➢3 Quebec ➢3 Ontario ➢2 West ➢1 Atlantic Two Critiques of Supreme Court Appointment Process ➢the republican critique ➢the federal critique
US Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh defending himself against
allegations of sexual assault during his confirmation hearing in the US Senate, September 2018. Paul Martin’s Advisory Committee for Supreme Court Nominations ➢one MP from each party in Parliament ➢a retired judge from the region where the vacancy arises ➢a representative of the provincial minister of justice from the region ➢a representative of the law societies from the region ➢two prominent Canadians who are neither lawyers or judges Justin Trudeau & the New New Process ➢A seven-member Independent Advisory Board for Supreme Court of Canada Judicial Appointments ➢a retired judge nominated by the Canadian Judicial Council; ➢two lawyers, one nominated by the Canadian Bar Association and the other by the Federation of Law Societies of Canada; ➢a legal scholar nominated by the Council of Canadian Law Deans; ➢the other three members, including two non-lawyers, have been nominated by the Minister of Justice.