Avatar

MagicwithClass

@magicwithclass / magicwithclass.tumblr.com

I pick the brain of Mark Rosewater or Maro in all things Magic the Gathering. I also document, discuss, and speculate on the reserved list and record the history of the game through changes and talks on this policy. Please reblog so that the history of the game can be preserved and to drive discussion of obscure, bulk reserved list cards. Thank you for contributing to the mtg community. He/Him

Reserved List

There are over 500 Magic the Gathering cards on the reserved list. This list is a promise to never reprint these cards in paper which means, that for these cards, the copies that exist are the only copies that will ever exist. The reserved list only comprises of sets from before the year 2000 so most reserve list cards are 25 years old minimum. You would think that the cards on the reserve list would all be astronomically high but very few are over a dollar. Many feel that the reserved list will eventually be rescinded but the failure of the 30th anniversary edition cards makes this seem unlikely especially in the modern era. It seems like a lot of money is in newer Magic cards especially with the advent of serialized Magic cards. Now may be the time to move in to bulk Magic the Gathering reserved list cards. Every year the number of reserve list cards in circulation dwindle. Cards get lost or destroyed or they enter vaults never to see circulation ever again due to investors and speculators. At the moment, old school Magic seems to be at an all time low so this might be time to move in to reserve list cards. I recently purchased a couple hundred reserved list cards in various conditions and over the next couple of weeks I will post them online and explain the logic behind my purchase. Am I simply wasting money buying bulk that will never rise above a buck? Am I a fool for diversifying my purchases instead of focusing on one specific reserved list card and attempting to buy it out? Only time will tell. However, I really do have a love and a passion for the cards and it makes me feel a part of the community to have a piece of magic history in my hands. It is an interesting feeling to own something where there are only a certain number of copies on earth. Isn't this the appeal of serial numbered cards? Are serialized cards just a modern day reserved list for a new era? After all, most of the cards on the reserved list are cheap for a reason. They are simply unplayable in the modern magic the gathering era in almost all formats. Most serialized cards are chosen because they see play and are highly sought after cards. Any cards seeing a lot of play on the reserved list are already astronomically expensive so what is the point? Well, no one can see the future and some cards that were completely unplayable just need the right card printed to become all stars. The only question is which cards will reach that echelon. Yes, I have some opinions on which cards are more likely to see possible play in the future but you never know. That is why I want to diversify my assets. Should a reserve list card below one dollar spike card I will likely have many copies of it in my collection. Should all cards on the reserve list eventually spike as people realize that once all copies are gone they are gone and the cards aren't getting any younger then I will have simply made a profit. Even now, I do think there are cards on the reserve list that are criminally undervalued. I also believe that one day a card will spike on the reserve list that no one will predict. I am going to show the reserve list cards I bought this month although I have been buying reserved list cards for years.

Anonymous asked:

ohhhh never mind , I get it. You're a conspiracy theorist with an interest in MTG. You don't let things like "facts" or "looking for more information than merely whatever confirms your bias" get in the way of good old fashioned outrage.

I am happy that I am having such an impact on the community that people show such strong reactions to my questions and writings. It makes me feel heard and seen and that my ideas generate thoughts and opinions even if they differ from my own. Thanks for your question. Please feel free to send me questions at any time.

Anonymous asked:

Guess who failed to live up to their username today?

I am assuming this is in reference to my misunderstanding of the change to boxes starting in aetherdrift. I was actually very happy to be wrong. I thought that the price of booster boxes was staying the same but the number of packs was being reduced to 30. This is not true. The price of boxes will now be lower to compensate for less packs. I was suspicious. I thought this was a scheme to sneakily raise prices by using a smokescreen. I was incorrect.

There is a rumor going around that wotc and the commander rules committee are in cahoots and are colluding. Perhaps WOTC is trying to fracture he commander community in order to take over the format and make it an official Magic the Gathering format run internally. I think they are doing this to prepare for the official launch of commander on mtg arena during holiday 2025. Is this 4 person commander or 1 v 1? This is unclear but the rumor is that commander on arena will release to coincide with the marvel set.

The RC members are beloved between casuals and are strongly integrated with the creator scene. The biggest commander content creators the command zone has 2 members of the cag in it.

It would be really weird if wizards wants to do that. I think this is simply a warning shot from the RC on the kind of cards they don't want to see printed into the format. Also Nadu sucks to play against.

I don't think it is anything more than that. However I could be completely wrong as well and you completely right. Only time can tell us

Didn't one of the members of the command zone literally just resign as a member of the commander rules committee? Timing seems coincidental and I do not believe in coincidence.

Wait they were in the rules committee? I recall josh and Rachel being in the cag not the RC. I could be wrong. My brain is fried by the exams.

Anyway, the human mind is great at noticing patterns and events and even action we take and retroactively justifying them. Even if a member left the RC that could mean so much stuff, from lack of time, hating the pressure etc that it would be impossible to deduce correctly the reason just from their action. I wouldn't read too much into this yet.

It would be a great shame if the RC dies or gets integrated into wizards. Those bans would never have happened by wizards. They killed 3 chase mythics in 3 lines. Wotc would never. Some may not like the bans, from gameplay perspective to financial perspective, but we all have to admit this was a move against wotc. Maybe a bit too little too late. We will have to see.

JLK was in the CAG, not the Rules Committee.

The latest command zone episode airs this out extensively.

Do you believe me now? That being said please do not threaten people for making decisions about a card game. It was not ok that the rules committee was threatened. That made me sad to hear. Even so, I do not think the rules committee would have been around for much longer anyway. The bracket system shows that they are already thinking about how to implement commander on arena. There will be 4 brackets with cedh being the most powerful bracket. The bans were meant to remove those 4 cards from even the most cedh of brackets on arena. There may be a few more bans now that wizards is in control but not many more. The bracket system will effectively regulate commander play on arena and maybe also in paper.

There is a rumor going around that wotc and the commander rules committee are in cahoots and are colluding. Perhaps WOTC is trying to fracture he commander community in order to take over the format and make it an official Magic the Gathering format run internally. I think they are doing this to prepare for the official launch of commander on mtg arena during holiday 2025. Is this 4 person commander or 1 v 1? This is unclear but the rumor is that commander on arena will release to coincide with the marvel set.

The RC members are beloved between casuals and are strongly integrated with the creator scene. The biggest commander content creators the command zone has 2 members of the cag in it.

It would be really weird if wizards wants to do that. I think this is simply a warning shot from the RC on the kind of cards they don't want to see printed into the format. Also Nadu sucks to play against.

I don't think it is anything more than that. However I could be completely wrong as well and you completely right. Only time can tell us

Didn't one of the members of the command zone literally just resign as a member of the commander rules committee? Timing seems coincidental and I do not believe in coincidence.

Wait they were in the rules committee? I recall josh and Rachel being in the cag not the RC. I could be wrong. My brain is fried by the exams.

Anyway, the human mind is great at noticing patterns and events and even action we take and retroactively justifying them. Even if a member left the RC that could mean so much stuff, from lack of time, hating the pressure etc that it would be impossible to deduce correctly the reason just from their action. I wouldn't read too much into this yet.

It would be a great shame if the RC dies or gets integrated into wizards. Those bans would never have happened by wizards. They killed 3 chase mythics in 3 lines. Wotc would never. Some may not like the bans, from gameplay perspective to financial perspective, but we all have to admit this was a move against wotc. Maybe a bit too little too late. We will have to see.

JLK was in the CAG, not the Rules Committee.

The latest command zone episode airs this out extensively.

Do you believe me now? That being said please do not threaten people for making decisions about a card game. It was not ok that the rules committee was threatened. That made me sad to hear. Even so, I do not think the rules committee would have been around for much longer anyway. The bracket system shows that they are already thinking about how to implement commander on arena. There will be 4 brackets with cedh being the most powerful bracket. The bans were meant to remove those 4 cards from even the most cedh of brackets on arena. There may be a few more bans now that wizards is in control but not many more. The bracket system will effectively regulate commander play on arena and maybe also in paper.

There is a rumor going around that wotc and the commander rules committee are in cahoots and are colluding. Perhaps WOTC is trying to fracture he commander community in order to take over the format and make it an official Magic the Gathering format run internally. I think they are doing this to prepare for the official launch of commander on mtg arena during holiday 2025. Is this 4 person commander or 1 v 1? This is unclear but the rumor is that commander on arena will release to coincide with the marvel set.

The RC members are beloved between casuals and are strongly integrated with the creator scene. The biggest commander content creators the command zone has 2 members of the cag in it.

It would be really weird if wizards wants to do that. I think this is simply a warning shot from the RC on the kind of cards they don't want to see printed into the format. Also Nadu sucks to play against.

I don't think it is anything more than that. However I could be completely wrong as well and you completely right. Only time can tell us

Didn't one of the members of the command zone literally just resign as a member of the commander rules committee? Timing seems coincidental and I do not believe in coincidence.

There is a rumor going around that wotc and the commander rules committee are in cahoots and are colluding. Perhaps WOTC is trying to fracture he commander community in order to take over the format and make it an official Magic the Gathering format run internally. I think they are doing this to prepare for the official launch of commander on mtg arena during holiday 2025. Is this 4 person commander or 1 v 1? This is unclear but the rumor is that commander on arena will release to coincide with the marvel set.

Please stop printing pinpoint enchantment removal in mono black at mana values below 5. Black should only be able to force you to sacrifice an enchantment at lower costs. Duskmourn has enchantment removal in black that is far too pushed

Avatar

We’ll have to agree to disagree. The Council of Colors has given this the thumbs up.

Avatar
You are using an unsupported browser and things might not work as intended. Please make sure you're using the latest version of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, or Edge.