PA. Lesson 9
PA. Lesson 9
PA. Lesson 9
Case 9.1. P9.5. Costs of sales and inventory under alternative cost-flow
assumptions, from the Sutton's book (pages 265-266).
Case 9.2. P9.6. Effect of cost-flow assumptions on income and tax, from the Sutton's
book (page 266).
Case 9.3. Evaluating the effects of inventory methods on income from operations,
income taxes, and net income1.
Coimbra company uses a periodic inventory system. Data for 2012: beginning
merchandise inventory (December 31, 2011), 2,000 units at $35; purchases, 8,000 units at
$38; operating expenses (excluding income taxes), $142,000; ending inventory per physical
count at December 31, 2012, 1,800 units; sales price per unit $70; and average income tax rate,
30%.
Required:
1. Prepare income statements under the FIFO, LIFO, and WAC costing methods. Use a
format similar to the following:
1
Adapted from Phillips, F., Libby, R. and Libby, P.A.(2013): Fundamentals of Financial Accounting,
Fourth Edition, McGraw-Hill International Edition, New York.
2. Between FIFO and LIFO, which method is preferable in terms of a) maximizing income
from operations or b) minimizing income taxes? Explain your answer.
3. What would be your answer to requirement 2 if costs were falling? Explain your
answer.
Required:
1) Calculate cost of goods sold using the LIFO method (Assume all sales took place in
March). Does this confirm the statement you made to David about the gross profit
earned on water ski sales in the first quarter?
2) Without doing any calculations, is it likely that any alternative inventory costing method
will produce a lower cost of goods sold?
3) Calculate cost of goods sold using the FIFO method. Would use of this method solve
David’s current dilemma?
4) Do you think it is acceptable within accounting rules to report the water skis using one
inventory costing method and the boats using a different method?
5) Do you see any problems with using the FIFO numbers for purposes of David’s meeting
with the board?
2
Adapted from Libby, P.A., Libby, R., Phillips, F., and Whitecotton, S. (2009): Principles of
Accounting, McGraw-Hill Irwin, New York.