3 Risks and Excesses in The Media Profession

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 25

Risks and

Excesses in the
Media Profession
Communication Media
Law and Ethics
Philip Aries B. Montemayor
April 23, 2022
Risks
In 2009, the Philippines
topped the list of countries
with the most number of
journalists killed, followed by
Mexico, Somalia, and Russia.
The Brussels-based
International News Safety
(INSI), a global media group,
reported that during the year,
a total of 132 journalists were
killed.
Risks
Included in the 2009
report, death total were the 32
local journalists killed on
November 23, 2009 in a
politically motivated massacre
of 57 people in Maguindanao in
Central Mindanao.
Risks
But the figure in 2009 was
well below the worst in recent
years. In 2007, a record of 172
journalists died and 168 were
killed in 2006 when media
deaths in Iraq were high
following the 2003 US-led
invasion and amid sectarian
fighting in the country.
Risks
In the INSI list for 2009,
Mexico was next with 11 killed ,
mostly in drug-related rub-outs,
followed by Somalia and Russia
with nine each. In 2009, Iraq
had only five deaths, the
lowest since US invasion.
For five years after 2003,
Iraq was the most dangerous
country in the world for
journalists.
Risks
Philippines as the
“deadliest country” for
journalists in 2009 -
International Press Institute

Philippines as the ‘most


deadly country’ for journalists
to practice their profession -
Reporters Sans Frontieres
(Reporters Without Frontiers)
Risks
Reporters Sans Frontieres
(Reporters Without Frontiers)
has reported that in 1987, out
of the 24 journalists killed
worldwide, nine were from the
Philippines; in 1988, out of 24
killed five were Filipinos; in
1990, out of the world total of
36, seven were from this
country.
Culture of Impunity

The IPI linked the killing of


journalists in the Philippines to
“the impunity that the killers
enjoy in the country.” It urged
[then] President Benigno S.
Aquino to tackle the issue of
impunity in the murder of
journalists and to prosecute
them.
Culture of Impunity

A total of 104-media
people have been killed in the
nine years of the Macapagal-
Arroyo presidency, and 140
altogether since democracy
was restored in the Philippines
in 1986.
Culture of Impunity

Earlier, the New York-based


Committee to Protect
Journalists (CPJ) has named the
Philippines as one of the most
hazardous spots to cover
during the last three years
ending in 1990. In 1990 alone,
seven local journalists were
killed. This record has
surpassed the killings in four
years of the Cory Aquino…
Culture of Impunity

Administration (Feb. 23, 1986 –


Feb. 23, 1990), which showed
an average of six a year, and is
higher than the average of 2.3
killings during the 14 years of
Marcos rule with a total of 32
killings.
Culture of Impunity

Most of the Filipino


journalists killed belonged to
the media in the provinces
where public criticisms are
usually taken as personal
attacks and where politicians
rule like “little barons.”
Culture of Impunity

Aggrieved parties in the


provinces seldom resort to
legal remedies, such as filing
libel complaints, in seeking
redress of grievances. They
even the score by getting the
services of guns-for-hire to
eliminate their tormentors in
the media.
Culture of Impunity

Aggrieved parties in the


provinces seldom resort to
legal remedies, such as filing
libel complaints, in seeking
redress of grievances. They
even the score by getting the
services of guns-for-hire to
eliminate their tormentors in
the media.
Excesses
Media’s shortcomings and excesses:
Shooting from the hip
Abuse of source-based stories
Resorting to “poetic license”
Imagined or manufactured
stories
Conflict of interest
Misquotation
Labeling
Excesses
Shooting from the hip
This is the penchant of some
columnists to write something
without first checking the facts
or veracity of the report. These
columnists often seek refuge
under the doctrine of fair
comment, although the intention
is to malign other people.
Excesses
Abuse of source-based
stories
Some reporters concoct stories
to suit to their pre-conceived ideas
or slant on how a news should be
written by attributing them to
anonymous sources, like “an
observer,” “an analysts,” or “an
official who requested for
anonymity.” This practice is not
only unethical but is a downright
Excesses
Resorting to “poetic
license”
Poetic license, or the freedom
of the poets and other artists to
deviate from the accepted
practices and norms for the sake of
art, is sometimes being confused
with writing factually. Journalism is
the record of unfolding events; it
should not be equated with fiction
or literary forms.
Excesses
Resorting to “poetic
license”
Late columnist Luis Beltran
realized this a little late, after the
Pres. Cory Aquino filed a libel
suit against him for writing in his
column (in Philippine Daily Star)
that at the height of August
1987 coup attempt, Pres. Aquino
“hid under her bed” in her
Arlegui residence.
Excesses
Imagined or manufactured
story
The most famous or
infamous example was the
sensational account entitled
“Jimmy’s World,” a story about
an eight-years old heroin addict
which won for the author, Janet
Cooke and the Washington Post,
the Pulitzer Prize for enterprise
reporting in 1981.
Excesses
Imagined or manufactured
story
Cooke later on was caught
lying and forced to admit that
Jimmy was fictitious and all
accounts that she had written
about him were fabricated.
Because of this, she was fired
from her job and the paper
forced to return the Pulitzer
Prize.
Excesses
Conflict of interest
Media practitioners, who are
expected to champion the people’s
cause, should have no other
interest than to serve the public.
But this doesn’t happen most of the
time. Some do moonlighting in the
media since they are consultants or
even officials of certain offices
whose interests run counter to
those of the public.
Excesses
Misquotation

Oftentimes, officials or news


personalities complain that they
have been misquoted by
reporters. Racing against the
deadline, this inevitably happens.
But most officials do not really
bother about this for as long as
the facts are not twisted and the
reports do not harm their
reputation or honor.
Excesses
Labeling

This is the habit of journalists


to put a label or tag on persons or
organization. The Kilusang Mayo
Uno (KMU) labor movement is
often tagged as “leftist” or
“communist.” Labeling is
dangerous because it is often a
generalization and may not truly
represent the true nature of a
certain person or group.
REFERENCE
Malinao, Alito L. Handbook on
Basic Media Laws and Ethics
(First Edition). Philippines:
National Book Store (2011).

You might also like