor people will get the facilities locally.
3 Kalaburagi, Construction of staff Work is under progress but materials like bricks, sand, cement, iron and The work must be completed as soon as
Sedam quarters for Group C and other required construction materials are made available. Construction is possible. In addition, 4-5 staff must be
D (2 BHK -05) at Primary yet to start. It will be helpful to Group C and D employees. Those who recruited for Kodla Primary Health
Health Centre, Kodla, are unable to pay rent outside due to low salaries. Moreover, if staff stay Centre, Sedam taluk.
Sedam taluk. nearby, it will be helpful to doctors and patients particularly pregnant
women during night time.
4 Koppal/Koppal Construction of Proposed SJICR is a macro project, currently work is under progress. After Work must be completed as soon as
region 300 Bedded SJICR completion it will be helpful to local people those who used to travel to possible.
Hospital at Kalaburagi Bengaluru for the treatment related to cardiovascular.
5 Raichur/Manvi Construction of Construction of veterinary hospital is under progress, presently 60 % of Work must be completed as soon as
Veterinary Hospital at the work is completed. This initiative will be helpful to farmers who are possible and also provide the Doctors and
Byagavata village, Mavi rearing livestock. Cattle diseases will be treated locally. This veterinary staff at the hospital. In addition, training
Taluk hospital will be helpful to produce milk and also boost local economy. on livestock disease management and also
Artificial insemination and other services are provided locally. Veterinary dairy farming will be helpful to local
hospital at Byagavata will be helpful for women to get involve in dairy farmers.
farming.
6 Yadgir Oxygen Cylinders Oxygen cylinders are supplied to Government District Hospital, Yadgir. May be provide other basic facilities like
(jumbo) This is macro work and presently completed. Patients are getting trolleys, space for storage and
benefitted from new additional oxygen cylinders during health operators/staffs. In addition, the additional
emergency. Health officials felt happy with this work because oxygen funds can be provided for operation and
cylinder was a shortage earlier. maintenance.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 123

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9.1.2 Education
KKRDB in the year 2021-22 funded various programmes related to education such as
providing grant to library, purchasing computers, desks, additional building and new
classrooms and smart classrooms, school compounds, toilets etc. Many of the schemes are
impressive to Kalyana Karnataka because students and teachers used to travel far distances to
get college level education. Presently, many of the projects are constructed at villages and
ward level and at small towns. Example, Providing TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop
at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region, Construction of additional two classrooms to
Govt. High School at Belur Village in Basavakalyan taluka, providing 40 computers and
basic facilities to Govt. Degree college located adjacent to Ashraya colony and Kalluratanda
in Afzalpur taluk and construction of compound for Chincholi Govt High School, Surpur
taluk Students, teachers and parents are happy as they are getting professional/job-oriented
courses locally. Girl students in particular are happier with these KKRDB initiatives because
it helps them to improve their educational levels. Earlier there were many school/college
dropout students in the village. During the study we have observed some challenges such as
lack of public transport, quality roads, streetlights, water at public toilets, unhygienic
situations, and other items like stationeries, libraries.

124 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

Table 33 : Sector-wise findings and recommendations (Education)

Sl. No. District/Taluk Work Name Key Findings Recommendations
1 Bellary/Bellary Supply of computers to • Government High School, Elubenchi village has 350 It is recommended that, additional fifty
Government High School, students and supplied only 2 computers. They are to be used (50) computers along with UPS facilitiesbe
Elubenchi village by both students and teachers. supplied.
• According to teachers, the school building is shifting to a
new place and then they plan to use the computers, but at
present the computer was not in use.
• As stated by the teacher, school has more than 350 students.
It needs more computer to match the students’ strength.
2 Bellary/Bellary Supply of sports equipment to • The Government High School, Thimmalapura village It is suggested to complete the computer
Government High School, Bellary has enrolled around 300 students in different installation work, which is pending at
Thimmalapura village classes. present and also provide twenty (20)
• As per the information from the school teacher they have additional computers and UPS facilities
received 5 computers and sports items through KKRDB
initiatives /programme.
• At present computers are not installed. .
3 Bellary/Harappana Construction of new class room • As stated by the teacher during the primary survey at It is suggested to construct a new
halli for Government High School, Government High School, Kambattalli, (Harappanahalli additional room for the kitchen along with
Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk), there are around 240 students studying in the school. dining hall for the Mid Day meal
Taluk, Jagalur MLA • The newly constructed school building has helped to (Bisioota).,
constituency increase the school strength compared to the previous
student’s strength.
• Due to the increase of students in the school, there is a
requirement of additional room for the kitchen with a dining
hall facility for the Mid Day meal (Bisioota)
4 Bellary/HB Halli Construction of toilets for both • The schoolhas received a grant for the construction of a The school needs a water connection and
boys and girls at Government toilet and water storage tank within the school premises and supply to the school premises.
High School, KVOR Colony, constructed the same.
16th Ward, Hagaribommanahalli • But in spite of the constructionof a toilet and water storage
Town tank they are still unable to use them due to the lack of
water connectionand supply of water from the
Hagaribommanaahlli municipality.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 125

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

5 Bellary/Hospet Construction of 2 class rooms • As pointed out by the teacher, the 2 new class rooms and It is suggested to construct one more
and compound for Vivekananda compound wall construction is there in work order, but only additional classroom.
Government High School, one room constructed along with compound wall.
Ranipet, Hospet • Before construction of compound wall, the public were
using the school premises for their personal activity
(Playing cards, playing games (sports), drinking alcohol
etc), but now (after construction of wall) such incidents are
not reported.
• The construction of new school building also helped to
increase the school strength. Earlier, the number of student
enrolment was 200 students, but after new building was
constructed under the KKRDB initiative, the number of
students enrolmentincreased to 250.
6 Bellary/Hospet Construction of additional 2 • Government High School, Kampli, (Hospet Bellay) has a It is suggested to provide drinking water
class rooms, clean drinking strength of 200 students which includes the 1st standard to facilities to the schoolas sanctioned in the
water unit and smart class for 7th standard. previous work order.
Government High School, • Under the KKRDB initiatives two new classrooms are
Regulator Camp, Kampli constructed and one classroom is used for the smart class at
present.
• In the current work order drinking water unit was
sanctioned but it has not been constructed.
7 Bidar, Basvakalyan Construction of Additional Two • The additional two classrooms to Govt. High School have
Classrooms to Govt. High been constructed and both classrooms are used by the
School at Belur Village in school.
Basavakalyan Taluka. • As pointed out by the school teacher, the school has enough
space now (after construction of classrooms) compare to
earlier, students and teachers feeling happy and they pointed
out that the construction of classrooms helped to attract
more students to school, and motivates teachers to teach the
students.
8 Bidar, Bidar Providing TATA Technologies • The TATA Technologies Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI in It is suggested to take necessary action to
Region Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI Bidar work is still under progress, and 20% equipments are supply rest 80% of the equipmentsas early
in Kalyana Karnataka Region provided. Trainers are happy with the work; they think it as possible.
will be helpful for them to learn many new and creative
tasks if rest of the 80% equipments provided to Lab.

126 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

9 Bidar, Humnabad Library and furniture facility to • Improved the existing library, books and almirah (cupboard)
Pre metric hostels at Humnabad are provided. The books include general knowledge,
town textbooks and competitive books. The students are getting
benefited from the project.
10 Kalaburagi, Providing 40 computers and • 40 computers are provided and several facilities are given
Afzalpur basic facilities to Govt. Degree such as tables, chairs, UPS, internet connection.
college located adjacent to • All the enrolled degree students are getting benefitted from
Ashraya colony and the same,
Kalluratanda in Afzalpur taluk • Two computer training teachers are working. Students are
getting motivated due to free and good computer training
and their services at their local place.
11 Kalaburagi, Purchasing 30 reversible desks, • All the mentioned infrastructure is given to ITI. Presently all
Chincholi 5 computers, 2 printers and 2 are in working condition and helping the students in
computer tables for computer education.
Kunchavaram ITI college in
Chincholi taluk
Kalaburagi, Providing TATA Technologies • Advanced technology equipment is received at lab, which It is suggested to create more awareness
Kalaburagi Region Lab and Workshop at Govt. ITI includes electrical vehicle, lorry, and so on. 2 Robots are among the women candidates about the
in Kalyana Karnataka Region available, and they are using for welding purposes. Machine training and its benefits to attract more
coded system is used to provide training to the students. women for the enrolment for the training.
• Teaching computer-based programming using the advance
equipments.
• Two wheelers are provided (both electrical and petrol
based) for the training purpose. Most of the trainees are
utilizing the services.
• Ensured jobs in TATA for the students, those who are
completed training from the ITI College. Initially, it was
planned that the ITI training for women, but, most of the
women candidates are not aware of the benefits. And also
due to less admission, presently allowed men for to enroll
and avail the training.
• This programme is highly job oriented, and helpful for self-
employment and completely skill based. 3D printing and
laser cutting facility is available in ITI.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 127

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

12 Koppal/Gangavathi Construction of Anganavadi in • The Anganwadi constructed in ward no 35 is very useful

Ward 33 (Ward 29), Gangawati and the majority of the PouraKarmikara childrenare availing
Town, Gangawati MLA the benefits. At present, there are about 20 to 30 students.
Constiuency The newly constructed Anganwadi is also helpful and
provides facilities for pregnant ladies and newborn babies.
13 Koppal/Koppal Tata Technologies Lab and • Before the KKRDB initiatives, the students were going to
region Workshops at Government different cities travelling longer distance to avail the
Industrial Training Institute training. But, after the KKRDB programme, equipment is
located at Kalyana Karnataka provided and trainers are happy with the work; most of them
Region said that the initiative is helpful for them to learn many new
and creative skills by using advanced tool given by the
KKRDB project.
14 Koppal/Kushtagi Providing high mask, raising • Theschool has around 250 to 300 students. Work order is
school compound, levelling given for high mask light, but they installed only 10 solar
field, toilets and other equipment lights. Additionally, through KKRDB project they have
to Government Model Higher constructed one smart class (Work order was not issued).
Primary School, Hanumanala And also changed two rooms into a single room for
conducting program.
15 Koppal/Yalburga Floor tiles fixing work at • Currently student enrolment is good and around 200 to 300 It is suggested to provide funds to repaint
Government Pre-University students are studying in the college, the student strength has the buildings of the college and also water
College, Balutagi Village, increased because of KKRDB project. College requested for connection and supply for the toilet within
Yalburga MLA Constiuency painting for the college buildings. the college premises.
• Toilet rooms are built, but no water connections are given.

16 Koppal/Yalburga Providing clean drinking water • Drinking water RO Plant is working in good condition.
unit to High School, Sirur Students are using filtered water for drinking purpose and
village, Yalburga MLA water also used for Bisioota preparation.
Constiuency
17 Raichur/Lingsugur Construction of 2 Laboratory • The Government Pre-University College, Maski town has One more new class room to be
rooms for Government Pre- sanctioned for two rooms but they have constructed only constructed as soon as possible.
University College, Maski Town one room.

128 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

18 Raichur/Sindhnoor Construction of Stadium for • The leveling of land work is completed.

Government High School, • Before KKRDB initiative, water was lacking in the stadium
Balaganoora town, Maski MLA was common phenomena. This was creating major issue to
Constituency the students for using stadium for different sports activities.
• The construction of stadium has helped students in better
way and most of the students are availing the benefits from
the initiatives.
Raichur/Sindhnoor Providing Infrastructure to Govt • Infrastructure is provided for Kendriyavidyalaya for Action must be taken to start the work at
Adarsh School in PWD camp temporary purpose. Already land is allocated for the earliest and complete project, so that
(Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriyavidyala near Eluragi. But construction work not the students can avail the benefits.
Kendriyavidyalaya) of started.
Sindhanur taluka of Raichur
Dist.
19 Yadgir Provision of additional 4 class • As per the request, there are 4 rooms constructed, a capacity
rooms and also construction of of 60 each along with 8 toilets.
toilets to Govt. Women First • The infrastructure is helping, almost 504 women students
Grade College, Yadgir and teachers are happy with the classrooms and toilets
facilities.
• The additional facilities are helping to increase the students
enrolment,
20 Yadgir Construction of compound for • Before construction of the compound, neighboring
Chincholi Govt High School, peoplewere encroaching on the land for house construction.
Surpur taluk School compound has helped to control the land encroaches.
Compound has also helped in preventing entry of the
grazing animals and also maintain cleanliness.
• Students are feeling safe from outsiders and livestock
especially cattle and pet animals.
• Almost 300 students are getting benefitted. School is
growing vegetables, which will be used for mid-day meals.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 129

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9.1.3 Infrastructure
Infrastructure includes construction and repairs of roads, bridges, foot paths and so on.
KKRDB took up a good number of projects in the year 2021-22. Constructing &connecting
roads and bridges is helping people to communicate between and among villages and towns
in the regions. For Example, construction of a bridge between Navalakal and Maratha, Manvi
taluk, construction of road from State Highway 130 (Kudarikotagi) to PG Centre and also
fixing street lights from Yalburga to PG Centre, Yalburga taluk and bridge construction on
Aurad (S) village road from Bidar-Munnakhelli main road. Many business activities are
progressing after initiatives of KKRBD works in the region. Due to developing roads, public
transport has been increased. It is directly helping students going to schools and colleges in
the region. In certain places tourism activities have improved. Upgradation of roads helps to
improve institutional deliveries, access to good hospitals and markets. Socio-cultural
activities are enhanced. Bridge construction facilitates to commute during the rainy season. It
is observed that due to lack of understanding, some local people opposed road construction
and widening in certain places. This may hinder the growth, therefore developing trust with
local people and creating awareness amongst them about the benefits will certainly help
speeding up the works. In some places beneficiaries complained about not maintaining
quality and using good material while constructing the roads.

130 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

Table 34 : Sector wise findings and recommendations (Infrastructure)

Sl. No. District Work Name Key Findings Recommendations

1 Bellary/Kudligi Road development from • The road development from Katrahalli cross to
Katrahalli cross to Geddalagatte (Road wide is 7 meter and 3.5 inch.) will
Geddalagatte provide connectivity between the two villages and provide
the access to services.
• The road constructed by the PWD through KKRDB
porgramme, is very good and good quality of materials are
used for construction.
2 Bellary/Sirguppa Construction of bridge for • The construction of bridge to Kalamma temple, Construction of the bridge needs to be
the stream near Kalamma Tekkalakote town is located in the centre of the city. completed early so that it provides give
temple, Tekkalakote town Before construction of the bridge, the ground level was very better access for the villagers to the
low and water was logging in the same area. The public towns.
were unable to pass through from the same road.
• The construction, of the bridge increased access to the
public and it is connecting KampliHampiGangavti and
Shiraguppa in Tekkalakote town.
3 Bidar, Humnabad Bridge construction on • Almost 80 % of the work is completed. Presently people are Rest of the pending work (20 %) to be
Aurad (S) village road using the services with restrictions. completed at the earliest, so that, the
from Bidar-Munnakhelli • There was a problem to commute during the rainy season, road will be free for public use.
main road. due to water flow on the roads, and people used to wait
until the water level recedes to cross the road.
• Presently it is helping several people especially during the
rainy season.
4 Kalaburagi, Construction of Barrage • Barrage cum bridge, work is completed almost 80%, and Action is to be taken to complete the
Chincholi cum Bridge across presently not allowed for public use. Materials are brought remaining 20 percent at the earliest.
Mullamari rivers between but needs to be installed/fixed.
Kanakpur-Garmpalli
village in Chincholi
Taluka

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 131

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

5 Koppal/Yalburga Construction of road from • Road quality is good and street lights are fixed. The new
State Highway 130 road is constructed from Kudarikotagi to PG centre.
(Kudarikotagi) to PG • The feedback for the new road is good and there are no
Centre and also fixing problems at the moment.
street lights from Yalburga
to PG Centre, Yalburga
taluk
6 Raichur/Manvi Construction of bridge • The Navalakal and Maratha, bridge work is completed and
between Navalakal and this bridge is connecting Shirvar and Navalkal. Before this
Maratha, Manvi taluk bridge, the peoples wee travelling from Shirvara road and
because of the new bridge the travel time reduced and given
the direct access to Navalkal villagers.
7 Yadgir, Yadgir Construction of box • Box culvert cum bridge constructed across the stream
culvert on Anapura Marg (Karangi to Anapura) is completed. The connectivity has
of Karanigi village been improved between the villages. It is highly helpful
during the rainy season for two villages having almost 3500
population. It is helping to improve local business for the
villagers.
8 Yadgir, Yadgir Bridge construction for the • The construction of the bridge work is completed. Earlier
road heading to scheduled there was no proper access to the SC/ST farmer’s field.
caste field from Basavanna Because of the KKRDB program, the new bridge has been
temple of Belagera village constructed and is helping almost 150 SC/ST farmers by
through village tank giving them access to their agriculture fields.

132 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

9.1.4 Agriculture/irrigation
Agriculture sector covers developing tanks, desilting tank, raising tank level, fencing the
tanks, storage of water for livestock drinking, canal development and so on. For example,
improvement of Ghodavadi tank in Humnabad taluk, construction of check dam cum CC
Road on Kamalavati river, construction of check dam on local streams of Kadacharla village
and improvement of Madana village tank in Sedam taluk and development of tank/lake
(continued) located at centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4). These initiatives are really helping
the farmers in certain areas. Many of the farmers are getting water for growing second crop in
their field which is directly helping to improve their income and social status and also
agricultural production in the region. In addition, groundwater level has increased by 200-300
ft from 400-500 ft. Fencing the tanks helps to maintain cleanliness. Construction of water
regulator to tanks helps to use the water sustainably. Check dam construction is helping to
recharge ground water at various patches of the agricultural fields. Presently works are
limited under agriculture, many more such schemes including training and field
demonstration to farmers on sustainable use of water is required.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 133

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 35 : Sector wise finding and recommendations (Agriculture/Irrigation)

Sl. No District/taluk Work Name Key Findings Recommendations

1 Bidar/Humnabad Improvement of This is a micro project, currently under progress, so far 70% of It is recommended to complete the remaining work of
Godavari tank in the work is completed. Fencing has been provided for the tank. Ghodavari tank as early as possible. In addition,
Humnabad taluk Improvement of this Godavari tank is helping to recharge stakeholders suggest that, flowing of municipal water to
nearby borewells. Ground water level has been elevated by the tank must be prevented. Local people recommending
200-300 ft from 400-500 ft. The main purpose of the tank is to to improving the tank as an ecotourism place. It is
provide water for irrigation. After completion of this tank, the suggested to provide lightings in the evening and open
farmers near tank will get 2 crops per year. This work maintains gym for daily users.
the cleanliness in the surrounding areas.
2 Bidar, Basvakalyan Improvement to Under this project, water regulator is constructed to Kamshetty Action be taken not to allow the municipal water to the
Kamshetty Talab tank to benefit the downstream farmers. Due to this project, tank and also provide fencing for the tank and park. The
tank bund at Hulsoor presently farmers are getting minimum 2 crops per year. They additional allocation is required for operation and
taluka of Bidar are happy with the work. The farming land nearby the tank is maintenance.
District. getting water logged due to seepage and farmers are
complaining to rectify it. In addition, this work is helping
livestock for water, groundwater recharge, and many other
purposes. While executing the work locally available labourers
were used to provide short-term employment. The economy of
the local people is improving. Out-migration is reduced.
3 Kalaburagi/ Sedam Construction of Among 2 check dams, 1 is completed and 1 is under progress, Funds to be provided for operation and maintenance such
check dam cum CC CC road construction is under progress. The purpose of as leakages, damages and de-siltation. There should be a
Road on Kamalavati constructing check dam is to store water for irrigation. The restriction on the movement of heavy vehicles on CC
river, construction of construction of CC road is to commute and connecting the roads.
check dam on local villages (kadacharla to Garampally to Kanakapura).Madanakere
streams of work is under progress: improvement work on stopping
Kadacharla village leakages, damages, raising the tank height and others are
and improvement of planned under this programme. This will help farmers to
Madana village tank cultivate crops and livestock for drinking water largely. The
in Sedam taluk. groundwater level in the borewells located near to check dams
will get recharged.
4 Raichur/Lingsugur Development of This work is completed and inaugurated on 6-2-2023. The Action be taken not to allow the municipal water to the
tank/lake is located stakeholders said that the quality of the work looks good and it tank and also provide fencing for the tank and park. The
at centre of has aesthetic appeal in the town. Moreover, they have additional allocation is required for operation and
Lingsugur town developed a park at the tank which is highly appreciated by the maintenance.
(Part -4) local people. Park is used for entertainment and walking in the
morning and evening.

134 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

9.1.5 Social infrastructure/drinking water/Sports/Others

KKRDB projects for giving drinking water supply to Vandganur village of Shorapur taluk,
construction of clean drinking water unit at Kortakunda village, Raichur taluk, construction
of OHT and Pipeline at Vadatyatanda in Chincholi taluk, construction of Stadium in Manvi
town (continued), Providing and Fixing open gym Equipments and construct open yoga
Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi Guest House in Kalaburagi city, park development at Ward no 24
Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk and so on
executing in the year 2021-22. All the said projects are meant to strengthen the local
communities and boost the local economy. Most of the women interviewed are happy with
the work such as drinking water supply to their villages because it saves their time and energy
which was used for collecting drinking water. The time saved can be utilized to teaching
children, cooking, agriculture work and so on. Further, social status and networking will be
improved and also out migration will be reduced.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 135

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Table 36 : Sector wise finding and recommendations (Social infrastructure/drinking water/Sports/Others)

Sl.
Districts Work Name Key Findings Recommendations
No
Drinking Water

1 Bidar/Humnabad Drilling borewell and providing Borewells drilled and supplying drinking to villages, and all Action be taken to provide direct tap water
motor to Shedola, Chandanahally, are in working condition. All borewells are drilled within the collection to their homes instead of
Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi vicinity only. Some outside people are also getting water from collecting at community points, as
villages of Humnabad taluk the borewell. Most of the women are happy with the work suggested by most Women
because their travel distance and time is reduced.
2 Kalaburagi/Chincholi Construction of OHT and Pipeline at Providing one-time drinking water facilities to about 30 Action be taken to provide direct tap water
Vadatyatanda in Chincholi taluk households. Before this, people used to go long distances to connection to their homes instead
bring water and depended on tank and other nalas where water connecting at community points.
was untreated. Presently all the beneficiaries are happy with
the services, it will improve their health condition. It also
reduced the work of women who used to go long distances to
fetch drinking water.
3 Raichur/Raichur Construction of clean drinking water The work completed 100 % and demo also given about water Action be taken to appoint a knowledgeable
unit at Kortakunda village, Raichur filter. But as per local people opinion this is not filtering machine operator. In addition, allocate
taluk properly. The knowledgeable operator is not appointed. The additional funds to regular cleaning and
machine is not open for public use but it is still under demo changing the filters frequently.
stage.
4 Raichur/Sindhnoor Drinking water pipeline works from This work completed and water supply pipeline is given to two
Hattigudda to Vagaranala village, villages. It is using for Drinking water purpose.
Maski MLA Constituency
5 Yadgir/Shorapur Giving drinking water supply to Drilled borewell and supplying drinking water to village, there
Vandganur village of Shorapur taluk is no overhead tank facility, supplying water directly to
common collection centres. Replaced the old water system
with new one. Point collection facility is made, there are 6
points in the village. Water is provided twice a day. Almost
800 households with a population of nearly 2500 people are
getting benefit. Largely women are happy by this service
because they used travel long distances to collect the drinking
water.

136 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

Sports and Tourism

6 Koppal/Kushtagi Construction of Indoor Stadium at Indoor stadium work is under progressand 60% work is Action be taken to complete the pending
Hanumasagara completed. This indoor stadium is to be used for basketball works of indoor stadium at Hanumasagara,
and Shuttle badminton. It helps local players and boost the Koppal, Manvi town, Raichur and Khustagi
local sports Taluk, Koppala District. Currently, the
indoor stadium doesn’t have kitchen
7 Raichur/Manvi Construction of Stadium in Manvi Under this project 60% work is completed. Construction of facilities. The operation and maintenance
town (continued) sitting gallery and Pavilion work and roofing work is under cost are required for paying electricity and
progress. water bills. Maintenance staff needs to be
appointed.
8 Yadgir/ Shahapur Construction (pending) activities of Indoor playground is ready with all the services. People are
indoor stadium of Shahapur town using this for morning walk. It has a capacity of roughly 2000
people. It is monitored by Nehru Yuvaka Kendra.
9 Yadgir/ Shahapur Construction of walking path near Walking path of about 800 m is constructed surrounding Action be taken to plant the trees all along
indoor stadium in Shahapur town stadium. Tiles are used for the construction of walking path. the walking path.
Nearly 200-300 people are using it every day. Senior
citizensare coming here for walking, they are feeling safe.

10 Yadgir/Shorapur Construction of Tourist Guest house Tourist home is constructed and it is benefitting devotees Action be taken to increase the number of
near Sri Jadi Shantalingeshwara coming from lond distances. In the month of February and rooms and construct the public toilets and
Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura March every year a large number of devotees visit the place drinking water facilities.
Village, Shorapur taluk. for worshiping. The yatrinivas is free for devotees. Both
rooms and halls are constructed.
Others

11 Bellary/Bellary Upgradation of Sitting Gallery & The upgradation of sitting gallery & bund work at district
Bund Work at District Stadium, stadium in Bellary is completed and the program is well
Bellary received by the people.
The initiative is very good and respondents said that all the
sport persons are getting benefits by utilizing the stadium for
many different sports activities.
The running tracks are very useful, because daily students
and people are come for walking and playing and practice.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 137

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

12 Bidar, Basvakalyan Park development at Ward no 24 The sanctioned work is not yet completed and the execution is Action be taken to complete the work and
Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 in haphazard. open it up for the public use as early as
Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan possible.
taluk
13 Bidar, Bidar Region Upgradation of 72 beded ICU wards According to hospital in charge, all 72 beds are purchased and
at BRIMS Bidar. 50 beds are in use in the ICU, remaining 22 are kept in room
for emergency.
At the moment 50 beds are enough for the patient’s getting
admission. Doctors are happy with the project and patients are
making use of the services.

14 Kalaburagi, Supplying erection, testing and As mentioned by the official at Kalaburagi High Court, they
Kalaburagi commissioning of 2 TR AC’s with have received 6 chambers, but presently using 4 chambers and
Copper Tube &Refrigent gas, Power upgraded with AC, Refrigerators and other facilities. Judges
Supply, Cable, CPVC Drain Pipe are happy with the work, they expressed it will be helpful for
and allied accessories to Hon’ble working population in the court.
Judges Chambers No-1, 2 & 3 at
High Court Bench Kalaburagi.

15 Kalaburagi, Providing and fixing open gym Constructed open gym at guest house, yoga facility is
Kalaburagi Equipments and construct open yoga available, guests are using facility. Gym has cycling, thread
Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi Guest wheel, twisters, and many more equipments which are very
House in Kalaburagi city. useful for the guest who are visiting the guest house. Guest
house officials are very happy with project.

16 Kalaburagi, Construction (pending) of Construction of Memorial bhavan is completed, but it is not • Action be taken to complete the pending
Kalaburagi ShivasharanaraAmbigaraChowdaiah opened for the public use. Works at balcony is pending, chairs work (balcony) and furnishing needs to
Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi are to be arranged, AC works are completed. Authority is be provided.
asking Kitchen facility to rent the memorial bhavan for many • Action be taken to provideKitchen
other events. Electricity bills are pending, therefore, facility which will help to rent the
suggesting to provide solar facilities. Lacking in cleanliness memorial bhavan to many other events.
because of Poor maintenance. • Pending Electricity bills to be cleared
and solar facilities to be provided along
with man power for the maintenance of
Memorial bhavan.

138 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

17 Koppal/Kushtagi Fitting wiring coat to hard passage at The hard passage work helps for Kidadur village and Kustagi,
Kidadura village because this bridge gets damaged in rainy season so they filled
the coat for that bridge so now there is no problem.

18 Koppal/Kushtagi Sapling of trees along the The authorities said that the work is completed as they have In addition to planting, fencing, watering
Kapilateertha Road, starts from paid the amount to the Forest Department. Now road and care is required for next 3 years to
Kabbaragi, Kushtagi taluk (From construction work is going on and is yet to be completed. sustain the saplings.
Forest Department) Sapling work can be taken up only after the completion of
road work.
19 Raichur/Sindhnoor Estimate for Shifting of 33KV Single Shifting of 33Kv work completed from Kendriyavidyalaya
Circuit Line from 110kV/33/11kV premises to other land. This will help to start the construction
Sindhanur Muss to Kurkunda of Kendriyavidyala.
33/11kV Muss near Eluragi village
Sy No.7 for construction of Proposed
Govt Kendriya Vidyalaya near
Eluragi village, Sindhanur.
20 Yadgir, Yadgir Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for Work completed, Water proofing has been done, Currently, it
boys/girls and post-matric and pre- is under use and hostels utilizing effectively.
matric boys/girls hostels of District
Backward Classes and Minorities
and Social Welfare Department
Model Residential School
(Navodaya).

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 139

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

9.2 Key Recommendations

The purpose of this study is to assess the progress of the schemes under the KKRDB for the
year 2021-22. Totally, 2216 schemes were sanctioned for all the six districts in the region
under five sectors- Health, Education, Agriculture/Irrigation, Infrastructure and Social which
included drinking water facilities, sports and tourism including micro infrastructure projects
like construction of class rooms and laboratories for schools. Delays are noticed in the
execution of infrastructure works such as roads, bridges and other physical works. Overall,
we observed varied response like good, not good, satisfied, not satisfied, poor and work yet to
start (please refer the results and discussion section or Table 31). They however want certain
additional facilities and some specific action to be taken in respect of each work among 60
sample projects. Taking into account the feedback from the local people and our own
observations, the following recommendations are made for KKRD to actions in future.

Objective -I: To assess the number of works carried out by KKRDB across various sectors
such as health, education, agriculture, irrigation, roads and bridges, water supply, sanitation
etc., in 2021-22.

Recommendations

1. Based on the findings and observation from the projects Construction of new
classroom for Government High School, Kambattalli, Harappanahalli Taluk, Jagalur
MLA constituency and Construction of 2 Laboratory rooms for Government Pre-
University College, Maski Town, it is suggested to take up the projects related to
construction of additional classrooms in government school and colleges coming in
all the 6 districts because it will benefit the students a lot.
2. According to findings from a project, Supply of computers to Government High
School, Elubenchi village Bellary district, new action plans should consider
increasing the lab facilities with adequate computers in relevant Govt. High Schools
located in KKR.
3. Based on the findings from the project, Providing TATA Technologies Lab and
Workshop at Govt. ITI in Kalyana Karnataka Region, Kalaburagi, it is necessary to
take up an awareness programme to women so that they can make use of such a good

140 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

facility. Initially this project was designed for women only, due to their less
enrollment, presently made provision to men as well to take training.
4. According to findings from the project, Floor tiles fixing work at Government Pre-
University College, Balutagi Village, Yalburga MLA Constiuency, Koppal, it is
suggested to provide funds to repaint the buildings of the college and also supply
water for the toilets constructed within the college premises.

5. Based on the analysis of the projects belong to education sector, it is suggested

establish a Special Education Zones in Yadgir and Raichur districts with model
schools and infrastructure to provide quality education focusing on establishing
Science, Technology, Engineering & Math (STEM) labs. The present programme of
IT infrastructure to be oriented towards establishing STEM labs as per National
Education Policy 2020.
6. Analysis of the projects belong to health sector such as providing Regular ambulance
in Bellary and Construction (pending) of Santapura community health centre in Aurad
taluk, Bidar, shows 24/7 ambulance facilities are required to all the PHCs located in
the KKR to facilitate patients in rural areas to take to hospitals whenever emergency.
7. According to the analysis of the project, providing Oxygen Cylinders (jumbo) in
Yadgir, it is suggested to provide funds for other logistics like trolleys, space for
storage and operators/staffs. In addition, allot funds for operation and maintenance.
8. Under Irrigation sector, based on the observation from the project, Kamshetty Talab
tank bund at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District and Development of tank/lake located at
centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4) farmers complain about the entry of
municipal/sewage water into tanks. Action needs to be taken to prevent the flow of
such water into the tanks, also provide fencing to such projects.
9. Based on the analysis of the project Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri Jadi
Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk Yadgir, it
is suggested to take action to increase the number of rooms and construct the public
toilets and drinking water facilities at the tourist places which facilitates tourist and
promotes local tourism.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 141

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Objective -II: To examine the present status of work, completed and in progress.

Recommendations

1. With respect to Sports, construction of indoor stadiums is taken up. Unfortunately,

most of the projects such as Construction of Indoor Stadium at Hanumasagara.
Koppal, Construction of Stadium in Manvi town (continued) Raichur and
Construction (pending) activities of indoor stadium of Shahapur town Yadgir are
incomplete. Observations from these projects suggest that action must be taken to
complete them soon. Further, it must be ensured that they are provided adequate staff
to manage the stadium and necessary funds to meet the water and electricity charges.
2. Based on the observations of under progress projects such as Construction of Barrage
cum Bridge across Mullamari rivers between Kanakpur-Garmpalli village in
Chincholi Taluka, Providing Infrastructure to Govt Adarsh School in PWD camp
(Proposed Temporary Govt Kendriya vidyalaya) of Sindhanur taluka of Raichur,
Development of tank/lake located at centre of Lingsugur town (Part -4) etc., it is
recommended that a proper supervision and monitoring mechanism be put in place.
Senior officers must regularly monitor the progress under various schemes and take
corrective action to complete the work as early as possible.

Objective -III: To check the quality of works

Recommendations

The lab test conducted for the projects such as Construction (pending) of Santapura
community health centre in Aurad taluk Bidar, Construction of Tourist Guest house near Sri
Jadi Shantalingeshwara Hiremath Sansthana, Devapura Village, Shorapur taluk Yadgir, etc.,
shows satisfactory in the quality of materials using for constructions. Moreover, it is
necessary to strictly adhere to quality control measures which result in a high-quality and safe
for its intended use in school buildings, bridges and roads.

Some projects like Park development at Ward no 24 Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18
Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk, Bidar, Improvement to Kamshetty Talab tank bund
at Hulsoor taluka of Bidar District, Bidar and Construction of toilets for both boys and girls at
Government High School, KVOR Colony, 16th Ward, Hagaribommanahalli Town, Bellary
are not satisfied with the quality during our visit to the field. It was observed they were using

142 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Finding and Recommendations

low standard materials for construction. Therefore, it is suggested to give more attention for
monitoring by the competent authority.

Objective - IV: To examine the need and adequacy of allocation across various sectors
and beneficiary groups.

Recommendations

1. Under social and micro infrastructure projects such as Drilling borewell and providing
motor to Shedola, Chandanahally, Ghodavadi, Hilalapura and Jalasangi villages of
Humnabad taluk. Bidar and Construction of OHT and Pipeline at Vadatyatanda in
Chincholi taluk, Kalaburagi, drinking water facility is provided to the village. But
women of the villages were asking the direct tap water connection to the households.
Therefore, their suggestions can be considered during the preparation of action plans in
the future, either through KKRDB alone or in convergence with other projects like Jal
Jeevan Mission.
2. It is suggested to construct an additional kitchen along with dining hall for the Mid
Day meal (Bisioota) facilities in Government High School, Kambattalli,
Harappanahalli.
3. It is suggested to create more awareness programme for women candidates about the
job-oriented training programmes available freely or with limited fees
4. Based on the findings from the project, Supply of computers to Government High
School, Elubenchi village, Bellary, computers distributed to schools are not meeting
the students’ requirements, therefore it is suggested to increase the number of
computers to the Government Schools and Colleges in the Kalyana Karnataka Region.
5. Social infrastructure projects will strengthen the networking of Farmer Producer
Organizations and Self-Help Groups for promoting agro processing, and other
economic activities. Therefore, it is suggested to give at least 20-30% more importance
to such type of projects in the future when developing a new action plan, it will
certainly help the women beneficiaries.
6. A major lacuna of most of the projects of KKRDB is the absence of adequate funds for
operation and maintenance (O&M). Unless these facilities are not created in the
projects, their utilization is adversely affected. Hence it may be ensured that necessary
provision is made in the budget to enable an efficient use of O&M system.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 143

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Objectives -V: To provide suggestions for better allocation of funds in future action
plans as well.
Recommendations

Analysis of all the 60 projects shows that, micro level social category projects are performing
better in education, health, social infrastructure, drinking water, and other sectors (refer key
findings section for the list of projects). Moreover, these projects are meeting the demands of
local communities in the region. Therefore, it is recommended to increase at least 25-35 % or
more such micro level projects in the future action plans in all the 6 districts coming under
Kalyana Karmataka Region.

Objective- VI: To examine the immediate impact of the works undertaken during 2021-
22 in terms of benefit to the people and region.

Recommendations

1. Drinking water facility provided through pipelines and overhead tanks to villages
located in Bidar, Kalaburagi and Raichur have shown positive impacts among local
communities especially women members. Therefore, it is recommended to increase 30-
40% more such projects in all the districts where there is a need for drinking water.
2. Construction of walking footpath in Yadgir and Providing and fixing open gym
Equipment and construct open yoga Platform at Aiwan-E-Shahi Guest House in
Kalaburagi city. open gym at guest house, Construction (pending) of Shivasharanara
Ambigara Chowdaiah Memorial Bhavan at Kalaburagi, Park development at Ward no
24 Mahadevi colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath colony in Basavakalyan taluk, Bidar,
Construction of walking path near indoor stadium in Shahapur town, Yadgir etc., are
bringing the happiness among the users particularly the senior citizen. They are finding
the positive impacts such as health, recreation, social tie-ups etc., from the projects.
Therefore, it is recommended to increase at least 20-25 % of such projects in the cities
and towns in Kalyana Karnataka Region.
3. The present study suggests to take up a larger study on all the projects undertaken since
several years by KKRDB to assess the impacts, quality and longevity.
4. It is suggested to update the details of all the projects of KKRDB which are completed
and ongoing on ‘Project Portfolio Management System Software’. In addition, update
the details of approximate cost, Tender details, work start time, completion, pending
details etc in ‘work soft’ software from time to time.

144 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

10. LAB REPORT: QUALITY CHECK REPORT

Introduction: The lab test report presents the results of the quality check conducted on the
construction of School buildings, Bridges and roads in different districts like Kalaburgi,
Bidar, Yadgir, Raichur, Bellary and Koppal. The purpose of this quality check was to ensure
that the construction was in compliance with the relevant standards and Specifications.

Materials and Equipment Used: The materials and equipment used in the construction of
the school buildings, bridges and roads were of high quality and met the relevant standards
and specifications. The materials used included steel, concrete, sand and bricks. The
specifications and manufacturers of the materials and equipment used were verified, and they
met the required standards. No rupture or crack visible on the bent portion and test has
passed of all the material used in the constructions. The specifications of all the materials
used to construct are lies between the standards.

Quality Control Measures: Several quality control measures were implemented during the
construction process. The construction was supervised by a qualified engineer who ensured
that the work was carried out in accordance with the design and specifications. The
construction workers were also trained to maintain quality standards and carry out their work
with precision.

Inspection and Testing Results: The construction of the school building, bridges and roads
underwent various inspections and tests to ensure its quality. The foundation was inspected to
verify its strength, and the concrete was tested to ensure that it met the required strength. The
details of the quality parameters of the materials of different works name in respective
geographical areas are mentioned in the lab report.

Conclusions and Recommendations: Based on the lab results of the quality check, the
construction of the school buildings, bridges and roads was of high quality, and it met the
relevant standards and specifications. It is recommended that future construction projects
implement similar quality control measures to ensure that they are of the same high quality.
Overall, the lab reports demonstrate a commitment to excellence in building construction are
satisfactory and upto the standards and was carried out with strict adherence to quality control
measures, resulting in a high-quality building that is safe and suitable for its intended use and
contributes to the ongoing development of best practices in the following sectors.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 145

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Appendices: The appendices include test reports, and other relevant data collected during the
construction process.

146 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 147

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

148 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 149

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

150 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 151

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

152 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 153

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

154 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 155

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

156 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Yadgir

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 157

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

158 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 159

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

160 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 161

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

162 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 163

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

164 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 165

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

166 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Kalaburgi

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 167

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

168 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 169

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

170 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 171

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

172 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 173

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

174 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Lab Report: Quality Check Report

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 175

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

176 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Field Photographs

11. FIELD PHOTOGRAPHS

Photos 26 : Development of public park in Basavakalyana Ward no 24 Mahadevi

Colony and Ward no 18 Hiremath Colony

Photos 27 : Construction of Check Dam for the Kamalavathi River and CC Road
construction in the Kadcharla village and Lake Development at Madana village in
Kalaburagi

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 177

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Photos 28 : Construction of bridge cum barrage across Mullamari rivers between

Kanakpur to Garmpalli village in Chincholi taluka of Kalaburagi district.

Photos 29 : Drinking water facility unit (OHT & PIPELINE) at the Vadthaya Thandya
Kalaburagi

178 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Field Photographs

Photos 30 : Basic facilities (Water Proofing) for boys/girls and post-matric and pre-
matric boys/girls hostels of District Backward Classes and Minorities and Social
Welfare Department Model Residential School (Navodaya), Yadgir

Photos 31 : Construction (pending) activities of indoor stadium of Shahapur town,

Yadgir

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 179

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

180 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

References

Barua, A., Watson, K., Plesons, M. et al. Adolescent health programming in India: a rapid
review. Reprod Health 17, 87 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12978-020-00929-4.

Gireesha L. P., Ashok D., M.S. Sapna (2016). ‘Hyderabad Karnataka Development: An
Evaluation’, EPRA International Journal of Economic and Business Review, Dubai, UAE,
Vol. 4, issue - 3.

Hams-ur et all (2000) Use of location-allocation models in health service development

planning in developing nations, European Journal of Operational Research, Volume 123,
Issue 3, 2000, Pages 437-452, ISSN 0377-2217.

Rao, R. R., Naidu, R. S., & Jani, R. (2008). Determining the cost of adequate education: a
critical review of the approaches. International Journal of Business and Management, 3(8),
48-52.

Ratnakar (2013). Article 371(J) – A Boon to Hyderabad Karnataka’s Development, Indian

Journal of Applied Research, Vol.3, issue 11, 2013, pp 468-469.

Rosegrant, M. W., Ringler, C., & Zhu, T. (2009). Water for agriculture: maintaining food
security under growing scarcity. Annual review of Environment and resources, 34(1), 205-
222.

Shinde S. (2021). History of Kalyana Karnataka. International Journal of Creative Research

Thoughts, Vol 9, issue 11: 812-815.

Tilak, J. B. (2003). Public expenditure on education in India: A review of trends and

emerging issues. Financing in India: Current Issues and Changing Perspectives. New Delhi:
Ravi Books, 3-54.
Venkataramana N. (2018). ‘Education and Economic Development - An Analytical Study of
Hyderabad Karnataka Region’. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science
Invention (IJHSSI), Vol. 7, issue 12 Ver.III, PP 78-86.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 181

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

182 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

ANNEXURE 1

QUESTIONNAIRE OF THE STUDY

KKRDB WORKS REPORT / DATA (INCLUSIVE)

NAME OF WORK / PROJECT:

1. Name of District
2. Name of Taluk
3. Name of Village

4. Name of the GP
Latitude of the
5. Degrees Minutes Seconds North
Work
Longitude of the
6. Degrees Minutes Seconds East
Work
Date of visit of
7.
Project
Agriculture Economic Industry Social Infra Financial &
8. Main Sector Infrastructure structure Technical
Infra
structure
Sub project
9.
sector

10. Is the selection of site appropriate on the following grounds

(Inclusive)?

A. YES/NO If No, why?

Access
B. YES/NO If No, why?
Drainage

C. YES/NO If No, why?

Hygiene

D. YES/NO If No, why?

Appropriate of size

E. YES/NO If No, why?

Aesthetics appeal

F. Any other YES/NO If No, why?

Parameter
(Specify)

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 183

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

11. Planned cost of project Rs.

12. Actual cost of Income Rs.
13. Duration proposed for
completing the project
14. Agency / contractor executing
the work/project
15. Date of Inauguration
16. Date of Completion
17. Date of putting it to use
18. Is the work/project is being used now YES/NO If No, why?

19. What is the use to which the

work is being used for?
20. Facility Utilisation
(Full/Partial/No)

21. If the actual use of work is different from what it was planned to be,
reasons for it?

22. Does the quality of work look to be good? If not, what components are
lacking quality and why?

23. What is the opinion about the location, design and quality of work as
expressed by any two stakeholders at least?

24. What are the sample civil structure collected for analysis along with:-

Sl. Details of Date of Name of Date of What Lab

No. Sample Collection Lab to sending report
which state?
1. Plastics (specify)
2. Steel (specify)

25. If would has been used in the construction, the following points:-
1. No Wood used at all YES/NO
2. If yes, then species of wood used and parts where used.

Any other remarks/findings relevant to the project/work and worthy ofreporting.

184 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

01: Additional questionnaire

Personal Information:
1. Name of the Respondent:
2. Sex:
a. Male b. Female
3. Religion:
a. General b. SC c. ST d. OBC
4. Education level:
a. Illiterate b. Literate
5. Do you have awareness about the different work undertaken by KKRDB?
a. Yes, b. No

If yes, how do you come to know? a. Media b. Friends c. Specify

COMPOUND WALL
1. Are you satisfied with the compound work? a. Yes b. No
2. Is it having gate?
3. Approximate height of the compound.
4. Does it protect entry of animals?
5. Plantation done inside the compound.
6. Whether it prevents of others?
7. Does it protect the plants inside the compound wall?
8. Benefit of compound wall

9. Do you suggest anything.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 185

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

02: Additional questionnaire

1. BEDS IN ICU

Personal Information
1. Name of the Respondent:
2. Sex:
a. Male b. Female
3. Religion:
a. General b, SC c. ST. d. OBC
4. Educational Level: a.
Illiterate b. Literate
5. Do you have awareness about the different work undertaken by KKRDB?
a. Yes b. No
6. If yes, how do you come to know? a. Media b. Friends c specify-
1. Is it satisfactory? a. Yes b. No
2. Is there any demand for additional beds? a. yes b. No
3. If yes. How much needed ______________________________
4. Whether hospital has sufficient staff to utilise the beds? a. yes b.
No
5. Do you need any other facility from the KKRDB? __________________________
6. Whether patients are happy with the new beds?
a. Yes b. No

186 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

03: Additional questionnaire

1. COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTRE
Personal Information:
1. Name of the Respondent:
2. Sex: a. Male b. Female
3. Religion: a. General b. SC ST. d. OBC
4. Educational Level: a. Illiterate b. Literate
5. Do you have awareness about the different work undertaken by KKRDB?
a. Yes b. No
6. If yes, how do you come to know? a. Media b. Friends c. specify
1. Are you satisfy with the hospital building? a. yes b. no
2. Is this sufficient?
a. yes b. no
3. Whether it provides in-patient and out-patient health care services? a. Yes b. No
4. Implementing family welfare programmes.
a. Yes b. No

Offering mental, dental and medical check ups

Control communicable diseases
National health programmes

04: Additional questionnaire

1. EXTENSION OF CLASSROOMS/LABORATORY
Personal Information:
1. Name of the Respondent:
2. Sex: a. Male b. Female
3. Religion:
a. General b. SC c. ST. d. OBC
4. Educational Level:
a. Illiterate b. Literate
5. Do you have awareness about the different work undertaken by KKRDB?
Yes b. No
6. If yes, how do you come to know?
a. Media b. Friends c. specify

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 187

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

1. Are you satisfied with the work?

a. Yes, b. No.
If yes

Attendance Rate increased

Students' satisfaction Level
Teachers’ satisfaction level
Improved the quality of education
Promoting enrolment in basic education
Number of students per classroom
Number of students per teacher
Students’ behavior

Any other:

188 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

Questionnaire for Officer (IDI)

In-Depth Interviews

Section I: General Information:

Sl. No Particulars Responses
1 Name of the respondent
2 Designation
3 Department
4 Address
5 Gender: (Male / Female)
6 Job Joining Year
7 Experience related to KKRDB works
8 Contact details (mobile/email)

Section II: Information related to KKRDB works

Sl. No Particulars Responses
1 No. of works associated
2 Type of works
3 Total no of Households
4 Total no of SC/ST/General SC
ST
Gen
Total
5 Total no. of health projects No.
Budget
Procurement process
Tendering system (online/offline)
Start date
End date
Extension
Additional cost
Time management
Quality management

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 189

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Record management
Reasons for delays
No. of beneficiaries covered
Present status: under use/not use
Benefits: Social/economic/environment
6 Total no. of education No.
projects Budget
Procurement process
Tendering system (online/offline)
Start date
End date
Extension
Additional cost
Time management
Quality management
Record management
Reasons for delays
No. of beneficiaries covered
Present status: under use/not use
Benefits: Social/economic/environment
7 Total no. of infrastructure No.
projects Budget
Procurement process
Tendering system (online/offline)
Start date
End date
Extension
Additional cost
Time management
Quality management
Record management
Reasons for delays
No. of beneficiaries covered

190 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

Present status: under use/not use

Benefits: Social/economic/environment
8 Total no. of irrigation projects No.
Budget
Procurement process
Tendering system (online/offline)
Start date
End date
Extension
Additional cost
Time management
Quality management
Record management
Reasons for delays
No. of beneficiaries covered
Present status: under use/not use
Benefits: Social/economic/environment
Total no. of other* projects No.
(*specify types) Budget
Procurement process
Tendering system (online/offline)
Start date
End date
Extension
Additional cost
Time management
Quality management
Record management
Reasons for delays
No. of beneficiaries covered
Present status: under use/not use
Benefits: Social/economic/environment

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 191

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

Section III: Challenges, causes and solutions

III.A- Health: Responses

Major issues

Major causes

Measures can be
taken to address
the issues

Remarks

III.B-Education: Responses

Major issues

Major causes

Measures can be
taken to address
the issues

Remarks

192 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

III, C- Responses
Infrastructure

Major issues

Major causes

Measures can be
taken to address
the issues

Remarks

III.D-Irrigation Responses

Major issues

Major causes

Measures can be
taken to address
the issues

Remarks

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 193

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

III.D-Others Responses

Major issues

Major causes

Measures can be
taken to address
the issues

Remarks

Field observations:

194 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

Questionnaire/Checklist (FGDs)
FOCUS GROUP DISCUSSION (FGDs)

Investigators Name: Date:

1. District:
2. Taluk:
3. Name of the Village:
4. Name of the work:
5. Name of the of the concerned Department:
6. Name of the Agency: _______________________
7. No of participants:
1.
2.
1 Awareness about the KKRDB 3.
4.
5.
1.
Awareness about the Work 2.
2 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3 Quality/Relatedness/Effectiveness 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
4 Involvements/Associations 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5 Positive impacts of the work
5.

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 195

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

1.
Negative impacts of the work 2.
6 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
7 Social Impacts 3.
4.
5.
1.
Educational/Health/Economic 2.
8 3.
impacts
4.
5.
1.
2.
9 Recreational benefits 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
10 Cost-benefit knowledge 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
11 Sustainability of the work 3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
12 Possible solutions 3.
4.
5.

196 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

Questionnaires of the Study

Annexure II

CENTRE FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT –

ECO TEAM

Management Team

Sr. No. Name Designation

1 Dr. A. Ravindra, IAS (Retd.) Chairman, Centre for Sustainable Development
Former Chief Secretary,
Government of Karnataka

2 Dr. R. Srinivas MBA, Executive Director, Centre for Sustainable

PhD Development

Project Core Team

Sr. No. Name Designation

Dr. Baswaraj Kumnoor Principal Investigator
1
MBA, PhD, DSc (H)

Dr. R. Srinivas, MBA, Core Team Member

2
PhD
Core Team Member
3 Dr. Umesh Babu, PhD

Mr. Satyanarayana Y K Core Team Member

4
B.E.
Field Officer
6 Mr. Harish S Mankur

Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority | 197

Evaluation of Works carried out by Kalyana Karnataka Region Development Board (KKRDB) in 2021-22

198 | Karnataka Monitoring and Evaluation Authority

EVALUATION OF WORKS CARRIED OUT BY KALYANA KARNATAKA
REGION DEVELOPMENT BOARD (KKRDB) IN 2021-22
Karnataka Monitoring & Evaluation Authority Website: kmea.karnataka.gov.in
#542, 5th Floor, 2nd Gate Contact No: 080 2203 2561
Dr. B.R Ambedkar Veedhi Email Id: kmeagok@karnataka.gov.in
M.S.Buidling,
Bengaluru – 560 001

Proffessional CV
50% (2)
Proffessional CV
2 pages
Urban Transformation Sector Best Practices Compendium
No ratings yet
Urban Transformation Sector Best Practices Compendium
149 pages
ToR KRIDL
No ratings yet
ToR KRIDL
17 pages
Karnataka State Action Plan On Climate Change
No ratings yet
Karnataka State Action Plan On Climate Change
224 pages
Economic Survey 2024 25 Compressed
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2024 25 Compressed
680 pages
Rapid Assessment of Blue Economy in Karnataka
No ratings yet
Rapid Assessment of Blue Economy in Karnataka
553 pages
Es Rkvy 2018
No ratings yet
Es Rkvy 2018
207 pages
Economic Survey 2017-18 PDF
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2017-18 PDF
892 pages
Karur
No ratings yet
Karur
150 pages
Volume 1
No ratings yet
Volume 1
593 pages
Super Market Billing Management
No ratings yet
Super Market Billing Management
47 pages
Cable Float Switch Type CFS2.d
No ratings yet
Cable Float Switch Type CFS2.d
2 pages
Economic Survey 2019 2020 NammaKPSC PDF
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2019 2020 NammaKPSC PDF
966 pages
MRF Research 2020 21
No ratings yet
MRF Research 2020 21
186 pages
Karnataka SDG Vision Document 27APRIL2020-With-coverpage
No ratings yet
Karnataka SDG Vision Document 27APRIL2020-With-coverpage
366 pages
Compass Magazine Feb 12th Saskatchewan
No ratings yet
Compass Magazine Feb 12th Saskatchewan
72 pages
Revised Draft Five Yr DDP 2015-20.final 3 Sept 2015 For Kaliro District
No ratings yet
Revised Draft Five Yr DDP 2015-20.final 3 Sept 2015 For Kaliro District
352 pages
Wencon Repair Manual English
No ratings yet
Wencon Repair Manual English
163 pages
Economic Survey 2023-24 Finalenglish Compressed
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2023-24 Finalenglish Compressed
568 pages
Karnataka Economic Survey 2021-22-m2 - Eng - Final
No ratings yet
Karnataka Economic Survey 2021-22-m2 - Eng - Final
895 pages
Economic Survey 2020-21 Eng Final R
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2020-21 Eng Final R
765 pages
Pico Log Self Help Guide
No ratings yet
Pico Log Self Help Guide
34 pages
Telegram Channel: @kasexam
No ratings yet
Telegram Channel: @kasexam
45 pages
Economic Survey 2022-23 English
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2022-23 English
532 pages
Working Paper Series No. 34: Government of Kerala
No ratings yet
Working Paper Series No. 34: Government of Kerala
42 pages
Httpsdes.karnataka.gov.Instoragepdf FilesEconomic20Survey202022 2320English.pdf
No ratings yet
Httpsdes.karnataka.gov.Instoragepdf FilesEconomic20Survey202022 2320English.pdf
532 pages
Economic Survey 2019-20 Eng
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2019-20 Eng
688 pages
English
No ratings yet
English
776 pages
Budget
No ratings yet
Budget
67 pages
PDF Mechanical Engineers Handbook Book 4 Energy and Power 3ed. Edition Kutz M. (Ed.) Download
100% (3)
PDF Mechanical Engineers Handbook Book 4 Energy and Power 3ed. Edition Kutz M. (Ed.) Download
84 pages
Optimum Volume Ratio of Sorbitol and Glycerol As Plasticizer On Bioplastic From Tapioca Starch
No ratings yet
Optimum Volume Ratio of Sorbitol and Glycerol As Plasticizer On Bioplastic From Tapioca Starch
15 pages
Unit - 3 Engineering Seismology
No ratings yet
Unit - 3 Engineering Seismology
55 pages
Design and Evaluation of PBL Based Course in Analog Electronics
No ratings yet
Design and Evaluation of PBL Based Course in Analog Electronics
7 pages
Ddugky Eng
No ratings yet
Ddugky Eng
392 pages
F - Huey II Emergency Detail Procedures Feb 15 English
No ratings yet
F - Huey II Emergency Detail Procedures Feb 15 English
23 pages
Membranes 11 00353 v2
No ratings yet
Membranes 11 00353 v2
13 pages
Shama Spring Industries
No ratings yet
Shama Spring Industries
12 pages
HddSurgery Seagate 7200.10 Head Change Tool
No ratings yet
HddSurgery Seagate 7200.10 Head Change Tool
14 pages
Oregon BAR 800 Weather Station
No ratings yet
Oregon BAR 800 Weather Station
2 pages
On The Development of Kasaragod District: Dr. P. Prabakaran
100% (1)
On The Development of Kasaragod District: Dr. P. Prabakaran
616 pages
3M Tape SOP
No ratings yet
3M Tape SOP
2 pages
karnataka economy syllabus
No ratings yet
karnataka economy syllabus
3 pages
Greening Karnataka’s Economy
No ratings yet
Greening Karnataka’s Economy
13 pages
Chapter 7 - Institutional Support
No ratings yet
Chapter 7 - Institutional Support
61 pages
Mickey Mouse: Career Objective
No ratings yet
Mickey Mouse: Career Objective
4 pages
Cia 2 Draft
No ratings yet
Cia 2 Draft
3 pages
Karnataka Economic notes
No ratings yet
Karnataka Economic notes
17 pages
KMEAPPTforChennaiTeamVisit
No ratings yet
KMEAPPTforChennaiTeamVisit
25 pages
Hobard Jet EX 5D, OMM-2094C, Rev10.
No ratings yet
Hobard Jet EX 5D, OMM-2094C, Rev10.
164 pages
Inventory Sample Probs
100% (3)
Inventory Sample Probs
5 pages
CETKOL
No ratings yet
CETKOL
3 pages
DHB 2013 14
No ratings yet
DHB 2013 14
130 pages
AIRPORT BRIEFING MMUN Rev. 04 PDF
No ratings yet
AIRPORT BRIEFING MMUN Rev. 04 PDF
1 page
1a. Uniform Building By-Laws 1984-K.GN - .5178 - 1984
No ratings yet
1a. Uniform Building By-Laws 1984-K.GN - .5178 - 1984
163 pages
Budget Karnataka
No ratings yet
Budget Karnataka
8 pages
ISGEC Master Requirement Details
No ratings yet
ISGEC Master Requirement Details
7 pages
JSG 3
No ratings yet
JSG 3
19 pages
Karim Nagar
No ratings yet
Karim Nagar
16 pages
CmZLrIW4BIPs Angul 2019-20 Final
No ratings yet
CmZLrIW4BIPs Angul 2019-20 Final
18 pages
FMass-1 (1)
No ratings yet
FMass-1 (1)
6 pages
CLASS XII (2018-19) Theory: Unit No. Title No. of Periods Marks
No ratings yet
CLASS XII (2018-19) Theory: Unit No. Title No. of Periods Marks
4 pages
Beginners Guide To Arch Linux
No ratings yet
Beginners Guide To Arch Linux
33 pages
Budget of Karnataka - 2024-25 (Foresightkas)
No ratings yet
Budget of Karnataka - 2024-25 (Foresightkas)
6 pages
Steel Purlin Design (Makong)
No ratings yet
Steel Purlin Design (Makong)
5 pages
Decisions Taken by the Cabinet of Ministers at Its Meeting Held on 29.01.2019
No ratings yet
Decisions Taken by the Cabinet of Ministers at Its Meeting Held on 29.01.2019
4 pages
Economic Survey 2020-21_Eng_Final_R-5-6
No ratings yet
Economic Survey 2020-21_Eng_Final_R-5-6
2 pages
KARUR
No ratings yet
KARUR
16 pages
07 VRM Pregrinder
No ratings yet
07 VRM Pregrinder
21 pages
Kerala Perspective Plan 0
No ratings yet
Kerala Perspective Plan 0
5 pages
wiring_diagram_v7-iii-e4-stone
No ratings yet
wiring_diagram_v7-iii-e4-stone
1 page
Tumkur Dist (Corrected)
No ratings yet
Tumkur Dist (Corrected)
18 pages
Df15a - 20a PDF
No ratings yet
Df15a - 20a PDF
66 pages
Inter Pipe
No ratings yet
Inter Pipe
7 pages