AGES GL 08 002 Vessel Sizing Guidelines
AGES GL 08 002 Vessel Sizing Guidelines
AGES GL 08 002 Vessel Sizing Guidelines
Guidelines
APPROVED BY:
AGES-GL-08-002
REVISION HISTORY
Projects
Reuben Digitally
by Reuben
signed
Yagam Yagambaram
Date: 2021.04.13
baram 15:56:12 +04'00'
Group Projects & Engineering is the owner of these Guidelines and responsible for its custody, maintenance and
periodic update.
In addition, Group Projects & Engineering is responsible for communication and distribution of any changes to
these Guidelines and its version control.
These Guidelines will be reviewed and updated in case of any changes affecting the activities described in these
guidelines.
DEFINITIONS
“ADNOC Group” means ADNOC together with each company in which ADNOC, directly or indirectly, controls
fifty percent (50%) or more of the share capital.
“Approving Authority” means the decision-making body or employee with the required authority to approve
Policies & Procedures or any changes to it.
“Business Line Directorates” or “BLD” means a directorate of ADNOC which is responsible for one or more
Group Companies reporting to, or operating within the same line of business as, such directorate.
“Business Support Directorates and Functions” or “Non- BLD” means all the ADNOC functions and the
remaining directorates, which are not ADNOC Business Line Directorates.
“Group Company” means any company within the ADNOC Group other than ADNOC.
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF EQUATIONS
Introduction
These guidelines specify the criteria and give recommendations for the selection and design of liquid-liquid, gas-
liquid and gas-liquid-liquid separators. Included are sizing methods, selection criteria for the inlet/outlet devices
and design rules for separator internals and nozzles.
This document also establishes the separation criteria in accordance with the requirements for the various
upstream and downstream business units. Separation performance of vessels are specified in the design stage
and the vessel/internal vendor shall be required to meet these specifications and fulfil performance guarantees
during EPC.
A vessel that operates as a slug catcher is included as a two-phase bulk separation vessel, but the following are
not included:
Finger type slug catcher
Expansion drums and utility drums such as nitrogen or air hold-up vessels
Separation of solids from liquids and gases and solids handling other than reference to sand settling
Desalters
Steam drums
Coalescers/Filters
Problems with oil and water separation are addressed with regards to waxes and emulsions and other aspects
of composition chemistry. For additional guidance associated with waxes and emulsions refer to Flow Assurance
Guideline AGES-GL-08-003.
Purpose
The purpose of this document is to specify the procedure to follow when selecting and sizing separators whose
main purpose is gas-liquid, liquid-liquid and gas-liquid-liquid separation. These guidelines are intended to enable
the engineer to select the optimum equipment orientation and internals and give guidance to ensure that the
sizing is sufficient to meet the separation requirements whilst maintaining an economic design.
It is not intended for use for vessels where the sole purpose is storage, fluid hold-up, solids handling or gas or
liquid expansion.
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
ADNOC Specifications
Other References
DOCUMENT PRECEDENCE
The specifications and codes referred to in these Guidelines shall, unless stated otherwise, be the latest approved
issue at the time of contract award.
It shall be the CONTRACTOR's responsibility to be, or to become, knowledgeable of the requirements of the
referenced Codes and Standards.
The CONTRACTOR shall notify the COMPANY of any apparent conflict between this specification, the related
data sheets, the Codes and Standards and any other specifications noted herein.
Resolution and/or interpretation precedence shall be obtained from the COMPANY in writing before proceeding
with the design/manufacture.
In case of conflict, the order of document precedence shall be:
UAE Statutory Requirements
ADNOC HSE Standards
Equipment Datasheets and Drawings
Project Specifications and Standard Drawings
Principles of Separation
The principles used to separate gases, liquids and solids are momentum, gravity settling and coalescing. In order
for separation to occur effectively the fluid phases must be immiscible and have different densities.
Gravity Settling
Gravity settling uses the principle that droplets with a higher density will settle out of a phase with lower density
e.g liguid settles out of gas, when the downward gravitational force on the droplet is greater than the opposing
drag force in an upward direction. For smaller droplets the drag force will govern and hence droplets will be
entrained in the light phase unless further measures are taken such as coalescing.
Momentum
Momentum used the principle of reducing velocity at different rates for the different densities. A lighter particle
will slow down and change direction more rapidly than a heavier particle.
Coalescing
When there are small droplets that cannot be separated by gravity alone, coalescing is used to form larger
droplets by forcing the fluid through a tortuous path such as a mist eliminator. The larger particles can then settle
out of the gas phase by gravity.
For Liquid-Liquid Separation two immiscible liquid phases can be separated using the same principles as for gas
and liquid separators. Liquid-liquid separators are fundamentally the same as gas-liquid separators except that
because the difference in densities is less, they must be designed with sufficient increased residence time to
allow separation by gravity to take place.
General
Separators are typically cylindrical vessels with dished heads in a horizontal or vertical orientation. Both have
their advantages and disadvantages depending on the phases being separated and the various process
parameters discussed in the following sections. A third type of separator is a spherical separator, but these are
only occasionally specified for high pressure/small liquid volume use where a compact size is desirable.
The simplest separator vessels are those without internals or have minimal internals such as a simple inlet device.
Other internals may be added to improve separation of the phases. Separators can be classified into different
categories depending on the phases they are handling as follows:
Liquid-liquid (2 phase)
Gas-liquid (2 phase)
Gas-liquid-liquid (3 phase)
The type of internals installed to achieve the required separation within these categories are discussed in more
detail in the following sections. The separation of solids from liquids and gases is not covered in these guidelines,
however, separators specified for the separation of liquids and gases may also have to be designed to handle
solids in the incoming feed of which a typical example is sand.
A separator vessel is normally divided into the following sections.
Primary separation
Primary separation takes place through the inlet of the vessel where the momentum and direction of flow of the
incoming stream is changed. Inlet devices or calming baffles can be fitted to facilitate the initial separation of
phases. In gas-liquid separation the bulk liquid and larger droplets fall by gravity into the liquid accumulation
section.
Secondary Separation
Secondary separation occurs in the main part of the vessel where the velocity of the gas and liquid are further
reduced compared to the inlet due to the increased cross-sectional area. This allows further liquid droplets to fall
from the gas stream into the liquid accumulation section by gravity.
Mist Extraction
Mist extraction takes place through internals inside the vessel where small liquid droplets carried in the gas stream
combine to form larger droplets which will settle out by gravity to the liquid accumulation section. The most
common types are wire mesh, vane pack and centrifugal. Mist extraction can be used to meet the required vapour
/ liquid separation performance with a reduced vessel diameter.
Liquid Accumulation
Liquids from the primary, secondary and mist extraction sections are collected in the liquid accumulation section
of the vessel. For liquid-liquid separation the sections should allow sufficient residence time for separation by
gravity between the phases and separate sections to retain the separated phases. Additional internals may be
fitted in this section to promote coalescing of the liquid droplets to aid further phase separation.
The following definitions for bulk separation and dehydration are used in processes in upstream applications:
Bulk separation is where outlet qualities of > 1% Water in Oil (WIO) and 500-2,000 ppm for OIW.
Operational Parameters
The following factors must be determined before the separator type is chosen and designed:
Operating and design pressure and temperatures.
Feed flowrate envelope identifying max and min gas and liquid flow rates. The flows shall include any
design margin and variations over the design life.
The pressure drop limitation of the system throughout the life of the facility.
The turndown requirements for the equipment.
The liquid droplet size distribution where required to meet downstream processing/equipment
requirements.
Separation Performance
The required degree of separation shall be specified depending on the process application for the flow of liquid-
liquid, gas-liquid or gas-liquid-liquid.
For upstream facilities the following typical performance specifications should be considered:
Gas-Liquid separation: maximum liquid carry-over of 0.1 USG/MMSCF and 99% percentage removal of
liquid droplets of size 10 microns and above.
Gas carry under in light hydrocarbons: typically to ensure the gas fraction in the outlet liquid to =
downstream units is <1 v/v% and to allow gas bubbles of 200 microns and above to escape y from the
liquid outlet. The design shall ensure fulfilling the degassing criteria as well as designing the liquid outlet
nozzle with Froude Number <0.3.
Oil in water carry over: dependent on the downstream produced water treatment requirements. Typical
range for disposal water is 700-1000 ppmv at water outlet in upstream production facilities. Further
treatment down to OIW<300 ppmv requires produced water treatment processes which are outside the
scope of this document.
Water in oil carry over: Typically, critical in upstream facilities where WIO is 1-2 vol% is targeted through
gravity separation. Dehydration is required where further improvement of liquid outlet qualities is targeted,
typically ≤1% WIO or BS&W. Separation through dehydration is outside the scope of this document.
Other consideration may have to be taken into account for a full specification of the separator requirements. If the
feed stream to the facilities comes from oil reservoirs, the stream conditions will fluctuate with time, e.g. a feed
stream temperature increase will have the following effects:
Lower oil viscosity and an increase in the relative difference in the densities between the oil and water
phases making separation easier.
Alternatively, more hydrocarbons come out of the oil phase into the gas phase leading to a reduction in
oil volume and density change.
Preventing the formation of wax which may otherwise have stabilised an emulsion.
Other potential compositional changes can be induced by factors such as breakthrough of CO2 at EOR
from a production well.
In addition, the wellhead pressure may drop over time resulting in a reduced pressure drop available for
processing the reservoir fluids. A decrease in operating pressure into the facilities will cause volatile hydrocarbons
to come out of the crude oil phase into the gas phase - affecting the volumetric gas flow and changing the oil
properties - and so the predicted performance of the separator will change over the life of the field. Similarly, an
increase in pressure at the production separator can impact the separation performance and needs to be
considered in the design.
Separator Orientation
The choice between using a horizontal or vertical separator is largely dependent on whether the volumetric flow
of gas or liquid(s) dominate in the separator inlet stream.
In general a horizontal separator is preferred when inlet liquid flow dominates (inlet flow regime is stratified, wavy,
slug, bubble or churn) and a vertical separator is preferred when the gas flow dominates (inlet flow regime is
annular, annular-mist or mist). The following Table 4.1 gives further guidance on criteria which determine
separator orientation.
Notes.
1. When good degassing is required and there is a high GOR, since there is a larger gas
to liquid interface area.
2. Liquid removal efficiency does not vary with liquid level. Also, there is more height
available for drainage level so that more efficient demisting internals can be used than
in horizontal separators.
3. Greater level control is possible with a vertical vessel for a given surge volume due to
the larger range between the shutdown level and the normal operating level.
4. Typically the volume available for liquid-liquid separation is less in a vertical vessel
and hence the selection only allows a limited residence time.
5. The intended service of a drum should dictate its orientation and type which is the
situation in most cases. However, in those instances where either a horizontal or a
vertical drum could be used, a check of the relative economics should be made. In
this regard, the project piping and layout group should be consulted for the effect on
plot arrangement.
6. Selection is not the preferred orientation for this service.
Notes
1. For details of the Separator Selection Criteria see section above.
2. Maximum allowable K-factor gives a measure of the gas handling capacity of the selected
separator, part of the separator or demisting internal.
3. For the definition of overall liquid removal efficiency see section 4.3.3. These are typical
efficiencies only as the efficiency is very dependent on the liquid droplet size distribution and
liquid load at the inlet to gas-liquid separation internals.
Filter Separator
Filter separators may be used as a secondary gas-liquid separator downstream of a primary separator when
maximum liquid removal is required.
The main features of a filter separator are given in Table 4.2.
Typical uses:
Final demisting of gas where required.
Additional protection for sensitive equipment and processes.
Filter separators should not be used in fouling service.
Notes
1. The separator selection is not the preferred type for this service.
Gas-Liquid-Liquid Separators
Separator orientation should be selected in accordance with Table 4.1.
The following Table 4.4 in conjunction with the additional details of each type of separator in sections 0 to 4.3.7.4,
should be used to define the type of separator for the duty.
Notes
1. The separator selection is not the preferred type for this service.
2. Refers to the liquid quality of the feed with respect to droplet dispersion and solids in the feed.
General
Separation through gravity settling occurs when dispersed droplets settle out of a continuous phase when the
gravitational force acting on the droplet is greater than the drag and buoyancy force of the continuous phase
passing around the droplet. The rate at which the droplet falls is known as the terminal velocity of the droplet and
is calculated from a balance of these forces. The terminal velocity is a function of the droplet size, relative
densities of the fluid phases and the drag coefficient of the particle. The drag coefficient is itself a function of the
shape of the particle and the Reynolds number.
Drag force
on droplet
Liquid Terminal
droplet velocity
Dp
Direction of Gravitational
flow force
Gravity settling is described by two theoretical approaches. At low droplet Reynolds numbers Re<2 Stoke’s law
describes the relationship. Stoke’s Law is valid for small droplets and relatively viscous fluids. For larger droplets
(>1000 micron) gravity settling is described by Newton’s law.
The following sections describe the simplified methods based on the above that shall be used to calculate an
initial separator size. Where complex flow regimes are observed the separator vendor should be consulted for a
more detailed analysis.
The following guidelines shall be observed when selected horizontal and vertical vessel sizes:
Where the vessel is below 800mm, standard pipe sizes should be used.
Vessel diameter should be rounded to the nearest 50mm for diameters from 800mm to 2000mm.
The vessel diameter should be rounded to the nearest 100mm for diameters greater than 2000mm.
Gas-Liquid Separation
General Principles
The gas handling criteria for a separator is based on the above principles of separation. The liquid droplet will
settle out of the gas phase when the terminal velocity of the droplet is greater than the vertical gas velocity.
For the purposes of vessel sizing, the terminal velocity of the droplet can be calculated using a simplified form of
Newton’s Law known as the Souders Brown equation (Equation 5.1). The K-factor given in this equation is a
value used to optimize the amount of entrainment based on as assumed droplet size and in order to achieve the
required degree of separation for different separator geometry and internals.
𝜌𝑙𝑖𝑞 − 𝜌𝑣
𝑉𝑡 = 𝐾𝑠 √( ) Equation 5.1
𝜌𝑣
The value of Ks is set based on the vessel geometry and the type of internals used in the vessel and is defined in
Table 5.1.
The terminal velocity calculated using Equation 5.1 is used to determine the internal flow area (Equation 5.2) at
the required volumetric gas flowrate. In the case of a vertical vessel this area will be equivalent to the cross-
sectional area of the vessel. For a horizontal vessel the area considered will be equivalent to the cross-sectional
area of the vessel that is available for gas flow. The gas cap area shall be taken as the area above the LZA(HH)
liquid level. Sample calculations for vertical gas-liquid and horizontal gas-liquid-liquid separators are provided in
Appendix A2 and the method to calculate a chord area for horizontal vessels is given in Appendix A1
𝑄𝑣
𝐴𝑖 = Equation 5.2
3600. 𝑉𝑡
For vertical vessels; once the area of the vessel is calculated, the height of the vertical vessel is determined based
on the liquid levels required in line with the requirements of section 5.4.4.
For horizontal vessels the diameter is calculated based on the liquid levels required for separation and control
time between level settings in line with section 5.4and allowing for sufficient area for the gas phase separation as
shown in section 5.4.
Notes
1. For high capacity vane packs and multi-cyclones, a preliminary design shall be based
on a maximum of 0.15 m/s K-factor. Internals MANUFACTURER shall be contacted
for further optimization of the vessel size.
2. For bulk separation use the higher K-factor.
3. For compressor suction scrubbers and expander inlet separators the K-factor should
be multiplied by 0.8.
4. For systems that are known to foam such as amines and glycols the K-factor should
be multiplied by 0.8.
5. K-factors for internals vary across different MANUFACTURER and different
proprietary designs. The K-factors given should be used for preliminary sizing and the
vessel sizing confirmed with the vessel MANUFACTURER once vendor information is
available.
6. K-factors are constants which are specific to particular equipment and are a function
of process parameters such liquid loading, gas/liquid viscosity, gas pressure and
surface tension. For fluids with low surface tension at high pressure, low temperatures,
light hydrocarbons (up to C6 components) or in other circumstances where small
Performance of mesh pads and vane packs is known to be affected by the operating pressure of the vessel. The
following Table 5.2 gives the derating factors to be used at different operating pressures for these internals.
Notes
1. Vendor should be consulted for K-factor derating values for operating pressures above 80 barg.
Liquid-Liquid Separation
The characteristics used to calculate the vessel separation volume dimensions for liquid-liquid separation are
droplet settling velocity and residence time. The rate of settling is a function of the continuous phase viscosity,
density difference and the dispersed phase droplet diameter. Sufficient residence time must be provided to allow
the dispersed phase to settle (or rise) out of the continuous phase.
The three liquid sections in the settling compartment of the vessel are:
The upper zone which contains the light fluid phase above the normal interface level NLi.
The intermediate zone which accommodates the dispersion band between LA(H)i and LA(L)i applicable
when the dispersed phase is more than 5%vol in the liquid feed.
The lower zone which contains the heavy fluid phase below the normal interface level NLi.
The principle of gravity settling using Stoke’s law is based on free fall of liquid droplets through a stagnant
continuous phase and laminar flow conditions. Where the flow regime within the vessel is turbulent additional
safety factors should be added to correct for the calculated settling velocity to allow for adequate separation.
For the purposes of vessel sizing, the vertical settling velocity of the droplet can be calculated using a simplified
form of the ideal Stokes Law. This simplification is based on low Reynolds number <2 corresponding to small
droplets in a relatively high viscosity fluid in laminar flow.
Dp Droplet diameter m
g Acceleration due to gravity 9.8 m/s2 m/s2
µC Continuous phase viscosity cP
ρh Heavy phase density kg/m3
ρl Light phase density kg/m3
Vs Settling velocity m/s
Typically where oil (light phase) as a dispersed phase is settling upwards through water (heavy phase) as the
continuous phase then the water viscosity is used as the continuous phase viscosity and for water settling in oil
then the oil viscosity is used as the continuous phase viscosity. However, if no further information is available
about the fluid characteristics the following equation can be used to determine which phase is considered the
continuous phase:
Water droplet
Liquid droplet Gas flow
NL
H9 hl
NiL
h
H10 hh
L
Oil droplet
Vaxial
Sizing a two or three-phase separator to meet specified liquid quality requirements should also ensure:
Liquids are retained in the vessel long enough to allow separation.
The liquid-liquid interface is maintained.
The separated phases are removed from the vessel at their respective outlets and qualities.
The following guidelines are proposed for Liquid-Liquid separation methodologies in different operating scenarios:
Method-1 where both the axial velocity and droplet diameter through the vessel are checked, is typically
followed in upstream production facilities where bulk separation requirements prevail in conjunction with
challenging characteristics of liquid phases such as emulsion, asphaltene and wax etc. For example: inlet
production three phase separators.
Method-2- is based on checking the residence time only. This approach may be used for systems where
the fluid flow rates and properties are better defined than those for upstream separators described above,
such as in downstream applications and for certain specific upstream applications such as compressor
suction drums or dehydration units.
In brief, the calculation methodology is described below:
Method 1: The vessel dimensions are initially estimated using the following sequence:
i. Determine the required gas cap area in line with section 5.2.
ii. Size the settling and outlet compartments based on the axial velocity criteria and adjusting for
level setting for each of the light and heavy phases.
iii. Estimate the corrected laminar settling velocity and the corresponding droplet diameter.
iv. The dimensions are adjusted such that a maximum axial velocity of 0.015 m/s is maintained and
a dispersed phase droplet diameter of 150 microns is recommended to be achieved.
v. The level settings shall be checked in accordance with the control hold-up time requirements
given in section 5.4.
Method 2: The vessel dimensions are estimated using the following sequence:
i. Size the settling and outlet compartments based on the residence time, hold-up and surge time
requirements in sections 5.2.1.1, 5.2.1.2, 5.2.1.3) and determining the level settings for each of
the light and heavy phases.
𝑄ℎ 𝑄𝑙
𝑉ℎ𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙 = 𝑉𝑙𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙 = Equation 5.5
𝐴ℎ 𝐴𝑙
ℎ𝑐 𝑉𝑐𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙
𝑉𝑑 = Equation 5.6
𝐿
The distance travelled by the droplet is for example the heavy dispersed phase droplet travelling from NL
to NLi (hc) through the light continuous phase.Table 5.5 Typical Residence Separation Times
Using the above laminar settling velocity (usually a turbulence correction is applied of typically 5% of the
axial velocity of the continuous phase); calculate the droplet size that will be separated using Stoke’s law
Equation 5.3. It is recommended that the droplet size limit of 150 microns is met. Consideration should
be given to increasing the diameter of the vessel on a case by case basis.
The vessel dimensions are iteratively adjusted where necessary to ensure that the axial velocity limit of
0.015m/s is not exceeded for each liquid phase and so that all control and mechanical requirements are
met in accordance with section 5.4.
The allowable vapour velocity for the gas phase should also be checked in accordance with section 5.2
to ensure that the minimum calculated gas cap area is available.
Where relevant the volume downstream of the weir will be calculated and the dimensions adjusted as
required in order to finalise the overall tan to tan length of the vessel.
An example calculation is provided in Appendix A2.2
≥ m/min ≤ m/min
Residence Times
The residence time is related to the volume of the vessel from normal level to the bottom of the vessel or liquid
outlet, the amount of liquid to be handled, and the relative specific gravities of the liquids. The effective retention
volume in a vessel is that portion of the vessel in which the liquids remain in contact with one another (settling
compartment). As far as liquid-liquid separation is concerned, once the liquid phase leaves the primary liquid
section where separation takes place (from calming baffle to end of settling compartment at the weir, or outlet
nozzle), although it may remain in the vessel in a separate outlet compartment, it cannot be considered as a part
of the retention volume. The following considerations should be addressed in specifying the residence time:
Light phase settling time to allow adequate heavy phase removal.
Heavy phase settling time to allow adequate removal of light phase.
Table 5.5 lists typical residence times for separation. These separation residence times assume equal residence
times for light in heavy phase and heavy in light phase.
Where details are known of the fluids to be separated, including density, viscosity, droplet or bubble size and
distribution then a more rigorous assessment should be made of the residence times to ensure separation to the
required outlet fluid specification is achieved.
Notes
1. Liquid residence times correspond to the normally controlled phase volume from NL to 'empty',
i.e. for light phase between NLi and bottom of vessel or lowest point of the phase exit from the
separator and for heavy phase between NL and NLi.
The above times are typical, and project specific requirements should be confirmed where appropriate.
Where a boot is included (refer section 4.3.4.1) three minutes hold-up should be considered initially between
LA(H)i to LA(L)i at the specified rate of drainage from the boot. However, if the hold-up time requirements mean
that the boot is too large for the drum then a different vessel design should be considered (liquid compartment
downstream of a weir). Typically, this would be if the calculated boot diameter is more than a third of the drum
diameter. Minimum initial boot dimensions shall be considered as 0.4m diameter and 1m boot length.
minimum minimum
H1
H3
LZA(HH) Trip
H4
LA(H) Alarm
D
Optional
Calming NL LZ range LC range
H5
Baffles
LA(L) Alarm
H6
LZA(LL) Trip
H7
Vessel Bottom
minimum
Notes
1. The control settings are applicable to both the light and heavy phases.
2. Where a dispersion band is applicable, the distance between LA(L) and LZA(LL) / LA(H) and
LZA(HH) shall be increased by half the dispersion band height selected.
3. Baffles may be used in a gas-liquid separator to prevent sloshing of incoming liquid slugs.
minimum minimum
H1
minimum
minimum
0.45D Ls et 0.25D
Notes
1. Where a dispersion band is applicable, the distance between LA(L) and LZA(LL) / LA(H) and
LZA(HH) shall be increased by half the dispersion band height selected.
2. Slug volume is to be accommodated between NL and LA(H) for transient slugs. Pigging
operational slugs can be considered to be accommodated between LA(L) and LA(H).
3. Only one baffle is required when a plate pack is used in the settling compartment.
minimum minimum
H1
LZA(HH) trip H3
LA(H) H4
NL NL
D H8
Light Liquid Phase Top of Weir
Optional H5
H9 H14 Calming
Baffles LZA(HH)i trip
H10 LA(H)i
NLi NLi LA(L)
H11 H6
LA(L)i LZA(LL) trip
H12 H15 LZA(LL)i trip
Heavy Liquid Phase H7
H13
minimum
minimum
0.45D Ls et 0.25D
Table 5.9 Horizontal Gas-liquid-liquid separator with Submerged Weir Level Settings
Notes
1. Where a dispersion band is applicable, the distance between LA(L) and LZA(LL) / LA(H) and
LZA(HH) shall be increased by half the dispersion band height selected.
2. Slug volume is to be accommodated between NL and LA(H) for transient slugs. Pigging
operational slugs can be considered to be accommodated between LA(L) and LA(H).
3. Only one baffle is required when a plate pack is used in the settling compartment.
Further details on weir types and selection are described in section 7.2. Where the heavy phase proportion is not
expected to vary through the facility lifetime then fixed weir plates can be used. Adjustable weir plates or
standpipes are recommended when the heavy phase is expected to vary significantly over the facility life,
generally increasing with time.
minimum minimum
H1
H3
LZA(HH) trip
H4
LA(H)
NL NL
H5
LA(L)
Light Liquid Phase H6
LZA(LL) trip
Optional
Calming
Baffles H7
H13
150mm high
stand-pipe
D H8
LZA(HH)i trip min min
0.45D H9
LA(H)i
NLi NLi
H10
LA(L)i Heavy
LZA(LL)i trip H11
Liquid
H12 Phase H14
Ls et
Notes
1. Slug volume is to be accommodated between NL and LA(H) for transient slugs. Pigging
operational slugs can be considered to be accommodated between LA(L) and LA(H).
Process Nozzles
All vessel nozzles should be designed in accordance with the minimum size (2”) and specifications given in
‘Pressure Vessel Specification’, AGES-SP-06-002.
Inlet Nozzles
The size of the inlet nozzle and the type of inlet nozzle device have an impact on the vapour/liquid separation.
The inlet nozzle is sized to limit the momentum of the feed and is based on a velocity head (ρv2) criterion. This
criterion is dependent on the selected inlet device. (See Table 6.1)
The piping configuration and flow regime upstream of the inlet nozzle can also have an effect on the separation
efficiency. Valves or reducers in the upstream piping can cause droplet shatter causing smaller droplets which
are more difficult to separate. The following arrangements should be followed to facilitate efficient separation.
Piping should be arranged wherever possible such that there are no bends, changes in pipe diameter,
flow elements or other components which would alter the flow regime within 10 pipe diameters of the inlet
nozzle. Where it is not possible to achieve this:
i. for inlet devices with non-swirling flow, bends should be in the vertical plane through the axis of the
nozzle,
ii. for inlet devices in swirling flow e.g. cyclonic devices, bends should be in the horizontal plane with
the curvature in the same direction as the swirl of the inlet
iii. any valve should be full-bore and maintained in the fully open position.
iv. The straight length criteria may be reduced for vessels with no liquid in the feed stream to no less
than 3 pipe diameters.
Inlet Devices
Inlet devices are designed to reduce the momentum of the inlet stream, separate bulk liquid and promote good
vapour distribution. The following criteria shall be used when selecting inlet device.
Vapour Outlet
The vapour outlet nozzle should be fitted at the high point of the vessel, centre of head for a vertical vessel or top
tan line for a horizontal vessel. Where the recommended orientation is not possible, alternative orientations may
be considered on a case by case basis. In-line separators where the inlet nozzle and the gas outlet nozzle are in
line with each other, shall be avoided as much as possible.
The outlet nozzle size shall be:
The same as the downstream piping sized for downstream pressure drop requirements.
and sized such that the velocity head criteria of ρv2<4500 kg/m.s2 is not be exceeded.
If it is necessary to increase the nozzle size to meet the velocity head criteria, the downstream pipe should remain
at the nozzle diameter for a minimum of 5 pipe diameters.
Liquid Outlet
Liquid outlet nozzles should generally be sized to meet the downstream pressure drop requirements. The velocity
should be limited in the outlet nozzle to no more than 1m/s. For revamp projects these criteria may be relaxed on
a case by case basis and subject to maintaining Fr <1 with a minimum static liquid height above the nozzle to
prevent gas carry under.
Liquid outlets shall be fitted with a vortex breaker.
Purge Connections
Purge connections shall be provided in line with the following:
Manways
Instrument Nozzles
Minimum instrument nozzle sizes shall be specified in ‘Automation and Instrumentation Design Philosophy’,
AGES-PH-04-001.
Level instrument nozzles should preferentially be mounted on the vessel wall and not on process nozzles.
Level instrument nozzles should preferentially be either top entry or located on the cylindrical wall of the
vessel.
Location of instrument nozzles should take account of vessel internals to ensure accurate measurement
is not affected by pressure drop across internals.
Instrument connections are not permitted at the bottom of the vessel unless approved by COMPANY.
Level instrument nozzles should preferentially be mounted on the cylindrical part of the vessel, not in the
vessel heads.
Baffles
Perforated plate baffles are used to even out the distribution of the incoming liquid to promote laminar flow and
hence to aid in separation of the two liquids phases in the settling compartment.
Where liquid slugs may be present a baffle should always be provided across the full diameter of the
settling compartment for liquid-liquid separators and from BTL to LZA(HH) for gas-liquid-liquid separators
to even out flow distribution and prevent sloshing.
Typically, two calming baffles are provided to separate the inlet compartment from the settling
compartment of a two or three phase separator.
Where plate packs or other internals are installed to promote separation only one calming baffle is
required upstream of the settling compartment.
Holes shall be evenly distributed across the baffle plate.
Where necessary baffles should be provided with manways to facilitate inspection and maintenance if it
is not possible to locate a manway on the shell of the vessel.
A small opening (≤150mm) should be provided at the bottom of the baffle to allow for vessel cleaning.
In addition, perforated baffles/plates are sometimes used for viscous liquids to minimise the vessel size when the
degassing requirement is the controlling sizing factor for the vessel.
Weirs
Several types of weir are typically installed in horizontal separators to separate the different phases. The heavy
phase is held on the upstream side of the weir with the weir height set so that the interface and any emulsion is
held upstream of the weir and the heavy phase outlet is located in this section as close as possible to the weir to
maximise the residence time. The light phase outlet is located downstream of the weir. The location of the weir
Vane Packs
Vane pack internals use close spaced metal plates often in a chevron pattern which present a convoluted flow
path for the gas stream. The primary separation mechanism is Inertial impaction as the liquid droplets impinge
on the plates followed by coalescence. The larger droplets then fall through the device into the liquid section of
the separator.
A number of different vane pack designs are available which accommodate higher gas flow throughput. Typical
K-factors for a standard capacity vane pack are given in Table 5.1. For high capacity vane packs,
MANUFACTURERs should be contacted.
Typically, droplets of 20-40 microns can be captured in vane packs. Smaller droplets down to 10 microns should
only be considered with consultation with a vendor.
Plate Packs
A plate pack consists of a set of flat or corrugated inclined parallel plates that reduce the distances a droplet must
rise or fall before leaving the bulk phase. Plate type coalescers are commonly limited to efficient removal of
droplets above 30 microns minimum droplet size.
The plates are tilted to facilitate the removal of the separated phase. Flat plates maintain laminar flow up to much
higher flow rates, but corrugated plates are less easily blocked by solids. The plate packs to be used in vessels
should be of the crossflow type. This means that the flow of separated product is perpendicular to the main flow
through the plate pack. This enables efficient use of the vessel volume resulting in a smaller vessel.
In clean service, the angle of the plates with the horizontal plane is typically 30 to 45 degrees, but if solids are
present, the angle should be steeper (typically 60 degrees) to facilitate the removal of the solids.
The plate spacing in fouling service should be at least 40 mm, whereas in clean service the plate spacing may
be as little as 10 mm. The choice of corrugated rather than flat plates and/or the increase of the plate spacing will
reduce the fouling risk but will also reduce the separation efficiency of the plate pack.
Waxes
Wax consisting of high molecular weight paraffinic compounds can be a problem in many crude oil compositions.
As crude oil cools the wax in the fluid starts to solidify until it starts to precipitate out of the liquid phase at the wax
appearance temperature (WAT). Wax causes a problem as it deposits on solids or forms gels in the fluid causing
blockages in the piping and equipment as well as forming tight emulsions which make separation more difficult.
Wax will tend to form on cold surfaces such as the pipe or vessel wall and can block internals, piping or
instrumentation nozzles causing a plant upset. Further details of wax behaviour and management is given in
AGES-GL-08-003 Flow Assurance Philosophy.
The cloud and pour point characteristics should be determined to enable proper design.
The temperature of the fluid should be maintained above the WAT to prevent the precipitation of wax.
Fluids that are prone to wax should be treated as a fouling service and selection of vessel internals and
sizing and location of instrument nozzles should take this into account. For example, plate packs shall
not be installed where wax is expected.
CFD Outputs
CFD is able to provide a large amount of data depending on the requirements of the particular study. Diagrams
would normally be provided showing the flow distribution for the various phases through the components within
the vessel. These CFD output maps are a means to easily see the velocity and direction of flow shown on
diagrams. In addition, CFD will identify the fluid conditions, phase density and residence time for the various
particles. The results of the CFD analysis will enable the engineer to identify whether the gas and liquid outlet
specifications have been met as well as showing the droplet size distribution and identifying any areas where
there is poor flow distribution or stagnation. This will ultimately lead to identifying where a modification to the
vessel design could improve or optimize the performance.
o
r α r
a b
Lab
A h
First calculate the area of the segment bounded by Oab for a vessel of known diameter 2r and at an angle of α
in radians:
𝑟2𝛼
𝐴𝑠𝑒𝑔𝑚𝑒𝑛𝑡 =
2
Where α in radians:
𝑟−ℎ
𝛼 = 2𝑎𝑟𝑐𝑜𝑠 ( )
𝑟
Chord length Lab is calculated from:
𝛼
𝐿𝑎𝑏 = 2𝑟𝑠𝑖𝑛 ( ) or 𝐿𝑎𝑏 = 2√𝐷. ℎ − ℎ2
2
Care should be taken to ensure that all calculations use angle α in radians.
Heads are ignored for the purposes of the cross-sectional area and volume calculations.
A2.1. Example 2.1 Vertical 2 Phase Separator with Wire Mesh Separator
𝜌𝑙𝑖𝑞 − 𝜌𝑣
𝑉𝑡 = 𝐾𝑠 √( )
𝜌𝑣
Select a Ks value for a vertical separator with a wire mesh demister from Table 5.1 K-Factors for Gas Phase
Internals of Ks = 0.10.
K is corrected for pressure prorated in line with Table 5.2 De-rating Factors for Pressure
35 − 20 715.7 − 22.7
𝑉𝑚𝑎𝑥 = 0.1 [(( ) (0.80 − 0.85)) + 0.85] √( ) = 0.449𝑚/𝑠
40 − 20 22.7
4𝑄 4.5277.6
Hence 𝐷=√ 𝑣 𝐷=√ = 2.04𝑚
𝜋𝑉 𝑡 3600.𝜋.0.449
The vessel diameter should be rounded to the nearest 50mm hence selected vessel internal diameter is 2.05m.
The length of the vessel should be built-up using the information in section 5.4 as shown below
For the light liquid phase above the NL calculate the volume based on the minimum required hold-up volume
between LA(L) and LA(H) is assumed at 8 minutes of hold up for light phase liquid flow and 1 minute to LZA(HH).
8
Volume between LA(L) to LA(H) 𝑥164.9 = 22𝑚3 - assuming NL is at 50%, hence NL to LA(H) = 11m 3
60
1
Volume above LA(H) to LZA(HH) 𝑥164.9 = 2.7𝑚3
60
𝜌𝑙𝑖𝑞 − 𝜌𝑣
𝑉𝑡 = 𝐾𝑠 √( )
𝜌𝑣
Select a Ks value for a horizontal separator with a wire mesh demister from Table 5.1 K-Factors for Gas Phase
Internals of Ks = 0.12.
K is corrected for pressure prorated in line with Table 5.2 De-rating Factors for Pressure at 17.5 barg.
The minimum area required for gas separation is calculated using Equation 5.2 :
𝑄𝑣 2376
𝐴𝑖 = = = 1.01𝑚2
3600. 𝑉𝑡 0.651
In all subsequent steps, the area above LZA(HH) shall be checked to fulfil the above minimum gas cap area.
Level setting calculations
The following tables show the calculation results. The chord calculation method in Appendix A1 is used to
calculate the area based on the height from BTL.
Control settings for the heavy phase are calculated using Linlet + Lset = 1.4+8=9.4m
Control setting for the light phase depend on whether the liquid is above or below the submerged weir and the
relevant length is identified in the table below.
Bottom of vessel 0
The area for the light phase settling from the heavy phase is between NLi-0.5Hdb and bottom of vessel = 1.6m 2
and is used in step 4 for the axial velocity check.
The area for the heavy phase settling from the light phase is between NL and NLi + 0.5H db =3.15m2 and is used
in the axial velocity check for the light phase in step 18.
The time between level settings is given in the table below and compared against the required criteria. The time
is calculated based on the flow rate of the respective phase divided by the differential volume.
Table A2.2-3 Hold-up/Control Time Calculations
Light Phase
LA(H) to LZA(HH) (10) 0.1 0.26 2.6 1.0 >1 min, >0.1 m
Top of weir to LA(L) 0.02 0.06 0.6 0.22 >1 min, >0.1m
(14f,15)
BTL to LZA(LL) (11) 0.85 1.7 1.4 0.5 >30 secs, >0.3m
Heavy phase
LA(H)i to LZA(HH)i (6) 0.25 0.8 7.5 5.45 >1 min, >0.1m
Axial velocity exceeds limit at 0.7m heavy phase compartment and NLi of 0.85m as shown in step 4
above.
Height used to calculate axial velocity (NLi – 0.5Hdb) is increased to 0.8m and axial velocity rechecked
with equivalent area of 1.6m2. Axial velocity is calculated as 0.014m/s and hence NLi is set at 0.8+0.15
= 0.95m
𝑄ℎ 82.46
𝑉ℎ𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙 = = = 0.014𝑚/𝑠
𝐴ℎ 1.6.3600
Axial velocity criteria met at 0.8m heavy phase compartment and NLi of 0.95m
5. Considering the NLi is midway between LA(L)i and LA(H)i as an initial estimate, set LA(H)i (8) at same
distance as LA(L)i from NLi. i.e. 0.95-0.55 = 0.4m and hence LA(H)i is preliminarily set at
0.95+0.4=1.35m.
6. LZA(HH)i (7) must be the minimum of 100mm +0.5H db or 1 minute from LA(H)i (min 1.37m 3) hence
LZA(HH)i is set at LA(H)i+0.15+0.1 m = 1.6 m
7. Set the top of weir height (6) at 200mm minimum above LZA(HH)i (7) =1.8 m
8. Check 8 minutes (minimum 3 minutes) hold up in accordance with table 5.6 between LA(L)i and LA(H)i
otherwise LA(H)i should be increased and the top of weir height checked accordingly. With LA(H)i set
at 1.35 m, the volume between LA(L)i and LA(H)i is 21.7 m3. Accordingly, the hold-up time is calculated
as 21.7/82.46=15.8 min.
The laminar settling velocity for the dispersed oil phase is calculated using Equation 5.6:
ℎ𝑐 𝑉𝑐𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙
𝑉𝑑 = = 0.0015 = 𝑚/𝑠
𝐿𝑠𝑒𝑡
Where:
The turbulent settling velocity is calculated based on the correction factor of 5% V axial.
𝑉𝑠𝑡𝑢𝑟𝑏 = 𝑉𝑑 + 0.05. 𝑉𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙 = 0.0015 + 0.05𝑥0.014 = 0.002𝑚/𝑠
The oil droplet size that will be separated from the continuous water phase is calculated using Equation 5.3:
1000. 𝑔. 𝐷𝑝 2 (𝜌ℎ − 𝜌𝑙 )
𝑉𝑠 =
18𝜇𝑐
The oil droplet diameter calculated is less than 150microns and hence size is adequate.
Droplet size Check Water in Oil
The laminar settling velocity for the dispersed water phase is calculated using Equation 5.6:
ℎ𝑐 𝑉𝑐𝑎𝑥𝑖𝑎𝑙
𝑉𝑑 = = 0.001 𝑚/𝑠
𝐿𝑠𝑒𝑡
Where:
The water droplet size that will be separated from the continuous oil phase is calculated using Equation 5.3:
1000. 𝑔. 𝐷𝑝 2 (𝜌ℎ − 𝜌𝑙 )
𝑉𝑠 =
18𝜇𝑐
The water droplet diameter calculated is less than 150microns and hence size is adequate.
Final Separator Dimensions
L
minimum minimum
H1
LZA(HH) trip H3
LA(H) H4
NL NL
D H8
Light Liquid Phase Top of Weir
Optional H5
H9 H14 Calming
Baffles LZA(HH)i trip
H10 LA(H)i
NLi NLi LA(L)
H11 H6
LA(L)i LZA(LL) trip
H12 H15 LZA(LL)i trip
Heavy Liquid Phase H7
H13
minimum
minimum
0.45D Ls et 0.25D
The calculation below is using method 2 for a downstream vessel where the residence time is used as the sizing
criteria.
Estimate the settling compartment vessel volume
Residence time is taken to be 10 minutes for each phase based on the assumption of a hydrocarbon separator
Refer Table 5.3. A preliminary vessel size is based on the liquid-liquid volume flow with the LZA(HH) at 75%
height (75% of vessel diameter).
Residence time of 10minutes each between NLi to bottom of vessel and NL to NLi.
Assuming a hold-up time of 8 minutes between LA(L) and LA(H) from table 5.4 and 60 seconds between each of
LA(H) to LZA(HH) and from LA(L) to LZA(LL) with NL at 50% LA(L) to LA(H).
Calculate the total volume required for settling based on 10 minutes residence time for each phase from NL to
NLi and NLi to BTL.
10 10
82.46𝑥 + 164.9𝑥 = 41𝑚3
60 60
For the light liquid phase above the NL calculate the volume based on the minimum required hold-up volume
between LA(L) and LA(H) at 8 minutes of hold up for light phase liquid flow and 1 minute to LZA(HH).
8
Volume between LA(L) to LA(H) 𝑥164.9 = 22𝑚3 - assuming NL is at 50% NL to LA(H) = 11m3
60
1
Volume above LA(H) to LZA(HH) 𝑥164.9 = 2.7𝑚3
60
As d>2 consider light phase as continuous, however check settling rate for both phases.
Dispersed heavy phase is 82.46/(82.46+164.9) = 33vol% of the liquid feed which is greater than 5% and hence
a dispersion band must be considered for the sizing. A 300mm dispersion band will be assumed.
From Appendix A1 area taken up by heavy phase:
10
82.46𝑥 2
𝐴ℎ = 60 = 1.7𝑚2 = (𝛼 − 𝑠𝑖𝑛𝛼) 1.6
8 2
This is less than 10 minutes residence time and hence residence time is controlling and particles of 150micron
and larger will settle out.
Area taken up by light and heavy phase to light phase NL based on total flow into the drum and considering only
the settling compartment length:
10
(82.46 + 164.9)𝑥 2
𝐴𝑙+ℎ = 60 = 5.2𝑚2 = (𝛼 − 𝑠𝑖𝑛𝛼) 1.6
8 2
This is less than the residence time and hence residence time is controlling.
In the event that settling rate is controlling, the engineer should consider either increasing the vessel diameter or
including internals to aid separation. The droplet size which can be separated without internals can be calculated
from equation 4.2 however vendor should be consulted to ensure optimum vessel sizing is selected.
Gas separation section
Confirm sufficient vapour space above LZA(HH).
Calculate terminal velocity from Equation 5.1
𝜌𝑙𝑖𝑞 − 𝜌𝑣
𝑉𝑡 = 𝐾𝑠 √( )
𝜌𝑣
Select a Ks value for a horizontal separator with a wire mesh demister from Table 5.1 K-Factors for Gas Phase
Internals of Ks = 0.12.
K is corrected for pressure prorated in line with Table 5.2 De-rating Factors for Pressure at 17.5 barg.
The minimum area required for gas separation is calculated using Equation 5.2:
𝑄𝑣 2376
𝐴𝑖 = = = 1.01𝑚2
3600. 𝑉𝑡 0.651
Gas cross-sectional area available for gas flow from below table 8.04-6.7=1.26m2
Using the preliminary vessel dimensions of 3.2m diameter and overall tan to tan length of 10.2m as specified
above; all the minimum hold-up control requirements must be checked to ensure all the required sizing criteria
are met:
Level setting calculations
The following tables show the calculation results. The chord calculation method in Appendix A1 is used to
calculate the area based on the height from BTL.
Control settings for the heavy phase are calculated using Linlet + Lset = 1.4+8=9.4m
Control setting for the light phase depend on whether the liquid is above or below the submerged weir and the
relevant length is identified in the table below.
Table A2.3-1 Area and Volume Calculation
14 NL 2 3.65 5.3
Bottom of vessel 0
The area for the light phase settling from the heavy phase is between NLi-0.5Hdb and bottom of vessel = 1.3m2
and is used in step 4 for the axial velocity check.
The area for the heavy phase settling from the light phase is between NL and NLi + 0.5H db =3.15m2 and is used
in the axial velocity check for the light phase in step 18.
The time between level settings is given in the table below and compared against the required criteria. The time
is calculated based on the flow rate of the respective phase divided by the differential volume.
Table A2.3-3 -Hold-up/Control Time Calculations
Light Phase
LA(H) to LZA(HH) (15) 0.1 0.3 2.8 1.0 >1 min, >0.1 m
Top of weir to LA(L) 0.03 0.1 1.0 0.4 >1 min, >0.1m
(10f)
BTL to LZA(LL) (7) 0.85 1.7 1.4 0.5 >30 secs, >0.3m
Heavy phase
LA(H)I to LZA(HH)i (5) 0.25 0.79 7.4 5.4 >1 min, >0.1m
minimum minimum
H1
LZA(HH) trip H3
LA(H) H4
NL NL
D H8
Light Liquid Phase Top of Weir
Optional H5
H9 H14 Calming
Baffles LZA(HH)i trip
H10 LA(H)i
NLi NLi LA(L)
H11 H6
LA(L)i LZA(LL) trip
H12 H15 LZA(LL)i trip
Heavy Liquid Phase H7
H13
minimum
minimum
0.45D Ls et 0.25D