Old-Fashioned Pie Recipes

All the old fashioned cream and custard pies, easy fruit pies, slab pies, and "desperation" pies. Easy Pie Recipes | Old Fashioned Pie Recipes | Fruit Pie Recipes | Pie Filling Recipes | Chess Pies | Cream Pies | Custard Pies | Homemade Pie Crust Recipes | Hand Pie Recipes | Slab Pie Recipes | Shoofly Pie | Chess Pie | Buttermilk Pie
190 Pins
·
7mo
Best Chocolate Chess Pie
This chocolate chess pie is rich and fudgy. It doesn't use evaporated milk so the chocolate flavor is really intense. Looking for a great old fashioned pie recipe that's also an indulgent chocolate dessert? Look no further than this traditional Southern classic, chocolate chess pie! #chocolatechesspie #chesspie #oldfashionedpierecipe #southerndesserts #homemadepie #chocolatepie #pastrychefonline
Easy Coconut Custard Pie
It's not Thanksgiving if there's no pie for dessert (it's a rule!), but that doesn't mean you always have to make the same old thing! Coconut custard pie is an easy and delicious pie recipe that won't have you prowling through your spice rack to find a bunch of spices. Simple ingredients, and incredibly delicious. Why not make a coconut pie a new Thanksgiving dessert tradition? #coconutpie #pie #Thanksgivingdessert #coconutcustardpie #oldfashionedpierecipe #pastrychefonline
Shoofly Pie Recipe
An old-school, traditional pie recipe, shoo fly pie is sweetened with molasses. To counteract the bitter edge, you add some baking soda, so all that's left is pure caramel sweetness. The streusel on top is a nice contrast to the gooey bottom, giving this the name "wet bottom" shoofly pie. An Amish specialty, everyone needs to try this delicious pie! #amishbaking #shooflypie #shooflypierecipe #molassespie #easypierecipe #homemadepie #pastrychefonline
Old-Fashioned Vinegar Pie
An easy pie recipe, old-fashioned vinegar pie is a pie you can turn to when you don't have any fruit in the house. Make your own crust or use storebought, then all you have to do is whisk your filling ingredients together and in no time, it's time for a vintage dessert! #easypierecipe #vinegarpie #oldfashionedpie #homemadepie #vinegarpierecipe #vintagerecipes #pastrychefonline
Easy Chocolate Chess Pie
This easy pie recipe delivers rich, deep chocolate flavor! You won't believe how gooey and chocolatey this old fashioned chocolate chess pie recipe is. A classic southern dessert, chess pie is made simply with eggs, sugar, butter, and cornmeal. Add some cocoa powder and a couple of other ingredients, and you'll have a pie every chocolate lover will be fighting over! #chesspie #easypierecipe #chocolatechesspie #chocolatepie #southerndessert #oldfashionedpie #pastrychefonline
Classic Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie
An old fashioned Amish pie recipe, shoofly pie only contains a handful of pantry staples, but it has a ton of flavor. The bitterness in molasses is neutralized by baking soda, so all you get is gooey, rich sweetness with some sandy streusel on top. Since this homemade pie recipe is gooey on the bottom, it's known as a wet bottom shoofly pie. And it's delicious! #oldfashionedpierecipe #shooflypie #molassespie #homemadepie #amishrecipes #amishpie #pastrychefonline
The Best "Hoosier Pie" Recipe
Sugar cream pie is the state pie of Indiana (Hoosier Pie) with good reason. Simple to make, creamy, and rich, this old-fashioned pie is a winner! It tastes a bit like creme brule, but it's thickened with flour rather than egg. An unexpected yet perfect Christmas dessert with its creamy white color and texture. #sugarcreampie #indianapie #hoosierpie #creampie #homemadepie #dessert #pastrychefonline
Apple Custard Pie for a Crowd
When you want to serve apple pie to a crowd, slab pie is the way to go. My apple custard pie is baked in a 9 x 13" quarter sheet pan. With a nutty, pecan dough encasing a spiced apple layer atop a creamy, Greek yogurt custard, this pie is creamy, spicy, appley delicious. If you've never made an apple custard pie, please consider giving my apple custard slab pie a try!
Old-Fashioned Butterscotch Pie
Smooth, rich butterscotch pudding fills a baked pie crust and gets topped with brown sugar meringue. A homey and comforting pie, butterscotch pie is a perfect, unfussy pie whenever you have a hankering for butterscotch. Or pie.
Indiana Sugar Cream Pie Recipe
This old-fashioned pie tastes like the best vanilla cream you've ever had. An easy pie recipe, the Indiana state pie deserves its title because of a short ingredient list and big flavor. Serve this on any occasion, and consider it as a Thanksgiving dessert. A little unexpected but no less comforting for that! #Indianastatepie #sugarcreampie #oldfashionedpies #pierecipes #easypierecipes #Thanksgiving #pastrychefonline
Old-Fashioned Vinegar Pie
Enjoy this old fashioned vinegar pie recipe. A traditional vintage pie made when there was no fruit around, vinegar pie uses apple cider vinegar as a flavoring, so this guy tastes a bit like a lightly lemon-flavored pie. #oldfashionedpie #vinegarpierecipe #vinegarpie #pie #easyrecipes #pastrychefonline
Classic Shoo Fly Pie
A homey, old fashioned recipe for Shoo Fly Pie. It's a classic recipe for a reason--it is incredibly delicious and also very easy to make. Now you know what to do with that leftover jar of molasses in your cupboard! #shooflypie #pierecipes | pastrychefonline.com