A lot of people in Bethany were curious to see Lazarus, the man Jesus raised from the dead. Just as earlier in John’s Gospel, the people of Cana sought out Jesus because He turned water into wine at the wedding feast there. In both cases something more subtle and more profound occurred.
If you remember, after returning to Cana from Jerusalem, people followed Jesus around hoping to see Him perform another marvelous deed. He was sought out by a distraught father, who wanted the Lord to come home with him and heal his son, who was in danger of death. In that instance, Jesus healed the man’s son without going to his house. He said the word and, as the man found out from his servants after journeying more than day to reach home, the boy was healed.
This miracle was not accessible to those who were hanging about to witness a miracle. The boy’s healing, while perhaps as sudden as it was mysterious, probably did seem all that miraculous to those who were there when he was healed. Only Jesus and the man knew.1
The profoundly subtle event in our Gospel today is Mary, the sister of Martha and Lazarus, the same one who was intent to sit at Jesus’ feet while her sister complained she wasn’t helping, anoints Jesus’ feet with costly oil.2 Judas takes exception to this. He doesn’t even point out that the costly oil could’ve been sold and given to the poor out of self-righteousness. As a thief, according to this Johannine narrative, who has been stealing from the common purse, he says this in a manipulatively.
Don’t get me wrong, selling luxury items and giving the money from their sale to the poor is a laudable thing. After all, the Lord Himself tells us that the poor will always be with us. This is not a throwaway line, let alone a justification for ignoring the poor by seeing their plight as God-ordained. Rather, it is something of an indictment.
Why will there always be poor people? Here’s a clue: it isn’t because the number of people, even now, outstrip the good earth’s abundance. In other words, there is enough to go around and then some. The failure lies in how the earth’s bounty is distributed. No matter the economic system, distribution of the earth’s goods favors the powerful. Economics is all about the problem of scarcity. This begets competition. “Get yours while supplies last!”
Once the distinction between wants and needs is blurred or, as in advanced modern societies, is obliterated, we find ourselves far from God’s kingdom, as the story Jesus tells about the rich man and Lazarus not so subtly demonstrates.3
So, the reason there will always be poor people is not because God decrees that they should be poor. Rather, it is due to our fallenness and sinfulness. Because God does not coerce but invites, encourages, and exhorts, you and I are free to act as we will in this regard. In doing so, each of us should keep in mind Jesus’ teaching. After all, it is He who will return to judge the living and the dead.
Dorothy Day, a truly American saint (though not yet canonized), founder of the Catholic Worker movement, which, though still extant, is in dire need of revival, wrote about a Holy Thursday she experienced: “The mystery of the poor is this: That they are Jesus, and what you do for them you do for him.”
Day continues that recognizing Jesus in the poor “is the only way we have of knowing and believing in our love.” Therefore, she concludes, “The mystery of poverty is that by sharing in it, making ourselves poor in giving to others, we increase our knowledge of and belief in love.”4 Let’s never forget, Deus caritas est- “God is love.”5
So where does this leave us with Mary’s extravagant gesture? On the side of Judas? Was she right to anoint the Lord’s feet with costly oil and dry them with her hair? Well, was she in the right when she chose to sit at His feet while her sister scurried about getting things ready? These are, of course, rhetorical questions. Mary’s prophetic gesture was not grasped by those who witnessed it.
As the Lord noted, Mary’s seemingly over-the-top devotion, which occurs well before Jesus’ triumphal entry into Jerusalem, pointed to His death and burial. While I can never repay the debt I owe to Him, I can see and serve Jesus in the poor after the manner of Mary. The Lord’s identification with the poor is not a mere metaphor. It is a true identification. This why Mother Teresa called the poor Jesus in a “distressing disguise.”
Making a nod to our first reading from Isaiah, which is one of five so-called “Servant Songs” found in deutero-Isaiah, Saint Oscar Romero noted, “As we draw near to the poor, we find we are gradually uncovering the genuine face of the Suffering Servant of Yahweh.”6
1 John 4:43-54.↩
2 Luke 10:38-42.↩
3 Luke 16:19-31.↩
4 This and the preceding two quotes from Dorothy Day.“The Mystery of the Poor.” Plough online, 21 March 2015.↩
5 1 John 4:8.16.↩
6 Oscar Romero. The Violence of Love, 203. Compiled and translated by James R. Brockman, S. J.
↩