Understanding A_Financial Statement Audit
Understanding A_Financial Statement Audit
Understanding A_Financial Statement Audit
com
Understanding a
financial statement audit
May 2017
The benefit of an audit is that it provides assurance that management has presented a ‘true and fair’ view of a
company’s financial performance and position. An audit underpins the trust and obligation of stewardship
between those who manage a company and those who own it or otherwise have a need for a ‘true and fair’ view,
the stakeholders.
Given the importance of its role, queries are often raised about the audit, the auditors and the stakeholders
they serve. This publication aims to provide useful background information on what a financial statement audit is
and the role of the auditor.
Definition of an audit
In general, an audit consists of evaluation of a subject matter with a view to express an opinion on whether the
subject matter is fairly presented. There are different types of audits that can be performed depending on the
subject matter under consideration, for example:
Audit of financial statements
Audit of internal control over financial reporting
Compliance audit
This publication only focuses on audits of financial statements, which are undertaken to form an independent
opinion on the financial statements of a company.
Companies prepare their financial statements in accordance with a framework of generally accepted accounting
principles (GAAP) relevant to their country, also referred to broadly as accounting standards or financial reporting
standards. The fair presentation of those financial statements is evaluated by independent auditors using a
framework of generally accepted auditing standards (GAAS) which set out requirements and guidance on how to
conduct an audit, also referred to simply as auditing standards.
This publication focuses in particular on financial statement audits of public companies (listed companies, whose
shares are typically traded on a stock exchange)—what most people have in mind when discussing ‘audit'. Whilst
care has been taken to keep explanations broadly applicable to most public company audits, requirements and
practices will vary from country to country, and jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Descriptions are based on the current
broad form and scope of audit, the future of which is currently under debate around the world and is open to
change. This publication does not provide detailed explanation of all aspects of a financial statement audit and
readers should refer to other sources for further information.
2 | PwC
Benefits of an audit
Overview Auditors are generally and ultimately appointed by
the shareholders and report to them directly or via
the audit committee (or its equivalent) and others
charged with governance.
Oversight
Customers
bodies
3 | PwC
Public vs. private companies In undertaking an audit, auditors apply relevant
GAAS that provides specific requirements and
While companies of all sizes produce financial
guidance on performing audit engagements. Auditing
statements, the number of stakeholders interested in
standards may be set by national or international
them would normally be larger for public companies
organizations, such as the International Auditing and
and larger private companies, due to the number of
Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) and adopted by
individuals, businesses and organisations that
national regulatory bodies.
interact with and are affected by them. Also, public
companies’ financial statements are typically
available to a larger number of users. In most
jurisdictions, for public companies, there are
additional requirements to comply with when
preparing their financial statements. Larger public Oversight
bodies
company audits are typically more complex and also
used by even more market participants.
Audit environment
Multi-location Legal
The changing economic and legal environment has audit matters environment
Audit
significant implications for a company’s operations
and financial reporting, and changes in the business,
economy and laws and regulations generally increase
the level of risks affecting the business and require
adequate response and disclosure in the financial
statements. This also affects the way an audit is
Auditing Accounting
conducted, since the auditor’s work needs to be standards standards
scaled to address increased risks of material (GAAS) (GAAP)
misstatement of the financial statements.
4 | PwC
Modified audit opinion
Reporting An audit opinion that is not considered ‘clean’ is one
that has been modified. Auditors issue a modified
audit opinion if they disagree with management
about the financial statements. In practice this may
be unusual as the company will typically make the
necessary amendments to the financial statements
Audit opinion
and disclosures rather than receive a modified
The management of a company is responsible for opinion. The auditors will also issue a modified
preparing the financial statements. The auditor is opinion if they have not been able to carry out all the
responsible for expressing an opinion indicating that work they feel is necessary, or if they have been
reasonable assurance has been obtained that the unable to gather all the evidence they need.
financial statements as a whole are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and that Auditors can also modify the audit report without
they are fairly presented in accordance with the modifying the opinion by adding additional
relevant accounting standards (e.g., International paragraphs to draw users’ attention to specific
Financial Reporting Standards). significant matters. For example, if the auditors
believe that there is some aspect of the financial
There are clear frameworks from independent statements that is subject to a material degree of
auditing standard setters which provide rules and uncertainty—even if fully disclosed—then they may
guidelines for how an audit should be carried out and draw attention to and emphasise this in the audit
the level of assurance obtained. It is the auditor’s report. This is widely known as an emphasis of matter
responsibility to plan and conduct the audit in such a paragraph.
way that it meets the applicable auditing standards
and sufficient appropriate evidence is obtained to Going concern assumption
support the audit opinion. However, what constitutes
Under the going concern assumption, a company is
sufficient appropriate evidence is ultimately a matter
viewed as continuing in business for the foreseeable
of professional judgement. The auditor considers a
future. Financial statements are prepared on a going
number of factors in determining whether financial
concern basis, unless management either intends to
statements are free of material misstatement, and in
liquidate the company or to cease operations, or has
evaluating any misstatements identified. These
no realistic alternative but to do so. When the use of
factors require professional judgement, where
the going concern assumption is appropriate, assets
auditors use their skill and experience to form a view
and liabilities are recorded on the basis that the
based upon the evidence gathered on the financial
company will be able to realise its assets and
statements taken as a whole.
discharge its liabilities in the normal course
of business.
The audit opinion is clearly stated as a separate
paragraph in the audit report. The auditor issues a
If management considers that the company will not
‘clean’ opinion when it concludes that the financial
continue to operate for the foreseeable future, the
statements are free from material misstatement.
financial statements must be prepared on a
‘liquidation’ (or ‘break-up’) basis—meaning that the
value of their assets must take account of potential
forced sales which will likely be significantly lower
and their liabilities may be significantly higher.
6 | PwC
Auditing standards also require auditors to maintain
The audit process professional scepticism—an attitude that includes a
questioning mind and a critical assessment of audit
evidence. The ability to think in a critical manner
about how the current economic environment may
affect the company’s financial statements, to identify
significant risks of material misstatement, to develop
Professional judgement and appropriate audit responses, to obtain and assess the
scepticism sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence and
to reach well-informed professional judgements is
In undertaking an audit, the auditors consider the
integral to performing a quality audit.
mandatory and detailed GAAP that set out how a
company should account for and disclose even the
Inherent limitations of an audit
most complex transactions. However, many of the
issues that arise in an audit—particularly those An opinion is not a guarantee of an outcome, but
involving valuations or assumptions about the rather a statement of professional judgement. The
future—involve estimates to which the auditor must auditor cannot obtain absolute assurance that
bring their professional judgement and experience to financial statements are free from material
bear. misstatement because of the inherent limitations of
an audit. These are caused by a number of factors.
Indeed, many accounting measures can only ever be For example, many financial statement items involve
estimates that are inevitably based on imperfect subjective decisions or a degree of uncertainty (e.g.,
knowledge or dependent upon future events. For accounting estimates). Consequently, such items are
example, if a company was involved in legal action, it subject to an inherent level of uncertainty which
would need to estimate the amount at which the case cannot be eliminated by the application of
would be resolved; or if it was planning to sell an auditing procedures.
office building it owns, it would have to estimate the
sale price. It should not be assumed that every single fact and
detail in a set of audited financial statements has
In such cases, the auditor may determine the been checked and verified by the auditors, and is
reasonable range of possible values, and consider therefore guaranteed to be 100 percent accurate.
whether the company’s estimates lie within that The auditor obtains reasonable assurance by
range. The uncertainties that affect this judgement gathering evidence through selective testing of
need to be disclosed and—if they could have a financial records.
material effect—the auditors may include an
emphasis of matter paragraph in their report. Fraud
Fraud has a corrosive effect on the trust necessary for
These are areas where the auditors must use their companies to do business. Management is
experience and skill to reach an opinion on the responsible for running the company and preventing
financial statements. The words ‘opinion’ and ‘true and detecting fraud. Preventing and detecting fraud
and fair’ are deliberately chosen to make clear that is difficult because fraud is intentionally hidden and
judgement is involved. They underline the fact that may involve collusion by multiple participants.
the auditor’s report is not a guarantee but rather
reflects the auditor’s professional judgement Even though audits are properly performed in
based on work performed in accordance with accordance with relevant GAAS, they may not detect
established standards. material fraud. However, auditors are responsible for
obtaining reasonable assurance that the financial
statements are not materially misstated as a result of
fraud.
8 | PwC
The audit committee (or equivalent)
Substantive testing
In public companies, it is generally the
In addition to testing controls, the auditor is required shareholders who ultimately approve the auditor’s
to perform further procedures to gather evidence appointment, and the auditors are primarily
from substantive procedures (substantive audit
responsible to and overseen by those representing
evidence), which can include a combination of the
following: the shareholders’ interests with regards to financial
reporting and internal controls.
Physically observing or inspecting assets (such
as inventory or property, plant and equipment); Typically an audit committee (or its equivalent),
Examining records to support balances acting as a largely independent body, will be charged
and transactions; with representing the shareholders’ interests.
Companies may not necessarily have an audit
Obtaining confirmations from third parties the committee and this interchange may be dealt with
company does business with (such as its less formally but in an equivalent manner. The audit
suppliers, customers and in particular the banks committee is a sub-committee of those charged with
it uses); governance, and is typically made up of a majority of
Checking elements of the financial statements non-executive directors who are the shareholders’
by comparison to relevant external information representatives in relation to the external audit. They
and investigating any differences (for example, are usually responsible for overseeing the audit and
using an external market index to check pricing evaluating the independence and performance of the
and valuations); and auditors.
Auditors interact with the company during all the As well as their public report on the financial
phases of the audit process listed above. There will be statements, the auditors will typically have more
continuing discussions and meetings with detailed communications with the audit committee.
management, both at operational and senior These communications may include a description of
executive levels, and with those charged with how the audit was carried out, the audit plan, the
governance. Using their professional scepticism and auditor’s views about the company’s accounting
judgement, auditors challenge management’s practices (including accounting policies, estimates
assertions regarding the numbers and disclosures in and disclosures), how the auditors satisfied
the financial statements. themselves on the key issues that arose, and
significant difficulties, if any, encountered during the
audit. The auditors may also comment to the audit
committee on their insights in areas such as the
strength of the organisation’s internal
control systems.
Requiring key personnel on the audit to be Auditor appointment is more complicated in the case
changed from to time to time, so that fresh pairs of of multi-location audits (see 'multi-location audits'
eyes are brought to bear including regular rotation below), as in this situation the group auditor will
of the lead audit partner. need to perform and/or coordinate audits of
components of the group (subsidiaries, etc.) to
The most important factor underpinning auditor
independence is the attitude of mind that is instilled support the group audit opinion. The component
audits may be performed by the lead audit firm (i.e.
through audit training, practice, and the culture of
the firm providing an opinion on the group’s
the audit firm, and which auditors exhibit through
professional scepticism in their work. The discipline consolidated financial information), by another audit
firm in the lead auditor’s network, or by another
of independence is core to an auditor’s approach
unconnected audit firm. The auditors of those
and mindset.
components report to the lead auditor of the group
for the purpose of the consolidated group financial
statements. The lead auditor typically has sole
responsibility for the audit opinion on the
consolidated financial statements.
10 | PwC
Auditor qualifications and skills Multi-location audits
Auditors are generally qualified accountants who are In many cases, a business comprises several legal
members of a professional institute in their respective entities (which may be located in different countries),
countries. Although this varies between countries, whose results are consolidated into a single set of
qualified accountants normally must meet certain financial statements that present the financial
educational requirements, take several years of position and performance of the consolidated group.
studying and professional exams and have sufficient Large companies may have dozens or even hundreds
practical experience. of entities. Audits of such clients normally involve
audit teams from audit firms around the world
Becoming an auditor is a challenging process that performing work in different locations.
requires a combination of significant academic study
and a large amount of learning on-the-job. This The lead auditor responsible for issuing the opinion
means the people who qualify as auditors benefit on the consolidated group financial statements
both from an understanding of the principles of develops the audit strategy and defines the scope of
auditing, accounting, finance, law, business work to be performed at each component (location,
management, among other topics, and hands- entity, etc.) of the group. The lead auditor
on experience. communicates with the audit firms responsible for
component audits and typically reviews component
In addition to the technical knowledge, auditors need auditor's work in order to obtain evidence to
to have good analytical skills to be able to effectively support an opinion on the group consolidated
analyse the company’s information, properly financial statements.
interpret the analysis, apply professional judgement
and arrive at appropriate conclusions. Auditors must As a result, multi-location audits entail more complex
also possess broad communication skills (both verbal considerations regarding audit strategy, planning,
and written). As auditors communicate to the execution and communication.
company’s senior management and those charged
with governance, it is very important that they do so
in a clear and professional manner. Multi-location audit considerations
Required procedures to obtain understanding of the
Auditors possess the analytical and logical skills component auditors by the lead auditor (e.g.,
needed to evaluate the relevance and reliability of the evaluating their professional competence, etc.);
systems and processes responsible for recording and
Different regulatory requirements, e.g. different
summarising financial information. These skills
laws, regulations and accounting standards (which
enable auditors to understand how to gather and
would need to be converted to a consistent set of
assess evidence to evaluate representations made
standards for group accounts);
by others.
Language and cultural differences;
Throughout their careers all auditors must undertake Emerging markets considerations (e.g., evolving
continuing professional development to maintain laws and regulations, corporate governance
their qualifications. Most audit firms invest practices, potentially higher business risks, etc.);
significant resources in training and professional Site visits of the company’s locations by the lead
development of their staff which go beyond the auditor around the world;
requirements of the territory professional
Additional procedures to support timely, accurate
regulations. Overall, the training that auditors receive
two-way communications between the lead auditor
provides them with a significant array of skills, which
and component auditors; and
form the foundation for a wide range of careers in
various fields and contribute to the overall Review of the audit procedures performed by the
recognition and high regard for audit professionals. component auditor(s).
3 Annual report
The annual report is a report issued by a company detailing its activities and financial
performance during the preceding year. It includes the financial statements and may
generally also include reports from those charged with governance (for example the
chairman of the board of directors), a review of the company’s strategy and performance,
information on risk management and governance, information for the shareholders and
other information such as a corporate and social responsibility statement.
4 Assurance
Assurance refers to enhancing the user’s confidence in the information that is being
reported. In a financial statement audit, the auditor obtains reasonable assurance about
whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement.
5 Audit committee
The audit committee is a committee of those charged with governance, responsible for the
oversight of a company’s financial reporting and accounting, financial regulatory
compliance, financial risk management processes, and the engagement of and interaction
with the company’s external auditor on behalf of the company’s shareholders. It is
typically comprised of a majority of independent non-executive directors.
8 Balance sheet
A financial statement that presents a company’s financial position as of a specified date. It
is also often referred to as ‘statement of financial position.’
9 Break-up basis
The break-up basis is used for preparing the financial statements of a company where
management is unable to confirm that it is a going concern (see below). On this basis,
assets and liabilities are included at the net value that would be realisable in the event of a
forced sale or liquidation.
10 Disclosures
Disclosures are the inclusion of information in the financial statements, such as further
analysis of the primary financial statements, a statement of principal accounting policies
applied, or key assumptions relating to accounting estimates, including information
required by law, financial reporting standards or other regulations. These are an integral
part of the financial statements.
11 Emphasis of matter
A paragraph included in the auditor’s report that refers to a matter appropriately
presented or disclosed in the financial statements that, in the auditor’s judgement, is of
such importance that it is fundamental to users’ understanding of the financial
statements. An emphasis of matter does not affect the audit opinion but modifies the audit
report to draw attention to specific matters disclosed in the financial statements.
14 | PwC
13 Financial statements
What specifically must be in the financial statements is governed by local law and
regulation and standards such as international financial reporting standards, however
generally they must include a balance sheet (showing assets, liabilities and equity),
income statement, cash flow statement and equity statement (showing changes in
equity). These are typically also referred to as the primary statements. Usually financial
statements are accompanied by additional disclosures (see the disclosures definition
above).
16 Going concern
Management’s assumption that the company will continue to operate for the foreseeable
future. Financial statements are prepared on a going concern basis, unless management
either intends to liquidate the company or to cease operations, or has no realistic
alternative but to do so. In these cases, the break-up basis is used (see above). The going
concern basis is one in which the assets and liabilities of the business are realised and
settled in the normal course of its activities.
17 Income statement
A financial statement that measures a company’s financial performance over a specific
accounting period.
19 Listed company
A listed company is a company whose shares can be bought and sold by the general
public and are listed on a stock exchange, such as the London Stock Exchange.
When determining whether a matter is material, the auditor also evaluates qualitative
considerations, such as the impact of misstatements on debt covenants, key ratios, etc.
21 Misstated/misstatement
A misstatement is a difference—arising from an error or fraud—between the amount,
classification, presentation or disclosure of an item in the financial statements, and the
amount, classification, presentation or disclosure that is required for that item to be in
accordance with the applicable financial reporting standards.
22 Modified/modifications
An audit opinion is modified when the auditor concludes that the financial statements
are materially misstated, or the auditor has been unable to obtain sufficient appropriate
audit evidence to reach a conclusion. A modified opinion could be:
A qualified opinion—the auditor concludes that, except for specific matters explained
in the audit report, the financial statements give a true and fair view;
An adverse opinion—the auditor concludes that the financial statements do not give
a true and fair view;
The audit report can also be modified through an emphasis of matter paragraph without
altering the audit opinion (see the emphasis of matter definition above).
16 | PwC
23 Narrative statements
Management’s narrative statements comprise information included in the annual
report, outside the financial statements, on matters such as the company’s strategy,
risks, activities and performance for the year.
24 Primary statements
See financial statements above.
25 Reasonable assurance
In the context of an audit of financial statements, a high, but not absolute, level
of assurance.
26 Regulatory bodies
These are bodies which, among other things, have responsibility in relation to the
qualification and supervision of auditors. Other bodies have responsibility for:
Accounting and financial reporting standard setting: for example, the International
Accounting Standards Board (IASB).
Auditing standard setting: for example, the International Auditing and Assurance
Standards Board (IAASB).
29 Working capital
A financial metric that measures the resources available to a company to finance its day-
to-day operations. It is typically calculated by deducting current liabilities from
current assets.
© 2012 PwC. All rights reserved. Not f or f urther distribution without the permission of PwC. “PwC” refers to the network of member firms of
PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited (PwCIL), or, as the context requires, individual member firms of the PwC network.
18 | PwC