Giao tiếp liên văn hóa
Giao tiếp liên văn hóa
Giao tiếp liên văn hóa
Symbols verbal and nonverbal The Japanese language and the Japanese
language Sign Language
Rituals (nghi the socially essential Oshichiya: The father draws the baby's
thức/phong collective activities within a name and the date of the birth on a white
tục) culture sheet of paper using Japanese traditional
calligraphy and posts the paper on the wall
on the seventh night after the birth of a
baby.
Giỗ tổ Hùng Vương, lễ hội chùa Hương
Heroes the real or imaginary people Tokugawa Ieyasu, Oda Nobunaga, etc.
who serve as behavior Thánh Gióng
models within a culture
which can be the subject of
novels and
other forms of literature
Cultural identity (bản sắc văn hóa):
- Members who consciously identify themselves with a group that has a shared system
of symbols and meanings as well as norms for conduct (Collier & Thomas, 1988).
- Knowing one person's cultural identity doesn't provide complete or reliable
information about that person. Knowing another's cultural identity does, however,
help you understand the opportunities and challenges that each individual in that
culture has had to deal with.
Subculture
- Complex societies are made up of a large number of groups with which people
identify and from which are derived distinctive values and rules for behavior (rút ra
giá trị và quy tắc ứng xử đặc biệt). These groups have been labeled subcultures. A
subculture resembles (the same) a culture in that it usually encompasses
(comprise) a relatively large number of people and represents the accumulation (sự
tích lũy) of generations of human striving (sự phấn đấu).
- Subcultures exist within dominant (chủ yếu) cultures and are often based on
geographic region, ethnicity, or economic or social class (Jandt, 2018)
- e.g. Vietnamese culture; Northern Vietnam, Central Vietnam, and Southern Vietnam
(geographic region); Hoa, Kinh (ethnicity)
Co-cultural
- Many scholars reject the use of the prefix sub- as applied to the term culture because
it seems to imply being under or beneath and being inferior or secondary. As an
alternative, the word co-culture is suggested to convey the idea that no one culture is
inherently superior to other coexisting cultures (Orbe, 1998).
- One of the many elements of a co-culture is its system of laws. The system of laws
in our hypothetical (giả định) homogeneous (đồng nhất) culture, then, was derived
bắt nguồn) from and reflects the values of that culture.
- The Treaty of Waitangi, signed in 1840, was an attempt to define the relationship
between the British and the Ma-ori in New Zealand.
- the Ma-ori in New Zealand. (13% Māori and 78% Pakeha (European)
- Cộng đồng người Khme ở Việt Nam
Subgroups
- Like cultures, subgroups provide members with relatively complete sets of values
and patterns of behavior, and in many ways pose similar communication problems as
cultures.
- Subgroups exist within a dominant culture and are dependent on that culture.
- Subgroups usually do not involve the same large number of people as cultures
and are not necessarily thought of as accumulating values and patterns of behavior
over generations in the same way cultures do.
- Membership in some subgroups is temporary, while those in other subgroups may
be longer lasting.
- e.g. Facebook users and Twitter users, Nurse, doctor, police officer.
Microculture
- Some believe the term subculture implies “less important”. Others point out that the
term co-culture doesn't seem to be a realistic term as history suggests that one
culture will be dominant over the other. The term subgroup seems also to imply “not
important”.
- Others now advocate using the term microculture referring to any identifiable smaller
group bound together by shared symbol system, behaviors, and values.
- e.g. African American community in the US
- Some scholars now suggest just using the term culture regardless of size or other
factors. (Jant 2018)
1. Communication
- Cultural Definitions of Communication: It has often been said that communication and
culture are inseparable (không thể tách rời).
- Culture is a code (mã số) we learn and share; and learning and sharing require
communication. Communication requires coding and symbols that must be learned
and shared (Smith, 1966).
- Every cultural pattern and every single act of social behavior involve communication.
(Chu, 1977).
- Confucian Perspectives on Communication:
+ Definitions of communication from many Asian countries stress harmony
(Chen & Starosta, 1996). This is most notable in cultures with a strong
Confucian tradition.
+ Societies heavily influenced today by Confucian history or tradition are China,
North and South Korea, Singapore, and many East Asian countries with large
Chinese communities
+ In Confucian perspective, there are 5 relationships
- Ruler and subjects (the relation of righteousness – lẽ phải) – người cai
trị và thần dân
- Husband and wife (chaste conduct) – hành vi trong sạch
- Father and son (love)
- Elder brother and younger brother (order) thứ tự
- Friend and friend (faithfulness) – sự chung thủy/chân thành
- The regulating factors (yếu tố điều tiết) in family relationships are extended to the
whole community and state (nhà nước). The chief virtue (đức tính chính yếu) is filial
piety (lòng hiếu thảo), a combination of loyalty and reverence (sự tôn kính), which
demands that the son honor and respect his father and fulfill the demands of his
elders.
Confucianism
- emphasizes virtue (đức hạnh), selflessness (long vị tha), duty (nghĩa vụ), patriotism
(lòng yêu nước), hard work, and respect for hierarchy (tôn trọng thứ bậc xã hội), both
familiar and societal.
- As a consequence of the value placed on balance and social harmony (do giá trị
được đặt lên sự cân bằng và hòa hợp xã hội), the Asian cultures have developed
many verbal (bằng lời) strategies such as compliments, greeting rituals (nghi thức
chào hỏi), and so on to maintain good interpersonal relations.
- Group harmony(sự hòa hợp trong nhóm), avoidance of loss of face to others and
oneself, and a modest presentation of oneself (thể hiện bản thân một cách khiêm
tốn) are means of respecting the relationship. One does not say what one actually
thinks when it might hurt others in the group.
- Korea adopted Confucianism and the evidence is seen in their language. Korean has
grammatical form of direct address, called an honorific (kính ngữ), shows respect.
- In business, junior business associates may address (xưng hô) seniors with honorific
rather than common language.
- When two people are introduced, they first engage in small talk to determine each
other's social position so they know who should use common language and who
should use honorific language.
Common Barriers
- Stereotype (khuôn mẫu/nhận định đã được hình thành từ lâu): negative or positive
judgments made about individuals based on any observable or believed group
membership. e.g. In the U.S, a lot of people think Asian Americans are good at Math.
In Vietnam, the majority thinks that white Americans are rich.
- Prejudice: irrational suspicion (sự nghi ngờ) or hatred (thù hận) of a particular group,
race, religion, or sexual orientation e.g. Some heterosexual (dị tính) people might
have prejudice against homosexual (đồng tính luyến ái) people.
- Racism: (phân biệt chủng tộc) prejudice with the exercise of power on or over the
group through institutional (thể chế), historical (lịch sử), and structural (cấu trúc)
mean e.g. In the same job position, White Americans are paid higher than African
Americans
Individuals are connected, fluid (linh hoạt) and Individuals are independent.
conditional
less verbal because the meaning is already more verbal or vocal as the meaning
embedded (nhúng) in the physical environment is not shared commonly but each
or already shared by the people. context will have each own code to
follow
prefer nonverbal messages and the meaning more open-mindset as individuals are
is already shared, individuals are connected, free and independent.
fluid (smooth) and conditional as they must
follow the culture.
e.g. Family communication: With your sister or e.g. Talking to stranger: With the
brother, a certain facial expression can have a stranger, you would have to explain in
shared meaning, such as “There Mom goes language that your mother's specific
again,” behavior was characteristic, somewhat
irritating, but so uniquely her.
e.g. Drinking tea: In the Japanese tea ceremony, Very direct and straightforward.
nothing is spoken; all the meanings are in the “Hurry up and drink the tea!”
context of shared experience, the teahouse, the
flower arrangement, the calligraphy scroll, and
the ceramics.
China, Japan, Korea, Most Latin American Switzerland, Germany, North America,
cultures, Southern and Eastern Mediterranean etc.
(địa trung hải) cultures, etc
Viet Nam is a High-context culture. People learn to read between the lines. The main
message in communication is more hidden. Although I just keep not replying or saying “No, I
ain't” with my boyfriend’s question “Are you angry with me”, he himself understands that he
did something wrong. And then, he always finds ways to make up for it such as giving me a
gift or buying me a cup of The Alley milk tea. Another example, last week, when I was
shopping in the supermarket in District 7, HCM city, I saw a 3-year-old girl wailing and crying
aloud in the middle of the supermarket because her mother didn’t agree to buy her the
candy. And the mother eventually agreed to buy the candy bar. In this situation, the mother
was making an unnecessary concession since she didn’t want to lose face and honor. From
my perspective, the two above examples all reflect the statement “Vietnam is a high-context
culture”. Another example, on Tet holiday, although the adults in my family always ask me
about my salary and boyfriend, I just smile and don’t reveal anything about my personal
inadequacy.
Communication in High-context
- High-context societies tend to be more hierarchical (có thứ bậc) and traditional
societies in which the concepts of shame and honor (xấu hổ và danh dự) are much
more important than they are in low-context societies.
- High-context cultures thus avoid direct confrontation (đối đầu) or use
communication strategies to maintain harmony and reduce the possibility of
conflict. e.g. Chinese use forms of smiles and other nonverbal behaviors to avoid or
to soften uncomfortable situations that would threaten a participant's face.
Communication in Low-context
- In low-context societies, individuals are guided more by personal responsibility rather
than by shaming one's group. e.g. Americans use direct-face negotiation and express
more self-face maintenance.
Communication Message skills: the ability to understand and use language and
skills feedback.
Psychological The ability to handle the feelings of culture shock, such as frustration,
adjustment stress, and alienation in ambiguous situations caused by new
environments. e.g. How students feel when transfering from high
school to university level.
Intercultural adroitness (sự khéo léo liên văn hóa): message skills,
self- disclosure, behavioral flexibility, interaction management, and
social skills
- Compare “self-concept” and “self-closure”. Give one example
Self-concept: how a person Self-closure: the willingness of individuals to openly and
views the self appropriately reveal information about themselves to their
e.g. I define myself as an counterparts.
optimistic person. e.g. I avoid talking about my salary in front of the others.
- How important is cultural awareness in intercultural communication
competence? Give one example.
It is absolutely crucial to have cultural awareness in intercultural communication because it
will keep the conversation going smoothly. For example, the U.S is very open with hugs as
people tend to hug each other as a greeting. However, when an American comes to an
Asian country, they should not give hugs as a greeting, instead, they can shake hands or
simple say, “Hello” or wave hands. By doing this, the American can save both parties from
being uncomfortable and awkward with the hugging.
- Which aspect of the Intercultural Communication Competence suggests the
respect of cultural differences, and give examples to explain how you would
apply this aspect in communication?
From my perspective, the aspect of the Intercultural Communication Competence which
imply respect cultural differences is cultural awareness. Cultural awareness is the
understanding of the social customs and social system of the host culture. There are three
perspectives in this aspect including intercultural sensitivity - to acknowledge and respect
cultural differences, intercultural awareness - self-awareness of one's own personal cultural
identity and understanding how cultures vary, and intercultural adroitness - message skills,
knowledge of appropriate self- disclosure, behavioral flexibility, interaction management, and
social skills. Because each country has its own culture, whenever I intend to communicate
with the other cultural people I always try to have a deep understanding about that culture
by reading books or researching about them. For example, my last business partner is a
German agency which highly prefers direct and clear communication. Therefore, in most of
the meetings with them, I always try to present my idea and address the issues directly and
clearly as much as possible. Another example, I have an American friend. It is true that the
U.S is very open with hugs as people tend to hug each other as a greeting that is opposite
to the U.S, VietNamese people usually shake hands or simply say, “Hello” or wave hands.
Therefore, whenever she comes to VietNam, I always hug her as a great greeting.
Chapter 3: Hofstede - Explain the six dimensions of culture and give examples
Phần 1: Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions – Lý thuyết chiều văn hóa của Hofstede
- People generally identify their culture as their national identity. Given this, the
question becomes how to describe how national identity varies.
- Hofstede initially developed his model of cultural dimensions in the 1960s and 1970s.
His intercultural theory was one of the first that could be quantified (định lượng) and
could be used to explain observed differences between national cultures.
- Hofstede was attempting to locate value dimensions across which cultures vary. His
dimensions have been used frequently to describe cultures.
- The three first cultural dimensions of Hofstede
Individualism Collectivism
People are defined by their car, their house, People are defined by their family’s fame
accomplishment
Masculinity Vs. Femininity – Nam tính và Nữ tính (motivation towards achivement and
success)
Masculinity Femininity
Decisive and assertive (đưa ra quyết use intuition and strive for consensus (sử dụng
định và quyết đoán) trực giác và cố gắng đạt được sự đồng thuận)
The distinction roles of male and There are overlapping social roles between
female are clear. male and female.
are expected to be decisive and use intuition (sử dụng trực giác) and strive for
assertive consensus (cố gắng đạt được sự đồng thuận)
At 95%, Japan is one of the most masculine societies in the world. In
Japanese companies, employees are most motivated when they are
fighting in a winning team against their competitors.
What you also see as an expression of masculinity in Japan is the drive for
excellence and perfection in their production and in services (hotels and
restaurants) and presentation (gift wrapping and food presentation) in every
aspect of life.
It is still hard for women to climb up the corporate ladders in Japan with
their masculine norm of hard and long working hours.
Displays respect for those of higher status Display respect for those of neither higher
or lower status
Have power and influence on a percentage Have power and influence distributed
of the population equally
A wide gap of salary between the top and A reasonable gap of salary between the top
the bottom and the bottom
Superiors (cấp trên) and subordinates (cấp Superiors and subordinates equally
dưới) unequally
Hofstede believes that power distance is learned early in families. In cultures with high
power distance, children are expected to be obedient toward parents. In these cultures,
people are expected to display respect for those of higher status. For example, in countries
such as Myanmar, Cambodia, Laos, and Thailand, people are expected to display respect
for monks by removing hats in the presence of a monk, dressing modestly, seating monks at
a higher level, and using a vocabulary that shows respect.
Sweden scores low on this dimension, with 31%, which means that the
following characterizes the Swedish style: Being independent, equal
rights, superiors accessible, and empowers.
Students expect teachers to be experts Students accepts teachers who admit to not
who have all the answers knowing all the answers
Vietnam scores 30 on this dimension and thus has a low preference for
avoiding uncertainty. In Vietnam, schedules are flexible. Hard work is
undertaken when necessary but not for its own sake. Precision and
punctuality do not come naturally.
Singapore scores 8% on this dimension and thus scores very low on this
dimension.
In Singapore people abide (tuân thủ) to many rules not because they
have need for structure but because of high Power Distance Index, 74%.
Singaporeans call their society a “Fine country. You’ll get a fine for
everything”.
Indulgence Self-restraint
Focus on leisure and having friends Helplessness, cynicism (tính hoài nghi)
A low score of 35% on this dimension indicates that the culture of Vietnam
is characterized as Restrained.
People with this orientation have the perception that their actions are
Restrained by social norms and feel that indulging themselves is
somewhat wrong.
Look at the cultural dimension index of South Korea. Choose ONE dimension index
and interpret its meaning.
* 'Masculinity' has been rephrased as 'Motivation towards Achievement and Success'.
With a low score of 29% on the indulgence dimension, I believe that South Korea is a
restrained culture. South Koreans seem to be less happy than others in Indulgent countries
and they have a tendency to cynicism and pessimism. In addition, in contrast to indulgent
countries, in restrained countries such as South Korea, not only gender roles are more
strictly prescribed but also people do not put much emphasis on leisure time and control the
gratification of their desires. The residents in South Korea have a perception that their
actions need to be curbed and regulated by strict social norms. If they do something that
indulges themselves, it is wrong.
The index of Power Distance of Vietnam is 70%. Give explanation for this score and
provide relevant examples for your viewpoint.
The index of Power Distance is the extent to which less powerful members of institutions and
organizations within a country expect and accept that power is distributed unequally. With a
score of 70% on the Power Distance index, I believe that VietNam is a high power distance
culture which means that the following characterizes the VietNam style: being dependent,
unequal rights, superiors inaccessible, and monopoly. Power is centralized. Employees
expect to obey. Control is preferred and attitudes towards managers are formal. There is a
wide gap in salary between the top and the bottom. Also, superiors and subordinates are
unequal. Communication is indirect and non-participative. For example, Vietnamese
children are expected to be obedient toward their parents versus being treated more or less
as equals. Also, in VietNam, residents are expected to display respect for those of higher
status. In addition, Vietnamese people usually wait for everyone to be seated or let the
elderly have their first taste of food. Or if children want to go out or buy something, they must
seek an allowance from their parents. In the workspace, all decisions will be made by
leaders or managers, and staff have to follow all instructions without any questions.
2. Feminine culture.
In Vietnam, the focus is on “working in order to live”, managers strive for consensus, people
value equality, solidarity, and quality in their working lives. Conflicts are resolved by
compromise and negotiation. Incentives such as free time and flexibility are favored.
3. France, with a score of 71, is shown to be an individualist society. Parents make their
children emotionally independent with regard to groups in which they belong. This means
that one is only supposed to take care of oneself and one’s family.
TEST OF UNIT
Test of chapter 1
1. According to Hofstede (1994), a culture consists of _____ categories. → 4
2. Lunar New Year reunion belongs to the category of_____. → rituals
3. K-pop fans is an example of_____. → subgroup
4. Vietnamese American community in the US is an example of_____. → microculture
5. Societies with Confucian influences emphasize_____. → harmony
6. In Confucinism, the relationship between friends highlight_____.→ faithfulness
7. According to Berlo (1960), the process of communication involves _____ aspects.→
4
8. In Western perspectives on communication, the process of decoding is _____.→ an
active process
9. “No culture is superior to other cultures” is the feature of which cultural concepts? →
Co-culture
10. After receiving the message from person A, which process person B will use in the
communication process? → Encoding -> Decoding -> Feedback
11. Which country below follows Confucianism? → South Korea
12. Which parties involve in the relationship of “love” in Confucianism?→ Father and son
13. Boss and subordinate belong to “ _____” relationship.→ righteousness
14. In societies influenced by Confucianism, people tend to avoid ‘losing face’ of the
others in communication by _____.→ not directly expressing their opinions
15. A culture is formed when _____.→ it has a language
16. When Korean meet each other, they _____.→ exchange small talk to determine the
order
17. Which one is NOT a cultural category? → Customs
18. In Western perspectives, the process of communication involves _____
components.→ 10
19. When the children respect and/or pay back the parents for everything the parents
have done for them.
→ children take care of parents when they are old or sick, children sent back money to
parents every month; children remember and take their children to visit and take care of the
parents’ graves.
20. Context: the environment in which the communication takes place and helps define
the communication. If you know the context, you can predict with a high degree of
accuracy much of the communication.
→ Knowing that a person is being stopped by a police officer for speeding is enough to
predict much of the communication. Certain things are likely to be said and done; other
things are very unlikely.
Test of chapter 2
1. When meeting a stranger, you should apply _____ communication strategies to
maintain a comprehensive communication.→ low-context
2. During the meeting, people tend to use more of smiles and nonverbal behaviors to
express their attitude. This is an example of _____ communication. → high-context
3. In a family, mostly _____ communication strategies are used due to the mutual
understanding among members. →high-context
4. The concept of face is heavily emphasized in _____. → high-context
5. Intercultural Communication Competence includes _____skill sets.→ 4
6. Behavioral flexibility refers to the ability to_____.→ adjust one’s behaviors
7. Social skills refer to the ability to_____. → express empathy
8. Self-disclosure refer to_____. →the revelation of one’s personal information
9. Which is NOT a skill area in Intercultural Communication Competence?→ Cultural
alteration
10. Which one is a feature of communication in low-context cultures? → Directly address
the issue.
11. Intercultural Communication Competence is the ability to communicate effectively
and appropriately in_____.→ various cultural contexts
12. Social skills in Communication skills refer to the _____.→ empathy and identity
maintenance
13. Psychological adjustment refers to the ability to be able to handle _____.→ culture
shocks
14. Which societies values individual responsibility? → Low-context societies
15. Câu 7. When talking to someone, I tend to use a lot of facial expressions, hand
gestures, and body movements along with verbal communication, so I am more likely
of a _____. → low-context communicator
16. _____ is the ability to select an appropriate behavior in diverse context.→ Behavior
flexibility
17. Using social comparison information to control and modify one’s self-presentation an
expressive behavior is _____.→ self-monitoring
18. You are ready to tell your age to other people. This reflects which feature?
→Self-disclosure
19. High context:
- Expect the emlpoyees to know their duties with out explicit explaination.
- Use the body language, tone, and the context to deliver the message.
- Maintain harmony at the workplace.
- Promote hierarchy.
20. Low context:
- Explicitly explaining to the employees the expectation: what dos and donts,
- Repeat the process from time to time to ensure the comprehension.
- Promote clarification and confrontation at the workplace.
21. Self-concept: how a person views the self
→ I define myself as an optimistic person.
Self-closure: the willingness of individuals to openly and appropriately reveal
information about themselves to their counterparts.
→ I avoid talking about my salary in front of others.
22. It is absolutely crucial to have cultural awareness in intercultural communication
because it will keep the conversation going smoothly. For example, the U.S is very
open with hugs as people tend to hug each other as a greeting. However, when an
American comes to an Asian country, they should not give hugs as a greeting,
instead, they can shake hands or simply say, “Hello” or wave hands. By doing this,
the American can save both parties from being uncomfortable and awkward with the
hugging.
Test of chapter 3