Burgos A. TLSA 2020 FINAL
Burgos A. TLSA 2020 FINAL
Burgos A. TLSA 2020 FINAL
Ariadna Burgos1
1
Laboratory of Local Heritage, Environment and Globalization, UMR 208 IRD-MNHN. Department of
Humans and the Environment, French National Museum of Natural History, French National Research
Institute for Sustainable Development, ANR Popei-Coll. 57 Rue Cuvier, CP 135, Paris France.
Abstract
In South-East Asia and Oceania as in many other areas of the world, shelled molluscs such as
clams, cockles, conchs and snails provide multiple services for coastal livelihoods (e.g. food
security, water purification, stabilization of the shoreline and habitat structure, etc.). On
Atauro Island (Timor-Leste) discarded shells resulting from human activities are found on the
coastal shore as well as at the top of Atauro mountains, both at the soil surface and buried in
the substrate. Nowadays, shelled molluscs provide a source of nutritious food, income and
inspiration to local communities. In total, 67 species of molluscs were found to be used in
Atauro Island for multiple purposes. Women and children played an important role gathering,
processing and selling molluscs. Indeed, in order to efficiently harvest shells local shellfishers
must have accurate knowledge regarding the diversity, habitat and distribution of molluscs, as
well as constantly learn new information on the dynamics of local fisheries and the marine
environment. In a world where ecosystems and societies are facing major challenges such as
climate change and ecological services degradation, the link between local knowledge and
academic science is central for sustainable development. Drawing from our research in Atauro
Island (Timor-Leste), the aim of this paper is 1) to illustrate the diversity of practices and local
knowledge involved in the gathering of molluscs; and 2) to identify socio-cultural and
ecological factors that affect the way local people interact with molluscs and the marine
environment. We found that the relationship between humans and molluscs in Atauro offers
insights to understand long-term socio-ecological changes on the island. Our results allow us
to propose lines of action to monitor, assess and manage molluscan fisheries in Timor-Leste
while combining traditional and scientific knowledge.
1
Artisanal molluscan fisheries: importance and resources
Molluscs are the largest marine group including almost a fourth of all known marine species
(Bouchet et al. 2016). Bivalves and gastropods, such as oysters, mussels, clams, cockles, snails,
abalones, conchs, whelks are shelled molluscs, or more commonly known as “shellfish”. They
are found in all habitats of the marine realm and provide essential ecological services such as
cycling and storage of carbon and nutrients, habitat structure, water purification, stabilization
of the shoreline, and food for other organisms (Gutierrez et al. 2003, Smaal et al. 2019). From
a societal point of view, the flesh of shellfish offers not only key nutritious elements and food
to coastal societies (Khan and Lieu 2019, Venugopal and Gopakumar 2017), but also the shell
itself carries cultural values and provides a source of income (Nijman 2019, Burgos et al.
2019).
Shelled molluscs are relatively sedentary and some are strictly sessile or fixed during their
adult stage (e.g. oysters, mussels and some clams). This condition makes that their
distribution and habitat are relatively predictable by shellfish foragers (Thomas 2007). Indeed,
bivalves and gastropods meld perfectly with their environment and foragers must pay
particular attention to different ecological features within coastal ecosystems while they glean
in order to maximize harvest outcomes. This requires a deep and up to date knowledge of
molluscan habitats, life habits and population dynamics. Additionally, a high awareness of
who is fishing where and what, is necessary to avoid selecting sites that have already been
exploited, decreasing shellfishers’ chances of finding molluscan species (Burgos 2016).
Study site
Atauro is a small oceanic island 22 km long and 5–10 km wide. It has a total area of 140 km²
and a maximum elevation of 1000 m at Mount Manucoco which is located in the southeastern
2
part of the island. Atauro is formed by a volcanic edifice mantled by a succession of uplifted
limestone coral reefs (Ely et al. 2011). The island comprises flat to sloping lime-stone terraces,
steep hills and deeply dissected valleys cut into the volcanic substrate (idem.). The northern
part of the island has a lower relief that contrasts strongly with the south part (Figure 1).
There is limited development of alluvial plains, and no freshwater wetlands, tidal rivers or
extensive mangroves are found on the island. The coastline typically comprises long beaches
with relatively narrow (30–200 m wide) fringing reefs and extensive seagrass beds are found
near the village of Beloi in the eastern side. In the southern part of the island, the coastline is
dominated by cliffs and rocky shores. Atauro is known for its outstanding marine biodiversity
and by a well-preserved coral reef system (Brian et al. 2019, Conservation International 2016,
Erdmann and Mohan 2013). Furthermore, the island has also a rich linguistic diversity
comprising three languages : Rasua (spoken in Atekru, Akrema, Bikeli, Beloi, Uaroana),
Ratunglu (spoken in Berau, Maker and Makadade) and Hrseuk (spoken only in Makili)
(Guillaud 2019).
Figure 1 : Map of Atauro Island and villages where research was conducted.
Fieldwork in Atauro was carried out between 2017 and 2019 for a total of 156 days.
Interviews with local people and inventories of the molluscan fauna were conducted in nine
out of the thirteen villages located in Atauro (Figure 1). Seventy-six interviews were carried
out with women (n=46) and men (n=30). Interviews were conducted in Indonesian,
Portuguese, Tetun (Timor-Leste official language) and Rasua (one of the three local languages
of Atauro). For the latter two, the assistance of a translator was required.
Fishing grounds were located by GPS and described according to local knowledge and
ecological observations. Molluscan species were inventoried during follows of shellfish
gathering activities and participatory observation of fishing activities. Shells seen along
Atauro’s trails, or dispersed on the surface of the soil in the hills or caves were registered in
order to determine the diversity of shell waste dumps or shell deposits. Market surveys (n=23)
were conducted at the Beloi weekly market to survey the diversity of molluscan species sold
for food or as souvenirs. The shells of species used by Atauro people were collected,
photographed and identified with their local name in-situ and with their scientific name at the
marine invertebrate collection of the French National Museum of Natural History in Paris.
3
Social structure and organization of fishing activities
Atauro artisanal molluscan fisheries are part of a larger frame of food production systems
which include other forms of fishing, agriculture, wild forest gathering, and livestock such as
raising pigs, chickens, and goats. The way Atauro people fish and relate to aquatic resources is
highly specific to each locality. In fact, the contrasted topographies of the Island produce a
high diversity of ecosystems and coastal habitats that house specific biota and thus different
marine resources and exploitation practices. This is particularly notable between the villages
of the extreme south (Makili, Berau and Maker) and the other villages of the island.
The social structure and organization of shellfishing activities displays gendered and
intergenerational particularities. Women are the main gatherers of shells in the seashore
(Figure 2), while men fish mainly in areas that are permanently submerged regardless of the
tide, and target large molluscan species such as Tritonia charonis, Tectus niloticus and Turbo
marmoratus. These species are sought after mainly for the economic and cultural value of the
shell, more than being target for edible purposes. Children can be seen accompanying their
mothers during gleaning activities. They also play an important role finding small empty shells
washed up on the beach, mainly gastropods, that are turned into necklaces or earrings by
their mothers and sold during the Saturday market at Beloi. Women are the main sellers of
molluscs, both for food or for ornamentation purposes.
Figure 2: Women play a key role harvesting molluscan species in intertidal environments.
4
Diversity and uses of bivalves and gastropods
In total, 67 species were found to be used in Atauro 48 of which were gastropods and 19
bivalves. Sixty-three species were used as food, of which nine were also used for ornamental
purposes. Four species, consisting only of gastropods, were used for ornamental purposes
only. Eleven species were sold at the Saturday market for local consumption and thirteen
species were sold as souvenirs or as jewelry. Asaphis violascens was the most abundant and
recurrent species sold at the Atauro Market. Two handfuls of shells of A. violascens were sold
for one dollar. These represented more less 20 - 30 shells depending on the size and were
bought mainly by other inhabitants of Atauro or by domestic tourists, visiting Atauro on
Saturday during the market day.
Names of molluscan species and coastal habitats varied between the different linguistic areas
of the island. Indeed, while some names displayed some similarities between Rasua and
Ratunglu, names of species and habitats were significantly different in Hresuk. Moreover, in
each language certain names of shells have become general terms to designate a group of
species. For instance, for the younger generations, the name “kima” can refer to various
species of Tridacna while for older generations all four species of Tridacna found on the island
had a specific name. Despite the erosion of knowledge regarding species names, it is
important to highlight that young women who glean for shells, were highly aware of
molluscan habitats and species behavior. This knowledge was fundamental to enhance the
efficiency and productivity of their shellfisheries.
5
species (e.g. Charonia tritonis, Turbo marmoratus, Tectus niloticus) are collected by hand.
These gastropods are often harvested for decoration and handcraft purposes.
Figure 2: Distribution of shellfishing activities in the shore (adapted from Tilley et al. 2020 © Burgos A. Billault L.
– IRD). Nerita species are found on the rocky shore, Asaphis violascens is buried in the gravel beach, Codakia
tigerina is specific to seagrass environments, Turbo setosus and Tridacna crocea are sought after in the reef flat,
and Tectus niloticus is harvested in the fore reef.
Molluscs were available year-round but were never harvested on a daily basis. The collection
of intertidal species was dependent upon the timing of the low tide whether subtidal species
were harvested disregarding of the tide. The most popular times to look for shells were during
the morning, evening and nighttime (using a torch). If low tide occurred outside these times,
shellfishing was more arduous due to high temperatures and sun exposure, and resulted in
lower catchability, particularly of gastropods, who sought refuge in reef crevices (Tilley et al.
2020). Indeed, some burying bivalves such as A. violascens and C. tigerina could be sought any
time of day, as their distribution was not affected by the heat.
6
transgressive behavior (Palmer and McWilliam 2019). The development of Tara bandu areas
has been increasingly adopted by the state and environmental organizations as a mean to
promote hybrids modes of resource governance. Nevertheless, the interpretation of the Tara
bandu concept is not yet clear and varies amongst authors as amongst organizations
promoting them (Alonso-Población et al. 2018, De Carvalho and Correia 2011, Palmer 2016,
Meitzner Yoder 2005). Today, the support and implementation of Tara bandu by state,
international development organizations, and non-governmental organizations (NGOs)
throughout Timor-Leste have revealed both positive and negative effects (Alonso-Población et
al. 2016, Kim 2021, Palmer and McWilliam 2019, Tilley et al. 2019). As a fact, if Tara bandu
provides unique opportunities to preserve biodiversity in the context of marine settings, their
establishment has not come without consequences for local people’s lifestyles, cultural
practices, and subsistence strategies.
In Atauro, several Tara bandu areas have been developed during the last five years. If the first
Tara bandu established in Atauro was the result of an entire year of negotiations with the
local communities of the village of Adara, the rapid subsequent implementation of twelve
other Tara bandu throughout the island may not have completely achieved the proper
consultation and characterization of the biological and social settings specific to each
community (Kim 2021). Nowadays, the majority of Tara bandu areas are located in front of
villages, and they often cover the total expanse of the village coastline, such as is the case in
Maker, Berau, Atekru and Uaroana. Two relevant issues affecting lifestyles and molluscan
shellfisheries will be highlighted here, but there are many other social and ecological aspects
that need to be consider (see Kim 2021). First, while international divers and tourists are
allowed to enter Tara bandu zones in exchange for a fee of two dollars, the same principles of
fees apply to locals - including children. Nevertheless, two dollars represents a significative
amount of money in Atauro and this principle entails that children can no longer swim in front
of their houses, or easily fish and collect shellfish in localities where they can be supervised by
their parents or relatives. This affects children’s interaction with the ocean, and puts them at
risk as they need to find far distant localities to be in contact with the ocean. Secondly, all
fishing practices are prohibited and liable to financial penalties within the boundaries of Tara
bandu. Women, whose fisheries depend on marine invertebrate species located in intertidal
habitats are disproportionally affected by these regulations as they need to walk long
distances in order to look for shellfish. This, in addition to the many tasks that women have to
accomplish for the functioning of their household, creates an impediment to look for and
rapidly harvest animal protein and discourages women from carry out this activity.
It is worth highlighting that in Timor-Leste 50% of children under 5 years of age are subjected
to malnutrition, and chronic food insecurity affects 64% of the population during the dry
season (Bonis‐Profumo et al. 2020). Shellfish and other marine invertebrates represent a rich
source of animal protein and provide micronutrients that can foster child development and
food security and provide nutrition in Timor-Leste (Lopez-Angarita et al. 2019). The majority of
women consulted within the framework of our project affirmed that, with the exception of
the most commonly sold species such as A. violascens and three large species of gastropods
sought after for their shell and primarily harvested by men (see above), there are still plenty
of edible molluscs on the island. One elderly woman in Akrema noted that when her husband
passed away, she depended significantly on Nerites and other shellfish species to feed her
four children. Both women and men affirmed that shellfish represent a unique source of food
during periods of shortage and in times of rough seas.
7
Molluscan fisheries and cultural heritage
Molluscan fisheries have a long tradition on Atauro and are part of a system of cultural
practices that deserve to be preserved and encouraged with as much emphasis as
biodiversity. These fisheries play a crucial role in supporting interconnected food production
systems, food security, nutrition and income (Grantham et al. 2021, Lopez-Angarita 2019,
Tilley at al. 2020), as well as, in the establishment of social bonds and networks of non-
commercial exchange (Grantham et al. 2020). Moreover, the diversity and abundance of shell
middens and molluscan archaeological records scattered throughout the island are a
testament to the importance that molluscan resources have played for the societies that have
inhabited the island since at least 18000 years (Galipaud et al. 2016).
Women in Atauro display a high diversity of shellfishing techniques and traditional ecological
knowledge related to molluscs. Whether the effects of their gleaning activities on coastal
ecological process and biodiversity remain understudied, the traditional management
practices carried in Atauro for millennia might have contributed in a way to support the
diversity of marine species and well-preserved coral reefs observed today in the island (Brian
et al. 2019, Conservation International 2016, Erdmann 2016). Indeed, marine invertebrates
and intertidal habitats are vulnerable today to rapid social and ecological change (Grantham
et al. 2021, Kim 2020, Tilley et al. 2020), but also cultural practices and local knowledge are
vulnerable to new forms of marine resource management.
Nowadays, the involvement of local communities and their knowledge of natural resource
management is fundamental to better understand changes in coastal ecosystems and to
favour the sustainable use of wild species. It is now widely accepted that “effective
conservation requires context-specific understandings of human interactions with, and
conceptions of, nature” (Infield et al. 2018). Transdisciplinary research linking methods and
approaches of anthropology, archaeology, ecology and geography are key to understand
human-mollusc interactions in the long term and to support the development of alternative
conservation models that take in account also the cultural heritage and social settings of each
locality (Burgos et al. 2019). In addition, local and scientific knowledge should complement
each other to build adaptive strategies in the face of rapid change of coastal socio-
ecosystems. To this end, it is crucial to develop coastal management frameworks where local
people are included, not only in the collection of data, but also in the development of
monitoring approaches and tools, in the analysis of data, and in the elaboration of
recommendations and policies. Indeed, achieving this will require shifts towards institutional
diversity at all levels of coastal management and governance.
Acknowledgments
This research was carried in the frame of the project “Cultural Policies, Local Heritage and
Collaborative Approaches in Eastern Insulindia” (Popei-Coll), ANR-18-CE27-0020-02. I would
like to express my deep and sincere gratitude to my research supervisor Dominique Guillaud
who gave me the golden opportunity to discover Atauro Island. Special thanks to the whole
team of the Popei-Coll project and to Alex Tilley (WorldFish) and Catherine Kim. My most
sincere thanks to all the wonderful people from Atauro Island.
8
Bibliography
Alonso-Población E., Rodrigues P., Wilson C., Pereira M. and Lee R. (2018). Narrative assemblages for power-
balanced coastal and marine governance. Tara Bandu as a tool for community-based fisheries co-
management in Timor-Leste. Maritime Studies, 17(1): 55–67.
Alonso-Población E., Rodrigues P. and Lee R. (2016). Tara Bandu as a coastal and marine resource management
mechanism: A case study of Biacou, Timor-Leste. In S. V. Siar & D. C. Kalikoski (Eds.), Strengthening
organizations and collective action in fisheries. Towards the formulation of a capacity development
programme. Workshop report and case studies. FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Proceedings No. 41. Rome.
(pp. 301–340). Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
Balée W. (2013). Indigeneity of Past Landscape Transformations of the Tropics. In Humans and the Environment.
Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780199590292.003.0011
Bouchet P., Bary S., Héros V. and Marani G. (2016). How many species of molluscs are there in the world’s
oceans, and who is going to describe them?, in: Héros V. et al. (Ed.) Tropical Deep-Sea Benthos 29.
Mémoires du Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle (1993), Collections MNHN, Paris, 208 pp.
Bonis‐Profumo G., Stacey N. and Brimblecombe J. (2020). Maternal diets matter for children’s dietary quality:
Seasonal dietary diversity and animal‐source foods consumption in rural Timor‐Leste. Maternal & Child
Nutrition. doi.org/10.1111/mcn.13071
Brian J.I., Davy S.K. and Wilkinson S.P. (2019) Elevated Symbiodiniaceae richness at Atauro Island (Timor-Leste): a
highly biodiverse reef system. Coral Reefs 38, 123–136.
Burgos A., Younger A. and Wolverton S. 2019. Human mollusk interactions in a changing world. Journal of
ethnobiology, 39(2) : 175-181.
Burgos A. 2016. Savoirs naturalistes et stratégies de collecte de Geloina erosa, Geloina expansa et Polymesoda
bengalensis dans la mangrove de l’île de Siberut (Indonesia). Revue d’ethnoécologie, No 9. DOI :
10.4000/ethnoecologie.2602
Conservation International (2016). Conservation International Timor-Leste. Online www.conservation.org/timor-
leste (Accessed the 2 August 2020).
De Carvalho D. and Correia J. (2011). Tara bandu as traditional ecological knowledge. Local Knowledge of Timor.
Jakarta: Unesco Jakarta, 57, 67.
Ely K.S., Sandiford M., Hawke M., Phillips D., Quigley M. and Reis J. E. dos. (2011). Evolution of Ataúro Island:
Temporal constraints on subduction processes beneath the Wetar zone, Banda Arc. Journal of Asian Earth
Sciences, 41(6): 477–493.
Erdmann, M. V. (2016, July 8). Little-known reef reveals wealth of unexpected riches, new species [Blog]. Little-
Known Reef Reveals Wealth of Unexpected Riches, New Species.
https://www.conservation.org/blog/little-known-reef-reveals-wealth-of-unexpected-riches-new-species/
Erdmann M. and Mohan C. (Eds.). (2013). A rapid marine biological assessment of Timor-Leste, RAP Bulletin of
Biological Assessment 66. Coral Triangle Support Partnership, Conservation International.
Galipaud J.-C., Kinaston R. and Guillaud D. (2016). Aleti Tunu Bibi: Contextualizing a New Rock Art Site in East
Timor and the Wider Asia-Pacific Region. Asian Perspectives, 55(2), 128–147
General Directorate of Statistics Ministry of Finance (GDS) and Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
(MAFF). 2020. Timor-Leste Agriculture Census 2019. National report, Timor-Leste.
Grantham R., Álvarez‐Romero J.G., Mills D., Rojas C. and Cumming G. (2021). Spatiotemporal determinants of
seasonal gleaning. People and Nature. https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.10179
Grantham R., Lau J. and Kleiber D. (2020). Gleaning: beyond the subsistence narrative. Maritime Studies, 19(4) :
509–524.
Guillaud D. (2019). Les narrations d’Atauro (Timor Est). Les Carnets du paysage, 35 :181-193.
Gutierrez J., Jones C., Strayer D. and Iribarne O. (2003). Mollusks as ecosystem engineers: the role of shell
production in aquatic habitats. Oikos, 101(1), 79–90
Infield M., Entwistle A., Anthem H., Mugisha A. and Phillips K. 2018. Reflections on cultural values approaches to
conservation: lessons from 20 years of implementation. Oryx, 52(2): 220-230.
Khan B. M. and Liu, Y. (2019). Marine Molluscs: Food with Benefits. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and
Food Safety, 18(2), 548–564.
9
Kim C. 2021 (in review). Coral Reef Management and Tara Bandu on Ataúro Island: an ecologist’s perspective.
Proceedings of the 2020 Timor-Leste Studies Association-Portugal Conference.
Kim C., Roelfsema C., Dove S. and Hoegh-Guldberg O. (2020). The condition of coral reefs in Timor-Leste before
and after the 2016–2017 marine heatwave. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory [BioRxiv, 2020.11.03.364323].
https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.11.03.364323
López-Angarita J., Hunnam K.J., Pereira M., Mills D., Pant J., Teoh S., Eriksson H., Amaral L. & Tilley A. (2019).
Fisheries and aquaculture of Timor-Leste in 2019: Current knowledge and opportunities. Penang, Malaysia:
WorldFish. Program Report: 2019-15.
Meitzner Yoder L. (2005). Custom, codification, collaboration: Integrating the legacies of land and forest
authorities in Oecusse Enclave, Timor-Leste. PhD thesis, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut.
Nijman V. (2019). Souvenirs, Shells, and the Illegal Wildlife Trade. Journal of Ethnobiology, 39(2): 282.
Palmer L. and McWilliam A. (2019). Spirit Ecologies and Customary Governance in Post-conflict Timor-Leste.
Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde / Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences of Southeast
Asia, 175(4): 474–505.
Smaal A., J. G. Ferreira, J. Grant, J. K. Petersen, O. Strand (eds). 2019. Goods and services of marine bivalves.
Springer, Cham.
Venugopal V. and Gopakumar K. (2017). Shellfish: Nutritive value, health benefits, and consumer safety.
Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 16(6): 1219-1242.
Thomas F. (2007). The Behavioral Ecology of Shellfish Gathering in Western Kiribati, Micronesia 1: Prey Choice.
Human Ecology, 35(2), 179–194.
Tilley A., Burgos A., Duarte A., dos Reis Lopes J., Eriksson H., & Mills, D. (2020). Contribution of women’s fisheries
substantial, but overlooked, in Timor-Leste. Ambio.
Tilley A., Hunnam K., Mills, D., Steenbergen D., Govan H., Alonso-Poblacion E., Roscher M., Pereira M., Rodrigues
P., Amador T., Duarte A., Gomes M. and Cohen, P. J. (2019). Evaluating the Fit of Co-management for
Small-Scale Fisheries Governance in Timor-Leste. Frontiers in Marine Science, 6.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2019.00392
10