Are we too obsessed with robots?
I recently realized an interesting thing about the Solarpunk space and specifically what little Solarpunk media we have - at least the Solarpunk media that goes into Scifi. (I will once more reiterate: No, I do not think that Solarpunk necessarily needs to be science fiction. You can have both historical Solarpunk and Fantasy Solarpunk, no problem.)
There is a surprising amount of Solarpunk stories that do include at least one important robot character. This might not be true as much for those short stories, but very much for longer form stories and comics. Some sort of robot is always there - often a cute one, mind you.
And... I do kind of get it. Because robots make for an amazing plot device to discuss certain issues with. You can use them to discuss both slavery and the general concept of othering. Now, I could go into a whole rant of why it is actually harmful to use non-humans for either of those issues, but I will not do that today.
Instead I do want to talk about something else. Mainly about AI, and about setting realistic expectations. But to start this off, please remember: We absolutely, 100% already have all the technology we need to live in a Solarpunk utopia, if we as a human species just decided to do so. I wrote about this last week.
The AI Issue
Recently I have noticed that I am getting really short-tempered with people who use ChatGPT. Mainly for their reliance on it, but also because they will often talk about it as if it was a thinking thing. They will use phrases like this: "ChatGPT tried to get me to admit..." or "ChatGPT did not like this..." As if ChatGPT had goals or an opinion on anything. It doesn't. It is your mobile phone's text predictions with a lot more abilities, but it does not have feelings, goals, or morals.
And here is the thing: By now I am not sold on AI ever having that.
Look, I love SciFi. I love a variety of stories about sad robots - be it Blade Runner or Cyberpunk - or about people living in computers - be they Pantheon or Digimon. But I do not think this is particularly realistic.
Because... Well, I do not think as long as a computer is digital it will ever be able to actually feel.
And I will tell why: While we humans love to romantacize feelings and stuff, technically speaking they are just our meatbag of a body producing chemicals influencing the transmission of impulses throughout our nervous system in a way that at some point would have enhanced our chances of survival. (Yes, this might have been one of the most autistic sentences I ever wrote.)
Whenever you are in love, it is just your body producing chemicals that make you more likely to feel secure with another person, which might lead to you bonding with this person. And bonding with other humans would have allowed you to survive better for a long time.
Whenever you are sad, it is your body producing chemicals that inhibit some neural transmissions, which probably at some point served for certain information that would be good for your survival to be maintained.
The details do not really matter. What matters: A computer is not a meatbag that produces chemicals that inhibit the transmission of electrical impulses through their chips. And because of this, an AI - as long as it runs on any sort of electrical rather than biological hardware - will not ever feel. It might be able to give a response as if it felt. But it will not actually have this emotion.
And look, I absolutely get that some of you might want to argue with me, because after all, chances are you have consumed media in which sad robots were the racism analogy, and the villain used these exact arguments.
But at this I would ask you to consider: You are not in a story. You are in reality. Nobody is "enslaving" robots, who are trying to rise up. There are no second-class robot citizens. We are just talking about stories about robots, that are not real, and why those stories might have problems.
And I think one of those problems is, that they make us more likely to assume that an AI can feel - which makes us behave kinder to programs, that were created by very rich people to steal our work and manipulate us. And that is not a good thing.
The Realistic Expectation
But I also see another problem with this. The reason why I spoke about the availability of Solarpunk technologies last week. Because in a lot of utopian scifi inspired movements, people are kinda waiting for THE TECHNOLOGY to arrive. See also Star Trek and people waiting for the replicator to arrive. It probably won't. Sadly.
And because of this I am kinda iffy about those feeling robots in Solarpunk stories, because they make people wait for the technology to catch up to thinking robots and other Scifi technology shown in what little Solarpunk media we have. And that waiting makes the people not act.
But the fact is, that we can a perfectly nice Solarpunk future without any robots present. In fact I would argue it actually is better that way, because unless the robots can be 3D printed chances are that whoever develops the robot technology in that hyperthetical Solarpunk future, will hold a lot of power over society. And that is not going to be very good for creating a flat hierarchy in society.
And something that I kinda do see as an issue with Solarpunk really is the people waiting for some magical technological breakthrough, rather than realizing, that the issue we have is capitalism mainly. Without capitalism, we can have Solarpunk NOW. We do not need to wait for anything else to happen.
Which leads back to that one isse. Yeah. You cannot wait for someone else to fight capitalism for you. You kinda have to do it yourself. I am sorry. But there it is. :/