Hawaii Historic Housing Study-Schofield
Hawaii Historic Housing Study-Schofield
Hawaii Historic Housing Study-Schofield
Wilikina Drive
3-29
1500
3000
Kunia Road
Neighborhood History
Historically, the principal mission of the United States Army in Hawaii was the defense of the naval base at Pearl Harbor. The perceived threat of Japan during the Russo-Japanese War instigated the buildup of naval forces in the Pacific and thus spurred an increase in Army personnel. After the establishment of Naval Base Pearl Harbor in 1901, a board was convened to investigate other appropriate sites for military defenses. The U.S. Army established Fort Shafter in 1907 to defend Pearl Harbor from the north. In 1908, the site for Schofield Barracks was selected as the base for Oahus mobile defense troops because of its strategic central location on the Leilehua Plain between the Waianae Mountain Range and the Koolau Mountain Range. Construction of temporary buildings began in December 1906 under the supervision of Captain Joseph C. Castner, the construction quartermaster.
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-30
The first plans for the permanent post were prepared in 1912 by General Macomb. The layout reflects the linear base design, with the barracks and administration buildings along a central line, the housing areas on one side, and the technical buildings along the other side. The permanent buildings
were to be organized into seven contiguous sections, each one shaped in a rectangle headed by a loop. The rectangles were to contain barracks in quadrangular formation with the Officers Quarters lining the loops; the main sewer and water lines ran down the center for economy.
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
Construction of the permanent post buildings began in 1913. Among the first completed in 1914 were the first two large masonry barracks buildings in what became known as Quad B. Each quad consists of three barracks buildings and one administration building, flanking the four sides of a central courtyard. Other buildings from this early period include the post library, the remaining buildings in Quad B and Quad C, which were completed in 1915 and 1916. Also constructed at this time were two loops of two-story Officers Quarters, sited above Quads B and C. These were demolished after WWII. In 1916, Schofields construction quartermaster developed a plan for the remainder of the base. The post developed rapidly in the following years; plans were made, and in some cases, construction began on the remainder of the cavalry barracks, two more infantry quads, a new hospital, NCO quarters, and the post stockade. Construction was delayed during WWI when all of Schofields tenants were called to war. In the interim between WWI and WWII, the 1916 construction plan was carried out. The three Craftsman-style houses along General Loop were completed in 1918. Quads D and E were finished in 1920 and 1921. In 1920, expansion of the railroad and the initial phase of Quartermaster warehouses were started. The Officers Quarters adjacent to Quads D and E were constructed between 1919 and 1922. Design of these U-shaped, Craftsman-style houses, which were also constructed at other Army bases in Hawaii, such as Fort Kamehameha, Fort Shafter, and Ford Island, were
Chapter 3
Large Mission-style Houses
Go rga sR d.
Leilehua Avenue
Ro ad
Canby Road
en
na
nS
t.
Da ws on
eR oad
Gl
Klin
nR
oad
rdo
St.
Go
on
Ro
ad
mb
Ba
Av e
Le
nu
ldw
Ro
inR
ote
wis
Fu
Fo
co
Waianae Avenue
Ma
Wi
liki
oad
nst
ad
3-31
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
Ku ni
Ro a
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-32
well adapted to Hawaiis climate. The first artillery barracks were completed in 1919 (Quad I), and the second in 1923 (Quad J). These quads also had the adjacent Officers Quarters housing area, which has since been demolished. Other buildings constructed during this period included a permanent post stockade, new post chapel, post exchange, NCO Housing, fire station, outdoor boxing bowl and other recreational buildings, hospital, ordnance magazine area, and the remaining Quartermaster warehouses. The historic core of the base was essentially in place by the mid-1930s. Following World War I, the Army increased the strength of the Hawaiian Department and formed a combat division at Schofield Barracks. The Hawaiian Division, formed in 1921 with its base at Schofield, was at that time the only complete division in the Army. The establishment of this large division and increased tensions in the Pacific explain the continual construction at Schofield during the 1920s and 1930s. The last group of Officers Quarters at Schofield, completed in 1932, was built to accompany Quad F. These Mission-style houses are similar to those constructed at Wheeler Field. The houses were built for officers and NCOs of the 11th Medical Regiment and the 19th Infantry. Rising tensions in the Pacific in the late 1930s resulted in increased defense mobilization throughout the islands and reorganization of the Hawaiian Division in 1941, forming the 24th and 25th (later named Tropic Lightning) Divisions. Schofield became the Armys largest single garrison and, in 1939,
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
Chapter 3
Schofield Barracks, c. 1938, with the Waianae Mountain Range in the distance
Source: Tropic Lightning Museum
was the second largest city in the Territory of Hawaii with a population of 20,000. Schofield Barracks population grew in the two years before the war, attaining a total pre-war strength of 43,177 troops. In the early morning of December 7, 1941, Japanese pilots flew from six aircraft carriers toward Oahu. The first wave of 183 planes struck its targets at 7:55 a.m. Schofields 25th Division had the
distinction of being the first Army unit to receive hostile fire in the invasion, and shot down two Japanese planes. The post received some damage, mostly consisting of bullet holes in buildings, and many men received injuries from shrapnel and machine gun fire. Adjacent Wheeler Field, location of the Army Air Corps fighter planes, received severe damage to planes and hangars and had many casualties.
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
The Hawaiian Departments commander and his naval counterpart were relieved of duty following the attack on Pearl Harbor and other sites. They were replaced by a unified command under Admiral Chester Nimitz, Commander-in-Chief, Pacific (CINCPAC), and the Hawaiian Department ceased to exist. The primary mission of the 24th and 25th Divisions, supported by troops from the West Coast of the United States, became the defense of Oahu. As WWII progressed, Schofield Barracks became the major training, staging, and supply center for the war in the Pacific. Various training camps were run at Schofield during WWII, including the Ranger Combat Training School, where men were trained for combat in the Pacific. Following the war, Schofields population shrank to 5,000 troops. The population at the installation remained low until the outbreak of the Korean War. Schofield Barracks played an important role in the Korean War and the Vietnam conflict by providing basic training for many raw recruits due to be sent to Asia. These years saw a dramatic increase in military housing construction, as well as schools, chapels, and other support facilities. Today, Schofield Barracks remains the largest permanent installation of the U.S. Army outside the continental United States.
3-33
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-34
The more notable open spaces around Schofield include the Generals Loop area with its Norfolk Island pines; the Watts/Ralstom Field area with its ironwood, monkeypod, jacaranda, and eucalyptus trees; Canby Field neighborhood with its monkeypods and royal palms; and Gimlet Field neighborhood with its row of earpods. Major Trees/Palms: Monkeypod Banyan Earpod
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
Norfolk Island pine Kauri Royal palm Ironwood Other Trees: Mango African tulip Plumeria Brassaia
Chapter 3
0
Large Mission-style Houses
Go rga sR d.
Canby Road
Da ws on
Ro ad
en
na
nS
t.
eR oad
Gl
Klin
nR
oad
rdo
St.
Go
on
Ro
ad
mb
Fo ote Av en ue
Ma
Waianae Avenue
Banyan, Norfolk Island Pine, Royal Palm, Wi liki na Kauri & Narra Dr
ive
oad
wis
Fu
inR
Le
ldw
Ro
ad
nst
co
3-35
Ba
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
Ku ni
Ro a
IE W
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
Facility # 225, 229, 401-408, 411-424, 427-440, 443-448, 501-508, 511-521, 523, 524, 527-538, 540, 543-548 410, 425, 426, 441, 442, 510, 525, 526, 541, 542 409 509 227 600-627, 629, 631, 633, 635, 637, 639
Facility or Design Name Craftsman Corner Entry Plan (CNP Type I) Craftsman Center Entry Six-Bedroom Plan (Type L) Craftsman Duplex Plan (Type K) Craftsman Center Entry Five-Bedroom Plan (Type M) Commanding Officer's Quarters Pan Mission Large Plan Mission Small Plan
Date
1919-1922
3-36
The Craftsman-style houses at Schofield Barracks represent an early recognition by the Army of the need for regional variations. Designed in the Honolulu Office of the Constructing Quartermaster, the designs show a conscious response to the regional architectural style and to the tropical environment of the site. These houses combine some of the refined Craftsman-style details with the singlewall, board-and-batten construction typical in
Hawaiis plantation housing. The pitched roofs, Ushaped plan around an open courtyard, and large screened areas show how Army housing design were adapted to tropical living by integration of the interior and exterior spaces. The screened lanai and hallway areas created a continuous indoor and outdoor circulation and also provided excellent cross-ventilation throughout the house. Examples of these adapted Craftsman designs, found only in Hawaii, were built at several Army installations, including Schofield Barracks, Fort Shafter, Luke Field (at Ford Island), and Fort Kamehameha.
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
Chapter 3
The Schofield Canby Craftsman housing area has 93 single-family houses and one duplex that were constructed over a period of nine years, between 1919 and 1928. The three houses at Generals Loop were built in 1918. Although several different floor plans were used, the houses utilize the same construction materials and details.
originally screened but now typically enclosed with jalousies or other windows. The living room and dining room are in the middle of the house. One wing consists of the kitchen, pantry, servants and utility areas, while the other wing contains the three bedS C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
rooms. Quarters 229 at Generals Loop varies from this standard design only in that the entry was moved to the center of the front elevation, and the dining room was moved to the previous location of the corner entry lanai, creating an expansive living room.
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-38
originally Bachelor Officers Quarters. The symmetrical room layout of this house corresponds with that of the Bachelor Officers Quarters, which had four two-room suites, each with an adjacent bathroom, and a shared living room space at the central
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
entry. To convert this to single-family quarters, two of the suite rooms were changed into a kitchen and dining room, one suite room was changed to a family room, and one of the bathrooms was converted into a laundry room.
Chapter 3
3-39
Four bedrooms and two bathrooms are in the opposite wing. The bedrooms are accessed by a hallway along the courtyard that was originally screened. The central courtyards of some of these houses have been enclosed.
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-40
central courtyard. This building, originally a Bachelor Officers Quarter, has been modified to create a duplex by dividing the central common living room space and creating an alcove entry with separate entry doors into the two living rooms. One bathroom was converted into a utility room, and two of the rooms on each side became a kitchen and a dining room.
Chapter 3
Commanding Officers House
The area now known as Generals Loop was originally designated to house artillery units. When the artillery role was enlarged, their barracks were moved and the generals quarters were built. Quarters 227, designated for the senior officer, was first occupied by Brig. Gen. John W. Heard in 1918. This unit is very similar in layout to the six-bedroom central entry design, except that the entry lanai and central courtyard are wider, the dining room does not protrude out from the side of the building, and the pantry is located directly adjacent to the kitchen. Also, the second bathroom in the bedroom wing is located between two bedrooms rather than being accessed from the hallway. The rooms at the back of the wing beyond the kitchen have been slightly modified from their original layout.
Quarters 227, Commanding Officers House
Source: Mason Architects, Inc.
3-41
Quarters 227, Commanding Officers House, Schofield, c. 1931 Dining room with built-in cabinets, Commanding Officers House
Source: Mason Architects, Inc.
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-42
CHARACTER-DEFINING FEATURES OF CRAFTSMAN DESIGNS Exterior Features: Wood-framed hipped roof. Stone or concrete chimneys. Exposed rafter ends (no fascia board). Lava-rock front wall foundation with small arched openings. Lava rock piers and cheekwalls at steps. Board-and-batten single-wall construction (12-inch wide vertical boards with wide battens on the exterior). Pilasters with pendate or lattice detail. Bracket-supported roof extension with paired notched rafters over main entry. Wooden or concrete entry stairs with cheekwalls, typically lava rock with a concrete coping.
Plate rail with ornate brackets at dining room. China closets with star-patterned muntins at dining rooms. Original French doors between the lanai and living room. Five-panel and single-panel wood interior doors. Historic wood shelves or built-in cabinets in pantries.
Double-hung windows at Craftsman houses
Source: Mason Architects, Inc.
Double-hung windows. Diamond-patterned wood muntins or leaded glass in the living and dining room windows. Screens at entry lanai or in the hallways along the interior courtyard. Interior Features: Wood floors. Fireplaces. Board-and-batten interior wall and ceiling finish. Cased beams at living and dining room ceilings. Wall paneling at living and dining rooms. Ceiling moldings and baseboards. Picture moldings.
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
Chapter 3
Designs Similar to Craftsman Houses at Schofield Barracks
Fort Kamehameha
The Craftsman-style houses at Fort Kamehameha were completed 1916. There are two house plan types. The 30 buildings of the smaller house plan type are the same as the Schofield corner-entry design. The four larger houses, H-shaped in plan, have a central recessed main entry, four bedrooms, and two servants rooms with a separate bath. These are the same as the Schofield Commanding Officers house design (Quarters 227) at Schofield Barracks. These houses differ from the Schofield houses in that they do not have fireplaces.
3-43
ELEMENTS THAT DETRACT FROM HISTORIC CHARACTER Asphalt roof shingles (replaced original wood shingles). Jalousie and fixed windows. Window A/C units. Flush and modern-style doors. Modern hardware on doors and cabinets. Vinyl flooring or carpet. Over painting of woodwork. Painting of glass around star muntins on doors or cabinets. Modern kitchens and bathrooms.
S C H O F I E L D B A R R A C K S
Fort Shafter
The Hawaii Ordnance Depot was completed in 1917 on the south side of what was at that time Fort Shafter. The Depot was a separate entity until 1955, when it became part of Fort Shafter. Four Craftsman-style houses were constructed in 1917 to accommodate officers of the Ordnance Depot. The houses were built from two of the standard designs used at the other Oahu Army installations. They appear to have been the same as the Schofield center-entry five-bedroom design and the centerentry six-bedroom design. These houses were demolished in 1999.
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
smaller plan in the housing area between Leilehua and Dickman Roads, at the southeast end of Waianae Avenue. The Canby Mission-style housing area has 34 houses, constructed in rows adjacent to Canby Field, above Quad F. There are 22 houses in the area adjacent to Leilehua Road. The houses are constructed of concrete blocks covered with stucco. Originally constructed with flat roofs, hipped roofs were later added to deal with the local climate.
3-44
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
Chapter 3
3-45
is located between and is accessed by the two bedrooms. The bedroom along the street side of the house has two precast decorative concrete grills. The kitchen has a breakfast nook built-in with table and two bench seats. Beyond the kitchen is the service area with laundry and storeroom.
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-46
CHARACTER-DEFINING FEATURES OF MISSION DESIGNS Exterior Features: Wood-framed hipped roof. Open soffit. Shingle roofing. Louvered roof vent. Concrete block walls with rough plaster finish. Decorative concrete designs above main entry door or at front wall. Small sloped roof with clay tile over main entry. Battered wall at main entry at large Missionstyle houses. Angled wall at main entry at smaller Mission-style houses. Historic wood entry door with vertical scoring. Historic French-style door at kitchen entry. Historic screen doors. Deep-set windows. Steel lanai doors. Arched doorways. Historic door and window hardware.
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
Chapter 3
Interior Features: Acid-stained concrete floors. Wrought iron metal railings at entry lanai. Fireplaces with copper hood. Historic built-in cabinetry. Historic light fixtures. Historic bathroom tiles, cabinets, and fixtures. Plaster wall and ceiling finish. Wood baseboards and ceiling moldings. Wood panel doors. Historic door and window hardware. ELEMENTS THAT DETRACT FROM HISTORIC CHARACTER Jalousie and fixed windows. Window A/C units. Flush and modern-style doors. Modern hardware at historic doors and cabinets. Vinyl flooring or carpet. Over painting of woodwork. Modern kitchens and bathrooms.
3-47
S C H O F I E L D
B A R R A C K S
O F
I S T O R I C
H I M
S T O R I C I L I T A R Y
C O N T E F A M I L
X T Y
S H
T U D Y I N
O U S I N G
A W A I I
3-48