States Role in Capitalist and Scialist
States Role in Capitalist and Scialist
States Role in Capitalist and Scialist
Definition of capitalism
Capitalism is defined as an economic system in which the means of
production and industry are owned and controlled by the private
individuals or corporations for profit also know as free market economy
or laisser-faire economy.
Under this political system, there is minimal government interference in
the financial affairs, the key elements of a capitalistic economy are
private property, the salient features of capitalism are as under:
• Factors of production are under private ownership. They can use it in a
manner they think fit, although the government can put some
restrictions for public welfare
• There is freedom of enterprise, i.e. every individual is free to engage in
the economic activity of his choice
• The gaps between haves and have-nots are wider due unequal
distribution of income
• Consumer sovereignty exists in the economy, i.e. producers produce
only goods that are wanted by the customers
• Extreme competition exists in the market between firms which uses
tools like advertisement and discounts to call customers attention
• The profit motive is the key component; that encourage people to
work hard and earn wealth
Definitions of Socialism
Socialist economy is defined as an economy in which the resources are
owned, managed and regulated by the state, the central idea of this
kind of economy is that all the people have similar rights and in this
way each and every person can reap the fruits of planned production
As the resources are allocated, in the direction of the centralized
authority that is why it is also termed as command economy or
centrally planned economy..
Under this system, the role of the market forces is negligible in deciding
the allocation of factors of production and the price f the product.
Public welfare is the fundamental objective of production and
distribution of products and services.
The following are the salient features of socialism:
• In socialist economy, collective ownership exists in the means of
production that is why the resources are aimed to utilize for attaining
socioeconomic goals
• Central planning authority exists for setting the socioeconomic
objectives in the economy, moreover the decisions belonging to the
objectives are also taken by the authority only
• There is an equal distribution of income to bridge the gap between
the rich and poor,
• People have right to work, they cannot go for the occupation of their
choice as the occupation is determined only by the authority
• As there is planned production, consumer sovereignty has no place
• The market forces do not determine the price of commodities due to
the lack of competition and absence of profit motive
Key differences between Capitalism and socialism
the following are the major differences between socialism and capitalist
• The basis of capitalism is the principle of individual rights. Whereas
socialism is based on the principle of equality
• Capitalism encourages innovation and individual rights whereas
socialism promotes equality and fairness
• in the socialist economy, the resources are state-owned.but in the case
of capitalist economy the means of production are privately owned
• in capitalism, the prices are determined by the market forces and
therefore the firms can exercise monopoly power by charging higher
prices conversely in socialism government decides the rates of any
product which leads to shortages
• In capitalism, the competition between firms is very close, whereas in
socialism there is no competition because the government controls the
market
• In capitalism there is a large gap between rich classes and poor
classes because of unequal distribution of wealth. As opposed to
socialism where there is no such a gap
• in capitalism, every individual works for own capital accumulation,
but in socialism the wealth is shared by all people equally
• In capitalism, the efficiency is higher as compared to socialism
because of the profit incentive that encourages the firm to produce
such products that are highly demanded by the customers, whereas
in socialism, there is lack of motivation to earn money which leads to
inefficiency.
Capitalism and socialism differ in terms of
• Ownership
• Equity
• Efficiency and
• employment
Classical perspectives on capitalism
Smith and Ricardo
One of the key authors who wrote about capitalism is Adam Smith, though
he did not use word capitalism per se, smith devised set of concept that
remains strongly associated with the capitalism today
The invisible hand
• The core of smith’s thesis was that human’s natural tendency towards
self interest results in prosperity
• Smith argued that by giving everyone freedom to produce and exchange
goods as they pleased (free trade) and opening the market up for
domestic and foreign competition, people’s natural self interest would
promote greater prosperity than with strict government regulations
• Smith believed that humans ultimately promote public interest through
their every day economic choices. The free market economy become
known as invisible hand, but it need support to bring about its magic
Elements of prosperity according to Smith
• Smith believed that nations needed the following
three elements to bring about universal prosperity
1. Enlightened self-interest
Smith wanted people to practice thrift (quality of using money and
other resources carefully), hard work, and enlightened self-interest.
He thought the practice of enlightened self-interest was natural for
majority of the people
He gave an example: a butcher does not supply meat based on good
heartened intentions, but because he profits by selling meat, if the
meat he sells is poor he will not have repeat customers and thus not
profit. Therefore it is in the butchers self-interest to sell good meat at
a price that customers are willing to pay so that parties benefit in
every day transaction.
2. Limited Government
Smith saw the responsibilities of the government being
limited to the defence of the union, universal education,
public works (infrastructure such as roads and bridges), the
enforcement of legal rights (property rights and contracts)
and the punishment of crime. the government would step
in when people acted on their short-term interests, and
would make and enforce laws against robbery fraud and
other similar crimes
3. Solid currency and free market: The third element smith
proposed was solid currency twinned with free market
principles. By backing currency with hard metals smith hoped
would curtail the governments ability depreciate currency by
circulating more of it to pay for war or other wasteful
expenditure,
• with hard currency acting as a check to spending, smith wanted the
government to follow free market principles by keeping taxes low and
allowing free trade across borders by eliminating tarrifs. He pointed
out that tariffs and other taxes only succeeded in making life more
expensive for the people while also stifling industry and trade
abroad.
Ricardo Perspective on capitalism
• He developed the law of comparative advantage, which aimed to
explain why it is profitable to parties to trade even if one of the two
partners is more efficient in every type of economic production
• He argued that a country boosts its economic growth by focusing on the
industry in which it has the largest comparative advantage.
• For example, Somalia was able to manufacture cheap milk, and Ethiopia
can produce cheap coffee, Somalia would stop producing coffee and
Ethiopia would stop producing milk.
• the theory of comparative advantage become the bases of free trade,
he argued that specialization and free benefit all partners
Absolute advantage and Comparative advantage
A country has an absolute advantage in producing goods over another
country if it uses a fewer resources to produce that good. Absolute
advantage can be the result of country’s natural endowment. For
example, extracting oil in Saudi Arabia is pretty much just a matter of
drilling a hole while USA has one of the largest farmland around the
world, they can produce easily corn or wheat
• Comparative advantage when a good can be produced at lower cost
in terms of other goods
• An example: imagine a world where there are only two countries
Saudi Arabia and United States, and two products OIL and corn,
assume that consumers of both countries desire both goods
• there are available resources to both countries: labour hours. Suadi
Arabia can produce oil with fewer resources and US can produce with
fewer resources
COUNTRY OIL (hours per barrel) Corn (hours per bushel)
Saudi Arabia 1 4
USA 2 1
Production possibilities before trade
Introduction
Governments control the money supply to ensure the stability
of money markets, The money market is the market for
money where the amount supplied and the amount
demanded meet to determine the nominal interest rate.
Governments has several ways to control money supply,
broadly they can be divided into two
1. Monetary policy
2. fiscal policy
Definition: monetary policy is the macroeconomic policy laid
down by the central bank. It involves management of
money supply and interest rate and is demand side
Goals of Monetary policy
Central banks have a number of goals when setting the monetary policy of
the country, the following five goals are main aim of monetary policy.
1. Price stability: inflation or rising prices erode the value of money, if prices
rise it will make households to decide how much to spend and save, firms
acing uncertain future will hesitate to enter into long term contracts.
Thus central banks attempt to lower prices
2. High employment
3. Economic growth: With high employment, businesses are likely to be
more confident that demand for their products will remain strong, and so
will be willing to engage in the long-term investment necessary for
growth.
4. Financial market stability: When financial markets and institutions
are not efficient in matching savers and borrowers, the economy
loses resources. Firms with the potential to produce high-quality
products and services cannot obtain the financing they need to
design, develop, and market these products and services.
5. Foreign exchange market stability
Tools of monetary policy
There are number of tools that central banks use to control supply of
money. These include
1. Open market operations: are the buying and selling the central bank
treasury bills and bonds. The Fed can decrease the federal funds rate by
increasing the supply of bank reserves, and it can increase the federal
funds rate by decreasing the supply of bank reserves. When the bank
want to decrease bank reserves it engages open market sale, when it
wants to increase bank reserves it engages an open market purchase.
It the central bank want to increase the money supply in the market, it
will sell its securities to public or other banks, if want s to reduce the
money in the market it can purchase government bills and bonds
2. discount rate (The interest rate the Fed charges on discount loans)
The discount rate is the interest rate paid by member banks when they
borrow at the Federal Reserve District Bank. If the central bank want to
increase money supply, it will reduce interest rates allowing banks to
barrow more money, thus increasing the money in the market.
If the central bank want to reduce money supply, it engages in increasing
interest rate, thus making difficult for commercial banks to barrow money
form central banks.
3. Federal reserve requirement: The Federal Reserve requires that banks hold a
certain percentage of their checking account deposits as either vault cash—
currency held in the bank—or as deposits with the
Fed.
• Banks that have reserves above the required levels are free to loan them to
households and firms or invest them in Treasury bills or other securities
• Reserve requirements provide the Fed with a monetary policy tool because
raising the required reserve ratio, or the percentage of checking account
deposits that must be held as reserves, reduces the ability of banks to make
loans and other investments. Lowering the required reserve ratio increases
the ability of banks to make loans and other investments
The limitations of monetary policy
1. Policy lags: In practice, the Fed is not instantly aware that a demand
shock or supply shock has occurred that is large enough to cause a
recession or to cause inflation to accelerate. Even after the Fed
becomes aware that a demand shock or supply shock has occurred, it
takes time to decide on an appropriate change in policy. Then it takes
time for the new policy to actually affect real GDP, employment, and
inflation
2. economic forecasts are not reliable: economists use economic
models to predict the performance of the economy but it is proved
these models cannot be relied
3. Moral Hazards: Moral hazard The risk that people will take actions
after they have entered into a transaction that will make the other
party worse off. The central bank is likely to intervene a collapsing
firm if that firm is Too-big-to-fail policy; A policy in which the federal
government does not allow large financial firms to fail for fear of
damaging the financial system. Monetary policy cannot moral hazard
Fiscal Policy: Fiscal policy refers to changes the federal
government makes in taxes, purchases of goods and
services, and transfer payments that are intended to
achieve macroeconomic policy objectives.
Tools of fiscal policy:
The two main tools of fiscal policy are taxes and spending.
Taxes influence the economy by determining how much
money the government has to spend in certain areas and
how much money individuals has to spend for
Spending is used as a tool for fiscal policy to drive government
money to certain sectors that need an economic boost.
Whoever receives those dollars will have extra money to
spend on goods and services
Example of three fiscal effecting the real GDP
1. Government Purchases: government purchases goods, such as
computers for government offices, aircraft carriers, and services.
Holding everything else constant, an increase in government
purchases (G), will increase aggregate expenditure(AE). The increase
in aggregate expenditure means that firms sell more goods and
services, which leads them to expand production, increasing real
GDP.
• An increase in government purchases : an increase in aggregate
expenditure : an increase in real GDP and employment
2. taxes: Governments obtain tax revenue from many different sources.
Such as personal income tax, VAT, sales tax, corporate tax etc Changes
in taxes affect the consumption and investment components of
aggregate expenditure.
Taxes affect the GDP in many ways
• Consumption side: taxes on consumption such as sales taxes or a VAT
affect consumption. An increase in these taxes makes goods and
services more expensive by raising prices, so households reduce their
consumption. Thus
• An increase in consumption taxes : an increase in prices of
consumption goods : a decrease in consumption : a decrease in
aggregate expenditure : a decrease in real GDP and employment.
• Income side: taxes on personal income tax increases or
decreases disposable income. Households can do one of two
things with their disposable income: They can either spend it on
goods and services, such as clothes and vacations, or they can
save it.
• A decrease in the tax rate on personal income: an increase in
disposable income : an increase in consumption : an increase in
aggregate expenditure : an increase in real GDP and
employment.
• Investment: An increase in corporate income taxes: a decrease in the
after-tax profitability of investment projects : a decrease in
investment : a decrease in aggregate expenditure : a decrease in real
GDP and employment.
3. Transfer payment: A transfer payment is a payment to one person
that is funded by taxing others. Food stamps, welfare benefits, and
unemployment benefits are all government transfer payments thus
An increase in transfer payments : an increase in disposable income : an
increase in consumption : an increase in aggregate expenditure : an
increase in real GDP and employment.
Types of fiscal policy
They are two types of fiscal policy: expansionary and contractionary
Expansionary is used at times of recession, high unemployment, it means
the government spending more money or lower taxes or both, the aim
is to put more money into the hands of customers as they spend goods
and services
Contractionary fiscal policy is used to slow down economic growth, such
as when inflation is growing too rapidly, it raises taxes and cut
spending.
Four major functions of fiscal policy
1. Allocation function: fiscal policy plays the role of allocation function,
the government should determine how funds will be allocated to the
provision of social goods, this relates the collection of taxes and
spending.
2. distribution: adjustment of the distribution of income and wealth to
assure conformance with what society considers a fair or just society
state of distribution of income. Taxes play an important role in
reducing inequality
Stabilization: Fiscal policy is needed for stabilization since full
employment and price stability does not come
automatically, the overall level of employment and prices
depend upon the level of aggregate demand, government
expenditure add to the total demand while taxes reduce.
Economic growth: fiscal policy may affect the rate of saving
and the willingness to invest and therefore may influence
the rate of capital accumulation.
Government and Re-distribution