A_©vr ÔMYZš¿ n‡”Q RbM‡Yi miKvi,

MYZš¿ Avgvi fv‡jv RbM‡Yi Øviv cwiPvwjZ I RbM‡Yi Rb¨

jv‡M bv MwVZÕ|1
-Ry‡qj ivbv Aa¨vcK wmwji g‡Z, ÔDemocracy is a
form of government in which everyone has a
AeZiwYKv :
share in itÕ A_v©r ÔMYZš¿ nj Ggb GK
`ywbqvRy‡o MYZ‡š¿i g›`v ïiæ kvmb e¨e¯’v, †hLv‡b mK‡ji
n‡q‡Q †ek Av‡MB| Avi eZ©gvb AskMÖn‡Yi AwaKvi i‡q‡QÕ| 2

mg‡q we‡k¦i wewfbœ †`‡k MYZ‡š¿i

jW© eªvBm Zvi Modern Democracies
msKU e¨vcK I cÖKUfv‡e †`Lv w`‡Z
MÖ‡š’ e‡jb, Ô†hLv‡b kvmb e¨e¯’v
ïiæ K‡i‡Q| MYZ‡š¿i eû ÎæwU-
†Kvb †kÖwYi Dci b¨¯Í bv †_‡K
wePz¨wZ wek¦vq‡bi GB hy‡M
mgMÖ mgv‡Ri m`m¨‡`i Dci b¨¯Í
Avgv‡`i‡K Av‡iv †ekx DwØMœ K‡i
_v‡K, Zv‡K MYZš¿ e‡jÕ|
Zz‡j‡Q| Gi cÖfv‡e MYZš¿ Zvi
bv`ym-by`ym †Pnviv eva¨ n‡q Aa¨vcK WvBwm e‡jb, ÔDemocracy is a
nviv‡Z ïiæ K‡i‡Q| Ae¯’v GLb Ggb form of government in which the governing
`uvwo‡q‡Q †h, MYZš¿‡cÖgx I body is a comparatively large fraction of the
entire populationÕ A_©vr ÔMYZš¿ n‡”Q
ivóªwPšÍvwe`‡`i g‡a¨ fq Xz‡K c‡o‡Q
Ges †mB mv‡_ MYZš¿‡K i¶vi AvIqvR Ggb GK kvmb e¨e¯’v †hLv‡b
D‡V‡Q| kvmKMY Zzjbvg~jKfv‡e RbmsL¨vi
GKwU weivU AskÕ|
MYZš¿ ej‡Z hv eywS :
Aa¨vcK g¨vKvBfvi e‡jb,
MYZš¿ eZ©gvb `ywbqvi GKwU eûj ÔMYZš¿ msL¨vMwiô ev Ab¨ Kv‡iv
Av‡jvwPZ gZev`| `ywbqvi GK wecyj Øviv kvmb cwiPvjbvi c×wZ bq, eis
msL¨K gvbyl MYZ‡š¿i cÖwZ †K ev Kviv kvmb Ki‡e Ges
cÖPÐfv‡e kÖ×vkxj| †gvUvgywU †Kvb&& D‡Ï‡k¨ kvmb
MYZš¿ AvaywbK hy‡Mi me‡P‡q Ki‡e, Zv wba©viY Kivi Dcvq¯^iƒcÕ|3
RbwcÖq miKvi e¨e¯’v| MYZ‡š¿ mKj
†h‡Kvb wel‡q wewfbœR‡bi wewfbœ
ivóªxq ¶gZvi Drm RbMY| MYZ‡š¿i
gZvgZ _vK‡Z cv‡i| Z‡e AwaKvsk
Bs‡iwR cÖwZkã Democracy, hv wMÖK
gvbyl †h gZwU mwVK g‡b K‡ib,
kã Demos Ges Kratos ev Kratia †_‡K D™
†mwUB MÖnY Kiv DwPZ| GB
¢~Z| Demos A_©- RbMY Ges Kratos ev
cÖwµqv‡K MYZš¿ ejv nq|4
Kratia k‡ãi A_©- kvmb¶gZv| myZivs
kãMZ A‡_© MYZ‡š¿i A_© n‡”Q 1
. ˆ`wbK Avgv‡`i mgq, 23 dvêyb 1423,
ÔRbM‡Yi kvmb ¶gZvÕ| c„t 3, (BwZnv‡mi ¸iæZ¡c~Y© K‡qKwU
fvlY)|
gvwK©b hy³iv‡óªi 16Zg 2
. evsjv‡`‡ki †jvK cÖkvmb (Abvm© Z…
†cÖwm‡W›U Aveªvnvg wjsKb Zxq el©), w`K`k©b cÖKvkbx, lô cÖKvk,
(1809-1865 Cmvqx) 1863 mv‡ji 19 A‡±vei 2016, c„t 511|
3
b‡f¤^i †MwUmev‡M© GK fvl‡Y . †cŠibxwZ I mykvmb 1g cÎ (cÖ‡dmi
†gvt †gvRv‡¤§j nK), GKv`k-Øv`k †kÖwY,
e‡jwQ‡jb, ÔDemocracy is a government of nvmvb eyK nvDm, XvKv, PZz_©
the people, by the people, for the peopleÕ ms¯‹iY: Ryb 2016, mßg Aa¨vq, c„t 225|
4
. cÖv_wgK evsjv‡`k I wek¦ cwiPq,

DËi cjvkevox, wPwiie›`i, w`bvRcyi| PZz_© †kÖwY (2017 wk¶vel©), lô
3 2q el© 6ô
8 msL¨v
 MYZ‡š¿i DrcwË I µgweKvk : 1935 mv‡j Bs‡iRiv G‡`‡k cÖewZ©Z
cÖvPxb MÖx‡mi G‡_‡Ý Lªx÷c~e© ¯^vqZ¡kvmb AvB‡bi Aaxb BD‡iv‡c
cÂg kZvãx‡Z ÔMYZš¿Õ kãwU cÖPwjZ MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z we‡kl
me©cÖ_g e¨eüZ nq| MÖx‡mi cwigvY ÔKiÕ `vZv‡`i †fvUvi evwb‡q
bvMwiK mgvR ÔMYZš¿Õ ej‡Z eySZ Zv‡`i †fv‡U wbe©vwPZ †jvK‡`i Øviv
Ggb GKwU ivR‰bwZK kvmbe¨e¯’v, cÖv‡`wkK cwil` MVb K‡i| Gi d‡j
hv‡Z †MvUv bvMwiK mgvR G‡`‡k ivR‰bwZK `j M‡o I‡V Ges
cÖZ¨¶fv‡e AskMÖnY Ki‡Z cv‡i| Zvi cy‡ivfv‡M ev †bZ…‡Z¡ Bs‡iwR
G‡_Ýxq MYZš¿ cieZ©x‡Z Pjgvb wkw¶Z †jv‡Kiv mvaviYfv‡e Ges
_v‡Kwb| ga¨hy‡M ag© I ivRvi Bs‡iR fveavivi AvBbRxexiv
ˆØZkvmb, ˆ¯^iZvwš¿K kvmb I we‡klfv‡e AMÖmi n‡q Av‡m| Avi
mvgšÍZvwš¿K kvmbe¨e¯’vq A‡bKUv Bs‡iRivI AwZ †KŠk‡j GB †kÖwYi
mgq †K‡U †M‡Q| `xN©Kvj c‡i †jvK‡`i‡KB ivR‰bwZK †bZ…‡Z¡i
BD‡iv‡c MYZ‡š¿i cybR©b¥ N‡U Avm‡b cÖwZwôZ K‡i| d‡j ZvivB nq
mß`k I Aóv`k kZvãx‡Z| Ewbk I wek gymwjg‡`i ivR‰bwZK †bZv| d‡j
kZ‡K c„w_exi wewfbœ †`‡k gymwjg RbM‡Yi g‡b GB aviYvB
MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vi cÖPjb †`Lv hvq| e×g~j n‡q `uvovq †h, Av‡jg mgvR
Aóv`k kZ‡Ki MYZvwš¿K fveavivi gymwjg‡`i ag©xq †bZv gvÎ| ivR
Drmg~j wnmv‡e Bsj¨vÛ‡K wPwýZ ‰bwZK †¶‡Î †bZ…Z¡ †`qvi Dchy³
Kiv nq|5 bq| ivR‰bwZK †¶‡Î †bZ…Z¡ w`‡Z
m¶g †Kej Bs‡iwR wkw¶Z †jv‡KivB|
BD‡iv‡c ga¨hy‡M †`k kvm‡bi mgMÖ †Kbbv, ZvivB kvmK Bs‡iR‡`i fvlv I
KZ…©Z¡ wQj wMR©vi Ges wMR©vi AvBb-Kvb~b Rv‡b Ges Bs‡iR
cv`ªx-cy‡ivwnZ‡`i nv‡Z| ZvivB wQj cÖewZ©Z kvmb e¨e¯’vi m‡½
wbi¼zk kvmb ¶gZv I ag©xq †bZ… mycwiwPZ| eZ©gv‡b †`‡k †h
‡Z¡i GK‡PwUqv AwaKvix| PZz`©k c×wZ‡Z wbe©vPb AbywôZ nq, Zv
kZ‡Ki ci BD‡iv‡c †i‡bmvui m~Pbv Bs‡iR‡`iB cÖewZ©Z Ges BD‡ivc
nq| K‡qK kZvãxe¨vcx i³¶qx Ø›Ø- †_‡K Avg`vbxK…Z|6
msMÖv‡gi ci kvmb KZ…
©Z¡ wMR©v KZ…©c‡¶i nvZ †_‡K †Kb GB †jLv :
†K‡o †bqv nq| Gici wewfbœ †`‡k B`vbxs Kv‡j gvbeZvi gyw³, Kvw•LZ
wbi¼zk AZ¨vPvix ivRZvwš¿K kvmb myL I kvwšÍ Avbq‡bi j‡¶¨ mKj †¶‡Î
e¨e¯’v cÖwZwôZ nq| wKš‘ be¨ MYZš¿‡K i¶v, MYZvwš¿K g~j¨‡ev‡ai
wkw¶Z‡`i g‡a¨ ivRZvwš¿K kvmb PP©v I MYZvwš¿K Av`k© cÖwZôvi
e¨e¯’vi weiæ‡× cÖPÐ we‡¶v‡fi bv‡g †h mKj cÖwZ‡hvwMZv Pj‡Q
AwMœ a~gvwqZ n‡q D‡V Ges Ges wcÖ›U I B‡jKUªwbK wgwWqvq
ivRZš¿ D‡”Q‡`i Av‡›`vjb ïiæ nq| †m wewfbœ eyw×RxexMY †hmKj e³e¨
Av‡›`vj‡bi d‡j ivRZš¿ D‡”Q` n‡q hvq cÖ`vb Ki‡Qb, Zv Avgvi wbKU GKwU
Ges RbwcÖq n‡q I‡V MYZš¿| NUgvb ev¯ÍeZvi fzj e¨vL¨v ev
mgm¨v mgvav‡bi c‡_ fzj cÖ‡Póv
Aa¨vq, c„t 28|
5
. `vwLj evsjv‡`k I wek¦ cwiPq: beg-`kg
†kÖwY, cybg©y`ªY: †m‡Þ¤^i 2016, Aóg 6
. gvIjvbv Avãyi inxg (int), MYZš¿ bq
Aa¨vq, c„t 118| c~Y©v½ wecøe (PDF), c„t 5 I 8|
msL¨v

3
2q el© 6ô

9
(Approach) e‡j g‡b n‡”Q Ges †mB †¶‡Î bq| Mfxifv‡e ü`q½g Ki‡j Avkv Kwi
mwVK G‡cÖvPwU Zz‡j aivi GKwU mevB eyS‡eb|
MiR‡eva wb‡Ri g‡b Abyfe Kijvg| MYZ‡š¿i †`vl :
†mB Abyf‡ei Zvobvq wb‡Ri g‡bi
Abyf~wZ dzwU‡q †Zvjvi Rb¨B Avgvi eZ©gv‡bi me‡P‡q RbwcÖq
GB †jLv| Avwg †Kvb †ckv`vi †jLK ev MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vi cÖavb cÖavb
ivR‰bwZK we‡kølK bB| ag©, †`vlmg~n GLv‡b ms‡¶‡c Av‡jvKcvZ
BwZnvm, `k©b cÖf…wZ wel‡q Kivi cÖqvm cve BbkvAvjøvn :
Avgvi †jLv-cov LyeB mvgvb¨| Z‡e 1. MYZ‡š¿ Ávb-weÁvb, wk‡íi cÖmvi
†hw`b †_‡K eyw× n‡q‡Q, †mw`b N‡U bv| wkí, mvwnZ¨ weKv‡ki Rb¨
†_‡KB MYZ‡š¿i msL¨vMwiôZvi †hiƒc Ávbx kvm‡Ki cÖ‡qvRb, Zv
aviYvwU wb‡q Avgvi g‡a¨ mskq MYZvwš¿K kvmb e¨e¯’vq mvaviYZ
ˆZwi n‡q‡Q| Avwg GLb wbwðZ, cvIqv hvq bv|
msL¨vMwi‡ôi iv‡qi wfwˇZ MYZ‡š¿i 2. MYZ‡š¿ eywj me©¯^ e¨w³iv
†h aviYv, Zvi cy‡ivUvB ÎæwUc~Y©, RbMY‡K wg_¨v ¯^cœ †`wL‡q,
A‡hŠw³K, A‰ea I gvbeZvi msKU wg_¨v cÖwZkÖæwZ w`‡q ¶gZvq
ˆZwii GKwU KviLvbv| GB welqwU Avmvi my‡hvM cvq| wkw¶Z I Ávbx-
RbZvi gv‡S cÖKvk Kivi wPšÍv gv_vq ¸Yx e¨w³ A‡bK mgq Gme wg_¨vi
Avm‡ZB Avgvi g‡b coj MZ 18 RyjvB, †emvwZ I Wvgv‡Wv‡ji g‡a¨
2016 msL¨vq Ôˆ`wbK evsjv‡`k wb‡R‡`i‡K Rov‡Z Pvb bv| Gi d‡j †`k
cÖwZw`bÕ cwÎKvq wewkó Kjvwg÷ I ewÂZ nq `¶ I Ávbx-¸Yx e¨w³‡`i
mvsevw`K Rbve cÖfvl Avwgb †mev †_‡K|
Qv‡n‡ei GKwU wbe‡Üi K_v| cyi‡bv
3. MYZvwš¿K kvmb e¨e¯’vq
cwÎKv NvUvNvwU K‡i †mB wbeÜwU
`xN©¯’vqx Dbœqb cwiKíbv MÖnY
AveviI cvV Kijvg| ÔMYZš¿ Avgvi
Kiv m¤¢e nq bv| †Kbbv,
fv‡jv jv‡M bvÕ GB wk‡ivbv‡g Rbve
MYZ‡š¿ hLb-ZLb miKv‡ii cZb NU‡Z
cÖfvl Avwgb Qv‡ne †h wbeÜwU
cv‡i|
wj‡L‡Qb, †mB wk‡ivbvgwU‡KB
Avwg Avgvi eZ©gvb †jLvi wk‡ivbvg 4. MYZš¿ mvg¨, ¯^vaxbZv I AvB‡bi
wnmv‡e e¨envi Kijvg| GB Rb¨ K_v ej‡jI ev¯Í‡e ¯^vaxbZv nq
cÖ_‡gB Rbve Avwgb Qv‡n‡ei eive‡i wecbœ| AvB‡bi kvm‡bi e`‡j †Rv‡ii
K…ZÁZv cÖKvk KiwQ| h_v¯’v‡b kvmb, †cwki kvmb cÖwZwôZ nq|
Zuvi e³e¨ D×…Z Kie BbkvAvjøvn| A‡bK mgq †`Lv hvq, †fv‡Ui e¨vjU
ev· wQbZvB nq, GgbwK †Kvb †Kvb
†mB mv‡_ cÖm½µ‡g Avgvi GB
†fvUvi‡`i †fvU‡K‡›`ª †h‡Z †`Iqv nq
†jLvq A‡b‡Ki bvg DwjøwLZ n‡q‡Q|
bv| d‡j abx A_ev †cwk me©¯^
B”QvK…Zfv‡e KvD‡K AvnZ Kivi
cÖfvekvjxivB wbe©vwPZ nb| GRb¨
A_ev †QvU ev eo Kivi B”Qv Avgvi
†jwK e‡j‡Qb, ÔMYZš¿ †kÖôZi
wQj bv| G †jLv Øviv †Kv‡bv †kÖwY,
cÖkvmwbK e¨e¯’vi wbðqZv cÖ`vb
m¤cÖ`vq ev †Kvb e¨w³we‡kl †KD
K‡i bv, AwaKZi ¯^vaxbZvi wbðqZv
hw` e¨w_Z nb, Z‡e Avwg
weavbI K‡i bvÕ|
webxZfv‡e `ytL cÖKvk KiwQ| Gi
Øviv KvD‡K †nq Kiv Avgvi D‡Ï‡k¨
4 2q el© 6ô
0 msL¨v
 5. A‡bK mgq ivR‰bwZK `j¸‡jvi K‡i| G‡Z mgq, m¤ú` I A‡_©i AcPq
ga¨Kvi Ø›Ø, fzj †evSveywS, A‰bK¨ nq|
cÖf…wZi d‡j RvZxq HK¨ I msnwZ 12. MYZ‡š¿ wbev©wPZ `j wbw`©ó
webó nq| mg‡qi Rb¨ miKvi MVb K‡i Ges
6. MYZš¿ gv‡b RbM‡Yi kvmb ejv n‡jI cÖwZwU `j Zv‡`i bxwZi wfwˇZ
AvaywbK cÖwZwbwaZ¡g~jK Kg©m~Px cÖYqb K‡i| †Kvb †Kvb
MYZš¿ n‡”Q `jxq kvmb e¨e¯’v| †¶‡Î miKv‡ii Kg©m~Px cy‡ivcywi
†Kbbv, hLb †h `j wbe©vP‡b Rqjvf ev¯ÍevwqZ nIqvi Av‡MB Zv‡`i †gqv`
K‡i, ZLb †mB `j Zv‡`i gZ K‡i †`k †kl n‡q hvq| d‡j miKvi cwieZ©‡bi
kvmb K‡i| mv‡_ mv‡_ bxwZI cwiewZ©Z nq|
7. MYZš¿ n‡”Q Avjvc-Av‡jvPbvi ZvB iv‡óªi Dbœqb evavMÖ¯Í nq|8
gva¨‡g cwiPvwjZ kvmb e¨e¯’v| Gi 13. MYZ‡š¿ RbcÖwZwbwa‡`i myôz
d‡j hiƒix cÖ‡qvR‡bi mgq MYZvwš¿K kvmb Kv‡h©i Rb¨ cÖ‡qvRbxq
miKvi ZvB `ªæZ wm×všÍ MÖn‡Y cÖkvmwbK Ávb ev AwfÁZv _v‡K bv|
m¶g nq bv| d‡j cÖkvmwbK e¨vcv‡i Zviv
8. MYZ‡š¿ A‡bK mgq RbgZ weåvšÍ Avgjv‡`i Dci AwZgvÎvq wbf©ikxj
nq| ZvB wg_¨v Avk¦vm cÖ`vb K‡i n‡q c‡o| Avi Avgjv‡`i cÖvavb¨-
RbMY‡K weåvšÍ K‡i GKwU `j mn‡RB cÖwZcwËi Rb¨ Rbmvavi‡Yi ¯^v_©
¶gZvq Avm‡Z cv‡i| Ae‡nwjZ nq|9
9. †ewkifvM Aíwkw¶Z I ga¨weË 14. MYZš¿ i¶Ykxj kvmb e¨e¯’v| G
†kÖwYi nv‡Z MYZvwš¿K miKvi Rb¨ F.W Coker gšÍe¨ K‡i‡Qb,
cwiPvjbvi fvi _v‡K| Giv ‘Democracies are the most conservative of all
forms of state.’ A_©vr ÔMYZš¿ n‡”Q
¯^v_©wmwׇZ e¨¯Í _v‡K|
iv‡óªi mKj KvVv‡gvi g‡a¨ LyeB i¶Ykxj
¯^RbcÖxwZ I `yb©xwZ MYZvwš¿K (kvmb e¨e¯’v)Õ|
miKvi‡K ZvB c½y K‡i †d‡j|
A_©wjáyZvq Zviv Avcv`g¯ÍK wjß 15. gvK©mev`x‡`i we‡kølY
_v‡K|7 Abyhvqx wb‡f©Rvj MYZš¿ e‡j †Kvb
wKQzi AwaKvi AZx‡Z wQj bv,
10. MYZ‡š¿ wbe©vP‡bi gva¨‡g Rq- eZ©gv‡bI †bB| GwU GKwU
civRq wba©viY Kiv nq e‡j GLv‡b ¸Y gyL‡ivPK I eywjme©¯^ Zš¿gZ gvÎ|
ev †hvM¨Zvi †P‡q msL¨vi Ici †ekx
¸iæZ¡ †`Iqv nq| A_©vr G‡Z gv_v 16. MYZ‡š¿ msL¨vMwi‡ôi kvmb ejer
MYbv Kiv nq, †gavi wePvi Kiv nq bv| _vKvq msL¨vjNy‡`i Afve-Awf‡hvM
m¤ú‡K© miKvi D`vmxb _v‡K| Gi d‡j
11. MYZ‡š¿ wbe©vP‡bi mgq msL¨vjNy‡`i AwaKvi Le© nq| GgbI
cÖv_©xiv RbM‡Yi mg_©b Av`v‡qi
Rb¨ cÖwZwU `j wjd‡jU, †cv÷vi, 8
. (10-12) gva¨wgK †cŠibxwZ I
Rbmfv BZ¨vw` K‡i cÖPzi A_© e¨q bvMwiKZv: beg-`kg †kÖwY (wk¶vel©
2017), PZz_© Aa¨vq, c„t 29-30|
7
. (1-9) †cŠibxwZ I mykvmb-cÖ_g cÎ 9
. ivR‰bwZK msMVb Ges weª‡Ub I
(cÖ‡dmi †gv: †gvRv‡¤§j nK): GKv`k- gvwK©b hy³iv‡óªi ivR‰bwZK e¨e¯’v
Øv`k †kÖwY, nvmvb eyK nvDm-XvKv; (wWMÖx cÖ_g el©-wØZxq cÎ),
PZz_© ms¯‹iY: Ryb 2016, mßg Aa¨vq, w`K`k©b cÖKvkbx, cybgy`ª©Y: Ryb
c„t 228-229| 2017, c„t 129|
msL¨v

4
2q el© 6ô

1
†`Lv hvq, we‡ivax`j eva¨ n‡q msm` 21. MYZ‡š¿i cÖv_wgK aviYvUvB
Awa‡ekb eR©b K‡i| ÎæwUc~Y©| eZ©gvb MYZvwš¿K
17. evK ¯^vaxbZv, e¨w³ I msev`c‡Îi e¨e¯’vq wbev©P‡bi gva¨‡g GKwU
¯^vaxbZv MYZ‡š¿ `jZ‡š¿i Kv‡Q ivR‰bwZK `‡ji Kv‡Q †`k‡K
G¸‡jv civf~Z nq| GgbwK `‡ji †gvUvgywU wjR †`Iqv n‡q hvq|12
jvwVevR‡`i nv‡Z wePvi wefvM 22. MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vq ciKvjxb †Kvb
ch©šÍ kw¼Z _v‡K| wPšÍv-fvebv bv _vKvq gvbyl e¯‘ev`x
18. MYZ‡š¿ RbM‡Yi Askx`vwi‡Z¡i a¨vb-aviYv wb‡q eo nq, hv Zv‡K
K_v ejv n‡jI †Kej †fv‡Ui mgq e¨ZxZ Avjøvn&i cÖwZ Revew`wnZvi
Ab¨ †Kvb wKQz‡Z Rbg‡Zi †Kvbiƒc `vqe×Zv †_‡K gyw³ †`q|
†Zvqv°v Kiv nq bv| d‡j Amš‘ó RbMY 23. MYZ‡š¿ gZ cÖKv‡ki Aeva
niZvj, wgwUs-wgwQj, Abkb, Mvwj- ¯^vaxbZv _vKvq A‡b‡K Akøxj K_v
MvjvR, nZ¨v-jyÉb I fvOPz‡ii c_ †e‡Q e‡j _v‡K| GgbwK Bmjvg ag© I
†bq| Gfv‡e MYZš¿ Ae‡k‡l SMovZš¿ I wek¦bex gynv¤§v` (Qvt)-†K wb‡qI
e›`yKZ‡š¿ cwiYZ nq| hvi cwiYvg KU~w³ Kiv n‡”Q! bex Kixg (Qvt)-Gi
cÖwZwU MYZvwš¿K †`‡kB GLb KU~w³Kvixiv Kv‡di I gyiZv` n‡q
†jv‡Kiv nv‡o nv‡o Dcjwä Ki‡Q| hvIqvi Kvi‡Y G‡`i kvw¯Í g„Zz¨`Ð, hv
19. MYZ‡š¿ wbev©Pbx cÖ_vq MYZ‡š¿ ˆea bq|
GKvwaK †fvUcÖv_©x _vKvq evsjv‡`‡k MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vi
cvi¯úwiK Ø›Ø I †ilv‡iwl m„wó nq| Kzdj :
wbev©P‡bi c‡iI GB Ae¯’v we`¨gvb 1. evsjv‡`‡ki †Kvb †Kvb ivR‰bwZK
_v‡K| hv mgv‡R wnsmv-nvbvnvwb †bZv-†bÎxi e³…Zv-wee„wZ ï‡b g‡b
GgbwK LybvLywb ch©šÍ m„wó nq MYZš¿ B‡Zvg‡a¨ †lvjAvbv
K‡i|10 cÖwZwôZ n‡q‡Q wKsev
20. XvKv wek¦we`¨vj‡qi ivóªweÁvb MYZš¿ AvZzi N‡i g„Zz¨eiY K‡i‡Q|
wefv‡Mi wk¶v_©x dvwng Avn‡g` A_©vr MYZš¿ m¤ú‡K© Zv‡`i Df‡qi
e‡j‡Qb, MYZ‡š¿i weiæ‡× cÖavb aviYv ci¯úi we‡ivax Ges ivR
Awf‡hvMwU nj- Gi gva¨‡g ‰bwZKfv‡e Zviv cÖwZwbqZ
†jvKiÄbev`x I ¯^v_©v‡š^lx †Mvôx m¤§yLxb n‡”Q ci¯úi we‡ivwaZvq|
GKwU †`‡ki Af¨šÍixY msL¨vMwiô 2. evsjv‡`‡ki cÖavb cÖavb ivR
RbM‡Yi wPšÍvaviv‡K bvbvfv‡e ‰bwZK `j we‡kl K‡i hviv ¶gZvq
cÖfvweZ K‡i wbev©P‡b Rqjvf Ki‡Q| Av‡Q Ges ¶gZvq wQj, †Kvb `‡jB
Avi Gi gva¨‡g evavcÖvß n‡”Q ¯^”Q I Revew`wnZvg~jK
msL¨vMwi‡ôi Ask bq Ggb RbM‡Yi MYZvwš¿K wbe©vPb c×wZ †bB; eis
Avkv-AvKv•ÿvi ev¯Íevqb|11
i‡q‡Q ÔIron Law of Oligarchy’ ev
10
. (17-19) gynv¤§` Avmv`yjøvn Avj- ÔKzjxbZ‡š¿i †jŠn AvBbÕ| GLv‡b ivR
Mvwje, Bmjvgx wLjvdZ I †bZ… ‰bwZK `j¸‡jvi †bZv I †bZ…
Z¡ wbev©Pb (ivRkvnx: nv`xQ dvD‡Ðkb
evsjv‡`k, cÖ_g cÖKvk: gynviig 1424 Avn‡g`)|
wnRix), c„t 12, 37, 46| 12
. ˆ`wbK evsjv‡`k cÖwZw`b, 18 RyjvB
11
. ˆ`wbK B‡ËdvK, 15 Ryb 2017 Bs, 2016 Bs, (MYZš¿ Avgvi fv‡jv jv‡M bv:
(MYZ‡š¿i mvd‡j¨ wk¶vi f~wgKv: dvwng cÖfvl Avwgb)|
4 2q el© 6ô
2 msL¨v
 Z¡ wbe©vwPZ nq †K KZUv gvigyLx 6. 18 †m‡Þ¤^i, 2017 †mvgevi
Zv w`‡q| we‡K‡j Ô‰`wbK cÖ_g Av‡jvÕ DËi
3. evsjv‡`‡ki ivR‰bwZK `j¸‡jvi Av‡gwiKv Kvh©vj‡q AbywôZ GK
g‡a¨ gvÎvwZwi³ wnsmvZ¥K AvPiY AvÇvq wk¶vwe` I †jLK Aa¨vcK ˆmq`
MYZš¿ PPv©i c_‡K KÈKvKxY© K‡i gbRyiæj Bmjvg e‡j‡Qb, evsjv‡`‡k
Zz‡j‡Q| GLv‡b ivR‰bwZK MYZvwš¿K miKvi _vK‡jI Gi AvPiY
gZcv_©‡K¨i gxgvsmvi Dcvq A‡bK †¶‡ÎB GL‡bv h_v_© n‡q DV‡Z
wnmv‡e mš¿vm I mwnsmZv‡K cv‡iwb| mvaviY gvbyl A‡bKvs‡kB
e¨envi Kiv nq| wbe©vPb‡K †K›`ª K‡i MYZ‡š¿i mydj †_‡K ewÂZ i‡q
mš¿vm I mwnsmZv GLv‡b †M‡Q|15
¯^vfvweK NUbvq cwiYZ n‡q‡Q| 7. evsjv‡`k msweav‡bi aviv 70(1)
4. evsjv‡`‡ki msweav‡bi 11 g‡Z Ômsm‡` `‡ji wec‡¶ †fvU w`‡j
Aby‡”Q‡` ejv n‡q‡Q ÔcÖRvZš¿ n‡e Zvi Avmb k~b¨ nB‡eÕ e‡j AvBb Kiv
GKwU MYZš¿Õ G m‡Ë¡I msweav‡bi n‡q‡Q| Gi d‡j `jxq ˆ¯^ivPvi Aek¨¤
g‡a¨B i‡q‡Q MYZš¿ weKv‡ki c‡_ ¢vex| †hUv 31 RyjvB, 2017 mycÖxg
weivU evav| MYZ‡š¿i ¯^v‡_© iv‡óªi †KvU© evwZj †NvlYv K‡i‡Q|
wZbwU wefv‡Mi g‡a¨ ¶gZvi fvimvg¨ 8. cwievi gvbemgv‡Ri g~j wfwË|
_vK‡Z nq| wKš‘ evsjv‡`‡k GLbI cvwievwiK Rxeb e¨wZ‡i‡K
AvB‡bi kvmb cÖwZôvq wePvi gvbemf¨Zv Kíbv Kiv hvq bv| cwievi
wefv‡Mi ¯^vaxbZvi cÖkœ D‡V|13 e¨e¯’v bv _vK‡j c„w_ex‡Z Aeva
5. wbe©vPbx cÖwµqv, ivR‰bwZK †hŠbvPvi e„w× cv‡eB| mgv‡Ri
eûZ¡ev`, miKv‡ii Kvh©µg, kvwšÍ-k„•Ljv, w¯’wZkxjZv, DbœwZ-
gZcÖKv‡ki ¯^vaxbZv, msMVb I AMÖMwZ BZ¨vw` myôz cvwievwiK
mgv‡e‡ki AwaKvi, AvB‡bi kvmb Ges e¨e¯’vi Dc‡i A‡bKvs‡k wbf©ikxj|
e¨w³¯^vaxbZvi ¸YMZ gvb we‡ePbvi wKš‘ evsjv‡`‡k cÖPwjZ MYZvwš¿K
wfwˇZ Zuvi (Aa¨vcK Avjx wiqvR) wbe©vP‡bi Kvi‡Y †mB cvwievwiK
g~j¨vq‡b evsjv‡`‡k GLb †h e¨e¯’v Rxe‡b fv½b I AkvwšÍ †`Lv w`‡Z ïiæ
Pj‡Q, Zv n‡”Q †`v-Avukjv MYZš¿, K‡i‡Q| †hgb-
Bs‡iwR‡Z nvBweªW †W‡gv‡µwm| (K) 23 †g, 2017 AbywôZ bovB‡ji
Zuvi (Aa¨vcK Avjx wiqvR) GB †`v- Kvwjqv Dc‡Rjvi cuvPMÖvg BDwc
Avukjv MYZš¿‡K bv ejv hvq wbev©P‡b AvIqvgx jxM g‡bvbxZ
MYZvwš¿K bv ejv hvq KZ… cÖv_©xi (Rûiæj nK) †bŠKv cÖZx‡K
©Z¡ev`x|14 †fvU bv †`qvq `yB mšÍv‡bi Rbbx ¯¿x
mv_x †eMg‡K (35) wcwU‡q ¸iæZi
RLg K‡i ZvjvK †`b cvlÐ ¯^vgx Avjg
13
. (1-4) evsjv‡`‡ki ivR‰bwZK I †gvjøv|16
mvsweavwbK Dbœqb-1971 n‡Z (L) ev‡Minv‡Ui KPzqv Dc‡Rjvi
eZ©gvb ch©šÍ (Abvm© Z…Zxq el©):
w`K`k©b cÖKvkbx, cybg©y`ªY: A‡±vei ivpxcvov BDwbqb cwil` wbe©vP‡b
2016, c„t 181-182|
14
. ˆ`wbK cÖ_g Av‡jv, e„n¯úªwZevi 18 †g 15
.Link:m.prothomalo.com/northamerica/article/
2017 Bs, (†`v-Avukjv MYZ‡š¿ ag© I 1327451.
ivRbxwZ : mvsevw`K Kvgvj Avn‡g`)| 16
. ˆ`wbK hyMvšÍi, 27 †g 2017 Bs|
msL¨v

4
2q el© 6ô

3
evevi m‡½ Ø›Ø _vKvq gv‡qi BAvBBD MYZ‡š¿i †h m~PK †ei
weiæ‡× cÖwZØw›ØZv K‡i‡Q †Q‡j| K‡i‡Q, Zv‡Z †`Lv hv‡”Q, we‡k¦i gvÎ
GB wb‡q GjvKvq e¨vcK Av‡jvPbv- 4 `kwgK 5 kZvsk RbMY c~Y©
mgv‡jvPbv P‡j|17 MYZ‡š¿i g‡a¨ evm K‡i| A‡a©‡Ki
(M) †fvjv m`‡ii ivRvcyi BDwbqb †ekx Rb‡Mvôx evm K‡i cy‡iv
cwil` wbev©P‡bi Av‡Mi w`b †fvjv AMYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vq| Avi evwK
†cÖmK¬v‡e msev` m‡¤§jb K‡ib A‡a©K †hme †`‡k evm K‡i, †mLv‡b
†Pqvig¨vb c`cÖv_©x PvPv Avey MYZš¿ i‡q‡Q, Z‡e ÎæwU-wePz¨wZI
Avãyjøvn Uzby †PŠayix I fvwZRv i‡q‡Q| 2015 mv‡ji cwiw¯’wZ
†iRvDj nK wgVz †PŠayix| D³ msev` we‡ePbvq wb‡q BAvBBD †h m~PK
m‡¤§j‡b PvPv-fvwZRv ci¯ú‡ii †ei K‡iwQj, Zv‡Z †`Lv †M‡Q †h,
weiæ‡× GjvKvq cÖfve we¯Ívi, Uªv‡¤úi ¶gZvq Avmvi Av‡MB
†cwkkw³i `vcU Ges mš¿vmx hy³iv‡óª MYZ‡š¿i gvb Kg‡Z ïiæ
Kg©Kv‡Ði Awf‡hvM G‡b‡Qb|18 K‡i‡Q|21
(N) bvivqYMÄ wmwU K‡cv©‡ikb †h Av‡gwiKvi mgvR‡K †K›`ª K‡i
wbe©vP‡b wmw×iM‡Äi 1 b¤^i Aveªvnvg wjsKb Zvi MYZvwš¿K
Iqv‡W© cÖwZØw›ØZv K‡i‡Qb e¨e¯’vi ¯^iƒc e¨³ K‡ib, †mLvbKvi
fvB‡qi weiæ‡× fvB, evevi weiæ‡× eZ©gvb evrmwiK Avq-e¨‡qi
†Q‡j| G cÖm‡½ KvDwÝji Avãyi iwng wnmv‡e A_©vr ev‡RU Av‡jvPbv Ki‡j
e‡jb, gvby‡li fv‡jvevmv wb‡q †`Lv hvq †h, cvigvYweK A¯¿mn
GKUvbv 28 eQi a‡i GjvKvi mvgwiK Lv‡Z †h A_© aiv nq, Zv
†g¤^viwMwi K‡iwQ †KD nviv‡Z RbKj¨vYg~jK A‡_©i †_‡K A‡bK †ekx|
cv‡iwb| wKš‘ Gevi wb‡Ri fvBI Avevi Z…Zxq we‡k¦i †cÖ¶vc‡U †`Lv
`uvwo‡q‡Qb, GUv eoB weeªZKi|19 hvq †h, AwaKvsk miKvi RbM‡Yi
¯^v‡_©i wecix‡Z wb‡Ri ¯^v_©
(O) bxjdvgvixi ˆmq`cyi Dc‡Rjvi wb‡q e¨¯Í, KLbB me©mvavi‡Yi
Kvwkivg †ejcyKzi BDwbqb cwil` ¯^v‡_© cwiPvwjZ bv| †Kbbv,
wbe©vP‡b PvPvi m‡½ †mLvbKvi cÖwZwôZ miKvi KZK¸‡jv
cÖwZØw›ØZv K‡i‡Qb Avcb `yB cyuwRcwZ‡`i mgš^‡q cwiPvwjZ
fvwZRv|20 wek¦e¨vsK, AvB.Gg.AvB M„nxZ
ev¯ÍeZv : mvnvh¨Kvix I civgk©`vbKvix †`k
B‡KvbwgK B‡›Uwj‡RÝ BDwbU (EIU) Z_v ms¯’vi K_vgZ P‡j| d‡j
2006 mvj †_‡K we‡k¦i MYZ‡š¿i gvb I Rbmvavi‡Yi cwie‡Z© †mLv‡b
Ae¯’v a‡i †h m~PK †ei K‡i hv‡”Q, kvmK‡Mvôxi ¯^v_© msiw¶Z nq,
Zv‡Z †`Lv hv‡”Q MYZ‡š¿i Ae¯’v µ‡g hviv Avav mvgšÍev`x I Avav
Lviv‡ci w`‡KB hv‡”Q| 2016 mv‡j cyuwRev`x †`‡ki
cÖwZwbwaZ¡ K‡i|22
17
. ˆ`wbK hyMvšÍi, 27 †deªæqvix 2016| 21
18
. ˆ`wbK Kv‡ji KÉ, 6 Ryb 2011| . ˆ`wbK cÖ_g Av‡jv, 27 GwcÖj 2017,
19
.Link:m.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/article/ (gZvgZ Kjvg: RbM‡Yi KvQ †_‡K MYZš¿ i¶v-
1043043. mvsevw`K G †K Gg RvKvwiqv)|
20 22
.Link:m.prothomalo.com/bangladesh/article/ . ivR‰bwZK msMVb Ges weª‡Ub I
868738. gvwK©b hy³iv‡óªi ivR‰bwZK e¨e¯’v
4 2q el© 6ô
4 msL¨v
 1954 mv‡ji wW‡m¤^‡i cvwK¯Ívb GRb¨ cÖavbZ ¶gZv‡jvfx GKwU
AvIqvgxjx‡Mi mfvcwZ cªfvekvjx Pµ‡KB `vqx Kiv nq| Avevi
†mvnivIqv`©x `‡ji wm×v‡šÍi evB‡i GRb¨ AvÂwjK I we‡kl AvšÍR©vwZK
wM‡q †gvnv¤§` Avjxi gwš¿cwil‡` kw³ `vqx e‡jI A‡b‡K g‡b K‡ib| GB
†hvM w`‡qwQ‡jb| gwš¿Z¡ †bIqvi ci †cÖ¶vc‡U bIqvR kix‡di miKvi
GK mvsevw`‡Ki cÖ‡kœi Rev‡e bvbvfv‡e cÖkœwe× n‡jI
wZwb e‡jwQ‡jb, ÔAvIqvgxjxM Avevi †gqv`c~wZ©i Av‡MB Zuvi we`v‡qi
wK? AvwgB AvIqvgxjxM| mvsevw`K NUbv mevi bhi †K‡o‡Q|
Avevi cÖkœ Ki‡jb, GUv wK wePviwefvM G †¶‡Î mvn‡mi cwiPq
AvIqvgxjx‡Mi g¨vwb‡d‡÷v we‡ivax w`‡q‡Q| Z‡e RbMY DwØMœ GUv
bv? †mvnivIqv`©xi Reve wQj, †f‡e †h, mvg‡bi w`b¸‡jv‡Z Avevi ivR
ÔAvwgB AvIqvgxjx‡Mi ‰bwZK Aw¯’wZkxjZv †`Lv hvq wK-
g¨vwb‡d‡÷vÕ| GB n‡jv Avgv‡`i bv| KviY, RvwZi Av¯’vfvRb Ges
MYZ‡š¿i gvbmcy‡Îi MYZvwš¿K mevi MÖnY‡hvM¨ Av`wk©Kfv‡e
†PZbv!23 ewjô I cwiw¯’wZ †gvKv‡ejvq `¶
26 †m‡Þ¤^i, 2017 g½jevi DMvÛvi †bZ…‡Z¡i Afve i‡q‡Q †`kwU‡Z|
msm‡` †cÖwm‡W‡›Ui kvm‡bi †gqv` Aciw`‡K †Nvjv cvwb‡Z gvQ wkKvi
e„w× wb‡q ZK©vZwK©‡Z msm` Kivi †jvKI Av‡Q A‡bK|26
m`m¨‡`i g‡a¨ gvivgvwi ïiæ nq| 1920 mv‡ji Rvbyqvix gv‡m
msm‡`i ¯úxKvi evievi m`m¨‡`i kvšÍ Av‡gwiKvi wm‡bU Ôg`¨ wbeviK
n‡Z ej‡Qb| wKš‘ †K Kvi K_v †kv‡b! AvBbÕ (Prohibition law) cvk K‡i| hZw`b
†KD †Pqvi Qzo‡Qb †Zv †KD Kjvi a‡i GB wb‡lavÁv KvMRcÎ I Dc‡`‡ki g‡a¨
Nuywl gvi‡Qb KvD‡K| Po, Nuywl mxwgZ wQj, ZZw`b gvwK©b RvwZ
†_‡K †Pqvi †QvovQzwo, ev` †Mj bv Zv‡K mg_©b w`‡qwQj| wKš‘ hLbB
wKQzB| AvnZ n‡jb †ek K‡qKRb|24 Zv ev¯Íevqb Ki‡Z hvIqv nj, ZLbB
MYZ‡š¿i K_v cyuwRev` Mjv dvwU‡q Zviv g` nviv‡bvi f‡q cvMjcviv n‡q
e‡j| ej‡ZB _v‡K, _v‡g bv| DVj| GB AvBb Kvh©Ki Ki‡Z wM‡q
MYZš¿ cÖwZôvi Rb¨ G‡`‡k-I‡`‡k 14 eQ‡i 200 †jvK wbnZ nq Ges 5 jvL
wM‡q †m nvbv †`q| gvbyl gv‡i| 34 nvhvi 335 Rb Kviviæ× nq|
wKš‘ hvi cÖwZôv NUvq, Zv nj Av‡gwiKvb‡`i gb-gM‡h g‡`i
cyuwRi †¯^”QvPvi|25 AcKvwiZv‡K e×g~j K‡i †`Iqvi Rb¨
Av‡›`vjb Kiv nq, eB-cy¯ÍK cÖKvk Kiv
cvwK¯Ív‡bi 70 eQ‡ii BwZnv‡m nq| GZبZxZ D³ AvBbwU Kvh©Ki
MYZš¿ mycÖwZwôZ n‡Z cv‡iwb| Ki‡Z wM‡q 14 eQ‡i gvwK©b
(wWMÖx cÖ_g el©- wØZxq cÎ): w`K`k©b RvwZ‡K 65 †KvwU cvDÛ e¨q Ki‡Z
cÖKvkbx, cybg©y`ªY: Ryb 2017, c„t 131| nq| wKš‘ g` wbwl× †NvlYv Kivi ci g`
23
.Link:www.bdpratidin.com/editorial/ †PvjvB‡qi †`vKv‡bi msL¨v c~‡e©i
2016/07/18/157466. †P‡q AviI †e‡o hvq| N‡i N‡i g` ˆZwii
24
. ˆ`wbK evsjv‡`k cÖwZw`b, 27 †m‡Þ¤^i KvR Pj‡Z _v‡K| Pzwi, WvKvwZ,
2017| wQbZvB, al©Y, mš¿vm, nZ¨vKvÐ
25
. ˆ`wbK mgKvj, 5 ˆR¨ô 1424, c„t 8, (gšÍe¨
26
Kjvg: MYZ‡š¿i c_NvU-Aa¨vcK wmivRyj . gvwmK c„w_ex, el© 36, msL¨v 12,
Bmjvg †PŠayix)| †m‡Þ¤^i 2017, c„t 48|
msL¨v

4
2q el© 6ô

5
BZ¨vw` mKj cÖKvi Aciv‡ai msL¨v ˆbwZK, PvwiwÎK I Ava¨vwZ¥K mKj
KíbvZxZfv‡e †e‡o hvq| †kl ch©šÍ w`K bó nIqvi Dcµg nq|27
wek¦ BwZnv‡mi GB e„nËg ms¯‹vi evsjv‡`‡k 2014 mv‡ji 5 Rvbyqvix
cÖ‡Póv wbõj cÖwZcbœ nq| Ae‡k‡l `kg RvZxq msm` wbev©P‡bi w`b
1933 mv‡ji wW‡m¤^‡i Av‡gwiKvi mwnsmZvq wbnZ n‡q‡Q 19 Rb|
miKvi 21Zg msweavb ms‡kvabxi 2013 mv‡ji 25 b‡f¤^i Zdwmj
gva¨‡g D³ AvBb‡K evwZj K‡i †NvlYvi ci †_‡K †fv‡Ui Av‡Mi w`b
g`cvb‡K ˆea †NvlYv K‡i| GB nj ch©šÍ 41 w`‡b gviv †M‡Q 123 Rb|28
AvaywbK mf¨ZvMe©x I
Avevi `jxq cÖZx‡K cÖ_g AbywôZ
MYZš¿‡cÖgx Av‡gwiKvi mgvRwPÎ|
BDwbqb cwil` wbev©P‡bi 6 av‡c
Gevi †`Lyb c„w_exi Ab¨ †Mvjv‡a©i cÖvY nvwi‡q‡Q 130 Rb Ges AvnZ
Av‡iKwU mgvRwPÎ| 1400 eQi n‡q‡Q cÖvq 8,000 Rb|29
c~‡e© AÜKvi hy‡M wPiKvj g`¨cv‡b
cÖPwjZ gvbeiwPZ MYZš¿B gvby‡li
Af¨¯Í AvieRvwZ Bmjvg MÖnY Kivi
cÖvY Gfv‡e wbwe©Pv‡i †K‡o
c‡i hLb g`¨cvb wbwl× nIqvi Bjvnx
wb‡”Q|
wb‡`©k jvf Kij (evK¡vivn 219 I
gv‡q`vn 90 AvqvZ)| m‡½ m‡½ Zviv g¨vMvwRb Abyôvb ÔBZ¨vw`Õ
webv evK¨e¨‡q g` cwiZ¨vM Ki‡jb, cÖ‡hvRK I weL¨vZ wUwf
gy‡L †bqv g‡`i cvÎ Qzu‡o †d‡j w`‡jb, e¨w³Z¡ nvwbd ms‡KZ Zuvi GKwU
†KD Mjvq Av½yj XywK‡q DMwi‡q †KŠZzK A¨vjev‡g e‡jwQ‡jb,
w`‡jb| wbR nv‡Z g‡`i fvÐ †f‡½ Aveªvnvg wjsK‡bi †W‡gv‡µwmi
¸uwo‡q w`‡jb| g`xbvi Awj-Mwj‡Z msÁvwU GLb n‡e ‘Government buy the
g‡`i †¯ªvZ e‡q †Mj| hviv g` Qvo‡Z people, Off the people, Far the people’
Pvbwb, Zv‡`i Rb¨ kvw¯Íi †NvlYv Kiv A_v©r ÔMYZš¿ RbMY‡K †K‡b,
nj| AvBb cÖ‡qvMKvix ms¯’v QvovB RbMY‡K evB‡i iv‡L Ges RbMY †_‡K
gyn~‡Z©i g‡a¨B g`¨cvb G‡Kev‡iB `~‡i _v‡KÕ|30
eÜ n‡q †Mj| AvaywbK hy‡M kw³kvjx Avgiv Kx ai‡bi MYZ‡š¿i PP©v Kwi
Av‡gwiKv Zvi mg¯Í cÖ‡Póv w`‡q hv Ges Kx ai‡bi MYZ‡š¿i †fZ‡i i‡qwQ
Ki‡Z e¨_© n‡q‡Q, Zv ïay cweÎ wKsev wQjvg Zvi DËi LyuR‡Z
KziAv‡bi GKwU AvqvZ (gv‡q`vn 90 nvwbd ms‡K‡Zi m‡½ wØgZ †cvl‡Yi
AvqvZ) ØvivB ga¨hyMxq Avi‡e Lye †ekx my‡hvM †eva Kwi bv| e¯‘Z
Kvh©Ki n‡q †M‡Q| wKš‘ GUv GRb¨B †h †`‡k MYZš¿ hZ‡ekx msKUvcbœ,
m¤¢e n‡q‡Q †h, Zuv‡`i g‡a¨ †m †`‡ki miKvi I ¶gZvmxb `‡ji
Avjøvn&i Av‡`k I wb‡la †g‡b Pjvi
GKUv Pig cÖeYZv wQj| GB wQj
g`xbvi Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Zi ev¯Íe djvdj| 27
. Bgvg Be‡b Zvqwgqv (int), kixqZx ivóª
e¨e¯’v, Abyev`: gvIjvbv RyjwdKvi Avn&g`
GK_v mZ¨ †h, kvmK hw` Bmjvg wKm&gZx (Avnmvb cvewj‡Kkb, cÖKvkKvj:
†_‡K `~‡i m‡i _v‡K, Zvn‡j RbM‡Yi Rvbyqvix 2008 Cmvqx), c„t 249|
28
. Link: bn.m.wikipedia.org/evsjv‡`‡ki mvaviY
wbev©Pb, 2014|
29
. ˆ`wbK BbwKjve, 5 Ryb 2016|
30
. Link: m.ntvbd.com/opinion/39851.
4 2q el© 6ô
6 msL¨v
 †bZviv ÔMYZš¿Õ kãwU ZZ‡ekx MYZ‡š¿i weiæ‡× Agymwjg
D”PviY K‡ib|31 wPšÍvwe`‡`i Agi evYx :
AZGe, GK_v ej‡j AZz¨w³ n‡e bv †h, hviv MYZ‡š¿i ¯ªóv Zv‡`i A‡b‡KB
MYZ‡š¿ RbM‡Yi kvm‡bi K_v ejv n‡jI GLb MYZ‡š¿i weiæ‡× Ae¯’vb
ïay †fv‡Ui mgq RbM‡Yi gZvgZ †bIqv wb‡q‡Qb, hLb Zvi Kzdj cÖKvwkZ
nq Avi mKj †¶‡Î Zv‡`i gZvg‡Zi n‡Z ïiæ K‡i‡Q| Avi A‡bK †kÖô
†Zvqv°v Kiv nq bv| wPšÍvwe` memgqB MYZ‡š¿i
wcÖq cvVK-cvwVKv! ÔBmjvgx ivóª weiæ‡× Ae¯’vb wb‡q‡Qb| †hgb-
e¨e¯’vq bvMwi‡Ki mvwe©K (K) cÖvPxbKv‡ji cÖL¨vZ gbxlx I
wbivcËv I †gŠwjK AwaKvi †hfv‡e `vk©wbKMY †hgb †cø‡Uv I Gwi÷Uj
wbwðZ Kiv n‡q‡Q, Zv GB AvaywbK MYZš¿‡K gy‡L©i I A‡hv‡M¨i kvmb
MYZ‡š¿i hy‡MI Ab¨ †Kvb ivóª e¨e¯’v e‡j AwfwnZ K‡i‡Qb|33
cwiPvjbv e¨e¯’vq KíbvI Kiv hvq bv| (L) Gwgj d¨v¸‡q e‡jb,
Ab¨ K_vq, Bmjvgx ivóª cwiPvjbv ÔMYZš¿ A¶gZvi kvmb cÖYvjxÕ (The
e¨e¯’v e¨ZxZ Ab¨vb¨ cÖvPxb wKsev cult of Incompetence).
AvaywbK ivóª e¨e¯’vi meUzKzB
(M) †jwKi g‡Z, ÔMYZš¿ n‡”Q
cÖYqb Kiv n‡q‡Q gvby‡li eyw×-
me©v‡c¶v `wi`ª, AÁ I AKg©Y¨
we‡ePbvi Av‡jv‡K| wKš‘ Bmjvgx
e¨w³i miKvi| KviY G †kÖwYi †jvKB
ivóª cwiPvjbv e¨e¯’v cÖYxZ n‡q‡Q
me©vwaKÕ|
Avn&Kvgyj nvwKgxb Avjøvn iveŸyj
Avjvgx‡bi c¶ †_‡K Awni gva¨‡g| Avi (N) Kvjv©Bj Dcnvm Q‡j MYZš¿‡K
Avjøvn n‡”Qb †mB cwic~Y© mËv Ôwb‡e©v‡ai ivRZ¡Õ e‡j AwfwnZ
whwb GKw`‡K †hgb mgMÖ K‡i‡Qb|34
m„óRx‡ei GKK ¯ªóv, Ab¨w`‡K (O) divwm `vk©wbK Ru¨v R¨vK
†Zgwb gvbylmn mgMÖ m„ó RM‡Zi iæ‡kv e‡jb, Ôm~²fv‡e wPšÍv Ki‡j
AZxZ-eZ©gvb-fwel¨Z A_©vr mK‡ji ej‡Z nq, †Kv_vI cÖK…Z MYZ‡š¿i
Kj¨vY-AKj¨vYmn hveZxq welq Aw¯ÍZ¡ cvIqv hvq bv| KviY GUv
m¤ú‡K© cwic~Y©iƒ‡c AeMZ| AZGe, cÖvK…wZK ixwZ weiæ×| Gi bxwZ
¯ªóv KZ…©K cÖ`Ë ivóªe¨e¯’vi nj, msL¨vMwiô‡K kvmb Ki‡Z n‡e Avi
†gvKv‡ejvq m„wó KZ…©K msL¨vjNy‡K kvwmZ n‡Z n‡eÕ|
ivóªe¨e¯’vi †Kvb ZzjbvB n‡Z cv‡i (P) KvbvwWqvb ivRbxwZwe` I
bv| Avi GB `vexi ev¯ÍeZv Avgiv mvsevw`K Henri Bourassa e‡jb,
cÖZ¨¶ Kwi bex Kixg (Qvt)-Gi ivóª ÔMYZ‡š¿i K_v ejvi †P‡q eo cÖZviYv
cwiPvjbv e¨e¯’v I ZrcieZ©x Avi wKQzB †bB| Gi ïiæUvB wg_¨v|
†Lvjvdv‡q iv‡k`x‡bi ivóª cwiPvjbvi
gv‡SÕ|32
33
. `vwLj evsjv‡`k I wek¦ cwiPq: beg-`kg
†kÖwY, cybg©y`ªY: †m‡Þ¤^i 2016, Aóg
Aa¨vq, c„t 119|
31
. mvsevw`K I †jLK Avgxb Avj-ikx`: Link: 34
. (L, M I N) †cŠibxwZ I mykvmb- cÖ_g cÎ
m.ntvbd.com/opinion/39851. (cÖ‡dmi †gv: †gvRv‡¤§j nK): GKv`k-Øv`k
32
. gvwmK g`xbv, 53 el©, 7g msL¨v, †kÖwY, nvmvb eyK nvDm- XvKv, PZz_©
†m‡Þ¤^i 2017, c„t 25| ms¯‹iY: Ryb 2016, mßg Aa¨vq, c„t 229|
msL¨v

4
2q el© 6ô

7
†Kvb e„nr ev mg„× iv‡óª GUv ¯’vqx gva¨‡g MYZvwš¿K iƒ‡c mymw¾Z
nqwbÕ| Kiv m¤¢e bqÕ|
(Q) evU©ªvÛ iv‡mj e‡jb, ÔEnvy is the (W) ivóªweÁvbx ievU© c¨v‡Kb nvg
Basis of DemocracyÕ A_©vr ÔwnsmvB (Robert Packen ham) e‡jb, ÔZ…Zxq
MYZ‡š¿i wfwËÕ| we‡k¦i AwaKvsk †`‡k A`~i fwel¨‡Z
(R) DBÝUb PvwP©j e‡jb, Ôc„w_ex‡Z D`vi‰bwZK MYZ‡š¿i fwel¨Z
MYZš¿B me‡P‡q wbK…ó kvmb †gv‡UB D¾¡j bqÕ| 37

e¨e¯’vÕ| Bnv QvovI AmsL¨ ivóªweÁvbx

(S) ivóªweÁvbx UK‡fjx e‡jb, MYZ‡š¿i weiæ‡× Zuv‡`i gZvgZ e¨³
ÔMYZ‡š¿i cÖavb mgm¨v nj K‡i‡Qb|
msL¨v¸iæi ˆ¯^ivPviÕ|35 MYZ‡š¿i weiæ‡× gymwjg
(T) 1950 mvj †_‡K 1990 mvj ch©šÍ wPšÍvwe`‡`i `„wófw½ :
ivóªweÁvbx A¨vWvg †cÖvRIiw¯‹ (K) wesk kZvãxi †kÖô gynvwÏQ
Ges dvbv©‡Wv wj‡gw¯‹ M‡elYv K‡i kvqL bvwQiæÏxb Avjevbx (int) e‡jb,
†`wL‡q‡Qb †h, Mo gv_vwcQz Avq ÔBmjvg I MYZš¿ `yÕ‡Uv
1500 Wjvi bv n‡j MYZš¿ †UKv wecixZgyLx e¨e¯’v, hv KL‡bv GK
gykwKj| G `yÕRb ivóªweÁvbx e‡jb, nIqvi bqÕ|
Ô`wi`ª Rb‡Mvôxi Rb¨ MYZš¿ bq|
(L) gnvKwe W. Avjøvgv BKevj
ivóª bvwK abx n‡q †M‡j
e‡j‡Qb, ÔcvjvI MYZš¿ †_‡K, AbyMZ
MYZš¿ AgiZ¡ jvf K‡iÕ| 36
nI R‰bK AwfÁ I eyw×gvb e¨w³i,
(U) Av‡gwiKvi ÔPublic InterestÕ GKRb gvby‡li wPšÍv Av‡m bv `yÕk
cwÎKvi m¤úv`K Avwf©s wµ÷j e‡jb, Mvavi gw¯Í®‹ †_‡KÕ|
ÔA`~i fwel¨‡Z MYZš¿ wek¦R‡q m¶g (M) Avjøvgv kvbK¡xZx
n‡e bv| wek¦ G Rb¨ ˆZwi nqwb| MYZš¿ m¤ú‡K© `xN© Av‡jvPbvi ci
MYZ‡š¿i c~e©kZ© AZ¨šÍ RwUj| e‡jb, ÔwbðqB hviv Avjøvn I Zuvi
wKš‘ cÖvYešÍ mvs¯‹…wZK `„wófw½ ivm~‡ji bxwZweiæ× gvbeiwPZ
I cÖeYZv G Rb¨ Acwinvh©Õ| wewa-weavb AbymiY K‡i hv kqZvb
(V) B‡qj wek¦we`¨vj‡qi Aa¨vcK Zvi Abymvix‡`i gva¨‡g cÖeZ©b
ievU© Wvj (Robert Dahl) 1984 mv‡j K‡i‡Q, Zviv wbtm‡›`‡n Kvwdi I
e‡jwQ‡jb, Ô`w¶Y I ga¨ Av‡gwiKvi gykwiKÕ|38
hy³ivóª MYZš¿ we¯Ív‡ii †h bxwZ (N) Avj-RvwgÔAvn Avm-
AbymiY K‡i‡Q, Zv åvšÍ| G A‡ji mvjvwdq¨vn-Gi cÖwZôvZv I
AMYZvwš¿K kvmbe¨e¯’v‡K A_© cwiPvjK kvqL Avãyi ivhhvK web
mvnvh¨, Dc‡`k weZiY ev n¯Í‡¶‡ci BDmyd e‡j‡Qb, Ôc„w_ex‡Z †h

35 37
. (O-S) gyhvddi web gynwmb, åvwšÍi . (U-W) ˆ`wbK bqvw`MšÍ, 1 b‡f¤^i 2015,
†eovRv‡j BK¡vg‡Z Øxb (cÖKvkK: evsjv‡`k (MYZ‡š¿i fwel¨r- GgvRDÏxb Avng`)|
Avn‡jnv`xQ hyemsN, wØZxq ms¯‹iY: RyjvB 38
. (K-M) kvqL gyhvddi web gynwmb,
2014), c„t 218-219| åvwšÍi †eovRv‡j BK¡vg‡Z Øxb (cÖKvkK:
36
.Link:m.banglatribune.com/columns/opinion/ evsjv‡`k Avn‡jnv`xQ hyemsN, wØZxq
76995. ms¯‹iY: RyjvB 2014), c„t 220-222|
4 2q el© 6ô
8 msL¨v
 MYZš¿ wkiKx cÖ_v, me‡P‡q msL¨vMwiô RbM‡Yi iv‡qi h_vh_
b¨v°viRbK, †bvsiv, RNb¨, ee©i, cÖwZdj‡bi e¨e¯’vI cvðv‡Z¨i
Amf¨ bxwZ-G K_v Avgiv wek eQi a‡i Z_vKw_Z MYZ‡š¿ †hgb Abycw¯’Z
e‡j AvmwQ| wm‡jKkb nj wbev©Pb †Zgwb m~² KviPzwc, Awbqg I
c×wZ‡Z ivm~‡ji Av`k©, ivm~‡ji A¯^”QZvi AvkÖq MÖnY K‡i cÖK…Z
wkóvPvi| Avi B‡jKkb nj gvby‡li Rbivq‡K wfbœ c‡_ cwiPvwjZ Kivi
evbv‡bv bxwZ| GB `yBUv GK n‡Z my‡hvM i‡q‡Q| †`‡ki Rbmgwói g‡a¨
cv‡i bvÕ|39 hw` msL¨vMwiô gvbyl mZ¨‡K
(O) kvqL gyhvddi web gynwmb wg_¨v e‡j ivq †`q, Zvn‡j cvðv‡Z¨i
e‡j‡Qb, ÔMYZš¿, mgvRZš¿, MYZš¿ mZ¨‡K wg_¨v e‡jB MÖnY
ag©wbi‡c¶Zvev`, RvZxqZvev` Ki‡Z eva¨Õ|42
cÖf…wZ wkiKx gZev‡`i c~Rv Kiv (R) wewkó AvšÍR©vwZK Bmjvgx
Ôwki‡K AvKeviÕ ev eo wkiK| GB eo M‡elK kvqL Avãyj nvgx` dvBhx Avj-
wki‡Ki cwiYvg nj- ZIev bv K‡i gviv gv`vbx e‡j‡Qb, ÔAwaKvsk gvbyl‡K
†M‡j Zvi ¶gvi †Kvb my‡hvM †bB Avjøvn&i cÖwZ wek¦vmx, K…ZÁ bv
Ges †Kvbw`b Rvbœv‡Z hvIqvi c_ Kiv ch©šÍ, msL¨vMwiô gvbyl
†bBÕ|40 mgS`vi I Ávbx bv nIqv ch©šÍ Ges
(P) kvqL gwZDi ingvb gv`vbx †ekxifvM gvbyl mZ¨vbymvix bv
e‡j‡Qb, ÔBmjvgx MYZš¿ e‡j wKQz nIqv ch©šÍ eZ©gv‡bi MYZvwš¿K
†bB| Bmjv‡g i‡q‡Q k~iv c×wZÕ|41 c×wZ‡Z Bmjvgx ivóª Kv‡qg Kiv
mnR bq| †`‡ki msL¨vMwi‡ôi gb i¶v
(Q) Kvive›`x gvIjvbv †`jvIqvi K‡i Pjvi ivRbxwZ Bmjv‡g †bB|
†nvmvBb mvC`x †kl Rxe‡b G‡m Bmjv‡gi hveZxq bxwZ †Kej
MYZš¿ m¤ú‡K© wZ³ AwfÁZv Zz‡j Avjøvn‡K mš‘ó Kivi gva¨g| AZGe,
a‡i e‡j‡Qb, Ô†fvMev`x MYZ‡š¿i GB AwaKvsk gvbyl evwZjcš’x n‡jI Zv‡`i
A`„k¨ g~wZ© mZ¨‡K wg_¨v, gb hywM‡q Avjøvn‡K Amš‘ó Kivi gZ
wg_¨v‡K mZ¨, mvay‡K †Pvi, †Pvi‡K `ytmvnwmKZvc~Y© ivRbxwZ
mvay, ˆea‡K A‰ea, A‰ea‡K ˆea gymwjg Ki‡Z cv‡i bvÕ| 43
evbv‡bvi ¶gZvI msi¶Y K‡i| cvðv‡Z¨i
MYZš¿ bvgK GB A`„k¨ g~wZ©i AÜ (S) Bmjvgx HK¨ Av‡›`vj‡bi
c~Rvix‡`i Kv‡Q ¯’vqx †Kvb g~j¨gvb cÖwZôvZv †Pqvig¨vb gvIjvbv
†bB- G‡`i Kv‡Q mZ¨ Avi wg_¨v, gynv¤§` Avãyi inxg (int) 1985 mv‡ji
b¨vq Avi Ab¨v‡qi wPišÍb †Kvb gvb`Ð cÖ_g fv‡M GK Kg©x m‡¤§j‡b cÖ`Ë
†bB| G‡`i gvb`Ð nj †`‡ki msL¨vMwiô fvl‡Y e‡jwQ‡jb, Ô†h
RbM‡Yi ivq ev gZvgZ| Avevi MYZš¿ eZ©gv‡b `ywbqvi †`‡k †`‡k
42
39
. gvIjvbv †`jvIqvi †nvmvBb mvC`x,
. BDwUDe: MYZš¿- gydwZ Avãyi iv¾vK mxiv‡Z mvB‡q¨`yj gyimvjxb (XvKv:
web BDmyd/Alor Poth. †Møvevj cvewjwks †bUIqvK©, Z…Zxq
40
. gvwmK Avj-BwZQvg, 1g el©, 11Zg cÖKvk: gvP© 2014), c„t 467|
msL¨v, †m‡Þ¤^i 2017, c„t 9, Kjvg-2| 43
. Avãyj nvgx` dvBhx Avj-gv`vbx, hye-
41
. BDwUDe: †fvU †`Iqv Ges MYZvwš¿K mgm¨v I Zvi kiqx mgvavb (XvKv: ZvInx`
ivRbxwZ Kiv Rv‡qh wK? Bmjvgx MYZš¿ e‡j †cÖm GÛ cvewj‡KkÝ, cÖ_g cÖKvk: gvP©
wKQz Av‡Q wK?/REAL TABLIG. 2010 Cmvqx), c„t 282|
msL¨v

4
2q el© 6ô

9
Pvjy i‡q‡Q, GUv GKUv wfwËnxb, mgqKvi D™¢~Z ivóªwPšÍvi GKwU
A‡hŠw³K, A‰eÁvwbK Z_v wg_¨v aviYv, Avwg GBUzKzB Rvwb| Bnvi
kvmb e¨e¯’v| GB wg_¨v I we¯ÍvwiZ wbðqB Rbve mwjgyjøvn
†auvKvevwRi kvmb e¨e¯’v Øviv Lvb Rv‡bb, Z‡e BD‡iv‡c ivóª I
RbM‡Yi †Kvb Kj¨vYB mvwaZ n‡Z Pv‡P©i ga¨Kvi ؇›Øi mv‡_ cÖv‡P¨i
cv‡i bv| ZvB Zv cÖwZôvi Rb¨ †Póv Bmjvg I Bmjvgx ivóªwPšÍv‡K
Kiv GKUv wb‡iU wg_¨v ÔKzdiÕ‡K †MvjvBqv †dwj‡j Bmjv‡gi `„wó‡Z †h
cÖwZwôZ Kivi †Póv Qvov Avi †mKzjvwiRg GKwU Kzdix gZev`
wKQzB bq| GB †Póv‡K ÔwRnv` dx Zvnv‡K Rbve mwjgyjøvn Lv‡bi
mvexwjjøvnÕ ejv †h‡Z cv‡i bv| wbKU mf¨ MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’v g‡b
KziAv‡bi fvlvq Zv n‡”Q ÔwRnv` dx nB‡ZB cv‡i| wKš‘ †Kvb Cgvb`vi
mvexwjZ Z¡vM~ZÕ Z_v Z¡vM~Zx gymwjg †mBiƒc g‡b Kwi‡Z cv‡ib
kvmb K¡v‡q‡gi msMÖvgÕ|44 bvÕ|47
(T) Bmjvgx wek¦we`¨vjq, Kzwóqv-Gi GQvovI cÖ‡Z¨K hy‡Mi nK¡cš’x
Avj-nv`xQ wefv‡Mi mn‡hvMx Av‡jg-Ijvgv cÖPwjZ MYZš¿‡K
Aa¨vcK W. †Lv›`Kvi Avãyjøvn mg_©b K‡ibwb|
Rvnv½xi (int) e‡j‡Qb, ÔBmjvg MYZš¿ ebvg Bmjvgx wLjvdZ :
cÖPwjZ MYZš¿ mg_©b K‡i bvÕ|45
(K) MYZš¿ gv‡b nj, gvby‡li m„ó
(U) be gymwjg W. Rb cvK©m Zvui gZev` cÖwZôv Kiv| c¶všÍ‡i Bmjvgx
GK mv¶vrKv‡i e‡j‡Qb, ÔBmjvg wLjvdZ cÖwZôv gv‡b nj, Avjøvn
m¤^‡Ü KvD‡K †evSv‡Z PvB‡j ˆah© cÖ`Ë Rxeb weavb cÖwZôv Kiv|
aiæb, ax‡i ax‡i mgq wb‡q Bmjvg
m¤ú‡K© mwVK Bbdi‡gkb w`b| (L) MYZ‡š¿i g~j w_Iix nj, †hfv‡eB
ivRbxwZ‡K `~‡i †V‡j ivL‡eb G †nvK gvbyl‡K mš‘ó Kiv| Avi Bmjvgx
mg‡q| Zvn‡j fzj †evSvSzwS †_‡K i¶v wLjvd‡Zi g~j w_Dix nj, Avjøvn&i
cv‡ebÕ|46 mš‘wó jv‡fi D‡Ï‡k¨ Rb‡mev Kiv|
(V) MvRxcyi †Rjv AvBbRxex (M) MYZš¿ ¶Y¯’vqx Ges Gi weavb I
mwgwZi mvaviY m¤úv`K (2006- bxwZ cwieZ©bkxj| MYZ‡š¿i AvBb-
2008 mb) †gvt gwbi †nv‡mb K¡vb~b G‡KK †`‡k G‡KK iKg|
e‡j‡Qb, ÔRbve mwjgyjøvn Lvb D`vniY¯^iƒc, evsjv‡`k msweavb G
†mKzjvwiRg‡K g‡b K‡ib mf¨ ch©šÍ 16 evi ms‡kvab Kiv n‡q‡Q|
MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’v wnmv‡e| c¶všÍ‡i Bmjv‡gi weavb I bxwZ
†mKzjvwiR‡gi aviYvUv BD‡iv‡c wK¡qvg‡Zi AvM ch©šÍ
PvP© Ges ivóªkw³i ga¨Kvi ؇›Øi AcwieZ©bkxj Ges mKj †`‡k GKB
iKg|
44
. nhiZ gvIjvbv Avãyi inxg (int), MYZš¿ bq
(N) MYZ‡š¿ mZ¨-wg_¨vi gvb`Ð nj,
c~Y©v½ wecøe (PDF), c„ôv 10|
45
. BDwUDe: Bmjvg MYZš¿ mg_©b K‡i
GK †kÖwYi gvbyl| c¶všÍ‡i Bmjv‡g
wKbv? -W. L›`Kvi Avãyjøvn Rvnv½xi|
46 47
. Avãyj nvgx` dvBhx Avj-gv`vbx, hye- . †gvt gwbi †nv‡mb, ivRbxwZ‡Z a‡g©i
mgm¨v I Zvi kviC mgvavb (ZvInx` †cÖm wRwKi wdwiqv Avwmj †Kb?, Bmjvgx wk¶v
GÛ cvewj‡KkÝ, cÖ_g cÖKvk: gvP© 2010 cÖKvkbv I M‡elYv ms¯’v, MvRxcyi, cÖ_g
Cmvqx), c„t 283| cÖKvk: 05 RyjvB 2014, f~wgKv, c„t 5|
5 2q el© 6ô
0 msL¨v
 mZ¨-wg_¨vi gvb`Ð n‡jb, gnvb m¤^‡Ü Rvb‡Z †P‡q Avcbv‡K cÖkœ
Avjøvn| K‡ib †h, Ôgynv¤§` (Qvt)-Gi wgk‡b
(O) MYZ‡š¿ RbMYB mKj ¶gZvi Drm| Kx Ggb wQj †h †kl ch©šÍ g°vi
c¶všÍ‡i Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Z mKj ¶gZvi mgvRcwZiv Zuv‡K nZ¨v Ki‡Z PvBj?
Drm gnvb Avjøvn (evK¡vivn 2/165; A_P cÖPwjZ aviYvg‡Z †Zv Bmjvg
AvbÔAvg 6/57; BDmyd 12/40)| kvwšÍi ag©!Õ ZLb Avcbvi Kvw•ÿZ I
(P) MYZ‡š¿ mve©‡fŠg‡Z¡i m½Z Reve Kx n‡e? Z‡e Avgvi Reve
(Sovereignty) gvwjK RbMY| c¶všÍ‡i n‡e- Ôgvby‡li Dci gvby‡li cÖfz‡Z¡i
Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Z mve©‡fŠg‡Z¡i Aemvb ev gvby‡li `vmZ¡ †_‡K
gvwjK n‡jb gnvb Avjøvn (Av‡j Bgivb gvbyl‡K gyw³ †`IqvB wQj Zuvi
3/26)| wgk‡bi cÖavb I e¨vcK j¶¨Õ|
(Q) MYZ‡š¿ msL¨vMwiô Z_v (U) MYZ‡š¿ AwaKvsk †¶‡Î cÖv_©x
AwaKvsk RbM‡Yi ivqB P~ovšÍ| wb‡Ri mybvg Ges cÖwZØ›Øxi
KziAv‡b ewY©Z n‡q‡Q Ô(†n bex) Kzrmv iUvq| c¶všÍ‡i Avjøvn ZvÔAvjv
Zzwg hw` AwaKvsk †jv‡Ki ivq‡K e‡jb, Ô†Zvgiv cvc I evovevwo‡Z
†g‡b bvI, Zvn‡j Zviv †Zvgv‡K G‡K A‡b¨i mn‡hvwMZv Ki bvÕ
Avjøvn&i c_ n‡Z wePz¨Z K‡i †dj‡e| (gv‡q`vn 5/02)|
Zviv †Kej KíbviB AbymiY K‡i _v‡K (V) MYZš¿ gvbyl‡K `‡j `‡j wef³ K‡i
Ges †KejgvÎ AbygvbB K‡i _v‡KÕ †`q A_©vr gvby‡li g‡a¨ A‡bK¸‡jv `j
(AvbÔAvg 6/116)| ˆZwi K‡i †`q| c¶všÍ‡i Bmjv‡g `‡j `‡j
(R) MYZš¿ m~`wfwËK A_©bxwZ wef³ nIqv nvivg| gnvb Avjøvn e‡jb,
cÖwZôv K‡i| c¶všÍ‡i Avjøvn µq- Ô†Zvgiv mK‡j Avjøvn&i i¾y‡K
weµq‡K ˆea Ges m~`‡K nvivg my`„p n‡¯Í aviY Ki Ges `‡j `‡j
†NvlYv K‡i‡Qb (evK¡vivn 2/275)| wew”Qbœ n‡q †hIbvÕ (Av‡j Bgivb
3/103)|
(S) MYZ‡š¿ †ek¨ve„wˇK jvB‡mÝ
w`‡q ˆea †NvlYv Kiv nq| ZvB‡Zv gnvKwe W. Avjøvgv BKevj
D`vniY¯^iƒc, eZ©gv‡b evsjv‡`‡ki e‡j‡Qb, Ô`jxq wefw³ I A‰b‡K¨i
wewfbœ ¯’v‡b cÖvq 22 wUiI †ekx wfwË ¸uwo‡q `vI, img-†iIqv‡Ri
miKvix wbeÜbavix †ek¨vjq i‡q‡Q|48 wmjwmjv‡K †f‡½ Pzigvi K‡i `vI|
KviY GUvB Øx‡bi wb‡`©k; GLv‡bB
c¶všÍ‡i Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Z †hbv-
i‡q‡Q weR‡qi `iRv, hvi d‡j mgMÖ
e¨wfPvi kvw¯Í‡hvM¨ Aciva (b~i
c„w_ex‡Z ZvInx‡`i evZ©v wPi
24/02)|
Db¥y³ n‡eÕ|49
(T) MYZ‡š¿ gvbyl gvby‡li
(W) MYZ‡š¿ gZ cÖKv‡k, †fvU `v‡b I
`vmZ¡ Ki‡Z eva¨| c¶všÍ‡i Bmjv‡g
wbe©vP‡b RvwZ, ag©, eY©
gvbyl †Kej Avjøvn&i `vmZ¡ Ki‡Z
wbwe©‡k‡l mK‡ji mgvb AwaKvi|
eva¨| m¤§vwbZ cvVK-cvwVKv!
c¶všÍ‡i Bmjv‡g gvbyl wnmv‡e mK‡j
GLv‡b GKwU †QvÆ K_v e‡j ivwL,
hw` †Kvb Agymwjg e¨w³ Bmjvg 49
. gyhvddi web gynwmb, Avn‡jnv`xQ‡`i
msMÖvgx †PZbv (AvQ-wQivZ
48
. gvwmK Avj-BwZQvg, 1g el©, 9g msL¨v Kw¤úDUvm©, ivRkvnx, wØZxq ms¯‹iY:
(RyjvB 2017), c„t 33| gvN 1417), c„t 24|
msL¨v

5
2q el© 6ô

1
mvaviYfv‡e †gŠwjK AwaKvi †fvM cÖwZôv Ki‡Z Pvq, Zviv wK Zvn‡j
Ki‡e wKš‘ †hvM¨Zv, AwfÁZv I wLjvdZ e¨e¯’v‡K eZ©gvb we‡k¦i
ZvK¡Iqvi wfwˇZ ¸YxR‡biv we‡kl Rb¨ †egvbvb g‡b K‡i bv?
g~j¨vwqZ nb| Avevi, Av‡iK`j †jvK bv‡g-†ebv‡g
(X) MYZvwš¿K wek¦v‡m ag© Aek¨B wRnv‡`i Ace¨vL¨v K‡i R½xev`x
ivRbxwZ weewR©Z A_©vr ag©xq ivRbxwZ ïiæ K‡i‡Q my‡KŠk‡j
ivRbxwZ ivóª cwiPvjbv †_‡K Avjv`v| `ywbqv †_‡K Bmjvg‡K wgwU‡q †djvi
c¶všÍ‡i Bmjvgx wewa-weavb Øviv Rb¨| Zv‡`i e³e¨ nj, Ôivóª¶gZv Qvov
ivóª cwiPvjbv Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Zi Bmjv‡gi weRq m¤¢e bq| myZivs,
Awe‡”Q`¨ Ask| †h‡Kvbfv‡e ivóªxq ¶gZv `Lj Ki‡Z
(Y) msL¨vMwiô RbM‡Yi B”Qvi cÖwZ n‡e| AZtci Bmjv‡gi weRq Avb‡Z
AvZ¥mgc©‡bi bvg MYZš¿| c¶všÍ‡i n‡eÕ| A_P Bmjvg Zv KL‡bvB
Avjøvn&i cÖwZ AvZ¥mgc©‡bi bvg mg_©b K‡i bv| bex-ivm~jM‡Yi
nj Bmjvg| bxwZ nj, AvK¡x`v I Avgj ms‡kva‡bi
gva¨‡g Avjøvn&i ev›`v‡K
Bnv QvovI MYZš¿ I Bmjvgx wLjvd‡Zi gyIqvn&wn` ev LuvwU ZvInx`cš’x
g‡a¨ GiKg jv‡Lv cv_©K¨ i‡q‡Q, hv wnmv‡e M‡o †Zvjv| GB cÖwµqvq
Ávbx cvVK gvÎB eyS‡Z †c‡i‡Qb| Avjøvn PvB‡j Zuvi Øxb‡K ivóªxqfv‡e
GKwU hiƒix ÁvZe¨ : cÖwZôv `vb Ki‡eb| †hgb- `vIqvZx
Avjøvn&i †`qv wba©vwiZ c_ wLjvdZ Kv‡Ri m~Pbvj‡MœB g°vi Kvwdi-
cÖwZôv Qvov gvby‡li Mov gZev` gykwiK †bZ…e„›` gynv¤§` (Qvt)-Gi
MYZš¿ w`‡q Kw¯§bKv‡jI Bmjvg Dci ivóª¶gZv Ac©Y Ki‡Z †P‡qwQj,
cÖwZôv Kiv m¤¢e n‡e bv| eZ©gvb wKš‘ wZwb Zv N„Yvf‡i cÖZ¨vLvb
†cÖ¶vc‡U MYZš¿ Qvov Bmjv‡gi K‡iwQ‡jb| c‡i `vIqvZx Kv‡Ri gva¨‡g
weRq m¤¢e bq, GUv MÐ g~L© I gvby‡li AvK¡x`v I Avgj ms‡kvab K‡i
gvZvj‡`i e³e¨| Zv‡`i e³e¨ ï‡b g‡b g`xbvq wM‡q c~Y© Bmjvgx ivóª
n‡”Q Bmjvg GBgvÎ bvwhj nj| ZvB cÖwZôv K‡iwQ‡jb| g~jK_v, AvK¡x`v
†giæ`Ðnxb MYZ‡š¿i Kv‡Q aY©v I Avgj ms¯‹v‡ii †gŠwjK c‡_i AbymiY
w`‡Z n‡e| A_P MYZ‡š¿i Rb¥ n‡q‡Q K‡iB bex-ivm~jMY Øxb K¡v‡q‡gi
wKQzw`b Av‡M| Avi GB me©‡kl I `vwqZ¡ cvjb K‡i‡Qb|
P~ovšÍ wKZve gnvMÖš’ Avj-KziAvb mywcÖq cvVK-cvwVKv!
bvwhj n‡q‡Q cÖvq †`o nvhvi eQi ÔDcwb‡e‡kvËi gymwjg †`k¸‡jvi
Av‡M| Avjøvn e‡jb, ÔAvR Avwg ˆ¯^ivPvi, Bmjvg we‡ivax AvPiY I
†Zvgv‡`i Rb¨ †Zvgv‡`i Øxb‡K wewa-weavb, avwg©K gvby‡li
c~Yv©½ K‡i w`jvg Avi †Zvgv‡`i Dci cÖwZ AZ¨vPvi BZ¨vw`i †cÖ¶vc‡U
Avgvi †bÔgZ m¤ú~Y© Kijvg Ges A‡bK Av‡eMx gymwjgB Abyfe K‡ib
†Zvgv‡`i Rb¨ Øxbiƒ‡c (Rxeb e¨e¯’v †h, Zvi †`kwU GKwU A‰bmjvwgK
iƒ‡c) Bmjvg‡KB g‡bvbxZ KijvgÕ (Av‡j †`k Ges G‡`‡k Bmjvgx ivóª cÖwZôv
gv‡q`vn 5/3)| mg‡qi `vex| Av‡eM ZvwoZ gZvgZ
myZivs, AvR hviv wLjvdZ e¨e¯’vi ev Kg© RvMwZK dj ev Avjøvn&i
cwie‡Z© MYZ‡š¿i gva¨‡g Bmjvg mš‘wó AR©‡b mnvqK bq| Av‡eM

5 2q el© 6ô
2 msL¨v
 hvB ejyK bv †Kb, Avgv‡`i‡K mܨvq j²xcyi †cŠi †gqi Rbve Avey
Av‡eMgy³ n‡q wm×všÍ wb‡Z n‡e| Zv‡ni cÖwZ Iqv³ Qvjv‡Zi mgq kn‡ii
KziAvb-nv`x‡Qi mvgwMÖK mKj †`vKvbcvU eÜ ivLvi Kov
wb‡`©kbv, Bmjv‡gi BwZnv‡mi mKj wb‡`©k w`‡q gvBwKs Kivb| Gi c‡iB
hy‡Mi ivóª¸wji e¨e¯’v, Zv‡eC I Pj‡Z _v‡K G wb‡q Av‡jvPbv-
ZrcieZ©x AvwjgM‡Yi gZvg‡Zi mgv‡jvPbv I wgkÖ cÖwZwµqv|
Av‡jv‡K Avgiv mywbwðZ eyS‡Z A‡b‡KB G‡K wØZxq mE`x Avie e‡jI
cvwi †h, mgKvjxb gymwjg †`k¸‡jv‡K AwfwnZ K‡i‡Qb| wKš‘ wfbœ
Kvwdi ivóª e‡j MY¨ Kivi †Kvb ag©vej¤^xmn A‡bK gymwjg
my‡hvM †bB| mgKvjxb †Kvb †Kvb e¨emvqx †gq‡ii GB wm×všÍ †g‡b
M‡elK gymwjg ivóª I Bmjvgx iv‡óªi wb‡Z cv‡ibwb| wm×všÍwU wb‡q
g‡a¨ cv_©K¨ K‡i‡Qb| G cv_©K¨ e¨vcK MYAm‡šÍvl †`Lv w`‡j j²xcyi
GKvšÍB M‡elYv| Bmjvgx kixÔAv‡Zi †Rjv cÖkvmK (wWwm) †nvgvqiv
weavb cÖ`v‡bi †¶‡Î G cv_©‡K¨i †eMg EaŸ©Zb KZ…©c‡¶i wb‡`©‡k
†KvbB ¸iæZ¡ †bB| kixÔAv‡Zi 16 A‡±vei 2017 †mvgevi iv‡Z †gqi
weav‡bi Av‡jv‡K G¸‡jv meB `viæj Avey Zv‡ni‡K KviY `k©v‡bvi
Bmjvg| Avjøvn&i c‡_ `vIqvZ ev †bvwUk (†kvKR) †`b| †bvwU‡ki
b¨v‡qi Av‡`k I Ab¨v‡qi wb‡l‡ai Ask Rev‡e †gqi Zuvi wm×všÍ cÖZ¨vnvi
wnmv‡e gywgb G mKj iv‡óªi K‡i †bb Ges g½jevi AveviI gvBwKs
Ab¨v‡qi cÖwZev` Ki‡eb; ms‡kva‡bi K‡i †`vKvb †Lvjv ivL‡Z e‡jb|51
Rb¨ mev©Z¥K †Póv Ki‡eb, wKš‘ m¤§vwbZ cvVK-cvwVKv!
KL‡bvB ivóªxq AvbyMZ¨ cwiZ¨vM
Rbve †gqi Qv‡ne GZ¶‡Y wbðqB
Ki‡eb bv ev ivóª‡`ªvnxZvq wjß n‡eb
ey‡S †M‡Qb †h, RbM‡Yi AvK¡x`v
bvÕ|50
cwieZ©b e¨wZ‡i‡K gvbeiwPZ gZev`
AZGe, gymwjg RvwZ Kw_Z AvBGm, ÔRbMY mKj ¶gZvi DrmÕ GB
Zv‡jevb, †ev‡Kv nvivg cÖf…wZ åvšÍ bxwZ‡Z A_©vr MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z
`j †_‡K mveavbZv Aej¤^b Kiæb- RvwZ, ag©, eY© wbwe©‡k‡l
GLbB mgq| msL¨vMwiô †jv‡Ki †fvU jy‡d wb‡q
RvwZi Avgj I AvK¡x`v ms‡kvab bv ¶gZvq e‡m RbM‡Yi Ici †Rvi K‡i
K‡i MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z ¶gZvq Bmjvgx weavb Pvwc‡q w`‡j Zvi dj ïf
wM‡q †h Bmjvg K¡v‡qg Kiv m¤¢e nq bv|
bq-Zvi D¾¡j D`vniY n‡q Av‡Qb D‡jøL¨, Ô†Kvb gymwjg hLb
wgk‡ii mv‡eK †cÖwm‡W›U Agymwjg †`‡k emevm Ki‡e, ZLb †m
†gvnv¤§` gyiwm| Avi †`‡ki miKv‡ii KvQ †_‡K wb‡Ri
mv¤cÖwZKKv‡ji G D`vniY Avgv‡`i ag©xq AwaKvi Av`v‡qi Rb¨
mvg‡b AviI ¯úó K‡i w`‡jb evsjv‡`‡ki wbqgZvwš¿Kfv‡e †Póv Ki‡e| bv cvi‡j
j²xcyi †cŠimfvi †gqi Rbve Avey Qei (ˆah©aviY) Ki‡e I Avjøvn&i
Zv‡ni| MZ 15 A‡±vei 2017 iweevi wbKU Gi e`jv Kvgbv Ki‡e| c¶všÍ‡i
50 51
. W. †Lv›`Kvi Avãyjøvn Rvnv½xi, Bmjv‡gi . Link: www.globalvision24.com/34311/141;
bv‡g Rw½ev` (Avm-mybœvn cvewj‡KkÝ, wewewm evsjv: iv‡Zi (10:30 wgwbU)
2q ms¯‹iY: †deªæqvix 2009), c„t 93| Awa‡ekb-cwiµgv, 17-10-2017 Bs|
msL¨v

5
2q el© 6ô

3
gymwjg †`‡k evm K‡iI †Kvb gymwjg cwiPvjbv Kivi Rb¨ KziAvbB GKgvÎ
miKvi hw` Bmjvgx weavb †gvZv‡eK MÖš’Õ|55
†`k kvmb bv K‡i, Z‡e D³ miKvi‡K AZGe, Avmyb! cÖPwjZ ÎæwUc~Y©
†hgb mr civgk© w`‡Z n‡e I bQxnZ MYZš¿ I R½xev`x ivRbxwZ‡K cvËv
Ki‡Z n‡e, †Zgwb mvaviY RbMY‡K bv w`‡q Ges ivóªxq ¶gZvi †cQ‡b
Bmjvgx wLjvdZ cÖwZôvi c‡¶ e¨_© cwikÖg bv w`‡q Av‡M RvwZi
DØy&× I m‡PZb Ki‡Z n‡e| Avgj I AvK¡x`v ms‡kva‡b eªZx nB|
ivm~jyjøvn (Qvt) wb‡RI c_åó `vDm gnvb Avjøvn Avgv‡`i‡K ZvIdxK¡ `vb
†Mv‡Îi I Zv‡`i †bZvi †n`vqv‡Zi Rb¨ Kiæb- Avgxb!!
†`vÕAv K‡iwQ‡jbÕ|52
†fvU we‡kølY :
ÔwZwb we‡k¦i wewfbœ †`‡ki
kvmK‡`i Kv‡Q cÎ I `~Z †cÖiY †fvU (vote) kãwU Bs‡iwR fvlv, hvi
K‡i‡QbÕ|53 evsjv A_© n‡”Q, mv¶¨ w`‡q
g‡bvbxZ ev wbe©vwPZ Kiv ev
¯§iYxq †h, ÔAZ¨vPvix kvmK hZw`b
mycvwik Kiv| MYZvwš¿K e¨e¯’vi Aci
ch©šÍ QvjvZ Av`vq Ki‡e, ZZw`b Zvi
bvg †fvU c×wZ| MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z
AvbyMZ¨ Kiv hv‡e| AZ¨vPvix kvmK
AbywôZ wbe©vP‡b GKRb †fvU`vZv
hw` Ab¨vqfv‡e cÖnvi K‡i wKsev
Kv‡ivi c‡¶ hLb †fvU cÖ‡qvM K‡i,
A_©-m¤ú` wQwb‡q †bq, ZeyI Zvi
ZLb Zvi GB †fvU cÖ`v‡bi gva¨‡g
AvbyMZ¨ Ki‡Z n‡e| niZvj K‡i, Mvox
wbtk‡ã GB cÖwZkÖæwZ †`qv nq
fvOPzi K‡i, wewfbœfv‡e ag©NU K‡i,
†h, ÔAvwg †Zvgv‡K †Zvgvi B”QvgZ
†`‡ki w¯’wZkxjZv‡K bó K‡i †Kvb
†h †Kvb AvBb cvk Kivi ¶gZv w`w”Q
miKvi‡K AcmviY Kiv kixÔAv‡Z
Ges Iqv`v KiwQ †h, Zzwg Ab¨‡`i
Av‡`Š Rv‡qh bqÕ|54
mv‡_ wgwjZ n‡q †h AvBb cvk Ki‡e,
wcÖq cvVK-cvwVKv! Avwg GB Zv Avwg wbwØ©avq †g‡b wbeÕ|
gyn~‡Z© `yÕRb Agymwjg cwЇZi
Avmyb! Gevi ms‡¶‡c ïf¼‡ii duvwK
evYx D‡jøL Kivi †jvf mvgjv‡Z cvijvg
wb‡q Av‡jvPbv Kwi| aiæb, †Kvb
bv| Zv nj- m¤ªvU †b‡cvwjqb
wbe©vPbx GjvKvq †gvU †fvUvi 100
†evbvcvU© e‡j‡Qb, ÔGKgvÎ
Rb| cÖv_©x wZb Rb h_vµ‡g K, L, M|
KziAvbB mZ¨ Ges gvbe‡K myL I
ÔKÕ †c‡q‡Q 40 wU †fvU, ÔLÕ
kvwšÍi c‡_ cwiPvwjZ Ki‡Z m¶gÕ| Avi
†c‡q‡Q 35 wU †fvU Ges ÔMÕ
¸iæbvbK e‡j‡Qb, Ô†e` I cyiv‡Yi hyM
†c‡q‡Q 25 wU †fvU| GLb
†kl n‡q †M‡Q; GLb `ywbqv‡K
wPšÍvbvqKMY wbðqB ÔKÕ †K
weRqx cÖv_©x wnmv‡e †NvlYv
52
. gynv¤§` Avmv`yjøvn Avj-Mvwje, Bmjvgx Ki‡eb| Avi GUvB evsjv‡`kmn
wLjvdZ I †bZ…Z¡ wbev©Pb (ivRkvnx: mvivwe‡k¦ ¯^xK…Z I cÖPwjZ| wKš‘
nv`xQ dvD‡Ûkb evsjv‡`k, cÖ_g cÖKvk: ÔKÕ †Zv †Kvbfv‡eB weRqx nqwb|
gynviig 1424 wnRix), c„t 20-21 | KviY msL¨vMwiô †fvUvi †Zv ÔKÕ-Gi
53
. Avj-we`vqv Iqvb wbnvqv, 4_© LÐ,
BmjvwgK dvD‡Ûkb evsjv‡`k, cÖ_g cÖKvk: 55
. BgvgyÏxb web Avãyj evQxi, Bmjv‡gi
Avlvp 1411, c„t 454| weiæ‡× Z_¨ mš¿vm (ivRkvnx: AvQ-wQivZ
54
. Avãyi ivhhvK web BDmyd, †K eo jvfevb cÖKvkbx, wØZxq ms¯‹iY: †deªæqvix 2014
(wØZxq cÖKvk: †cŠl 1418 e½vã), c„t 188| Cmvqx), c„t 78-79|
5 2q el© 6ô
4 msL¨v
 c‡¶ †bB| †Kbbv, 100 Rb †fvUv‡ii hv‡nvK, †fvUv-fzwUi mv‡_ Bmjv‡gi
g‡a¨ (L+M) 35+25=60 Rb †fvUviB †KvbB m¤úK© †bB| D‡jøL¨, e¯ÍvcPv
A_v©r msL¨vMwiô RbMYB Pvbwb MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z wek¦we`¨vj‡qi
†h, ÔKÕ weRqx †nvK| †mLv‡b wfwm Qv‡n‡ei †fv‡Ui g~j¨ hv, GKRb
Kxfv‡e ÔKÕ †K weRqx cÖv_©x RyZv †mjvB Kiv g~L© gywPi †fv‡Ui
wnmv‡e †NvlYv Kiv nj? GUv wK g~j¨I Zv| Bmjvg GB †evKv I Amg
ïf¼‡ii duvwK bq? bxwZ KLbB mg_©b K‡i bv|
Avevi hyw³i LvwZ‡i †KD hw` e‡j BDbvB‡UW KwgDwbwU †m›Uvi,
e‡mb †h, eû`jxq kvmb e¨e¯’v Pvjy wm‡jU- G kvqL Avãyi ivhhvK web
bv K‡i wØ`jxq kvmb e¨e¯’v Pvjy Kiv BDmyd Qv‡n‡ei cÖ`Ë e³‡e¨i mv‡_
fv‡jv| Zvn‡j aiæb, 100 †fv‡Ui g‡a¨ GKgZ †cvlY K‡i Avwg ej‡Z PvB †h,
ÔKÕ †c‡q‡Q 51 wU †fvU Ges ÔLÕ Ôwbe©vP‡b GKRb weËkvjx f`ª,
†c‡q‡Q 49 wU †fvU| GLv‡bI wbðqB bgª, wkw¶Z †jvK †c‡q‡Qb 2,999
51 Rb †fvUv‡ii djvd‡ji wfwˇZ ÔKÕ †fvU Avi GKRb gywP †c‡q‡Q 3,000
†K weRqx †NvlYv Kiv n‡e Ges GUvB †fvU| GLv‡b MYZvwš¿K c×wZ‡Z
Kiv n‡q _v‡K| Zvn‡j cÖkœ n‡”Q- †bZv n‡e gywP| Bmjvg GB †evKv I
evKx 49 Rb †fvUv‡ii wK †KvbB g~j¨ A‡hŠw³K bxwZ mg_©b K‡i bv|
†bB? wZwb Zuvi cÖ`Ë e³‡e¨ AviI e‡jb,
hv‡`i `yÕwU †PvL Av‡Q, Zviv Aek¨B Ô†fvU †`Iqv hv‡e bvÕ| Avwg Zuvi
†`L‡Z cv‡”Qb †h, hv‡`i `yÕwU Kvb GB e³‡e¨i mv‡_I GKgZ n‡q ej‡Z PvB,
Av‡Q, Zviv Aek¨B ïb‡Z cv‡”Qb †h- G ïay Bmjvg †Kb, c„w_ex‡Z †Kvb
c„w_exi msL¨vMwiô gvbylB Av`k©B †fvUv-fzwUi gva¨‡g wU‡K
mZ¨Z¨vMx, n‡K¡i e¨vcv‡i AeyS, AÁ I _vK‡Z cvi‡e bv| bex-ivm~jMY
AK…ZÁ| Avi G K_v cweÎ KziAvb G‡m‡Qb Awni `vIqvZ wb‡q, Zuviv
wek¦evmx‡K Rvwb‡q w`‡q‡Q evi c„w_ex‡Z Abymvix wnmv‡e Aí
evi| †hgb- Ô(AvMvgx Cmvi hyM msL¨K †jvKB †c‡q‡Qb| Zuviv †fvUv-
Qvov) cÖ‡Z¨K hy‡M c„w_exi fzwUi gva¨‡g ivóªxq ¶gZv `Lj
msL¨vMwiô gvbyl mZ¨Z¨vMx K‡ibwb|
dv‡mK¡Õ (gv‡q`vn 59; Av‡j Bgivb 110; kvqL gyhvddi web gynwmb e‡j‡Qb,
AvÔivd 102; ZIevn 8; gywgb~b 70; `yLvb Ô†fvU †`Iqv hv‡e bv| GUv wkiKÕ|56
78)|
D‡jøL¨, ÔAvgvi †fvU Avwg †`e, hv‡K
KziAvb gvRx‡` evi evi D‡jøL Kiv Lywk Zv‡K †`eÕ Gi g‡Zv GKwU PUzj
n‡q‡Q †h, G c„w_exi AwaKvsk `vwqZ¡nxb m¯Ív †køvMvb GL‡bv
gvbylB n‡K¡i e¨vcv‡i AeyS I AÁ| Avgv‡`i †`‡k MYZš¿ PPv©i g~j
†hgb- (gv‡q`vn 103; AvbÔAvg 37, 111; `k©b wnmv‡e KvR K‡i| AZGe,
AvÔivd 131, 187; Avbdvj 34; BDbym 55; ÔAvgvi †fvU Avwg †`e, hv‡K Lywk
BDmyd 40, 68; bvn&j 75, 101; Avw¤^qv
24; dziK¡vb 44; bvgj 61; K¡vQvQ 13, 57;
Zv‡K †`eÕ bv e‡j Ô†`‡L, ï‡b, ey‡S
AvbKve~Z 63; iƒg 6, 30; jyK¡gvb 25; mvev
28, 36; hygvi 29, 49; gywgb 57; `yLvb 39; 56
. BDwUDe: †fvU †`Iqv Ges MYZvwš¿K
RvwQqvn 26; Z~i 47)| ivRbxwZ Kiv Rv‡qh wK? Bmjvgx MYZš¿ e‡j
wKQz Av‡Q wK?- (wØZxq Av‡jvPK)/REAL
TABLIG.
msL¨v

5
2q el© 6ô

5
†`eÕ ej‡j †¯^”QvPvwiZvi †P‡q
hyw³wbôZvB †ekx ¸iæZ¡ cvq|
Avmj K_v GB †h, Bmjvgx kixÔAvZ
Abyhvqx mwVK I m‡e©vËg cš’v nj-
cÖv_©x wb‡R wb‡R‡K RbM‡Yi
wL`g‡Z †ck Ki‡e bv, K¨vbfvm Ki‡e
bv; eis gymwjg‡`i g‡a¨ huviv Ávbx,
Øxb`vi I `vq-`vwqZ¡ m¤ú‡K©
m‡PZb, Zuviv RbM‡Yi wL`g‡Zi Rb¨
Kv‡iv Dci Av¯’v cÖKvk K‡i G Kv‡R
cÖv_©x nIqvi j‡¶¨ DrmvwnZ Ki‡e|
Aemvb :
MYZ‡š¿i bv‡g `ywbqvq hZ †kvi‡Mvj
D‡V‡Q, gvby‡li Rxe‡b `ytL I ˆ`b¨
ZZB †e‡o‡Q| GgbwK mZ¨ K_v GB
†h, MYZ‡š¿i †nvZvivB gvbyl‡K `ytL I
ˆ`‡b¨i gy‡L †V‡j w`‡Z gyL¨ f~wgKv
cvjb Ki‡Q| Avi nZfvM¨ gvbyl G‡KB
¯^vaxbZv I ¯^vwaKvi †f‡e MYZ‡š¿i
Rb¨ cÖvYcvZ Ki‡Q| A_P Kvw•LZ
myL I kvwšÍi gyL Zviv †Kvbw`bB
†`L‡Z cv‡”Qb bv, Zv wPiKvj ïay
†mvbvi nwiY iƒ‡c aiv-†Quvqvi
evB‡iB †_‡K hv‡”Q| ZvB Av‡jvPbvi
†kl †ejvf~wg‡Z `uvwo‡q ejwQ-
ivóªweÁvb wefv‡Mi wk¶v_©x nIqv
m‡Ë¡I ÔMYZš¿ Avgvi fv‡jv jv‡M
bvÕ|

5 2q el© 6ô
6 msL¨v