8 - Understanding Life Insurance
8 - Understanding Life Insurance
8 - Understanding Life Insurance
_________________________________________________________________
Section 6
Understanding Life Insurance
INTRODUCTION
Like it or not, life insurance, for most people, is the foundation or starting
point for any financial plan. The exception is for non-married people who have no
children and no heirs they are trying to protect or pass wealth to.
Why the starting point or foundation?
Well, that begs the question: Why do people buy life insurance? There are
many reasons some of which everyone knows and some reasons that are not
widely known.
Here are the traditional reasons people buy life insurance:
1) To protect a loved one.
This is the most obvious reason people buy life insurance. Young couples
get married; and, if one is the primary breadwinner, coverage is purchased to
make sure the other is taken care of in the event of an early death of the
breadwinner.
Certainly, for those who have children, life insurance is a necessity. It is
needed to take care of the children until they reach a certain age. For some that
will be age 18; for others the death benefit will also help pay for college.
2) To cover a debt (current or future).
Many people buy mortgage protection insurance. This type of policy
simply pays off the mortgage so the remaining spouse or loved one(s) are not
burdened with the payments from a mortgage.
A future debt that some buy life insurance for is funeral expenses. These
policies typically have no underwriting and are fairly inexpensive to cover usually
up to $15,000 in costs. Some policies come with additional services to help loved
ones navigate the funeral home process.
3) To pass wealth to the heirs and/or cover estate taxes.
With the estate tax exemption being more than $10 million per person,
most people will not be buying life insurance to cover estate taxes.
Some people will, however, buy life insurance because they want to pass a
specific amount of life insurance to their heirs at death (like $100,000 to each
child or grandchild).
Here are a few reasons that most people do NOT know about that are
valid reasons to buy life insurance.
1) To build wealth for retirement.
To many, the concept of building wealth for retirement in a life insurance
policy seems counterintuitive.
1 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
Why would anyone want to build wealth for retirement in a “cash value”
life insurance policy?
-What if the policy allowed money to grow tax free?
-What if the policy could generate a rate of return of between 6%-8%?
-What if gains in the policy were locked in every year and could never be
lost due to a downturn in the stock market?
-What if you could remove money from the policy tax free in retirement?
What many people don’t know is that a “good” cash value life insurance
policy can be a tremendous retirement vehicle.
2) For Long-Term Care (LTC) type benefits.
Most people do not know that many life policies today come with a FREE
rider that will pay for long-term care type expenses through what is called a
chronic illness rider. This is not a reason alone to buy life insurance; but if you are
going to buy life insurance, buying one with this type of rider will make sense.
Since more than 50% of all Americans will have LTC expenses sometime
during their lifetime, it would be prudent to have a life policy that could cover
some of those costs.
If you are wondering why the material isn’t elaborating on the topics
covered, that’s because each will be covered in more detail in the material to
follow.
Introduction Summary
What the introduction material is trying to convey is that life insurance for
most people will be the starting point of their financial plan. It can be used to
protect loved ones, pay off debts, pass wealth to the heirs, be used as a retirement
vehicle, and can even be used to pay for long-term care expenses.
There are many types of life insurance policies available in the
marketplace today. This material will break them down into two categories ─ the
“originals” and the “hybrids.” In addition to these types of products, the material
will also point out pitfalls to policies and tricks insurance agents use to make the
purchase of a policy much more advantageous.
Notwithstanding the cautionary language in the previous paragraphs, life
insurance can be one of the best financial planning tools you have at your
disposal. What other planning tool do you have at your disposal where in day one
you can contribute a monthly premium of $500 and have an immediate payout to
a beneficiary of $1,000,000? What other product can you use in a supplemental
retirement plan that is self-completing?
What does self-completing mean? Three things can happen to you after
you buy a life insurance policy. You can live, die, or become disabled. A properly
structured life plan can provide or complete itself no matter which of the three
happens. Either you or your beneficiaries will receive money from the policy.
2 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
The following pages will discuss the types of life products available so
you will see why the words “Life Insurance” should NOT be taboo.
THE BASICS
The material to follow goes into detail on the various types of life
insurance policies, how they work, and who is a candidate for each type of policy.
Before getting into the more detailed information, the basic concept of how a
death benefit is paid needs to be dealt with. The following applies to every type of
individual life insurance policy.
Proceeds Payable at Insured’s Death
One of the unique and beneficial aspects of life insurance is that the death
benefit, when paid to the beneficiary, is generally done so income tax free (IRC
Section 101(a)(1)).
There are some exceptions to the general rule that life insurance death
benefits are paid income tax free. These include life insurance purchased in a
corporate setting where the premium is deducted or purchased by an employee in
a qualified retirement plan (not discussed in this course).
While death benefits generally pay income tax free to the beneficiary, they
will NOT pass estate tax free through the estate to the heirs/beneficiaries (unless
the benefit is being passed to a surviving spouse who then will have the estate tax
problem). If your estate is in excess of the estate tax exempted amount ($11.4
million if single), you can still pass the death benefit to your heirs tax free by
using an Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust (ILIT); but that is outside the scope of
this course material.
TYPES OF LIFE INSURANCE POLICIES
The two original types of insurance are term insurance (insurance for a
specified period of time) and permanent/whole life insurance (insurance coverage
guaranteed for the duration of your life). Both products are used in planning; and
depending on your situation, one may work better than the other.
TERM LIFE INSURANCE
Term life insurance is thought of as a simple product. It obviously has to
be if people are purchasing it in droves on the Internet and from television
commercials, right? While most people think of term life as simple, it is not as
simple as it seems due to some important factors that many times should not be
overlooked.
A simple explanation of term insurance is that you pay a set insurance
premium for a certain period of time (the term); if you pass away during that term,
the beneficiaries receive the death benefit. If you do not die during the term, with
most policies, there is no refund of premium.
3 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
4 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
Policy Riders
Life insurance policies can come with a number of different riders if the
insured is willing to pay for them. These vary from product to product and from
carrier to carrier. These are the most common:
-Waiver of Premium. This rider will waive all premium payments during a
period of disability, after a stated waiting period. This rider is very important and
can make sure a supplemental retirement plan will self complete if a disability
does happen.
-Guarantee Purchase Option. This rider allows the insured to purchase a
stated amount of coverage at a future date without proving insurability. This could
become extremely important in the event an insured becomes seriously ill.
-Long-Term Care Rider. This rider is very attractive. It allows the insured
to purchase coverage that will help cover the cost of a nursing home or assisted
living facility in the event the insured needs long-term care. These costs can be
crippling and financially devastating without some form of coverage.
CONCLUSION ON TERM LIFE
Statistics show that over 97% of the term life policies sold do NOT pay a
death benefit. What does that mean? It means that 97% of the people who
purchased term life insurance will feel like they wasted the premium due to the
fact that they didn’t die (although they are usually happy they didn’t die).
Generally speaking, most people who have wealth, or want to, or expect to
have wealth, do have a need for “permanent” insurance (either for tax-favorable
wealth-building and/or for the death benefit). If that is the case, then buying term
life insurance is NOT a good idea except to cover a short-term need.
THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW BEFORE LEARNING/DISCUSSING
CASH VALUE LIFE (CVL) INSURANCE POLICIES
A “cash value” policy is a whole life, universal life, or variable life
insurance policy. In short, an insured pays a planned premium; and some portion
of the premium will go towards the “cash value.” The premium allocated to the
cash account value of the policy earns interest either at an annually declared rate
or a rate that fluctuates due to stock market returns such as those in variable life
policies or in indexed universal life policies.
1) Cash Surrender Value (CSV)
The CSV of a policy is the amount of cash you would receive if you
decide to give up or terminate the life policy. The CSV in the early years of a life
policy (typically years 1-10 and sometimes up to year 15) is always less than the
cash account value (CAV). A good rule of thumb is that the CSV will equal the
cash account value (CAV) in year 10.*
*This is the rule of thumb. There are policies in the marketplace that have
high cash value in the early years. I’m not generally a fan of high cash value
policies because there is an additional cost to have high cash value early. I only
recommend high cash value policies in leveraged situations (where borrowed
funds are used to pay the premium) or when a client wants to hedge against
5 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
something going wrong in the few years after the policy is purchased (like losing
a job, becoming disabled, etc.).
The CSV is lower in the early years to make sure the insurance company
stays profitable in case an insured chooses to surrender the policy. The difference
between the CSV and cash account value comes from the fact that the insurance
company has underwriting expenses, has to pay commissions to insurance agents,
and has taxes to pay.
2) Cash Account Value (CAV)
The CAV in a life policy is the amount of money the company actually
allocates to an insured’s growth account. The cash account value is always higher
than the cash surrender value in the early years of the policy. The insured does
not have access to the entire cash account value until the “surrender” charges in
the policy are gone.
The CAV is really what grows inside a non-term life policy. If there are
investment returns inside the policy, they are credited to the CAV. Then the
insurance company applies its scheduled surrender charge to the CAV to calculate
the client’s CSV. If an insured plans to keep the policy in place for more than 10
years, typically the surrender charge is not an issue.
3) Policy Withdrawals
A “withdrawal” of money from a cash value life insurance policy is the
partial surrender of the policy. A policyowner will not have taxable income until
withdrawals (including previous withdrawals and other tax-free distributions from
the policy such as dividends) made from the cash reserves of a “flexible
premium” policy (i.e., universal or adjustable life) exceed the policyowner’s cost
(accumulated premiums).
Until the policyowner has recovered his/her aggregate premium cost,
he/she will generally be allowed to receive withdrawals tax free under what is
known as the “cost-recovery-first” rule.
Side note: An insured’s income tax liability is accelerated if a cash
withdrawal/distribution occurs within 15 years of the policy’s issue and the
distribution is coupled with a reduction in the policy’s contractual death benefits.
In other words, a withdrawal within 15 years of policy issuance coupled with a
drop in death benefits triggers taxable income.
4) Cash in a properly designed policy grows tax free and can be
removed tax free.
Section 7702 of the Deficit Reduction Act of 1984 (DEFRA) and Technical and
Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988 (TAMRA) (which deals with the Modified Endowment
Contracts (MEC) rules).
One of the main reasons cash value life insurance is used as a wealth-
building tool is because cash in the policy is allowed to grow tax free and be
removed tax free.
6 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
7 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
The ideal funding of a cash value life insurance policy for retirement
planning is to fund it in an equal amount for at least seven years. Funding less
means you bought too much death benefit and funding more means the policy will
violate the 7-pay test.
5) Policy Loans
When an insured is sold a cash-building life policy, the sale, in large part,
usually revolves around “loans” that can be taken from the policy “income tax
free.” There are two types of loans available in most cash-building policies: 1)
wash loans and 2) variable loans.
You will pay NO income tax if you borrow cash value from your life
insurance policy (this assumes the policy stays in place until death).
This is sometimes confusing for the insured. Often you will hear advisors
(including myself) talk about receiving tax-free income from a life insurance
policy. That's not technically accurate as you now know. You do not receive
“income” from your life insurance policy; instead, you access the cash via loans.
Generally, loans are treated as debts, not taxable distributions. This can
give you virtually unlimited access to your cash value on a tax-advantaged basis.
Also, these loans need not be repaid (the loan is repaid at death through a
reduction in death benefit).
After a sizable amount of cash value has built up in a policy, it can be
borrowed systematically to help supplement your retirement income. In most
cases, you will never pay one cent of income tax on the gain.
The main circumstance you will need to guard against is taking too much
cash out of your policy through loans. If you do that, you will run the risk of the
policy not having enough cash left in it to pay the premiums for you until death.
Typically, cash value policies are funded over a specific period of time, 5-
7-10-20 years. If the policy is “over-funded” at the MEC minimum death benefit,
significant cash should grow in your policy. After your premium payment period,
there is still an annual cost of insurance that is owed in the life policy. This cost
is paid out of the cash value of the policy.
When an insured borrows cash from a life insurance policy, the policy
must stay in place until death (otherwise the insured runs the risk of the loan
becoming taxable). Greedy clients or owners who do not budget well can get into
a situation where there is not enough cash in the policy in the later years (and after
loans) to continue to pay the internal costs of the policy. If the policy does not
stay in force until death, the insured will have to pay taxes on the loans received
from the policy that exceed the premiums paid.
To guard against the policy lapsing and having a client risk their loans
being taxable, newer life insurance policies in the marketplace have added a free-
policy rider that kicks in when you borrow money over the age of 65-70
(insurance companies offer this rider at different ages). The rider, once activated,
guarantees that your policy will never lapse; and, therefore, you will avoid any
8 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
potential that the policy will lapse due to a lack of cash to pay annual expenses in
the policy.
MORE ON LIFE INSURANCE POLICY LOANS
Many companies have created what are called “wash loans” to make
borrowing from a life insurance policy more saleable. A few examples are really
the best way to explain wash loans. Let’s start with a non-wash loan example:
If an insured has $200,000 of cash surrender value (CSV) in a life
insurance policy, the insured could call the insurance company and request a “tax-
free” loan from the policy. Let’s say that loan is $10,000.
The insurance company has to charge interest in the policy on the
borrowed money. If the loan rate is 8% on the borrowed funds, then the insured’s
policy is charged 8% interest on the loan; and that must be paid every year.
The insured’s cash in the policy is still growing, but at what rate? If the
crediting rate on the cash in the life policy is only 6%, then there will be a
shortfall on the interest owed; and the cash value in the policy will start to go
backwards.
If the cash in the policy goes backwards for too long, the policy could
eventually lapse (which could trigger a taxable event on the money previously
borrowed from the policy). Also, to avoid a policy from lapsing, a policyholder
can make new premium payments (which is something most insureds do not want
to be forced to do in retirement when they planned on removing money from the
policy tax free via loans).
What if the insured had a wash loan option in the policy? If the insured
had a wash loan, the interest charged on the loan would equal the growth rate on
the cash in the policy. With a wash loan, the cash in the policy will not have to be
used to pay the interest on the loan. Instead, the returns on the cash value will pay
the interest.
If the interest on the loan is 8%, the insurance company will credit 8% on
the same amount of cash in the life policy so it is a neutral transaction from the
insured’s point of view. The life policy was charged 8% on the $10,000 loan, but
the life policy also earned 8% on $10,000 in the policy to create a neutral
position.
Some of the newer policies have what are called “variable loans.” I will
discuss these powerful and much abused loans later in this chapter where I discuss
equity indexed universal life insurance.
9 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
10 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
11 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
Usually, policies issued during long periods of high interest rates will
carry a higher guaranteed rate than those issued during or after a protracted period
of low interest rates. Changes to interest rates allow the holder to take advantage
of rising interest rates. The danger is that falling interest rates may cause
premiums to increase or even cause the policy to lapse if interest income in the
policy can no longer pay a major portion of the insurance costs (this is not likely
to happen in an over-funded, non-MEC policy which has much more cash than is
needed to pay the costs of insurance).
For many years, fixed UL products did not have a “guaranteed” death
benefit option. Basically, a UL’s death benefit stayed in place as long as the
premium was paid and the crediting amount on the cash was reasonable. In recent
years, UL products have been updated to allow riders that can guarantee a death
benefit in a “paid-up” manner similar to the 10- and 20-pay policies of a whole
life policy. In fact, some UL policies will allow a client to buy a guaranteed
lifetime benefit with a single premium.
Universal Life insurance policies are generally restricted to safe, low-
yielding investments; and the most common investments are purchased in the
bond markets.
The question then becomes: Should you use a traditional UL policy for
wealth building?
My answer is NO; I would not use a traditional UL policy for wealth
building.
What is a traditional UL good for? As stated, it’s the cheapest way to buy
a guaranteed death benefit; and that’s primarily how I recommend its use.
VARIABLE UNIVERSAL LIFE
Variable Universal Life (VUL) is a combination of insurance products and
mutual funds. Like its cousin, UL, VUL is very flexible, accumulates cash, and
some newer products even offer riders that offer death benefit guarantees.
VUL was popular when the stock market was averaging returns in excess
of 12% a year. I like to explain VUL policies by stating that a VUL is like
investing money in a mutual fund except the mutual fund is housed inside a tax-
free wrapper. Insureds who own VUL policies can avoid annual dividend and
capital gains taxes associated with actively managed money in a typical brokerage
account.
Honestly, everyone loved VUL policies until the stock market tanked in
2000. One of the major drawbacks with a VUL is that there is typically NO
guarantee on the cash in your policy. Remember, the money is literally invested in
mutual funds inside the policy. If those mutual funds lose nearly 50% of their
value like many did from 2000-2002 and over 50% between the highs of 2007 to
the lows of 2009, the cash in your policy will decrease by that amount and more.
12 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
Why more? Because in a life insurance policy you have additional loads
that you do not have in a brokerage account. I call this the double whammy. Not
only do you lose money in the market which decreases your cash value in the
policy; but with a VUL, the costs of insurance increase every year.
Owning a VUL in an up market is great and in a down market is a disaster.
The question becomes: Would I recommend using a VUL to build wealth?
Absolutely not.
Readers looking to earn 6-8+% returns in their life insurance policy with
no investment downside risk should look at Indexed Universal Life policies.
INDEXED UNIVERSAL LIFE (IUL) INSURANCE
As just stated, many owners of variable life policies have found out that
cash values in a variable policy not only go up with the market but they fall with
the market as well. This prompted the proliferation of a “new” universal life
policy, the Indexed Universal Life insurance policy (IUL). An IUL policy is a UL
policy that has an annual minimum return guarantee (with most policies the
guarantee is zero) but still allows the cash value in the policy to grow at market
rates every year if the stock market has positive returns.
The policies also LOCK IN THE GAINS every year which is very
helpful in a volatile equity market.
How are investment returns calculated in an IUL policy?
The vast majority of IUL products peg the cash value growth in the
policies to the Standard & Poor’s 500 stock index (one of the best performing
stock indexes).
When I first looked at indexed life products, I actually thought the
insurance companies took an insured’s money, applied X amount to the costs of
the policy, and invested the remainder into the S&P 500 stock index. I thought
that was a bit risky, but I figured insurance companies own half the world so they
could afford it if they had a few bad years.
In fact, the insurance companies DO NOT invest premium dollars inside
an insured’s policy into the S&P 500 index. After X amount of the premium
dollars are allocated to pay the costs in the policy, the remaining amount of
money is used to purchase income-producing bonds. The insurance company
then takes the income from the bonds and buys the most favorable “options” it
can on the S&P 500 stock index.
Explaining “options” is not easy, but I’ll do the best I can without boring
you to tears. The best way to explain options is with an example.
Assume we are dealing with a $100,000 investment. Assume you allocate
$90,000 to an S&P 500 mutual fund (also known as a spider or index fund).
Assume you allocate $10,000 to purchase “options” on the S&P 500. Let’s
say with the $10,000 you would be able to buy a “$100,000 option” in the S&P
500.
If the S&P increased 10% in the first year, what would be your returns?
13 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
The $90,000 you invested into an S&P 500 indexed fund would increase
by $9,000 to a value of $99,000.
On your “option,” you would earn a 10% return on the $100,000 position
you purchased. This would return to you your option cost of $10,000, plus
$10,000 which is the 10% return on the $100,000 position.
Total assets at the beginning of the following year:
$99,000 + $20,000 = $119,000.
In the real world, when you buy “options,” there are costs to the options;
and I do not want to get into the exact structure in my discussion for this material.
What I will tell you is that, because of the costs and the structure of the options
purchased by life insurance companies, the option returns in an IUL policy are
capped. By capped, I mean that, if the S&P 500 returns 25% in one year, you will
not be earning 25% in your IUL policy.
Caps on IUL policies vary per company. Some companies have caps of
14% and some as low at 10%.
New Volatility Control Indexes (VCI)
Some companies are rolling out unique/proprietary investment indexes to
be used as an alternative to the S&P 500 index. These new VCIs are managed by
firms like Morgan Stanley and other big investment firms. VCIs are “actively
managed” strategies vs. the S&P 500 which is a passive buy strategy.
200% rate of return—at the time this material is being published, one
insurance company offers a VCI index that credits 200% (double) of what the
VCI returns. So, if the VCI returns 7%, the return credited on cash in the policy is
14% (with no cap on the returns).
Trying to fully explain how VCIs are designed and managed is outside the
scope of this material. But they seem to be growing in popularity in the industry,
and readers should make sure they are dealing with an advisor who knows all the
viable IUL products in the marketplace and can help explain the pros and cons of
each.
It should also be noted that the returns in the S&P 500 based IUL policies
do not include the dividend income that would normally be paid to an indexed
mutual fund.
DON’T FORGET THE GUARANTEES
Talking about upside growth that is pegged to the best measuring stock
index is great. However, what is equally as great is the fact that the policies have
guarantees in them so your money does NOT GO BACKWARDS due to
downturns in the S&P 500. Every year there is a positive investment return inside
the IUL, the policy locks in the gains.
When you couple the locking/guarantee feature of IUL policies with the
potential to earn returns that closely mirror the S&P 500 stock index, you really
have, in my opinion, the “best” type of life insurance policy to grow cash for
retirement planning.
14 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
I know the Whole Life policy advocates take issue with my stance and
that’s okay. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. We won’t know which policy
works the best for 10-20-30 years after one is purchased. At this point, all we can
do is look at the numbers of past performance and make an informed opinion as to
which life insurance policy will work best to grow wealth.
Here’s an example to illustrate how an IUL policy can save a client
significant money. I intentionally used 1999 as a starting point to show you how
well an IUL policy works when the market goes negative. The following is from
January 1999 to January 2009. The S&P 500 was negative 2.31%, and cash in an
IUL with a 12.5% annual cap would have grown at 5.24%. The chart on the left is
the performance and on the right is the maximum drawdown (zero for the IUL).
Let’s look at another example that includes the last two market crashes
and a historic bull run in the stock market (2002-2018). You’d think that the S&P
500 would do much better than an IUL policy with a 12.5% cap, but it doesn’t.
15 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
As you can see on the chart, the S&P 500 was down over 50% while there
are never any negative returns in an IUL. Also, the cash in the IUL grew at 7.38%
vs. 7.23% for the S&P.
The previous two examples are not perfect because they don’t take into
account the expenses in the life policy or taxes and fees in a typical brokerage
account. I will cover the real math of growing wealth in a brokerage account, tax-
deferred IRAs/401ks, vs. an IUL in a separate section of the course.
But for this section of the material, I’m simply trying to explain the
protective wealth-building features (annual locking of gains) of an IUL which I
think come through pretty clear in the previous two charts.
“FREE” (NO-COST) LONG-TERM CARE BENEFITS
One of the expenses more than 50% of Americans can look forward to
paying for is the cost of long-term care (LTC).
Many Americans are tuned into the costs associated with LTC because a
loved one (parent or grandparent usually) has had to pay for LTC costs.
If many Americans are tuned into this cost and if the statistics state that
more than 50% of Americans will need LTC at some point in their lives, then it
must be the case that the majority of Americans are buying LTC insurance to
protect against this cost. Right?
Wrong. Traditional LTC insurance is very expensive, and the vast
majority of Americans do not have it (even though many know they need it).
One of the unique features of my favorite IUL policy is a free LTC
benefit. How can any insurance company afford to give an insured a free LTC
benefit? It’s actually not that hard to understand.
The insurance company is simply going to pay the insured part of the
death benefit from the policy early to pay for LTC expenses (it’s a tax-free benefit
as well). The company is going to have to pay a death benefit when an insured
dies; so instead of waiting, the company makes a portion of the death benefit
available when the insured needs it.
The insurance company lowers the death benefit to take into account
payments or LTC expenses.
Most people do not think of buying a life insurance policy for the “living
benefits,” but being able to receive a FREE LTC benefit is truly revolutionary and
gives IUL policies a leg up on other types of cash value life insurance policies.
The primary FREE benefit that is offered is technically called a chronic-
illness rider. It typically kicks in when an insured can’t perform two of their six
ADLs (Activities of Daily Living) without assistance. Those six ADLs are eating,
bathing, getting dressed, toileting, transferring (being able to either walk or move
oneself from a bed to a wheelchair and back again), and continence (the ability to
control one's bladder and bowel functions).
16 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
17 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
18 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
19 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
20 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
This issue is different than the previous one about buying term insurance
to cover the death benefit shortfall.
An insurance agent can choose to run an illustration at the 7-pay test
minimum death benefit with a level or increasing death benefit.
But the outcome for the client buying the policy is dramatically different.
The best way to explain this is with an example. Let’s use the same 45
year old who is going to pay a $15,000 premium into an IUL for 20 years and
then is going to borrow tax free a level amount each year from the policy from
ages 66-90.
Illustration #1—level death benefit from day one.
The initial death benefit = $941,362
The amount that can be borrowed tax free from ages 66-90 = $48,179
Illustration #2—increasing death benefit the first 20 years (the payment
period) and level death benefit years 21 through age 100.
The initial death benefit = $362,533
The amount that can be borrowed tax free from ages 66-90 = $60,353
The difference in borrowing each year is $12,356 (more using increasing).
The difference over the 30-year borrowing phase is $370,680.
The difference is huge, and this is why I recommend using an increasing
death benefit. You start with a lower initial death benefit and can buy term
insurance to fulfill your short-term life insurance need.
In this example, if we assumed the client needs $1 million in death benefit,
the level death benefit illustration got the client close to that number.
But at what cost? $12,356 a year in borrowing each year for 30 years?
Just as an FYI, a $650,000 death benefit/20-year term life insurance policy
for a healthy 45 year old male only costs approximately $775 a year.
It’s no brainer to buy the CVL with an increasing death benefit and to fill
the other life insurance need with a 20-year term. Why did I use 20-year term?
Because as budgeted, the CVL policy will have approximately $1 million in cash
in it at age 65 when the term policy would expire.
Why then would an insurance agent recommend or use level death benefit
when selling a cash value life policy to a client?
Commissions!
The commission for the level death benefit illustration is nearly three
times larger than the increasing death benefit illustration.
For clients who don’t know any better, the level death benefit illustration
showing borrowing of $48,179 each year looks pretty good. But it’s not nearly as
good as what could be expected with an increasing death benefit policy.
21 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
This is why I wrote my book Bad Advisors: How to Identify Them; How to
Avoid Them and why I put a section in this course on bad advisors.
NEEDS ANALYSIS
I’d like to conclude this section of the material on what many insurance
agents call a needs analysis. What’s that? It’s simply an analysis to determine how
much life insurance (death benefit) you need.
Depending on what kind of insurance agent you work with, you will get a
different answer to the question.
My answer is always the same, as little as possible to accomplish the goal
at hand.
Many insurance agents are looking for excuses for clients to buy as much
as possible so they can make the biggest commission.
I’m not going to get into the many different ways to calculate the need.
Most people are smart enough to figure it out without the help of an agent or
needs analysis.
If you died today, if you died next year, if you died five years from now or
10 or 20, what kind of death benefit would be needed to accomplish your goals?
Those goals could be paying off a debt or amassing enough cash for a
loved one so he/she didn’t have to work for 5, 10, 20 years or more. The goals
could include paying for a child’s college education.
When looking at the lump sum death benefit that will be paid, you have to
make certain assumptions about how that death benefit will be invested and spent.
I’ll give a few simple examples. Let’s use the 45-year-old male but let’s
assume he’s married to a spouse (also age 45) who works and they have two
children. For argument’s sake, let’s say the spouse makes $60,000 a year; and the
husband makes $50,000 a year.
Who needs life insurance and why?
Does each spouse need life insurance to take care of the other one in the
event of death? That’s a tough question. An insurance agent would typically want
to have each spouse buy approximately the same amount of life insurance. Why?
To pay off debt (assume they have a $400,000 mortgage) and to pay for the
children’s’ college education.
The typical sales pitch is also that, when one spouse dies, the other will
want to take a significant amount of time off from work and a large death benefit
will allow for that to happen.
The reality is that, if one spouse dies, the other spouse isn’t going to all of
a sudden be a stay-at-home mom or dad. They will have a period of mourning but
then will go back to work.
22 Copyright-The WPI
OnPointe’s Financial Literacy Course
_________________________________________________________________
23 Copyright-The WPI
Understanding Life Insurance
______________________________________________________
My point with this section of the material is to say don’t be afraid to think
critically about the amount of life insurance you need to purchase. Don’t just
blindly follow an insurance agent’s needs analysis. Invariably, the one I’ve seen
done typically recommends a death benefit that is far in excess of what I typically
would recommend.
CONCLUSION ON LIFE INSURANCE
To say that life insurance is a misunderstood tool when it comes to wealth
building would be a dramatic understatement. When insureds do not understand
how and why a wealth-building tool works, how can they be expected to embrace
its use as part of a main tool in their overall financial/retirement plan?
While this material will not make you a life insurance expert, I hope you
have learned several things you didn’t know before you read it. I hope now you
know the differences between term, whole, universal, variable, and indexed
universal life insurance.
I hope you understand the tax-free aspects of building wealth in life
insurance policies which are designed as over-funded, non-MEC policies.
Since I believe IUL is the best type of cash-building policy, I spent quite a
bit of time explaining how the policy works to protect your cash from downturns
in the stock market while providing you good upside potential in the equity
market (the S&P 500).
If you understand how variable loans work with IUL, I can guarantee you
that you know more about the product than half of the agents selling it.
While many readers think that anyone can get a life insurance license and,
therefore, anyone can give good advice about life insurance policies, you now
know that there are many variables and nuances to life insurance policies that
must be known in order to give the best advice to clients.
With the information learned in this material, you should be able to have a
meaningful discussion with a life insurance agent about the best type of life
insurance that is best for you.
Now that you should have a good working knowledge about CVL
insurance; you can move onto the next section of the course which will cover how
CVL insurance compares as a wealth-building tool to funding stocks, mutual
funds after tax in a brokerage account, or building wealth through tax-deferred
IRAs/401(k) plans and Roth IRAs/401(k) plans.
24 Copyright-The WPI