GEGN 401 - Mineral Deposits: Lecture 19 - Epithermal Au-Ag Deposits With Examples From Creede and Summitville, CO
GEGN 401 - Mineral Deposits: Lecture 19 - Epithermal Au-Ag Deposits With Examples From Creede and Summitville, CO
GEGN 401 - Mineral Deposits: Lecture 19 - Epithermal Au-Ag Deposits With Examples From Creede and Summitville, CO
Murray Hitzman
Epithermal Deposits
• Epithermal deposits
generally contain precious
metals (Ag, Au) with minor
to significant base metals
(Zn, Pb, Cu).
Murray Hitzman
Types of epithermal deposits
3 endmember types
• High sulfidation (HS) bodies: Cu-Au-As, sulfide (enargite) rich, hosted by acid-
leached zones with haloes of advanced argillic alteration in andesite arcs, over
porphyries
– Barren lithocaps: advanced argillic zones over porphyry systems, lack metals
Murray Hitzman
Depth of Formation of Epithermal Au-Ag Deposits
Ya
RMt
Vi To
HS IS LS
DEPOSIT TYPE
High sulfidation
High grade
– El Indio, Chile (El(DSO))
0.18Mt, 218 grams/ton
Au
– Hishikari, Japan (Hi) 5.2
Mt, 60 grams/ton Au
Low grade
– Round Mountain, Nevada
(RM) 196 Mt, 1.2
grams/ton Au
– Yanacocha, Peru (Ya)
nearly 1 Bt, 1.2 grams/ton
Au
Murray Hitzman
from Hedenquist et al., 2000, SEG Reviews, v. 13, p. 263
Epithermal Deposits -
Controls on Location of Mineralization
Epithermal deposits are
extremely variable in form,
from high-grade veins to
irregular zones of
disseminated or veinlet-
controlled mineralization.
There are three primary
controls for epithermal
deposits:
– Structural: Hydrothermal fluids
often flow along faults and are
concentrated in areas where faults
are wide, such as fault intersections
and fault bends (high grade) or in
stockwork zones (low grade).
– Hydrothermal: Explosion breccias
caused by overpressure (boiling) or
intrusion of magma to the near
surface provide permeable zones
for mineral precipitation.
– Lithological: Large variations in
permeability between rock units
may channel fluid flow and result in
zones of mineral precipitation.
from Sillitoe, 1993, Geol Assoc Canada Spec Paper 40. Murray Hitzman
Structural Controls for Epithermal Deposits
• Many epithermal deposits occur in veins.
• Many of these veins fill faults or fault-related fractures.
• Within fault systems the most probable location for deposits is in areas of increased
permeability:
– fault flexures (dilational rather than compressional jogs)
– fault intersections
– tension fractures (fault step-overs)
– splay zones (horsetails)
– imbricated fault zone (abundant dilational jogs and tension fractures)
Murray Hitzman
Types of Epithermal Deposits -
High Sulfidation Deposits
Murray Hitzman
Werner Giggenbach, geochemist, 1937-
1997
Murray Hitzman
(metals during sericite stage)
Murray Hitzman
Field Characteristics of High and Low Sulfidation
Epithermal Deposits
High Sulfidation Low (and Intermediate)
Sulfidation
Genetically related Andesite-rhyodacite Andesite - rhyolite
volcanic rocks
Trace metals Bi, Sb, Mo, Sn, Zn, Te, Mo, Sb, As, (Te, Se, Hg)
(Hg)
Murray Hitzman
Types of Epithermal Deposits -
Low Sulfidation Deposits
Murray Hitzman
Lithocap (± HS) settings only LS settings only
(steam-heated blanket possible) H2S + 2O2 = H2SO4
Steam-heated waters,
LS, IS, HS possible
(HCl, SO2)
Murray Hitzman
Low-sulfidation schematic model
Murray Hitzman
Field Characteristics of High and Low Sulfidation
Epithermal Deposits
High Sulfidation Low (and Intermediate)
Sulfidation
Genetically related Andesite-rhyodacite Andesite - rhyolite
volcanic rocks
Metals present Cu, Au, As (Ag, Pb) Au and/or Ag (Zn, Pb, Cu)
Trace metals Bi, Sb, Mo, Sn, Zn, Te, Mo, Sb, As, (Te, Se, Hg)
(Hg)
Murray Hitzman
Boiling - Key to Epithermal Deposits
• Most epithermal deposits contain
a variety of evidence for boiling
(mineralogy, fluid inclusion,
temperature patterns).
Murray Hitzman
Waiotapu (Sacred Waters), NZ
Murray Hitzman
Lewis-Crofoot, NV: LS veins, steam-heated overprint (falling water table)
(NB: remnant qtz veins + Au within overprinted zone)
Murray Hitzman
Quartz -
The Ubiquitous Mineral in Epithermal Deposits
Murray Hitzman
Murray Hitzman
Key Epithermal Minerals
• Adularia:
– a moderate to low-temperature mineral of the alkali feldspar group (KAlSi 3O8). Translucent to white, often with opalescence. Typically has a high
barium content. LS or IS deposits, in veins.
• Clays:
– Illite, interstratified illite-smectite, and smectite, forming alteration haloes around veins, indicating progressively lower temps (>200, 150-200, <150
C, respectively). All epithermal deposits.
• Kaolinite
– An aluminum silicate, indicating acid conditions, either within a steam-heated blanket, or as a halo to HS deposits.
• Alunite:
– Hydrothermal alteration product of feldspathic igneous rocks. KAl 3(SiO4)2(OH)6. Has a dull white to cream color - if yellow may have intermixed
jarosite, an ocher-yellow iron sulfate. KFe 3(SO4)2(OH)6. HS, or steam-heated blanket.
• Pyrophyllite:
– A white to grey hydrous alumino-silicate mineral which resembles talc. AlSi 2O5(OH). Roots of HS deposits, some IS veins.
• Barite:
– A white, yellow, or brown orthorhombic sulfate mineral which occurs in tabular crystals. Has a high specific gravity (4.5; i.e. it is heavy). BaSO 4.
IS veins, late in HS deposits.
• Calcite:
– CaCO3, either as a replacement of feldspar (eg in propylitic alteration) , or bladed, within LS veins due to boiling.
• Rhodochrosite:
– A rose-red to pink to grey rhombohedral mineral which is the manganese end-member of the carbonate group. MnCO 3. Commonly contains some
calcium and iron. IS veins with ore.
• Chalcedony:
– A cyrptocrystalline variety of quartz. It commonly forms concretionary masses with radial-fibrous and concentric structure. It is commonly
transluscent to semitransparent, has a wax-like luster, and ranges in color from white to pale blue to grey to black depending on impurities. It is
commonly microscopically fibrous and has a lower density and lower indices of refraction than quartz. LS veins, late in HS deposits.
• Enargite:
– A greyish black or black orthrhombic copper-arsenic mineral. Cu 3AsS4. It may also contain antimony, iron, and zinc. Is dimorphous with luzonite.
Luzonite is a grey isometric mineral, Cu 3AsS4, dimorphous with enargite. HS deposits.
• Tetrahedrite:
– Steel-grey to black isometric mineral (Cu,Fe) 12Sb4S13 which is isomorphous with tennantite (Cu,Fe)12As4S13 and commonly contains Zn, Pb, Ag, or
Hg. Commonly with sphalerite, ZnS. It is a significant ore of silver. IS veins, or late in HS deposits.
Murray Hitzman
Key Epithermal
Minerals
Murray Hitzman
Examples of Low (IS)
and High Sulfidation
Epithermal Systems in
Colorado
X
We will look at the Creede
system (low sulfidation) and Summitville
the infamous Summitville
system (high sulfidation)
Murray Hitzman
Creede, CO —
A Low Sulfidation
Precious Metals
Deposit
• The Creed Ag- (Au) district is located in
the San Juan Mountains of SW Colorado X
• It was a significant producer of silver
with subsidiary Au, Pb, and Zn. The
Ag:Au ratio is approximately 400 (i.e.
high silver to gold).
• The San Juan Mountains consist of
dominantly mid-Tertiary andesites
derived from stratovolcanic centers
which are overlain by a series of quartz
latitic to rhyolitic ash-flow sheets
erupted from at least 15 major calderas.
• The Creede district is located within the
Bachelor caldera which is itself located
between the younger San Luis and
Creede calderas. All of these calderas
erupted within a short interval between
27.6 and 26.5 m.y.
• The Creede ores are hosted by latitic to
rhyolitic ash flow tuffs infilling the
Bachelor caldera.
Long section projection of the OH vein and the southern portion of the Amethyst vein
from Hayba et al., 1985, SEG Reviews, v. 2, p. 139.
Murray Hitzman
Creede, CO
What is the Difference Between the Two Assemblages?
• The North assemblage has chlorite-hematite and chalcopyrite, the southern has
barite-rhodochrosite. Which is higher temperature?
Long section projection of the OH vein and the southern portion of the Amethyst vein
from Hayba et al., 1985, SEG Reviews, v. 2, p. 139.
Murray Hitzman
Creede, CO —
Direction of Fluid Flow
• Several indicators are
used to determine fluid
movement within the vein
system:
– Fluid inclusions in quartz and
barite indicate higher
temperatures and evidence of
boiling in the Northern (OH)
Assemblage.
– A well developed “clay cap”
of feldspar-destructive,
mixed-layer illite/smectite
(“sericite”) alteration occurs
above the Northern (OH)
Assemblage caused by
recondensation of acid-rich
steam derived by boiling of
the ore fluid. Direction of fluid movement
– Hydrothermal leaching of
minerals (barite, fluorite,
rhodochrosite) is more
intense at the northern end of
the OH vein. Hydrothermal
leaching indicates that the
solutions entering the ore
zone were, at times,
undersaturated with respect
to selected components. Direction of fluid movement
Murray Hitzman
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO — Geology
• The deposit is hosted in a quartz latite porphyry lava dome (South Mountain volcanic dome -
quartz latite) which was emplaced 22.8 m.y. ago at the intersection of the Summitville caldera
ring fracture and the Pass Creek- Elwood Creek - Platoro fault zone.
• The South Mountain quartz latite dome was intruded into the 29 m.y. old Summitville
Andesite which filled the Platoro caldera.
• The South Mountain quartz latite dome is overlain by the unaltered Cropsy Mountain Rhyolite
(20.2 m.y. old).
• Thus, mineralization is bracketed between 22.8 and 20.2 m.y. A date on hydrothermal alunite
gives 22.3 m.y. — shortly after dome emplacement.
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO — Orebody Geometry
• Orebodies are localized along the southwest margin of the coarsely porphyritic core of the
dome.
• The ore occurs as a series of irregular pipes and vein-like masses of quartz-alunite formed by
replacement of the latite.
• Significant mineralization is confined to a vertical interval of approximately 400m and the
surface outcrop of the altered and mineralized area is an ellipse.
Murray Hitzman
after Gray and Coolbaugh, 1994, by Arribas, 1995
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO — Wallrock Alteration
• Alteration displays a well defined vertical
and lateral pattern from:
– An inner zone of vuggy silica alteration
interpreted to be the result of acid
dissolution of all the primary rock forming
minerals except quartz. Most of the ore
occurs in this very permeable zone
(permeability due to the holes left by the
dissolved phenocyrsts). The vuggy silica
zone thins downward becoming extremely
thin (a narrow vein) below 300m below the
present surface. Rare fluid inclusions
indicate this alteration occurred at
temperatures between 230° - 300°C; there is
no evidence of boiling at this level.
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO — Wallrock Alteration
• Alteration displays a well defined lateral pattern from the inner quartz-alunite zone to clay
zones that are zoned outward from:
– Inner illite-kaolinite zone
– Intermediate montmorillonite zone
– Outer chlorite zone (not always present)
Note that kaolinite is present throughout the clay zone but decreases in abundance outward.
• Rock in the inner quartz-alunite zone is hard and brittle and forms prominent outcrops,
rock in the clay alteration zones is soft and incompetent and weathers easily.
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO: vuggy qtz with sharp alunite halo
Murray Hitzman
Summitville, CO — Mineralization
• Field evidence such as the presence of ore minerals in cross-cutting
fractures and in voids in vuggy silica indicate that mineralization post-
dated most of the advanced argillic alteration.
Murray Hitzman
High and Low Sulfidation Epithermal Deposits
• Low Sulfidation deposits:
– The ore zone commonly occurs at distances of several kilometers
from the heat source that drove hydrothermal circulation. The
ores occupy a narrow vertical range, the top of which lies at
distances of 200 - 600 m below the paleo-water table.
– The ores appear to have been deposited at, or close to, the
interface between a deeply circulating, hydrothermal fluid
(moderately saline to saline) and overlying groundwater.
– In the upper portion of this system, fluid flow is commonly lateral
and discharge to the surface may be minimal and confined to a
small fraction of the total projected surface area of the system.
– Either lithologic aquitards or gravity-driven groundwater flow form
hydrologic caps on the hydrothermal plume; structures above this
level are barren of mineralization and often display no evidence of
vein filling or wallrock alteration.
– The waters making up the hydrothermal fluid are predominantly of
meteoric origin, though some magmatic contribution cannot be
ruled out.
– Boiling occurs in the upper portion of the hydrothermal plume,
and mixing with surrounding ground waters occurs along the
sides and top of the plume. The depth of boiling is dependent on Low
the salinity and gas content of the hydrothermal fluid as well as sulfidation
the structural regime (pressure constraints). The degree of fluid
mixing is dependent on the density contrasts between the
hydrothermal plume and the surrounding groundwater.
– Both boiling and fluid mixing lead to the precipitation of ore and
gangue minerals.
– The acid required to produce sericitic alteration associated with
the deposits is produced by the condensation, in the upper part of
the system, of acid volatiles produced by boiling of the
hydrothermal fluid.
Murray Hitzman
High and Low Sulfidation Epithermal Deposits
High
Sulfidation
• High Sulfidation deposits
– These deposits commonly display a direct
temporal and spatial association with recently
active volcanic domes.
Murray Hitzman
High and Intermediate Sulfidation Epithermal Deposits
Murray Hitzman
Low Sulfidation Epithermal Deposits
Murray Hitzman
Volcanic-Hosted Epithermal Deposits-
Important Question to Ask for Exploration or Production
• What are the age of the host rocks? They should be young (<30 m.y.)
• What kind of system is it? High or low sulfidation. Has the alteration zoning
been worked out?
• What kind of grades have they encountered? High grade or low. If high, are
they targeting a small, structurally controlled deposit? If low, do they expect
high grade veins? If so why? Or is the target a bulk tonnage, low grade
deposit?
• Is the structure in the deposit understood well enough to reasonably target
drill holes?
• Is the exposure being investigated near the top of the system (a large tonnage
below) or structurally deeper so that grade will disappear soon with depth?
• Are there hydrothermal breccias or lithologic contacts that would control
permeability?
• Have geophysical models been developed to take into account silicification
(high resistivity) and clay alteration (low resistivity)?
• What is the metallurgy of the deposit? Is the gold encapsulated in silica? Are
there complex, gold-bearing sulfides?
• If high sulfidation deposit, has work been undertaken to mitigate
environmental impacts - acid mine drainage?
Murray Hitzman
Characteristics of LS deposits
Steam-heated blanket
in vadose zone Sinter
Murray Hitzman