Hot take: Annabeth didn’t need to be the daughter of Athena in order to be smart
Hear me out - this isn't shade against Athena herself nor Annabeth, but this decision Rick made for them is, at best, mythological wrong and, at worst, offensive.
Athena is known to be a virgin goddess, just like Hestia and Artemis, so even having children from her thoughts breaks her vow. So Annabeth (and the others) shouldn't be born from Athena.
Before someone goes 'But who would be a better fit?' Or 'There isn't anyone better for her!' I actually have some other godly parents suited for our Wise Girl that let her still be smart, gives her cool powers, AND add layers for her and the series.
This one was the easiest because Apollo is also a god of knowledge like Athena, and he isn't considered a virgin god, unlike our owl godess. Plus, you can have other talents for Annabeth to practice AND more angst when they (the other Apollo kids) all died in the Battle of Manhattan
This one I thought on the fly - while he isn't known for wisdom or knowledge like the others on the list, he's a pretty good contender for Annabeth’s godly parent. He's known of battle smarts/strategy AND bravery, and Ares kids aren't just blood thirsty fighters. They can be quiet, gather information, and spy on the enemy. It's perfect for Annabeth, plus her Hubris makes more sense and her need to be validated by her godly parent (Fuck PJO Ares, Mytho Ares is better)
This one was also easy to pick. Metis is the mother of Athena AND also associated with wisdom and knowledge. Plus, considering she doesn't have a cabin despite giving birth to an Olympian goddess, it'll give angst to Annabeth’s character and her place in Camp, adding on to WHY minor gods are just as important as the Olympian Gods. (BTW, Shape Shifting is a part of Metis's Domain, so Annabeth can have cool powers!!)
This one I found from research. Coeus is the Titan of Intellect and the Axis of Heaven. And he's known to be smarter than Metis and Athena combined! Plus, if you add in the fact that the first series stars the Titans as antagonists, MORE angst of Annabeth’s character, and like I said for Metis, it shows why we shouldn't alienate the other gods, primordials and titans JUST because they're not Olympians
If you still want to keep Athena as Annabeth's godly parent, try this- make her Athena's Champion.
Like in my DGAF au, Athena blessed Annabeth as a baby as a gift for her parents. That way, Annabeth could still be related to Athena without breaking the vow.
That's all I have for now, thank you for reading.
*Maybe I should make this a side series?