2019-6-1-2-Lamnadi
2019-6-1-2-Lamnadi
2019-6-1-2-Lamnadi
Introduction
Phd Candidate, Universitat Rovira I Virgili, Spain.
https://doi.org/10.30958/ajt.6-1-2 doi=10.30958/ajt.6-1-2
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
However, this change in the structure of the economy might have led, in some
cases, to an excessive capital production (capital accumulation). This excess
capital has created a new challenge for the authorities to maintain its profitability
without inflation. Some official studies, which were carried out by the
government, suggested that one effective solution for this situation could lay in
creating more tourist-residential housing that generates much higher return rates
than the conventional hotel activity. The creation of these small-scale tourist
accommodations will help the state to solve effectively the capital accumulation
problem.
Management plans such as Vision 2010 and 2020 (Ministère du Tourisme
2001, Ministère du Tourisme 2010) are considered to be a perfect fit for such
measures. The overall achievement rates of the drawn objectives for both plans
16
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
Methodology
This paper uses secondary sources of data to analyse the Moroccan tourism
marketing strategy. The collected data consisted of governmental reports and
studies, tourism sector statistics, and different scientific articles and studies
addressing the Moroccan tourism sector in general and specifically its marketing
strategies. These data were also used to form a descriptive profile of the Moroccan
tourism sector for the unfamiliar readers of the country‟s tourism sector. In
addition, the concept and definition of tourism marketing are reviewed in order to
build a coherent conceptual framework for the paper. The collected data were
analysed and categorised into data sets (codes, categories and sub-categories)
according to the nature and function of each variable in this paper. The main data
set categories were assigned to texts themed on tourism marketing for the texts
dealing with the country‟s marketing strategies/policies. Connected to this
category, other sub-categories were assigned for texts highlighting marketing
actors, marketing channels and marketing techniques. Codes were created within
the sub-categories to evaluate the nature and function of each single component.
The same process was carried out concerning public management data set
category and connected sub-categories. Some resource illustrations had to be
modified or re-elaborated without affecting its viability or significance.
17
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
influence destination image (Beerli and Martín 2004). For this, different media
information and communication technology (narratives/visuals) are deployed to
promote a destination image in the market (Govers et al. 2007). Gallarza, et al.
(2002) define a destination image as a complex concept, which is open to different
interpretation and as lacking a unique meaning.
The portrayal of destination image has been always affected by various
objective and subjective factors. It is, principally, feeding on the information
available on that certain destination. This information has many sources including
promotion (advertising and brochures), the opinions of others (family/friends,
travel agents), media reporting (newspapers, magazines, television news reporting
and documentaries) and popular culture (motion pictures, literature). Nevertheless,
Echtner and Ritchie (2003) point out that this information is always manipulated
by visitors‟ first hand impression: “Furthermore, by actually visiting the
destination, the image will be affected and modified based upon first-hand
information and experience”. Another approach was introduced by Gallarza et al.
(2002) by stating that despite the fact that tourism services are intangible, images
become more important than reality; and the tourism destination images projected
in information space will greatly influence the destination images as perceived by
consumers. Tasci and Gartner (2007) present a review of destination image
formation based on the works of (Alhemoud and Armstrong 1996, Bramwell and
Rawding 1996, Court and Lupton 1997, Gartner 1993, Gunn 1972, and Young
1999 as cited in Tasci and Gartner (2007)). They conclude that image formation is
defined as a construction of a mental representation of a destination on the basis of
information cues delivered by the image formation agents and selected by a
person.
This destination image research line was initially approached in two different
ways: empirical studies that apply statistical instruments without developing
theoretical frameworks; (Schroeder 1996 as cited in (Gallarza et al. 2002)). The
other approach consisted of empirical studies that address image measurement
problems while presenting methodological explanation (Carmichael 1992, Echtner
and Ritchie 1993, Reilly 1990 as quoted in (Gallarza et al. 2002)). They classified
destination image as a variable depending on various factors contributing to the
formation of the destination image (Tasci and Gartner 2007).
Baloglu and MacCleary (1999) state that “image is mainly caused or formed
by two major forces: stimulus factors and personal factors. The former are those
that stem from the external stimulus and physical object as well as previous
experience. Personal factors on the other hand, are the characteristics (social and
psychological) of the perceiver”. This formation process is addressed by two
different approaches (Gallarza et al. 2002). A static one that studies the
relationship between image and tourist behaviour; and a dynamic one that deals
with the structure and formation of the destination image itself.
It is important to note here that tourism promotion is not a standalone factor
within the destination image building process. Rather, it depends on other
information sources that are projected about the destination influencing its final
built image. Moreover, the variables affecting the destination image are various
and can differ in type and nature; such as destination preference and visitation
18
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
19
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
Findings/Results
Promotion Actors
In Morocco, the main tourism agent is the ONMT (Office National Marocain
du Tourism), a public administration created in 1918 in charge of the promotion
and marketing of the product „Morocco‟ on the national and international level.
The Office plans promotion strategies as a public stakeholder, as it has become a
statuary branch of the Tourism Ministry. However, it may include in its promotion
strategy some of the private stakeholders as well, as a collaboration policy
between public and private sector. For instance, during the last two decades, many
promotion projects were implemented along with some private actors such as
travel agencies, real estate investors etc. Other public/private collaborations may
be involved at different levels in this promotion process (Figure 2).
Source: Author.
20
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
The ONMT
21
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
Source: Author.
22
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
provider of financial, material and human resources and a guarantee of respect for
the financial balance of the Office.
The restructure consisted of the creation of two new internal departments; as
for the "Digital & New Technologies" Department, it will be in charge of the
integration of new technologies in the promotion strategy of the destination
Morocco to offer a better visibility on the Internet. While "Morocco and internal
tourism" department will have as main missions the participation in the definition
of the strategic orientations of Morocco‟s brand and the development of a deep
knowledge and an expertise of the product Morocco. The general orientation of
the new structure tends to focus on participation in the definition of product
positioning, the development of awareness and the image of domestic tourism and
the development of a permanent contact with tourism sector professionals in
Morocco, local authorities and the press.
The SMIT
A public institution created in December 2007 by the Moroccan State with the
aim of implementing the strategy of development of the tourist product in
Morocco (see Figure 4). It emanates from the need to bring out a public actor in
charge of the construction of the tourist product. In addition to carrying out new
major projects on behalf of the State or legal entities governed by public law
throughout the national territory, the SMIT has other mission such as:
23
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
24
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
partner for any project leader in Morocco. Figure 5 shows that structurally
speaking, it consists of two main departments that form the core operation the
CRIs perform nationally for help desk for starting businesses as a unique
interlocutor of contact for all business starters/project holders; or the Investment
Assistance Division which provides investors with all the useful information for
regional investment; study all requests for administrative authorizations; and
prepares all necessary administrative acts to the realization of investment projects.
Investors willing to operate in the country on its different regions can find at
the correspondent CRI alliance and partnership. In this public institution,
necessary information for the creation of a business or investment in the region
and a valuable help is presented. The CRI in Morocco is an intermediary entity
between the project manager and the administrations that enables him to guarantee
the creation of the enterprise. As part of the assessment of the experience of these
centres, significant results were recorded at the level of business creation,
particularly in the reduction of creation time. Court of Auditors (financial
jurisdiction provided mainly responsible for monitoring the regularity of public
accounts of the State), notes in a report, published in 2015, that several internal
and external constraints that did not allow these entities to achieve the objectives
assigned to them, including the adoption of action plans specific to each one. In
addition, the report points to the lack of a special status of CRI staff, the existence
of financial resources dependent on state subventions, the lack of follow-up of the
companies created, and a limited role of CRIs in the implementation of national
policies at the local level. The report, also, mentions the inadequacy of the IT
interconnection of CRIs with their partners, the limited representation of
administrations within the interlocutor and the absence of a single system for the
25
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
payment of creation costs, as well as a legal framework that governs the Regional
Investment Commission.
Created in 1995, its main mission is to bring together all the tourism
professions and contribute to the reinforcement of the structures of the various
professions for greater efficiency and participation at the regional level namely
Regional Federations of Tourism (FRT). Initially, the CNT was under the
supervision of its mother federation, the CGEM (Confédération générale des
Entreprises du Maroc), of which it was externalised since 2007 but remains
statutorily attached to it. The CNT acquires a new ambitious structure turned
towards its members: Regional Federations of Tourism) and National (National
Federations of Tourism Professions). The following are the seven National
Federations of Tourism professions included in the confederation: 1) National
Federation of Hotel Industry; 2) National Federation of Moroccan Travel
Agencies; 3) Association of Touristic Investors; 4) Federation of car rental
companies without a driver in Morocco; 5) National Federation of Restaurants
owner; 6) National Federation of Tour Guides and Mountains Guides; 7) National
Federation of Tourist Transporters. The CNT designates its intervention in the
sector on three main strategic axes; the strategic interlocutor of the entire sector to
the public authorities and to all decision-makers; achieving the deployment of the
2020 vision; provide real services to members.
One other of the most vital actors contributing to the national tourism sector is
the network of Tour Operators (TO) providing trips and circuits services along
with accommodation and other leisure products. These agencies could be
categorised to many sets according to their nationality (national/foreign), operating
cities, and provided products. In their majority, the present ones are the national
TO focusing their products on the desert and imperial cities. In general, these are
the product most acquired by tourist arriving to Morocco. Within this network, a
set of criteria might affect the each TO‟s sales on the market. These could be
product type, pricing, operating cities, and coherence or variety of the circuits. The
major tour operators in the country may be found in the table below (Table 1).
Hotel Industry
26
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
as well as in low-cost category). This group also manages other subgroups that are
considered of its brand too such as: Ibis, Fairmont, Banyan Tree, L‟univers Sofitel,
Pullman, etc. across the major Moroccan cities (Marrakech, Agadir, and
Casablanca) where the majority of accommodation capacity can be found. To
illustrate more on this point, detailed information concerning dominant hotel
chains can be found in Table 2 below.
27
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
28
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
29
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
Promotion Channels
Once the promotion strategy is drawn, the actors included (private and/or
public) tend to establish a work plan based on the drawn strategy guidelines.
Depending on the nature and function of each actor, their intervention in terms of
projecting a certain promotional material may vary. In addition, the techniques
used to transmit the promotion of the destination may differ largely. This section
highlights the main channels through which promotion actors project their
promotional image. This projection is executed principally on three levels; 1)
direct information, 2) public relations, and 3) touristic advertisement.
30
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
These techniques are, in general, the ones deployed actually on the promotion
in the Moroccan tourism sector. However, they might be used differently
depending on the nature and function of the actors using them. However, the
promotional material is conveyed through various distribution channels such as
travel agencies, trade and tourists exchange, professional associations, press
releases, web-based portals.
Promotion Techniques
31
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
new markets. The initial action plan (2010) concerning promotion was focused on
the following points:
32
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
objective was an annual share of 500 million dirhams (45 Million €) in the horizon
of 2020, exclusively intended for the promotion. The state reached an agreement
between different implied actors in the sector on the need to schedule this effect an
increase of the product of the TPT (Taxe de Promotion Touristique) and predict
the contribution of other institutions (private or public) benefiting from tourism
revenues.
Discussion
33
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
belonged to Plan Azur (2010 and 2020). Also, the latest terrorist attacks in various
European cities (Paris, London, Berlin, Brussels) led to spread fear among the
public about visiting any country in the region; even though Morocco marked a
clean security record during the last decade (since the last terrorist attacks in
Casablanca 2003). This wrong idea formulated to the European public is due to the
misleading media propaganda. The non-efficient promotion of Moroccan
destination to those areas allows those wrong ideas of chaos and insecurity to
spread quicker and wider. In addition to this factor, essential points that make
promotion of the product Morocco inefficient.
The poor optimization of communications established by the ONMT has not
managed to get into regional and international dynamics. There is no
regionalization of promotion through the CRTs. In this context, Laws 1995 (cited
in Cox and Wray 2011) proposed five key phases of destination marketing which
ease the path to development objectives. 'diagnosis phase' in which destinations
must assess the market situation through inspection of existing tourist facilities,
identification of tourists‟ preferences and behaviours about the destination, and
identification of competitor destinations. Then comes the “prognosis phase”,
which seems to have more futuristic view, regarding the planning of destination‟s
development. The other three phases consist of setting objectives for the regional
destination; implementing marketing strategy; and monitoring marketing
performance. However, in the Moroccan tourism context we can notice the
absence of some of these phases in the country‟s tourism marketing plans
especially the first one (the diagnosis phase). This absence lays in the sector
invariant facilities as well as the inconsistent competitive performance compared
to similar product based destinations in the area.
In parallel with the external promotion efforts, the ONMT has also future
plans to regionalize the touristic promotion; that is to say that the office will carry
out this mission (the institutional image of destination Morocco) so that each
region can execute the promotion and marketing of its own territory. Concerning
the financial aspect, part of the budget drawn for the operation ought to stay at the
ONMT and another will be transferred to the regions with the support of CRIs and
sector professionals. The benefits for the regions from this regionalized promotion
are the expected investments that will generate jobs. It is also the role of the
regionally elected councils to promote their destinations and boost the economy of
their regions.
Cox and Wray (2011) point out that destination marketing, in its traditional
perspective, has focused on image creation and promotion aimed at achieving
growth in domestic and international arrivals rates. Adding that recently carried
out research tend to recommend more emphasis on adopting a sustainable
marketing approach that combines sustainable destination management and
development objectives. This approach explicitly suggests that destination
marketing should act as a strategic tourism management tool which creates some
kind of balance between the market objectives of stakeholders and the destinations
sustainability. In addition, the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO 1999)
proposed a sustainable model for marketing destinations. This model consists of
generating a detailed record of existing tourism attractions and facilities of the
34
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
35
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
the most affecting factors, its full potential, and the best practice that could be
carried out will be the best strategy. A key element here, after the identifying the
sector fully, may be the identification of similar practices in competing
destinations with similar potential.
Morocco must use competitive advantages over its direct competitors in the
area currently, such as Turkey, Cyprus, Tunisia and Egypt. Therefore, Moroccan
policymakers and tourism industry leaders ought to re-draw their management
strategy to reach the maximum exploitation of the country‟s tourism resources. In
this sense, many applicable steps could be taken into account like resetting the
tourism image of the country - portrayed through the official promotional
materials - via diversifying the offer to contain other promising products especially
outside the typical imperial cities of the country. There is a considerable touristic
potential in areas like the North of Morocco or the marginal areas of the Atlas with
splendid natural resource. If correctly managed, these „forgotten‟ regions could
make a huge difference in the performance of the Moroccan tourism sector.
Marketing of tourism in Morocco still sticks with the same destination image
created by first world agencies or worst from the colonial period. Even in some
recent promotional media, they concentrate on the product desert as the main
theme of the destination. The depiction of Moroccan tourism product in official
promotional media is still highly superficial. It does not show the real identity of
the destination. In some cases, the exhausting use of local culture elements for the
sake of tourism led to some kind of reluctance towards their own culture
compositions. For instance, in the city of Chaouen, the excessive exposition of
cultural artefacts covering all the blue beautiful walls of the city, making it all
about a large artefacts market. In this sense, from the image existing on the ground
it seems that the Moroccan public policies have led to centring the touristic activity
solely around the touristic product; totally neglecting the human factor. Absence of
empowering of the Moroccan Man within the destination make the tourism
activity appear as any normal trade with product and consumers.
This reorientation process requires a serious implication of all actors and
stakeholders implied in the marketing of the destination Morocco. Both public and
private sectors have to develop a shared vision that could function as a roadmap
for a new promotion strategy that empowers the full-diversified potential of the
country. To facilitate achieving this objective, some short- and long-term tactics
and strategies should be deployed. Such as directed investments at improving the
content and quality of the Moroccan promotional and marketing techniques and
channels; also, a cooperative effort between the private sector and the public sector
is needed in order to systematically promote the tourism and cultural image of
Morocco through hosting well-orchestrated international fairs and exhibitions.
Such a strategy should focus on improving the competitiveness of the different
aspects of Moroccan tourism as a standalone destination generally, and its interior
major sub-destination as the core competing product that will reset the country as a
leading destination in the region. Finally, the Moroccan government must
reconsider its commitment and national priority in relation to the tourism industry.
36
Athens Journal of Tourism March 2019
References
37
Vol. 6, No. 1 Lamnadi: The Evaluation of Tourism Marketing Model within…
38