Gas Technology Institute Presentation
Gas Technology Institute Presentation
Gas Technology Institute Presentation
> How does California compare with elsewhere > Key points
Wobbe Number is key metric > Methane Number rarely used in industry Variations are common Rule 30 plus NGC + Work Group > Good foundation for natural gas quality standards
2
> Natural gas industry is interconnected to crude oil and natural gas liquids (NGL) marketplace
Wobbe Number
> Wobbe Number (or Wobbe Index) is a key metric for combustion performance
More meaningful than heating value WN = Heating Value (Specific Gravity)0.5 Accounts for flow and heat input of gas through an orifice
> Balance:
Non-methane hydrocarbons (e.g., ethane, propane) Other gases (e.g., carbon dioxide, nitrogen)
NonMethane Fraction
Ethane 3.6% Propane CO2 0.8% 1.0% Butanes+ 0.5% Nitrogen 1.8%
Based on survey data containing 7000 natural gas samples across 26 US cities
6
Average Natural Gas Composition -- Twenty Six US Cities (1989 1992 time period)
Rich Gases
Lean Gases
Maximum
98.1 13.3 2.6 2.1
N2 + CO2
0.0
2.6
2.5
10.0
Source: Gas Technology Institute
National: 26 cities, about 7000 samples California: 12 locations, about 1200 samples
8
970
1033
1035
1127
0.563
0.598
0.599
0.698
1201
1336
1337
1418
California Statistics
12 Sites, 1226 samples
SITE 1 METHANE (Vol.%) 93.92 94.33 95.53 96.64 94.94 93.10 93.73 HEATING VALUE (Btu/scf) 1033 995 1017 1011 1026 1039 1028 WOBBE NUMBER (Btu/scf) 1340 1301 1326 1336 1340 1341 1335
Lean Gases
2 3 4 5 6 7
93.60
92.25 91.19 93.48 92.34 Summary 93.09 90.31 96.88
1030
1040 1048 1029 1042 1035 986 1060
1335
1335 1337 1333 1340 1337 1290 1358
Rich Gases
10
CA In-State Production
Rich Natural Gas
> Select regions in state can have wider gas composition & properties range
Proximity to associated gas wellsresult in higher ethane levels Lack of regional market limits ability to economically lower ethane > Ethane removal expensive, energy losses
2001 - 2004 Data Methane Ethane Heating Value Specific Gravity Wobbe Number #1 86.9 9.0 1103 0.638 1381 11 #2 85.6 9.55 1107 0.647 1376 #3 84.1 10.3 1117 0.661 1374
130
Natural Gas
120 110 100 90 80 40 50 60 70 Methane Number 80 90 100
Gasoline
12
Panel 1 Summary
Current Gas Quality > Natural gas composition variations are common in California, US, and World
Support ample supplies from various sources In-state producersethane issue Future sources likely need composition limit leewayLNG, bio-energy, hydrogen
Panel 1 Summary
Current Gas Quality
> Current utility requirements (e.g., Rule 30) provides a very good framework
Already includes main interchangeability indices Also speak to pipeline-specific issues
> Ongoing NGC + Work Group developing consensus industry position on specific values and ranges
Draft recommendations in process
14